Isolation of a 40 kDa immunoinhibitory protein induced by rat liver transplantation

Nuclear antigens and auto/alloantibody responses: friend or foe in transplant immunology

In addition to cellular immune responses, humoral immune responses, mediated by natural antibodies, autoantibodies, and alloantibodies, have increasingly been recognized as causes of organ transplant rejection. In our previous studies, we have demonstrated the induction of antinuclear antibodies against histone H1 and high-mobility group box 1 (HMGB1), in both experimental and clinical liver transplant tolerance. The active induction of antinuclear antibodies is usually an undesirable phenomenon, but it is often observed after liver transplantation. However, the release of nuclear antigens and its suppression by neutralizing antibodies are proposed to be important in the initiation and regulation of immune responses. In this review article, we summarize the current understanding of nuclear antigens and corresponding antinuclear regulatory antibodies (Abregs) on infection, injury, inflammation, transplant rejection, and tolerance induction and discuss the significance of nuclear antigens as diagnostic and therapeutic targets.

Immunological and regenerative aspects of hepatic mast cells in liver allograft rejection and tolerance

The precise roles of mast cells in liver allograft rejection and tolerance are still unknown. This study aimed to explore the roles of mast cells in immune regulation and liver regeneration for tolerance induction by using rat models of orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT). Stem cell factor (SCF) and its receptor c-Kit, which are critical to the migration and development of not only stem cells but also mast cells, significantly increased in the tolerogenic livers as compared with rejected livers. The significant elevation of mast cell tryptase, high-affinity IgE receptor, and histamine suggested the activation of mast cells in liver allografts at the tolerogenic phase after OLT. Immunohistochemical analysis using confocal microscope clearly showed colocalization of mast cells, Foxp3+ Tregs, γδ T cells, and recipient-derived hepatic progenitor cells with higher expression of SCF, IL-9, IL-10, TGF-β1, and IL-17 related to immunoregulation and liver regeneration in the donor grafts of a tolerogenic OLT model. Cross-talk among mast cells and other cells was evaluated by in vitro studies demonstrating that syngeneic bone marrow-derived mast cells (BMMCs) co-cultured with naïve splenocytes or primary hepatocytes significantly increased the population of splenic γδ T cells by mitogen stimulation or by mast cell degranulation, and also significantly induced the hepatocyte proliferation, respectively. Our results suggested that mast cells in the donor grafts may play important roles in the induction/maintenance of immune tolerance and liver regeneration resulting in the replacement of hepatic cells from donor to recipient.

Tolerance in liver transplantation

Operational tolerance (OT) in liver transplant patients occurs much more frequently than OT of other transplanted organs; however the rate of OT varies considerably with the centre and patient population. Rates of OT range from 15% of the total liver transplant (LTX) patient population down to less than 5%. This review examines the reports of liver OT and compares the factors that could contribute to this variation. Multiple factors were examined, including the time from transplantation when weaning of immunosuppression (IS) was commenced, the rapidity of weaning, the contribution of maintenance and induction IS and the patient population transplanted. The approaches that might be used to increase the likelihood of OT are discussed and the approaches to monitoring OT in LTX patients are reviewed.

Immunological tolerance-related genes in a spontaneous tolerant model of rat liver transplantation explored by suppression subtractive hybridization

Natural immunological tolerance can be induced in certain types of allogeneic liver transplantation in rats. To screen for genes associated with the induction of tolerance, suppression subtractive hybridization was performed in the rat liver transplantation model between a DA donor and PVG recipient combination where spontaneous immunological tolerance is known to occur without any immunosuppressive treatment. As a result, 112 genes were cloned from a DA liver graft that survived for 20 days in the fully allogeneic PVG recipient. After confirmation of the expression intensity using an in-house manufactured DNA array with cDNAs from the DA graft, 36 genes were classified in the highly expressed group and 26 moderately expressed group. In the first group, there were 8 immunoglobulin-related genes and 6 MHC class II-related genes, suggesting the existence of an underlying rejection response. Among those genes, an antiapoptotic gene in the p38 MAP kinase pathway, heme oxygenase gene (HO-1), and a ras cascade gene, IQ motif containing GTPase activating protein 1 (Iqgapl), retained biological significance. The results suggested that the molecular response to a liver graft tends to be antiapoptotic and to terminate the rejection response. Unfortunately, there was no gene identified that qualified as a putative immunosuppressive protein, liver suppressor factor-1 (LSF-1). The panel of genes identified in the present work will be a useful panel of candidate genes to investigate the induction of spontaneous tolerance.

