Genetic control of alcohol deprivation effect in congenic mice

Sex Differences in Motivation to Self-Administer Alcohol After 2 Weeks of Abstinence in Young-Adult Heavy Drinkers

BACKGROUND

Studies in animal models document that forced abstinence from usual consumption of alcohol changes subsequent seeking and consumption, with increases or decreases depending on the species, duration of abstinence, number of deprivations, and sex. Human laboratory-based alcohol deprivation studies are rare.

METHODS

We conducted a 2-session, within-participant, randomized-order comparison of intravenous, progressive ratio, alcohol self-administration during 2.5 hours of progressive work for alcohol and/or vehicle; once while the participants pursued their usual drinking habits and once after 2 weeks of closely monitored, voluntary outpatient abstinence from alcohol. The schedule of work for rewards and the incremental increases in breath alcohol concentration following completion of an alcohol work-set were identical across participants. Fifty young-adult (27 men), heavy-drinking participants completed both sessions. Our primary hypothesis was that motivation to work for alcohol after 2 weeks of abstinence would be greater in participants with a weekly binge pattern of drinking, compared to those who regularly drink heavily, and we intended to explore associations with biological family history of alcoholism and sex.

RESULTS

We detected no change in work for alcohol associated with recent drinking history. However, females, on average, increased their work for alcohol upon resumption after 2 weeks of abstinence (mean ± SEM = +16.3 ± 9.6%), while males decreased that work (-24.8 ± 13.8%). The sex difference was substantial and significant (p < 0.03), with a medium effect size (Cohen's d = 0.63).

CONCLUSIONS

We believe a more comprehensive study of mechanisms underlying the sex differences in the human postabstinence response is warranted.

Glutamate Receptors within the Mesolimbic Dopamine System Mediate Alcohol Relapse Behavior

Glutamatergic input within the mesolimbic dopamine (DA) pathway plays a critical role in the development of addictive behavior. Although this is well established for some drugs of abuse, it is not known whether glutamate receptors within the mesolimbic system are involved in mediating the addictive properties of chronic alcohol use. Here we evaluated the contribution of mesolimbic NMDARs and AMPARs in mediating alcohol-seeking responses induced by environmental stimuli and relapse behavior using four inducible mutant mouse lines lacking the glutamate receptor genes Grin1 or Gria1 in either DA transporter (DAT) or D1R-expressing neurons. We first demonstrate the lack of GluN1 or GluA1 in either DAT- or D1R-expressing neurons in our mutant mouse lines by colocalization studies. We then show that GluN1 and GluA1 receptor subunits within these neuronal subpopulations mediate the alcohol deprivation effect, while having no impact on context- plus cue-induced reinstatement of alcohol-seeking behavior. We further validated these results pharmacologically by demonstrating similar reductions in the alcohol deprivation effect after infusion of the NMDAR antagonist memantine into the nucleus accumbens and ventral tegmental area of control mice, and a rescue of the mutant phenotype via pharmacological potentiation of AMPAR activity using aniracetam. In conclusion, dopamine neurons as well as D1R-expressing medium spiny neurons and their glutamatergic inputs via NMDARs and AMPARs act in concert to influence relapse responses. These results provide a neuroanatomical and molecular substrate for relapse behavior and emphasize the importance of glutamatergic drugs in modulating relapse behavior.

SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT

Here we provide genetic and pharmacological evidence that glutamate receptors within the mesolimbic dopamine system play an essential role in alcohol relapse. Using various inducible and site-specific transgenic mouse models and pharmacological validation experiments, we show that critical subunits of NMDARs and AMPARs expressed either in dopamine neurons or in dopamine receptor D1-containing neurons play an important role in the alcohol deprivation effect (the increase in alcohol intake after a period of abstinence) while having no impact on context- plus cue-induced reinstatement of alcohol-seeking responses. Medications targeting glutamatergic neurotransmission by selective inactivation of these glutamate receptors might have therapeutic efficacy.

