Behavioural states in growth-retarded human fetuses

Delayed rhythm formation of normal-structured, growth-restricted fetuses using fetal heart rate monitoring patterns

AIMS

Growth-restricted fetuses have delayed rhythm formation in utero. The awake-sleep cycle of fetal heart rate pattern is thought to represent fetal rhythm. We aimed to study if the emergence of rhythm formation on fetal heart rate pattern delays in fetal growth restriction compared to appropriate-for-date fetuses.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study including 75, normal-structured, singleton fetuses. Of them, 21 were fetal growth restriction and the remaining 54 were appropriate-for-date infants. We examined timing of emergence of rhythm formation on fetal heart rate pattern comparing between fetal growth restriction and appropriate-for-date fetuses after adjusting possible confounding factors as outcome measures.

RESULTS

Rhythm formation was significantly delayed in fetal growth restriction (<10th percentile) compared to the appropriate-for-date subgroups (10-30, 30-50, 50-70 and 70-90th percentile) by 1-2 weeks. After adjusting confounding factors, growth restriction was the only independent variable to delay fetal rhythm formation. One infant for each group had neurodevelopmental disorder and the incidence did not reach statistically significant.

CONCLUSION

Based on fetal heart rate pattern analysis, growth-restricted fetuses show 1-2 weeks delay in rhythm formation compared to appropriate-for-date fetuses.

Reference values for a fetal movement acceleration measurement recorder to count fetal movements

BackgroundA newly developed fetal movement acceleration measurement recorder has made it possible to count gross movements for hours. The purpose of this study was to determine the normal reference values for such movements.MethodsOne hundred and six pregnant women recorded fetal movements by themselves when they slept at home weekly from 28 weeks to term. The normal reference values were determined based on the data that could be recorded for more than 4 h per night.ResultsA total of 2,458 h of data from 385 recordings from 64 women was available. The median ratio of 10-s periods in which fetal movements occurred to the total time interval was 17% at 28 gestational weeks, decreasing to ∼6% at term. The number of fetal movements was 74 times/h, decreasing to 29 times at term. The number, the mean, and the longest durations of periods with no fetal movement, meaning no fetal movements were found for more than 5 min, were 1.56 times/h, 7.95 and 14.25 min, respectively, at 28 weeks, and increasing to 2.54 times, and 9.63 and 19.67 min, respectively, at term.ConclusionsThis study provides normal reference values for gross fetal movement count using the fetal movement acceleration measurement recorder.

Doppler-based fetal heart rate analysis markers for the detection of early intrauterine growth restriction

INTRODUCTION

One indicator for fetal risk of mortality is intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR). Whether markers reflecting the impact of growth restriction on the cardiovascular system, computed from a Doppler-derived heart rate signal, would be suitable for its detection antenatally was studied.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We used a cardiotocography archive of 1163 IUGR cases and 1163 healthy controls, matched for gestation and gender. We assessed the discriminative power of short-term variability and long-term variability of the fetal heart rate, computed over episodes of high and low variation aiming to separate growth-restricted fetuses from controls. Metrics characterizing the sleep state distribution within a trace were also considered for inclusion into an IUGR detection model.

RESULTS

Significant differences in the risk markers comparing growth-restricted with healthy fetuses were found. When used in a logistic regression classifier, their performance for identifying IUGR was considerably superior before 34 weeks of gestation. Long-term variability in active sleep was superior to short-term variability [area under the receiver operator curve (AUC) of 72% compared with 71%]. Most predictive was the number of minutes in high variation per hour (AUC of 75%). A multivariate IUGR prediction model improved the AUC to 76%.

CONCLUSION

We suggest that heart rate variability markers together with surrogate information on sleep states can contribute to the detection of early-onset IUGR.

Effect of maternal position on fetal behavioural state and heart rate variability in healthy late gestation pregnancy

KEY POINTS

Fetal behavioural state in healthy late gestation pregnancy is affected by maternal position. Fetal state 1F is more likely to occur in maternal supine or right lateral positions. Fetal state 4F is less likely to occur when the woman lies supine or semi-recumbent. Fetal state change is more likely when the woman is supine or semi-recumbent. Fetal heart rate variability is affected by maternal position with variability reduced in supine and semi-recumbent positions.

ABSTRACT

Fetal behavioural states (FBS) are measures of fetal wellbeing. In acute hypoxaemia, the human fetus adapts to a lower oxygen consuming state with changes in the cardiotocograph and reduced fetal activity. Recent studies of late gestation stillbirth described the importance of sleep position in the risk of intrauterine death. We designed this study to assess the effects of different maternal positions on FBS in healthy late gestation pregnancies under controlled conditions. Twenty-nine healthy women had continuous fetal ECG recordings under standardized conditions in four randomly allocated positions, left lateral, right lateral, supine and semi-recumbent. Two blinded observers, assigned fetal states in 5 min blocks. Measures of fetal heart rate variability were calculated from ECG beat to beat data. Compared to state 2F, state 4F was less likely to occur when women were semi-recumbent [odds ratio (OR) = 0.11, 95% confidence interval (95% CI) 0.02, 0.55], and supine (OR = 0.27, 95% CI 0.07, 1.10). State 1F was more likely on the right (OR = 2.36, 95% CI 1.11, 5.04) or supine (OR = 4.99, 95% CI 2.41, 10.43) compared to the left. State change was more likely when the mother was semi-recumbent (OR = 2.17, 95% CI 1.19, 3.95) or supine (OR = 2.67, 95% CI 1.46, 4.85). There was a significant association of maternal position to mean fetal heart rate. The measures of heart rate variability (SDNN and RMSSD) were reduced in both semi-recumbent and supine positions. In healthy late gestation pregnancy, maternal position affects FBS and heart rate variability. These effects are likely fetal adaptations to positions which may produce a mild hypoxic stress.

