Intraoperative duplex sonography during renal artery reconstruction

Revascularization for Renovascular Disease: A Scientific Statement From the American Heart Association

Renovascular disease is a major causal factor for secondary hypertension and renal ischemic disease. However, several prospective, randomized trials for atherosclerotic disease failed to demonstrate that renal revascularization is more effective than medical therapy for most patients. These results have greatly reduced the generalized diagnostic workup and use of renal revascularization. Most guidelines and review articles emphasize the limited average improvement and fail to identify those clinical populations that do benefit from revascularization. On the basis of the clinical experience of hypertension centers, specialists have continued selective revascularization, albeit without a summary statement by a major, multidisciplinary, national organization that identifies specific populations that may benefit. In this scientific statement for health care professionals and the public-at-large, we review the strengths and weaknesses of randomized trials in revascularization and highlight (1) when referral for consideration of diagnostic workup and therapy may be warranted, (2) the evidence/rationale for these selective scenarios, (3) interventional and surgical techniques for effective revascularization, and (4) areas of research with unmet need.

Early duplex predicts restenosis after renal artery angioplasty and stenting

OBJECTIVE

To examine the relationship between early renal duplex sonography (RDS) and restenosis after primary renal artery percutaneous angioplasty and stenting (RA-PTAS).

METHODS

Consecutive patients undergoing RA-PTAS for hemodynamically significant atherosclerotic renal artery stenosis with hypertension and/or ischemic nephropathy between September 2003 and July 2010 were identified from a prospective registry. Patients had renal RDS pre-RA-PTAS, within 1 week of RA-PTAS and follow-up RDS examinations after the first postoperative week for surveillance of restenosis. Restenosis was defined as a renal artery peak systolic velocity (PSV) ≥ 180 cm/s on follow-up RDS. Associations between RDS and restenosis were examined using proportional hazards regression.

RESULTS

Eighty-three patients (59% female; 12% nonwhite; mean age, 70 ± 10 years; mean pre-RA-PTAS PSV, 276 ± 107 cm/s) undergoing 91 RA-PTAS procedures comprised the sample for this study. All procedures included a completion arteriogram demonstrating no significant residual stenosis. Mean follow-up time was 14.9 ± 10.8 months. Thirty-four renal arteries (RAs) demonstrated restenosis on follow-up with a median time to restenosis of 8.7 months. There was no significant difference in the mean PSV pre-RA-PTAS in those with and without restenosis (287 ± 96 cm/s vs 269 ± 113 cm/s; P = .455), and PSV pre-RA-PTAS was not predictive of restenosis. Within 1 week of RA-PTAS, mean renal artery PSV differed significantly for renal arteries with and without restenosis (112 ± 27 cm/s vs 91 ± 34 cm/s; P = .003). Proportional hazards regression analysis demonstrated increased PSV on first post-RA-PTAS RDS was significantly and independently associated with subsequent restenosis during follow-up (hazard ratio for 30 cm/s increase, 1.81; 95% confidence interval, 1.32-2.49; P = .0003). There was no difference in pre- minus postprocedural PSV in those with and without restenosis on follow-up (175 ± 104 cm/s vs 179 ± 124 cm/s; P = .88), nor was this associated with time to restenosis. Best subsets model selection identified first postprocedural RDS as the only factor predictive of follow-up restenosis. A receiver-operating characteristic curve was examined to assess the first week PSV post-RA-PTAS most predictive of restenosis during follow-up. The ideal cut point for RA-PSV was 87 cm/s or greater. This value was associated with a sensitivity of 82.4%, specificity of 52.6%, and area under the receiver-operating characteristic curve of 69.3%. Increased first postprocedural RA-PSV was predictive of lower estimated glomerular filtration rate in the first 2 years after the procedure (-1.6 ± 0.7 mL/min/1.73 m(2) lower estimated glomerular filtration rate per 10 cm/s increase in RA-PSV; P = .010).