Is the alcohol deprivation effect genetically mediated? Studies with HXB/BXH recombinant inbred rat strains

BACKGROUND

Two features of alcohol addiction that have been widely studied in animal models are relapse drinking following periods of alcohol abstinence and the escalation of alcohol consumption after chronic continuous or intermittent alcohol exposure. The genetic contribution to these phenotypes has not been systematically investigated.

METHODS

HXB/BXH recombinant inbred (RI) rat strains were given access to alcohol sequentially as follows: alcohol (10%) as the only fluid for 1 week; alcohol (10%) and water in a 2-bottle choice paradigm for 7 weeks ("pre-alcohol deprivation effect [ADE] alcohol consumption"); 2 weeks of access to water only (alcohol deprivation); and 2 weeks of reaccess to 10% alcohol and water ("post-ADE alcohol consumption"). The periods of deprivation and reaccess to alcohol were repeated 3 times. The ADE was defined as the amount of alcohol consumed in the first 24 hours after deprivation minus the average daily amount of alcohol consumed in the week prior to deprivation. Heritability of the phenotypes was determined by analysis of variance, and quantitative trait loci (QTLs) were identified.

RESULTS

All strains showed increased alcohol consumption, compared to the predeprivation period, in the first 24 hours after each deprivation (ADE). Broad-sense heritability of the ADEs was low (ADE1, 9.1%; ADE2, 26.2%; ADE3, 16.3%). Alcohol consumption levels were relatively stable over weeks 2 to 7. Post-ADE alcohol consumption levels consistently increased in some strains and were decreased or unchanged in others. Heritability of pre- and post-ADE alcohol consumption was high and increased over time (week 2, 38.5%; week 7, 51.1%; week 11, 56.8%; week 15, 63.3%). QTLs for pre- and post-ADE alcohol consumption were similar, but the strength of the QTL association with the phenotype decreased over time.

CONCLUSIONS

In the HXB/BXH RI rat strains, genotypic variance does not account for a large proportion of phenotypic variance in the ADE phenotype (low heritability), suggesting a role of environmental factors. In contrast, a large proportion of the variance across the RI strains in pre- and post-ADE alcohol consumption is due to genetically determined variance (high heritability).

The alcohol deprivation effect model for studying relapse behavior: a comparison between rats and mice

Understanding the psychological mechanisms and underlying neurobiology of relapse behavior is essential for improving the treatment of addiction. Because the neurobiology of relapse behavior cannot be well studied in patients, we must rely on appropriate animal models. The alcohol deprivation effect (ADE) is a phenomenon in laboratory animals that models a relapse-like drinking situation, providing excellent face and predictive validity. In rodents, relapse-like behavior is largely influenced by the genetic make-up of an animal. It is not clear which other factors are responsible for variability of this behavior, but there seems to be no correlation between levels of baseline alcohol intake and the occurrence, duration, and robustness of the ADE. Rats that undergo long-term alcohol drinking for several months with repeated deprivation phases develop a compulsive drinking behavior during a relapse situation, characterized by insensitivity to taste adulteration with quinine, a loss of circadian drinking patterns during relapse-like drinking, and a shift toward drinking highly concentrated alcohol solutions to rapidly increase blood alcohol concentrations and achieve intoxication. Some mouse strains also exhibit an ADE, but this is usually of shorter duration than in rats. However, compulsive drinking in mice during a relapse situation has yet to be demonstrated. We extend our review section with original data showing that during long-term alcohol consumption, mice show a decline in alcohol intake, and the ADE fades with repeated deprivation phases. Furthermore, anti-relapse compounds that produce reliable effects on the ADE in rats produce paradoxical effects in mice. We conclude that the rat provides a better model system to study alcohol relapse and putative anti-relapse compounds.

