Growing human B-cell precursors in vitro: the continuing challenge

Identification of hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells: strength and drawbacks of functional assays

A major challenge in hematopoiesis is to conceive assays that could bring useful insights into experimental and clinical hematology. This means identifying separately the various classes of hematopoietic progenitors that are produced sequentially during the progression from stem cells to differentiated functional cells. Standardized short-term colony assays easily quantify lineage-committed myeloid precursors, but identification of primitive cells, which have both the ability to repopulate durably myeloid and lymphoid lineages and perhaps to self-renew, still depends on in vivo assays. Whatever the assay, two important requisites have to be solved: one is the definition of appropriate read-outs that will depend solely on the function of these cells, and the second is to evaluate precisely their numbers and proliferative potential in quantitative assays. When evaluating hematopoiesis, three parameters have to be taken into account: (1) the lack of reliable correlation between the phenotype of a given cell and its function. This is especially problematic in post-transplantation situations where cells from transplanted animals are analysed; (2) functionally heterogeneous cells are identified in a single assay; and (3) ontogeny-related changes in hematopoietic cell proliferation and self-renewal that, in human beings, hampers the exploration of adult stem cells. Nevertheless, years of progress in the manipulation of hematopoietic stem cells have recently resulted in the purification of a cell subset that repopulates irradiated recipients with absolute efficiency.

Individual CD34+CD38lowCD19−CD10− Progenitor Cells From Human Cord Blood Generate B Lymphocytes and Granulocytes

Identification of human hematopoietic stem cells and analysis of molecular mechanisms regulating their function require biological assays that permit differentiation in all hematopoietic lineages simultaneously. In this study, we established conditions that permit the joint expression of the B-lymphoid and myeloid potential from cord blood-derived CD34+CD38lowCD19−/CD10− primitive progenitors that lack B-specific markers and transcripts. When cocultured during 6 weeks with the murine stromal cells MS-5 in the absence of exogenous human cytokines, CD34+CD38lowCD19−CD10− cells generated a high number of CD19+ B cells. Virtually all of these cells expressed a CD34−CD10+CD19+cIgM− phenotype of late pro-B cells and transcripts of Pax-5, λ-like, and μ chain were detected. We further show that 7% of CD34+CD38lowCD19− cells from cord blood, when grown individually with MS-5 cells, generated both CD19+ and CD11b+ cells after 6 weeks. Efficient B-cell differentiation was also observed in vivo after transplantation of human cord blood-derived unfractionated mononuclear cells or CD34+CD19+CD10− cells into immune-deficient mice. In contrast to the in vitro situation, all stages of B-cell differentiation were observed in vivo, including pro-B, pre-B, and sIgM+ B cells. Interestingly, human progenitors with the ability to differentiate along both B-lymphoid and granulocytic pathways were also detected among human CD34+CD38low cells in the marrow of chimeric mice 6 to 7 weeks after transplantation. Both in vitro and in vivo systems will offer an invaluable tool to further identify the lymphoid and myeloid potentialities of primitive progenitor cells isolated from fetal as well as adult human hematopoietic tissues and characterize stromal-derived signals that regulate their function.

Individual CD34+CD38lowCD19−CD10− Progenitor Cells From Human Cord Blood Generate B Lymphocytes and Granulocytes

Identification of human hematopoietic stem cells and analysis of molecular mechanisms regulating their function require biological assays that permit differentiation in all hematopoietic lineages simultaneously. In this study, we established conditions that permit the joint expression of the B-lymphoid and myeloid potential from cord blood-derived CD34+CD38lowCD19−/CD10− primitive progenitors that lack B-specific markers and transcripts. When cocultured during 6 weeks with the murine stromal cells MS-5 in the absence of exogenous human cytokines, CD34+CD38lowCD19−CD10− cells generated a high number of CD19+ B cells. Virtually all of these cells expressed a CD34−CD10+CD19+cIgM− phenotype of late pro-B cells and transcripts of Pax-5, λ-like, and μ chain were detected. We further show that 7% of CD34+CD38lowCD19− cells from cord blood, when grown individually with MS-5 cells, generated both CD19+ and CD11b+ cells after 6 weeks. Efficient B-cell differentiation was also observed in vivo after transplantation of human cord blood-derived unfractionated mononuclear cells or CD34+CD19+CD10− cells into immune-deficient mice. In contrast to the in vitro situation, all stages of B-cell differentiation were observed in vivo, including pro-B, pre-B, and sIgM+ B cells. Interestingly, human progenitors with the ability to differentiate along both B-lymphoid and granulocytic pathways were also detected among human CD34+CD38low cells in the marrow of chimeric mice 6 to 7 weeks after transplantation. Both in vitro and in vivo systems will offer an invaluable tool to further identify the lymphoid and myeloid potentialities of primitive progenitor cells isolated from fetal as well as adult human hematopoietic tissues and characterize stromal-derived signals that regulate their function.

