Imaging fibrinogen adsorbed on noble metal surfaces with scanning tunneling microscopy: correlation of images with electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis, secondary ion mass spectrometry, and radiolabeling studies

Immobilization of Proteins with Controlled Load and Orientation

Biomaterials based on immobilized proteins are key elements of many biomedical and industrial technologies. However, applications are limited by an inability to precisely construct materials of high homogeneity and defined content. We present here a general "protein-limited immobilization" strategy by combining the rapid, bioorthogonal, and biocompatible properties of a tetrazine-strained trans-cyclooctene reaction with genetic code expansion to site-specifically place the tetrazine into a protein. For the first time, we use this strategy to immobilize defined amounts of oriented proteins onto beads and flat surfaces in under 5 min at submicromolar concentrations without compromising activity. This approach opens the door to generating and studying diverse protein-based biomaterials that are much more precisely defined and characterized, providing a greater ability to engineer properties across a wide range of applications.

Fibrinogen: a journey into biotechnology

Fibrinogen has been known since the mid-nineteenth century. Although initially its interest had been within the field of physiology over time its study has spread to new disciplines such as biochemistry, colloids and interfaces or biotechnology. First, we will describe the bulk properties of the molecule as well as its supramolecular assembly with different ligands by using different techniques and theoretical models. In the next step we will analyze the interfacial properties, an important topic because fibrinogen is considered to be a major inhibitor of lung surfactants' function at the lining layer of alveoli. The final step will be devoted to its main application in biotechnology. Thus, the adsorption of fibrinogen at solid/electrolyte interfaces and at carrier particles will be discussed. The reversibility of adsorption, fibrinogen molecule orientation, and maximum coverage will be thoroughly discussed. The stability of fibrinogen monolayers formed at these surfaces with respect to pH and ionic strength cyclic changes will also be presented. Based on the physicochemical data, adsorption kinetics and colloid particle deposition measurements, probable adsorption mechanisms of fibrinogen on solid/electrolyte interfaces will be defined.

Fibrinogen adsorption mechanisms at the gold substrate revealed by QCM-D measurements and RSA modeling

Adsorption kinetics of fibrinogen at a gold substrate at various pHs was thoroughly studied using the QCM-D method. The experimental were interpreted in terms of theoretical calculations performed according to the random sequential adsorption model (RSA). In this way, the hydration functions and water factors of fibrinogen monolayers were quantitatively evaluated at various pHs. It was revealed that for the lower range of fibrinogen coverage the hydration function were considerably lower than previously obtained for the silica sensor [33]. The lower hydration of fibrinogen monolayers on the gold sensor was attributed to its higher roughness. However, for higher fibrinogen coverage the hydration functions for both sensors became identical exhibiting an universal behavior. By using the hydration functions, the fibrinogen adsorption/desorption runs derived from QCM-D measurements were converted to the Γd vs. the time relationships. This allowed to precisely determine the maximum coverage that varied between 1.6mgm(-2) at pH 3.5 and 4.5mgm(-2) at pH 7.4 (for ionic strength of 0.15M). These results agree with theoretical eRSA modeling and previous experimental data derived by using ellipsometry, OWLS and TIRF. Various fibrinogen adsorption mechanisms were revealed by exploiting the maximum coverage data. These results allow one to develop a method for preparing fibrinogen monolayers of well-controlled coverage and molecule orientation.

Revealing fibrinogen monolayer conformations at different pHs: electrokinetic and colloid deposition studies

