Immune response in healthy volunteers vaccinated with BCG plus killed leishmanial promastigotes: antibody responses to mycobacterial and leishmanial antigens

The History of Live Attenuated Centrin Gene-Deleted Leishmania Vaccine Candidates

Leishmaniasis, caused by an infection of the Leishmania protozoa, is a neglected tropical disease and a major health problem in tropical and subtropical regions of the world, with approximately 350 million people worldwide at risk and 2 million new cases occurring annually. Current treatments for leishmaniasis are not highly efficacious and are associated with high costs, especially in low- and middle-income endemic countries, and high toxicity. Due to a surge in the incidence of leishmaniases worldwide, the development of new strategies such as a prophylactic vaccine has become a high priority. However, the ability of Leishmania to undermine immune recognition has limited our efforts to design safe and efficacious vaccines against leishmaniasis. Numerous antileishmanial vaccine preparations based on DNA, subunit, and heat-killed parasites with or without adjuvants have been tried in several animal models but very few have progressed beyond the experimental stage. However, it is known that people who recover from Leishmania infection can be protected lifelong against future infection, suggesting that a successful vaccine requires a controlled infection to develop immunologic memory and subsequent long-term immunity. Live attenuated Leishmania parasites that are non-pathogenic and provide a complete range of antigens similarly to their wild-type counterparts could evoke such memory and, thus, would be effective vaccine candidates. Our laboratory has developed several live attenuated Leishmania vaccines by targeted centrin gene disruptions either by homologous recombination or, more recently, by using genome editing technologies involving CRISPR-Cas9. In this review, we focused on the sequential history of centrin gene-deleted Leishmania vaccine development, along with the characterization of its safety and efficacy. Further, we discussed other major considerations regarding the transition of dermotropic live attenuated centrin gene-deleted parasites from the laboratory to human clinical trials.

Vaccination in Leishmaniasis: A Review Article

Leishmaniasis is caused by protozoan Leishmania parasites that are transmitted through female sandfly bites. The disease is predominantly endemic to the tropics and semi-tropics and has been reported in more than 98 countries. Due to the side effects of anti-Leishmania drugs and the emergence of drug-resistant isolates, there is currently no encouraging prospect of introducing an effective therapy for the disease. Hence, it seems that the key to disease control management is the introduction of an effective vaccine, particularly against its cutaneous form. Advances in understanding underlying immune mechanisms are feasibale using a variety of candidate antigens, including attenuated live parasites, crude antigens, pure or recombinant Leishmania proteins, Leishmania genes encoding protective proteins, as well as immune system activators from the saliva of parasite vectors. However, there is still no vaccine against different types of human leishmaniasis. In this study, we review the works conducted or being performed in this field.

From infection to vaccination: reviewing the global burden, history of vaccine development, and recurring challenges in global leishmaniasis protection

INTRODUCTION

Leishmaniasis is a major public health problem and the second most lethal parasitic disease in the world due to the lack of effective treatments and vaccines. Even when not lethal, leishmaniasis significantly affects individuals and communities through life-long disabilities, psycho-sociological trauma, poverty, and gender disparity in treatment.

AREAS COVERED

This review discusses the most relevant and recent research available on Pubmed and GoogleScholar highlighting leishmaniasis' global impact, pathogenesis, treatment options, and lack of effective control strategies. An effective vaccine is necessary to prevent morbidity and mortality, lower health care costs, and reduce the economic burden of leishmaniasis for endemic low- and middle-income countries. Since there are several forms of leishmaniasis, a pan-Leishmania vaccine without geographical restrictions is needed. This review also focuses on recent advances and common challenges in developing prophylactic strategies against leishmaniasis.

EXPERT OPINION

Despite advances in pre-clinical vaccine research, approval of a human leishmaniasis vaccine still faces major challenges - including manufacturing of candidate vaccines under Good Manufacturing Practices, developing well-designed clinical trials suitable in endemic countries, and defined correlates of protection. In addition, there is a need to explore Challenge Human Infection Model to avoid large trials because of fluctuating incidence and prevalence of leishmanasis.

