Treatment volume shaping with selective beam blocking using the Leksell gamma unit

Repeated in-field radiosurgery for locally recurrent brain metastases: Feasibility, results and survival in a heavily treated patient cohort

Purpose

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is an established primary treatment for newly diagnosed brain metastases with high local control rates. However, data about local re-irradiation in case of local failure after SRS (re-SRS) are rare. We evaluated the feasibility, efficacy and patient selection characteristics in treating locally recurrent metastases with a second course of SRS.

Methods

We retrospectively evaluated patients with brain metastases treated with re-SRS for local tumor progression between 2011 and 2017. Patient and treatment characteristics as well as rates of tumor control, survival and toxicity were analyzed.

Results

Overall, 32 locally recurrent brain metastases in 31 patients were irradiated with re-SRS. Median age at re-SRS was 64.9 years. The primary histology was breast cancer and non-small-cellular lung cancer (NSCLC) in respectively 10 cases (31.3%), in 5 cases malignant melanoma (15.6%). In the first SRS-course 19 metastases (59.4%) and in the re-SRS-course 29 metastases (90.6%) were treated with CyberKnife^® and the others with Gamma Knife. Median planning target volume (PTV) for re-SRS was 2.5 cm³ (range, 0.1–37.5 cm³) and median dose prescribed to the PTV was 19 Gy (range, 12–28 Gy) in 1–5 fractions to the median 69% isodose (range, 53–80%). The 1-year overall survival rate was 61.7% and the 1-year local control rate was 79.5%. The overall rate of radiological radio-necrosis was 16.1% and four patients (12.9%) experienced grade ≥ 3 toxicities.

Conclusions

A second course of SRS for locally recurrent brain metastases after prior local SRS appears to be feasible with acceptable toxicity and can be considered as salvage treatment option for selected patients with high performance status. Furthermore, this is the first study utilizing robotic radiosurgery for this indication, as an additional option for frameless fractionated treatment.

Photon Radiosurgery: A Clinical Review

The term radiosurgery has been used to describe a variety of radiotherapy techniques which deliver high doses of radiation to small, stereotactically defined intracranial targets in such a way that the dose fall-off outside the targeted volume is very sharp. Proton, charged particle, gamma unit, and linear accelerator-based techniques appear to be equivalent from the standpoint of accuracy, dose distributions, and clinical results. However, capital and operating costs associated with the use of linear accelerators in general clinical use are much lower. Radiosurgery has an established role in the treatment of arteriovenous malformations and acoustic neurinomas. Interest in these techniques is increasing in neurosurgical and radiation oncological communities, as radiosurgery is rapidly assuming a place in the management of several other conditions, including craniopharyngiomas, meningiomas, and selected malignant lesions.

Gamma Knife surgery for invasive pituitary macroadenoma

OBJECT

Pituitary adenomas have been treated using a variety of modalities including resection, medication, fractionated radiotherapy, and stereotactic radiosurgery. The policy has been that all adenomas should first be treated with resection to reduce the volume of the tumor. The authors' study was conducted to determine the efficacy of using Gamma Knife surgery (GKS) for pituitary adenomas invading the cavernous sinus.

METHODS

Of 397 patients with pituitary tumors who underwent GKS between October 1994 and October 2005, 68 patients had pituitary macroadenomas invading the cavernous sinus. Sixty-seven cases were available for follow up. The mean age of the patients in these cases was 42.8 years (range 14-73 years). The male/female ratio was 0.8:1. The mean adenoma volume was 9.3 cm3. A total of 24 patients had undergone craniotomies and resection, and 11 patients had undergone transsphenoidal surgery prior to GKS. The mean follow-up period was 32.8 months. Tumor control was defined as a decrease or no change in tumor volume after GKS. Endocrinological improvement was defined as a decline in hormone levels to below 50% of the pre-GKS level. Tumor control was achieved in 95.5% of the cases. Endocrinological improvement was achieved in 68% of 25 patients. One patient suffered hypopituitarism after GKS.

CONCLUSIONS

Gamma Knife surgery is a safe and effective treatment for invasive pituitary macroadenoma with few complications.

CHAINED LIGHTNING, PART II

THE FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE in the radiosurgical treatment of neurological conditions is the delivery of energy to a lesion with minimal injury to surrounding structures. The development of radiosurgical techniques from Leksell's original design has focused on the refinement of various methodologies to achieve energy containment within a target. This article is the second in a series reviewing the evolution of radiosurgical instruments with respect to issues of energy beam generation and delivery for improved conformal therapy.

Continuing with concepts introduced in an earlier article, this article examines specific aspects of beam delivery and the emergence of stereotactic radiosurgery as a measure for focusing energy beams within a target volume. The application of stereotactic principles and devices to gamma ray and linear accelerator-based energy sources provides the methodology by which energy beams are generated and targeted precisely in a focal lesion. Advanced technological systems are reviewed, including fixed beams, dynamic radiosurgery, multileaf collimation, beam shaping, and robotics as various approaches for manipulating beam delivery. Radiosurgical instruments are also compared with regard to mechanics, geometry, and dosimetry. Finally, new radiosurgical designs currently on the horizon are introduced. In exploring the complex history of radiosurgery, it is evident that the discovery and rediscovery of ideas invariably leads to the development of innovative technology for the next generation.