Adsorption mechanism of human fibrinogen on mica at different pHs is studied using the streaming potential and colloid deposition measurements. The fibrinogen monolayers are produced by a controlled adsorption under diffusion transport at pH of 3.5 and 7.4. Initially, the electrokinetic properties of these monolayers and their stability for various ionic strength are determined. It is shown that at pH 3.5 fibrinogen adsorbs irreversibly on mica for ionic strength range of 4×10(-4) to 0.15 M. At pH 7.4, a partial desorption is observed for ionic strength below 10(-2) M. This is attributed to the desorption of the end-on oriented molecules whereas the side-on adsorbed molecules remain irreversibly bound at all ionic strengths. The orientation of molecules and monolayer structure is evaluated by the colloid deposition measurements involving negatively charged polystyrene latex microspheres, 820 nm in diameter. An anomalous deposition of negative latex particles on substrates exhibiting a negative zeta potential is observed. At pH 3.5 measurable deposition of latex is observed even at low ionic strength where the approach distance of latex particles exceeded 70 nm. At pH 7.4 this critical distance is 23 nm. This confirms that fibrinogen monolayers formed at both pHs are characterized by the presence of the side-on and end-on oriented molecules that prevail at higher coverage range. It is also shown that positive charge is located at the end parts of the αA chains of the adsorbed fibrinogen molecules. Therefore, it is concluded that the colloid deposition method is an efficient tool for revealing protein adsorption mechanisms at solid/electrolyte interfaces.

Human fibrinogen adsorption on positively charged latex particles

Fibrinogen (Fb) adsorption on positively charged latex particles (average diameter of 800 nm) was studied using the microelectrophoretic and the concentration depletion methods based on AFM imaging. Monolayers on latex were adsorbed from diluted bulk solutions at pH 7.4 and an ionic strength in the range of 10(-3) to 0.15 M where fibrinogen molecules exhibited an average negative charge. The electrophoretic mobility of the latex after controlled fibrinogen adsorption was systematically measured. A monotonic decrease in the electrophoretic mobility of fibrinogen-covered latex was observed for all ionic strengths. The results of these experiments were interpreted according to the three-dimensional electrokinetic model. It was also determined using the concentration depletion method that fibrinogen adsorption was irreversible and the maximum coverage was equal to 0.6 mg m(-2) for ionic strength 10(-3) M and 1.3 mg m(-2) for ionic strength 0.15 M. The increase of the maximum coverage was confirmed by theoretical modeling based on the random sequential adsorption approach. Paradoxically, the maximum coverage of fibrinogen on positively charged latex particles was more than two times lower than the maximum coverage obtained for negative latex particles (3.2 mg m(-2)) at pH 7.4 and ionic strength of 0.15 M. This was interpreted as a result of the side-on adsorption of fibrinogen molecules with their negatively charged core attached to the positively charged latex surface. The stability and acid base properties of fibrinogen monolayers on latex were also determined in pH cycling experiments where it was observed that there were no irreversible conformational changes in the fibrinogen monolayers. Additionally, the zeta potential of monolayers was more positive than the zeta potential of fibrinogen in the bulk, which proves a heterogeneous charge distribution. These experimental data reveal a new, side-on adsorption mechanism of fibrinogen on positively charged surfaces and confirmed the decisive role of electrostatic interactions in this process.

Fibrinogen monolayer characterization by colloid deposition

Colloid particle deposition was applied to characterize bovine and human fibrinogen (Fb) monolayers on mica produced by controlled adsorption under diffusion transport at pH 3.5. The surface concentration of Fb was determined by AFM enumeration of single molecules adsorbed over the substrate surface. The electrokinetic properties of Fb monolayers for various ionic strength were studied using the in situ streaming potential measurements. It was shown that Fb adsorbs irreversibly on mica for a broad range of ionic strength of 4 × 10(-4) to 0.15 M, NaCl. The overcharging of initially negative mica surface occurred for fibrinogen surface concentrations higher than 1400 μm(-2). The orientation of fibrinogen molecules in the monolayers was evaluated by the colloid deposition method involving negatively charged polystyrene latex microspheres, 820 nm in diameter. An anomalous deposition of negative latex particles on substrates exhibiting a negative zeta potential was observed, which contradicts the mean-field DLVO predictions. Measurable deposition was observed even at low ionic strength where the minimum approach distance of latex particles to the interface exceeds 70 nm (for 6 × 10(-4) M NaCl). This confirms that, at this pH, fibrinogen molecules adsorb end-on on mica assuming extended conformations with the positive charge located mostly in the end part of the αA chains. This agrees with previous experimental and theoretical results discussed in the literature (Santore, M. M.; Wertz Ch. F. Protein spreading kinetics at liquid-solid interfaces via an adsorption probe method. Langmuir 2005, 21, 10172-10178 (experimental); Adamczyk, Z.; Barbasz, J.; Cieśla, M.; Mechanisms of fibrinogen adsorption at solid substrates. Langmuir, 2011, 25, 6868-6878 (theoretical)). This unusual latex deposition on Fb monolayers was quantitatively interpreted in terms of the model developed in ref 55 (Jin, X.; Wang, N. H. L.; Tarjus, G.; Talbot, J. Irreversible adsorption on nonuniform surfaces: the random site model. J. Phys. Chem. 1993, 97, 4256-4258). It was concluded that the colloid deposition method is an efficient tool for revealing protein adsorption mechanisms at solid/electrolyte interfaces.