CONCLUSIONS

Early renal artery PSV within 1 week after RA-PTAS predicted renal artery restenosis and lower postprocedure renal function. Recurrent stenosis demonstrated no association with absolute elevation in PSV prior to RA-PTAS nor with the change in PSV after RA-PTAS. These data suggest that detectable differences exist in renal artery flow parameters following RA-PTAS that are predictive of restenosis during follow-up but are not apparent on completion arteriography or detectable by intra-arterial pressure measurements. Further study is warranted.

Branch renal artery repair with cold perfusion protection

PURPOSE

This retrospective review describes the use and clinical outcome of cold perfusion protection during branch renal artery (RA) repair in 77 consecutive patients.

METHODS

From July 1987 through November 2006, 874 patients had open operative RA repair to 1312 kidneys. Seventy-seven patients (62 women, 15 men; mean age, 44 +/- 17 years) had branch RA reconstruction using ex vivo or in situ cold perfusion protection for 78 kidneys. Demographic data and surgical technique were examined. Blood pressure response and renal function were estimated. Patency of repair was determined by angiography and renal duplex ultrasound (RDUS) imaging. Primary RA patency was estimated by life-table methods.

RESULTS

Seventy-eight RAs were repaired using ex vivo (49 kidneys) or in situ (29 kidneys) cold perfusion protection. Bilateral RA repair was performed in eight patients, with 13 repairs to solitary kidneys. RA disease included aneurysm (RAA) in 50, fibromuscular dysplasia (FMD) in 37, atherosclerosis in 5, and arteritis in 2; 16 patients had both FMD and RAA. Hypertension was present in 93.5% (mean blood pressure, 184 +/- 35/107 +/- 19 mm Hg; mean of 1.9 +/- 1.1 drugs). RA repair included bypass using saphenous vein in 69, hypogastric artery in 3, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) in 2, composite vein/PTFE in 2, cephalic vein in 1, or aneurysmorrhaphy in 1. The eight bilateral RA repairs were staged. One patient required bilateral cold perfusion protection. One planned nephrectomy was performed at the time of contralateral ex vivo reconstruction. No primary nephrectomies were required for intended reconstruction. Each RA reconstruction required branch dissection and reconstruction (mean of 2.8 +/- 1.6 branches were repaired). Mean cold ischemia time was 125 +/- 40 minutes. Each kidney was reconstructed in an orthotopic fashion. Five early failures of repair required three nephrectomies and one operative revision. Based on postoperative angiography or RDUS, or both, primary patency of RA repair at 12 months was 85% +/- 5%; assisted primary patency was 93% +/- 4%. Among patients with preoperative hypertension, 15% were cured, 65% were improved, and 20% were considered failed. Early renal function was improved in 35%, unchanged in 48%, and worse in 17%. Four patients had perioperative acute tubular necrosis. No patient progressed to dialysis-dependence.

CONCLUSION

Both ex vivo and in situ cold perfusion protection extend the safe renal ischemia time for complex branch RA repair and avoid the need for nephrectomy.

Renovascular disease in children and adolescents

PURPOSE

This retrospective review describes the surgical management of renovascular disease in 25 consecutive children and adolescents with severe hypertension.

METHODS

Patients </=21 years of age (mean age, 11.6 +/- 5.4 years; 12 females, 13 males) underwent repair of 34 renal arteries (RAs), and their management forms the basis of this report. Early and late blood pressure responses were adjusted for gender, age, and height. RA repair was evaluated by angiography, renal duplex sonography (RDS) scanning, or both. Primary patency and survival were estimated by product-limit methods.

