Evidence for a mechanical filter in the cochlea of the 'constant frequency' bats, Rhinolophus rouxi and Pteronotus parnellii

Correlating Cochlear Morphometrics from Parnell's Mustached Bat (Pteronotus parnellii) with Hearing

Morphometric analysis of the inner ear of mammals can provide information for cochlear frequency mapping, a species-specific designation of locations in the cochlea at which different sound frequencies are encoded. Morphometric variation occurs in the hair cells of the organ of Corti along the cochlea, with the base encoding the highest frequency sounds and the apex encoding the lowest frequencies. Changes in cell shape and spacing can yield additional information about the biophysical basis of cochlear tuning mechanisms. Here, we investigate how morphometric analysis of hair cells in mammals can be used to predict the relationship between frequency and cochlear location. We used linear and geometric morphometrics to analyze scanning electron micrographs of the hair cells of the cochleae in Parnell's mustached bat (Pteronotus parnellii) and Wistar rat (Rattus norvegicus) and determined a relationship between cochlear morphometrics and their frequency map. Sixteen of twenty-two of the morphometric parameters analyzed showed a significant change along the cochlea, including the distance between the rows of hair cells, outer hair cell width, and gap width between hair cells. A multiple linear regression model revealed that nine of these parameters are responsible for 86.9 % of the variation in these morphometric data. Determining the most biologically relevant measurements related to frequency detection can give us a greater understanding of the essential biomechanical characteristics for frequency selectivity during sound transduction in a diversity of animals.

Postnatal ontogeny of the cochlea and flight ability in Jamaican fruit bats (Phyllostomidae) with implications for the evolution of echolocation

Recent evidence has shown that the developmental emergence of echolocation calls in young bats follow an independent developmental pathway from other vocalizations and that adult-like echolocation call structure significantly precedes flight ability. These data in combination with new insights into the echolocation ability of some shrews suggest that the evolution of echolocation in bats may involve inheritance of a primitive sonar system that was modified to its current state, rather than the ad hoc evolution of echolocation in the earliest bats. Because the cochlea is crucial in the sensation of echoes returning from sonar pulses, we tracked changes in cochlear morphology during development that included the basilar membrane (BM) and secondary spiral lamina (SSL) along the length of the cochlea in relation to stages of flight ability in young bats. Our data show that the morphological prerequisite for sonar sensitivity of the cochlea significantly precedes the onset of flight in young bats and, in fact, development of this prerequisite is complete before parturition. In addition, there were no discernible changes in cochlear morphology with stages of flight development, demonstrating temporal asymmetry between the development of morphology associated with echo-pulse return sensitivity and volancy. These data further corroborate and support the hypothesis that adaptations for sonar and echolocation evolved before flight in mammals.

Different auditory feedback control for echolocation and communication in horseshoe bats

Auditory feedback from the animal's own voice is essential during bat echolocation: to optimize signal detection, bats continuously adjust various call parameters in response to changing echo signals. Auditory feedback seems also necessary for controlling many bat communication calls, although it remains unclear how auditory feedback control differs in echolocation and communication. We tackled this question by analyzing echolocation and communication in greater horseshoe bats, whose echolocation pulses are dominated by a constant frequency component that matches the frequency range they hear best. To maintain echoes within this “auditory fovea”, horseshoe bats constantly adjust their echolocation call frequency depending on the frequency of the returning echo signal. This Doppler-shift compensation (DSC) behavior represents one of the most precise forms of sensory-motor feedback known. We examined the variability of echolocation pulses emitted at rest (resting frequencies, RFs) and one type of communication signal which resembles an echolocation pulse but is much shorter (short constant frequency communication calls, SCFs) and produced only during social interactions. We found that while RFs varied from day to day, corroborating earlier studies in other constant frequency bats, SCF-frequencies remained unchanged. In addition, RFs overlapped for some bats whereas SCF-frequencies were always distinctly different. This indicates that auditory feedback during echolocation changed with varying RFs but remained constant or may have been absent during emission of SCF calls for communication. This fundamentally different feedback mechanism for echolocation and communication may have enabled these bats to use SCF calls for individual recognition whereas they adjusted RF calls to accommodate the daily shifts of their auditory fovea.