Effect of beam channel plugging on the outcome of gamma knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia

PURPOSE

We studied the influence of using plugs for brainstem protection during gamma knife radiosurgery (GKR) of trigeminal neuralgia (TN), with special emphasis on irradiation doses delivered to the trigeminal nerve, pain outcomes, and incidence of trigeminal dysfunction.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A GKR procedure for TN using an anterior cisternal target and a maximum dose of 90 Gy was performed in 109 patients. For 49 patients, customized beam channel blocking (plugs) were used to reduce the dose delivered to the brainstem. We measured the mean and integrated radiation doses delivered to the trigeminal nerve and the clinical course of patients treated with and without plugs.

RESULTS

We found that blocking increases the length of trigeminal nerve exposed to high-dose radiation, resulting in a significantly higher mean dose to the trigeminal nerve. Significantly more of the patients with blocking achieved excellent pain outcomes (84% vs. 62%), but with higher incidences of moderate and bothersome trigeminal nerve dysfunction (37% mild/10% bothersome with plugs vs. 30% mild/2% bothersome without).

CONCLUSIONS

The use of plugs to protect the brainstem during GKR treatment for TN increases the dose of irradiation delivered to the intracisternal trigeminal nerve root and is associated with an important increase in the incidence of trigeminal nerve dysfunction. Therefore, beam channel blocking should be avoided for 90 Gy-GKR of TN.

Single-Fraction Stereotactic Radiosurgery for Intracranial Targets

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is a technique for treating intracranial lesions with a high dose of ionizing radiation, usually in a single session, using a stereotactic apparatus for accurate localization and patient immobilization. This article describes several modalities of SRS and some of its applications, particularly for intracranial lesions.

A constrained tracking algorithm to optimize plug patterns in multiple isocenter gamma knife radiosurgery planning

We developed a source blocking optimization algorithm for Gamma Knife radiosurgery, which is based on tracking individual source contributions to arbitrarily shaped target and critical structure volumes. A scalar objective function and a direct search algorithm were used to produce near real-time calculation results. The algorithm allows the user to set and vary the total number of plugs for each shot to limit the total beam-on time. We implemented and tested the algorithm for several multiple-isocenter Gamma Knife cases. It was found that the use of limited number of plugs significantly lowered the integral dose to the critical structures such as an optical chiasm in pituitary adenoma cases. The main effect of the source blocking is the faster dose falloff in the junction area between the target and the critical structure. In summary, we demonstrated a useful source-plugging algorithm for improving complex multi-isocenter Gamma Knife treatment planning cases.

Treatment of pituitary tumors: radiation

In this paper, the role of conventional radiotherapy and radiosurgery in the management of pituitary tumors is reviewed. After a short summary of the mechanism of action of irradiation therapy and the types of different irradiation techniques, the therapeutic effects and side effects are analyzed in patients with different types of pituitary tumors, including our own experience with conventional radiotherapy and radiosurgery in patients with acromegaly. Conventional fractionated radiotherapy has long been used to control growth and/or hormonal secretion of residual or recurrent pituitary tumors. However, patient selection for conventional radiotherapy still remains a controversial issue, because a number of potentially significant side effects, including hypopituitarism and other complications, have been described. Stereotactic radiotherapy/radiosurgery methods have several potential advantages over conventional radiotherapy, including their use in patients with residual or recurrent pituitary tumors who had previously been treated by conventional radiotherapy, but long-term follow-up data with these relatively new techniques are still limited.

Selective source blocking for Gamma Knife radiosurgery of trigeminal neuralgia based on analytical dose modelling

We have developed an automatic critical region shielding (ACRS) algorithm for Gamma Knife radiosurgery of trigeminal neuralgia. The algorithm selectively blocks 201 Gamma Knife sources to minimize the dose to the brainstem while irradiating the root entry area of the trigeminal nerve with 70-90 Gy. An independent dose model was developed to implement the algorithm. The accuracy of the dose model was tested and validated via comparison with the Leksell GammaPlan (LGP) calculations. Agreements of 3% or 3 mm in isodose distributions were found for both single-shot and multiple-shot treatment plans. After the optimized blocking patterns are obtained via the independent dose model, they are imported into the LGP for final dose calculations and treatment planning analyses. We found that the use of a moderate number of source plugs (30-50 plugs) significantly lowered (approximately 40%) the dose to the brainstem for trigeminal neuralgia treatments. Considering the small effort involved in using these plugs, we recommend source blocking for all trigeminal neuralgia treatments with Gamma Knife radiosurgery.

Concomitant boost of stratified target area with gamma knife radiosurgery: a treatment planning study

Conventional Gamma Knife Stereotactic Radiosurgery (GKSRS) has been focused on delivering a single peripheral dose to the gross target volume based on the anatomic information derived from the magnetic resonance or computed tomography (CT) studies. In this study, we developed a treatment planning approach that allows a boost dose to be delivered concomitantly to the desired subtarget area while maintaining the peripheral isodose coverage of the target volume. The subtarget area is defined as the high-risk or the tumor burden areas based on the functional imaging information such as the magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) studies or the physician's clinical diagnosis. Treatment plan comparisons were carried out between the concomitant boost plans and the conventional treatment plans using dose volume histogram (DVH), tissue volume ratio (TVR), and the maximum dose to the peripheral dose ratio (MD/PD) analysis. Using the concomitant boost approach, more conformal and higher dose was delivered to the desired subtarget area while maintaining the peripheral isodose coverage of the gross target volume (GTV). Additionally, the dose to the normal brain tissue was found to be equivalent between the concomitant boost plans and the conventional plans. As a result, we conclude that concomitant boost of a stratified target area is feasible for GKSRS.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for pituitary tumors

Pituitary adenomas frequently pose challenging clinical problems. Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is one treatment option in selected patients. The purpose of this report is to identify the advantages and disadvantages of radiosurgery in cases of pituitary tumors to assess better its role in relation to other treatment. Methods for optimizing outcome are described. The author reviews several recent series to determine rates of growth control, endocrine response, and complications. In general, growth control is excellent, complications are very low, and reduction of excessive hormone secretion is fair. Depending on the clinical situation, SRS may be the treatment of choice in selected patients.

