Absolute pitch in humans, its variations and possible connections with other known rhythmic phenomena

Absolute pitch: music and beyond

"Perfect pitch," known in the scientific literature as "absolute pitch" (AP), is a rare phenomenon that has fascinated musicians and scientists alike for over a century. There has been a great deal of conflict in the literature between advocates of the two main theories on the etiology of AP: some believe that AP is learned early in life through intensive musical training, whereas others believe AP to be largely innate. Both theories are alike, however, in considering AP to be exclusively a musical phenomenon. We propose a paradigm shift by presenting here a new model of AP, one that is predicated on two principles: (1) that AP may be relatively independent of musical experience; and (2) that there are different types of AP, each of which can be ascribed to discrete neurobiological mechanisms. We also review data from a diverse series of experiments that were designed to test explicitly both the predictions of our model and a series of historical myths about AP. In each case, the data strongly support our model. We conclude with a general discussion on the nature of AP, the relevance of these findings for other areas of research, and future directions of study.

A nonmusical paradigm for identifying absolute pitch possessors

The ability to identify and reproduce sounds of specific frequencies is remarkable and uncommon. The etiology and defining characteristics of this skill, absolute pitch (AP), have been very controversial. One theory suggests that AP requires a specific type of early musical training and that the ability to encode and remember tones depends on these learned musical associations. An alternate theory argues that AP may be strongly dependent on hereditary factors and relatively independent of musical experience. To date, it has been difficult to test these hypotheses because all previous paradigms for identifying AP have required subjects to employ knowledge of musical nomenclature. As such, these tests are insensitive to the possibility of discovering AP in either nonmusicians or musicians of non-Western training. Based on previous literature in pitch memory, a paradigm is presented that is intended to distinguish between AP possessors and nonpossessors independent of the subjects' musical experience. The efficacy of this method is then tested with 20 classically defined AP possessors and 22 nonpossessors. Data from these groups strongly support the validity of the paradigm. The use of a nonmusical paradigm to identify AP may facilitate research into many aspects of this phenomenon.

Auditory brainstem responses after ovariectomy and estrogen replacement in rat

Previous work has suggested possible influences of ovarian hormones on evoked potentials in the auditory system. The aim of this project was to study the effects of ovariectomy and subsequent administration of estrogen replacement on the auditory brainstem response and the middle latency response. Groups of 90 day-old Long-Evans hooded rats were anesthetized for bilateral ovariectomies (ovex) and recordings made 3 weeks later. During the week prior to recordings some ovariectomized groups received subcutaneous injections of 10, 100 or 500 micrograms/kg Premarin in peanut oil, and other unoperated animals received vehicle injections. Recordings from vertex/chin using needle electrodes and pure tone stimulus parameters were made under Rompun/Ketamine. The results using 40 kHz tone stimuli showed that mean latencies for ovex animals were longer than animals in the 100 micrograms/kg Premarin group for waves 1a, 1an, 1b, 11, 111, 111n, and 1V/V. Other posthoc comparisons at 40 kHz stimulation revealed differences between control and 100 micrograms/kg Premarin groups for latencies of waves 1b, 1bn, 11 and 111. Latency reduction appeared for waves 1b, 1bn, 11 and 111 for the 10 ovex group, but only at wave 11 for the 500 ovex group, compared to ovex-only animals. Data from 8 kHz stimulation also demonstrated significant differences between the ovex and ovex 100 groups at waves 1bn and Vn. Observations of interpeak latency differences, especially between waves 1a and 11, suggested central as well as cochlear involvement in hormone action.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Statistical quantification of 24-hour and monthly variabilities of spontaneous otoacoustic emission frequency in humans