Effect of captivity and mineral supplementation on body composition and mineral status of mustached bats (Pteronotus parnellii rubiginosus)

We investigated the whole-body crude nutrient (fat, protein, ash) and mineral (Ca, P, Mg, Na, K) composition of mustached bats of three different groups: animals from the wild (n = 6), and animals from captivity on an unsupplemented feeding regime of mealworms (n = 7), and on a feeding regime in which the mealworms were kept on a mineral substrate prior to feeding (n = 6). It was shown that mealworms from the mineral substrate had higher Ca contents than mealworms from the conventional substrates. In an earlier study, differences in bone mineral density had been found between the groups. These differences, however, were not reflected in differences in whole-body composition. Captive animals showed a larger variation in body weight and fat content, indicating potential shortcomings of the dietary and husbandry regime.

Directionality of hearing in two CF/FM bats, Pteronotus parnellii and Rhinolophus rouxi

The head-related transfer function (HRTF) has been measured in two CF/FM bats, Pteronotus parnellii and Rhinolophus rouxi from 575 positions in the frontal hemisphere. P. parnellii showed an increase of the elevation angle of the axis of highest pinna gain with increasing frequency followed by a specific decrease at 75 kHz. Such a drop of elevation angle of the acoustic axis was not seen in R. rouxi. The HRTF further showed a spectral notch dependent on elevation and frequency in P. parnellii, but not in R. rouxi. The functional implications of this difference between both bat species are discussed. Frequencies at maximum pinna gain values did not clearly match the frequencies of the harmonics of the echolocation calls whereas spatial resolution of interaural intensity differences was best in a frequency range that included the higher harmonics of the echolocation calls in both bat species. However, specializations of HRTF patterns matching the exact frequencies of the harmonics of the echolocation calls could not be observed in both bat species.

Neurobiological specializations in echolocating bats

Although the bat's nervous system follows the general mammalian plan in both its structure and function, it has undergone a number of modifications associated with flight and echolocation. The most obvious neuroanatomical specializations are seen in the cochleas of certain species of bats and in the lower brainstem auditory pathways of all microchiroptera. This article is a review of peripheral and central auditory neuroanatomical specializations in echolocating bats. Findings show that although the structural features of the central nervous system of echolocating microchiropteran bats are basically the same as those of more generalized mammals, certain pathways, mainly those having to do with accurate processing of temporal information and auditory control of motor activity, are hypertrophied and/or organized somewhat differently from those same pathways in nonecholocating species. Through the resulting changes in strengths and timing of synaptic inputs to neurons in these pathways, bats have optimized the mechanisms for analysis of complex sound patterns to derive accurate information about objects in their environment and direct behavior toward those objects.

Evolutionary aspects of bat echolocation

This review is yet another attempt to explain how echolocation in bats or bat-like mammals came into existence. Attention is focused on neuronal specializations in the ascending auditory pathway of echolocating bats. Three different mechanisms are considered that may create a specific auditory sensitivity to echos: (1). time-windows of enhanced echo-processing opened by a corollary discharge of neuronal vocalization commands; (2). differentiation and expansion of ensembles of combination-sensitive neurons in the midbrain; and (3). corticofugal top-down modulations. The second part of the review interprets three different types of echolocation as adaptations to ecological niches, and presents the sophisticated cochlear specializations in constant-frequency/frequency-modulated bats as a case study of finely tuned differentiation. It is briefly discussed how a resonant mechanism in the inner ear of constant-frequency/frequency-modulated bats may have evolved in common mammalian cochlea.

What determines the tuning of hearing organs and the frequency of calls? A comparative study in the katydid genus Neoconocephalus (Orthoptera, Tettigoniidae)

The calls of five syntopic species of Neoconocephalus varied significantly in their spectral composition. The center-frequency of the narrow-band low-frequency component varied from 7 kHz to 15 kHz among the five species. Hearing thresholds, as determined from whole nerve recordings, did not vary accordingly among the five species but were lowest in the range from 16 kHz to 18 kHz in all five species. Iso-intensity response functions were flat for stimulus intensities up to 27 dB above threshold, indicating an even distribution of the best frequencies of individual receptor cells. At higher stimulus intensities, the intensity/response functions were steeper at frequencies above 35 kHz than at lower frequencies. This suggests the presence of a second receptor cell population for such high frequencies, with 25-30 dB higher thresholds. This receptor cell population is interpreted as an adaptation for bat avoidance. The transmission properties of the Neoconocephalus habitat (grassland) had low-pass characteristics for pure tones. Frequencies below 10 kHz passed almost unaffected, while attenuation in excess of spherical attenuation increased at higher frequencies. Considering these transmission properties and the tuning of female hearing sensitivity, call frequencies of approximately 9-10 kHz should be most effective as communication signals in this group of insects. It is discussed that the frequency of male calls is strongly influenced by bat predation and by the transmission properties of the habitat but is not strongly influenced by the tuning of the female hearing system.