Role of NKT cells in allogeneic islet graft survival

Although NKT cells expressing CD1d-reactive TCR exerted protective role in autoimmune diseases, the regulatory function of CD1d-dependent NKT cells in alloimmune responses has not been investigated thoroughly. Here, we demonstrated the regulatory effects of NKT cells using a pancreas islet transplantation model. CD40/CD154 blocking induced long-term graft survival in most B6 recipients, but B6.CD1d(-/-) recipients showed co-stimulation blockade-resistant rejection. Adoptive transfer of NKT cells into B6.CD1d(-/-) restored tolerizing capacity of co-stimulatory blockade. Activation of NKT cells was effective for the prolongation of graft survival and up-regulated membrane-bound TGF-beta expression transiently on their cell surface. The activated CD1d-dependent NKT cells inhibited alloantigen-driven cell proliferation through cell contacts and the beneficial effect of CD154 blocking for allograft survival was related to TGF-beta pathway. Thus, we can conclude that NKT cells are essential for the stable allograft survival and the regulatory function is dependent on, at least in part, TGF-beta engagement.

The immunological role of lipid transfer/metabolic proteins in liver transplantation tolerance

BACKGROUND

In a rat tolerogenic orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) model, recipient serum after OLT (post-OLT serum) has been reported to prevent allograft rejection. A previous proteomic study indicated that apolipoprotein E (apo-E), which is an important factor for cholesterol transportation, is expressed at the latter tolerogenic phase after OLT. It has also been known that adipose tissue-derived adipokine, adiponectin, is an essential factor for fatty acid catabolism. This study aimed to characterize the role of lipid transfer/metabolic proteins in liver transplantation tolerance.

METHODS

To identify the apo-E and adiponectin in post-OLT serum, Western analyses and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) were performed, respectively. The immunosuppressive activities of those factors were evaluated by inhibition of the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR).

RESULTS

Western analyses showed that the mobility of apo-E was shifted at the latter tolerogenic phase after OLT in a natural tolerance model, and a similar phenomenon was confirmed in the serum of a drug-induced tolerance model (rejection model+cyclosporin A (CsA); 0 to 14 days) after cessation of CsA. Further study revealed that neutralization of modified apo-E in post-OLT serum reduced the immunosuppressive activity. Additionally, plasma adiponectin was significantly elevated at the latter phase after OLT, and possessed MLR-inhibitory activity.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the mobility shift of apo-E and/or the up-regulation of adiponectin may be necessary for overcoming the rejection, recovering the liver allograft function, and following tolerance induction in experimental OLT models, and may be useful as one indicator to surmise the prognosis after liver transplantation.

Impact of vaccine therapy using nuclear histone H1 on allograft survival in experimental organ transplantation

BACKGROUND

We recently reported that autoreactive antibody (Ab) against nuclear histone H1 had been identified as an immunosuppressive factor in a rat tolerogenic orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) model. The present study aimed to determine whether the up-regulation of antihistone H1 Ab by histone H1 vaccination leads to tolerance.

METHODS

Histone H1-immunized rats were established by intraperitoneal vaccination with histone H1 at every two-weekly interval. By using mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and heterotopic heart transplantation (HHT), the alloreactive T cell response and allograft survival of histone H1-immunized rats were compared with those of control rats. Cytokine and cellular profiles in histone H1-immunized rats were determined by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and flow cytometry.

RESULTS

Immunization with histone H1 in Freund's adjuvant induced alloreactive T cell unresponsiveness and prolonged heterotopic heart allograft survival. It also down-regulated the expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II and CD25 on splenic cells, elevated the T helper cell type 2 (Th2) skewing index (Interleukin (IL)-4/interferon (IFN)-gamma ratio or IL-4/IL-2 ratio) and modified the serum cytokine profiles.