Neurodevelopment after fetal growth restriction

Fetal growth restriction (FGR) can emerge as a complication of placental dysfunction and increases the risk for neurodevelopmental delay. Marked elevations of umbilical artery (UA) Doppler resistance that set the stage for cardiovascular and biophysical deterioration with subsequent preterm birth characterize early-onset FGR. Minimal, or absent UA Doppler abnormalities and isolated cerebral Doppler changes with subtle deterioration and a high risk for unanticipated term stillbirth are characteristic for late-onset FGR. Nutritional deficiency manifested in lagging head growth is the most powerful predictor of developmental delay in all forms of FGR. Extremes of blood flow resistance and cardiovascular deterioration, prematurity and intracranial hemorrhage increase the risks for psychomotor delay and cerebral palsy. In late-onset FGR, regional cerebral vascular redistribution correlates with abnormal behavioral domains. Irrespective of the phenotype of FGR, prenatal tests that provide precise and independent stratification of risks for adverse neurodevelopment have yet to be determined.

Intrauterine growth restriction and cerebral palsy

Intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) can be described as condition in which fetus fails to reach his potential growth. It is common diagnosis in obstetrics, and carries an increased risk of perinatal mortality and morbidity. Moreover, IUGR has lifelong implications on health, especially on neurological outcome. There is a need for additional neurological assessment during monitoring of fetal well-being, in order to better predict antenatally which fetuses are at risk for adverse neurological outcome. Studies have revealed that the behavior of the fetus reflects the maturational processes of the central nervous system (CNS). Hence, ultrasound investigation of the fetal behavior can give us insight into the integrity and functioning of the fetal CNS. Furthermore, investigations carried out using modern method, four-dimensional (4D) sonography, have produced invaluable details of fetal behavior and its development, opening the door to a better understanding of the prenatal functional development of the CNS. Based on previous observations and several years of investigation, our reaserch group has proposed a new scoring system for the assessment of fetal neurological status by 4D sonography named Kurjak antenatal neurodevelopmental test (KANET). The value of KANET in distinguishing fetal brain and neurodevelopmental alterations due to the early brain impairment in utero is yet to be assessed in large population studies. However, preliminary results are very encouraging.

Maturational changes and effects of chronic hypoxemia on electrocortical activity in the ovine fetus

We have studied the maturation of electrocortical (ECoG) activity in fetal sheep and the impact of chronic hypoxemia using a growth restriction model with placental embolizations. Twenty chronically catheterized fetal sheep (control, n=9; hypoxemic, n=11) were monitored at 116-119, 121-126 and 128-134 days gestational age (term=145 days), with ECoG activity scored using automated analysis of amplitude and frequency components to distinguish low-voltage/high frequency (LV/HF) and high-voltage/low frequency (HV/LF) state epochs, along with indeterminate voltage/frequency (IV/F) and transition period activities. We have shown that multiple aspects of ECoG state activity in the ovine fetus undergo maturational change as electrophysiologic measures of brain development. With chronic fetal hypoxemia, some maturational changes continue to occur, i.e. ECoG activity amplitude and 95% SEF, indicating the resiliency of these parameters to adverse conditioning. However, some maturational changes were altered, i.e. LV/HF and HV/LF incidence and duration, and likely regulated and adaptive with a decrease in the brain's nonessential energy needs, while some were altered, i.e. IV/F incidence and duration, and state transition times, and likely indicating a degree of aberrant development in associated control circuitries. This may then have consequences for disturbed sleep-wake patterns during later life and for adverse neurologic sequelae known to be increased in humans born with growth restriction.

Neurodevelopment following fetal growth restriction and its relationship with antepartum parameters of placental dysfunction

Placental dysfunction leading to fetal growth restriction (FGR) is an important risk factor for neurodevelopmental delay. Recent observations clarify that FGR evolves prenatally from a preclinical phase of abnormal nutrient and endocrine milieu to a clinical phase that differs in characteristics in preterm and term pregnancies. Relating childhood neurodevelopment to these prenatal characteristics offers potential advantages in identifying mechanisms and timing of critical insults. Based on available studies, lagging head circumference, overall degree of FGR, gestational age, and umbilical artery (UA), aortic and cerebral Doppler parameters are the independent prenatal determinants of infant and childhood neurodevelopment. While head circumference is important independent of gestational age, overall growth delay has the greatest impact in early onset FGR. Gestational age has an overriding negative effect on neurodevelopment until 32-34 weeks' gestation. Accordingly, the importance of Doppler status is demonstrated from 27 weeks onward and is greatest when there is reversed end-diastolic velocity in the UA or aorta. While these findings predominate in early-onset FGR, cerebral vascular impedance changes become important in late onset FGR. Abnormal motor and neurological delay occur in preterm FGR, while cognitive effects and abnormalities that can be related to specific brain areas increase in frequency as gestation advances, suggesting different pathophysiology and evolving vulnerability of the fetal brain. Observational and management studies do not suggest that fetal deterioration has an independent impact on neurodevelopment in early-onset FGR. In late-onset FGR further research needs to establish benefits of perinatal intervention, as the pattern of vulnerability and effects of fetal deterioration appear to differ in the third trimester.

Behavioural state linkage in the ovine fetus near term

Nine fetal sheep were surgically prepared with placement of electrocortical and electro-ocular electrodes for monitoring behavioural state activity to determine the relationship of adjacent low-voltage (LV)/rapid eye movement (REM) and high-voltage (HV)/non-(N)REM epoch durations and the inter-epoch transition time. Animals were subsequently studied over an 8-hour period with behavioural state epoch duration and transition time assessed using paired t-test and regression analysis. For all animals, the duration of LV/REM epochs averaged 14.8+/-0.8 (SEM) minutes which was significantly greater than that for HV/NREM epochs at 10.1+/-0.5 min (P<0.01). The mean duration of LV/REM to HV/NREM transition periods at 93+/-3 s was also significantly longer than that for the HV/NREM to LV/REM transition periods at 78+/-6 s (P<0.05). HV/NREM epoch duration was positively correlated with the prior LV/REM epoch duration with a group mean correlation of 0.59 (P<0.01). HV/NREM epoch duration was likewise positively correlated with the subsequent LV/REM epoch duration with a group mean correlation of 0.46 (P<0.01). We conclude that the transition time into HV/NREM is longer than that into LV/REM for the ovine fetus near term which may involve differences in the rate of maturation of cycling control mechanisms for these two behavioural states and earlier development of REM-on versus REM-off pathways. The positive LV/REM-HV/NREM linkage relationships also support a homeostatic model of behavioural state control whereby LV/REM and HV/NREM timings are both controlled by accumulation of propensity for these states during the other state and favours an interactive process between these states in the brain's growth and development.

