Liposomes as antigen carriers and adjuvants in vivo

The Production of Polyclonal Antibodies in Laboratory Animals. The Report and Recommendations of ECVAM Workshop 35

This is the report of the thirty-fifth of a series of workshops organised by the European Centre for the Validation of Alternative Methods (ECVAM). ECVAM's main goal, as defined in 1993 by its Scientific Advisory Committee, is to promote the scientific and regulatory acceptance of alternative methods which are of importance to the biosciences and which reduce, refine or replace the use of laboratory animals. One of the first priorities set by ECVAM was the implementation of procedures which would enable it to become well informed about the state-of-the-art of non-animal test development and validation, and the potential for the possible incorporation of alternative tests into regulatory procedures. It was decided that this would be best achieved by the organisation of ECVAM workshops on specific topics, at which small groups of invited experts would review the current status of various types of in vitro tests and their potential uses, and make recommendations about the best ways forward (1). This joint ECVAM/FELASA (Federation of European Laboratory Animal Science Associations) workshop on The Immunisation of Laboratory Animals for the Production of Polyclonal Antibodies was held in Utrecht (The Netherlands), on 20-22 March 1998, under the co-chairmanship of Coenraad Hendriksen (RIVM, Bilthoven, The Netherlands) and Wim de Leeuw (Inspectorate for Health Protection, The Netherlands). The participants, all experts in the fields of immunology, laboratory animal science, or regulation, came from universities, industry and regulatory bodies. The aims of the workshop were: a) to discuss and evaluate current immunisation procedures for the production of polyclonal antibodies (including route of injection, animal species and adjuvant ); and b) to draft recommendations and guidelines to improve the immunisation procedures, with regard both to animal welfare and to the optimisation of immunisation protocols. This report summarises the outcome of the discussions and includes a number of recommendations and a set of draft guidelines (included in Appendix 1).

A fusion intermediate gp41 immunogen elicits neutralizing antibodies to HIV-1

The membrane-proximal external region (MPER) of the human immunodeficiency virus, type 1 (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein subunit gp41 is targeted by potent broadly neutralizing antibodies 2F5, 4E10, and 10E8. These antibodies recognize linear epitopes and have been suggested to target the fusion intermediate conformation of gp41 that bridges viral and cellular membranes. Anti-MPER antibodies exert different degrees of membrane interaction, which is considered to be the limiting factor for the generation of such antibodies by immunization. Here we characterize a fusion intermediate conformation of gp41 (gp41(int)-Cys) and show that it folds into an elongated ∼ 12-nm-long extended structure based on small angle x-ray scattering data. Gp41(int)-Cys was covalently linked to liposomes via its C-terminal cysteine and used as immunogen. The gp41(int)-Cys proteoliposomes were administered alone or in prime-boost regimen with trimeric envelope gp140(CA018) in guinea pigs and elicited high anti-gp41 IgG titers. The sera interacted with a peptide spanning the MPER region, demonstrated competition with broadly neutralizing antibodies 2F5 and 4E10, and exerted modest lipid binding, indicating the presence of MPER-specific antibodies. Although the neutralization potency generated solely by gp140(CA018) was higher than that induced by gp41(int)-Cys, the majority of animals immunized with gp41(int)-Cys proteoliposomes induced modest breadth and potency in neutralizing tier 1 pseudoviruses and replication-competent simian/human immunodeficiency viruses in the TZM-bl assay as well as responses against tier 2 HIV-1 in the A3R5 neutralization assay. Our data thus demonstrate that liposomal gp41 MPER formulation can induce neutralization activity, and the strategy serves to improve breadth and potency of such antibodies by improved vaccination protocols.

Immunological effect of subunit influenza vaccine entrapped by liposomes

OBJECTIVE

To elevate the immunological effect of subunit influenza vaccine in infants and aged people (over 60) using liposomal adjuvant in the context of its relatively low immunity and to investigate the relation between vaccine antigens and liposomal characteristics.