CONCLUSIONS

The present results suggest that histone H1 vaccination of transplant recipients, which leads to the production of immunosuppressive factor and the modification of the cytokine/cellular profiles, has great potential as a tolerance therapy for prospective transplantation.

The potent role of graft-derived NKR-P1+TCRalphabeta+ T (NKT) cells in the spontaneous acceptance of rat liver allografts

BACKGROUND

The mechanism involved in the spontaneous acceptance of liver allografts in some rat strain combinations remains unclear. Immunoregulatory NKR-P1TCRalphabetaT (NKT) cells primarily produce IL-4 and IFN-gamma, and enhance the polarization of immune responses to Th2 and Th1, respectively. The aim of this study was to clarify the role of graft-derived NKT cells in inducing the spontaneous acceptance of rat orthotopic liver transplantation (OLTx)

METHODS

The experimental groups were divided as follows: Group 1, BN to LEW "low responder (acceptor)" combination; Group 2, DA to LEW "high responder (rejector)" combination; naïve BN (Group 3) or LEW recipients (Group 4) with liver allografts from irradiated BN donors. The recipients had liver allografts from irradiated donors reconstituted from the following cell populations 24 hr before harvesting, spleen cells (SPCs, Group 5), IgSPCs (Group 6), IgNKR-P1SPCs (Group 7), and IgTCRabSPCs (Group 8)

RESULTS

In Group 1, the percent of graft-derived NKT cells harvested on day 7 posttransplant were significantly higher than in Group 2. In the case of BN liver allografts that had been irradiated and reconstituted with cell populations including NKT cells (Groups 5 and 6), the mean graft survival (MST) was extended to 39.2+/-5.7 and 38.8+/-8.0 days, respectively. In contrast, when NKT cells were excluded (Groups 7 and 8), the grafts were acutely rejected within MST of 17.8+/-4.0 and 18.8+/-7.7 days, respectively. The concentrations of IL-10 and TGF-beta, but not IL-4 in IgGICs culture supernatants were predominant in the acceptor, whereas those with IFN-gamma predominated in the rejector.

CONCLUSIONS

Graft-derived NKT cells might be responsible for spontaneous acceptance in the rat OLTx.

Assessment of the immune response to dose of nerve allografts

Nerve allotransplantation provides a limitless source of nerve graft material for the reconstruction of large neural defects. It does require systemic immunosuppression or induction of immune unresponsiveness to prevent allograft rejection. It is unknown whether a greater volume of nerve graft material will increase the risk of rejection or the need for more intensive immunosuppression. This study assessed the relationship between the quantity of nerve tissue transplanted and the magnitude of the resulting immune response. Forty female (BALB/c) mice were randomly assigned to two groups that received either nerve isografts (BALB/c) or nerve allografts (C57BL/6). Each group was then subdivided into two groups that received either one or 10 sciatic nerve graft inlays. Histological and immunological assessments were performed at 10 days after engraftment. Histologic analysis demonstrated greater cellular infiltration in the allograft than the isograft groups but no appreciable difference in infiltration related to quantity of transplanted nerve tissue. In vitro assessments of the immune response using mixed lymphocyte assays and limiting dilution analysis similarly demonstrated a robust immune response to allografts but no effect on quantity of transplanted nerve tissue. These data suggest that larger peripheral nerve allografts may not be subject to increased risk for rejection.

