Cytotoxic flow-cytometric crossmatches (flow-tox): a comparison with conventional cytotoxicity crossmatch techniques

Detecting and monitoring human leukocyte antigen-specific antibodies

Renewed awareness of the relevance of HLA-specific antibodies to transplantation and the development of protocols to reduce or eliminate sensitization have made monitoring of antibodies and accurate interpretation of test results increasingly important. Here we review the various tests available and provide guidelines for the development of monitoring protocols.

Use of molecular modeling and site-directed mutagenesis to define the structural basis for the immune response to carbohydrate xenoantigens

BACKGROUND

Natural antibodies directed at carbohydrates reject porcine xenografts. They are initially expressed in germline configuration and are encoded by a small number of structurally-related germline progenitors. The transplantation of genetically-modified pig organs prevents hyperacute rejection, but delayed graft rejection still occurs, partly due to humoral responses. IgVH genes encoding induced xenoantibodies are predominantly, not exclusively, derived from germline progenitors in the VH3 family. We have previously identified the immunoglobulin heavy chain genes encoding VH3 xenoantibodies in patients and primates. In this manuscript, we complete the structural analysis of induced xenoantibodies by identifying the IgVH genes encoding the small proportion of VH4 xenoantibodies and the germline progenitors encoding xenoantibody light chains. This information has been used to define the xenoantibody/carbohydrate binding site using computer-simulated modeling.

RESULTS

The VH4-59 gene encodes antibodies in the VH4 family that are induced in human patients mounting active xenoantibody responses. The light chain of xenoantibodies is encoded by DPK5 and HSIGKV134. The structural information obtained by sequencing analysis was used to create computer-simulated models. Key contact sites for xenoantibody/carbohydrate interaction for VH3 family xenoantibodies include amino acids in sites 31, 33, 50, 57, 58 and the CDR3 region of the IgVH gene. Site-directed mutagenesis indicates that mutations in predicted contact sites alter binding to carbohydrate xenoantigens. Computer-simulated modeling suggests that the CDR3 region directly influences binding.

CONCLUSION

Xenoantibodies induced during early and delayed xenograft responses are predominantly encoded by genes in the VH3 family, with a small proportion encoded by VH4 germline progenitors. This restricted group can be identified by the unique canonical structure of the light chain, heavy chain and CDR3. Computer-simulated models depict this structure with accuracy, as confirmed by site-directed mutagenesis. Computer-simulated drug design using computer-simulated models may now be applied to develop new drugs that may enhance the survival of xenografted organs.

Gene therapy to inhibit xenoantibody production using lentiviral vectors in non-human primates

Xenoantibodies to the gal alpha1,3 gal (gal) epitope impede the use of pig tissues for xenotransplantation, a procedure that may help overcome the shortage of human organ donors. Stable gal chimerism and tolerance to gal(+) hearts could be achieved in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase (alpha1,3GT)(-/-) mice using lentiviral vectors expressing porcine alpha1,3GT, the enzyme that synthesizes the gal carbohydrate. In this study, we evaluated whether chimerism sufficient to inhibit anti-gal xenoantibody responses can be achieved using lentivectors in non-human primates. Rhesus macaques were transplanted with autologous, alpha1,3GT-transduced bone marrow (BM) following sublethal irradation. Simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV)- and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-1-derived lentiviral constructs were compared. Chimerism was observed in several hematopoietic lineages in all monkeys. Engraftment in animals receiving SIV-based alpha1,3GT constructs was similar to that achieved using the HIV-1-derived lentivector for the first 2 months post-transplantation, but increased thereafter to reach higher levels by 5 months. Upon immunization with porcine hepatocytes, the production of anti-gal immunoglobulin M xenoantibody was substantially reduced in the gal(+) BM recipients compared to controls. This study is the first to report the application of gene therapy to achieve low-level, long-term gal chimerism sufficient to inhibit production of anti-gal antibodies after immunization with porcine cells in rhesus macaques.

USE OF LENTIVIRAL VECTORS TO INDUCE LONG-TERM TOLERANCE TO GAL+ HEART GRAFTS

BACKGROUND

Tolerance to organ grafts has been achieved by establishing a state of stable mixed-cell chimerism after bone marrow transplantation. Gene therapy has been applied to establish chimerism for cells expressing galactose alpha 1,3 galactose in alpha 1,3 galactosyltransferase deficient (gal knockout) mice using retroviral vectors. Limitations to the success of this methodology include short-term expression of the introduced gene and rejection of gal hearts transplanted into these animals within a month.

