Dynamics of genetically-engineered enzymes: fluorescence and depolarized rayleigh scattering studies of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase

Theory vs. experiment: The rise of the dynamic view of proteins

Over the past century, the scientific conception of the protein has evolved significantly. This paper focuses on the most recent stage of this evolution, namely, the origin of the dynamic view of proteins and the challenge it posed to the static view of classical molecular biology. Philosophers and scientists have offered two hypotheses to explain the origin of the dynamic view and its slow reception by structural biologists. Some have argued that the shift from the static to the dynamic view was a Kuhnian revolution, driven by the accumulation of dynamic anomalies, while others have argued that the shift was caused by new empirical findings made possible by technological advances. I analyze this scientific episode and ultimately reject both of these empiricist accounts. I argue that focusing primarily on technological advances and empirical discoveries overlooks the important role of theory in driving this scientific change. I show how the application of general thermodynamic principles to proteins gave rise to the dynamic view, and a commitment to these principles then led early adopters to seek out the empirical examples of protein dynamics, which would eventually convince their peers. My analysis of this historical case shows that empiricist accounts of modern scientific progress-at least those that aim to explain developments in the molecular life sciences-need to be tempered in order to capture the interplay between theory and experiment.

Tryptophan phosphorescence as a monitor of the solution structure of phosphoglycerate kinase from yeast

The enzyme phosphoglycerate kinase from yeast possesses two tryptophan residues whose phosphorescence spectrum in low-temperature glasses is resolved into two distinct components with 0-0 vibronic bands centered at 408 and 412.5 nm. The thermal profile of the phosphorescence intensity and lifetime shows that the red (longer wavelength) component is quenched in fluid solutions so that the long-lived phosphorescence observed at ambient temperature in buffer is due entirely to the blue (shorter wavelength) component. The remarkable heterogeneity in flexibility of the two chromophores' sites inferred from the thermal behaviour, when analyzed in terms of the crystallographic structure, allows to make a straightforward assignment of the long-lived emission to internal Trp-333. Because in buffer the phosphorescence is due to only one Trp residue the biphasic nature of the decay reveals the presence of stable, slowly interconverting, conformers with profound differences in the internal fluidity of the C-domain. Further, according to the triplet lifetime, complex formation with substrates affect the protein structure in a very selective way. Thus, while 3-phosphoglycerate has practically no influence on the average lifetime, Mg ATP and Mg ADP increases tau by a factor of 1.9 and 5.3, respectively. The change in lifetime implies a remarkable stiffening of the C-domain which is partly relaxed in ternary complexes with 3-phosphoglycerate. These findings are discussed in terms of ligand-induced "closed" conformations of the protein.

A study of the hinge-bending mechanism of yeast 3-phosphoglycerate kinase

The hinge-bending mechanism proposed as part of the catalytic mechanism for phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) has been investigated using yeast PGK and the site-directed mutant [H388Q]PGK, where His388 is replaced by Gln. The emission and quenching of fluorescence, supported by the aromatic CD band, show that the mutation in the waist region affects the tryptophan environment in the C-terminal domain. The mutant is also less stable to guanidine denaturation and less cooperative in its unfolding. The effect of substrates on the conformation of PGK was studied using 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulphonic acid (ANS), a competitive inhibitor of ATP binding to the C-terminal domain, and 8-(2-[(iodoacetyl)ethyl]amino)naphthalene (I-AEDANS), attached to Cys197 on the N-terminal domain. Under the influence of substrates the novel anisotropy decay curves for ANS indicate a 1-5 degrees change in the orientation of the probe, interpreted as a small reorientation of the domains about the waist region. The experimental data are interpreted as a small swivelling of the domains about the waist region under the influence of substrate. The results with AEDANS anisotropy decay are consistent with those for ANS. The enzyme activity of PGK shows a break in the Arrhenius plot at 20 degrees C mirrored by a break in the temperature dependence of tryptophan ellipticity. This is interpreted as a change in protein dynamics associated with destabilisation of the waist region. This destabilisation is shown to have already taken place in the mutant enzyme and in the wild type at pH 5.6, both of which exhibit linear Arrhenius plots. NMR titration curves show that the pH effect must be due to a group other than histidine. The results give further support to the permissive model of hinge bending previously proposed by one of the authors, in which binding of substrate destabilises the waist region. This loosens the hinge which can then swing slightly to bring the domains closer together to make favourable interactions between the domains and the substrates, with the exclusion of water.

A comparison of the reactivity and stability of wild type and His388----Gln mutant phosphoglycerate kinase from yeast

A variety of physico-chemical techniques have been used to probe the possible interactions between the characteristic structural domains of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase by comparison of the wild-type enzyme with the specific H388Q mutant in which a potential interaction between His388 and Glu190 in the crucial interdomain region is disrupted. Enzyme kinetic studies indicate that, despite being structurally remote from the active site, this mutation has significant effects on both the Vmax and Km values for various substrates. The single cysteine residue in the N domain of the protein is markedly more reactive in the mutant, and this enhanced accessibility is moderated by binding of substrates and various anions. Differences are also observed in the near-ultraviolet CD spectra of these proteins. The chemical and thermal stability of the mutant enzyme is reduced, as indicated from guanidinium chloride and differential-scanning calorimetry denaturation studies. Moreover, interdomain interactions seem to be altered in the mutant, resulting in the appearance of independent thermal transition for the two domains, in contrast to the single cooperative transition observed for the wild-type enzyme. The conformational and/or dynamic effects of the mutation on the H388Q enzyme are therefore various and not solely localised in the hinge region.

A proton-NMR study of a site-directed mutation (His388----Glu) in the interdomain region of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase. Implications for domain movement

Proton NMR has been used to study a site-directed mutant of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase in which the interdomain residue His388 has been replaced by a glutamine residue. Using 1H-NMR spectroscopy, it was found that 3-phosphoglycerate binding to the mutant protein induces different conformational effects to those observed for the wild-type enzyme. These differences are not only located at the 3-phosphoglycerate binding site but are also seen as long-range effects at the surface of the protein. Measurements of the Kd for 3-phosphoglycerate from the NMR experiments show that the mutant enzyme has a 30-times reduced affinity for this substrate as compared with the wild-type enzyme. These data are consistent with the suggestion that an aromatic residue at position 388 plays an important role in the proposed hinge-bending mechanism.