Previous evidence has suggested a relationship between spontaneous otoacoustic emissions (SOAEs) and established, biological cycles, although detailed statistical quantifications of the suggested relationships do not exist in the literature. In an attempt to statistically quantify the purported circadian and monthly influences on this phenomenon, two experiments were undertaken. The first experiment was conducted over eight weeks, investigating 31 SOAEs recorded from eight women and two men. Time series statistical analysis examined whether daily, weekly, and/or monthly cycles characterized SOAE frequency variability. Results yielded a significant monthly cycle for the majority of SOAEs recorded from the women but for none of the SOAEs recorded from the men. These results suggest the possibility that SOAE frequency fluctuation in women may be entrained to the monthly menstrual cycle. In the second experiment, hourly SOAE frequency stability was examined over a 24-h period to ascertain the nature of the daily frequency variation as precisely as possible. Four SOAEs from two subjects were examined, and time series analysis of these data included (1) modelling the autocorrelation structure of the measurements, (2) resolving each 24-h series of measurements into cyclical components of various periodicities, and (3) testing the statistical significance of given cycles within the spectrum of each series. Findings included a significant 24-h variability of frequency for each SOAE, suggesting the possibility of a circadian influence on frequency fluctuation. Results from the two experiments provide quantitative evidence supporting a hypothetical relationship between SOAEs and established, biological cycles.

Accuracy and consistency of absolute pitch

The accuracy and consistency of absolute pitch (AP) judgments have been measured on three subjects in two longitudinal studies separated by twenty years. The drifts and cyclical variations observed in the earlier study still persisted, and an investigation of two other subjects, one of whom was first studied forty years ago, suggests that they might undergo similar cyclical variations in their pitch perception. Pitch judgments also varied during the day. The detailed observations of these nonrandom fluctuations have been used to determine a value for the underlying consistency of the AP estimates. When the effects of the daytime variations and longer-term drifts were removed, the values for this consistency, as measured by the standard deviation, were calculated to be 3.1, 3.4, 3.7, 4.4, and 4.5 Hz for the five subjects. When an oscillator was used to produce the estimate, the consistency of the judgments was observed to depend on the accuracy of those judgments.

Effect of melatonin on the human electrocardiogram and simple reaction time responses

It has been suggested that melatonin may have therapeutic potential for alleviating jet lag. In an attempt to define further the effects of low pharmacological doses of melatonin on the human body, 5 mg of melatonin was given orally to one subject in a blind experiment. The electrocardiogram (ECG) was recorded together with simple reaction time (SRT) responses over a 5-h period after taking melatonin. The main part of the project was carried out under artificial domestic lighting conditions and involved ten evening sessions. Microprocessor analysis of the ECG of one subject clearly showed that melatonin had the effect of lengthening the RR interval, that between the peak of the P wave and the onset of the R wave, and the interval between the onset of the R wave and the peak of the T wave. A model to explain the cubic curve, which was fitted by regression analysis to the data, implies that the natural evening increase in melatonin may also increase these intervals. The results suggest that melatonin may affect both the phase and the amplitude of the observed ECG phenomenon. Analysis of more than 40,000 SRT responses to both visual and auditory stimuli implied that these responses might also be lengthened by melatonin. Frequency histograms of the responses and observations on premature and missed responses were not able to reproduce the results of other workers who found that higher doses (240 mg) of melatonin decreased the number of incorrect responses to simple reaction time tasks.

Changes in auditory perception in the menstrual cycle

In a attempt to specify the critical functional components involved in the menstrual fluctuation of the upper frequency limit of the binaural beat we have obtained evidence of better performance in a variety of tasks at period and mid-cycle than at other times. These tasks include detection of physical beating, low-frequency octave matching, and lateralisation of clicks having interaural time delays in the 100 musec region. Continuous pure-tone frequency discrimination did not show a significant cyclical pattern overall but there was a tendency for low-frequency discrimination to show the described pattern. An attempt is made to reconcile some of these results with those of Wynn (1973) on absolute pitch, in terms of possible physiological and biochemical correlates. Three conclusions can be drawn: (1) The representations both of low-frequency tones and of the interaural time differences involved in some localisation tasks are particularly susceptible to alteration by the biochemical changes of the menstrual cycle: (2) The changes underlying perceptual variations are multiple, and inevitably confounded in any single task. (3) The distinction between the sensitivity and bias parameters of performance appears to be valuable in specifying menstrual effects. Several further lines of enquiry are suggested, but methodological difficulties in cycle research make it likely that more progress will come from better understanding of the physiological bases of psychoacoustic tasks using other methods, rather than from investigating natural menstrual effects.