Effect of normobaric oxygen on tumor radiosensitivity: fractionated studies

The Role of Imaging Biomarkers to Guide Pharmacological Interventions Targeting Tumor Hypoxia

Hypoxia is a common feature of solid tumors that contributes to angiogenesis, invasiveness, metastasis, altered metabolism and genomic instability. As hypoxia is a major actor in tumor progression and resistance to radiotherapy, chemotherapy and immunotherapy, multiple approaches have emerged to target tumor hypoxia. It includes among others pharmacological interventions designed to alleviate tumor hypoxia at the time of radiation therapy, prodrugs that are selectively activated in hypoxic cells or inhibitors of molecular targets involved in hypoxic cell survival (i.e., hypoxia inducible factors HIFs, PI3K/AKT/mTOR pathway, unfolded protein response). While numerous strategies were successful in pre-clinical models, their translation in the clinical practice has been disappointing so far. This therapeutic failure often results from the absence of appropriate stratification of patients that could benefit from targeted interventions. Companion diagnostics may help at different levels of the research and development, and in matching a patient to a specific intervention targeting hypoxia. In this review, we discuss the relative merits of the existing hypoxia biomarkers, their current status and the challenges for their future validation as companion diagnostics adapted to the nature of the intervention.

Implications of Hyperoxia over the Tumor Microenvironment: An Overview Highlighting the Importance of the Immune System

Hyperoxia is used in order to counteract hypoxia effects in the TME (tumor microenvironment), which are described to boost the malignant tumor phenotype and poor prognosis. The reduction of tumor hypoxic state through the formation of a non-aberrant vasculature or an increase in the toxicity of the therapeutic agent improves the efficacy of therapies such as chemotherapy. Radiotherapy efficacy has also improved, where apoptotic mechanisms seem to be implicated. Moreover, hyperoxia increases the antitumor immunity through diverse pathways, leading to an immunopermissive TME. Although hyperoxia is an approved treatment for preventing and treating hypoxemia, it has harmful side-effects. Prolonged exposure to high oxygen levels may cause acute lung injury, characterized by an exacerbated immune response, and the destruction of the alveolar-capillary barrier. Furthermore, under this situation, the high concentration of ROS may cause toxicity that will lead not only to cell death but also to an increase in chemoattractant and proinflammatory cytokine secretion. This would end in a lung leukocyte recruitment and, therefore, lung damage. Moreover, unregulated inflammation causes different consequences promoting tumor development and metastasis. This process is known as protumor inflammation, where different cell types and molecules are implicated; for instance, IL-1β has been described as a key cytokine. Although current results show benefits over cancer therapies using hyperoxia, further studies need to be conducted, not only to improve tumor regression, but also to prevent its collateral damage.

Role of hyperoxic treatment in cancer

IMPACT STATEMENT

Tumor hypoxia promotes cancer cell aggressiveness, and is strongly associated with poor prognosis across multiple tumor types. The hypoxic microenvironments inside tumors also limit the effectiveness of radiotherapy, chemotherapy, and immunotherapy. Several approaches to eliminate hypoxic state in tumors have been proposed to delay cancer progression and improve therapeutic efficacies. This review will summarize current knowledge on hyperoxia, used alone or in combination with other therapeutic modalities, in cancer treatment. Molecular mechanisms and undesired side effects of hyperoxia will also be discussed.

Operable non-small cell lung cancer: correlation of volumetric helical dynamic contrast-enhanced CT parameters with immunohistochemical markers of tumor hypoxia

PURPOSE

To assess the relationship between helical dynamic contrast material-enhanced (DCE) computed tomographic (CT) parameters and immunohistochemical markers of hypoxia in patients with operable non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

After institutional review board approval was obtained, 20 prospective patients who were suspected of having NSCLC underwent whole-tumor DCE CT with kinetic modeling (Patlak analysis) 24 hours before scheduled surgery. Flow-extraction product (in milliliters per 100 milliliters per minute) and blood volume (in milliliters per 100 milliliters) were derived. After surgery, matched whole-tumor sections were stained for exogenous and endogenous markers of hypoxia (pimonidazole infused intravenously 24 hours before surgery, immediately after DCE CT; glucose transporter protein). Correlation between DCE CT parameters and immunohistochemical markers was assessed by using the Spearman rank correlation. DCE CT parameters and immunohistochemical markers were also compared according to pathologic subtype, grade, stage, and nodal status by using the Mann-Whitney test. P values less than .05 indicated a statistically significant difference.