Normal fetal physiology and behavior, and adaptive responses with hypoxemia

The principal objective of antenatal testing is to detect fetal hypoxia before the fetus has suffered lasting harm. This article summarizes some of the mechanisms by which fetal oxygen consumption is maintained under normal conditions, and adaptations that occur in response to hypoxemia. Alterations in the fetal heart rate are prominent in the fetal response to hypoxemia and are the basis of some methods of antenatal testing. The principal mechanisms underlying these fetal heart rate changes are described. Adaptations in the distribution of blood flow that permit the fetus to deal with reduced oxygen levels are summarized. Developmental trends in fetal motility and behavior are outlined, and also how these are modified by fetal growth retardation and maternal diabetes. Fetal movements are suppressed during acute hypoxemia, but with gradually developing hypoxemia, normal movement patterns may continue until the fetus becomes acidemic. This may limit the use of these biophysical variables in antenatal testing.

Neurobehavioral assessment from fetus to infant: the NICU Network Neurobehavioral Scale and the Fetal Neurobehavior Coding Scale

This review provides an overview and definition of the concept of neurobehavior in human development. Two neurobehavioral assessments used by the authors in current fetal and infant research are discussed: the NICU Network Neurobehavioral Assessment Scale and the Fetal Neurobehavior Coding System. This review will present how the two assessments attempt to measure similar processes from pre to post-natal life by examining three main components of neurobehavior: neurological, behavioral and stress/reactivity measures. Assessment descriptions, strengths and weaknesses, as well as cautions and limitations are provided.

Neurobehavioral assessment before birth

The complexities of neurobehavioral assessment of the fetus, which can be neither directly viewed nor manipulated, cannot be understated. Impetus to develop methods for measuring fetal neurobehavioral development has been provided by the recognition that individual differences in neurobehavioral functioning do not originate with birth and acceptance of the key contribution of the antenatal period to postnatal life. Research has centered around four aspects of fetal functioning: heart rate, motor activity, behavioral state, and responsivity to stimulation. Longitudinal studies have revealed that the developmental trajectories of these characteristics parallel the developing nervous system, detected a transitional period between 28 and 32 weeks gestation, and established within-fetal stability during the second half of gestation. Despite the promise of fetal stimulation and habituation paradigms as measures of neural functioning, significant safety and ethical concerns exist. Construction of a unified fetal neurobehavioral scale is premature until a sufficient degree of normative data is available and the predictive validity of specific aspects of fetal neurobehavior to child developmental outcomes is better established.

Fetal behavior

Fetal behavior reflects the activity of the fetal central nervous system (CNS). Insight in fetal behavior is crucial for the understanding of normal fetal well-being and in the evaluation of the possibly compromised fetus. In order to recognize 'behavioral' patterns, linkage of variables (absence of movements, absence of eye movements, heart rate patterns) is obligatory. No single test can predict with certainty if the fetus is compromised and/or what the optimal timing is for the delivery. That is why the study of fetal behavior is very time-consuming. Development of more appropriate methods to analyze fetal behavior should have high priority in clinical perinatology.

Fetal state concordance predicts infant state regulation

Fetal state organization reflects the development of the central nervous system but may also portend individual differences in postnatal state organization. The goal of the present study was to determine the extent to which fetal state regulation, defined as the percentage of an observation period in which fetal heart rate and movement concordance was displayed, is associated with neonatal state regulation. Neonatal state regulation was evaluated through a standard neurobehavioral assessment at 2 weeks postpartum. Biobehavioral concordance was measured in 52 normally developing fetuses at 24, 30 and 36 weeks gestation using an actocardiograph; the neonatal assessment was administered to 41 of these as infants. Intrafetal stability in biobehavioral concordance did not emerge prior to 36 weeks. Fetuses with higher concordance at 36 weeks were infants that displayed better state regulation during the exam, including more alertness and orientation (r(35)=0.29), less cost of maintaining attention (r=0.36), less irritability (r=-0.41), better regulatory capacity (r=0.47), a greater range of available states (r=0.34), and were significantly more likely to maintain control during the most aversive portions of the exam F(1,31)=4.63, p<0.05). These results support fetal state as a stable individual attribute that is conserved across the prenatal and neonatal periods.

Temporal sequence of abnormal Doppler changes in the peripheral and central circulatory systems of the severely growth-restricted fetus

OBJECTIVE

To identify the temporal sequence of abnormal Doppler changes in the fetal circulation in a subset of early and severely growth-restricted fetuses.

METHODS

This was a prospective observational study in a tertiary care/teaching hospital. Twenty-six women who were diagnosed with growth-restricted fetuses by local standards before 32 weeks' gestation and who had abnormal uterine and umbilical artery Doppler velocimetry were enrolled onto the study. To compare Doppler changes as a function of time, pulsed-wave Doppler ultrasound was performed on five vessels in the fetal peripheral and central circulations. Doppler examinations were performed twice-weekly and on the day of delivery if the fetal heart rate tracing became abnormal. Doppler indices were scored as abnormal when their values were outside the local reference limits on two or more consecutive measurements. Biometry for assessment of fetal growth was performed every 2 weeks. Computerized fetal heart rates were obtained daily. Delivery was based on a non-reactive fetal heart rate tracing and not on Doppler information. Patients with a severely growth-restricted fetus who were delivered for maternal indications such as pre-eclampsia were excluded. Perinatal outcome endpoints included: intrauterine death, gestational age at delivery, newborn weight, central nervous system damage of grade 2 or greater, intraventricular hemorrhage and neonatal mortality.