Negative hair-bundle stiffness betrays a mechanism for mechanical amplification by the hair cell

Hearing and balance rely on the ability of hair cells in the inner ear to sense miniscule mechanical stimuli. In each cell, sound or acceleration deflects the mechanosensitive hair bundle, a tuft of rigid stereocilia protruding from the cell's apical surface. By altering the tension in gating springs linked to mechanically sensitive transduction channels, this deflection changes the channels' open probability and elicits an electrical response. To detect weak stimuli despite energy losses caused by viscous dissipation, a hair cell can use active hair-bundle movement to amplify its mechanical inputs. This amplificatory process also yields spontaneous bundle oscillations. Using a displacement-clamp system to measure the mechanical properties of individual hair bundles from the bullfrog's ear, we found that an oscillatory bundle displays negative slope stiffness at the heart of its region of mechanosensitivity. Offsetting the hair bundle's position activates an adaptation process that shifts the region of negative stiffness along the displacement axis. Modeling indicates that the interplay between negative bundle stiffness and the motor responsible for mechanical adaptation produces bundle oscillation similar to that observed. Just as the negative resistance of electrically excitable cells and of tunnel diodes can be embedded in a biasing circuit to amplify electrical signals, negative stiffness can be harnessed to amplify mechanical stimuli in the ear.

Frequency responses of two- and three-tone distortion product otoacoustic emissions in Mongolian gerbils

The frequency responses of distortion product otoacoustic emission (DPOAEs) were investigated in adult Mongolian gerbils. The main goal was to investigate in this species the extent to which DPOAE measurements might be useful in estimating cochlear frequency-tuning characteristics. Specifically, this study investigated the parameter space for generation of DPOAEs to determine those regions, if any, where the emission responses gave "simple" frequency responses, i.e., responses similar in form to typical neural responses. At the same time, it was desired to determine in this species the existence, extent, and nature of the more complex three-tone emission frequency responses as observed in some other species [e.g., Martin et al., Hearing Res. 136, 105-123 (1999)]. In the present work, two-tone frequency response curves (f2/f1 ratio functions) were obtained by varying the lower frequency, f1, while holding the f2 frequency and both amplitudes (L1, L2) constant. Only for frequencies, f2, near 8 kHz did the response at the emission frequency, 2 f1-f2, form a simple, relatively broad peak. At all lower frequencies, the two-tone frequency response curve was typically complex and composed of multiple peaks. In comparison, three-tone frequency responses were constructed by fixing the primary stimulus pair (f1, f2) and varying a third tone widely in frequency (f3) and intensity (L3). Points in f3 and L3 which caused a criterion reduction in primary emission amplitude (at 2 f1-f2) were used to construct emission suppression tuning curves (STCs). Only for primary frequencies, f2, at 8 kHz and above were the emission STCs found to be simple, with shapes similar to neural frequency-tuning curves. At lower primary frequencies, particularly for relatively low primary frequency ratios (low f2/f1), three-tone responses were very complex. This complex response usually included a region of anomalous suppression in which very low suppression levels (L3) could result in significant decreases in the primary emission amplitude, often exceeding 12 dB. Regions of such anomalous suppression were typically observed under the following conditions: (1) for all f2 frequencies from 0.5 to 4 kHz; (2) for f3 frequencies between 1.4 and 8 kHz; (3) i.e., for f3 frequencies 1-3 octaves above the primary frequency, f2; (4) at L3 levels often 10 dB lower or more than the usual "best frequency" threshold, i.e., even lower than the relative minimum threshold found near the primary stimulus frequencies; (5) exhibiting sharp amplitude decreases often accompanied by emission phase shifts of about 180 deg; (6) present in both cubic emissions (2 f1-f2 and 2 f2-f1); (7) to be less extreme at larger primary stimulus frequency ratios (larger f2/f1); and (8) less extreme at larger intensity ratios (larger L1/L2). Because of the anomalous behavior at f2 frequencies below 8 kHz, "simple" emission STCs were typically only obtainable, if at all, near the extreme boundaries of the parameter space giving measurable emission amplitudes.

