Biochemical studies of homologous and nonhomologous recombination in human cells

Z-form extracellular DNA is a structural component of the bacterial biofilm matrix

Biofilms are community architectures adopted by bacteria inclusive of a self-formed extracellular matrix that protects resident bacteria from diverse environmental stresses and, in many species, incorporates extracellular DNA (eDNA) and DNABII proteins for structural integrity throughout biofilm development. Here, we present evidence that this eDNA-based architecture relies on the rare Z-form. Z-form DNA accumulates as biofilms mature and, through stabilization by the DNABII proteins, confers structural integrity to the biofilm matrix. Indeed, substances known to drive B-DNA into Z-DNA promoted biofilm formation whereas those that drive Z-DNA into B-DNA disrupted extant biofilms. Importantly, we demonstrated that the universal bacterial DNABII family of proteins stabilizes both bacterial- and host-eDNA in the Z-form in situ. A model is proposed that incorporates the role of Z-DNA in biofilm pathogenesis, innate immune response, and immune evasion.

Making ends meet: repairing breaks in bacterial DNA by non-homologous end-joining

DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are one of the most dangerous forms of DNA lesion that can result in genomic instability and cell death. Therefore cells have developed elaborate DSB-repair pathways to maintain the integrity of genomic DNA. There are two major pathways for the repair of DSBs in eukaryotes: homologous recombination and non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ). Until very recently, the NHEJ pathway had been thought to be restricted to the eukarya. However, an evolutionarily related NHEJ apparatus has now been identified and characterized in the prokarya. Here we review the recent discoveries concerning bacterial NHEJ and discuss the possible origins of this repair system. We also examine the insights gained from the recent cellular and biochemical studies of this DSB-repair process and discuss the possible cellular roles of an NHEJ pathway in the life-cycle of prokaryotes and phages.

Modification of non-conservative double-strand break (DSB) rejoining activity after the induction of cisplatin resistance in human tumour cells

The induction of collateral radioresistance after the development of cisplatin resistance is a well-documented phenomenon; however, the exact processes that are responsible for the cisplatin-induced radioresistance remain to be elucidated. There was no obvious difference in the level of radiation-induced DNA double strand breaks (DSBs), in DSB rejoining rates, or the level of the catalytic subunit of the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PKcs) in the cisplatin- and radiation-sensitive 2780/WT and cisplatin-resistant 2780/CP cell lines. However, there was a significantly (P < 0.01) lower level of DSB misrejoining activity within nuclear protein extracts derived from the cisplatin- and radiation-sensitive 2780/WT and OAW42/WT tumour cell lines than in similar extracts from their cisplatin- (and radiation-) resistant 2780/CP and OAW42/CP counterparts. All of the DSB misrejoining events involved deletions of between 134 and 444 bp that arose through illegitimate recombination at short repetitive sequences, such as those that arise through non-homologous repair (NHR). These data further support the notion that the radiosensitivity of DSB repair proficient human tumour cell lines may be partly determined by the predisposition of these cell lines to activate non-conservative DSB rejoining pathways. Furthermore, our data suggest that the induction of acquired cisplatin resistance is associated with a two- to threefold decrease in the activity of a non-conservative DSB rejoining mechanism that appears to be a manifestation of NHR.

End joining of genomic DNA and transgene DNA in fertilized mouse eggs

A linear 5.2-kb HS2/beta-globin construct with an upstream KpnI terminus (4-nucleotide (nt) 3' protruding single strand, PSS) and a downstream SalI terminus (4-nt 5' PSS) was microinjected into fertilized mouse eggs. The injected DNA fragments integrated into the mouse genome primarily as a head-to-tail tandem array. Chromosome/transgene junctions were obtained from seven of eight transgenic animals. All of the junctions occurred in the proximity of a transgene KpnI end; a maximum loss of 8 nt from the transgene terminus was observed. Two of these junctions completely preserved the 4-nt KpnI 3' PSS. Transgene/transgene junctions from two animals were analyzed. SalI/KpnI junctions that completely preserved both the SalI 5' PSS and the KpnI 3' PSS were found in each animal. These are the first examples of complete nt preservation at junctions formed between a 5' PSS terminus and a 3' PSS terminus in transgenic mice. The data are consistent with the fill-in model of Thode et al. [Cell 60 (1990) 921-928] in which alignment proteins juxtapose 5' PSS and 3' PSS termini; DNA polymerase then utilizes the recessed 3'-OH of the 5' PSS terminus as a primer to synthesize DNA across the gap. This mechanism results in the formation of junctions with no loss of sequence. The results described in the present paper suggest that this mechanism may be involved in the formation of junctions in transgenic mice.

