CD4 similarity to proteins of infectious agents in AIDS and their role in autoimmunity

Human Immunodeficiency Virus Proteins Mimic Human T Cell Receptors Inducing Cross-Reactive Antibodies

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) hides from the immune system in part by mimicking host antigens, including human leukocyte antigens. It is demonstrated here that HIV also mimics the V-β-D-J-β of approximately seventy percent of about 600 randomly selected human T cell receptors (TCR). This degree of mimicry is greater than any other human pathogen, commensal or symbiotic organism studied. These data suggest that HIV may be evolving into a commensal organism just as simian immunodeficiency virus has done in some types of monkeys. The gp120 envelope protein, Nef protein and Pol protein are particularly similar to host TCR, camouflaging HIV from the immune system and creating serious barriers to the development of safe HIV vaccines. One consequence of HIV mimicry of host TCR is that antibodies against HIV proteins have a significant probability of recognizing the corresponding TCR as antigenic targets, explaining the widespread observation of lymphocytotoxic autoantibodies in acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). Quantitative enzyme-linked immunoadsorption assays (ELISA) demonstrated that every HIV antibody tested recognized at least one of twelve TCR, and as many as seven, with a binding constant in the 10-8 to 10-9 m range. HIV immunity also affects microbiome tolerance in ways that correlate with susceptibility to specific opportunistic infections.

Antigenic Complementarity Resulting in Idiotype–Antiidiotype Immune Complexes: Possible Contributor to AIDS Pathogenesis and Autoimmunity

One hundred and sixty seven combinations of viral + viral antibodies or viral + bacterial antibodies were tested for their ability to precipitate each other. Some antibodies produced against HIV epitopes recognize and precipitate some antibodies produced against cytomegalovirus (CMV), hepatitis B virus (HBV) core antigen, and Mycobacteria tuberculosis (MTb) and Staphylococcus epitopes but not those against HBV surface antigen, herpes simplex types 1 and 2 (HSV1 and HSV2) or Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), Streptococcus, or Escherichia coli. In addition, CMV antibodies precipitate those of HBV core and surface antigens as well as MTb, but not HSV, HSV2, EBV, Streptococcus or E. coli. HBV core (but not surface) antibodies precipitated Mycobacterium avium antibodies (MAv) but not MTb, Streptococcus, Staphylococcus or E. coli antibodies. Binding constants vary between kds of 10(-9) and 10(-7) M. Interactive antibodies act like idiotype-antiidiotype pairs suggesting that the inducing antigens are molecularly complementary. The resulting antibody interactions may explain the formation of circulating immune complexes that are commonly found in AIDS and in other diseases characterized by multiple, concurrent infections. This observation suggests that AIDS pathogenesis may involve autoimmune mechanisms in which the immune system attacks itself to form antibody-antibody circulating immune complexes that contribute to the hypergammaglobulinemia characteristic of AIDS. Complementary cofactor infections in AIDS may therefore contribute to the immunosuppression of the syndrome and difficulties treating these corresponding infections.

Antigenic complementarity in the origins of autoimmunity: a general theory illustrated with a case study of idiopathic thrombocytopenia purpura

We describe a novel, testable theory of autoimmunity, outline novel predictions made by the theory, and illustrate its application to unravelling the possible causes of idiopathic thrombocytopenia purpura (ITP). Pairs of stereochemically complementary antigens induce complementary immune responses (antibody or T-cell) that create loss of regulation and civil war within the immune system itself. Antibodies attack antibodies creating circulating immune complexes; T-cells attack T-cells creating perivascular cuffing. This immunological civil war abrogates the self-nonself distinction. If at least one of the complementary antigens mimics a self antigen, then this unregulated immune response will target host tissues as well. Data demonstrating that complementary antigens are found in some animal models of autoimmunity and may be present in various human diseases, especially ITP, are reviewed. Specific mechanisms for preventing autoimmunity or suppressing existing autoimmunity are derived from the theory, and critical tests proposed. Finally, we argue that Koch's postulates are inadequate for establishing disease causation for multiple-antigen diseases and discuss the possibility that current research has failed to elucidate the causes of human autoimmune diseases because we are using the wrong criteria.