RESULT

Fourteen patients with confirmed primary NSCLC underwent resection. There were negative correlations between blood volume and pimonidazole staining (r = -0.48, P = .004), and between flow-extraction product and glucose transporter protein expression (r = -0.50, P = .002). Flow-extraction product was significantly higher in adenocarcinomas than in squamous cell tumors (17.73 vs 11.46; P = .043). Glucose transporter protein expression was significantly lower for adenocarcinomas than for squamous tumors (14.07 vs 33.03; P < .001) and in node negative than in node positive tumors (15.63 vs 23.85; P = .005).

CONCLUSION

Blood volume and flow-extraction product derived at DCE CT correlated negatively with pimonidazole and glucose transporter protein expression, indicating the potential of these CT parameters as imaging biomarkers of hypoxia.

Preclinical studies on how to deal with patient intolerance to nicotinamide and carbogen

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Accelerated radiation carbogen nicotinamide (ARCON) therapy is generally well tolerated, but some patients experience intolerance to nicotinamide and carbogen (95% O(2)+5% CO(2)). This study investigated the effect of reducing both the nicotinamide dose and carbogen CO(2) content on radiation response.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A C3H mouse mammary carcinoma grown in the right rear foot of female CDF1 was used and treated when at 200 mm(3). Nicotinamide was intraperitoneally injected 20 min prior to irradiation. Carbogen (CO(2) content of either 2 or 5%, balance O(2)) breathing was started 5 min before, and continued during, additional treatments. Radiation was given locally to tissues of restrained non-anaesthetised mice either as a single or fractionated (10 fractions in 12 days) schedule. The endpoints were local tumour control at 90 days, development of moist desquamation 11-23 days after treatment of normal foot skin, or tumour oxygenation measured with the Eppendorf electrode.

RESULTS

The TCD50 values in this tumour following single or fractionated radiation treatment were 52 and 71Gy, respectively. Carbogen (5% CO(2) content) breathing with every radiation treatment in the fractionated schedule significantly (Chi-squared test; P<0.05) enhanced radiation response (ER 1.25). Significant enhancements were also seen with nicotinamide given either as 10x120 mg/kg (ER 1.25), 6x120 mg/kg (ER 1.11) or 10x90 mg/kg (ER 1.18), although the 6x120 schedule was significantly less effective than 10x120. Combining nicotinamide with carbogen resulted in ERs of 1.39-1.44, and these were independent of the nicotinamide treatments. There was also no significant difference in the enhancement of tumour radiation response or improved tumour oxygenation status if the CO(2) content of the gas breathing was varied from 0% (i.e. 100% O(2)) to 2 or 5% (balance O(2)), although a CO(2) content of 2% did give a smaller enhancement of radiation-induced normal skin damage than 5%.

CONCLUSIONS

Both the nicotinamide dose, but not the frequency, and carbogen CO(2) content may be reduced in patients experience intolerance without any significant loss of sensitisation.

Effects of hyperbaric oxygen and normobaric carbogen on the radiation response of the rat rhabdomyosarcoma R1H

PURPOSE

Hypoxic tumor cells are an important factor of radioresistance. Hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) and normobaric carbogen (95% oxygen, 5% carbon dioxide) increase the oxygen delivery to tumors. This study was performed to explore changes of tumor oxygenation during a course of fractionated irradiation and to determine the effectiveness of normobaric carbogen and HBO during the final phase of the radiation treatment.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Experiments were performed on the rhabdomyosarcoma R1H growing on WAG/Rij rats. After 20 X-ray fractions of 2 Gy within 4 weeks, oxygen partial pressure (pO2) was measured using the Eppendorf oxygen electrode under ambient conditions, with normobaric carbogen or HBO at a pressure of 240 kPa. Following the 4-week radiation course, a top-up dose of 10-50 Gy was applied in 2-10 fractions of 5 Gy with or without hyperoxygenation.

RESULTS

HBO but not carbogen significantly increased the median pO2 in irradiated tumors. The radiation doses to control 50% of tumors were 38.0 Gy, 29.5 Gy, and 25.0 Gy for air, carbogen, and HBO, respectively. Both high oxygen content gas inspirations led to significantly improved tumor responses with oxygen enhancement ratios (OERs) of 1.3 for normobaric carbogen and 1.5 for HBO (air vs. carbogen: p = 0.044; air vs. HBO: p = 0.02; carbogen vs. HBO: p = 0.048).

CONCLUSION

Both normobaric carbogen and HBO significantly improved the radiation response of R1H tumors. HBO appeared to be more effective than normobaric carbogen, both with regard to tumor oxygenation and response to irradiation.

