Membrane structure and electron microscopy. The significance of physical problems and techniques (freeze etching)

Deep-etch EM reveals that the early poxvirus envelope is a single membrane bilayer stabilized by a geodetic "honeycomb" surface coat

Three-dimensional "deep-etch" electron microscopy (DEEM) resolves a longstanding controversy concerning poxvirus morphogenesis. By avoiding fixative-induced membrane distortions that confounded earlier studies, DEEM shows that the primary poxvirus envelope is a single membrane bilayer coated on its external surface by a continuous honeycomb lattice. Freeze fracture of quick-frozen poxvirus-infected cells further shows that there is only one fracture plane through this primary envelope, confirming that it consists of a single lipid bilayer. DEEM also illustrates that the honeycomb coating on this envelope is completely replaced by a different paracrystalline coat as the poxvirus matures. Correlative thin section images of infected cells freeze substituted after quick-freezing, plus DEEM imaging of Tokuyasu-type cryo-thin sections of infected cells (a new application introduced here) all indicate that the honeycomb network on immature poxvirus virions is sufficiently continuous and organized, and tightly associated with the envelope throughout development, to explain how its single lipid bilayer could remain stable in the cytoplasm even before it closes into a complete sphere.

Cryo-electron microscopy of nervous tissue. A review

The present work attempts to demonstrate that cryofixation is a valuable method for the study of the nervous tissue. The use of the newly developed methods of cryofixation and freeze-etching without fixatives or cryoprotectants allows new exciting perspectives for the electron microscopical observation of cellular components, emphasizing their three-dimensional morphological structures. Significant contributions have been made on the fine structure of the cytoskeleton, cell membranes and cell organelles. The components of the cytoskeleton are distributed in different composition through the perikarya, dendrites and axon. The ubiquitous presence of the cytoskeleton suggests a crucial role in the functional activities of the neurons, especially in relation to the intracellular communication and to developmental and regeneration processes. Vitrified cellular membranes of myelin sheaths and rod outer segments have been observed in hydrated state by using cryofixation and cryotransfer techniques. These procedures allow new insights into the supramolecular structure and an approximation of morphological data to the present biophysical membrane model including a critical comparison with the current descriptions gained by conventional electron microscopy.

Intermediary structures during membrane fusion as observed by cryo-electron microscopy

Lipidic phases, containing 'lipidic particles' (dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine/cholesterol/dioleoylphosphatidylcho lin e and cardiolipin/dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine in the presence of Ca2+) have been investigated by preparing thin films from a suspension of sonicated vesicles. These thin films were vitrified and observed 'directly' by cryo-electron microscopy in their hydrated form. The thin films show various fusion products and fusion intermediates such as lipidic particles.

Modification of lipid phase behavior with membrane-bound cryoprotectants

Several derivatives of cholesterol containing oxyethylene headgroups with and without a terminal galactose have been synthesized in order to examine the effects of immobilizing a cryoprotectant at a membrane surface. In this work, we have studied the ability of the triethoxycholesterol (TEC) and triethoxycholesterol galactose (TEC-Gal) derivatives to modulate the phase behavior of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine membranes. Methods of fluorescence polarization, 31P-NMR and freeze-fracture electron microscopy were employed to monitor these changes in lipid phase behavior. Fluorescence polarization data demonstrated the ability of the derivatives to fluidize gel state and rigidify liquid-crystalline state phosphatidylcholines in a manner similar to that observed for cholesterol. Unlike cholesterol, however, the Tm of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) was reduced in a concentration-dependent manner with each of the derivatives. Freeze-fracture electron microscopy and 31P-NMR of DOPE dispersions indicate an increase in the lamellar to hexagonal phase-transition temperature on the order of 10-20 C degrees above room temperature for mixtures with 20 mol% of the derivatives. These results are discussed in terms of the properties exhibited by compounds such as carbohydrates, which are known to serve as cryoprotectants for synthetic and biological membranes.

Particles and pits matched in native membranes

We have obtained high resolution electron microscopic images of complementary membrane surface replicas of purified microsomal vesicles from pig kidney outer medulla containing Na+,K+-ATPase. Ultra-rapid freezing of a membrane suspension was followed by fracturing and replicating of the liquid helium cooled specimen under ultra-high vacuum conditions free of hydrocarbon contaminants. The protoplasmic fracture faces are populated with intramembrane particles while the external fracture faces reveal complementary pits. This is the first demonstration of extended precise matching of individual intramembrane particles and their corresponding pits in biological membranes containing transmembrane proteins. The data are also consistent with the theory that the majority of Na+,K+-ATPase mass is located at the protoplasmic half of the membrane.