Interpretation of distortion product otoacoustic emission measurements. I. Two stimulus tones

The interpretation of common but poorly understood observed characteristics of distortion product emissions is assisted by the development of a simple model. This model essentially includes only saturation of the cochlear amplifier, with emissions arising naturally from the same nonlinear processes which cause the saturation. The model provides useful physical explanations of emission behaviour, particularly considered as a function of the stimulus intensities of the two primaries, i.e., behavior with fixed stimulus frequencies. It is assumed that emission generation consists of two main components which are always present in the total emission, but which most often have approximately opposite, i.e., canceling, phases. One component arises in a small region centered about the peak of the emission generation function, while the other arises from the region basal to this peak. At low stimulus levels with normal cochlear amplifier operation, the peak of the emission generation function is sharp, so the emission from the peak region dominates the total emission. This "peak" emission has typically been characterized as the "active" emission. At high stimulus levels where saturation is important, or at all levels when the gain of the cochlear amplifier is reduced, the summed "basal" component dominates the total emission. The characteristics of this basal emission are similar to, and continuous with, the characteristics of the truly "passive" emission, i.e., the emission observed when the cochlear amplifier gain is identically zero. Under circumstances when the emissions from the peak and basal components are approximately equal, there is seen a sharp "notch" characteristic of phase cancellation. The simple model produces emission distributions as a function of independent variation of the two stimulus amplitudes which are in good agreement with observation. It is shown that the furosemide assay provides a good estimate of cochlear amplifier gain when a correction factor of about 10 dB is added. However, when using two stimulus tones, neither absolute emission amplitudes, or emission input-output functions, or the furosemide assay can adequately distinguish between cases of moderate versus poor cochlear amplifier dysfunction when the cochlear amplifier gains are in the range from about half normal to zero.

Further studies on the mechanics of the cochlear partition in the mustached bat. I. Ultrastructural observations on the tectorial membrane and its attachments

From semithin and ultrathin sections of the mustached bat cochlea, baso-apical gradients in ultrastructural composition, shape and attachment site of the tectorial membrane (TM) were determined in relation to gradients in hair cell size and stereocilia size. These provide a data base for estimates of the mechanical properties of the organ of Corti as they relate to specialized aspects of the cochlear frequency map (Kössl and Vater, 1996). As in other mammals, the TM is composed to type A and type B protofibrils. Measurements of the packing density of type A protofibrils reveal gradients in both the radial and longitudinal direction. Distinct variations in packing density of type A protofibrils across the radial extent of the TM allow the definition of more subregions than in other mammals. Throughout the cochlea, packing density is highest in the 'stripe' region located close to the spiral limbus. The centrally located 'core' region of the middle zone contains distinctly fewer type A protofibrils than the laterally located 'mantle' region of the middle zone. The TM in the specialized basal turn (first and second half-turns) features a higher packing density of type A protofibrils in the 'mantle' than the TM in the apical cochlea (upper third to fifth half-turns), and in incorporation of longitudinally directed type A protofibrils in the marginal zone. Among cochlear turns, there are pronounced changes in cross-sectional area of the TM and the extent of its limbal attachment site. Within the densely innervated second half-turn that contains an expanded representation of the 60 kHz constant frequency (CF) component of the echolocation signal, both the cross-sectional area (see also Henson and Henson, 1991) and the attachment site of the TM are enlarged. An extended limbal attachment site is also observed in the densely innervated region of the lower first half-turn that represents the upper harmonics of the call. Within the sparsely innervated region of the upper first half-turn, the limbal attachment site of the TM is significantly diminished. Size of outer hair cells (OHC) ranges between 12 and 13 microns throughout the basal 80% of cochlear length and reaches maximal values of 20 microns in the apex. Size of OHC stereocilia ranges between 0.7 and 0.8 microns throughout the basal 60% of cochlear length and reaches a maximal size of 2.2 microns in the apex. These data corroborate and extend previous notions that morphological specializations of the TM in concert with specializations of the basilar membrane and perilymphatic spaces play an integral role in creating specialized cochlear tuning in the mustached bat.