In-vitro models of stroma-dependent lymphopoiesis

The differentiation of hematopoietic stem cells into lymphocytes can be replicated ex vivo under the inductive influence of the stromal cells that frame the bone marrow and thymus. We summarize hereafter the development of culture systems where lymphopoiesis-supporting cell compartments are maintained in either their normal three-dimensional arrangement, in organotypic culture, or as culture dish-adherent monolayers and review the recent and current uses of those in-vitro models to investigate T- and B-cell differentiation in mouse and man.

Applications of cytometry to study acute leukemia: in vitro determination of drug sensitivity and detection of minimal residual disease

Modern clinical applications of cytometry include the determination of the most powerful antileukemic drugs in each patient at the time of diagnosis and the monitoring of residual disease during and off treatment. The precision of in vitro assays to test the susceptibility of cancer cells to cytotoxic drugs depends on the ability to maintain the cells' viability in culture. We found that bone marrow-derived allogeneic stromal cells are critical to prevent death by apoptosis of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) cells. Thus, we devised an in vitro drug sensitivity assay in which ALL cells are seeded onto stromal cells and viable leukemic cells are counted at the end of cultures by flow cytometry. Our preliminary results indicate that this assay is suitable for evaluating the drug sensitivity of leukemic lymphoblasts and testing the antileukemic activity of potentially effective compounds which have not yet been administered to patients with ALL. The identification of immunophenotypes expressed on leukemic cells but absent or extremely rare among normal hematopoietic progenitors allows close monitoring of the effects of drug treatment in vivo. Phenotypes that afford a detection level of 1 leukemic cell among 10,000 normal bone marrow cells have been identified in 90% of cases of T-ALL, 25% of B-lineage ALL, and 40% of acute myeloid leukemia (AML). In several studies, residual disease emerging during continuation therapy or off treatment almost invariably anticipated overt relapse by 1-7 months. These data indicate the reliability of immunologic techniques to detect occult leukemia.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Growth requirements of normal and leukemic human B cell progenitors

Leukemic lymphoblasts in B-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) express morphologic, phenotypic and genotypic features which resemble those of B lymphocyte progenitors in normal bone marrow. Normal immature B cells and cells from most cases of B-lineage ALL rapidly die in vitro unless they are supported by bone marrow-derived stromal feeder layers. Techniques suitable for maintaining normal and leukemic immature B cells in culture have been developed. Thus, the stromal cell types and growth factors that generate a milieu suitable for immature B-cell development can now be elucidated. In addition, the similarities and discrepancies in survival requirements of normal and leukemic B cell precursors can be studied. We postulate that leukemic B cell precursors can survive and expand in microenvironments incapable of supporting their normal counterparts, and that the study of the survival requirements of ALL cells will provide indications about the aggressivity of the disease in vivo. In this review, we discuss the culture conditions that support in vitro survival of human immature B cells, some of the factors that influence their expansion, and the putative molecular basis for the prolonged life-span of leukemic lymphoblasts.

In vitro sensitization for human monoclonal antibody production

We have found that cell adhesion prior to in vitro antigenic stimulation enriched the B-cell population and diminished the CD8 lymphocyte subset. These changes in lymphocyte proportions were favourable for increasing the percentage of antibody-producing cells after culturing in vitro followed by Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infection. The immunodepletion of leukocytes by methyl esters did not yield satisfying results under analogous culture conditions. In vitro primary antigenic stimulations with the addition of IL-2 (25 U/ml medium) and low amounts of interferon-gamma provided better recruitment of antibody-producing cells and higher binding activity of antibodies to sperm than secondary antigenic stimulation. IL-6 did not positively influence the EBV-transformed cell lines.