Single bacteriorhodopsin molecules revealed on both surfaces of freeze-dried and heavy metal-decorated purple membranes

The flat sheets of the purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium contain only a single protein (bacteriorhodopsin) arranged in a hexagonal lattice. After freeze-drying at -80 degrees C (a method that is superior to air-drying), shadowing with tantalum/tungsten, and image processing, structural details on both surfaces are portrayed in the range of 2 nm. One surface is rough and lattice lines are clearly visible, whereas the other is smooth and the hexagonal order seems to be absent. The optical diffraction patterns, however, indicate a hexagonal lattice for both surfaces. In addition, these diffraction patterns are characteristic and easily distinguished. The orientation of the two surfaces was identified by silver decoration: partial condensation of silver on purple membranes enabled the smooth surface to be identified as the plasmatic and the rough surface as the exoplasmic surface. After image processing, the exoplasmic surface shows a triplet structure which exactly fits the projected structure determined by Unwin and Henderson (1975. Nature(Lond.). 257:28-32) at molecular resolution, whereas, on the plasmatic surface, four image details per unit cell are visible. Three of them match the arrangement of bacteriorhodopsin, whereas the fourth must be located over a lipidic array. Summarizing these results, it is possible to show the part of each single bacteriorhodopsin protein that is present in the surfaces of the purple membrane. By "shadowing" the membranes perpendicularly, we prove that these components of the surfaces are mainly portrayed by a decoration effect of the tantalum/tungsten condensate.

A freeze-etch electron microscopic study of liquid propane jet-frozen human erythrocyte membranes

Freeze-etch electron micrographs of haemolysing erythrocytes and isolated erythrocyte membranes frozen using a liquid propane jet-freezer reveal fracture faces very different from those seen after conventional freezing by dipping the specimens into partly solidified Freon 22. Instead of the rather smooth extracellular fracture faces found after conventional specimen freezing, extracellular fracture faces exhibiting large amounts of fibre-like structures are seen after liquid propane jet-freezing of these specimens. No such structures were found in normal red blood cells. When isolated erythrocyte membranes are frozen under conditions favouring spectrin-actin release, freeze-etch micrographs reveal an apparent continuity between the fibre-like structures on the extracellular fracture face and the long fibre-like structures which extent from the protoplasmic surface of the erythrocyte membrane. These results suggest that liquid propane jet-freezing is capable of revealing a structural difference between the membrane of haemolysing and nonhaemolysed red blood cells, and that this difference is related to the fibrous, peripheral proteins of the membrane.

Ice crystals specifically decorate hydrophilic sites on freeze-fractured models membranes

Experiments with yeast plasmalemma fracture faces, produced at -196 degrees C and exposed to pure water vapor before replication, showed a "specific decoration" with ice crystals of those pits in the extraplasmatic face where the matching particles of the plasmatic face had been removed (H. Gross et al., J. Cell Biol. 79 (1978) 646). THe preferred growth of cubic ice crystals on the small depressions of the extraplasmatic face could be caused by the cavity-like character of the surface relief or by physicochemical surface properties which differ from those of the surrounding lipid fractures face. The following results suggest that not geometric or topographic but physicochemical surface properties are responsible for the trapping of water molecules in the regions of the depressions. Freeze-fractured multilamellar stearic-acid crystals and cardiolipin liposomes exhibit after fracturing hydrophobic faces and hydrophilic steps (bimolecular steps with two polar head groups in half of the step height) which act as preferential nucleation sites and lead to the formation of discrete ice crystals mainly along the steps. Multilamellar crystals of the paraffin n-octatriacontane (C38H78) exhibit after freeze-fracturing hydrophobic faces and geometrically identical, but hydrophobic steps. In contrast to stearic acid these steps do not act as preferential nucleation sites.

Morphology of freeze-etched Treponema refringens (Nichols)

The freeze-etch technique was used to study the morphology of Treponema refringens (Nichols). There is a single band of cytoplasmic fibrils which follows a path in the form of a right-handed helix with a periodicity of 1500 nm around the body of the treponeme just below the cytoplasmic membrane. There are two major fracture planes, one located in the interior of the outer envelope and the second in the interior of the cytoplasmic membrane. The "blebs" or "surface protuberances", which are quite prominent in negative-stained preparations, were not evident with freeze-etch preparation, indicating they are not a part of the normal structure of this organism. The outer envelope in untreated cells was observed to closely fit the body of the treponeme, whereas the outer envelope of glutaraldehyde-treated cells had a loose, wrinkled appearance. Thus the "loose-fitting" outer envelope generally described for treponemes is most likely an artifact of preparation for negative-staining and thin-sectioning.

Evaluation of membrane structure facts and artefacts produced during freeze-fracturing

The freeze-fracture technique is now widely used in the study of membranes, but it should be stressed that it shows internal hydrophobic planes of membranes, prepared under physical conditions far removed from those prevailing in vivo. Hence there is considerable potential for artefact. Work on the membrane lipid component, the intramembrane particles, and their aggregation under certain conditions, is reviewed in the context of fact versus artefact. Particular attention is paid to the results of complementary replica experiments, performed in the author's laboratory and elsewhere, which indicate that lipid collapse and protein particle deformation contribute to the appearance of the membrane fracture face seen in the final replica. A model, showing the effects of freeze-fracturing on membranes, is presented.