RESULTS

Thirty-four RAs among 32 kidneys were repaired. Bilateral renal RA disease to a solitary kidney was present in nine patients. RA lesions included dysplasia (44%), RA hypoplasia (20%), midaortic syndrome (12%), RA aneurysm (12%), dissection (8%), and arteritis (4%). All patients had severe hypertension (>95 th percentile systolic or diastolic pressure adjusted for gender, age, and height). RA repair comprised 25 bypasses (73%) consisting of 28% saphenous vein, 60% hypogastric artery, and 12% polytetrafluoroethylene; 2 patch angioplasties (6%), and 7 reimplantations (21%). Branch RA exposure was required in 28 kidneys (88%), and branch reconstruction was required in 61%. Warm in situ repair was used in 53%, in situ cold perfusion in 24%, and ex vivo cold perfusion in 23%. Of six bilateral RA repairs, one was staged and two patients are awaiting a staged repair. Combined aortic reconstruction was required in three patients. No unplanned nephrectomy was performed. There were no perioperative deaths. Hypertension was cured in 36%, improved in 56%, and failed in 8% at mean follow-up of 46.4 +/- 7.8 months. The mean calculated glomerular filtration rate increased from 82.0 mL/min/1.73 m 2 preoperatively to 98.2 mL/min/1.73 m 2 postoperatively. The postoperative patency of 30 RA reconstructions was evaluated by angiography, RDS scanning, or both. At mean follow-up of 32.8 months (median, 21.2 months), primary RA patency was 91%. No failures were observed after 2 months follow-up. Estimated survival was 100% at 60 months, with one death 9 years after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Renovascular hypertension in children and adolescents was caused by a heterogeneous group of lesions. All patients had RA repair, with arterial autografts in most of the RA bypasses. Cold perfusion preservation was used in half of the complex branch RA repairs. These strategies provided 91% primary patency at mean follow-up of 32.8 months, with beneficial blood pressure response in 92%. Surgical repair of clinically significant renovascular disease in children and adolescents is supported by these results.

Intraoperative duplex ultrasound of visceral revascularizations: optimizing technical success and outcome

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the use of intraoperative duplex ultrasound scanning (IOUS) during visceral revascularizations and correlate its results with clinical outcome.

METHODS

We studied 68 patients (15 men and 53 women, mean age 66.5 years, range 27-86 years) who underwent visceral revascularization with concomitant IOUS examination of 120 visceral arteries (52 celiac, 60 superior mesenteric, and 8 inferior mesenteric arteries) from 1992 to 2002. Patients were divided into two groups on the basis of ultrasound findings: normal and abnormal IOUS. The incidence of early and late graft-related complications (thrombosis, restenosis, recurrent symptoms, reintervention) and graft-related death was compared in both groups.

RESULTS

One-hundred and two (85%) arteries had normal IOUS. Eight (6.6%) arteries had minor defects, including small kinks (4), mild residual stenoses (3), and small intimal flap (1). Ten (8.4%) arteries had major defects, consisting of hemodynamically significant residual stenoses (4), thrombus (2), kinks (2), bidirectional flow (1), and intimal flap (1). Major defects were successfully revised in all except three cases: two persistent mild stenoses and one bidirectional flow. Patients with abnormal IOUS at the end of the operation had increased incidence of graft-related complications and/or death (55.5% vs 7.8%; P =.004), early graft thrombosis (14.2% vs 1.0; P =.04), reintervention (21.4% vs 3.2%; P =.03), and graft-related death (33.3% vs 1.9%; P =.02), compared with patients with normal IOUS.

CONCLUSION

This study supports the routine use of IOUS during visceral revascularizations to optimize technical success and outcome. Persistent ultrasound scanning abnormalities are associated with risk of early graft failure, reintervention, and death. Patients with normal ultrasound scans can expect excellent results.