Repair of a specific double-strand break generated within a mammalian chromosome by yeast endonuclease I-SceI

We established a mouse Ltk- cell line that contains within its genome a herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene (tk) that had been disrupted by the insertion of the recognition sequence for yeast endonuclease I-SceI. The artificially introduced 18 bp I-SceI recognition sequence was likely a unique sequence in the genome of the mouse cell line. To assess whether an induced double-strand break (DSB) in the genomic tk gene would be repaired preferentially by gene targeting or non-homologous recombination, we electroporated the mouse cell line with endonuclease I-SceI alone, one of two different gene targeting constructs alone, or with I-SceI in conjunction with each of the two targeting constructs. Each targeting construct was, in principle, capable of correcting the defective genomic tk sequence via homologous recombination. tk+ colonies were recovered following electroporation of cells with I-SceI in the presence or absence of a targeting construct. Through the detection of small deletions at the I-SceI recognition sequence in the mouse genome, we present evidence that a specific DSB can be introduced into the genome of a living mammalian cell by yeast endonuclease I-SceI. We further report that a DSB in the genome of a mouse Ltk- cell is repaired preferentially by non-homologous end-joining rather than by targeted homologous recombination with an exogenous donor sequence. The potential utility of this system is discussed.

Homologous pairing and strand exchange promoted by the Escherichia coli RecT protein

RecT protein of Escherichia coli promotes the formation of joint molecules between homologous linear double-stranded M13mp19 replicative-form bacteriophage DNA and circular single-stranded M13mp19 DNA in the presence of exonuclease VIII, the recE gene product. The joint molecules were formed by a mechanism involving the pairing of the complementary strand of the linear double-stranded DNA substrate with the circular single-stranded DNA substrate coupled with the displacement of the noncomplementary strand. When the homologous linear double-stranded DNA substrate had homologous 3' or 5' single-stranded tails, then RecT promoted homologous pairing and strand exchange in the absence of exonuclease VIII. Histone H1 could substitute for RecT protein; however, joint molecules formed in the presence of histone H1 did not undergo strand exchange. These results indicate that under the reaction conditions used, the observed strand exchange reaction is promoted by RecT and is not the result of spontaneous branch migration. These results are consistent with the observation that expression of RecE (exonuclease VIII) and RecT substitutes for RecA in some recombination reactions in E. coli.

Characterization of DNA end joining in a mammalian cell nuclear extract: junction formation is accompanied by nucleotide loss, which is limited and uniform but not site specific

Mammalian cells have a marked capacity to repair double-strand breaks in DNA, but the molecular and biochemical mechanisms underlying this process are largely unknown. A previous report has described an activity from mammalian cell nuclei that is capable of multimerizing blunt-ended DNA substrates (R. Fishel, M.K. Derbyshire, S.P. Moore, and C.S.H. Young, Biochimie 73:257-267, 1991). In this report, we show that nuclear extracts from HeLa cells contain activities which preferentially join linear plasmid substrates in either a head-to-head or tail-to-tail configuration, that the joining reaction is covalent, and that the joining is accompanied by loss of sequence at the junction. Sequencing revealed that there was a loss of a uniform number of nucleotides from junctions formed from any one type of substrate. The loss was not determined by any simple site-specific mechanism, but the number of nucleotides lost was affected by the precise terminal sequence. There was no major effect on the efficiency or outcome of the joining reaction with substrates containing blunt ends or 3' or 5' protruding ends. Using a pair of plasmid molecules with distinguishable restriction enzyme sites, we also observed that blunt-ended DNA substrates could join with those containing protruding 3' ends. As with the junctions formed between molecules with identical ends, there was uniform loss of nucleotides. Taken together, the data are consistent with two models for the joining reaction in which molecules are aligned either throughout most of their length or by using small sequence homologies located toward their ends. Although either model can explain the preferential formation of head-to-head and tail-to-tail products, the latter predicts the precise lossof nucleotides observed. These activities are found in all cell lines examined so far and most likely represent an important repair activity of the mammalian cell.