Antigenic complementarity among AIDS-associated infectious agents and molecular mimicry of lymphocyte proteins as inducers of lymphocytotoxic antibodies and circulating immune complexes

BACKGROUND

People at risk for acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) have high rates of cofactor infections in addition to HIV, including cytomegalovirus, hepatitis viruses, Mycobacteria, Mycoplasmas, and Staphylococcus aureus. Most people with AIDS also develop lymphocytotoxic antibodies (LCTA) and circulating immune complexes (CIC). While HIV proteins mimic HLA antigens, many cofactor agents mimic CD4 antigens. It has therefore been proposed that cofactor infections may interact with HIV by producing complementary antigens that induce LCTA and CIC, and that the resulting immunological dysfunction is part of AIDS pathogenesis.

OBJECTIVES

To test (1) whether HIV and its cofactor infections elicit complementary (idiotype-anti-idiotype) antibodies, and (2) if any of these antibodies mimic anti-lymphocyte antibodies.

STUDY DESIGN

Two immunological methods are employed to test for antibody complementarity: (1) double antibody diffusion, a modification of Ouchterlony immunodiffusion, in which antibodies are tested for their ability to precipitate each other; (2) double-antibody ELISA, in which an antibody against one infectious agent is adsorbed to an ELISA plate and an antibody against a second agent is used to detect the first.

RESULTS

Data on over a thousand double antibody diffusion (DAD) and about 70 DA-ELISA experiments are reported. These show that only specific pairs of antibodies are complementary: HIV-CMV; HIV-HBV; HIV-tuberculosis; HIV-mycoplasmas; HIV-S. aureus; and CMV-mycoplasmas. In addition, HIV antibodies precipitate CD4 antibodies; CMV antibodies precipitate HLA-DR antibodies; while mycobacteria and mycoplasma antibodies precipitate macrophage antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

Antibodies elicited by HIV infection can interact with antibodies elicited by cofactor infections to form CIC, and some of these antibodies mimic lymphocyte antibodies so that they may function as LCTA. Since LCTA and CIC are associated with increased lymphocyte death in AIDS, the immune response against cofactors in HIV may play a significant role in AIDS pathogenesis. The fact that both HIV and cofactors elicit antibodies with LCTA characteristics may pose problems for vaccine development.

Anti-HLA alloantibody is found in children but does not correlate with a lack of HIV type 1 transmission from infected mothers

Searching for mechanisms of natural resistance to HIV infection with which to guide HIV vaccine design, we have examined antibody responses to HLA class I antigens in children of HIV-1-infected mothers. Anti-HLA antibodies are known to block HIV infectivity in vitro and can be protective against SIV challenge in macaques immunized with purified class I HLA. It was hypothesized that alloantibody to maternal HLA in children might contribute to the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV-1. In fact, a surprisingly high proportion of the children examined, 22%, were found to have antibody against class I alloantigens. This alloantibody, however, did not correlate with the HIV status of the children and was found in a similar proportion of children of HIV-negative mothers. The HLA specificity of the antibody was not correlated with noninherited maternal HLA alleles and occurred with a higher frequency in older children. This result suggests environmental factors, rather than exposure to maternal cells, are involved in the formation of the alloantibody. The finding that anti-allo-class I HLA antibodies are not associated with a decreased risk of mother-to-child transmission indicates that this humoral immune response is unlikely to be the natural mechanism that accounts for the lack of transmission observed in many births. This result, however, does not preclude the further investigation of cellular alloimmune responses, or the use of alloimmunization as an artificial HIV immunization strategy.

Using transgenic mouse models to dissect the pathogenesis of virus-induced autoimmune disorders of the islets of Langerhans and the central nervous system