Guidelines for the Reporting of Renal Artery Revascularization in Clinical Trials

Although the treatment of atherosclerotic renal artery stenosis with use of percutaneous angioplasty, stent placement, and surgical revascularization has gained widespread use, there exist few prospective randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing these techniques to each other or against the standard of medical management alone. To facilitate this process as well as help answer many important questions regarding the appropriate application of renal revascularization, well-designed and rigorously conducted trials are needed. These trials must have clearly defined goals and must be sufficiently sized and performed so as to withstand intensive outcomes assessment. Toward this end, this document provides guidelines and definitions for the design, conduct, evaluation, and reporting of renal artery revascularization RCTs. In addition, areas of critically necessary renal artery revascularization investigation are identified. It is hoped that this information will be valuable to the investigator wishing to conduct research in this important area.

Guidelines for the reporting of renal artery revascularization in clinical trials

Although the treatment of atherosclerotic renal artery stenosis with use of percutaneous angioplasty, stent placement, and surgical revascularization has gained widespread use, there exist few prospective randomized controlled trials (RCTs) comparing these techniques to each other or against the standard of medical management alone. To facilitate this process as well as help answer many important questions regarding the appropriate application of renal revascularization, well-designed and rigorously conducted trials are needed. These trials must have clearly defined goals and must be sufficiently sized and performed so as to withstand intensive outcomes assessment. Toward this end, this document provides guidelines and definitions for the design, conduct, evaluation, and reporting of renal artery revascularization RCTs. In addition, areas of critically necessary renal artery revascularization investigation are identified. It is hoped that this information will be valuable to the investigator wishing to conduct research in this important area.

Intraoperative renal duplex sonography: a valuable method for evaluating renal artery reconstructions

OBJECTIVES

to determine the ability of duplex sonography to intraoperatively detect technical problems with renal artery reconstructions.

DESIGN

retrospective evaluation of a standard protocol.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

the outcome of intraoperative duplex was compared with postoperative angiography, surface duplex, MRA, echo or direct inspection in case of re-exploration in 77 renal artery reconstructions in 62 patients. These included six extracorporeal reconstructions, eight and 17 reconstructions with an artery and autogenous vein respectively, 10 renal artery re-implantations in the aorta (prosthesis), 32 endarterectomies and four reconstructions of kidney transplant vessels.

RESULTS

intraoperative duplex was normal in 67/73 reconstructions with sufficient data. In six cases technical problems were revealed by intraoperative duplex and the reconstruction was re-explored. After re-exploration intraoperative duplex was normal in all cases. Confirmatory studies demonstrated normal results in 61/64 reconstructions with normal intraoperative duplex and abnormal results in 6/6 reconstructions with technical problems revealed by intraoperative duplex. Three reconstructions with normal intraoperative duplex occluded as demonstrated by angiography less than 2 weeks after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

renal duplex sonography is a valuable method available for intraoperative detection of technical problems. Haemodynamic duplex data were less important than B-mode imaging in discriminating between normal and abnormal reconstruction.

Management of ischemic nephropathy: dialysis-free survival after surgical repair

PURPOSE

This retrospective review describes the surgical management of consecutive patients with severe hypertension and ischemic nephropathy due to atherosclerotic renovascular disease.

METHODS

From January 1987 through December 1998, a total of 590 patients underwent operative renal artery repair at our center. A subgroup of 232 hypertensive patients (97 women, 135 men; mean age, 66 +/- 8 years) with atherosclerotic renovascular disease and preoperative serum creatinine levels of 1.8 mg/dL or more forms the basis of this report. Change in renal function was determined from glomerular filtration rates estimated from preoperative and postoperative serum creatinine. The influence of selected preoperative parameters and renal function response on time to dialysis and dialysis-free survival was determined by a proportional hazards regression model.