Inspired and expired gas concentrations in man during carbogen breathing

Capnometer measurements during 46 evaluable treatments in which patients were administered carbogen (95% O2, 5% CO2) have demonstrated that the mean inspired carbon dioxide level was 3.1% (range 0-4.7) and the mean inspired oxygen concentration was 70.6% (range 26.4-94). The explanation for this observation is leakage of air into the breathing system during radiotherapy.

Tumour response to hypercapnia and hyperoxia monitored by FLOOD magnetic resonance imaging

Flow and oxygenation dependent (FLOOD) MR images of GH3 prolactinomas display large intensity increases in response to carbogen (5% CO2/95% O2) breathing. To assess the relative contributions of carbon dioxide and oxygen to this response and the tumour oxygenation state, the response of GH3 prolactinomas to 5% CO2/95% air, carbogen and 100% O2 was monitored by FLOOD MRI and PO2 histography. A 10-30% image intensity increase was observed during 5% CO2/95% air breathing, consistent with an increase in tumour blood flow, as a result of CO2-induced vasodilation, reducing the concentration of deoxyhaemoglobin in the blood. Carbogen caused a further 40-50% signal enhancement, suggesting an additional improvement due to increase blood oxygenation. A small 5-10% increase was observed in response to 100% O2, highlighting the dominance of CO2-induced vasodilation in the carbogen response. Despite the large FLOOD response, non-significant increases in tumour pO2 were observed in response to the three gases. Tissue pO2 is determined by the balance of oxygen supply and demand, hence increased blood flow/oxygenation may not necessarily produce a large increase in tissue PO2. The FLOOD response is determined by the level of deoxygenation of blood, the size of this response relating to vascular density and the potential of high-oxygen content gases to improve the oxygen supply to tumour tissue.

Magnetic resonance imaging techniques for monitoring changes in tumor oxygenation and blood flow

The application of functional magnetic resonance (MR) imaging techniques to the measurement of oxygenation and blood flow in tumors is described. Gradient recalled echo MR imaging (GRE-MRI) offers a real-time noninvasive method for monitoring tumor response to vasomodulators such as carbogen (95% O2/5% CO2) breathing in attempts to overcome tumor hypoxia and improve treatment efficacy. Although the response is tumor-type dependent, increases in signal intensity of up to 100% have been observed in several animal tumor types. Responses are also seen in human tumors. The observed increases in GRE-MRI signal intensity are due to a combination of a reduction of deoxyhemoglobin in the blood causing changes in the MR imaging relaxation time T2* and changes in blood flow and may also reflect the capillary density. Thus, the magnitude of the GRE image intensity change gives an indication of the potential response of an individual tumor to treatments that aim to improve tissue oxygenation and therefore how the tumor may respond to therapy. In addition, carbogen breathing by the host has been shown to increase the uptake and efficacy of chemotherapeutic agents in animal tumors.

Enhancement of radiosensitivity of rat rhabdomyosarcoma R1H with normobaric carbogen and hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) using conventionally fractionated irradiation

Hypoxic clonogenic cells are an important contributory factor in tumour radioresistance. The objective of the present study was to evaluate whether hyperbaric oxygen enhances tumour radiosensitivity, using a conventionally fractionated irradiation schedule, and whether the radiosensitizing potential is different from carbogen. Experiments were performed using the rhabdomyosarcoma R1H model transplanted subcutaneously in the flank of WAG/Rij rats. A total of 30 X-ray fractions of 2 Gy were given either in air, normobaric carbogen or high pressure oxygen (HPO) (240 kPa, 2.37 atm) without anaesthesia. The time taken to achieve complete remission was 38.7 +/- 3.6 days, 36.7 +/- 2.7 days and 32.4 +/- 4.1 days for air, normobaric carbogen and HBO, respectively. The differences between air and HBO (p = 0.002) and carbogen and HBO (p = 0.015) were significant. Use of carbogen and HBO produced the same local control probability at 150 days and this was significantly higher than local control under ambient conditions (p < 0.0001). It was concluded that the time to achieve complete remission of the rat rhabdomyosarcoma R1H can be shortened by HBO. Furthermore, both HBO and carbogen give higher local control probabilities than treatment under ambient conditions when used with a conventionally fractionated radiation schedule.

Hyperfractionation: where do we stand?

Hyperfractionation is generally expected to allow an escalation of total dose, thereby increasing tumour control rate, without increasing the risk of late complications. The purpose of this review is to assess the empirical evidence for this therapeutic gain from hyperfractionated radiotherapy. Although extensive clinical data have been accumulated until now, especially on treatment of head and neck cancer, the line of evidence is not consistent. The present analysis indicates that the dose per fraction generally used in standard radiotherapy is already a good choice.