The role of antibodies in Bacille Calmette Guérin-mediated immune responses and protection against tuberculosis in humans: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

The mechanisms underlying Bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine's protective effects against tuberculosis (TB) are incompletely understood but are proposed to involve a predominantly cell-mediated process. However, there is increasing evidence for the involvement of antibodies in the control of Mycobacteria tuberculosis and in the immune response to BCG.

METHODS

We did a systematic review of studies investigating anti-BCG antibodies in individuals with active or latent TB, and in the response to BCG vaccination.

RESULTS

Of 1417 articles screened, 70 were relevant, comprising 52 investigating anti-BCG antibodies in TB and 18 investigating the anti-BCG antibody response to BCG-vaccination. Individuals with active TB have higher levels of anti-BCG antibodies compared with individuals with latent TB or healthy individuals. Antibodies to BCG are present after BCG vaccination. There is some evidence for the in utero transfer of maternal anti-BCG antibodies to infants.

CONCLUSIONS

BCG vaccination induces a humoral response. Antibodies targeted against BCG and its antigens may play a role in protection against active TB.

A review of adjuvants for Leishmania vaccine candidates

Over the last decade, there has been a flurry of research on adjuvants for vaccines, and several novel adjuvants are now licensed products or in late stage clinical development. The success of adjuvants in enhancing the immune response to antigens has led many researchers to re-focus their vaccine development programs. Although several vaccine candidates have been tested against leishmaniasis, there is yet no effective vaccine against this parasitic disease. Recent research has documented that efforts to develop effective Leishmania vaccine have been limited due to lack of an appropriate adjuvant. In view of this, this review paper outlines some of the adjuvants that have been used in Leishmania vaccine candidates and cites a few of the responses obtained from these studies. The aim of the present review is to consolidate these findings to facilitate the application of these adjuvants in general and experimental vaccinology.

Safety and immunogenicity of a defined vaccine for the prevention of cutaneous leishmaniasis

Healthy Colombian adult volunteers with no history of leishmaniasis were evaluated for evidence of previous subclinical infection with Leishmania based on the Montenegro skin test (MST). Twelve MST-positive subjects were enrolled in an open-label, uncontrolled clinical trial (the "MST-positive trial") and received three injections of the LEISH-F1+MPL-SE vaccine (consisting of 10 microg recombinant Leishmania polyprotein LEISH-F1 antigen [TSA+LmSTI1+LeIF]+25 microg MPL-SE adjuvant). Sixty-eight MST-negative subjects were enrolled in a randomized, double-blind, controlled trial (the "MST-negative trial") and were randomly assigned to receive three injections of either the vaccine (n=34), 10 microg LEISH-F1 protein alone (n=17), or saline placebo (n=17). In both trials, the study injections were given subcutaneously on Days 0, 28, and 56, and subjects were followed for safety and immunological endpoints. The LEISH-F1+MPL-SE vaccine was safe and well tolerated in MST-positive and MST-negative subjects. In both trials, an IFN-gamma response to the LEISH-F1 antigen at Day 84 was observed in more than half of the vaccine recipients. In the MST-negative trial, the IFN-gamma response was significantly more frequent and of greater magnitude in vaccine recipients than in protein-alone or placebo recipients. An IgG antibody response to LEISH-F1 was observed in all vaccine recipients. In both trials, delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) to LEISH-F1 was observed in most of the vaccine recipients. In the MST-negative trial, DTH was significantly higher in vaccine than placebo recipients. These clinical trials of the first defined vaccine for leishmaniasis show that the LEISH-F1+MPL-SE vaccine is safe and immunogenic in healthy subjects with and without evidence of previous subclinical infection with Leishmania.