Further studies on the mechanics of the cochlear partition in the mustached bat. II. A second cochlear frequency map derived from acoustic distortion products

It has been proposed that acoustic 2f1-f2 distortions reflect the frequency characteristics of a secondary cochlear filter mechanism (Brown et al., 1992; Allen and Fahey, 1993). This concept was used to construct a second cochlear frequency map that may represent aspects of tectorial membrane (TM) tuning. Within the frequency range of 15-105 kHz, for a given f2 frequency, f1 was varied and the frequency ratio f2/f1 determined that produced maximum levels of the 2f1-f2 distortion (best ratio). The second cochlear frequency map was derived by plotting the distortion frequency that corresponded to the best ratio f2/f1 against the cochlear place of f2 which was obtained from the HRP-frequency map of Pteronotus (Kössl and Vater, 1985b). Minimum best ratios of 1.0005 and hence practically identical characteristic frequencies of the putative tuning of basilar membrane (HRP) and TM (2f1-f2) were found at about 45% distance from the base, a point at which 62 kHz are represented on the BM. This frequency is associated with strong cochlear resonance and large evoked and spontaneous otoacoustic emissions. Between 45% and 20% distance from the base, the basilar membrane (BM) tuning progressively increases to about 70 kHz whereas the calculated TM tuning remains constant at a frequency close to 62 kHz. The range of constant TM tuning coincides with the sparsely innervated cochlear region of Pteronotus where BM thickness is maximal and TM mass and limbal attachment are reduced (Vater and Kössl, 1996). We suggest that here the TM oscillates strongly at 62 kHz and may carry most of the energy of cochlear resonance which is transferred into movement of the organ of Corti at and apical to the 45% location where the BM is tuned to 62 kHz.

The cochlea of Tadarida brasiliensis: specialized functional organization in a generalized bat

Tadarida brasiliensis mexicana employs a broad-band sonar system at frequencies between 80 and 20 kHz and is characterized by non-specialized hearing capabilities. The cochlear frequency map was determined with extracellular horseradish peroxidase tracing in relation to quantitative morphological data obtained with light, scanning and transmission electron microscopy. These data reveal distinct species characteristic specializations clearly separate from the patterns observed in other bats with either broad-band or narrow-band sonar systems. The basilar membrane (BM) is coiled to 2.5 turns and about 12 mm long. Its thickness and width only change within the extreme basal and apical ends. The frequency range from about 30 to 80 kHz is represented in the lower basal turn with a typically mammalian mapping coefficient of about 3 mm/octave. This region exhibits morphological features correlated with non-specialized processing of high frequencies. (1) The BM is radially segmented by thickenings of pars tecta and pars pectinata. (2) The 3 rows of outer hair cells (OHCs) have similar morphology. Between 35 and 86% distance from base, frequencies between 30 and 12 kHz are represented with a slightly expanded mapping coefficient of about 6 mm/octave. In analogy to previous work, this cochlea region is termed acoustic fovea. It includes the frequency range of maximum sensitivity and sharpest tuning (21-27 kHz) but also frequencies below the sonar signals. The fovea is characterized by several morphological specializations. (1) The BM features a continuous radial thickening mainly composed of hyaline substance. (2) There is an increased number of layers of tension fibroblasts in the spiral ligament. (3) There are morphological differences in the arrangements of stereocilia bundles among the 3 rows of OHCs. The transitions between non-specialized and specialized cochlear regions occur gradually within a distance of about 600 microns. The gradients in stereocilia length of both receptor cell types and the gradations in length of the OHC bodies match specialized aspects of the frequency map.

The effect of contralateral stimulation on cochlear resonance and damping in the mustached bat: the role of the medial efferent system

In the unanesthetized mustached bat, stimulation of the ear with an acoustic transient produces damped oscillations which are evident in the cochlear microphonic potential. In this report we demonstrate how the decay time of these oscillations is affected by broadband noise presented to the contralateral ear (CLN). In the absence of CLN, the mean decay time was 1.94 +/- 0.23 ms, but during the presentation of CLN the decay time consistently decreased. The changes were finely graded, the higher the CLN, the greater the change. The effect could be maintained at a constant level for extended periods of time and this was evident when the CLN exceeded 40 dB SPL. The latency of the reflex for 64 dB noise was about 11 ms and near maximum changes occurred within 15 ms of CLN onset. Sectioning medial efferent nerve fibers in the floor of the fourth ventricle or the administration of a single dose of gentamicin eliminated changes produced by CLN. The prominence of CM responses to damped oscillations and the robust changes in response to CLN make the mustached bat an excellent model for studying the influence of the medial efferent system on cochlear mechanics.

