Seeding protein folding

Under-folded proteins: Conformational ensembles and their roles in protein folding, function, and pathogenesis

For decades, protein function was intimately linked to the presence of a unique, aperiodic crystal‐like structure in a functional protein. The two only places for conformational ensembles of under‐folded (or partially folded) protein forms in this picture were either the end points of the protein denaturation processes or transiently populated folding intermediates. Recent years witnessed dramatic change in this perception and conformational ensembles, which the under‐folded proteins are, have moved from the shadow. Accumulated to date data suggest that a protein can exist in at least three global forms–functional and folded, functional and intrinsically disordered (nonfolded), and nonfunctional and misfolded/aggregated. Under‐folded protein states are crucial for each of these forms, serving as important folding intermediates of ordered proteins, or as functional states of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and IDP regions (IDPRs), or as pathology triggers of misfolded proteins. Based on these observations, conformational ensembles of under‐folded proteins can be classified as transient (folding and misfolding intermediates) and permanent (IDPs and stable misfolded proteins). Permanently under‐folded proteins can further be split into intentionally designed (IDPs and IDPRs) and unintentionally designed (misfolded proteins). Although intrinsic flexibility, dynamics, and pliability are crucial for all under‐folded proteins, the different categories of under‐foldedness are differently encoded in protein amino acid sequences. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 99: 870–887, 2013.

Mechanism of formation of the C-terminal beta-hairpin of the B3 domain of the immunoglobulin binding protein G from Streptococcus. II. Interplay of local backbone conformational dynamics and long-range hydrophobic interactions in hairpin formation

Two peptides, corresponding to the turn region of the C-terminal beta-hairpin of the B3 domain of the immunoglobulin binding protein G from Streptococcus, consisting of residues 51-56 [IG(51-56)] and 50-57 [IG(50-57)], respectively, were studied by circular dichroism and NMR spectroscopy at various temperatures and by differential scanning calorimetry. Our results show that the part of the sequence corresponding to the beta-turn in the native structure (DDATKT) of the B3 domain forms bent conformations similar to those observed in the native protein. The formation of a turn is observed for both peptides in a broad range of temperatures (T = 283-323 K), which confirms the conclusion drawn from our previous studies of longer sequences from the C-terminal beta-hairpin of the B3 domain of the immunoglobulin binding protein G (16, 14, and 12 residues), that the DDATKT sequence forms a nucleation site for formation of the beta-hairpin structure of peptides corresponding to the C-terminal part of all the B domains of the immunoglobulin binding protein G. We also show and discuss the role of long-range hydrophobic interactions as well as local conformational properties of polypeptide chains in the mechanism of formation of the beta-hairpin structure.

Conformational studies of the alpha-helical 28-43 fragment of the B3 domain of the immunoglobulin binding protein G from Streptococcus

To determine whether the alpha-helix in the B3 immunoglobulin binding domain of protein G from group G Streptococcus has conformational stability as an isolated fragment, we carried out a CD and NMR study of the 16-residue peptide in solution corresponding to this alpha-helix. Based on two-dimensional H-NMR spectra recorded at three different temperatures (283, 305, and 313 K), it was found that this peptide is mostly unstructured in water at these temperatures. Weak signals corresponding to i,i+3 or i,i+4 interactions, which are characteristic of formation of turn-like structures, were observed in the ROE spectra at all temperatures. The absence of a stable three-dimensional structure of the investigated peptide supports an earlier study (Blanco and Serrano, Eur J Biochem 1995, 230, 634-649) of a possible mechanism for folding of other (B1 and B2) immunoglobulin binding domains of Protein G.

Electrostatic screening and backbone preferences of amino acid residues in urea-denatured ubiquitin

Local structures in denatured proteins may be important in guiding a polypeptide chain during the folding and misfolding processes. Existence of local structures in chemically denatured proteins is a highly controversial issue. NMR parameters [coupling constants (3) J(H(alpha),H(N)) and chemical shifts] of chemically denatured proteins in general deviate little from their values in small peptides. These peptides were presumed to be completely unstructured; therefore, it was considered that chemically denatured proteins are random coils. But recent experimental studies show that small peptides adopt relatively stable structures in aqueous solutions. Small deviations of the NMR parameters from their values in small peptides may thus actually indicate the existence of local structures in chemically denatured proteins. Using NMR data and theoretical predictions we show here that fluctuating beta-strands exist in urea-denatured ubiquitin (8 M urea at pH 2). Residues in such beta-strands populate more frequently the left side of the broad beta region of -psi space. Urea-denatured ubiquitin contains no detectable beta-sheet secondary structures; nevertheless, the fluctuating beta-strands in urea-denatured ubiquitin coincide to the beta-strands in the native state. Formation of beta-strands is in accord with the electrostatic screening model of unfolded proteins. The free energy of a residue in an unfolded protein is in this model determined by the local backbone electrostatics and its screening by backbone solvation. These energy terms introduce strong electrostatic coupling between neighboring residues, which causes cooperative formation of beta-strands in denatured proteins. We propose that fluctuating beta-strands in denatured proteins may serve as initiation sites to form fibrils.