Short communication: a technique for delivering carbogen with high dose rate intraluminal brachytherapy in carcinoma of the oesophagus; early results and toxicity

A technique to deliver carbogen with high dose rate afterloading therapy to the oesophagus is described. Treatment is given using a standard high dose rate (HDR) afterloading catheter which is passed through the tumour-bearing area of the oesophagus within a nasogastric tube. In order to achieve a gas-tight seal, a standard "oxygen" mask used for delivery of carbogen is modified to incorporate the nasogastric tube allowing the treatment catheter to pass through the mask and be connected to the afterloading machine. The technique has proven to be feasible and well tolerated during treatment in four patients treated in this way. Severe acute radiation toxicity, possibly attributable to the carbogen, has been encountered in these patients receiving 1500 cGy at 1 cm via the HDR catheter after 4050 cGy in 27 fractions in 9 days using CHART external beam. Modifications to the radiation scheduling is recommended to enable carbogen to be incorporated in this way.

Radiosensitisation in normal tissues with oxygen, carbogen or nicotinamide: therapeutic gain comparisons for fractionated x-ray schedules

METHODS

Radiosensitisation with oxygen, carbogen or nicotinamide alone and oxygen or carbogen combined with nicotinamide was compared in early and late responding normal tissues in rodents. X-ray treatments were delivered as single doses or fractionated schedules of 2 fractions in 1 day, 2, 12 and 36 fractions in an overall time of 12 days and 10 fractions in 5 or 12 days. Acute skin reactions, survival of intestinal crypts, breathing rate, reduction in the packed red-cell volume and clearance of 51Cr-EDTA were used as assays of epidermal, gut, lung and renal damage.

RESULTS

Relative to air-breathing mice, carbogen or oxygen produced a small, and not always significant, increase in sensitivity (enhancement ratios < or = 1.15) in gut, lung and kidneys; however, in skin a dose enhancement of 1.2-1.3 was observed. The effect of nicotinamide in air, carbogen or oxygen was studied only in lung and gut. The drug produced variable but generally significant increases in radiosensitisation ( < or = 1.26) in all three gases. Relative to treatments in air, enhancement ratios for nicotinamide alone were usually slightly higher than those observed when either carbogen or oxygen were administered without the drug. With all three modifiers (i.e. oxygen, carbogen, nicotinamide alone or for the drug-gas combinations) there was no significant change in the enhancement ratios observed as the number of radiation dose fractions was varied.

CONCLUSIONS

Comparisons with fractionated X-ray studies done previously in rodent tumours indicate that a therapeutic benefit, relative to lung, gut and renal damage, would be observed with oxygen or carbogen alone but not with nicotinamide alone. The greatest gain would be achieved with the combination of carbogen and nicotinamide, with which a benefit was observed even relative to epidermal damage. These results indicate that some decrease in normal tissue tolerance could be observed when using these modifiers in clinical radiotherapy and, although small, the appropriate dose reductions should be considered; caution should be exercised especially when carbogen and nicotinamide are used in conjunction with the more radical accelerated schedules.

Carbogen and nicotinamide as radiosensitizers in a murine mammary carcinoma using conventional and accelerated radiotherapy

PURPOSE

To compare the radiosensitivity of mouse tumors treated in air with conventional and accelerated radiotherapy with that of tumors treated in carbogen alone or carbogen combined with nicotinamide.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

CaNT mammary tumors were irradiated with either 30 x-ray fractions in 6 weeks or 40 fractions in 26 days in air, carbogen alone, or carbogen combined with 120 mg/kg of nicotinamide (NAM), the latter given intraperitonealy 30 min before each fraction. The response to treatment was assessed using local control, weight loss, and metastasis-free survival.

RESULTS

Both carbogen and carbogen plus nicotinamide significantly increased tumor radiosensitivity; enhancement ratios (ERs) in the 6-week regimen were similar to those seen in the accelerated schedule. The majority of the effect was achieved by carbogen alone but the addition of NAM further enhanced tumor radiosensitization (ERs of 1.5 and 1.4 for carbogen in the conventional and accelerated schedule, respectively, were significantly lower than ERs of 1.7 and 1.6 obtained with carbogen plus nicotinamide; p < or = 0.005). Treatment protraction significantly increased radioresistance, especially when tumors were treated under air. An extra 1.5 Gy per day was required in air to counterbalance proliferation; in carbogen alone and carbogen plus nicotinamide a dose loss of 0.9 and 0.6 Gy per day was observed, respectively. Compared with treatments in air alone delivered in 6 weeks, acceleration of treatment combined with carbogen and nicotinamide gave the greatest increase in tumor radiosensitization (ER = 1.9). No toxic side effects and no detrimental changes in body weight were encountered when the sensitizers were administered 30 times (one fraction per day) or 40 times (two fractions per day). In both regimens, the incidence of metastases in mice treated with carbogen or carbogen plus nicotinamide was similar to that seen in animals treated in air. There was, however, a nonsignificant trend of a higher proportion of mice with metastasis in the accelerated schedule compared with the 6-week schedule.