Plug pattern optimization for gamma knife radiosurgery treatment planning

PURPOSE

To develop a novel dose optimization algorithm for improving the sparing of critical structures during gamma knife radiosurgery by shaping the plug pattern of each individual shot.

METHOD AND MATERIALS

We first use a geometric information (medial axis) aided guided evolutionary simulated annealing (GESA) optimization algorithm to determine the number of shots and isocenter location, size, and weight of each shot. Then we create a plug quality score system that checks the dose contribution to the volume of interest by each plug in the treatment plan. A positive score implies that the corresponding source could be open to improve tumor coverage, whereas a negative score means the source could be blocked for the purpose of sparing normal and critical structures. The plug pattern is then optimized via the GESA algorithm that is integrated with this score system. Weight and position of each shot are also tuned in this procedure.

RESULTS

An acoustic tumor case is used to evaluate our algorithm. Compared to the treatment plan generated without plug patterns, adding an optimized plug pattern into the treatment planning process boosts tumor coverage index from 95.1% to 97.2%, reduces RTOG conformity index from 1.279 to 1.167, lowers Paddick's index from 1.34 to 1.20, and trims the critical structure receiving more than 30% maximum dose from 16 mm(3) to 6 mm(3).

CONCLUSIONS

Automated GESA-based plug pattern optimization of gamma knife radiosurgery frees the treatment planning team from the manual forward planning procedure and provides an optimal treatment plan.

The clinical application of plugging patterns for the Leksell gamma knife

Object. In this report the authors explore the use of standardized plugging templates in formulating stereotactic radiosurgery dose plans for the Leksell gamma knife.

Methods. Unplugged gamma knife dose plans previously used in the treatment of patients with trigeminal neuralgia (TN) and vestibular schwannoma (VS) were studied. Standardized plugging templates were then superimposed on these plans, and their effects on the conformity index of tumors and the transposition of the radiation field from the brainstem to the cerebrospinal fluid spaces for the trigeminal cases were examined.

Conclusions. The standardized plugging templates significantly increased the conformity indices in cases of VS plans and for TN. Plugging significantly reduced the brainstem exposure to radiation while at the same time not altering the length of the trigeminal nerve being treated. Standardized plugging templates may therefore be a useful tool in optimizing dose plans.

Conformal radiotherapy optimization with micromultileaf collimators: comparison with radiosurgery techniques

PURPOSE

Conformal radiotherapy (CRT) consists of irradiating the target volume while avoiding the healthy peripheral tissues and organs at risk as far as possible. One technique used to treat intracranial tumors consists of using micromultileaf collimators (MMLCs). Given the dose constraints involved, it is of interest to optimize MMLC irradiation parameters and compare the results of this technique with those of conventional radiosurgery (RT) techniques (Gamma Knife and linear accelerator stereotactic RT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

MMLC protocols are optimized in two stages. The orientation of the fields, delimited by a beam's eye view technique, is determined using a genetic algorithm method. The weighting of the fields and subfields when using intensity modulation and the position of the leaves are optimized using a simulated annealing method. We compared the results obtained for 8 clinical cases using 5 intensity-modulated fields with those obtained using the two radiosurgery techniques. The comparison indexes are those defined by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG).

RESULTS

The results of this study demonstrated the advantages of using intensity modulation and the improvement obtained for the RTOG indexes in the case of CRT with MMLC, although the healthy peripheral tissues were less exposed to radiation with the radiosurgery techniques. The results also highlight the difficulty encountered with radiosurgery techniques in obtaining satisfactory dose homogeneity when the protocol is defined with numerous iosocenters.

CONCLUSION

In CRT with MMLC, intensity modulation makes it possible to reduce the number of fields used. It is especially useful to optimize the orientations in the case of target volumes of complex shape or when volumes at risk are in the vicinity of the target. If used correctly, MMLC can be a valuable alternative to conventional radiosurgery techniques.

Local tumor control and morbidity after one to three fractions of stereotactic external beam irradiation for uveal melanoma

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

To evaluate prospectively local tumor control and morbidity after 1-3 fractions of stereotactic external beam irradiation (SEBI) in patients with uveal melanoma, unsuitable for ruthenium-106 brachytherapy or local resection.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This phase I/II study includes 62 selected patients with uveal melanoma. The mean initial tumor height was 7.8+/-2.8 mm. With the Leskell gamma knife SEBI, 41 patients (66%) were irradiated with two equal fractions of 35, 30 or 25 Gy/fraction, 14 patients (22%) were treated with three fractions of 15 Gy each, and seven patients (11%) with small tumor volumes below 400 mm(3) were treated with one fraction of 45 Gy. The mean total dose was 54+/-8 Gy. The minimal follow-up period was 12 months, and the median follow-up was 28.3 months. Data on radiation-induced side-effects were analyzed with the Cox proportional hazards model for possible risk factors.