The shape of 2f1-f2 suppression tuning curves reflects basilar membrane specializations in the mustached bat, Pteronotus parnellii

Iso-suppression tuning curves (STCs) of the 2f1-f2 distortion product (dp) were measured over a primary frequency range of 20 to 93 kHz in mustached bats, Pteronotus parnellii parnellii. Primary levels were chosen to produce dp levels between 0 and 7 dB SPL. At frequencies outside the ranges of 60-72 kHz and 90-93 kHz the shapes of the STCs were symmetrical or asymmetrical with a steep high frequency slope. In the vicinity of 61 kHz where a strong stimulus frequency otoacoustic emission (SFOAE) is present, the asymmetry of the STCs was inverted with a very steep low frequency slope (max. -89 dB/kHz) and a shallow high frequency slope. The inverted STCs resemble neuronal tuning curves of the same species with best frequencies at about 61 kHz. Close to 61 kHz the STCs were sharply tuned with Q10dB values up to 177. The STC-thresholds were about 20 dB above the neuronal thresholds. Thickenings of the basilar membrane located just basal to the cochlear place of the SFOAE frequency are probably involved in creating the asymmetric STCs. Cochlear resonance at the SFOAE frequency and an increased longitudinal coupling within the thickened basilar membrane region are thought to contribute to the specialized STC shape. In the range of 90-93 kHz, the STCs are also sharply tuned with inverted asymmetry which is probably not due to an harmonic effect of the specialized cochlear mechanics in the 60 kHz region but may be caused by an independent mechanism.

Otoacoustic emissions from the cochlea of the 'constant frequency' bats, Pteronotus parnellii and Rhinolophus rouxi

During stimulation with continuous pure tones, the cochlea of each individual of the mustached bat, Pteronotus parnellii, produces a strong evoked stimulus-frequency otoacoustic emission (SFOAE) at about 62 kHz. The SFOAEs were on average 480 Hz above the dominant constant frequency component of the echolocation call (resting frequency, RF). In two out of nine individuals of Pteronotus the SFOAEs changed into spontaneous otoacoustic emissions of 25-40 dB SPL. In the rufuous horseshoe bat, Rhinolophus rouxi spontaneous emissions were not detected and only in two out of seven animals were there weak SFOAEs about 300 Hz above the RF of 78 kHz. This difference may be due to a stronger damping of underlying resonant processes in Rhinolophus (Henson et al., 1985a). Acoustic distortion products behaved quite similar in both species. The first lower sideband distortion 2f1-f2 was measurable over a wide frequency range between 10 and 100 kHz. The optimum frequency separation delta f of the two primary tones to evoke maximum 2f1-f2 distortion was 0.8 to 5.8 kHz in Pteronotus and 1 to 7 kHz in Rhinolophus for frequencies outside the range of the constant frequency components of the call. This corresponds to ratios f2/f1 of about 1.03 to 1.2. At the frequency of the SFOAE in Pteronotus (480 Hz above the RF) and about 300 Hz above the RF in Rhinolophus the optimum delta f decreased sharply to values of 31-63 Hz in Pteronotus (ratio f2/f1 of 1.0005-1.001), and to 39-590 Hz in Rhinolophus (ratio f2/f1 of 1.0005-1.007). In Pteronotus a second minimum of delta f was found at about 90 kHz (values of 180-620 Hz, ratios f2/f1 of 1.002-1.007). In both bat species, the respective minima of delta f are located at or close to frequencies where neuronal tuning sharpness is exceptionally high. This indicates a mechanical origin of enhanced tuning. After adjusting the frequency of f2 to match the optimum delta fs, 2f1-f2 threshold curves were obtained. The distortion product threshold approximately parallels neuronal data and is in both species characterized by a pronounced insensitivity at the RF followed by a steep threshold minimum at frequencies 0.3-3 kHz above the RF. These features may be involved in reducing the cochlear response to the call such that the bats are able to focus on the Doppler-shifted echos which are slightly higher in frequency and thus within the range of the threshold minimum.