Viruses have often been associated with autoimmune diseases. One mechanism by which self-destruction can be triggered is molecular mimicry. Many examples of cross-reactive immune responses between pathogens and self-antigens have been described. This review presents two transgenic models of autoimmune disease induced by a virus through activation of anti-self lymphocytes. Viral antigens are expressed as transgenes either in beta-cells of the pancreas or in the oligodendrocytes of the CNS. Infection by a virus encoding the same gene activated autoreactive T cells that cleared the viral infection, and as a consequence of transgene expression resulted in organ-specific autoimmune disease. In both transgenic mouse models, autoreactive lymphocytes that escaped thymic negative selection were present in the periphery. Several factors are described that play a role in the regulation of the self-reactive process precipitated by a viral infection. These include the quantity of activated autoreactive T cells, the affinity of these T cells, the number of memory T cells generated following primary infection, costimulation by accessory molecules, and the types and locations of cytokines produced. In addition, unique barriers exist in target tissues that prevent or suppress autoreactive responses and define to a large extent the outcome of disease. Restimulation of autoreactive memory lymphocytes may be required to bypass these barriers and enhance autoimmune disease. Therapy directed at modifying these factors can reduce and even prevent autoimmune disease after it has been initiated.

Semen alloantigens and lymphocytotoxic antibodies in AIDS and ICL

More than 90% of people with AIDS develop circulating immune complexes (CICs) and lymphocytotoxic antibodies (LCTAs). Animals infected with HIV, however, never display CICs or LCTAs, and remain healthy. Similarly, HIV-infected people who do not develop CICs or LCTAs also do not progress to AIDS. The appearance of CICs and LCTAs is, however, highly prognostic for AIDS and death. Since HIV infection does not, per se, lead to the development of CICs and LCTAs, other causes are likely. One such cause, for which both epidemiologic and experimental evidence exists, is semen. Semen components include sperm, seminal fluid, lymphocytes, and sometimes infectious agents, including HIV, mycoplasmas, and herpes and hepatitis viruses, all of which independently cause immune suppression. Extensive evidence demonstrates sperm (and various viruses) contains many proteins mimicking the CD4 protein of T-helper cells, while HIV, mycoplasmas, and seminal fluid mimic class II MHC proteins of other lymphocytes. We identify a large number of protein sequences that display such mimicry using computer homology searching, and demonstrate experimentally that sperm antibodies specifically precipitate antibodies against class II MHC mimics such as mycoplasmas, which in turn precipitate antibodies to lymphocyte antigens. These data prove that immunologic exposure to sperm and lymphocytes (as may occur in receptive anal intercourse, needle sharing, or blood transfusions) is theoretically capable of initiating lymphocytotoxic autoimmunity. Such autoimmunity may play a significant role in the pathogenesis of AIDS, and will need to be addressed clinically in high risk individuals regardless of HIV status and regardless of the success of anti-HIV prophylaxis and treatment.

Five myths about AIDS that have misdirected research and treatment

A number of widely repeated and factually incorrect myths have pervaded the AIDS research literature, misdirecting research and treatment. Five of the most outstanding are: 1) that all risk groups develop AIDS at the same rate following HIV infection; 2) that there are no true seroreversions following HIV infection; 3) that antibody is protective against HIV infection; 4) that the only way to treat AIDS effectively is through retroviral therapies; and 5) that since HIV is so highly correlated with AIDS incidence, it must be the sole necessary and sufficient cause of AIDS. A huge body of research, reviewed in this paper, demonstrates the falsity of these myths. 1) The average number of years between HIV infection and AIDS is greater than 20 years for mild hemophiliacs, 14 years for young severe hemophiliacs, 10 years for old severe hemophiliacs, 10 years for homosexual men, 6 years for transfusion patients of all ages, 2 years for transplant patients, and 6 months for perinatally infected infants. These differences can only be explained in terms of risk-group associated cofactors. 2) Seroreversions are common. Between 10 and 20 percent of HIV-seronegative people in high risk groups have T-cell immunity to HIV, and may have had one or more verified positive HIV antibody tests in the past. 3) Antibody, far from being protective against HIV, appears to be highly diagnostic of loss of immune regulation of HIV, and some evidence of antibody-enhancement of infection exists. 4) Non-retroviral treatments of HIV infection, including safer sex practices, elimination of drug use, high nutrient diets, and limited reexposure to HIV and its cofactors have proven to be effective means of preventing or delaying onset of AIDS. 5) Many immunosuppressive factors, including drug use, multiple concurrent infections, and exposure to alloantigens, are as highly correlated with AIDS risk groups as HIV. These data are more consistent with AIDS being a multifactorial or synergistic disease than a monofactorial one.