Polydactyly of the thumb

Modified Bilhaut-Cloquet Procedure for the Reconstruction of Wassel Type III Radial Polydactyly

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this research is to study the modified surgical effect of Wassel type III radial polydactyly thumbs of equal or nearly equal size treated.

METHODS

The study sample consisted of 12 reconstructed cases of Wassel type III radial polydactyly. The proximal phalanx was unequally combined by the curvature osteotomy and aligned the articular surface, and the distal phalanx was symmetrically combined. A fragment bone was filled in the depression of the distal phalanx to correct nail curvature and prevent seagull deformities. Twelve cases were available for assessment using an evaluation form on the Japanese Society for Surgery of the Hand.

RESULTS

An average functional point was 13.75 points (maximum 14 points). The interphalangeal joint motion was reduced, but this joint was stable in all cases. The cosmetic score was averaged 3.6 (maximum 4 points), and most parents were satisfied with the postoperative appearance and functional results.

CONCLUSION

Our modification of Bihaut-Cloquet procedure is an effective way to provide a well-functioning thumb for Wassel type III radial polydactyly thumbs.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

Nail size and appearance following nail fusion plasty of thumb duplication✰

PURPOSE

To evaluate nail appearance after nail fusion plasty to treat thumb duplication.

METHODS

A modified form of nail fusion plasty was performed on 17 reconstructed thumbs of 16 children with thumb duplications, commencing in January 2010. We assessed nail width and nail, lunular, and nail fold deformities using the Wang-Gao scoring system. All 17 thumbs were evaluated over an average of 32 months (range, 12-48 months) of follow-up.

RESULTS

One patient with bilateral thumb deformities was excluded. The width ratios of 15 reconstructed nails (compared with those of the contralateral thumbs) were 82-118% (average, 97%). Nine thumbs exhibited nail ridges or gaps; the average ridge/gap score was 1.23 (maximum, 2). Six thumbs exhibited lunular deformities; the average score was 1.58 (maximum, 2). Another six thumbs evidenced nail fold deformities; the average score was 1.64 (maximum, 2). Only one thumb exhibited nail dehiscence. Two thumbs had no nail deformity. The final assessments were excellent in 14 cases, good in 2 cases, and fair in 1 case.

CONCLUSIONS

We could not significantly reduce the deformity rate of the nail plate, nail fold, or lunula using our new technique, but the deformities were much less marked than previously. Nail fusion plasty usefully enlarges the nail and pulp in patients with hypoplastically duplicated thumbs.

A Modified Bilhaut-Cloquet Procedure for Zigzag Thumb Polydactyly Types III and IV

Background:

A review of the English literature over the least 43 years revealed only a total of 53 cases of Wassel types III, IV, and VII treated by the Bilhaut–Cloquet (B–C) procedure. Furthermore, the detailed results and range of motion were only given in 2 series (a total of 9 cases).

Methods:

Four cases of Wassel types III and IV thumb duplications with zigzag deformity were treated with a modified B–C procedure. The main modification was minimal central resections at the joints aiming for joint preservation to improve the postoperative range of motion of the new thumb.

Results:

The results showed an excellent overall functional score (Tada score of 5 of 5 in all cases). The mean range of motion at the metacarpophalangeal joint was excellent (60°), but the mean at the interphalangeal joint was only 20°. Cosmetically, all thumbs were “too wide” and a panel of 3 hand surgeons scored the cosmetic result (0–10 scoring system) between 5.7 and 6.7. No secondary procedures were done, and all parents were “very satisfied” despite the wide thumbs and split nails. This was attributed to the presence of an ugly preoperative zigzag appearance, and hence the comparative postoperative appearance was satisfactory.

Conclusion:

The modified B–C procedure gives a satisfactory function, but the cosmetic outcome is suboptimal.

On-top and side-to-side plasties for thumb polydactyly

•

“On-top” and “side-to-side” plasties are techniques used for treating thumb duplications.

•

The functional results of these techniques have not been reported in the literature.

•

We report on two cases and document excellent functional results.

Introduction

“On-top” and “side-to-side” plasties are techniques used for treating thumb duplications in which one thumb is adequate proximally and the other thumb contains a better pulp and nail distally. The detailed functional results of these techniques have not been reported in the literature. We report on two cases.

