Do we really know why chloroplast membranes stack?

Acclimation of leaves to low light produces large grana: the origin of the predominant attractive force at work

Photosynthetic membrane sacs (thylakoids) of plants form granal stacks interconnected by non-stacked thylakoids, thereby being able to fine-tune (i) photosynthesis, (ii) photoprotection and (iii) acclimation to the environment. Growth in low light leads to the formation of large grana, which sometimes contain as many as 160 thylakoids. The net surface charge of thylakoid membranes is negative, even in low-light-grown plants; so an attractive force is required to overcome the electrostatic repulsion. The theoretical van der Waals attraction is, however, at least 20-fold too small to play the role. We determined the enthalpy change, in the spontaneous stacking of previously unstacked thylakoids in the dark on addition of Mg(2+), to be zero or marginally positive (endothermic). The Gibbs free-energy change for the spontaneous process is necessarily negative, a requirement that can be met only by an increase in entropy for an endothermic process. We conclude that the dominant attractive force in thylakoid stacking is entropy-driven. Several mechanisms for increasing entropy upon stacking of thylakoid membranes in the dark, particularly in low-light plants, are discussed. In the light, which drives the chloroplast far away from equilibrium, granal stacking accelerates non-cyclic photophosphorylation, possibly enhancing the rate at which entropy is produced.

Granal stacking of thylakoid membranes in higher plant chloroplasts: the physicochemical forces at work and the functional consequences that ensue

The formation of grana in chloroplasts of higher plants is examined in terms of the subtle interplay of physicochemical forces of attraction and repulsion. The attractive forces between two adjacent membranes comprise (1) van der Waals attraction that depends on the abundance and type of atoms in each membrane, on the distance between the membranes and on the dielectric constant, (2) depletion attraction that generates local order by granal stacking at the expense of greater disorder (i.e. entropy) in the stroma, and (3) an electrostatic attraction of opposite charges located on adjacent membranes. The repulsive forces comprise (1) electrostatic repulsion due to the net negative charge on the outer surface of thylakoid membranes, (2) hydration repulsion that operates at small separations between thylakoid membranes due to layers of bound water molecules, and (3) steric hindrance due to bulky protrusions of Photosystem I (PSI) and ATP synthase into the stroma. In addition, specific interactions may occur, but they await experimental demonstration. Although grana are not essential for photosynthesis, they are ubiquitous in higher plants. Grana may have been selected during evolution for the functional advantages that they confer on higher plants. The functional consequences of grana stacking include (1) enhancement of light capture through a vastly increased area-to-volume ratio and connectivity of several PSIIs with large functional antenna size, (2) the ability to control the lateral separation of PSI from PSII and, therefore, the balanced distribution of excitation energy between two photosystems working in series, (3) the reversible fine-tuning of energy distribution between the photosystems by State 1-State 2 transitions, (4) the ability to regulate light-harvesting via controlled thermal dissipation of excess excitation energy, detected as non-photochemical quenching, (5) dynamic flexibility in the light reactions mediated by a granal structure in response to regulation by a trans-thylakoid pH gradient, (6) delaying the premature degradation of D1 and D2 reaction-centre protein(s) in PSII by harbouring photoinactived PSIIs in appressed granal domains, (7) enhancement of the rate of non-cyclic synthesis of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) as well as the regulation of non-cyclic vs. cyclic ATP synthesis, and (8) the potential increase of photosynthetic capacity for a given composition of chloroplast constituents in full sunlight, concomitantly with enhancement of photochemical efficiency in canopy shade. Hence chloroplast ultrastructure and function are intimately intertwined.