Effects of naltrexone on post-abstinence alcohol drinking in C57BL/6NCRL and DBA/2J mice

The present experiment evaluated the effects of naltrexone, a non-selective opioid receptor antagonist, on post-abstinence alcohol drinking in C57BL/6NCRL and DBA/2J male mice. Home cage 2-bottle (alcohol vs. water) free-choice procedures were employed. During the pre-abstinence period, alcohol intake was much lower for the DBA/2J mice relative to the C57BL/6NCRL mice, and this strain difference was observed for groups receiving either 3% or 10% alcohol concentrations. The four-day abstinence period effectively reduced alcohol intakes (i.e., a negative alcohol deprivation effect, negative ADE) in both groups of DBA/2J mice, but had no effect on alcohol intakes in either group of C57BL/6NCRL mice. Both groups trained with 3% alcohol received the second four-day abstinence period, where the effects of acute administration of either naltrexone or saline on post-abstinence alcohol drinking were assessed. Naltrexone was more effective in reducing post-abstinence drinking of 3% alcohol in the DBA/2J mice than in the C57BL/6NCRL mice. In the DBA/2J mice, naltrexone further reduced, relative to saline-injected controls, the low levels of post-abstinence alcohol intake. Thus, the low baseline levels of alcohol drinking in DBA/2J mice were further diminished by the four-day abstinence period (negative ADE), and this suppressed post-abstinence level of alcohol drinking was still further reduced by acute administration of naltrexone. The results indicate that naltrexone is effective in reducing further the low levels of alcohol drinking induced by the negative ADE.

Performance in the cross-maze and slip funnel tests of four pairs of rat lines selectively bred for divergent alcohol drinking behavior

Alcohol naive rats from lines genetically selected for high and low alcohol drinking and founded on either Wistar (P/NP lines) and distinct heterogeneous stocks (AA/ANA and replicate HAD/LAD lines) were tested in the explorative cross-maze and the inescapable slip funnel. Rats of the low alcohol-consuming ANA, NP, LAD1 and LAD2 lines all exhibited a shorter latency before initiating exploration of the maze than did their high alcohol-consuming counterparts (66, 51, 33 and 51% of the values for AA, P, HAD1 and HAD2 lines, respectively). Significant line differences were also found with the slip funnel test (AA > ANA for time in a sprawling posture; P > NP but HAD1 < LAD1 and HAD2 < LAD2 for time escaping), but the directions of line differences were not consistently related to those in alcohol drinking.

Blood alcohol concentrations after scheduled access in high-alcohol-preferring mice

Development of procedures yielding substantial blood alcohol concentrations during voluntary access to an alcohol solution in mice is necessary to further characterize genetic and neurobiologic mechanisms underlying alcohol self-administration. Although, in experimental situations, some populations of mice readily drink an alcohol solution, results from previous studies have not typically revealed high blood alcohol concentrations after voluntary access, probably because of the high alcohol metabolism rate in mice. Toward development of a murine drinking model, 36 selectively bred high-alcohol-preferring mice of both sexes were subjected to a 30-min scheduled-access procedure by using saccharin fading to gradually introduce an alcohol solution. Mice had ad libitum access to food and water 24 h a day. The alcohol solution was available 1 h after the start of the dark part of the cycle for 30 min per day, 5 days per week. After complete removal of saccharin from the drinking tubes, mice consistently drank 1.4 g/kg of a 10% [volume/volume (vol./vol.)] alcohol solution in 30 min. Analysis of tail blood samples, taken immediately after the end of the 30-min access period, indicated blood alcohol concentrations were tightly correlated with alcohol intakes (range, 6-130 mg/dl; average, nearly 60 mg/dl). A concentration-response function of 10%, 12%, 15%, 18%, and 21% (vol./vol.) alcohol solutions indicated an inverted U-shaped relation between alcohol intake and alcohol concentration, with peak intake of greater than 1.75 g/kg per 30 min when a 15% alcohol solution was available. No sex differences were seen. These findings indicate the utility of this procedure in obtaining pharmacologically relevant blood alcohol concentrations after voluntary oral self-administration of an alcohol solution in mice.