CONCLUSIONS

In both conventional and accelerated experimental radiotherapy, carbogen alone or combined with a small clinically relevant dose of NAM were well tolerated, achieved large and significant increases in radiosensitization, and did not affect the incidence of metastases. The sparing of damage, resulting from extending the overall treatment time, was less when the sensitizers were administered than when irradiations were performed in air. The study suggests that clinical radiotherapy regimens, which aim to reduce hypoxic and/or tumor clonogen proliferation, would benefit from the use of carbogen, especially if the gas is combined with nicotinamide and treatment acceleration.

PO2 in irradiated versus nonirradiated tumors of mice breathing oxygen at normal and elevated pressure

PURPOSE

To determine if prior tumor irradiation influences tumor pO2 changes in mice breathing oxygen (100%) at normal and elevated pressure.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Single-point pO2 measurements were performed in nonirradiated and previously irradiated (72 h) isotransplanted MCaIV tumors in C3H/Sed mice. Continuous recordings were performed at the same tumor locus under air breathing, followed by 100% oxygen and oxygen at three atmospheres pressure. Following decompression and induction of pentobarbital anesthesia, the procedure was repeated at the same locus. Six nonirradiated and five irradiated tumors were evaluated under the three gas breathing conditions +/- anesthesia.

RESULTS

The mean, median, and range of pO2 values did not differ under air-breathing conditions in the nonirradiated vs. previously irradiated tumors. However, prior irradiation substantially enhanced the tumor pO2 increase when the inspired gas phase was switched from air to 100% oxygen at 1 or 3 atmospheres pressure. In four of six nonirradiated tumors, 100% oxygen breathing resulted in a pO2 increase of < 4 mmHg; in the irradiated tumors, the minimum increase was 16 mmHg. Pentobarbital anesthesia did not significantly influence the results obtained.

CONCLUSION

These data indicate that the efficacy of oxygen breathing increases during tumor treatment, and suggests that oxygen breathing is a simple nontoxic method for reducing or eliminating radiobiologic hypoxia during therapy.

Histological necrosis in soft tissue sarcoma following preoperative irradiation

Forty-eight patients with soft tissue sarcomas that presented adverse features for treatment by limb salvage surgery and postoperative irradiation were treated by preoperative irradiation and surgery using a consistent protocol. Following resection, the extent of histological necrosis in the specimen was scored according to the criteria of Willet et al. Of the 48 cases, 16 (34%) demonstrated Grade 1 response (< 50% necrosis), 15 (31%) Grade 2 (50-80% necrosis), and 17 (35%) Grade 3 (> 80% necrosis). There was a trend toward more extensive necrosis in liposarcoma tumors (53% showing Grade 3 response compared to 26% of other sarcomas). Logistic regression analysis demonstrated a significant relationship between necrosis and tumor size (P < 0.001) with larger tumors having higher grades of necrosis. Tumor grade did not seem to affect the extent of necrosis. In comparison to the previous report of necrosis in soft tissue sarcoma following irradiation, the current analysis revealed a smaller proportion of tumors with Grade 3 necrosis.

Middle dose rate irradiation in combination with carbogen inhalation selectively and more markedly increases the responses of SCCVII tumors

PURPOSE

Carbogen increases the radiation response of tumors and reduced dose rate irradiation spares the damage of normal tissues. The purpose in this paper is to investigate the possibility of selective radiosensitization of tumors by reduced dose rate irradiation in combination with carbogen inhalation.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

SCCVII tumors in C3H/He mice were irradiated at middle dose rate (0.1 Gy/min) or high dose rate irradiation (3.0 Gy/min) in combination with carbogen inhalation. The mice were enclosed in a box with carbogen flushing at 1.01/min. The tumor response was measured by a cytokinesis block micronucleus assay. The effects on intestinal crypt cells and bone marrow cells were investigated by microcolony assay or Hendry's method, respectively.