RESULTS

Mean gestational age and newborn weight at delivery were 29 (standard deviation (SD), 2) weeks and 818 (SD, 150) g, respectively. The sequence of Doppler velocimetric changes was described by onset time cumulative curves that showed two time-related events. First, for each vessel there was a progressive increase in the percent of fetuses developing a Doppler abnormality. Second, severely growth-restricted fetuses followed a progressive sequence of acquiring Doppler abnormalities which were categorized into 'early' and 'late' Doppler changes. Early changes occurred in peripheral vessels (umbilical and middle cerebral arteries; 50% of patients affected 15-16 days prior to delivery). Late changes included umbilical artery reverse flow, and abnormal changes in the ductus venosus, aortic and pulmonary outflow tracts (50% of patients affected 4-5 days prior to delivery). The time interval between the occurrence of early and late changes was significantly different (P < 0.0001) and late changes were significantly associated with perinatal death (P < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Doppler velocimetry abnormalities develop in different vessels of the severely growth-restricted fetus in a sequential fashion. Late changes in vascular adaptation by the severely growth-restricted fetus are the best predictor of perinatal death.

Temporal organization of fetal behavior from 24-weeks gestation onwards in normal and complicated pregnancies

Developmental aspects of behavioral organization were investigated in 29 healthy fetuses from 24-weeks gestation onwards: (a) short-term association between body (GM) and eye (EM) movements; (b) linkage of pairs of the three state variables [fetal heart rate pattern (FHRP), GM, and EM]; and (c) sequence of change of state variables during transitions. Linkage and sequence were also studied in complicated pregnancies. Short-term association between GM and EM was well established after 28 weeks. Linkage of state variables improved considerably after 32-34 weeks. FHRP was the first variable to change during synchronized transitions from 1F to 2F between 28-39 weeks, and the last variable during 2F to 1F transitions between 32-39 weeks. Although clear developmental patterns could be recognized, the interfetal variability was such that identification of the abnormal fetus is still difficult. Only transitions were significantly different in growth-restricted fetuses, as they showed no specific sequence of change. Assessing the temporal organization of fetal behavior seems, therefore, until now, not of great clinical value.

State transitions in uncomplicated pregnancies after term

A behavioural state transition is the time interval between two different behavioural states. In low-risk fetuses, the fetal heart rate pattern (FHRP) is the first variable to change in transitions from 1F to 2F ('non-REM-sleep' to 'REM-sleep') and the last variable to change in transitions from 2F to 1F. This is not the case in IUGR (intra-uterine growth retardation), and absence of a specific order in which behavioural variables are changing might be an indication for a (mild) disturbance of the fetal central nervous system (CNS). We investigated whether state transitions in twelve low risk term fetuses (39-41 weeks post menstrual age, PMA; control group) differ from those in twelve uncomplicated pregnancies > 41 weeks PMA (study group). All subjects underwent one behavioural study in which fetal heart rate pattern, eye and body movements were recorded simultaneously. We recorded 23 transitions from 1F to 2F and 20 from 2F to 1F. Median (range) duration for transitions from 1F to 2F was 85 (10-180) s in the study group, and 60 (10-180) s in the control group. Transitions from 2F to 1F lasted 80 (10-140) and 60 (30-100) s, respectively. In both groups, the FHRP was the first variable to change in transitions from 1F to 2F, however, in transitions from 2F to 1F, no specific order in change of variables could be demonstrated. We conclude that the study of transitions does not distinguish between the term and after term fetuses under optimal conditions. Whether or not the analysis of state transitions can be used to distinguish 'normal' from 'abnormal' fetuses and detect the fetus at risk after term awaits further study.

Computer-assisted analysis of fetal movements in intrauterine growth retardation (IUGR)

A quantitative analysis of various fetal activities (mouth, eye and gross body movements) was made in 10 IUGR human fetuses. The aim of the study was to see whether IUGR fetuses move differently to normal fetuses. Each real-time ultrasound recording lasted 1 h and the analysis of various activities was carried out during replay of video recordings by means of a specially designed computer program. The following aspects have been investigated: (1) incidence, duration and interval for each of the fetal activities described; (2) the relationship between incidence, duration and interval for each single activity; (3) the correlations between the different activities. The results were compared with a group of 10 fetuses from normal pregnancies. On quantitative evaluation no clear effects due to uncomplicated IUGR could be detected except for median duration of eye movements, which turned out to be longer in the IUGR group. The evaluation of correlations between the characteristics (incidence, duration and interval) of each activity showed a positive correlation between incidence and duration of mouthing movements in the IUGR group, not found in the normal group. The study of the correlation between different fetal activities has shown an inverse correlation between mouthing and other activities in the normal fetuses, not found in the IUGR group. We conclude that in mildly affected fetuses with no evidence of hypoxia, there are no quantitative differences compared to normal fetuses in terms of the motility studied. The only differences found were in relation to the performance of such activities and they could reflect a dysfunction of the central nervous system resulting from a metabolic disturbance.

Metabolic and circulatory adaptations to chronic hypoxia in the fetus

When oxygenation is compromised the fetus is capable of a number of adaptive responses, both protective and potentially pathologic, which can be categorized as those affecting fetal metabolism and those affecting fetal oxygen transport. However, both the extent and the duration of the impairment in oxygenation will bear on these adaptive responses. While fetal O2 extraction is increased when oxygenation is acutely compromised thus maintaining O2 consumption, with chronic hypoxemia there is a decrease in O2 consumption paralleling that in O2 delivery and contributed to by the resultant fall-off in growth and alterations in behavioural activity. While a redistribution of blood flow to vital organs continues to be evident, this will be less pronounced than that seen with acute hypoxemia reflecting diminished hormonal changes, underlying metabolic alterations, and the extent to which fetal blood gases are normalized. Much of this information is based on experimental data using unanesthetized fetal sheep with chronic catheterization; however, clinical outcome data and the use of investigative techniques including ultrasound scanning and cordocentesis have supported the relevance of this experimental data to the human situation.