RESULTS

In all, 83 patients underwent unilateral renal artery repair and 149 patients underwent bilateral repair, including repair to a solitary kidney in 17 cases. A total of 332 renal arteries were reconstructed, and 32 nephrectomies were performed in these patients. After surgery, there were 17 deaths (7.3%) in the hospital or within 30 days of surgery. Advanced patient age (P =.001; hazard ratio, 1.1; 95% CI [1.1, 1.2]) and congestive heart failure (P =.04; hazard ratio, 2.9 CI [1.0, 8.6]) demonstrated significant and independent associations with perioperative mortality. With a change of 20% or more in EGFR being considered significant, 58% of patients had improved renal function, including 27 patients removed from dialysis dependence; function was unchanged in 35% and worsened in 7%. Follow-up death from all causes or progression to dialysis dependence demonstrated a significant and independent association with early renal function response. Both patients whose function was unchanged (P =.005; hazard ratio, 6.0; CI [2.2, 16.6]) and patients whose function was worsened (P =.03; hazard ratio, 2.2; CI [1.1, 4. 5]) remained at increased risk of death or dialysis dependence. For patients with unchanged renal function after operation, risk of death or dialysis demonstrated a significant interaction with preoperative renal function. In addition to severe preoperative renal dysfunction, diabetes mellitus demonstrated a significant and independent association with follow-up death or dialysis.

CONCLUSION

Surgical correction of atherosclerotic renovascular disease can retrieve excretory renal function in selected hypertensive patients with ischemic nephropathy. Patients with improved renal function had a significant and independent increase in dialysis-free survival in comparison with patients whose function was unchanged and patients whose function was worsened after operation. These results add further evidence in support of a prospective, randomized trial designed to define the value of renal artery intervention in patients with ischemic nephropathy.

Intraoperative duplex monitoring of infrainguinal vein bypass procedures

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate intraoperative duplex scanning of infrainguinal vein bypass grafts to detect technical and hemodynamic problems, monitor their repair, and correlate findings with the incidence of thrombosis and stenosis repair rates within 90 days of operation.

METHODS

Color duplex scanning was used at operation to assess vein/anastomotic patency and velocity spectra waveforms of 626 infrainguinal vein bypass grafts (in situ saphenous, 228 grafts; nonreversed translocated saphenous, 170 grafts; reversed saphenous, 147 grafts; alternative [arm, lesser saphenous], 81 grafts) to the popliteal (n = 267 grafts), infrageniculate (n = 323 grafts), or pedal artery (n = 36 grafts). The entire bypass graft was scanned after intragraft injection of papaverine hydrochloride (30-60 mg) to augment graft flow. Vein/anastomotic/artery segments with velocity spectra that indicate highly disturbed flow (peak systolic velocity, >180 cm/sec; spectral broadening; velocity ratio at site, >3) were revised. Grafts with a low peak systolic velocity less than 30 to 40 cm/s and high outflow resistance (absent diastolic flow) underwent procedures (distal arteriovenous fistula, sequential bypass grafting) to augment flow; if this was not possible, the grafts were treated with an antithrombotic regimen, including heparin, dextran, and antiplatelet therapy.

RESULTS

Duplex scanning prompted revision of 104 lesions in 96 (15%) bypass grafts, including 82 vein/anastomotic stenoses, 17 vein segments with platelet thrombus, and 5 low-flow grafts. Revision rate was highest (P <.01) for alternative vein bypass grafts (27%) compared with the other grafting methods (reversed vein bypass grafts, 10%; nonreversed translocated, 13%; in situ, 16%). A normal intraoperative scan on initial imaging (n = 464 scans) or after revision (n = 67 scans) was associated with a 30-day thrombosis rate of 0.2% and a revision rate of 0.8% for duplex-detected stenosis (peak systolic velocity, >300 cm/s; velocity ratio, >3.5). By comparison, 20 of 95 bypass grafts (21%) with a residual (n = 29 grafts) or unrepaired duplex stenosis (n = 53 grafts) or low flow (n = 13 grafts) had a corrective procedure for graft thrombosis (n = eight grafts) or stenosis (n = 12 grafts; P <.001). Overall, 8% of patients with bypass grafts underwent a corrective procedure within 90 days of operation. Secondary graft patency was 99.4% at 30 days and 98.8% at 90 days (eight graft failures).