RESULTS

Local tumor control was achieved in 98% and tumor height reduction in 97%. The mean relative tumor volume reductions were 44, 60 and 72% after 12, 24 and 36 months, respectively. Seven patients developed metastases (11%). Secondary enucleation was performed in eight eyes (13%). Morbidity was significant in tumors exceeding 8 mm in initial height; it was comparable and acceptable in those smaller. In the stepwise multiple Cox model, tumor localization, height and volume, planning target volume (PTV), total dose and patient age were identified as the strongest risk factors for radiation-induced lens opacities, secondary glaucoma, uveitis, eyelash loss and exudative retinal detachment. In this model, the high-dose volume irradiated with more than 10 Gy/fraction was the strongest risk factor for radiation-induced uveitis.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic external photon beam irradiation and a total dose of 45-70 Gy delivered in one to three fractions are highly effective at achieving local tumor control in uveal melanoma. Further clinical studies using smaller fraction doses, and consequent smaller high-dose volumes, are justified to optimize dose and fractionation. Fractionated stereotactic irradiation has a challenging potential as an eye-preserving treatment in uveal melanoma.

Optimizing computerized treatment planning for the Gamma Knife by source culling

PURPOSE

A good plan is crucial to the success of gamma knife treatment, which depends not only on parameters such as the number of shots, shot position, collimator sizes, and shot weight, but also on the number of blocked cobalt sources. However, during treatment, a plug is generally used to block those cobalt sources, so the beam cannot reach critical tissues. We present here an automated method to optimize all of those parameters, and to choose a source set, although the beams of some blocked sources do not hit any critical tissue. This strategy is used to achieve a high dose that better conforms to the tumor shape, and at the same time, avoids healthy tissue.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Using a workstation that integrates the gamma knife treatment planning system, we developed a two-step optimization algorithm. First, we used a modified Powell's method to optimize the location of the shot, collimator size, and shot weight; we used simulated annealing to determine if the number of shots was adequate using this parameter. Then, simulated annealing was used to determine which cobalt sources we needed to block.

RESULTS

Application of this optimization method in two cases showed that the treatment plan can be much improved when the set of blocked cobalt sources has been taken into consideration.

CONCLUSION

Determining the set of blocked sources is necessary in certain cases. This technique better conforms the desired isodose curves to the outline of the target volume and minimizes damage to the surrounding normal tissues.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for jugular foramen schwannomas

BACKGROUND

Jugular foramen schwannomas pose difficult management problems because of the surgical risk of lower cranial neuropathy. The indications and results of stereotactic radiosurgery are not well documented.

METHODS

We reviewed our 10-year experience in the management of 17 patients who had jugular foramen schwannomas managed with the gamma knife. Thirteen patients previously had undergone surgery (range, 1-6 resections). Four patients had multiple cranial nerve deficits before microsurgical resection; 12 developed multiple lower cranial nerve palsies after resection. Four patients underwent radiosurgery based on imaging criteria alone. Conformal dose planning (tumor margin dose of 12-18 Gy) successfully encompassed the irregular tumor volumes in all patients.

RESULTS

Follow-up varied from 6 to 74 months. Tumor size decreased in eight patients, remained stable in eight, and increased in one patient during the average follow-up interval of 3.5 years. Six patients improved and 10 others retained their preradiosurgery clinical status. One patient had an increase in tumor size and clinical deterioration 6 months after radiosurgery and underwent microsurgical resection. No patient developed new cranial nerve or other neurological deficits after radiosurgery.

CONCLUSIONS

We believe that gamma knife radiosurgery is an effective alternative to microsurgical resection for patients who have small tumors and intact lower cranial nerve function. It is also effective for patients who have residual or recurrent tumors after microsurgical resection.

Treatment planning of stereotactic convergent gamma-ray irradiation using Co-60 sources

The basic features of the convergent Co-60 gamma-ray unit, known as Gamma Knife and the standard procedures of treatment planning for various cases in general have been described in details. The new generation of the rotating gamma system and the future clinical applications are briefly mentioned.

[Progress in dosage optimization for stereotactic radiosurgery]

Stereotactic radiosurgery is a technique for treatment of intracranial lesions requiring high precision in all steps--from image acquisition to final irradiation. One of most difficult steps is the treatment planning phase, consisting of determination of irradiation parameters sufficient to cover the target volume by avoiding sensitive volumes. A manual and empirical definition can be very long and difficult, especially in the case of complex target volumes situated in sensitive zones. As in conventional radiotherapy, stereotactic radiosurgery has taken advantages from dosimetric optimization. The question is: "What is the configuration of irradiation parameters used in order to obtain the treatment plan by satisfying defined constraints?". The purpose of this article is to summarize optimization methods used in radiosurgery and to describe the technical alternatives proposed for this treatment as well as the possibilities of plan evaluation between different techniques. This purpose will be illustrated by the optimization methodology used in the Center Oscar Lambret of Lille, France for the radiosurgical treatment with linear accelerator.

Stereotactic localization with magnetic resonance imaging: a phantom study to compare the accuracy obtained using two-dimensional and three-dimensional data acquisitions

OBJECTIVE

To compare the accuracy of stereotactic localization using magnetic resonance imaging (Siemens 1.5-T Magnetom; Siemens, Erlangen, Germany) with two-dimensional and three-dimensional data acquisition techniques.

METHODS

A phantom study was performed in which the coordinates of an array of rods were determined from images in both two-dimensional and three-dimensional studies and compared with measured values in a series of transverse, coronal, and sagittal images.

RESULTS

The results demonstrated a distinct advantage in using three-dimensional acquisition; an error greater than 2 mm was identified in only 0.8% of the imaged volume, compared with 12% of the imaged volume in the two-dimensional study.