RESULTS

The anti-tumor effect of middle dose rate irradiation was equal to that of a high dose rate irradiation. Carbogen inhalation, more efficiently, increased the antitumor effect when combined with middle and high dose rate irradiation, and yielded enhancement ratios of 1.6 at around 2 Gy. Middle dose rate irradiation produced less damage on intestinal crypt cells and bone marrow cells in comparison with high dose rate irradiation, and carbogen inhalation never enhanced the responses of these normal tissues in combination with middle dose rate irradiation. Dose modifying factors were 1.3-2.0.

CONCLUSION

Since middle dose rate irradiation in combination with carbogen inhalation gave the therapeutic gain factors of 2.0-3.2, which were much larger than those obtained with any other radiosensitizers, this combination has a potential as a new modality for improving the results of cancer radiotherapy.

Pharmacokinetics of varying doses of nicotinamide and tumour radiosensitisation with carbogen and nicotinamide: clinical considerations

Plasma concentrations, after administration of varying doses of nicotinamide, were measured in CBA male mice using a newly-developed high performance liquid chromatography assay. In all dose groups, peak levels were observed within the first 15 min after an i.p. administration of 0.1, 0.2, 0.3 or 0.5 mg g-1 of nicotinamide. There was a clear dose-dependent increase in plasma concentration with increasing dose, with almost a five-fold lower concentration (1.0 vs 4.9 mumol ml-1) achieved with a dose of 0.1 mg g-1 compared with 0.5 mg g-1, respectively. The half-life of nicotinamide increased from 1.4 h to 2.2 h over the dose range (P < 0.01). Comparisons with previous pharmacokinetic data in humans show that clinically-relevant oral doses of 6 and 9 g in humans give plasma levels slightly higher than those achieved at 1 h with doses of 0.1 to 0.2 mg g-1 in mice. Tumour radiosensitisation with carbogen alone, and with carbogen combined with varying doses of nicotinamide (0.05 to 0.5 mg g-1), was investigated using a 10-fraction in 5 days X-ray schedule. Relative to air-breathing mice, a statistically significant increase in sensitisation was observed with both a local tumour control and with an in vivo/in vitro excision assay (P < or = 0.007). With the local control assay, a trend was observed towards lower enhancement ratios (ERs) with decreasing nicotinamide dose (from 1.85 to 1.55); carbogen alone was almost as effective as when combined with 0.1 mg g-1 of nicotinamide. With the excision assay, ERs for carbogen combined with nicotinamide increased with decreased levels of cell survival. At a surviving fraction of 0.02, enhancement ratios of 1.39-1.48 were obtained for carbogen plus 0.1 to 0.3 mg g-1 of nicotinamide. These were lower than those seen with the two higher doses of 0.4 to 0.5 mg g-1 (ERs = 1.63-1.69).

Precision in reporting the dose given in a course of radiotherapy

A knowledge of the precise dose given in a course of radiotherapy is vital to the interpretation of the result. Despite this, an acceptable level of reporting was found in only 72 (36%) of 200 papers published in the two leading journals of radiation oncology. Analysis of the treatment data of the cases with head and neck tumours in the pilot study of CHART showed that the mean of the minimum tumour doses given was 5.1% lower than the mean of those at the intersection points. Had the same total dose been prescribed to the intersection point instead of the minimum there would have been a similar lowering of dose. There is evidence from published clinical data and a suggestion from an analysis of the CHART pilot study data that a dose difference as small as 5% may lead to real impairment or enhancement of tumour response, as well as altering the risk of morbidity. Inadequate reporting may lead to a false interpretation of a study and to its wrongful application. It is strongly recommended that it should be editorial policy to publish only those papers where the radiation dose is fully described.

Should carbogen and nicotinamide be given throughout the full course of fractionated radiotherapy regimens?

PURPOSE

Tumor radiosensitization with carbogen and nicotinamide (CON) was compared when both agents were given throughout fractionated radiotherapy with the sensitization observed when administered with only half of the fractions. The effect of overall treatment time on the local control of tumors irradiated in air or with CON was also investigated.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Local tumor control of a rodent adenocarcinoma, CaNT, was studied using eight different 20-fraction x-ray regimens. An overall time of either 10 or 20 days was used and CON was given with all, the first half or last half of the treatment.

RESULTS

Relative to air, all six sensitizer combinations gave a large and significant increase in sensitization (p << 0.00001). Enhancement ratios were 1.9 and 2.1 when CON was given with all 20 fractions in either 10 or 20 days, respectively. For both overall times, enhancement ratios were reduced by 15-25% when CON was given with only half of the fractions. In air, reducing the treatment time from 20 to 10 days gave a small but significant decrease in the isoeffective doses. When CON was administered with either all or part of a schedule, varying the treatment time had little or no effect on local tumor control. No toxic side-effects were encountered when the sensitizers were administered 10 or 20 times, either once or twice per day.