CONCLUSION

The observed 15% intraoperative revision rate coupled with a low 90-day failure/revision rate (2.5%) for bypasses with normal papaverine-augmented duplex scans supports the routine use of this diagnostic modality to enhance the precision and early results of infrainguinal vein bypass procedures.

Surgery after failed percutaneous renal artery angioplasty

PURPOSE

This retrospective review describes the surgical management of 51 patients after failed percutaneous renal artery angioplasty (F-PTRA).

METHODS

From January 1987 through June 1998, 51 consecutive patients underwent surgical repair of either atherosclerotic (32 patients) or fibromuscular dysplastic (FMD; 19 patients) renovascular vascular disease after F-PTRA. These patients form the basis of this report. Surgical repair was performed for hypertension (29 patients with atherosclerosis: mean blood pressure, 205 +/- 34/110 +/- 23 mm Hg; 18 patients with FMD: mean blood pressure, 194 +/- 24/118 +/- 18 mm Hg) or ischemic nephropathy (20 patients with atherosclerosis: mean serum creatinine level, 2.0 +/- 0.8 mg/dL; three patients with FMD: mean serum creatinine level, 2.0 +/- 1.1 mg/dL). Emergency operation was required in four patients for acute renal artery thrombosis (one patient with atherosclerosis, one patient with FMD), renal artery rupture (one patient with atherosclerosis), or infected pseudoaneurysm (one patient with atherosclerosis). Operative management, blood pressure and renal function response to operation, and dialysis-free survival rate were examined and compared with 487 patients (441 patients with atherosclerosis, 46 patients with FMD) treated by operation alone.

RESULTS

Among the patients with atherosclerotic renovascular disease, there were three postoperative deaths (9.4%) after repair for F-PTRA. Secondary operative repair was associated with emergent repair or nephrectomy in 16% of cases, while more extensive renal artery exposure and more complex operative management was required in 50% of patients with atherosclerosis and 65% of patients with FMD repaired electively. Among the 28 operative survivors with hypertension and atherosclerotic renovascular disease, blood pressure benefit after F-PTRA was significantly lower when compared with patients with atherosclerosis who underwent treatment with operation only (57% vs 89%; P <.001). However, blood pressure benefit in the 19 patients with FMD did not differ (89% vs 96%). Among the 28 patients with atherosclerosis, preoperative estimated glomerular filtration rate (EGFR) as compared with postoperative EGFR was significantly increased (47.4 +/- 4.2 mL/min/1.73m(2) vs 56. 6 +/- 5.1 mL/min/1.73m(2); P =.002). However, EGFR prior to PTRA was not significantly different from postoperative EGFR (51.6 +/- 3.4 mL/min/1.73m(2) vs 56.6 +/- 4.9 mL/min/1.73m(2); P =.121). As compared with patients with atherosclerosis who underwent treatment with operation alone, there was no difference in the dialysis-free survival rate.

CONCLUSION

Operative repair after F-PTRA was altered in 59% of the patients with atherosclerosis and in 68% of patients with FMD. Blood pressure benefit for patients with FMD was unchanged after F-PTRA. However, the blood pressure benefit was significantly decreased among patients with atherosclerosis. Decreased EGFR after F-PTRA was recovered with operative renal artery repair. However, postoperative EGFR as compared with EGFR prior to PTRA was unchanged. Blood pressure and renal function response after F-PTRA for atherosclerotic renovascular disease warrants further study.