METHODS

Several formulations of liposomal subunit influenza vaccine were prepared. Their relevant characteristics were investigated to optimize the preparation method. Antisera obtained from immunizinged mice were used to evaluate the antibody titers of various samples by HI and ELISA.

RESULTS

Liposomal trivalent influenza vaccine prepared by film evaporation in combinedation with freeze-drying significantly increased its immunological effect in SPF Balb/c mice. Liposomal vaccine stimulated the antibody titer of H3N2, H1N1, and B much stronger than conventional influenza vaccine. As a result, liposomal vaccine (mean size: 4.5-5.5 microm, entrapment efficiency: 30%-40%) significantly increased the immunological effect of subunit influenza vaccine.

CONCLUSION

The immune effect of liposomal vaccine depends on different antigens, and enhanced immunity is not positively correlated with the mean size of liposome or its entrapped efficiency.

Sucrose fatty acid sulphate esters as novel vaccine adjuvants: effect of the chemical composition

Adjuvant activity of novel, synthetic sucrose derivatives towards a recombinant glycoprotein was determined in large, non-rodent animal species. Compared to antigen alone, up to 3000-fold higher virus neutralizing antibody titres (VNTs) and 10-fold higher cellular responses against classical swine fever virus were observed in pigs after two immunizations with the sucrose derivatives combined with a squalane-in-water emulsion. The chemical composition of the derivative was crucial and sucrose esters containing one sulphate and seven dodecanoic (C12) or decanoic (C10) esters exerted the highest adjuvanticity. Derivatives without sulphate, with fewer fatty acid esters or with shorter or longer alkyl esters were less effective. Strong adjuvant activity of these formulations was the result of synergistic collaboration between the sucrose ester and the squalane emulsion, as factor of increase in VNT by the individual components was between 4 and 34. Enhanced humoral and cell-mediated immune responses lasted for at least 24 weeks. We concluded that combinations of hydrophobic, negatively-charged sucrose fatty acid sulphate esters plus submicron emulsions of squalane-in-water are strong adjuvants for humoral and cell-mediated immunity and that these formulations are promising adjuvants for future vaccines containing poor immunogens.

Enhanced immune response to T-independent antigen by using CpG oligodeoxynucleotides encapsulated in liposomes

Immunostimulatory CpG oligodeoxynucleotides (ODN) have been tested as immunoadjuvants for various vaccines including T-cell independent (TI) antigens. Findings from previous reports suggest that close physical association of CpG ODN to the antigen could enhance its adjuvant effect. As an alternative to chemical conjugation of CpG ODN to the antigen, the current study is aimed at determining the benefit of using liposomes as a carrier for CpG ODN to improve the immune response to biotinylated liposomes (Bx-liposomes), a model of a TI antigen. Liposomes with suboptimal concentration of hapten (1% biotin) were not immunogenic. However, when CpG ODN encapsulated in Bx-liposomes were used to immunize mice, a hapten-specific response was obtained as indicated by antibody-mediated elimination of re-administered Bx-liposomes. CpG ODN co-administered with empty Bx-liposomes could not achieve the same effect, indicating the requirement for encapsulation of the adjuvant. Using both intravenous (i.v.) and subcutaneous (s.c.) immunization methods, it was found that IgM levels, but not IgG levels were elevated. Immunization in nude mice confirmed that the immune response obtained was TI. The use of non-CpG ODN and an ODN with alternatively flanked CpG motifs showed no adjuvant effect. Incorporation of poly(ethylene)glycol (PEG)-modified lipid in liposomes enhanced the immune response even further. In conclusion, our data shows that liposomes are a useful delivery vehicle for CpG ODN as an immune adjuvant for TI antigens.