Pregnancy-induced hypertension, antihypertensive drugs and the development of fetal behavioural states

In 21 pregnancies complicated by pregnancy-induced hypertension (PIH) which was treated by antihypertensive drugs (labetalol, nifedipine), fetal behavioural recordings (quiet state, C1F; active state, C2F; no coincidence, NOC) and Doppler measurements of blood flow velocity in the umbilical artery (UA) (resistance index, RI) were made on two occasions (27-32 and 33-36 weeks of gestation). Data were compared to those of a control group of normally grown fetuses (n = 96); in 15 cases we were able to match fetuses from the study group for age (+/- 1 week) and weight (+/- 150 g) at birth with fetales from a control group. It was the aim of this study to investigate if there are disturbances in the development of fetal behavioural states and if possible disturbances are due to poor fetal growth or to antihypertensive therapy. Our results show that in PIH treated by antihypertensive drugs, there are disturbances in the development of fetal behavioural states with higher percentages of NOC and C1F, lower percentages of C2F, and higher UA RI values. These disturbances are mainly due to coexisting placental impairment and poor fetal growth rather than to nifedipine or labetalol therapy, although these drugs may cause some redistribution of states.

Is neurological assessment of the fetus possible?

The possibility to assess the functional condition of the fetal nervous system is of great importance to the obstetrician, since a considerable part of early brain damage is of prenatal origin. Several attempts to develop such a technique are reviewed. In addition, a new method, the qualitative assessment of fetal general movements, is described as a successful tool to obtain reliable data on the fetal brain dysfunction. This new method is robust, non-intrusive and cost-effective. There is also the advantage that the same criteria for the diagnostic assessment can be used for the fetus as well as for the young infant.

Computerised analysis of behaviour in normal and growth-retarded fetuses

Fetal behaviour [fetal heart rate (FHR) variation and movements (FA)] was studied in 27 normally grown fetuses and in 18 fetuses with intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR). FHR and FA were recorded using a single 1.5 MHz ultrasound transducer and analyzed by computer. The IUGR fetuses had significantly lower FA rates than the normally grown fetuses at all gestation times. They also spent a significantly lower proportion of time exhibiting high FHR variation at 28-31 weeks. Only two of the eighteen IUGR fetuses had abnormal biophysical profile scores (BPS) at the time of recording and yet all but one of them had either FHR or FA patterns that were outside the 10-90th centile range for the normally grown fetuses, suggesting that FHR and FA abnormalities predated BPS changes. More of the IUGR fetuses had abnormalities of FA than FHR. Finally, within the IUGR fetuses, those with small head circumferences (less than 3rd centile) had lower FA rates during periods of both low and high FHR variation, though this was only statistically significant for periods of low FHR variation (P < 0.05). This preliminary study offers the possibility that such objective evaluation of fetal behaviour could be used in a clinical setting and provide a more sensitive method of fetal assessment than the BPS.

Spontaneous motility in preterm, small-for-gestational age infants. II. Qualitative aspects

In order to document in detail the developmental course of qualitative aspects of early spontaneous motility in intrauterine growth-retarded infants, sequential videotape recordings were made in 19 preterm infants with a birth weight below the 5th percentile. The quality of general movements (GMs) was studied longitudinally during the preterm and postterm period until approximately 20 weeks corrected age, using Prechtl's method of quality assessment. An abnormal quality of GMs was present in 15 out of 19 infants. Compared to a low-risk group, consisting of appropriate-for-gestational age preterm infants, the proportion of infants with normal findings on brain scans who had an abnormal quality of GMs was high. The presence of 'abrupt chaotic' GMs was related to late fetal heart-rate decelerations and ischaemic alterations of the placenta. The quality of GMs normalized before or during the third month postterm in most infants with abnormal GMs. In four infants, the GMs did not normalize during the study period. The quality of fidgety movements was, in particular, a marker for neurological outcome at 24 months. This study demonstrates that intrauterine growth retardation may cause prolonged, but in most cases transient brain dysfunction; the qualitative assessment of GMs may help to identify infants at increased risk for neurodevelopmental abnormalities.

Temporal stability in the distribution of behavioral states for individual human fetuses

Although behavioral state analyses have been useful in differentiating between groups of normal and at-risk fetuses, the large between-subject differences in the percent time spent in the various behavioral states poses a major obstacle in identifying abnormal neurological functioning in individual fetuses. Does this variability represent a true difference in state organization between fetuses, or does it simply reflect individual fluctuations in state control at the time of observation? To answer this question, we examined each of 33 human fetuses for 4 h on three separate days between 38 and 40 weeks gestation. The percent time spent in each behavioral state and in transition and insertion periods was determined for each of the three 4-h study sessions, and within-subject analysis of variance was performed to obtain an objective measure of state profile consistency for each fetus. We found that, on the average, fetuses exhibited remarkable within-subject consistency in their state profiles. However, even among this group of low-risk fetuses, there were significant differences in the degree of state organization achieved by individual fetuses. These findings, which indicate the existence of a well-developed central nervous system before birth, suggest that individual differences in the consistency of behavioral state profiles may be indexing important between-subject differences in neurological development.

Fetal brain sparing is associated with accelerated shortening of visual evoked potential latencies during early infancy

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to assess the effects that fetal growth restriction exerts on the myelination of the developing brain.