Intraoperative color duplex sonography of basal arteries during aneurysm surgery

This prospective study aimed at (1) characterizing the duplex sonographic appearance of cerebral aneurysms, (2) visualizing their location, and (3) ensuring the complete occlusion of the aneurysm as well as the patency of the basal arteries during aneurysm surgery. During 9 months 30 craniotomies for aneurysm clipping in 29 patients were monitored intraoperatively by B-mode and color-coded duplex sonography. Following craniotomy the aneurysm and the preaneurysmatic and postaneurysmatic arteries were sonographically visualized before and after clipping and removal of the spatulas. Twenty-seven (90%) of 30 aneurysms appeared as a hypoechoic structure. Together with the typical dichromatic picture in the color mode and the characteristic bidirectional flow pattern in the duplex mode, 29 (97%) of 30 aneurysms were identified and localized anatomically correctly. Eighty (99%) of 81 relevant vessels were visualized and measured with the Doppler mode. After clipping, flow was detectable in all major arteries except 3 middle cerebral artery (MCA) branches. In 1, occlusion was confirmed by postoperative angiography. In the other 2, early postoperative computed tomography showed an infarction of the corresponding MCA territories. This study demonstrated the potential of color duplex sonography to visualize and characterize cerebral aneurysms and adjacent basal arteries before and after clipping. It offers a noninvasive intraoperative method to control the patency of basal arteries and complete occlusion of the aneurysm.

David M. Hume memorial lecture. Surgical treatment of renovascular hypertension

BACKGROUND

Renal artery occlusive disease is the most common form of surgically correctable hypertension. Considerable scientific advances have improved our understanding of the pathophysiologic sequellae of a renal artery stenosis, the means of documenting the functional importance of such lesions, and the role of alternative surgical approaches in treating this disease. This work assesses the historical basis for the surgical treatment of renovascular hypertension.

DATA SOURCES

A review of the American literature on the subject of renovascular hypertension was undertaken, with particular attention to early work emanating from the University of California, San Francisco, the University of Michigan, and Vanderbilt University. These three institutions had considerable influence on the evolving techniques of operative intervention for renovascular hypertension.

CONCLUSIONS

The contemporary surgical management of renal artery stenotic disease causing secondary hypertension includes recognition of the heterogeneic character renal artery diseases, documentation of the functional significance of the stenoses, and performance of a properly chosen operation. Surgical therapy benefits 85% to 95% of properly selected patients having renovascular hypertension.

Transaortic mesenteric endarterectomy

Although a number of methods for mesenteric artery reconstruction have been suggested, we believe that patients with atherosclerotic stenosis and occlusion of mesenteric vessels presenting with either acute or chronic visceral ischemia are best managed by either antegrade aortomesenteric bypass or transaortic mesenteric endarterectomy. Antegrade bypass is the most versatile technique and is therefore best adapted to extensive mesenteric disease. Transaortic mesenteric endarterectomy lends itself well to simultaneous renal artery endarterectomy when clinically significant osteal atherosclerosis is present at both sites. With any method of reconstruction, the technical adequacy of repair should be defined intraoperatively. In this regard, intraoperative duplex sonography provides both anatomic and hemodynamic data necessary to ensure technical success and late patency.

A comparison of outcome criteria in the diagnosis of renovascular hypertension

The outcome criteria used for the diagnosis of renovascular hypertension (RVHT) following renal revascularization have not been validated. Differing criteria of indeterminate accuracy have yielded conflicting conclusions concerning the prevalence and efficacy of treatment of RVHT. We compared the accuracy of conventional outcome criteria used in the diagnosis of RVHT to that of novel, ordered outcome analysis to determine whether such an analysis might provide a more consistent means of diagnosing RVHT. Twenty-seven patients underwent intervention for treatment of presumed RVHT (group I), and 40 patients with presumed essential hypertension were treated with antihypertensive medication alone (group II). A standard dichotomized (improved or unimproved) outcome scheme and a five-level, ordered outcome scheme (ranging from definitely unimproved to definitely improved) were used to generate nominal outcomes of therapy for each patient. The resultant outcome groups were examined to determine the effect of such partitioning on blood pressure and medication requirements. To determine their diagnostic accuracy, the conventional and ordered outcome schemes were compared with a consensus outcome scheme derived from the use of numerous criteria. Significant correlations were observed between the ordered outcome score and posttreatment reductions in systolic blood pressure (r = 0.53, p = 0.007), diastolic blood pressure (r = 0.74, p = 0.0001), and medication score (r = 0.71, p = 0.0001). Overall diagnostic accuracy was estimated to be 91% for ordered criteria and 85% for dichotomized criteria. Correlation of the ordered and conventional schemes' assignments with the consensus scheme's assignments was 0.79 (p = 0.0001) and 0.63 (p = 0.0001), respectively. A simple, ordered outcome scheme compares favorably with the standard dichotomized scheme in assigning a diagnosis of RVHT to patients following renal revascularization or nephrectomy. The ordered scheme offers the advantages of simplicity and accuracy over current schemes.