Mechanisms of fibrinogen adsorption at solid substrates at lower pH

Adsorption of fibrinogen was theoretically studied using the three-dimensional random sequential adsorption (RSA) model. Fibrinogen molecule shape was approximated by the bead model considering the presence of flexible side arms. Various cases were considered inter alia, the side-on adsorption mechanisms and the simultaneous side-on/end-on adsorption mechanism. The latter mechanisms is pertinent to fibrinogen adsorption at lower pH (below isoelectric point of 5.8) where the entire molecule is positively charged. Extensive calculations enabled one to determine the jamming surface concentration (coverage) of molecules adsorbed under the side-on and end-on orientations as well as the total coverage. For the simultaneous side-on/end-on model the maximum surface concentration was 7.29 × 10(3) μm(-2) corresponding to the protein coverage of 4.12 mg m(-2) (without considering hydration). Additionally, the surface blocking functions for different adsorption regimes were determined and analytically approximated for the entire range of coverage by the interpolating polynomials. Using these blocking functions, fibrinogen adsorption kinetics for diffusion controlled transport conditions was evaluated. Comparison of these theoretical results with experimental data was made. It was demonstrated that the simultaneous side-on/end-on model properly reflects the maximum coverage of fibrinogen adsorbed on latex particles determined via the electrokinetic (electrophoretic mobility) and AFM measurements. Also, streaming potential measurements of fibrinogen adsorption kinetics on mica were successfully interpreted in terms of this model. The theoretical results derived in this work have implications for basic science providing information on mechanisms of anisotropic protein adsorption.

Human fibrinogen monolayers on latex particles: role of ionic strength

The adsorption of human serum fibrinogen on polystyrene latex particles was studied using the microelectrophoretic and concentration depletion methods. Measurements were carried out for pH 3.5 and an ionic strength range of 10(-3) to 0.15 M NaCl. The electrophoretic mobility of latex was determined as a function of the amount of adsorbed fibrinogen (surface concentration). A monotonic increase in the electrophoretic mobility (zeta potential) of the latex was observed, indicating a significant adsorption of fibrinogen on latex for all ionic strengths. No changes in the latex mobility were observed for prolonged time periods, suggesting the irreversibility of fibrinogen adsorption. The maximum coverage of fibrinogen on latex particles was precisely determined using the depletion method. The residual protein concentration after making contact with latex particles was determined by electrokinetic measurements and AFM imaging where the surface coverage of fibrinogen on mica was quantitatively determined. The maximum fibrinogen coverage increased monotonically with ionic strength from 1.8 mg m(-2) for 10(-3) M NaCl to 3.6 mg m(-2) for 0.15 M NaCl. The increase in the maximum coverage was interpreted in terms of the reduced electrostatic repulsion among adsorbed fibrinogen molecules. The experimental data agree with theoretical simulations made by assuming a 3D unoriented adsorption of fibrinogen. The stability of fibrinogen monolayers on latex was also determined in ionic strength cycling experiments. It was revealed that cyclic variations in NaCl concentration between 10(-3) and 0.15 M induced no changes in the latex electrophoretic mobility, suggesting that there were no irreversible molecule orientation changes in the monolayers. On the basis of these experimental data, a robust procedure of preparing fibrinogen monolayers on latex particles of well-controlled coverage was proposed.