STUDY DESIGN

Fetal haemodynamic centralization, an adaptive strategy to growth restriction caused by placental insufficiency, was determined by Doppler ultrasonography. Infants with a raised ratio between umbilical artery pulsatility index and cerebral artery pulsatility index are severely growth restricted. Visual evoked potentials give information on the degree of brain myelination. Shortening of visual evoked potential latencies is a normal feature of myelination. In a consecutive series of 105 Neonates, visual evoked potentials were recorded at the corrected ages of 6 months and 1 years. Correction for possible confounders, such as cranial ultrasonographic findings, gestational age, and head circumference, was performed.

RESULTS

At 6 months, infants with a raised umbilical artery/cerebral artery pulsatility index ratio have shorter visual evoked potential latencies. Opposite of neonates with a normal umbilical artery/cerebral artery ratio, they show no postnatal maturational shortening of visual evoked potential latencies.

CONCLUSION

Accelerated neurophysiologic maturation, found in infants with a high umbilical artery/cerebral artery ratio, might be the result of a beneficial adaptive process to severe fetal growth restriction.

Morphology of active sleep--quiet sleep transitions in normal human term fetuses

Periods of no coincidence (PsNC) among state variables appear to be more predictive of neurobehavioral outcome than the amount of time spent in any particular behavioral state. It has recently been suggested that analysis of the ordering of state variables during a state transition may provide results equivalent to full state analysis. If this were the case, then there ought to be a relationship between the duration of PsNC and fetal heart rate (FHR)-fetal eye movement (FEM) sequencing at the time of a state change. To test this hypothesis, we compared full state analysis with analysis of individual state transitions for 52 normal human fetuses between 38 and 42 weeks of gestation. For the study population as a whole, FHR was the first variable to change in 62 (77%) of 81 1F-->2F transitions and FEM was the first variable to change in 50 (63%) of 79 2F-->1F transitions (chi 2 = 67.9, p < 0.001). Ordering of FHR and FEM at the time of a state change was reversed in 8 (67%) of 12 fetuses with PsNC > or = 15% and is only 6 (15%) of 40 fetuses with PsNC < 15% (chi 2 = 12.5, p < 0.001). We conclude that fetuses who exhibit poor state organization more often display a FHR-FEM sequence at the time of a state transition which is opposite that of fetuses with considerably better state control. However, since only one-third of fetuses with reversed FHR-FEM sequencing actually exhibited more than one such episode, it is unlikely that isolated analysis of state transitions will provide a reliable measure of behavioral state organization in the individual fetus.

Behavioural development and Doppler velocimetry in relation to perinatal outcome in small for dates fetuses

Twenty-two small for dates (SFD) fetuses and 96 fetuses from uncomplicated pregnancies were monitored on two occasions between 27 and 32 weeks and the second time between 33 and 36 weeks of gestation by studying the development of behavioural states (coincidence 1F and 2F; no coincidence) and umbilical artery Doppler waveform patterns (UA; Resistance Index, RI). Data were related to neurological outcome at 8 months after birth. The purpose of this study was to investigate if the development of behavioural state is disturbed in SFD fetuses and if SFD fetuses who needed to be delivered early and/or had abnormal neurological outcome showed different state development and RI than SFD fetuses delivered later in pregnancy or with normal neurological outcome. Finally, we studied if there was a relationship between state development and RI. At 27-32 weeks of gestation the percentage of coincidence 2F (C2F%) was lower and the percentage of coincidence 1F (C1F%) and no coincidence (NOC%) were higher in the SFD fetuses than in the control group. At 33-36 weeks C2F% was lower and NOC% was higher but not statistically different (P = 0.2 and P = 0.07, respectively). SFD fetuses who needed to be delivered early had poorer state development than SFD fetuses at lower risk and infants who were abnormal at 8 months of life showed a higher C1F% and lower C2F% at 27-32 weeks. There were significant correlations between RI on the one hand and NOC% (r = 0.62) and C2F% (r = -0.48) on the other hand at 27-32 weeks in the subgroup with abnormal neurological outcome. In conclusion, in SFD fetuses there are disturbances in the development of behavioural states as well in the distribution of the periods of coincidence (with a decrease in C2F% and an increase in C1F%). Poorest state development is present in SFD fetuses at highest risk and in this group there appears to be a significant relationship between the degree of utero-placental insufficiency (RI) and disturbances in behavioural development.

Fetal behaviour in normal and compromised fetuses. An overview

Fetal intrauterine behaviour is not a stable situation but a continuous alternation of states characterized by significant changes in fetal motility, heart rate, hemodynamics, metabolism and response to stimulation. Associations between fetal heart rate patterns and movements occur from 26-28 weeks of gestation onwards. As fetuses grow older these variables become gradually more related temporally and clustered in behavioural states similar to those present in newborns. This article describes the technique of recording and analyzing fetal behaviour, its development in normal pregnancy and its influence on different physiological parameters that are assessed in clinical practice. Furthermore the deviations from the norm occurring in compromised fetuses are described.

Categorization of heart rate-eye movement patterns in human fetuses using the statistical technique of discriminant analysis

The purpose of this study was to determine if discriminant analysis could be used to categorize fetal heart rate (FHR) - fetal eye movement (FEM) patterns. Statistical characteristics from 27 normal human fetuses at term for behavioral states, transitions, and insertions were established by combining the digitized FHR-FEM data for subjectively identical epochs. The mean FHR, the variance about the mean, and the presence or absence of FEM were calculated for each 3-min block in a sliding moving window with a 1-min step size. For each fetus, discriminant analysis was then used to assign 3-min blocks to either a behavioral state, a transition, or an insertion by comparing the statistical properties of a 3-min block with that of the data base. We found no difference between discriminant analysis and visual assignment in the average time spent in behavioral states 1F, 2F, and 4F, or in the mean duration of the transition/insertion periods. There was a highly significant linear relationship between computer-generated and visually-determined durations for behavioral states 1F (r = 0.972, p < 0.0001) and 2F (r = 0.989, p < 0.0001) and for the transition/insertion periods (r = 0.863, p < 0.0001). We conclude that discriminant analysis is a reliable computer-based method for behavioral state identification.