Expression, by functional proteomics, of spontaneous tolerance in rat orthotopic liver transplantation

Orthotopic liver transplants (OLT) performed in certain combinations of donor and recipient rat strains, such as DA (RT1a) to PVG (RT1c), without immunosuppressive drugs could completely overcome major histocompatibility complex barriers. Although other organs transplanted in a similar fashion within the same combination have been promptly rejected, 60 day post-OLT serum (POD 60) has been proven competent in rapidly reversing the established rejection in animal models. In order to understand the functional role of tolerogenic serum proteins and their involvement with immune response regulation, a comprehensive analysis surveying global changes in complex OLT systems by proteomic techniques was applied. The results display the varying protein expressions in sera extracted from naïve and transplanted animals on POD 60 with regard to immunosuppression. Among these proteins, haptoglobin (Hp) which is related to inhibition of T-cell proliferation was found to be up-regulated following OLT. In addition, the transcriptional expression level and intracellular localization of Hp correlated with the immune events. Hp also exhibited a strong in vitro immunosuppressive effect on the mixed lymphocyte reaction. In conclusion, the presence of Hp may play an important role in modulating the spontaneous tolerance of liver transplantation. Furthermore, the serum proteome map could provide guidance with respect to discovering potential protein targets in OLT tolerance and eventually prolong hepatic allograft survival in the future.

LIVER TRANSPLANTATION-INDUCED ANTIHISTONE H1 AUTOANTIBODIES SUPPRESS MIXED LYMPHOCYTE REACTION

BACKGROUND

In a rat model of orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT), recipient serum after OLT (post-OLT serum) has been reported to prevent allograft rejection. However, the molecular identities of immunosuppressive factors, which are in the early stage of post-OLT, remain elusive. This study was aimed to identify immunodominant suppressive factors present in early post-OLT serum.

METHODS

The immunosuppressive activities of post-OLT serum, immunoglobulin (Ig) G-depleted serum, and purified IgG were evaluated in vitro by inhibition of the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). Autoantigens recognized by the MLR-inhibitory IgG in early post-OLT serum were identified by the internal protein sequencing.

RESULTS

Recipient post-OLT serum inhibited MLR, and its immunosuppressive activity vanished by means of the elimination of OLT-inducible IgG. IgG from post-OLT sera (2-3 weeks) specifically reacted to 31-, 34-, and 73-kDa autoantigens on splenic cells. The internal sequences of the doublet 31- and 34-kDa antigens coincided completely with those of histone H1 molecules. The levels of histone H1-specific antibodies were transiently increased to a plateau around 2 to 3 weeks after OLT but decreased in the later tolerogenic phase. Immunodepletion of antihistone H1 autoantibodies from early post-OLT serum abolished the MLR-inhibitory activity. Furthermore, rabbit polyclonal antibody-directed histone H1 not only suppressed MLR but also prolonged allograft survival.

CONCLUSIONS

In this article, the authors provide evidence that autoreactive antibodies against histone H1, which are transiently induced at the early stage by liver transplantation, are a major OLT-induced graft survival factor.

LSF-1 may modulate the indirect allorecognition pathway to delay allograft rejection

Liver suppressor factor one (LSF-1) is a 40-kDa immunosuppressive protein in the serum of rats 60 days after orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) between the non-rejector combination of DA donors into PVG recipients. In the present study, a polyclonal anti-LSF-1 antibody was used to detect the lymphoid cell populations expressing LSF-1 epitopes in several transplant models. In this study we examined cell samples acquired from rats that had undergone OLT in syngeneic, rejecting or non-rejecting combinations. Flow cytometry indicated that the polyclonal antibody reacts specifically with an epitope present on a CD4 CD11b positive cell of recipient origin. In the first 3 weeks after transplant there is a large increase in the number of these cells isolated from the spleens and livers of rats in tolerogenic OLT model, which correlates with prolongation of allograft survival. In the rejector and isograft models of OLT there is a minimal change in the expression of the LSF-1 N-terminal pep epitope. These results suggest that these recipient CD4 CD11b cells may have a critical role in the formation of transplant tolerance by interfering with the indirect pathway of allorecognition via as yet undetermined mechanisms. The increased expression of the LSF-1 N-terminal pep epitope on liver leukocytes 14 days after partial hepatectomy indicates a natural role for LSF-1 in the process of liver regeneration after insult or injury.