Reversible stretching of a monomeric unit in a dimeric bovine carbonic anhydrase B with the atomic force microscope

We have previously shown that a full stretching of native carbonic anhydrase B (CAB) using the atomic force microscope could not be achieved, presumably due to the presence of a 'knot' in the C-terminal region of the protein. When we used an engineered dimer of CAB, where the N-terminal monomeric unit (unit I) was expected to be 'knotless', we successfully recorded extension of the protein up to 110 nm which was long enough to account for the full extension of unit I monomer. In this paper we report that, by limiting the maximum length of extension to 90 nm extensions (corresponding to about 80 nm extension of the dimer and 70 nm of unit I), retractions of the polypeptide chain can be repeated cyclically without breaking the covalent crosslinking system. The force-extension curves obtained from the forward and reverse cycles of such experiments were almost perfectly superimposable with each other and with the corresponding part of the curves obtained from full extension experiments suggesting that the structure of unit I in the dimer was reversibly stretched and contracted. During the stretching of unit I of the dimer in either type of the experiments mentioned above, we occasionally observed a force peak having the force of about 0.5-0.7 nN when extension length reached 40-50 nm. We interpreted the appearance of such force peaks as an indication of formation of a tightly folded domain structure in unit I of CAB dimer.

Structural and dynamic characterization of an unfolded state of poplar apo-plastocyanin formed under nondenaturing conditions

Plastocyanin is a predominantly beta-sheet protein containing a type I copper center. The conformational ensemble of a denatured state of apo-plastocyanin formed in solution under conditions of low salt and neutral pH has been investigated by multidimensional heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. Chemical shift assignments were obtained by using three-dimensional triple-resonance NMR experiments to trace through-bond heteronuclear connectivities along the backbone and side chains. The (3)J(HN,Halpha) coupling constants, (15)N-edited proton-proton nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs), and (15)N relaxation parameters were also measured for the purpose of structural and dynamic characterization. Most of the residues corresponding to beta-strands in the folded protein exhibit small upfield shifts of the (13)C(alpha) and (13)CO resonances relative to random coil values, suggesting a slight preference for backbone dihedral angles in the beta region of (phi,psi) space. This is further supported by the presence of strong sequential d(alphaN)(i, i + 1) NOEs throughout the sequence. The few d(NN)(i, i + 1) proton NOEs that are observed are mostly in regions that form loops in the native plastocyanin structure. No medium or long-range NOEs were observed. A short sequence, between residues 59 and 63, was found to populate a nonnative helical conformation in the unfolded state, as indicated by the shift of the (13)C(alpha), (13)CO, and (1)H(alpha) resonances relative to random coil values and by the decreased values of the (3)J(HN,Halpha) coupling constants. The (15)N relaxation parameters indicate restriction of motions on a nanosecond timescale in this region. Intriguingly, this helical conformation is present in a sequence that is close to but not in the same location as the single short helix in the native folded protein. The results are consistent with earlier NMR studies of peptide fragments of plastocyanin and confirm that the regions of the sequence that form beta-strands in the native protein spontaneously populate the beta-region of (phi,psi) space under folding conditions, even in the absence of stabilizing tertiary interactions. We conclude that the state of apo-plastocyanin present under nondenaturing conditions is a noncompact unfolded state with some evidence of nativelike and nonnative local structuring that may be initiation sites for folding of the protein.

Conformational properties of five peptides corresponding to the entire sequence of glutathione transferase domain II

Five peptides matching the helices alpha4, alpha5, alpha6, alpha7, and alpha8, spanning the entire sequence of domain II of pG-STP1-1, have been synthesized and their conformations analyzed by far-UV CD spectroscopy. The results show that a5, a7, and a8 peptides are unstructured in water/2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE) solutions. The a4-peptide also adopts random conformations in aqueous solvent. Moreover, the relative low helical content (20%), estimated for this peptide in the presence of 30% (v/v) TFE, suggests that the sequence of this protein fragment does not possess sufficient information for a strong helical propensity. On the contrary, the synthesized a6 peptide, in the presence of TFE, showed a relevant structural autonomy with a helical content (41%) which was significantly higher than that estimated, under the same conditions, for all other peptides. More in general in the presence of solvents less polar than water, the isolated a6 peptide shows the same helical conformation adopted by the corresponding alpha6-helix in the hydrophobic core of the protein. A n-capping box motif, strictly conserved at the N-terminal of the alpha6-helix of all GST and related protein including eucaryotic translation elongation factor (EF1gamma) and the yeast prion protein Ure2, plays an important role in the alpha-helix nucleation and stability of this protein fragment. The results suggest that the alpha6-helix might represent a nucleation site of GST folding and that the helical conformation of this region of the protein is an important requirement during earlier events of GST refolding.