CONCLUSION

The results indicated that more accurate stereotactic localization is achieved with a three-dimensional acquisition.

Computer-aided design optimization with the use of a fast dose model for linear-accelerator-based stereotactic radiosurgery

In order to efficiently plan non-spherical radiosurgical targets we have used computer-aided design optimization techniques with a fast dose model. A study of the spatial dose distribution for single or multiple non-coplanar arcs was carried out using a 18 cm diameter spherical head model. The dose distribution generated from the 3D dose computation algorithm can be represented by a simple analytic form. Two analytic dose models were developed to represent the dose for preset multiple non-coplanar arcs or a single arc: spherical and cylindrical. The spherical and cylindrical dose models compute dose quickly for each isocentre and single arc. Our approach then utilizes a computer-aided design optimization (CAD) with the use of two fast approximate dose models to determine the positions of isocentres and arcs. The implementation of CAD with fast dose models was demonstrated. While the fast dose models are only approximations of the true dose distribution, it is shown that this approximate model is sufficient to optimize isocentric position, collimator size and arc positions with CAD.

The field-matching problem as it applies to the peacock three dimensional conformal system for intensity modulation

PURPOSE

Intensity modulated beam systems have been developed as a means of creating a high-dose region that closely conforms to the prescribed target volume while also providing specific sparing of organs at risk within complex treatment geometries. The slice-by-slice treatment paradigm used by one such system for delivering intensity modulated fields introduces regions of dose nonuniformity where each pair of treatment slices abut. A study was designed to evaluate whether or not the magnitude of the nonuniformity that results from this segmental delivery paradigm is significant relative to the overall dose nonuniformity present in the intensity modulation technique itself. An assessment was also made as to the increase in nonuniformity that would result if errors were made in indexing during treatment delivery.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Treatment plans were generated to simulate correctly indexed and incorrectly indexed treatments of 4, 10, and 18 cm diameter targets. Indexing errors of from 0.1 to 2.0 mm were studied. Treatment plans were also generated for targets of the same diameter but of lengths that did not require indexing of the treatment couch.

RESULTS

The nonuniformity that results from the intensity modulation delivery paradigm is 11-16% for targets where indexing is not required. Correct indexing of the couch adds an additional 1-2% in nonuniformity. However, a couch indexing error of as little as 1 mm can increase the total nonuniformity to as much as 25%. All increases in nonuniformity from indexing are essentially independent of target diameter.

CONCLUSIONS

The dose nonuniformity introduced by the segmental strip delivery paradigm is small relative to the nonuniformity present in the intensity modulation paradigm itself. A positioning accuracy of better than 0.5 mm appears to be required when implementing segmental intensity modulated treatment plans.

A phantom study to assess the accuracy of stereotactic localization, using T1-weighted magnetic resonance imaging with the Leksell stereotactic system

This phantom study assesses the accuracy of stereotactic localization using the Leksell G frame (Elekta Instruments AB, Stockholm, Sweden) with T1-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (Siemens 1.5 T Magnetom; Erlangen, Germany). The coordinates of an array of solid perspex rods were determined and compared with measured values in a series of transverse, coronal, and sagittal images. The maximum absolute errors observed (X = 2.7 mm, Y = 7.0 mm, Z = 8.0 mm) were discouraging. However, the more reasonable mean errors (X = 0.4 mm, Y = 0.7 mm, Z = 1.3 mm) reflect considerable variation in accuracy throughout the volume assessed and limitation of maximum errors to specific areas. We present details of the spatial variation and discuss possible mechanisms for improving accuracy. The overall results are of direct relevance only to the scanner used. These results are, however, an indication of the need to approach with caution stereotactic localization using magnetic resonance imaging and to emphasize the requirement for quality assurance and for a comprehensive study of the scanner's characteristics.

Implementation of multiple isocentre treatment for dynamic radiosurgery

Radiosurgery using the dynamic rotation technique with a single isocentre was introduced at the Toronto-Bayview Regional Cancer Centre (T-BRCC) in 1988. Since then, over 100 patients have been treated. It was soon recognized that 25-30% of patients were referred with either non-spherical lesions or multiple lesions located sufficiently close together that consideration had to be given to the overlapping dose distributions throughout the treated volume. To treat these more complex targets a multiple isocentre technique was developed which also took account of these effects and the resulting normalization problem. This technique was implemented in September 1992. Comparisons between calculated doses and actual doses delivered have been undertaken using a spherical phantom containing radiochromic film. Measured dose distributions agreed with the planned distributions to within +/- 1 mm. The effect of multiple isocentres on the penumbra of dose distributions has been examined. The methods adopted for the normalization of treatment plans and clinical examples illustrating the application of the multiple isocentre technique are presented.

Single isocenter treatment planning for homogeneous dose delivery to nonspherical targets in multiarc linear accelerator radiosurgery

PURPOSE

Conventional radiosurgery refers to single isocenter focused beam irradiation of small intracranial targets with a single collimator. Conventional radiosurgery is characterized by spherical-shaped isodose surfaces. Nonspherical targets require a different approach to avoid exposing a large volume of nontarget brain tissue to high dose, particularly for lesions larger than 25 mm. Multiple isocenters are frequently used to treat nonspherical large targets, but multiple isocenter treatments are associated with a relative dose inhomogeneity of approximately 100% within the target volume, and may be correlated with an increased rate of complications. The feasibility of conformally treating elongated targets to an approximately homogeneous dose using a single isocenter methodology will be demonstrated.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A prolate ellipsoid of revolution, 25 mm in diameter, 35 mm in length, positioned at five representative locations in a head phantom, was used as a target model. The alignment of the target was taken to be parallel in turn to each of the three principal axes of the head model (A/P, R/L, and C/C). Dose conformation is achieved by nonuniform arc weighting, selective limitation of the extent of individual arcs, and the use of different collimator apertures for the different arcs in accordance with the aperture size required to encompass the target for that arc. Treatment plans were selected based on considerations of dose-volume histograms and conformation of the 80% dose surface with the surface of the target. The goal was that the minimum target dose would not be less than 80% of the maximum dose.