Clusterin may be involved in rat liver allograft tolerance

Little is known about the possible role of complement inhibitors on tolerance induced by liver allografts. Clusterin, which is a plasma glycoprotein, inhibits cytolytic membrane attack complex (MAC) of complement by binding to soluble C5b-7 complex. The role of clusterin in relation to the naturally achieved tolerance in a rat orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) has not been investigated before. Here we determined the kinetics of clusterin expression at different post-transplantation time points in a tolerogenic model (DA-PVG) where rejection was naturally overcome without any immunosuppressive drugs in comparison with the syngenic OLT model (DA-DA). Peripheral blood and liver tissues were taken from OLT at various post-operative time points. A strong expression of soluble clusterin was observed on post-transplantation day 7, which occurred at the peak of the rejection in this tolerogenic OLT model. The expression of clusterin remained strong even after tolerance was achieved. The intensity of clusterin expression was much stronger when compared with the syngenic OLT (DA-DA) model after OLT. A strong expression of clusterin mRNA was also observed in the tolerogenic model on post-OLT day (POD) 7 and the expression persisted when compared with the syngenic model on post-OLT day 60. Our data have shown that the strongest levels of clusterin during the reaction phase in tolerogenic OLT may be involved in tolerance induction.

Analysis of immunosuppressive proteins in serum of liver-transplanted rats by using an anti-LSF-1 affinity column

Liver suppressor factor one (LSF-1) is a 40-kDa immunosuppressive protein in the serum of rats 60 days after orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) between the nonrejector combination of DA donors into PVG recipients. In the present study, the purification of proteins from rat OLT serum taken 60 days after transplantation was performed by affinity chromatography using the anti-LSF-1 polyclonal antibody (pAb). The assessment of column eluates using anti-LSF-1 and OLT serum was studied using rat heart and liver transplantation models. Rejection was not suppressed by the administration of OLT serum in heart or liver allografts. However, heart allografts treated with peak eluates (450 micrograms single shot im, dissolved in Intralipos) taken from the affinity OLT serum survived significantly longer than untreated rats (median = 36.5 days; n = 7 vs 6.5 days; n = 5, respectively, P = 0.011). The same treatment with anti-LSF-1 column eluates also prolonged liver allografts significantly (>200 days) than those in either the untreated group (median = 11 days; n = 7) or those which received only Intralipos (median = 10.5 days; n = 5, P = 0.019). Subsequent analysis of the N-terminal sequences of some of the proteins which were eluted from the affinity column revealed that the homology of a 30-kDa protein was identical to hemoglobin alpha-chain, a 59-kDa protein to granulocyte inhibitory factor, a 70-kDa and a 90-kDa to albumin and its precursor, respectively. Although the specific immunosuppressive component has not been isolated, our results suggested that the anti-LSF-1 column can extract immunosuppressive moiety of LSF-1 from OLT serum.

Tolerance to rat liver allografts: IV. Acceptance depends on the quantity of donor tissue and on donor leukocytes

Liver allografts in some rat strains are often spontaneously accepted across a complete major histocompatibility barrier without the requirement for immunosuppression while other nonliver allografts are rejected. In previous studies, we have shown that spontaneous acceptance is dependent on liver passenger leukocytes. Depletion of passenger leukocytes by donor irradiation allows rejection, with DA recipients of irradiated PVG livers having a median survival time (MST) of 16 days. Here we show that, in this model, spontaneous acceptance is reconstituted by intravenous injection of donor leukocytes. Intravenous injection of 3-5x10(7) PVG liver leukocytes significantly prolonged DA survival time (MST=96 days, P=0.026), as did 5x10(7) spleen leukocytes (MST>100 days, P=0.002). Deletion of T cells from the reconstituting inoculum reduced survival time (MST=78 days, P=0.039), whereas deletion of B cells or monocytes/macrophages had no effect on survival time. In contrast, PVG hearts are regularly rejected by DA recipients, and PVG liver or spleen leukocytes, even at doses of greater than 3x10(8) cells/recipient, were unable to induce heart acceptance. To investigate the possibility that acceptance of the irradiated liver but not the heart might be due to the large mass of the liver, two kidneys and two hearts of PVG origin were transplanted to each DA recipient together with 1.5x10(8) PVG leukocytes. These organs survived for greater than 200 days, thereby showing that a large mass of donor tissue, in association with donor leukocytes, leads to acceptance of organs that are rejected if transplanted singly. It appears likely that spontaneous liver transplant tolerance is a high-dose or activation-associated immune phenomenon.