Entropy-assisted stacking of thylakoid membranes

Chloroplasts in plants and some green algae contain a continuous thylakoid membrane system that is structurally differentiated into stacked granal membranes interconnected by unstacked thylakoids, the stromal lamellae. Experiments were conducted to test the hypothesis that the thermodynamic tendency to increase entropy in chloroplasts contributes to thylakoid stacking to form grana. We show that the addition of bovine serum albumin or dextran, two very different water-soluble macromolecules, to a suspension of envelope-free chloroplasts with initially unstacked thylakoids induced thylakoid stacking. This novel restacking of thylakoids occurred spontaneously, accompanied by lateral segregation of PSII from PSI, thereby mimicking the natural situation. We suggest that such granal formation, induced by the macromolecules, is partly explained as a means of generating more volume for the diffusion of macromolecules in a crowded stromal environment, i.e., greater entropy overall. This mechanism may be relevant in vivo where the stroma has a very high concentration of enzymes of carbon metabolism, and where high metabolic fluxes are required.

Grana stacking and protection of Photosystem II in thylakoid membranes of higher plant leaves under sustained high irradiance: An hypothesis

We propose yet another function for the unique appressed thylakoids of grana stacks of higher plants, namely that during prolonged high light, the non-functional, photoinhibited PS II centres accumulate as D1 protein degradation is prevented and may act as dissipative conduits to protect other functional PS II centres. The need for this photoprotective mechanism to prevent high D1 protein turnover under excess photons in higher plants, especially those grown in shade, is due to conflicting demands between efficient use of low irradiance and protection from periodic exposure to excessive irradiance.

Why do thylakoid membranes from higher plants form grana stacks?

Chloroplasts contain a system of membrane sacs, the thylakoids, some of which are stacked to form grana (singular, granum), whereas others float freely in the stroma. It is on the thylakoid membranes that the electron carriers necessary for photosynthesis reside. There has been continuous speculation and discussion about the function of the grana ever since Menke postulated their lamellar nature in 1939. On the basis of new insights into the biophysics of the two photosystems and the molecular organization of thylakoid membranes of algae that exhibit a different lateral heterogeneity from that of higher plants, we propose that the membrane stacking found in the chloroplasts of higher plants and green algae is just one way in which Nature implements a general principle, namely that of physically separating a slow (PS II) and a fast (PS I) photosystem.

The prochlorophytes: are they more than just chlorophyll a/b-containing cyanobacteria?

The prochlorophytes are a diverse group of photosynthetic prokaryotes that fall within the cyanobacterial lineage, yet lack phycobilisomes as light harvesting structures. Instead, the prochlorophytes have a light-harvesting apparatus composed of the higher plant pigments chlorophylls a and b. This review discusses the evolutionary relationships among these bacteria, with focus on the structure and function of the photosynthetic apparatus. This analysis yields a consensus from studies both on Prochloron sp. and Prochlorothrix hollandica as to how the thylakoid membrane is organized. Overall, we propose that the structure of the light-harvesting complexes (LHC) from prochlorophytes is very different from those of chloroplast systems, and is evolutionarily very ancient. The functional association of the light-harvesting apparatus with photosystem I (PSI) in both Prochlorothrix and Prochloron, as well as a demonstrated capacity for PSI-dependent anoxygenic photosynthesis in Prochlorothrix, may indicate that there is an increased dependence on cyclic photophosphorylation in these organisms. Finally, the structure of the prochlorophyte thylakoid membrane is discussed with respect to the forces that drive thylakoid membrane stacking in prochlorophytes and chloroplasts. We suggest that the light-harvesting structures in prochlorophytes play little, if any, role in this process.

How does protein phosphorylation regulate photosynthesis?

Phosphorylation of light-harvesting antenna proteins redirects absorbed light energy between reaction centres of photosynthetic membranes. A generally accepted explanation for this is that electrostatic forces drive the more negatively charged, phosphorylated antenna proteins between membrane domains that differ in surface charge. However, structural studies on soluble phosphoproteins indicate that phosphorylated amino acid side chains have specific effects on molecular recognition, by ligand blocking or by intramolecular interactions which alter protein structure. These studies suggest alternative mechanisms for phosphorylation in control of pairwise protein-protein interactions in biological membranes. Thus, in photosynthesis, the surface charge model is only one possible interpretation.