Leishmaniavaccines: progress and problems

Leishmaniaare protozoan parasites spread by a sandfly insect vector and causing a spectrum of diseases collectively known as leishmaniasis. The disease is a significant health problem in many parts of the world resulting in an estimated 12 million new cases each year. Current treatment is based on chemotherapy, which is difficult to administer, expensive and becoming ineffective due to the emergence of drug resistance. Leishmaniasis is considered one of a few parasitic diseases likely to be controllable by vaccination. The relatively uncomplicated leishmanial life cycle and the fact that recovery from infection renders the host resistant to subsequent infection indicate that a successful vaccine is feasible. Extensive evidence from studies in animal models indicates that solid protection can be achieved by immunisation with protein or DNA vaccines. However, to date no such vaccine is available despite substantial efforts by many laboratories. Advances in our understanding ofLeishmaniapathogenesis and generation of host protective immunity, together with the completedLeishmaniagenome sequence open new avenues for vaccine research. The major remaining challenges are the translation of data from animal models to human disease and the transition from the laboratory to the field. This review focuses on advances in anti-leishmania vaccine development over the recent years and examines current problems hampering vaccine development and implementation.

Genome-wide scan for loci influencing quantitative immune response traits in the Belém family study: comparison of methods and summary of results

Here we report the results from a genome-wide linkage scan to identify genes and chromosomal regions that influence quantitative immune response traits, using multi-case leprosy and tuberculosis families from north-eastern Brazil. Total plasma IgE, antigen-specific IgG to Mycobacterium leprae soluble antigen (MLSA), M. tuberculosis soluble antigen (MTSA) and M. tuberculosis purified protein derivative (PPD), and antigen-specific lymphocyte proliferation (stimulation index or SI) and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) release to MLSA and PPD, were measured in 16 tuberculosis (184 individuals) and 21 leprosy (177 individuals) families. The individuals were genotyped at 382 autosomal microsatellite markers across the genome. The adjusted immune-response phenotypes were analysed using a variety of variance components and regression-based methods. These analyses highlighted a number of practical issues and problems with regard to implementation of the methods and, interestingly, differences were observed between several standard statistical and genetic analysis packages used. From this we determined that, for this set of traits in these pedigrees, significant p values for linkage using variance components analysis, supported by significance using the Visscher-Hopper modification of the Haseman-Elston method, provided the most compelling evidence for linkage. Using these criteria, linkage (5.8 x 10(-5) < p < 0.008) was seen for: total plasma IgE on chromosome 2; IgG to MLSA on chromosomes 8, 17 and 21; IgG to PPD on chromosome 12; SI to PPD on chromosome 1; IFN-gamma to MLSA on chromosomes 6, 7, 10, 12 and 14; and IFN-gamma to PPD on chromosomes 1, 16 and 19.

Study of the safety, immunogenicity and efficacy of attenuated and killed Leishmania (Leishmania) major vaccines in a rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta) model of the human disease

We have compared the efficacy of two Leishmania (Leishmania) major vaccines, one genetically attenuated (DHFR-TS deficient organisms), the other inactivated [autoclaved promastigotes (ALM) with bacillus Calmete-Guérin (BCG)], in protecting rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta) against infection with virulent L. (L.) major. Positive antigen-specific recall proliferative response was observed in vaccinees (79% in attenuated parasite-vaccinated monkeys, versus 75% in ALM-plus-BCG-vaccinated animals), although none of these animals exhibited either augmented in vitro gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) production or positive delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) response to the leishmanin skin test prior to the challenge. Following challenge, there were significant differences in blastogenic responses (p < 0.05) between attenuated-vaccinated monkeys and naïve controls. In both vaccinated groups very low levels of antibody were found before challenge, which increased after infective challenge. Protective immunity did not follow vaccination, in that monkeys exhibited skin lesion at the site of challenge in all the groups. The most striking result was the lack of pathogenicity of the attenuated parasite, which persisted in infected animals for up to three months, but were incapable of causing disease under the conditions employed. We concluded that both vaccine protocols used in this study are safe in primates, but require further improvement for vaccine application.