Allograft acceptance and rejection, mediated by a liver suppressor factor, LSF-1, purified from serum of liver transplanted rats

In certain rat strain combinations liver allografts are spontaneously accepted without immunosuppression and induce donor-specific tolerance to further skin and heart graft in the recipient. Such an effect is also transferrable using serum from orthotopically liver transplanted rats (OLT serum). In the OLT serum of one such combination, DA (RT1a) donor into PVG (RT1c) recipient, a 40 kDa protein (liver suppressor factor, LSF-1) has been identified and shown to be immunosuppressive in vitro. The aim of the present study is to investigate the immunological effect of LSF-1 and a polyclonal antibody (anti-LSF-1) against this molecule, in a rat heterotopic heart transplant (HHT) model and OLT model, respectively. Intramuscular injection of 300 micrograms of LSF-1, 1 h postoperatively, into a PVG recipient of either a DA or BN (RT1n) cardiac allograft caused significant prolongation of graft survival. Intravenous injection of polyclonal rabbit sera raised against an N-terminal peptide of LSF-1 (anti-LSF-1), within 1 h postoperatively, had variable effects on the survival of DA liver grafts in PVG recipients. In 5/6 cases injection of between 1 and 2 ml of anti-LSF-1 resulted in death of the recipient. Histological examination of the liver showed severe rejection with lymphoid cell infiltration of the portal tract and sinusoids and extensive damage to the parenchyma. All control rats survived for more than 60 days without any signs of rejection. The anti-LSF-1 polyclonal antibody prevented the injection of tolerance in the normally tolerogenic model (DA into PVG). This, together with the in vivo results, suggests a role for LSF-1 in the induction of tolerance.

New immunosuppressive proteins (KX-2, -4, and -5) induced by liver transplantation

The presence in rat serum of three novel immunosuppressive proteins is associated with induction of tolerance after liver grafting. One of these, KX-5 (40 kilodalton molecular weight) is present 40-100 days after grafting of DA liver into PVG, a combination in which liver grafts are not rejected; two others, KX-2 (87 kilodaltons) and KX-4 (10 kilodaltons), are present in PVG sera in a retransplantation model. N-terminal amino acid sequencing indicated that none of the proteins had been described previously. Induction of KX-5 was inhibited by cyclosporin A. All three proteins inhibited mixed lymphocyte responses nonspecifically. Administration of a single dose of 300 micrograms purified KX-5 to PVG rats receiving heterotopic heart allografts led to prolonged graft acceptance. The results raise the possibility of clinical application of the immunosuppressive properties of liver grafts through administration of soluble proteins.

Novel immunosuppressive proteins purified from the serum of liver-retransplanted rats

Liver grafts between certain rat strain combinations, such as DA (RT1a)-into-PVG (RT1c), are accepted without the use of immunosuppressive agents. To explore the nature and role of serum proteins in liver-induced immunosuppression, we have developed a retransplantation model of rat liver grafting. In this procedure, orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) is carried out in the DA-into-PVG combination; two days later the DA liver is removed and a new PVG liver implanted into the same recipient (re-OLT). Serum from re-OLT rats was immunosuppressive when tested in mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR). Three novel proteins were detected in re-OLT serum by SDS-PAGE, with sizes of 180 kD, 87 kD, and 10 kD. The N-terminal sequences of these were distinct and did not match protein sequences in the computer databases, although there was some homology between the 10 kD sequence and the beta-chain of rat hemoglobin. Purified 87 kD and 10 kD proteins were immunosuppressive in MLR; in both cases suppression was dose-dependent and nonstimulator-specific. Production of the 180 kD and 87 kD molecules required the presence of the recipient spleen. We conclude that re-OLT serum contains novel immunosuppressive proteins, which may be products of immune recognition and associated with the immediate termination of graft rejection.