Predictors of perinatal outcome in intrauterine growth retardation: a long term study

Fifty-three intrauterine retarded fetuses (IUGR) and seventy-five healthy pregnancies were monitored by neurobehavioural profile (quiet state or S1F and activity state or S2F percentages) and umbilical artery Doppler velocimetry (UA RI) on two occasions between the 27th-32nd and the 33rd-36th week of gestation. The aims of the present study were the following 1) to relate S1F, S2F and RI to mild and severe IUGR 2) to relate behavioural state analysis and UA Doppler velocimetry to the following perinatal outcomes: Cesarean section (CS); Preterm delivery (PD); small for gestational age (SGA); Apgar score at 1st and 5th min < 7; Respiratory Distress Syndrome (RDS); Neurological Injury (NI) (evaluated at the birth, the 4th, the 8th and the 12th month of life). 3) to establish the best predictors of perinatal outcome with these monitoring parameters by a stepwise computerized processing. Our results suggest: 1) mild IUGR, characterized by a progressive increase in peripheral vascular resistances, positive diastolic peak flow (RI: 0.72 +/- 0.01; mean +/- SD), is associated with gradual increase in S1F (12.51 +/- 2.84; mean +/- SD) and a decrease in S2F (27.51 +/- 2.81; mean +/- SD) percentages; 2) severe IUGR, characterized by zero or negative diastolic peak flow (UA RI-->1), is associated with a significant increase in S1F (21.32 +/- 12.11; mean +/- SD) and a decrease in S2F percentages (30.93 +/- 20.35; mean +/- SD).

IN CONCLUSION

S1F is the best predictor of severe IUGR and significant for all the perinatal outcomes selected; S2F is the best predictor of mild IUGR and significant for SGA; UA RI is the best parameter for recognizing mild IUGR and evolution to severe IUGR.

Doppler velocimetry in cerebral vessels of small for gestational age infants

Using the duplex Doppler system, blood velocity was measured serially at two sites of the anterior cerebral artery (ACA) and in the middle cerebral artery (MCA) during the first 3 days of life, in eight term, small for gestational age (SGA) infants (birthweight, 2179 +/- 230 g; mean +/- S.D.), and 13 term, appropriate for gestational age (AGA) infants (3376 +/- 441 g). All infants in both groups had normal Apgar scores and none manifested signs of respiratory distress. At 1 h post partum, the average MCA mean velocity in the SGA group (25.8 +/- 6.9 cm/s) was higher than that in the AGA group (19.6 +/- 5.7 cm/s), whereas the average values of the two ACA sites did not differ between the groups. A significantly increased value of the average mean velocity as compared to the value at 4 h post partum was reached earlier in the AGA group at all three vessel sites. The pulsatility index (as defined by Gosling) was lower at all vessel sites up to 72 h in the SGA group. Pulse pressure was significantly lower in the SGA group due to increased diastolic blood pressure. We suggest the results imply a state of cerebral vasodilation in the SGA infants and a poor ability to respond with an increased perfusion in the frontal regions supplied by the ACA. Changes in blood pressure and cerebral haemodynamics appear to exist in SGA infants in the absence of postnatal hypoxia which might explain the vulnerability of the growth-retarded infant to perinatal hypoxia.

Fetal heart rate accelerations, fetal movement, and fetal behavior patterns in twin gestations

OBJECTIVE

Previous studies have shown that twins, when monitored simultaneously, show a remarkably high incidence of coincident fetal heart rate accelerations (about 58%). The current study examines synchrony of behavior patterns in twins.

STUDY DESIGN

We examined 37 fetal monitor strips from 15 sets of twins with simultaneous fetal heart rate and fetal movement recorded by means of Doppler techniques (Toitu MT-430 fetal actocardiograph). The strips were analyzed for coincidence of fetal heart rate accelerations and fetal movement episodes and then conceptually for synchrony of fetal behavior patterns on the basis of descriptions of behavioral states by Prechtl.

RESULTS

Thirty-six percent of fetal heart rate accelerations were found to be simultaneous. Forty-three percent of movement epochs were considered simultaneous. We found that twins exhibited synchronous behavior patterns (basically sleep or awake state) 94.7% of the time.

CONCLUSION

Twin-twin interactions are more consistently related than suspected when observation is limited to heart rate alone, and the synchrony and role of fetal behavior states must be considered when twin interactions and behavior are studied.

The relationship between heart rate and eye movement in the human fetus at 38-40 weeks of gestation

The purpose of this study was to compare two different methods for assessing fetal heart rate (FHR)--fetal eye movement (FEM) synchronization: (1) periods of high (HV) and low (LV) variability in the FHR and the presence (EM) and absence (NEM) of FEM were determined by visual inspection and the degree of association between FHR and FEM was assessed in terms of the fraction of study time for which no periods of LV-NEM and HV-EM could be identified; and (2) the maximum cross-correlation coefficient (rmax) and the lag at rmax (Lmax) were determined by direct computer analysis of FHR and FEM data for each fetus. Twenty normal human fetuses between 38 and 40 weeks of gestation were examined for a total of 2051 min (mean 103 min, range 72-150 min). In general, the state HV-EM was observed approximately twice as often as was the state LV-NEM; neither of these two states could be identified during 12.4% of the study time. The coefficient rmax was calculated assuming a sliding 3-min moving window, using either the average FHR (mean 0.53, range 0.31-0.85) or the variability in the FHR (mean 0.52, range 0.18-0.77). No relationship was found between rmax and Lmax calculated using the mean FHR and the fraction of time for which no state could be identified (P = 0.995). When the cross-correlation analysis was performed using FHR variability, a statistically significant relationship was found between the periods of no coincidence (of states LV-NEM and HV-EM) and rmax and Lmax (r2 = 0.32; P = 0.04).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The development of ultradian rhythms in the human fetus

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to determine the normal sequence of neurobehavioral development in the human fetus between 14 weeks' gestation and delivery.