Is the unfolded state the Rosetta Stone of the protein folding problem?

Solving the protein folding problem is one of the most challenging tasks in the post genomic era. Identification of folding-initiation sites is very important in order to understand the protein folding mechanism. Detection of residual structure in unfolded proteins can yield important clues to the initiation sites in protein folding. A substantial number of studied proteins possess residual structure in hydrophobic regions clustered together in the protein core. These stable structures can work as seeds in the folding process. In addition, local preferences for secondary structure in the form of turns for beta-sheet initiation and helical turns for alpha-helix formation can guide the folding reaction. In this respect the unfolded states, studied at increasing structural resolution, can be the Rosetta Stone of the protein folding problem.

Thermodynamics of a beta-hairpin structure: evidence for cooperative formation of folding nucleus

To elucidate early nucleation stages in protein folding, multi-probed thermodynamic characterization was applied to the beta-hairpin structural formation of G-peptide, which is a C-terminal fragment of the B1 domain of streptococcal protein G. The segment corresponding to the sequence of G-peptide is believed to act as a nucleus during the folding process of the B1 domain. In spite of the broad thermal transition of G-peptide, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) melting measurements combined with our original analytical theory enabled us to obtain the thermodynamic properties of the beta-hairpin formation with considerable accuracy. Additionally, all the thermodynamic properties determined by every NMR probe on both the main-chain and the side-chains were quite similar, and also comparable to the values that were independently determined by calorimetric analysis of G-peptide. These results demonstrate that G-peptide folds cooperatively throughout the molecule. In other words, the formation of the beta-hairpin is interpreted as the fashion of a first-order phase transition between two states without any distinguishable intermediates. This cooperative formation of the short linear peptide consisting of only 16 residues provides insight into not only the first folding events of the B1 domain, but also the general principles of proteins in terms of structural hierarchy, stability and folding mechanism.

De novo design of a monomeric three-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet

Here we describe the NMR conformational study of a 20-residue linear peptide designed to fold into a monomeric three-stranded antiparallel beta-sheet in aqueous solution. Experimental and statistical data on amino acid beta-turn and beta-sheet propensities, cross-strand side-chain interactions, solubility criteria, and our previous experience with beta-hairpins were considered for a rational selection of the peptide sequence. Sedimentation equilibrium measurements and NMR dilution experiments provide evidence that the peptide is monomeric. Analysis of 1H and 13C-NMR parameters of the peptide, in particular NOEs and chemical shifts, and comparison with data obtained for two 12-residue peptides encompassing the N- and C-segments of the designed sequence indicates that the 20-residue peptide folds into the expected conformation. Assuming a two-state model, the exchange kinetics between the beta-sheet and the unfolded peptide molecules is in a suitable range to estimate the folding rate on the basis of the NMR linewidths of several resonances. The time constant for the coil-beta-sheet transition is of the order of several microseconds in the designed peptide. Future designs based on this peptide system are expected to contribute greatly to our knowledge of the many factors involved in beta-sheet formation and stability.

Role of a nonnative interaction in the folding of the protein G B1 domain as inferred from the conformational analysis of the alpha-helix fragment

BACKGROUND

The role of local interactions in protein folding and stability can be investigated by the conformational analysis of protein fragments. The hydrophobic staple and Schellman motifs have been described at the N and C terminus, respectively, of protein alpha-helices. These motifs are characterized by an interaction between two hydrophobic residues, one outside the helix and one within the helix, and their importance for helix stability has been analyzed in model peptides. In the alpha-helix of the protein G B1 domain, only the Schellman motif is formed--the hydrophobic staple motif is absent despite the favourable sequence pattern. We have experimentally analyzed the solution conformation of the 19-41 fragment of protein G. This peptide comprises the helical residues and contains both the hydrophobic staple and Schellman motif sequences.

RESULTS

In the isolated peptide in water, the hydrophobic staple motif is formed and stabilizes the helical structure as compared with a shorter peptide lacking it, but the Schellman motif is not formed. In 30% aqueous TFE, the helix is more stable than in pure water and both motifs are formed.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that the importance of each motif for the folding and stability of protein G is different. The nonnative hydrophobic staple interaction can help to nucleate the helix at the beginning of folding but has later to be disrupted. The Schellman motif, while not providing enough energy for substantial helix stabilization in the unfolded state, could be important for determining the local fold of the sequence in the context of the rest of the protein.