[Evaluation of the sensitization power of Montenegro skin test]

The Montenegro skin test, used to diagnose cutaneous leishmaniasis, is now being considered to detect immunogenicity after vaccination. In this study, we evaluated the ability of this test to induce immune response and IFN-g production in subjects not previously exposed to Leishmania. The Montenegro skin test was performed using antigens of L. amazonensis produced by our laboratory (group I) or by FIOCRU-RJ (group II). At day 30, 33% of the subjects from group I and 42% from group II were positive, compared to 67% from group I and 50% from group II at day 90. IFN-y was detected in 56 % of subjects from group I and 17% from group II at day 30 (169+/-309 and 11+/-36pg/ml) and in 67% from group I and 58% from group II by day 360 (69+/-107 and 18+/-20pg/ml). These data demonstrate that the Montenegro skin test induces not only a delayed hypersensitivity reaction, but also IFN-y production.

Immunogenicity and safety of autoclaved Leishmania major plus BCG vaccine in healthy Sudanese volunteers

In a longitudinal study in the epidemiology of Leishmania donovani infection in an endemic focus in eastern Sudan, we observed that previous exposure or infection with Leishmania major appeared to protect against visceral leishmaniasis caused by L. donovani. We therefore conducted a study to test the safety and immunogenicity of a vaccine consisting of autoclaved L. major (ALM) plus BCG in inducing protection in vaccinated individuals. Leishmanin-negative healthy Sudanese volunteers were enrolled in the study and were divided into three groups: group (A) received ALM+BCG, group (B) received BCG alone, and group (C) received the vaccine diluent. The subjects were examined for their clinical and immunological responses before intervention, following intervention and 6-8 weeks after vaccination. Vaccinated subjects (group A) developed localized reactions at the sites of vaccine inoculation that ulcerated and healed within 4-6 weeks; 61.6% of them converted to leishmanin reactive following vaccination. Only one subject in group (C) became leishmanin-positive. A total 76.9% of the vaccinated volunteers in group (A) produced significant levels of interferon-gamma in response to L. major antigen. The vaccine produced significant cellular immune responses that may protect against natural challenge. None of the groups had systemic reactions and all the reactions observed in the vaccinated group were comparable with the BCG-vaccinated group.

Safety and immunogenicity of a killed Leishmania (L.) amazonensis vaccine against cutaneous leishmaniasis in Colombia: a randomized controlled trial

The safety and immunogenicity of an intramuscular (i.m.) and intradermal (ID) formulation of autoclaved Leishmania (Leishmania) amazonensis vaccine was evaluated in 296 volunteers in a randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind trial in Colombia. There were 4 vaccination groups: i.m. vaccine, i.m. placebo, ID vaccine, and ID placebo. The ID formulations were mixed with BCG as adjuvant at the time of injection. For each group, 3 vaccinations were given with a 20-day interval between injections, and adverse events were monitored at 20 min, and at 2, 7 and 21 days after each injection. BCG-induced adverse reactions resulted in cancellation of the third vaccine administration in the ID groups. Antibody titres did not differ significantly between the groups. Montenegro skin-test conversion was achieved by 86.4% and 90% of the i.m. vaccine group and by 25% and 5% of the i.m. placebo group 80 days and 1 year after vaccination, respectively. A significant increase in mean Leishmania-antigen lymphocyte proliferation indexes was observed after i.m. vaccine immunization, but not after i.m. placebo immunization, 80 days and 1 year after vaccination. Significant levels of IFN gamma but not IL-10 were observed 1 year after vaccination in the i.m. vaccine group compared to the i.m. placebo group. The good safety profile and evidence of Th1 immune reactions due to i.m. vaccination in this phase-I/II study suggest that a population-based phase-III efficacy trial of the i.m. vaccine should be initiated.