STUDY DESIGN

The study was performed by longitudinal ultrasonographic observation of 45 low-risk singleton fetuses.

RESULTS

During the first half of the midtrimester there was a high rate of spontaneous movement that appeared randomly distributed. By the end of that trimester an increase in the duration of intervals of quiescence resulted in activity appearing cyclically distributed, with the duration of quiet cycles progressively increasing to term. Fetal mouthing and breathing were linked with cyclic behavior from the time of their emergence. Fetal heart rate pattern A could be recognized from around 32 weeks, due to a reduction in baseline variability in quiet cycles after 30 weeks, whereas pattern B could be recognized several weeks earlier. From the time cyclic behavior and heart rate patterns could be recognized, intervals of coincidence of the fetal behavioral state variables increased progressively with advancing gestation.

The effect of intrauterine growth retardation on the quality of general movements in the human fetus

The effect of severe intrauterine growth retardation on the quality of general movements was studied longitudinally in 17 human fetuses. During the prenatal and postnatal periods, fetal movements were recorded by means of weekly 1 h ultrasound and video registrations. Neurological examinations were performed at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months after birth. No clear effect of uncomplicated intrauterine growth retardation could be detected on the quality of general movements. General movements became slow and small in amplitude (4/5) in cases where there was a reduction in the amount of amniotic fluid. Parallel to the onset of abnormal fetal heart rate patterns, general movements became poor in repertoire (7/7), while they were hardly discernible after further deterioration of the fetal condition (5/7). With the exception of 3 infants with cerebral haemorrhages, the quality of general movements observed just before and after birth was identical (13/16). In these infants, the quality of general movements as well as the results of the standardized neurological examination tended to normalize at 3 months and 1 year, respectively. Uncomplicated IUGR had no marked effect on the quality of general movements or on the results of the neurological examination at the age of 1 year.

Fetal rest-activity cycles and chronic exposure to antiepileptic drugs

Rest-activity patterns were studied in fetuses exposed to antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) and in control fetuses at three intervals during pregnancy: 20, 32, and 38 weeks. At 20 weeks, periods of rest and activity were distinguished on the basis of fetal motility. Trunk, head, and arm movements were totaled. Periods of absence of movements for greater than 3 min were found in 20 of 31 recordings from AED-exposed fetuses compared with 11 of 20 recordings from controls (p greater than 0.05). The duration of these periods of inactivity did not differ significantly between the two groups. At 32 and 38 weeks, information on fetal motility and fetal heart rate (FHR) were combined to recognize rest-activity patterns according to the fetal behavioral state concept. At 32 weeks, three true fetal behavioral states were found for the study group, while there were none in the control group. Coincidence 1F through 4F occurred significantly less frequently at 32 weeks than at 38 weeks, regardless of whether fetuses were AED-exposed or not: 59% vs. 82% for the study group and 59% vs. 80% for the controls. At 38 weeks, true fetal behavioral states appeared in 20 of 34 fetuses exposed to AEDs and in 17 of 35 controls (p greater than 0.05). The sequence in which parameters changed within state transitions was found to follow the same preferred pattern in both groups. For transitions from behavioral state 1F (quiet sleep) into 2F (active sleep) the FHR pattern changed significantly earlier than fetal body or eye movements, while for the reverse transitions the FHR pattern changed significantly later (p less than 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Continuation of normal neurobehavioural development in fetuses with absent umbilical arterial end diastolic velocities

Detailed serial observations of behaviour were made in four singleton fetuses who were very small for dates and who had persistently absent umbilical artery end diastolic velocities for 2 to 9 weeks duration. All were born preterm for deteriorating maternal disease, and in two there were additional fetal indications for delivery. Behavioural comparison with 45 low risk singleton fetuses, at comparable gestations, revealed no significant differences in the development of behavioural cycles, the proportion of time spent in quiet cycles, or the amount of fetal breathing. None of the fetuses developed an abnormal heart rate pattern. We conclude that prenatal neurobehavioural development may continue apparently unimpaired in the presence of absent umbilical artery end-diastolic velocity of several weeks duration. Long term data of infant outcome are necessary before the clinical significance of this can be assessed.

The effect of maternal hyperoxia on behavioral activity in growth-retarded human fetuses

Thirteen pregnant women who subsequently were delivered of infants with birth weights less than the 3rd percentile were studied for examination of fetal heart rate and fetal activity patients during maternal administration of oxygen at a concentration of 50% or room air for 2 hours. None of the fetuses was acidotic at birth. Maternal transcutaneous PO2 levels increased from 79 +/- 3 mm Hg to 158 +/- 10 mm Hg for the 2 hours of observation. The results indicated that maternal hyperoxia produced sustained fetal breathing activity that was almost 100% higher than that in room air (analysis of variance, p = 0.024). Gross fetal body movements, fetal heart rate accelerations, and fetal heart rate variability increased significantly with increasing observation time (analysis of variance, p less than 0.01), but were not significantly altered by maternal hyperoxia or room air. We conclude that despite significant change in fetal breathing activity, ultrasonographic observation of fetal behavioral activity during maternal hyperoxia could not be used to differentiate severely growth-retarded from normally grown human fetuses. We speculate that altered fetal heart rate and fetal body movement patterns usually associated with intrauterine growth retardation might be related to altered development of the fetal central nervous system and are not reversible during prolonged maternal administration of oxygen.

Diagnosing handicap using the behaviour of the fetus

The study of fetal behaviour may have important implications for the prenatal diagnosis of handicap. Since behaviour reflects the integrity of the fetal neural system the examination of fetal behaviour enables neurological assessment of the fetus. This paper discusses present methods of assessing fetal well-being and their shortfalls and then considers current research using behaviour to identify the compromised fetus. Studies using both spontaneous and elicited fetal behaviour are discussed. The paper concludes that a greater understanding of fetal behaviour promises great advances in the antenatal detection of handicap or fetal compromise and may enable midwives to become more involved in the assessment of fetal well-being.