Development of short-lasting alcohol deprivation effect in sardinian alcohol-preferring rats

Alcohol deprivation effect (ADE), defined as a temporary increase in voluntary alcohol intake following a period of alcohol abstinence, was evaluated in selectively bred Sardinian alcohol-preferring (sP) rats. Alcohol was initially offered in free choice with water for 35 consecutive days (predeprivation phase). Subsequently, one group of rats was deprived of alcohol for 1, 3, 7, 15, 30, 90 or 180 consecutive days, while the second group had continuous access to alcohol (deprivation phase). Once alcohol was re-presented, alcohol intake in alcohol-deprived rats was recorded 1 and 24 h after alcohol re-presentation and compared to that monitored in alcohol-nondeprived rats over the same time periods (postdeprivation phase). Alcohol deprivation for 3 to 30 days resulted in a significant increase in voluntary alcohol intake only in the first hour of re-access. These results demonstrate the development of ADE in sP rats. However, the rapid return of alcohol intake to control levels is discussed as evidence in favor of a set-point mechanism capable of regulating alcohol-drinking behavior in sP rats.

Haloperidol administered subchronically reduces the alcohol-deprivation effect in mice

During the pre-experimental phase, hybrid (CBA x C57BL) male mice having had 16 weeks free access to food, water and flavored 30% alcohol were deprived of alcohol for 3 days. The next day they were given free choice between similarly flavored water and 30% alcohol. The mice were divided into two subgroups having (HD) or lacking (LD) the deprivation-induced elevation in alcohol intake during the first 1.5 h of renewed access compared with their intake during the last 22.5 h of first postdeprivation day. In Experiment 1, alcohol naive, LD, and HD mice received daily injections of haloperidol (Haldol; 1 mg/kg) or vehicle during 14 days of abstinence. The behavior of the mice was evaluated in an exploratory cross-maze and inescapable slip funnel test a day after the 13th injection (before the 14th injection). On the first postinjection day, the mice were again given a free choice between flavored water and alcohol. In Experiment 2, all the mice were administered with vehicle during the first 13 days of abstinence. On 14th day, they received an injection of haloperidol (1 mg/kg) or vehicle and a day later were given choice between flavored water and alcohol. Unlike a single injection, the subchronic administration of haloperidol lowered the alcohol intake by HD mice with a more prominent decrease seen during the first 1.5 h than during the last 22.5 h of first postdeprivation day. The alcohol-deprivation effect in HD mice decreased by 79% after subchronic haloperidol. No significant change in alcohol intake was found in alcohol-naive and LD mice. Water intake did not vary systematically. Among the groups, the effect of subchronic haloperidol on the alcohol-deprivation effect did not parallel changes in most of the measures of exploratory or avoidance behavior. It is proposed that haloperidol administered subchronically may attenuate motivation for alcohol.

Different behavioral patterns related to alcohol use in rodents: a factor analysis

To estimate genetic correlations among behavioral measures from explorative crossmaze, inescapable slip funnel, as well as from drinking tests, the data from five pairs of high/low alcohol drinking rat (AA/ANA, P/NP, HAD1/LAD1, HAD2/LAD2, HIGH-IPH/LOW-IPH) and from three pairs of mouse (B10.AKM/B10.A(4R), HD/LD, Small_Brain/ Large_Brain) lines were evaluated by the use of principal component analysis. The analysis yielded a two-factor solution explaining 71.8% of total variability. Both the factors had high positive loadings on alcohol drinking. The first factor had sufficient positive loadings on latency of crossmaze exploration and total time of slip funnel immobility, whereas, there was a negative loading on slip funnel avoidance. The second factor had positive loadings on efficacy of crossmaze exploration and slip funnel escape attempts, whereas there was a negative loading on slip funnel immobility. The number of defecations in the crossmaze, time in open arms of the elevated plus-maze, time immobile during the forced-swim test, as well as intake of a saccharin solution, additionally available for a lesser number of the lines, were studied for correlations with the factor scores. The first factor of "alcohol drive with timidity and meekness" exhibited positive relation to saccharin intake. Time in the open arms of the elevated plus-maze showed significant negative correlation with a latency of crossmaze exploration. The second factor of "alcohol drive with novelty seeking and persistence" showed a negative link to crossmaze defecations and forced-swim immobility.