Follow-up evaluation after renal artery bypass surgery with use of carbon dioxide arteriography and color-flow duplex scanning

PURPOSE

Postoperative evaluation of renal artery bypass grafts historically has been obtained by contrast renal arteriography before discharge from the hospital. Recent reports have advocated replacing arteriography with abdominal duplex scanning for evaluating and monitoring the integrity of renal artery bypasses. We propose a combination of these two techniques, which provides minimal risk to the patient and renal parenchymal function.

PURPOSE

Between July 1, 1990, and Dec. 31, 1991, 17 patients (8 men, 9 women) underwent 24 renal artery bypasses for poorly controlled hypertension or deteriorating renal function. In the immediate postoperative period each patient underwent carbon dioxide (CO2) renal arteriography to detect any technical defects and to define bypass graft anatomy. Subsequently, color-flow duplex scanning of the renal artery bypass grafts were done at 3-month intervals with the postoperative CO2 arteriogram for baseline comparison. CO2 arteriography clearly defined proximal/distal anastomotic anatomy, bypass conduit integrity, and bypass conduit runoff.

RESULTS

Procedural morbidity was zero because no hematomas developed and serum creatinine remained stable. Duplex scanning for a mean follow-up of 8.3 months revealed antegrade flow in 23 bypasses with peak systolic velocity of 60 to 100 cm/sec. One bypass graft had a peak systolic velocity greater than 150 cm/sec suggestive of a proximal anastomotic stenosis; however, the patient died before a repeat, verifying CO2 arteriogram could be obtained. Recurrent hypertension developed in one patient with velocities less than 100/cm/sec, and repeat CO2 arteriography revealed no evidence of graft or anastomotic stenosis.

CONCLUSION

CO2 arteriography and duplex scanning provide an accurate means of initially evaluating and subsequently monitoring renal artery bypass grafts, with minimal risk of renal or patient morbidity.

Intraoperative B-mode ultrasonography is a useful adjunct to peripheral arterial reconstruction

We used an ultrasound imaging system with a 10 MHz probe during 118 vascular procedures. These procedures included 56 cerebrovascular, 38 infrainguinal, 16 renal, 4 mesenteric, and 4 aortic reconstructions. In 29 procedures, intraoperative ultrasonography was used to supplement or replace preoperative arteriography to better define the extent of disease for the optimal placement of an anastomosis or to determine the need for an additional reconstructive procedure. In 106 cases, ultrasonography was used for postreconstruction assessment. Of the 21 (20%) defects found, 11 (10%) were deemed important enough to warrant correction. Defects were significantly more common following endarterectomy procedures (p < 0.01). All 11 of the major defects were successfully repaired, and neither the corrected defects nor the 10 uncorrected minor defects were associated with postoperative complications. Patients (with and without defects) underwent routine early postoperative follow-up assessment of the technical adequacy of their reconstruction using color duplex imaging; no residual defects were discovered. Two (2%) postoperative occlusions (one femorofemoral and one aortorenal bypass) occurred without a technical defect noted on reexploration. This clinical experience demonstrates that B-mode ultrasonography can supplement or replace preoperative arteriography in selected cases and is a valuable technique for identifying defects intraoperatively so that they can be immediately corrected.