Biological freezing and cryofixation

Freezing and freeze fixation are commonly used to achieve ultrastructural and biological preservation. Freezing in biological materials is complex because of their heterogeneous nature-water is unevenly distributed and the various domains are separated by semi-permeable membranes. Processes to be considered include: (1) osmotic gradients leading to redistribution of water, (2) nucleation and uncontrolled growth of ice crystals, (3) recrystallization of nucleated aqueous substrate. To avoid ultrastructural deformation in biological specimens cryofixatives are commonly employed. These are water soluble molecules, able to penetrate cell membranes (e.g. glycerol and dimethylsulphoxide). Interacting strongly with water, ions and bipolymers, they give rise to metabolic and physiological changes which render them useless for X-ray microprobe analytical studies. However, they can enable tissues to survive low temperature storage. Some plants and animals develop in vivo mechanisms which enable them to avoid or tolerate freezing. Alternative means of cryofixation have recently been developed. They rely on non-penetrating polymers of high and specific water binding capacity. These polymers enable the extracellular spaces to be vitrified rather than frozen. Such suppression of ice nuclei enables the cell contents to be maximally subcooled, resulting in the formation of nm dimension ice crystals. Since the polymers have a low osmotic activity and do not penetrate membranes, the interior of the cell is substantially undisturbed. Also hydrophilic polymers used as cryofixatives are physiologically less active than conventional cryoprotectants at equivalent weight concentrations, and th eir mechanical properties render them useful as matrices for cryosectioning.

The quatenary structure of Pseudomonas cytochrome oxidase studied by electron microscopy

Pseudomonas cytochrome oxidase (EC 1.9.3.2) was studied by negative staining in the electron microscope. The best resolution was obtained with uranyl oxalate (pH 6.0) as negative stain. Electron micrographs confirm the idea of the dimeric structure of the enzyme. A rough model of cytochrome oxidase was constructed based on different projections of the molecule seen in the electron micrographs. In this model the subunits are identical and sterically equivalent.

Effects of lipid phase transition of the freeze-cleaved envelope of Escherichia coli

We studied the fine structure of the envelope of Escherichia coli auxotroph K1060 after the cells were grown in the presence of one of the following fatty acids; oleic, palmitelaidic, or elidic acid. The cells were freeze-fractured after exposure to temperatures above and below the lipid phase transition range. As judged by freeze-etching methods, we observed that below the transition range the fracture plane of the inner membrane showed the typical aggregation of intramembranous particles (IMP) and concomitant development of areas devoid of IMP. In these areas we found a regular arrangement of equally spaced ridges, often intersected at 90 degrees by arrays of similar ridges. The ridges were composed of spherical particles measuring 4 to 5 nm in diameter. Formation and melting of these arrays took place within 15 to 30s after temperature shift-down or shift-up, respectively. Fixation in glutaraldehyde prevented these changes. The outer-membrane fracture plane revealed ordered areas to a lesser degree; these were discernible only by the regular arrangement of the IMP of the concave fracture plane. We interpret the data by suggesting that the pattern of ridges in E. coli K1060 is analogous to the band patterns described for artificial liposomes, and that the particles, possibly proteins, are lined up or extruded along the ridges during membrane lipid crystallization.

Freeze-etch study of Pseudomonas aeruginosa: localization within the cell wall of an ethylenediaminetetraacetate-extractable

A freeze-etch study of normal cells of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and of cells after incubation with ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA) and tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane (Tris) was performed. When cells were freeze-etched without a cryoprotective agent, a smooth outer cell wall layer, which showed a regular array of subunits, and the presence of flagella and pili were observed. These features were not observed in cells freeze-etched after cryoprotection with glycerol. Four fracture surfaces, which resulted from splitting down the center of the outer wall membrane and of the inner cytoplasmic membrane, were revealed in freeze-etched glycerol-protected cells. The murein layer was seen in profile between the outer cell wall membrane and the cytoplasmic membrane. Spherical units and small rods composed of the spherical units were observed in the inner layer of the outer cell wall membrane. These spherical units appeared to be attached to, or embedded in, the inner face of the outer layer of the outer cell wall membrane. These spherical units were removed from cells on exposure to EDTA-Tris, resulting in cells that were osmotically fragile. The spherical units were detected via electron microscopy of negatively stained preparations in the supernatant fluid of cellular suspensions treated with EDTA-Tris. Upon addition of Mg(2+), the spherical units were reaggregated into the inner layer of the outer cell wall membrane and the cells were restored to osmotic stability. The spherical units were shown to consist primarily of protein. These data are thought to represent the first ultrastructural demonstration of reaggregation of cell wall components within a living cell system.