RESULTS

Practical treatment plans for which the minimum target dose exceeded 80% were obtained for the three orthogonal orientations of the target for the five target locations. Plan parameters were essentially independent of the target position, dependent only on target orientation. The 80% isodose contour surface enclosed on average 2.8 cm3 larger volume (range: 2.1-3.9 cm3) than the prescribed 11.45 cm3 target. The minimum dose to the target ranged from 80.1 to 84.5%, and the average dose to the target was 94.26%. The 80-to-50% dose volume enclosed an average of 14.8 cm3 of nontarget volume (range: 12.7-15.9 cm3). Average deviation in the principal planes of the 80% isodose lines from the surface of the target volume was 0.95 mm for the 25 mm dimension (range 0.0 to +1.9 mm) and 0.86 mm (range 0.0 to + 2.4 mm) for the 35 mm dimension.

CONCLUSION

Standardized single isocenter treatment plans with the isocenter at the center of the target can achieve good conformation of the dose distribution to targets elongated along any of the principal axes, and located anywhere in the brain.

Suction fixation system for stereotactic radiosurgery of intraocular malignancies

We designed a suction fixation system for the radiosurgical treatment of intraocular malignancies with the Leksell gamma unit (gamma knife). OUr device consists of a circular suction chamber and an adjustable unit to be fixed to the Leksell stereotactic head frame. All components are made of plastic materials in order to avoid artifacts in CT or MRT imaging. A permanent suction of 600 to 800 millibars is provided by a standard vacuum pump, powered by a portable battery. Suction times up to 40 minutes were well tolerated in all cases. In the gamma knife of the Neurosurgical Department at the University of Vienna, we successfully used this device. Up to January 1994 we have performed 19 radiosurgical treatments in 9 patients with large or extra-large uveal melanomas and in one patient suffering from a choroidal metastasis.

Stereotactic radiosurgery for pituitary adenomas: imaging, visual and endocrine results

To determine the endocrine, ophthalmologic, and tumor growth control responses after stereotactic radiosurgery using the gamma unit, we reviewed our experience in 35 patients with pituitary adenomas. Twenty-four females and 11 males (mean age 47 years, range 9-81 years) had radiosurgery with average follow-up of 26 months (range 6-60 months). Most patients were refractory to surgical removal. Fifteen patients had Cushing's disease. Prior transsphenoidal resection was performed in 14 patients (6 had two prior operations), fractionated radiotherapy in 3, and adrenalectomy in 2. In 11 evaluable patients, the hormone response was normalized in 8, decreased in 2 and increased in 1. Five patients remained on cortisol suppression. Of 12 patients with imaging follow-up, 4 had decreased tumor size, 6 had no change, and 2 had an increase; these 2 patients underwent subsequent surgery. Ten patients had acromegaly, and 6 had undergone prior surgery. Of 8 evaluable patients, growth hormone secretion has normalized in 3, decreased in 3, and increased in 2. Six tumors decreased in size, and 2 were unchanged. One patient had repeat resection 21 months after radiosurgery and one patient underwent repeat radiosurgery. Ten patients had non-secreting adenomas; all 10 had prior operations (1-4 operations, 6 underwent frontal craniotomy) and 5 had undergone fractionated radiotherapy. Eight patients had panhypopituitarism prior to radiosurgery. Four tumors decreased in size and 6 were without change.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Radiosurgery/stereotactic external beam radiotherapy for malignant brain tumours: the Royal Marsden Hospital experience

SRT is a high-precision technique of radiotherapy which delivers focused irradiation to small target volumes. In the context of external beam radiotherapy it can be described as stereotactically guided conformal radiotherapy. As the technique originated from neurosurgical technology, it has initially been limited to single fraction treatment. However, with the use of relocatable fixation devices the way ahead particularly in its application in the treatment of brain tumours is in fractionated SRT. Currently, single fraction SRT/radiosurgery is of proven value only in the treatment of small inoperable arteriovenous malformations. It is being exploited in the management of brain tumours but so far remains as experimental treatment. We have demonstrated that fractionated SRT in patients with gliomas is a non-invasive equivalent to brachytherapy and in patients with solitary metastases a non-invasive alternative to surgical excision. However, the treatment is not without side effects, and the long-term effectiveness and toxicity of SRT, particularly with the use of unconventional fractionation, is not defined. The future use of SRT in the treatment of brain tumours should not be guided simply by the technical possibilities but by a rational appraisal of all treatment options to achieve the best disease control, survival and toxicity. Although there is potential for benefit in a number of small tumours, SRT cannot at present be recommended as the primary treatment in any tumour. In addition, its use should be discouraged in the treatment of unbiopsied brain lesions and as the major form of treatment of pineal germinomas. The technology of stereotactic radiotherapy is evolving, and it is likely that SRT will be integrated into conventional radiotherapy practice to become simply a high-precision technique of radiotherapy delivery in everyday use.