Nonhomologous recombination in human cells

Nonhomologous recombination (NHR) is a major pathway for the repair of chromosomal double-strand breaks in the DNA of somatic cells. In this study, a comparison was made between the nonhomologous end joining of transfected adenovirus DNA fragments in vivo and the ability of purified human proteins to catalyze nonhomologous end joining in vitro. Adenovirus DNA fragments were shown to be efficiently joined in human cells regardless of the structure of the ends. Sequence analysis of these junctions revealed that the two participating ends frequently lost nucleotides from the 3' strands at the site of the joint. To examine the biochemical basis of the end joining, nuclear extracts were prepared from a wide variety of mammalian cell lines and tested for their ability to join test plasmid substrates. Efficient ligation of the linear substrate DNA was observed, the in vitro products being similar to the in vivo products with respect to the loss of 3' nucleotides at the junction. Substantial purification of the end-joining activity was carried out with the human immature T-cell-line HPB-ALL. The protein preparation was found to join all types of linear DNA substrates containing heterologous ends with closely equivalent efficiencies. The in vitro system for end joining does not appear to contain any of the three known DNA ligases, on the basis of a number of criteria, and has been termed the NHR ligase. The enriched activity resides in a high-molecular-weight recombination complex that appears to include and require the human homologous pairing protein HPP-1 as well as the NHR ligase. Characterization of the product molecules of the NHR ligase reaction suggests that they are linear oligomers of the monomer substrate joined nonrandomly head-to-head and/or tail-to-tail. The joined ends of the products were found to be modified by a 3' exonuclease prior to ligation, and no circular DNA molecules were detected. These types of products are similar to those required for the breakage-fusion-bridge cycle, a major NHR pathway for chromosome double-strand break repair.

Homologous pairing proteins encoded by the Escherichia coli recE and recT genes

Early genetic analysis of alternate recombination pathways in Escherichia coli identified the RecE recombination pathway and the required exonuclease VIII encoded by the recE gene. Observations that not all recombination events promoted by the RecE pathway require recA suggest the existence of an additional homologous pairing protein besides RecA in E. coli. Genetic and biochemical analysis of the recE gene region indicates there are two partially overlapping genes, recE and recT, encoding at least two proteins: exoVIII and the RecT protein. Biochemical analysis has shown that the RecT protein, in combination with exoVIII, promotes homologous pairing and strand exchange in reactions containing linear duplex DNA and homologous, circular, singlestranded DNA as substrates. This reaction occurs in the absence of any high-energy cofactor. These two proteins, RecT and exoVIII, appear to be members of a second class of homologous pairing proteins that are required in genetic recombination and differ from the class of homologous pairing proteins that includes RecA. Members of this second class of proteins appear to include both bacteriophage-encoded proteins and proteins from eukaryotes and their viruses.

Nonhomologous recombination in human cells

Nonhomologous recombination (NHR) is a major pathway for the repair of chromosomal double-strand breaks in the DNA of somatic cells. In this study, a comparison was made between the nonhomologous end joining of transfected adenovirus DNA fragments in vivo and the ability of purified human proteins to catalyze nonhomologous end joining in vitro. Adenovirus DNA fragments were shown to be efficiently joined in human cells regardless of the structure of the ends. Sequence analysis of these junctions revealed that the two participating ends frequently lost nucleotides from the 3' strands at the site of the joint. To examine the biochemical basis of the end joining, nuclear extracts were prepared from a wide variety of mammalian cell lines and tested for their ability to join test plasmid substrates. Efficient ligation of the linear substrate DNA was observed, the in vitro products being similar to the in vivo products with respect to the loss of 3' nucleotides at the junction. Substantial purification of the end-joining activity was carried out with the human immature T-cell-line HPB-ALL. The protein preparation was found to join all types of linear DNA substrates containing heterologous ends with closely equivalent efficiencies. The in vitro system for end joining does not appear to contain any of the three known DNA ligases, on the basis of a number of criteria, and has been termed the NHR ligase. The enriched activity resides in a high-molecular-weight recombination complex that appears to include and require the human homologous pairing protein HPP-1 as well as the NHR ligase. Characterization of the product molecules of the NHR ligase reaction suggests that they are linear oligomers of the monomer substrate joined nonrandomly head-to-head and/or tail-to-tail. The joined ends of the products were found to be modified by a 3' exonuclease prior to ligation, and no circular DNA molecules were detected. These types of products are similar to those required for the breakage-fusion-bridge cycle, a major NHR pathway for chromosome double-strand break repair.