Injection with interleukin-4-secreting fibroblasts efficiently induces T helper type 2 cell-dominated immune response

To determine whether the paracrine secretion of interleukin-4 (IL-4) can efficiently induce T helper type 2 (Th2) cell-dominated immune response, BLK fibroblasts were stably transfected to secrete IL-4 (750 units/10(6) cells/48 h). Their effects on T helper cell-mediated immune response were investigated in ovalbumin (OVA)-primed C57BL/6 mice, and were compared with those of free recombinant IL-4. Injection with IL-4-secreting fibroblasts (BLK/IL-4) significantly increased anti-OVA IgG1 production in OVA-primed mice. In addition, the BLK/IL-4 cells were more effective than free recombinant IL-4 in decreasing OVA-specific IFN-gamma production and in increasing OVA-specific IL-4 production by splenic CD4(+) T cells. This work suggests that IL-4-secreting fibroblasts can efficiently induce Th2 cell-dominated immune response and may be beneficial in the treatment of diseases caused by undesired Th1 cell-dominated responses.

IFN-gamma, IL-4, IL-10 and IL-12 gene expression in BCG-Leishmania vaccination of Trypanosoma cruzi-infected mice

We have previously shown that vaccination of BALB/c mice with a combination of BCG plus killed Leishmania promastigotes, applied by the i.p. route 10 and 3 days before Trypanosoma cruzi inoculation, prolonged their survival and decreased their parasitaemia. In the present study we show that the BCG-Leishmania vaccine induced higher levels of circulating IFN-gamma in acute and chronic infection of mice [on day 25 and 40 post-infection (p.i.) respectively], in comparison to unvaccinated animals (PBS-treated). Though the IFN-gamma mRNA content of spleen cells of vaccinated and infected mice (on day 25 p.i.) was similar to that of unvaccinated animals, the BCG-Leishmania vaccine enhanced significantly the production of IFN-gamma by spleen cells stimulated with T. cruzi antigens. This effect was observed to a lower extent in BCG- and Leishmania-treated mice. The BCG-Leishmania vaccine reduced the expression of the IL-10 mRNA of splenocytes as soon as day 12 p.i., before the peak parasitaemia. Such this effect was not observed in BCG- or Leishmania-treated animals. On day 25 p.i., the BCG plus Leishmania- or BCG-treatment of mice abolished the capacity of spleen cells to produce IL-10 in response to T. cruzi antigens. The levels of mIL-4 RNA and protein production were not modified in any group of mice. T. cruzi infection in BCG-Leishmania-vaccined mice stimulated an early and high production of IL-12 transcripts in spleen cells during the acute phase of the infection, that was prolonged during the chronic phase of infection. This effect was weaker or absent in BCG- and Leishmania-treated animals, respectively. These results indicate that the BCG-Leishmania vaccine stimulates the production of IL-12 and IFN-gamma, but inhibits that of IL-10 and is without effect on IL-4 when mice are infected with T. cruzi. This highlights the key role of endogenously produced IFN-gamma, IL-10 and IL-12 in the control of T. cruzi acute and chronic infection in mice and the favorable modulation of their balance by a vaccination combining BCG and Leishmania.

Vaccination of mice with a combination of BCG and killed Leishmania promastigotes reduces acute Trypanosoma cruzi infection by promoting an IFN-gamma response