Incorporation of bacterial membrane proteins into liposomes: factors influencing protein reconstitution

Meningococcal and gonococcal outer membrane proteins were reconstituted into liposomes using detergent-mediated dialysis. The detergents octyl glucopyranoside (OGP), sodium cholate and Empigen BB were compared with respect to efficiency of detergent removal and protein incorporation. The rate of OGP removal was greater than for cholate during dialysis. Isopycnic density gradient centrifugation studies showed that liposomes were not formed and hence no protein incorporation occurred during dialysis from an Empigen BB containing reconstitution mixture. Cholate-mediated reconstitution yielded proteoliposomes with only 75% of the protein associated with the vesicles whereas all of the protein was reconstituted into the lipid bilayer during OGP-mediated reconstitution. Essentially complete protein incorporation was achieved with an initial protein-to-lipid ratio of 0.01:1 (w/w) in the reconstitution mixture; however, at higher initial protein-to-lipid ratios (0.02:1) only 75% protein incorporation was achieved. Reconstituted proteoliposomes were observed as large (>300 nm), multilamellar structures using cryo-electron microscopy. Size reduction of these proteoliposomes by extrusion did not result in significant loss of protein or lipid. Extruded proteoliposomes were unilamellar vesicles with mean diameter of about 100 nm.

Synthetic lipopeptides incorporated in liposomes: in vitro stimulation of the proliferation of murine splenocytes and in vivo induction of an immune response against a peptide antigen

Amphiphilic lipopeptides, such as Pam3CysAlaGly and Pam3CysSerSer, were synthesized and incorporated into liposomes, and their ability to induce the proliferation of BALB/c mouse splenocyte was tested in vitro. When compared to monophosphoryl lipid A (MPL) the following potency order was found: liposomal lipopeptides > liposomal MPL > free (emulsified) lipopeptides. These results strongly depend on the size of the vesicles used: a mitogenic effect was observed only with lipopeptides incorporated within vesicles of diameter < or = 100 nm while lipopeptides in larger vesicles (diameter approximately 300 nm) gave no response. This may be related to the necessity for the liposome-associated lipopeptides to be endocytosed to reach putative intracellular targets. As immunoadjuvanticity seems to be linked to B-lymphocyte activation, the lipopeptides represent attractive alternatives to MPL for the realization of completely synthetic liposome-based peptide vaccine formulations. This was borne out by showing that Pam3CysAlaGly and Pam3CysSerSer, when incorporated in small unilamellar vesicles carrying a covalently conjugated synthetic peptide of sequence IRGERA, corresponding to an epitope of the C-terminal region of histone H3, were able to induce a potent and long-lasting immune response.

Immunogenicity of new heterobifunctional cross-linking reagents used in the conjugation of synthetic peptides to liposomes

We have investigated the immunogenicity of six thiol-reactive heterobifunctional cross-linking reagents that permit the conjugation of cysteine carrying peptides to the surface of liposome containing monophosphoryl lipid A. Such constructs elicit an immune response against short synthetic peptides and our aim was to find the least immunogenic linkers to limit potential carrier-induced epitopic suppression. For that purpose the properties of three new polyoxyethylene linkers of different lengths and thiol-reactive moieties (maleimide, bromoacetyl, dithiopyridine) were compared to known derivatives obtained by reacting the classical reagents SMPB and SPDP or N-succinimidyl bromoacetate with phosphatidylethanolamine. The least immunogenic linkers were the bromoacetate derivatives whereas those containing a maleimide group evoked a significant anti-linker immune response. In addition, using IRGERA as a model peptide, we found that all six liposomal constructs strongly elicited the production of anti-peptide IgG antibodies. This immune response was therefore independent of the length of the linkers (ranging between 0.3 and 1.6 nm) and of the nature of the linkage. between the peptide and the thiol-reactive moieties of the cross-linkers, i.e. stable thioether or bio-reducible disulfide bonds.