Interleukin 4 inhibits in vitro proliferation of leukemic and normal human B cell precursors

In the present study, we have investigated the effects of IL-4 on the proliferation and differentiation of leukemic and normal human B cell precursors (BCP). We have demonstrated that IL-4 significantly inhibited spontaneous [3H]thymidine ([3H]-TdR) incorporation by leukemic blasts from some B lineage acute lymphoblastic leukemia (BCP-ALL) patients (8 of 14). Furthermore, IL-4 was found to suppress the spontaneous and factor-dependent (IL-7 and IL-3) proliferation of normal BCP (CD10+ surface [s] IgM- cells) isolated from fetal bone marrow. Maximum growth inhibition of either leukemic or normal BCP was reached at low IL-4 concentrations (10 U/ml), and the effect was specifically neutralized by anti-IL-4 antibody. IL-4 was further found to induce the expression of CD20 antigen on BCP-ALL cells from a number of the cases examined (5 of 8), but in contrast to leukemic cells, IL-4 failed to induce CD20 antigen on normal BCP. Finally, IL-4 was found to induce neither the expression of cytoplasmic mu chain, nor the appearance of sIgM+ cells in cultures of normal or leukemic BCP. Our data indicate that IL-4 has the potential to inhibit cell proliferation in leukemic and normal human B lymphopoiesis but is unable to drive the transition from BCP to mature B cells.

In vitro growth and maturation of human B-cell precursors

Purified B cell precursors (BCP) (CD10+ CD19+ surface-membrane (s)Ig-cells) isolated from human fetal bone marrow (BM) were cultured with various cytokines, in the presence or absence of a fibroblastic stromal cell layer derived from adult human BM. We demonstrated that IL-7, IL-3, and stem-cell factor (SCF) participate in inducing low magnitude BCP proliferation in the absence of stroma. Addition of either IL-4, IFN (alpha and gamma), or TGF beta, resulted in significant inhibition of proliferation. Strikingly, BCP proliferated at remarkably higher levels when cultured on BM stromal cells, and this effect was further enhanced by exogenously supplied IL-7. Proliferating cells were mostly CD20+, and included both c mu- and c mu+ cells. Furthermore, BCP proliferated in response to anti CD40 antibody presented by Fc gamma RII-transfected murine fibroblastic Ltk- cells (CD40 system) (Banchereau et al. 1991), demonstrating a functional role for CD40 in B cell ontogeny. However, this effect was shown to require a second signal, which could be specifically provided by IL-3 among a panel of cytokines examined. Finally, although suggestive of BCP maturation, the culture systems examined did not permit the transition to mature B cells (sIgM+ sIgD+).

Vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 and the integrin VLA-4 mediate adhesion of human B cell precursors to cultured bone marrow adherent cells

Adhesion of B cell precursors to accessory cells in the bone marrow microenvironment may be required for normal early B cell development. Human bone marrow B cell precursors adhere more avidly than mature B cells to bone marrow-derived fibroblasts. To determine the mechanism of this adhesion, expression of adhesion proteins on human B precursor cells and cell lines was measured by flow cytometry. The very late antigen (VLA) integrins VLA-4 and VLA-5 were the only adhesion proteins expressed at higher levels in B cell precursors than mature B cells. Antibodies to the alpha and beta chains of VLA-4, but not VLA-5, significantly blocked binding to bone marrow-derived fibroblasts of immature B cells and cell lines. Although fibronectin is a ligand for VLA-4, anti-fibronectin antibody and a soluble fibronectin fragment containing the VLA-4 binding domain did not block adhesion, suggesting that VLA-4 is involved in adhesion of B cell precursors, but not as a fibronectin receptor. Vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 (VCAM-1), the other known counterreceptor for VLA-4, was identified on bone marrow-derived fibroblasts, and anti-VCAM-1 significantly blocked adhesion of normal B cell precursors to bone marrow-derived fibroblasts, indicating that VLA-4/VCAM-1 interactions are important in adhesion of B cell precursors to the bone marrow microenvironment.