Tuning conformations of fibrinogen monolayers on latex particles by pH of adsorption

Adsorption of fibrinogen on polystyrene latex particles was studied using the micro-electrophoretic and the concentration depletion methods. Measurements were carried out for pH 3.5, 7.4 and ionic strength of 0.15M, NaCl. Electrophoretic mobility of latex was determined as a function of the amount of adsorbed fibrinogen, expressed as a surface concentration. A monotonic increase in the electrophoretic mobility (zeta potential) of the latex was observed, indicating a significant adsorption of fibrinogen on latex for pH equal to 3.5 and 7.4, respectively. The anomalous adsorption in the latter case was explained in terms of the heterogeneous charge distribution on the fibrinogen molecule. The stability of fibrinogen monolayers formed on latex was also determined in pH cycling between 3.5 and 9.7. These measurements revealed that fibrinogen adsorption was irreversible, governed by the two main adsorption mechanisms: (i) the unoriented (random) mechanism prevailing for pH=3.5 where adsorbing molecules significantly penetrate the latex particle core and (ii) the side-on adsorption mechanism prevailing for pH equal to 7.4. In both cases, variations in the zeta potential with the fibrinogen coverage were adequately described in terms of the electrokinetic model, previously formulated for particle adsorption on planar substrates. Based on these experimental data, an efficient procedure of preparing fibrinogen monolayers on latex particles of controlled conformations and coverage was envisaged.

Structure of fibrinogen in electrolyte solutions derived from dynamic light scattering (DLS) and viscosity measurements

Bulk physicochemical properties of bovine plasma fibrinogen (Fb) in electrolyte solutions were characterized. These comprised determination of the diffusion coefficient (hydrodynamic radius), electrophoretic mobility, and isoelectric point (iep). The hydrodynamic radius of Fb for the ionic strength of 0.15 M was 12.7 nm for pH 7.4 (physiological conditions) and 12 nm for pH 9.5. Using these values, the number of uncompensated (electrokinetic) charges on the protein N(c) was calculated from the electrophoretic mobility data. It was found that for physiological condition (pH 7.4, I = 0.15), N(c) = -7.6. For pH 9.5 and I = 10(-2), N(c) = -26. On the other hand, N(c) became zero independent of the ionic strength at pH 5.8, which was identified as the iep. Consequently, for pH < 5.8, N(c) attained positive values, approaching 26 for lower ionic strength and pH 3.5. It was also found from the hydrodynamic diameter measurements that for a pH range close to the iep, that is, 4-7, the stability of Fb suspension was very low. These physicochemical characteristics were supplemented by dynamic viscosity measurements, carried out as a function of Fb bulk volume concentration, for various pH values. Using these experimental data the contour length of 80 nm was predicted for Fb molecules in electrolyte solutions. On the other hand, the effective length of the molecule was 53-55 nm for physiological conditions, which suggested a collapsed state of the terminal chains. However, for the range of pH outside the iep, its effective length increased to 65-68 nm. This was interpreted in terms of a significant unfolding of the terminal chains of Fb caused by electrostatic repulsion. The effective charge, contour length, and effective length data derived in this work seem to be the first of this type reported in the literature.

Adsorption of fibrinogen on tantalum oxide, titanium oxide and gold studied by the QCM-D technique

The adsorption of human fibrinogen on tantalum oxide, titanium oxide and gold surfaces has been studied by quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation (QCM-D) at 37 degrees C. Two different protein concentrations have been used, one close to physiological concentration (1 mg/ml) and one significantly lower (0.033 mg/ml). To further characterize the adsorbed fibrinogen layer, the subsequent binding of both polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies of fibrinogen is studied. We found that the viscoelastic properties of the fibrinogen layer depends strongly on the initial protein concentration. The trend is generally seen for all three surfaces. The fibrinogen layer on gold and tantalum oxide is found to have the same viscoelastic properties, which are different from those found for the fibrinogen layer adsorbed on titanium oxide. The dependency of the surface chemistry on the viscoelastic properties of the fibrinogen layer is observed directly for the 0.033 mg/ml solution, and indirectly through the antibody response for the 1 mg/ml solution. From this we conclude that the orientation and/or denaturation of fibrinogen on a surface depends on the surface chemistry and the protein concentration in the solution, and that the binding of antibodies is a useful way to detect this difference.