Characterization of DNA end joining in a mammalian cell nuclear extract: junction formation is accompanied by nucleotide loss, which is limited and uniform but not site specific

Mammalian cells have a marked capacity to repair double-strand breaks in DNA, but the molecular and biochemical mechanisms underlying this process are largely unknown. A previous report has described an activity from mammalian cell nuclei that is capable of multimerizing blunt-ended DNA substrates (R. Fishel, M.K. Derbyshire, S.P. Moore, and C.S.H. Young, Biochimie 73:257-267, 1991). In this report, we show that nuclear extracts from HeLa cells contain activities which preferentially join linear plasmid substrates in either a head-to-head or tail-to-tail configuration, that the joining reaction is covalent, and that the joining is accompanied by loss of sequence at the junction. Sequencing revealed that there was a loss of a uniform number of nucleotides from junctions formed from any one type of substrate. The loss was not determined by any simple site-specific mechanism, but the number of nucleotides lost was affected by the precise terminal sequence. There was no major effect on the efficiency or outcome of the joining reaction with substrates containing blunt ends or 3' or 5' protruding ends. Using a pair of plasmid molecules with distinguishable restriction enzyme sites, we also observed that blunt-ended DNA substrates could join with those containing protruding 3' ends. As with the junctions formed between molecules with identical ends, there was uniform loss of nucleotides. Taken together, the data are consistent with two models for the joining reaction in which molecules are aligned either throughout most of their length or by using small sequence homologies located toward their ends. Although either model can explain the preferential formation of head-to-head and tail-to-tail products, the latter predicts the precise lossof nucleotides observed. These activities are found in all cell lines examined so far and most likely represent an important repair activity of the mammalian cell.

The effects of terminal heterologies on gene targeting by insertion vectors in embryonic stem cells

We have examined the effects of placing nonhomologous DNA on the ends of an insertion-type gene targeting vector. The presence of terminal heterologies was found to be compatible with insertion targeting, and the terminal heterologies were efficiently removed. Terminal heterologies reduced the frequency of gene targeting to variable extents. The degree of inhibition of targeting was dependent on the length and the position of the heterology: 2.1kb heterologous sequences were more inhibitory than shorter regions of heterology, and heterology placed on the end of the long (4.8kb) arm of homology was more inhibitory than heterology positioned on the end of the short (0.8kb) arm. When heterology was placed on both arms of the targeting vector the targeting efficiencies were similar to or higher than when heterology was present on the long arm only. These results suggest that terminal sequences are removed simultaneously from both ends of targeting vectors. The removal of terminal sequences probably occurs by exonucleolytic degradation of both strands at each end, and removal of at least one of the strands is intimately coupled with the process of homologous recombination. These findings have implications for the design of gene targeting vectors.

DNA strand exchange catalyzed by proteins from vaccinia virus-infected cells

Vaccinia virus infection induces expression of a protein which can catalyze joint molecule formation between a single-stranded circular DNA and a homologous linear duplex. The kinetics of appearance of the enzyme parallels that of vaccinia virus DNA polymerase and suggests it is an early viral gene product. Extracts were prepared from vaccinia virus-infected HeLa cells, and the strand exchange assay was used to follow purification of this activity through five chromatographic steps. The most highly purified fraction contained three major polypeptides of 110 +/- 10, 52 +/- 5, and 32 +/- 3 kDa. The purified protein requires Mg2+ for activity, and this requirement cannot be satisfied by Mn2+ or Ca2+. One end of the linear duplex substrate must share homology with the single-stranded circle, although this homology requirement is not very high, as 10% base substitutions had no effect on the overall efficiency of pairing. As with many other eukaryotic strand exchange proteins, there was no requirement for ATP, and ATP analogs were not inhibitors. Electron microscopy was used to show that the joint molecules formed in these reactions were composed of a partially duplex circle of DNA bearing a displaced single-strand and a duplex linear tail. The recovery of these structures shows that the enzyme catalyzes true strand exchange. There is also a unique polarity to the strand exchange reaction. The enzyme pairs the 3' end of the duplex minus strand with the plus-stranded homolog, thus extending hybrid DNA in a 3'-to-5' direction with respect to the minus strand. Which viral gene (if any) encodes the enzyme is not yet known, but analysis of temperature-sensitive mutants shows that activity does not require the D5R gene product. Curiously, v-SEP appears to copurify with vaccinia virus DNA polymerase, although the activities can be partially resolved on phosphocellulose columns.