Adjuvant properties of non-phospholipid liposomes (Novasomes) in experimental animals for human vaccine antigens

Non-phospholipid liposomes composed of dioxyethylene cetyl ether, cholesterol and oleic acid were evaluated as adjuvants with human vaccine antigens, tetanus toxoid (TT) and diphtheria toxoid (DT), in mice and rabbits. Antigens encapsulated in or mixed with liposomes elicited antitoxin levels similar to those elicited by antigens given with Freund's adjuvant or adsorbed onto aluminum phosphate. All liposomal antigen preparations, antigen given with Freund's adjuvant or adsorbed onto aluminum phosphate, elicited significantly higher IgG antibodies and antitoxin levels than soluble antigens in mice after a single injection and in rabbits after each of three injections. TT encapsulated in liposomes elicited sustained anti-TT IgG antibody levels in mice after a single injection as compared to TT mixed with liposomes. TT mixed with or encapsulated within liposomes containing monophosphoryl lipid A/squalene or squalene alone, as well as aluminum phosphate adsorbed TT elicited greater primary responses in mice than TT mixed with or encapsulated within plain liposomes. Liposomal TT preparations produced a slightly higher anamnestic response in mice than aluminum phosphate adsorbed TT. Subclass analysis of anti-TT antibodies showed that the majority of the antibodies belong to IgG1 subclass. Liposomal TT preparations, particularly those with encapsulated monophosphoryl lipid A/squalene or squalene alone, consistently elicited higher levels of anti-TT IgG2a and IgG2b than aluminum phosphate adsorbed or soluble TT. None of the preparations elicited IgG3 or IgM antibodies. It appears that non-phospholipid liposomes are as potent adjuvants as the currently employed adjuvant for human vaccines (aluminum phosphate) or a benchmark adjuvant for experimental immunology (Freund's adjuvant), and may be able to modulate the immune response towards the Th1 type.

Antigen processing: the gateway to the immune response

The T-lymphocyte response to an antigen is governed by the source of that antigen and the way in which it is processed. Before recognition by T lymphocytes, proteins must be degraded to peptides by antigen-presenting cells. The peptides are then presented on major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules for recognition by the T cells. Antigens arising outside the cell (e.g., bacteria) are phagocytosed and processed by the exogenous pathway for presentation on MHC class II molecules (e.g., DR) to CD4+ cells. Antigens derived from the cytoplasm (e.g., viral proteins) are processed by the endogenous pathway for presentation by MHC class I molecules (e.g., HLA-A, -B, -C) to CD8+ cells. The response to a hapten or drug is a function of the antigen processing pathway and is determined by its chemical properties. Antigen processing also governs the T-cell response to pathogens, vaccines, and autoimmune conditions.

Liposomal presentation of antigens for human vaccines

Liposomes are considered prime candidates to improve the immunogenicity of both antigens with hydrophobic anchor sequences and soluble, nonmembrane proteins or synthetic peptides. During the 20 years since liposomes were first demonstrated to have adjuvant potential, studies have shown that variation in liposomal size, lipid composition, surface charge, membrane fluidity, lipid-protein composition, anchor molecules, and fusogenicity can significantly influence results. In addition, antigen location (e.g., whether it is adsorbed or covalently coupled to the liposome surface or encapsulated in liposomal aqueous compartments) may also be important. Analysis of these variables as well as a comparison of the various techniques used to ensure the efficacy, stability, homogeneity, and safety of liposomal vaccine have been discussed.