CONCLUSION

CON is an effective and non-toxic tumor radiosensitizer. In CaNT tumors, a significantly greater effect is seen when CON is given with every fraction of the schedule. The sensitizers reduced or abolished the sparing effect of overall time.

Radiosensitization of SCCVII tumours and normal tissues by nicotinamide and carbogen: analysis by micronucleus assay

The radiosensitizing effect on SCCVII tumours of carbogen (95% O2 + 5% CO2) combined with nicotinamide was investigated using the micronucleus assay and an in vivo/in vitro colony formation assay following single irradiation. The effects on intestinal crypt cells and bone marrow cells were also examined in mice. The frequency of micronuclei in tumours increased with an increase in the nicotinamide dose (administered 1 h before the irradiation of 5 Gy) from 0.1 to 1.0 mg/g, and showed a 1.3-fold increase at 1.0 mg/g when compared with radiation alone. The micronucleus frequency showed a more marked increase following irradiation combined with nicotinamide and carbogen inhalation starting 15 min before irradiation. The radiosensitizing effect reached a plateau at a nicotinamide dose of 0.1 mg/g in combination with carbogen, giving an enhancement ratio (ER) of 1.8 relative to radiation alone at 2 Gy. In the radiation dose range of 5-20 Gy, ERs of 1.8-1.9 and 1.5 (at a 10% cell-survival level) were obtained for the combination of 0.1 or 1.0 mg/g nicotinamide and carbogen and for carbogen alone, respectively. A slight increase in the regeneration response of the jejunum and the bone marrow was observed following irradiation combined with 0.1 mg/g nicotinamide and carbogen, yielding ERs of 1.07 for the jejunum and 1.15 for the bone marrow. Thus, the nicotinamide/carbogen combination, with its large therapeutic gain factor at low doses and proven low toxicity in humans, seems to improve the response of cancer to radiotherapy.

Enhancement of tumor radiosensitivity and reduced hypoxia-dependent binding of a 2-nitroimidazole with normobaric oxygen and carbogen: a therapeutic comparison with skin and kidneys

To evaluate the therapeutic potential of normobaric oxygen and carbogen as hypoxic-cell sensitizers, both radiosensitization in a mouse mammary carcinoma, mouse skin and kidneys, and the reduction in the proportion of hypoxic tumor cells were quantified in mice breathing air, oxygen, or carbogen. Local tumor control, acute skin reactions, reduced renal clearance, and hematocrit were used as assays. X rays as 10 fractions in 5 days were given to skin and tumors and 10F/12 days to kidneys. In the tumor study, the pre-irradiation breathing time was varied from 2 to 20 min. Hypoxic cells, before and during a 10F/5 day schedule, were quantified using a 2-nitroimidazole with a theophylline side chain. Bioreductively reduced metabolites of this probe were localized in hypoxic cells that were then stained using an immunofluorescent technique and analyzed by flow cytometry. The fraction of cells with high fluorescence intensity was 19% in air, 9% in oxygen, and 3% in carbogen-breathing mice. For all three gases, hypoxia-dependent binding was similar in non-irradiated tumors and those treated with four or nine fractions. Both gases significantly enhanced tumor radiosensitivity (ER = 1.3 to 1.6) and carbogen was slightly more effective than oxygen. With carbogen, maximum sensitization was observed with a 5 min pre-irradiation breathing interval. With oxygen, pre-irradiation breathing times of 2-20 min gave similar sensitization. In skin an enhancement ratio of 1.2 was observed, whereas enhancement ratios for both renal endpoints were significantly lower (1.0 to 1.07). Relative to both tissues, there was therefore a substantial therapeutic gain by irradiating CaNT tumors under both gases, especially with carbogen.

Improving the radiation response in a C3H mouse mammary carcinoma by normobaric oxygen or carbogen breathing

The limited therapeutic benefit from nitroimidazoles has renewed the interest in normobaric oxygen as a hypoxic cell radiosensitizer. In this experimental study we have tried to modify the oxygenation of a C3H mammary carcinoma by flushing tumor-bearing mice with oxygen or carbogen for 5 min before and during treatment. The response to these treatments was evaluated by the changes in radiation-induced tumor control (TCD50) and by the changes in tumor hypoxic fraction (HF). Irradiation was given either as a large, single dose or as five equal, daily fractions. High levels of oxygen in the inspired air were found to decrease the TCD50 significantly. The enhancement ratios were in the range of 1.2-1.4 (p less than 0.05) for both single dose and fractionated irradiation, which suggests that hypoxic cells may be important even when reoxygenation is believed to be complete between fractions. The change in TCD50 corresponded to a decrease in the fraction of clonogenic hypoxic cells from 12% to 3-4% (p less than 0.05). Tumor blood flow was not significantly influenced by the gas treatment. This study thus shows that normobaric oxygen/carbogen inhalation may significantly improve the local tumor control by reducing the diffusion related hypoxia within tumors.