The combination of BCG with killed Leishmania promastigotes, demonstrated to be efficient in the cure of patients suffering American cutaneous leishmaniasis and in the induction of a long-term immune response in healthy vaccinated volunteers, was tested in BALB/c mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi, in comparison to BCG or Leishmania alone, and a vehicle (PBS) control. BCG-Leishmania vaccination, applied intra-peritoneally 10 and 3 days before T. cruzi trypomastigote inoculation, prolonged the survival, and reduced blood parasitaemia of infected animals. Proliferation studies indicated that splenocytes of mice vaccinated with BCG-Leishmania and harvested in the acute phase of T. cruzi infection displayed stimulation indices higher than cells from PBS-treated mice when stimulated with PHA mitogen, PPD, Leishmania or T. cruzi antigens. Injections of a monoclonal antibody able to neutralise IFN-gamma into BCG-Leishmania vaccinated mice increased parasitaemia to levels similar to those of control animals (treated with PBS) and reversed the beneficial effect of vaccination on the proliferative response to T. cruzi antigen. These results show that vaccination of mice with BCG plus killed Leishmania promastigotes delayed acute T. cruzi infection, stimulated a T-cell response to T. cruzi antigen and promoted IFN-gamma production.

A randomised, double-blind, controlled trial of a killed L. major vaccine plus BCG against zoonotic cutaneous leishmaniasis in Iran

Safety and efficacy of killed (autoclaved) L. major promastigotes, ALM, mixed with BCG against zoonotic cutaneous leishmaniasis was tested in healthy volunteers (n = 2453) in a randomized double blind trial vs. BCG as control. Side-effects were similar in both groups but tended to be slightly more frequent and prolonged in the ALM + BCG group. Leishmanin skin test conversion (induration > or =5 mm) was significantly greater in the ALM + BCG than in the BCG group (36.2% vs. 7.9% on day-80 and 33% vs. 19%, after 1 year, respectively). Cumulative incidence rates for 2 years, were similar in both groups (18.0% vs. 18.5%). However, LST responders on day 80 (> or =5 mm) had a significantly lower incidence (35%) of CL during the first year than non-responders. A single dose of ALM + BCG is not sufficiently immunogenic to provide a measurable response when compared to BCG alone. A single dose of this vaccine has been shown to be safe with no evidence of an exacerbating response following natural infection; hence, multiple doses or other adjuvants should be considered to increase its immunogenicity.

Leishmania vaccines: Old and New

The approach to the development of a Leishmania vaccine has undergone a revolution since its early beginnings with the ancient practice of leishmazation: the inoculation of infectious parasites from an active lesion in order to produce a self-healing lesion in a healthy individual. Controlled infection has been followed by injection of killed parasites and has now progressed to subunit and naked DNA vaccines. Emanuela Handman here discusses the current studies and the future prospects for a Leishmania vaccine with a focus on cutaneous leishmaniasis. Unfortunately, what J.F. Williams said about antiparasite vaccines in 1987 (Ref. 1) is still true in 1997: 'the reasons for optimism are less evident than the reasons for enthusiasm'.

Polymorphism in tumor necrosis factor genes associated with mucocutaneous leishmaniasis

Recent studies have shown that mucocutaneous leishmaniasis (MCL), a severe and debilitating form of American cutaneous leishmaniasis (ACL) caused by Leishmania braziliensis infection, is accompanied by high circulating levels of tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha. Analysis of TNF polymorphisms in Venezuelan ACL patients and endemic unaffected controls demonstrates a high relative risk (RR) of 7.5 (P < 0.001) of MCL disease in homozygotes for allele 2 of a polymorphism in intron 2 of the TNF-beta gene, especially in females (RR = 9.5; P < 0.001) compared with males (RR = 4; P < 0.05). A significantly higher frequency (P < 0.05) of allele 2 at the -308-basepair TNF-alpha gene polymorphism was also observed in MCL patients (0.18) compared with endemic control subjects (0.069), again associated with a high relative risk of disease (RR = 3.5; P < 0.05) even in the heterozygous condition. Because both the TNF-alpha and TNF-beta polymorphisms have previously been linked with functional differences in TNF-alpha levels, these data suggest that susceptibility to the mucocutaneous form of disease may be directly associated with regulatory polymorphisms affecting TNF-alpha production.