Human interleukin-4: an immunomodulator with potential therapeutic applications

Human interleukin-4 (IL-4) is a 20kDa cytokine produced by activated T cells and has an extensive range of stimulatory and inhibitory effects on the wide range of cells which express its receptor. It specifically promotes the immunoglobulin class switch to IgE and IgG4 and potently co-stimulates with CD40 monoclonal antibodies the long term proliferation of human B cells. It has variable effects on T cells, but predominantly has inhibitory actions on monocytes suggesting a potential therapeutic role as an anti-inflammatory agent. There is evidence for indirect anti-cancer activity of IL-4 both in animal models and in in vitro studies on human tumour infiltrating lymphocytes. In addition, IL-4 directly inhibits the in vitro proliferation of the majority of B cell neoplasms. Phase I studies of IL-4 in patients with cancer have commenced and promising observations have been made in patients with haematological malignancies receiving low, well-tolerated doses.

Differentiation of normal human pre-B cells in vitro

The differentiation of surface Ig- pre-B cells into surface Ig+ B cells is a critical transition in mammalian B cell ontogeny. Elucidation of the growth factor requirements and differentiative potential of human pre-B cells has been hampered by the absence of a reproducible culture system that supports differentiation. Fluorescence-activated cell sorting and magnetic bead depletion were used to purify fetal bone marrow CD10+/surface mu- cells, which contain 60-70% cytoplasmic mu+ pre-B cells. CD10+/surface mu- cells cultured for 2 d were observed to differentiate into surface mu+ cells. Analysis by Southern blotting provided direct evidence that rearrangement of kappa light chain genes occurs in culture, and flow cytometric analysis revealed the appearance of surface Ig+ B cells expressing mu/kappa or mu/lambda. Unexpectedly, the kappa/lambda ratio in differentiated cells was the inverse of what is normally observed in adult peripheral blood. Differentiation occurs in the absence of exogenous growth factors or cytokines, suggesting that a stimulus-independent differentiative inertia might characterize pre-B cells in vivo. Future use of this model will facilitate our understanding of normal and abnormal human pre-B cell differentiation.

Functional characterization of individual human hematopoietic stem cells cultured at limiting dilution on supportive marrow stromal layers

A major goal of current hematopoiesis research is to develop in vitro methods suitable for the measurement and characterization of stem cells with long-term in vivo repopulating potential. Previous studies from several centers have suggested the presence in normal human or murine marrow of a population of very primitive cells that are biologically, physically, and pharmacologically different from cells detectable by short-term colony assays and that can give rise to the latter in long-term cultures (LTCs) containing a competent stromal cell layer. In this report, we show that such cultures can be used to provide a quantitative assay for human "LTC-initiating cells" based on an assessment of the number of clonogenic cells present after 5-8 weeks. Production of derivative clonogenic cells is shown to be absolutely dependent on the presence of a stromal cell feeder. When this requirement is met, the clonogenic cell output (determined by assessment of 5-week-old cultures) is linearly related to the input cell number over a wide range of cell concentrations. Using limiting dilution analysis techniques, we have established the frequency of LTC-initiating cells in normal human marrow to be approximately 1 per 2 X 10(4) cells and in a highly purified CD34-positive subpopulation to be approximately 1 per 50-100 cells. The proliferative capacity exhibited by individual LTC-initiating cells cultured under apparently identical culture conditions was found to be highly variable. Values for the number of clonogenic cells per LTC-initiating cell in 5-week-old cultures ranged from 1 to 30 (the average being 4) with similar levels being detected in positive 8-week-old cultures. Some LTC-initiating cells are multipotent as evidenced by their generation of erythroid as well as granulopoietic progeny. The availability of a system for quantitative analysis of the proliferative and differentiative behavior of this newly defined compartment of primitive human hematopoietic cells should facilitate future studies of specific genetic or microenvironmental parameters involved in the regulation of these cells.