METHODS

Autologous bone marrow from gal knockout mice was transduced with a lentiviral vector expressing porcine alpha 1,3 galactosyltransferase and transplanted into lethally irradiated gal knockout mice. Chimerism was monitored by flow cytometry. Hearts from wild type mice (gal/) were transplanted into these animals and palpated daily. Xenoantibodies directed at the gal carbohydrate or porcine xenoantigens were detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

RESULTS

Hearts from wild-type gal/ donors were permanently accepted in all mice receiving autologous, transduced bone marrow before heart transplantation. Control mice rejected gal hearts within 12 to 14 days. Histologic analysis demonstrated classical signs of rejection in controls and normal myocardium with no evidence of rejection in mice chimeric for the gal carbohydrate. Anti-gal xenoantibodies were not produced in gal chimeras, but normal antibody responses to other xenoantigens were detected. Specific tolerance for the gal carbohydrate was achieved by this procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

These experiments report the first demonstration of permanent survival of gal hearts after transplantation with autologous, transduced bone marrow. Transduction with lentiviral vectors results in long-term, stable chimerism at levels sufficient to induce long-term tolerance to heart grafts in mice.

Human serum reactivity to porcine endothelial cells after antisense-mediated down-regulation of GpIIIa expression

The hyperacute rejection of vascularized grafts exchanged between discordant species is a result of the binding of preformed natural antibodies to the endothelium of the donor organ, and the subsequent activation of the complement system. Human natural antibodies to pig endothelial cell antigens appear to be predominantly directed at carbohydrate epitopes expressed by a variety of porcine integrins, including GpIIIa. The identification of porcine xenoantigens whose recognition by human natural antibodies results in hyperacute rejection would allow for the development of strategies to genetically modify the xenograft reaction. We have used antisense technology to down-regulate the expression of one of seven recently identified xenoantigens from the surface of pig aortic endothelial cells. Down-regulation of GpIIIa on endothelial cells resulted in a 20.8% decrease in the mean channel shift (MCS) of IgM natural antibody binding from pooled human sera, and a 28-35% decrease in the MCS of IgM binding from two high-titer individuals. The MCS for human IgG natural antibody binding to the surface of pig cells decreased by 27%. Natural antibody-mediated cytotoxicity to pig endothelial cells was not significantly altered, as indicated by a 2.5-6% decline in complement-mediated cytotoxicity. These results indicate that down-regulation of GpIIIa alone may not be sufficient to significantly alter xenograft rejection. Our results also suggest, however, that antisense-mediated regulation of a functionally important target antigen is technically feasible and may represent a strategy to prevent the xenograft reaction.

A prospective, double-blind, randomized study of high-versus low-dose OKT3 induction immunosuppression in cadaveric renal transplantation

We undertook a prospective, double-blind study of high-(5-mg) versus low-(2-mg) dose OKT3 for induction immunosuppression (12 days) in cadaveric renal allograft transplantation. Maintenance immunosuppression was identical in both groups and consisted of azathioprine and prednisone initially, with cyclosporine beginning on the 5th postoperative day. Twenty-six patients were randomized. The groups were similar in terms of age, kidney ischemia time, peak PRA, and latest PRA. There were more diabetics and women in the high-dose group. Patient survival at 12 months was 100% in both groups. Graft survival at 12 months was 92% and 100% in the high- and low-dose groups, respectively. Infections were mostly minor and equal in frequency in the two groups. All patients receiving high- or low-dose OKT3 had manifestations of the cytokine release syndrome; these were delayed in onset in the low-dose group. Eleven patients (85%) in each group produced anti-OKT3 antibodies. Lymphocyte depletion after 1 day was major (> 98%) and identical in both groups. CD3 antigens were removed more slowly in the low-dose group but eventually at equal rates in both groups. Cost was significantly lower in the low-dose group. We conclude that while both doses of OKT3 were effective and safe for induction immunosuppression, it may be prudent to use a lower dose of OKT3 for induction immunosuppression because of its potential to reduce cytokine-mediated effects and to avoid the complications of overimmunosuppression and because of the lower costs associated with it.