Optimisation of dose distribution for linear accelerator-based stereotactic radiosurgery

The work presented in the paper addresses a method for obtaining the optimal dose distribution for LINAC-based stereotactic radiosurgery. As many targets have nonspherical or irregular shapes and three-dimensional dose calculations included in dose optimisation, long computation times are required to determine the optimum isocentre separation and collimator sizes to shape the irregular target using the multiple-isocentre approach, by trial-and-error types of method. The simple approach, using a computer-aided design optimisation technique and a fast approximate dose model, has been developed to find the optimum isocentre positions and collimator sizes quickly and automatically. A spherical dose model has been developed to represent the dose for a standard arc system with a single isocentre. The implementation of computer-aided design algorithms with the spherical dose model and their application to several cases are discussed. It is shown that the spherical dose model gives dose distribution similar to that of the exact dose model, which makes this simple dose model more efficient, with computer-aided design optimisation, in finding optimum isocentre positions and collimator sizes used in stereotactic radiosurgery.

Stereotactic radiosurgery of cavernous sinus meningiomas as an addition or alternative to microsurgery

To evaluate the response of cavernous sinus meningiomas to stereotactic radiosurgery, we reviewed our 54-month experience with 34 patients. All patients underwent radiosurgery with a 201-source cobalt-60 gamma unit. Twenty-eight patients (82%) had previous histological confirmation of a meningioma (1 to 5 cranial base craniotomies per patient); 6 (18%) were treated on the basis of neuroimaging criteria alone. The single-fraction radiation tumor margin dose (10 to 20 Gy) was designed to conform to the irregular tumor volumes in all patients. The maximum radiation dose to the optic nerve or tract was reduced to 9 Gy in 31 patients. No patient had tumor growth (100% tumor control) during the follow-up interval (median, 26 mo). Tumor regression was observed in 56% of patients imaged at an average of 18 months. Eight patients (24%) improved clinically at follow-up examinations. Four patients developed new or worsened cranial nerve deficits during the follow-up interval; two had subsequent full improvement. No patient developed an endocrinopathy or new extraocular muscle paresis. Stereotactic radiosurgery, using multiple isocenter dosimetry facilitated by the gamma unit, is an accurate, safe, and effective technique to prevent the growth of tumors involving the cavernous sinus. Despite the proximity of such tumors to adjacent cranial nerves, complications were rare. The maximum length of hospital stay was 36 hours, and all patients returned to their preoperative employment status within 3 to 5 days.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Stereotactic radiosurgery: at the threshold or at the crossroads?

More than 15,000 patients worldwide have undergone stereotactic radiosurgery since the technique was first described in 1951. Over 6000 of these patients had arteriovenous malformations, usually relatively small. Increasingly, patients with benign and malignant brain tumors have had radiosurgery as an alternative to microsurgical removal. The role of radiosurgery as a tool for functional neurosurgery is being evaluated further. Numerous studies over the past 10 years have examined the benefits and risks of radiosurgery performed with various devices (cyclotron-generated particle beams, the multisource cobalt-60 gamma knife, and modified linear accelerators). As radiosurgical centers continue to proliferate, often without appropriate regulatory review, lamentable lapses in appropriate patient selection, quality assurance, training, and results analysis may ensue. Critical clinical and radiobiological questions (dose, histology, and volume variables) remain to be answered in appropriate studies; these needs can no longer be ignored by governmental funding sources. Stereotactic radiosurgery is a multidisciplinary field, requiring the leadership of neurological surgeons in cooperation with radiation oncologists, radiologists, and medical physicists. For many indications, stereotactic radiosurgery appears poised at both the threshold and at the crossroads. As clinical application progresses, continued dialogue between neurological surgeons and their professional colleagues is necessary to guide proper patient management decisions.

Stereotactic radiosurgery: principles and comparison of treatment methods

Methods of stereotactic radiosurgery are reviewed and compared with respect to technical factors and published clinical results. Heavy-ion beams, the Leksell cobalt-60 gamma knife, and the conventional linear accelerator (linac) are compared with respect to dosimetry, radiobiology, treatment planning, cost, staffing requirements, and ease of use. Clinical results on the efficacy of treatment of arteriovenous malformations are tabulated, and other applications of radiosurgery are described. It is concluded that although there are dosimetric and radiobiological advantages to charged-particle beams that may ultimately prove critical in the application of radiosurgery to large (> 30 mm) lesions, these advantages have not yet demonstrated clinical effect. On the other hand, equally excellent clinical results are obtained for small lesions with photon beams--the gamma knife and the linac. There are only minor differences between gamma and x-ray beam dose distributions for small, spherical-shaped targets. Mechanical precision is superior for the gamma knife as compared with the linac. The superior mechanical precision is of limited importance for most clinical targets, because inaccuracy of cranial target localization based on radiological imaging is greater than the typical linac imprecision of +/- 1 mm. Treatment planning for the linac is not standardized, but existing systems are based on well-known algorithms. The linac allows flexible, ready access to individualized beam control, without intrinsic field size limitations. Thus, it is more readily possible to achieve homogeneous dose distributions for nonspherical targets with one or more dimensions greater than 25 mm, as compared with that achieved with the gamma unit.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Cranial nerve length predicts the risk of delayed facial and trigeminal neuropathies after acoustic tumor stereotactic radiosurgery

PURPOSE

To test the hypothesis that length of cranial nerve irradiated is a major factor predicting the risk of cranial nerve injury following radiosurgery and to identify any other significant related treatment factors.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ninety-two patients (93 acoustic tumors) were treated with a 201 source Cobalt-60 gamma unit from 1987 to 1990 and prospectively followed. The range of minimum tumor dose was 12-20 Gy and maximum dose 24-50 Gy. Univariate and multivariate analyses were used to evaluate any correlations between tumor measurements and treatment factors, with the development of trigeminal and facial neuropathies following radiosurgery.