Thermally Induced Transient Activity Changes of Plasmin Adsorbed onto Bare and Fibrinogen-Modified Graphite and Glassy Carbon Surfaces

The occurrence of a thermally induced first-order transition affecting the amidolytic activity of plasmin adsorbed onto bare and protein-modified graphite and glassy carbon was demonstrated in the 10-45 degrees C temperature range in the presence of a chromogenic substrate. Modification of the surfaces was achieved upon spontaneous adsorption of plasmin to surfaces bearing a coating of fibrinogen, whether electrochemically oxidized or not. The amount of fibrinogen adsorbed at graphite was determined by ELISA. The kinetics of the transition was characterized by its starting temperature (T(c)), which was between 14 and 19 degrees C, the first-order rate constant, and the activation energy E(a) deduced from Arrhenius plots. Results showed the absence of a correlation between T(c), E(a), and contact angle variations. It is therefore likely that these variables address separate steps in a complex pathway of reactions undergone by plasmin under mild thermal constraints. Copyright 2001 Academic Press.

Individual plasma proteins detected on rough biomaterials by phase imaging AFM

In the past several years, atomic force microscopy (AFM) has provided topographic images of adsorbed plasma proteins in situ at unprecedented resolution. Imaging has been limited to adsorbed protein on relatively smooth model substrates such as mica, graphite, or self-assembled monolayers on which the small height of the protein can be observed from the background. The inherent roughness of biomaterial surfaces has prevented observation of adsorbed proteins in topographic images. We report imaging isolated fibrinogen molecules adsorbed on National Heart Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI) reference materials polydimethylsiloxane and low-density polyethylene in situ using phase imaging AFM. Fibrinogen, a plasma protein important for blood coagulation and platelet aggregation, was adsorbed from dilute solution onto reference biomaterial surfaces at sub-monolayer coverage. Tapping mode AFM was used to image the samples. For polydimethylsiloxane, the lateral size of the surface features is much greater than the dimensions of proteins. This allowed adsorbed proteins to be observed in topographic images. The phase imaging signal of tapping mode AFM provides information on differences in material properties of the surface, and was used to distinguish individual protein molecules from the underlying polymer surface. On the low-density polyethylene surface, characteristic topographical features are of the same magnitude as the protein molecules, so that protein cannot be distinguished from the surface using topographic images. However, phase images were used to successfully locate and characterize the distribution of the protein. Phase imaging was not able to distinguish fibrinogen adsorbed onto expanded polytetrafluoroethylene. The utility and limitations of the phase imaging technique for characterizing protein adsorption to rough surfaces is discussed.

Quantitative Assessment of Protein Adsorption by Combination of the Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay with Radioisotope-Based Studies

Protein adsorption at polymer surfaces has been investigated by means of both ELISA and radiolabeling techniques. Most of the data obtained are linearly related to each other for protein concentrations between 0.01 and 1 µg/ml, i.e., the concentration range in which the maximum amount of adsorbed active protein (ELISA) is achieved. The correlation of ELISA data with radioisotope-based measurements allows quantification of the former. Specific correlation factors are described. Adsorption is shown to be strongly dependent on the polymer/protein system. Copyright 1999 Academic Press.

Scanning probe microscopy for the characterization of biomaterials and biological interactions

The scanning probe microscopies provide a unique view of biological and biomedical systems at a nanoscale appropriate to appreciate molecular events. The advent of these methods has brought the ability to acquire quantitative information at the molecular level. Given the proliferation of microscopes and associated methods, the probability for important discoveries is high. If tempered with an appreciation for the potential for artifacts, the SPMs may revolutionize our view of biological systems and biomaterials interactions with those systems.