Lipid-protein interactions in stacked and destacked thylakoid membranes and the influence of phosphorylation and illumination. Spin label ESR studies

The effects of membrane destacking, protein phosphorylation, and continuous illumination have been studied in pea thylakoid membranes using ESR spectroscopy of an incorporated spin-labelled phosphatidylglycerol. This spin-labelled analogue of an endogenous thylakoid lipid has previously been shown to exhibit a selectivity of interaction with thylakoid proteins. Neither destacking, phosphorylation nor illumination was found to change the ESR spectra appreciably, suggesting that for phosphatidylglycerol at least, neither the number of protein-associated membrane lipids nor their pattern of selectivity was altered. The redistribution of the thylakoid protein complexes in the membrane, under these various conditions, therefore takes place with conservation of the properties of the lipid/protein interface.

Protein phosphorylation and control of excitation energy transfer in photosynthetic purple bacteria and cyanobacteria

The function of phosphorylation of light-harvesting polypeptides is well characterised in chloroplasts of green plants, but the prokaryotic cyanobacteria and purple photosynthetic bacteria have quite different light-harvesting polypeptides whose structure and function cannot be controlled in precisely the same way. Nevertheless, cyanobacteria show light-dependent phosphorylation of membrane polypeptides associated with photosystem II and with the light-harvesting phycobilisome, and purple bacteria show light-dependent phosphorylation of low molecular-weight chromatophore membrane polypeptides. In both cases membrane protein phosphorylation is associated with functional changes observed by chlorophyll fluorescence spectroscopy or chlorophyll fluorescence induction kinetics. Here we report on our recent protein sequence and other data concerning the identities of these phosphoproteins. We also discuss the significance of these findings for regulation by protein phosphorylation of photosynthesis in prokaryotes.

The rate of bulk flow from the endoplasmic reticulum to the cell surface

Tripeptides containing the acceptor sequence for Asn-linked glycosylation (Asn-X-Ser/Thr) were added to CHO and HepG2 cells. The tripeptides were glycosylated in the ER and then secreted into the medium, via the Golgi complex in which the oligosaccharide chains were processed. The half-time for secretion, approximately 10 min, was faster than that of known proteins transported through the same pathway. Since much evidence suggests that oligosaccharide chains are not signals for transport, it appears that no signal is necessary for rapid and efficient transport from the ER to the Golgi, or from the Golgi to the cell surface. Rather, it appears that proteins retained as permanent residents en route through the ER-Golgi transport pathway must contain specific retention signals.

Implications of cytochrome b6/f location for thylakoidal electron transport

The cytochrome b6/f complex of higher plant chloroplasts is uniformly distributed throughout both appressed and nonappressed thylakoids, in contrast to photosystem II and photosystem I, the other major membrane protein complexes involved in electron transport. We discuss how this distribution is likely to affect interactions of the cytochrome b6/f complex with other electron transport components because of the resulting local stoichiometries, and how these may affect the regulation of electron transport.

A study of factors which regulate the membrane appression of lettuce thylakoids in relation to irradiance

Factors that may influence the extent of thylakoid membrane appression have been examined using lettuce (Lactuca sativa cv. Celtuce) grown under different irradiances. Electron microscopy and salt-induced chlorophyll fluorescence suggest that the percentage of membrane appression is increased in plants grown in low light (20 Wm(-2)) compared with those grown in high light (150 Wm(-2)). In high light plants surface charge, as measured by 9-aminoacridine, was found to be twice that measured in low light plants. There was a similar difference in ATPase activity of CF1 and in light saturated photophosphorylation. The chlorophyll content of LHC-2 as a proportion of the total chlorophyll was greatest in thylakoids of low light plants. Measurement of non-cyclic photophosphorylation rates suggested that membrane appression has a stimulatory role in the photophosphorylation process. The importance of these inter-related factors for the mechanism of thylakoid appression is discussed.