RESULTS

The risks of trigeminal and facial neuropathy following radiosurgery were associated with the pon-petrous distance and mid porous transverse tumor diameters respectively (anatomically related to the irradiated length of cranial nerves V and VII respectively) in both univariate (p = .002 for V and p = .026 for VII) and multivariate (p = .004 for V and p = .055 for VII) analyses. Tumor volume, other tumor measurements, maximum dose, minimum tumor dose, and tumor dose inhomogeneity were not significantly related to either trigeminal or facial neuropathy in univariate and multivariate analyses.

CONCLUSION

Within a minimum tumor dose range of 12-20 Gy, the incidence of delayed trigeminal or facial neuropathy depended more on the estimated length of nerve irradiated than the tumor dose or tumor volume. In the future, the risk of delayed facial or trigeminal cranial neuropathy may be reduced significantly by performing radiosurgery when the tumor still has both a small mid-porous transverse diameter and a small pons-petrous distance.

Tumor control after stereotactic radiosurgery in neurofibromatosis patients with bilateral acoustic tumors

During a 4-year interval, 17 patients with bilateral acoustic tumors (vestibular schwannomas) underwent unilateral stereotactic radiosurgery using a multisource gamma unit; 2 patients underwent radiosurgery of both tumors in separate sessions. Eleven patients with unoperated contralateral tumors served as concurrent controls to compare the effects of radiosurgery with the natural history of acoustic tumors. After radiosurgery, the tumor control and regression rates were 89.5 and 21.1%, respectively (median neuroimaging follow-up, 1.4 years; range, 0.3-3.9). The tumor regression rate increased to 40% for patients evaluated at least 12 months after radiosurgery. In comparison to the unoperated contralateral tumors, stereotactic radiosurgery achieved tumor control, as assessed by the ultimate change in tumor size at follow-up (P, 0.012), the change in tumor size over time (P, 0.006), and tumor growth rates (P, 0.003). This study provided convincing evidence that tumor stabilization after radiosurgery (as assessed by neuroimaging) truly represented tumor control. The incidence of delayed facial neuropathy after radiosurgery compared favorably with the incidence reported after microsurgical removal. Some hearing was preserved in one-third of the patients who had preoperative hearing, including three patients who were contralaterally deaf. Stereotactic radiosurgery should be considered as a primary surgical modality for many patients with neurofibromatosis Type II.

Three-dimensional dose mapping from gamma knife treatment using a dosimeter gel and MR-imaging

A new method has been investigated for the mapping of dose distributions in three dimensions delivered by the Leksell gamma knife. The irradiation unit is used to selectively treat small volumes in the brain with single high doses of ionising radiation--a treatment procedure known as radiosurgery. The dosimetry method investigated utilises a dosimeter gel consisting of ferrous sulphate solution and agarose which is, prior to irradiation, loaded into a cavity in a spherical phantom. Chemical changes induced in the gel by the radiation are measured by means of an MR-scanner. This imaging method permits rapid evaluation of the dose distribution in an irradiated volume. It thus offers a potential verification of individual radiation intracranial target treatment regimes as well as quality assurance measurements, assuming that the precision and accuracy of the dose mapping are adequate. The dose and its distribution registered by the gel dosimeter, in this initial experiment, are in good agreement with corresponding computed data obtained with the KULA treatment planning system of the gamma knife. The gel has thus the potential of being an attractive alternative dose mapping method to those used at present in radiosurgery, i.e. radiographic film and small ionisation chambers. The precision of the dosimeter gel is, however, not yet sufficient high to be used as a basic dosimetry system for the gamma knife.

Radiosurgery and brain tolerance: an analysis of neurodiagnostic imaging changes after gamma knife radiosurgery for arteriovenous malformations

In order to analyze complications and the factors responsible for the development of serial imaging changes after stereotactic radiosurgery for intracranial arteriovenous malformations, we reviewed serial post-treatment magnetic resonance imaging scans in 72 patients. Median follow-up was 23 months (range 12 to 35 months). Twenty patients developed post-radiosurgical imaging changes consisting of new regions of increased T2 signal on magnetic resonance imaging in brain surrounding the arteriovenous malformation (two year actuarial incidence of 31%). Imaging changes were associated with headache or new neurological deficits in nine of these 20 (45%) and remained asymptomatic in 11 (55%). Symptoms developed in three of 13 patients with imaging changes in the cerebral cortex or cerebellum, in contrast to six of seven patients who had symptoms with imaging changes in the brainstem (p = .028). The onset of imaging changes varied from five to 18 months after radiosurgery (median, 12 months). Serial follow-up scans four to 25 months after the onset of imaging changes were available for review in 16 patients. Post-radiosurgical imaging changes completely resolved within 4 to 19 months in ten patients and have not yet completely resolved after 6 to 25 months in six patients. The projected actuarial rate for resolution of imaging changes was 88%, 19 months after onset; the median time for resolution was 14 months. Univariate analysis revealed that the development of imaging changes was significantly associated with treatment volume (p = .025), the risk predicted from the integrated logistic formula (p = .042), and the number of isocenters treated (p = .042). In multivariate analysis, volume was the only factor significantly associated with the development of imaging changes.