Presentation of cases

The first case had Wassel type VI duplication. The ulnar duplicate had a functioning interphalangeal joint and the radial duplicate had a functioning carpometacarpal joint. “On-top” plasty was done by putting the distal part of the ulnar duplicate on top of the proximal part of the radial duplicate. At 10 years after surgery, the outcome was excellent both cosmetically and functionally. In the second case (Wassel type VII with a zigzag deformity), the radial duplicate had a hypoplastic distal phalanx with no nail. The ulnar duplicate had a functioning interphalangeal joint and the radial duplicate had a functioning carpometacarpal joint. “Side-to-side” plasty was done by joining both thumbs side-to-side at the level of the proximal phalanx. At 3 years after surgery, the outcome we considered acceptable cosmetically and excellent functionally.

Discussion

We could not find similar cases in the literature with detailed long-term postoperative results.

Conclusion

“On-top” and “side-to-side” plasties in the management of specific cases of thumb polydactyly obtain excellent functional results with excellent or acceptable cosmetic outcome.

A Matched Comparative Study of the Bilhaut Procedure Versus Resection and Reconstruction for Treatment of Radial Polydactyly Types II and IV

PURPOSE

To compare outcomes of the Bilhaut procedure with outcomes of conventional resection and reconstruction in radial polydactyly types II and IV.

METHODS

Patients treated with the Bilhaut procedure were radiologically matched with patients treated with reconstruction. Evaluated outcomes included the Rotterdam assessment system, pinch strength, and thumb size measurements. To determine objectively which aesthetic outcome scores truly depended on surgical technique rather than observer opinion, we analyzed evaluations by a panel of 22 individuals with varying clinical experience who were blinded to the study protocol, using a linear mixed regression model.

RESULTS

The Bilhaut procedure reduced the risk of suboptimal outcome for metacarpophalangeal joint instability in type IV radial polydactyly. Conversely, the Bilhaut procedure increased the risk of suboptimal scar appearance, residual prominence at amputation site, thumb size, and nail appearance. Tip pinch strength was more significantly reduced after the Bilhaut compared with reconstruction, whereas pulp circumference and nail width exceeded 100% of the unaffected contralateral hand after the Bilhaut reconstruction. There was no significant difference in active range of motion between procedures. Nail appearance proved the only aesthetic drawback of the Bilhaut procedure after adjustment for clinical experience.

CONCLUSIONS

There was superior metacarpophalangeal joint stability after the Bilhaut procedure for radial polydactyly type IV, but this did not result in the presumed benefit to thumb strength. For experienced surgeons, both procedures resulted in comparable thumb active range of motion. However, aesthetic results were more likely perceived as pleasing after conventional reconstruction, even after adjusting for observer experience with regard to nail appearance. Despite possible benefits of modified Bilhaut procedures that preserve the nail, conventional reconstruction is the preferred procedure until otherwise proven.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic III.

Duplication

Congenital limb duplications include pre- and post-axial polydactyly, central polydactyly, and the mirror-hand spectrum. Treatment of these duplications constitutes a significant functional and aesthetic challenge for the reconstructive hand surgeon. This article provides an inclusive review of the embryologic and molecular mechanisms underlying these deformities and focuses on their clinical treatment. The anatomic variation, classification, surgical treatment, and outcomes of surgical intervention are reviewed for each of the disorders of duplication.

The "U-ligament" for collateral ligament reconstruction in duplicate thumb

Duplicate thumb is a common congenital difference with complex management. Surgical treatment includes reconstruction of the collateral ligaments to optimise future function and cosmesis. We present the use of the "U-ligament" to further refine collateral ligament reconstruction. We have found it to be a simple and reliable technique.

Congenital anomalies: a 25-year overview

Expansion of the discipline of hand surgery and heightened interest in congenital problems have resulted in major advances in the treatment of congenital hand anomalies over the past 25 years. Increased experience with congenital anomalies of the hand has expanded the hand surgeon's knowledge of patterns and relationships between different anomalies resulting in new methods of classification and more logical approaches to treatment. The principles of treatment of the more common anomalies, such as syndactyly, established by prior generations of hand surgeons have been refined in details of technique. New technologies, such as distraction lengthening and free vascularized transfers, have allowed the surgeon to treat new problems and old problems in new ways. In spite of our successes, much remains to challenge hand surgeons in this new millennium, especially in the construction of joints and the expanding field of fetal surgery.