TLC--a rapid method for liposome characterization

One of the most important problems for the use of liposomes as a drug delivery system is the modification of the vesicle induced by the liquid medium in which they are introduced (blood plasma for in vivo studies and the saline buffer solution for in vitro studies). Using thin-layer chromatography (TLC) we compared the behaviour of phosphatidylcholine (used for liposomes preparation) to that of the following unfilled liposomes: multilamellar liposomes (MLV); small unilamellar vesicles (SUV); and reverse phase evaporation vesicles (REV), before and after storage for 15 min in Krebs-Henseleit solution (37 degrees C, pH 7.4, aerated continuously with 95% O2 + 5% CO2). All variants contained the same amount of phosphatidylcholine. Thin-layer chromatography was performed on silica gel 60 as adsorbent. Two types of solvents were tested: one based on chloroform/alcohol (n-butanol or n-propanol or methanol)/water mixture (in different ratios) and another based on alcohol/alcohol/water mixture (n-butanol/n-propanol/water in 4/3/3 volume ratio). In all variants of chloroform containing solvents no differences were found between phosphatidylcholine and all types of liposomes. When using as solvent n-butanol/n-propanol/water significant differences were found between all types of liposomes before and after storage in Krebs-Henseleit solution. Their presence, after TLC treatment, was shown in electron microscopy studies.

Vaccination with immunodominant peptides encapsulated in Quil A-containing liposomes induces peptide-specific primary CD8+ cytotoxic T cells

Immunostimulating complexes (ISCOMs), containing lipids, the saponin Quil A, and proteinaceous antigens, have been proven to vaccinate effectively CD8+ cytolytic T cells in vivo. However, conventional ISCOM technology is restricted to hydrophobic proteins or fatty acid-derivatized proteins or peptides. We therefore analysed whether Quil A-containing liposomes are an effective vehicle to shuttle hydrophilic proteins or peptides into the MHC class I pathway of antigen presentation resulting in the in vivo induction of antigen-specific cytolytic T cells (CTL). Liposomes were formed by a lipid dry-down method followed by resuspension with an aqueous solution containing protein/peptide and Quil A and then an extrusion step. Quil A-containing liposomes are an effective means to elicit a CD8+ CTL response to peptide antigen in vivo. CTL could be raised in C57B1/6 mice against ovalbumin (OVA) peptide 257-264 and vesicular stomatitis virus nucleoprotein 52-59, as well as in Balb/c mice against listeriolysin peptide 91-99 and cytomegalovirus pp89 168-176, demonstrating the versatility of this approach. The elicited response was peptide-specific, peptide dose-dependent and Quil A was necessary. Vaccination with liposomes entrapping the whole ovalbumin molecule or an extended (OVA) peptide 254-276 also yielded a CTL responsive to the immunodominant OVA peptide 256-264, implying cellular internalization and correct processing. Thus Quil A-containing liposomes appear to be a versatile vehicle to vaccinate CD8+ T cells in vivo; in addition, they could rapidly enhance the understanding of subunit vaccines and rules of antigen processing and peptide-MHC class I binding.

Monophosphoryl lipid A enhances specific CTL induction by a soluble protein antigen entrapped in liposomes

Exogenous soluble antigen loaded in membranous vehicles including splenocytes and liposomes can induce a CD8+ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response in mice. Plain liposomes of simple composition, however, are not as effective as cellular vehicles such as splenocytes. In the present study it is shown that incorporation of monophosphoryl lipid A (MPL), a semisynthetic bacterial adjuvant, into liposomes enhanced the ability of liposomal ovalbumin (OVA) to prime for a specific CTL response. With the MPL formulation, the minimal antigen dose required for a detectable CTL induction was reduced about fivefold, and this approximated the required minimal dose of OVA loaded in the splenocytes. Moreover, liposomes containing MPL could induce a considerable level of CTL activity by either an intravenous, intramuscular or subcutaneous immunization protocol, whereas liposomes without MPL could only elicit such a response by an intravenous injection route. Subcutaneous injection of a mixture of liposomes containing MPL and liposomes containing antigen also elicited specific CTL activity. However, simultaneous subcutaneous administration of liposomal MPL and liposomal OVA at two distant sites did not prime the mice for a CTL response. These results indicate that MPL, although not necessarily incorporated in the same liposomes, must be in close proximity to the antigen to exert its adjuvant activity. Based on the results of this model antigen study, it is suggested that an optimal CTL inductive vaccine should include immunomodulatory adjuvant in addition to a class I pathway delivery vehicle such as liposomes.