A therapeutic benefit from combining normobaric carbogen or oxygen with nicotinamide in fractionated X-ray treatments

The ability of normobaric oxygen and carbogen (95% O2 + 5% CO2) combined with nicotinamide to enhance the radiosensitivity of two rodent adenocarcinomas and of mouse skin and kidneys, using a 10 fraction radiation schedule, was compared with the effect of radiation in air with and without the drug. Tumour response was assayed using local control and regrowth delay, and compared with acute skin reactions, decreased renal 51Cr-EDTA clearance and reduction in haematocrit. Nicotinamide increased the radiation sensitivity of CaNT tumours under all three different oxygen concentrations tested (21, 95 and 100% oxygen). The effect was statistically significant for oxygen and carbogen but not for air; the combination of nicotinamide with carbogen gave the greatest increase in tumour radiosensitivity. Relative to treatments in air without the drug, the enhancement ratios (ER) at the TCD50 level were 1.17, 1.65 and 1.83 for CaNT tumours irradiated in air, oxygen or carbogen and injected with nicotinamide 1 h before each fraction. The ER in CaRH tumours irradiated in carbogen plus the drug was 1.83, which was greater, but statistically not significantly different, to that seen with carbogen alone (ER = 1.68). In skin, relative to air without the drug, the increase in radiosensitivity by nicotinamide was greater in oxygen and carbogen than in air (1.29, 1.36 and 1.08, respectively). The ERs for both assays of renal damage were similar and lower than those in skin: less than or equal to 1.07, less than or equal to 1.13 and less than or equal to 1.16 for irradiations done in air, oxygen and carbogen plus nicotinamide, relative to air alone. A comparison of these results in the tumours and normal tissues showed that a significant therapeutic benefit was obtained with normobaric oxygen and carbogen combined with nicotinamide. This benefit is greater than observed with other radiosensitizers tested so far. Toxic side effects of the treatment are unlikely in a clinical situation, since prolonged administration of nicotinamide is well tolerated in man. The combination of normobaric carbogen with nicotinamide could be an effective method of enhancing tumour radiosensitivity in clinical radiotherapy where hypoxia limits the outcome of treatment.

Tumor hypoxia, reoxygenation and oxygenation strategies: possible role in photodynamic therapy

The concept of hypoxia and its role in tumor therapy are currently under re-evaluation. Poor oxygenation is no longer visualized as an independent feature promoting necrosis and resistance to treatments, but rather as one of the several interdependent microenvironmental parameters associated with impaired blood perfusion. Tumor cells display several survival strategies and remain clonogenic for long periods in nutrient-deprived situations. Reoxygenation may cause lethal damage, improve the response to therapy, or else allow the cell variants adapted to hypoxia to resume proliferation with enhanced aggressiveness and resistance to treatment. The blood supply parameters, oxygenation status and metabolism of malignant cells are discussed here from the standpoint of tumor photodynamic therapy. The role of the tumor interstitial fluid as oxygen- and sensitizer-carrier is discussed. Techniques for assessing tumor oxygenation and for mapping hypoxic territories are described. Strategies for locally improving the oxygenation levels or for selectively destroying the hypoxic populations are outlined.

A simple method for fitting curves to dose-effect data for functional damage

Dose-effect curves are used extensively to assess how tissues respond to radiation. One method of obtaining these is to fit a curve to the values of some measured effect plotted against dose using non-linear least-squares regression. This paper reports the use of a generalized (four-parameter) sigmoid equation fitted to all the individual data points, rather than to the mean values for each dose group, which eliminates the need to incorporate weighting of the data. The equation allows an analytical solution for values of isoeffect doses, which can be used, for example, to determine dose enhancement ratios, or equivalent remembered doses in top-up experiments. The regression approach can also determine both standard errors and 95% confidence limits on the mean predicted effect values from the fit to the data at all doses, and these define a uniform envelope of errors about the best-fit line, from which an error in an isoeffect dose can be assessed. This approach has been used to fit dose-effect data from a variety of normal tissues and tumours with highly satisfactory results.