Protein folding and wring resonances

The polypeptide chain of a protein is shown to obey topological constraints which enable long range excitations in the form of wring modes of the protein backbone. Wring modes of proteins of specific lengths can therefore resonate with molecular modes present in the cell. It is suggested that protein folding takes place when the amplitude of a wring excitation becomes so large that it is energetically favorable to bend the protein backbone. The condition under which such structural transformations can occur is found, and it is shown that both cold and hot denaturation (the unfolding of proteins) are natural consequences of the suggested wring mode model. Native (folded) proteins are found to possess an intrinsic standing wring mode.

Coherent topological phenomena in protein folding

A theory is presented for coherent topological phenomena in protein dynamics with implications for protein folding and stability. We discuss the relationship to the writhing number used in knot diagrams of DNA. The winding state defines a long-range order along the backbone of a protein with long-range excitations, 'wring' modes, that play an important role in protein denaturation and stability. Energy can be pumped into these excitations, either thermally or by an external force.

A synthetic peptide from the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 integrase exhibits coiled-coil properties and interferes with the in vitro integration activity of the enzyme. Correlated biochemical and spectroscopic results

Integration of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) DNA into the host genome is catalysed by a virus-encoded protein integrase. Here, we report some of the structural and functional properties of two synthetic peptides: integrase-(147-175)-peptide reproducing the residues 147-175 (SQGVVESMNKELK159KIIGQVRDQAEHLKTAY) of the HIV-1 integrase, and [Pro159] integrase-(147-175)-peptide where the lysine 159 is substituted for a proline. Circular dichroism revealed that both peptides are mostly under unordered conformation in aqueous solution, contrasting with the alpha-helix exhibited by residues 147-175 in the protein crystal structure. In a weak alpha-helix-promoting environment, integrase-(147-175)-peptide self-associated into stable coiled-coil oligomers, while [Pro159] integrase-(147-175)-peptide did not. This property was further confirmed by cross-linking experiments. In our in vitro experiments, only integrase-(147-175)-peptide was able to reduce the integration activity of the enzyme. We propose that the inhibitory activity shown by integrase-(147-175)-peptide is dependent on its ability to bind to its counterpart in integrase through a peptide-protein coiled-coil structure disturbing the catalytic properties of the enzyme.

A short linear peptide derived from the N-terminal sequence of ubiquitin folds into a water-stable non-native beta-hairpin

A 16-residue peptide derived from the N-terminal sequence of ubiquitin forms a stable monomeric beta-hairpin that is estimated to be approximately 80% populated in aqueous solution. The peptide sequence has been modified from native ubiquitin by replacing the five residues found in a type I G1 bulged turn (Thr-Leu-Thr-Gly-Lys) with four residues (Asn-Pro-Asp-Gly) to maximize the probability of forming a beta-turn. Unexpectedly, the bulged turn conformation is re-established in the beta-hairpin in solution with two consequences: a one-amino acid frameshift in the alignment of the peptide main chain occurs relative to the native hairpin, and side chains formerly on opposite faces of the hairpin are brought together on the same face. The presence of the bulged turn in native ubiquitin may help in the avoidance of the stable non-native register of amino acids found here which would be unproductive for folding.

Tolerance to amino acid variations in peptides binding to the major histocompatibility complex class I protein H-2Kb

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules are cell-surface glycoproteins that bind peptides and present them to T cells. The formation of a peptide-MHC complex is the initial step in specific, T cell-mediated immune responses. But, unlike other receptor-ligand systems, peptides are essential for a stable conformation of the MHC proteins. To investigate the contribution of every amino acid of octapeptides to the stability and antigenic integrity of MHC proteins, complex octapeptide libraries with one defined amino acid and mixtures of 19 amino acids in the remaining seven positions were synthesized and tested for their capacity to stabilize the conformation of the mouse MHC class I molecule H-2Kb. Peptide transporter-deficient RMA-S cells were employed in this study. Amino acid preferences found for the eight sequence positions reveal constitutional, volumetric, and steric constraints that govern peptide selection by MHC molecules. The pattern of amino acid preferences indicates that the peptides behave as integral parts of the MHC proteins and follow rules established for the interrelationship of primary sequence and the conformation and stability of proteins in general.

A peptide fragment of human DNA topoisomerase II alpha forms a stable coiled-coil structure in solution

Results are presented on a peptide fragment (1013-1056) from human DNA topoisomerase II alpha. This was selected using the procedure of Lupas et al. (Lupas, A., Van Dyke, M., and Stock, J. (1991) Science 252, 1162-1164) for its potential to adopt a stable coiled-coil structure. The same theoretical treatment rejected the segment 994-1021 proposed by Zwelling and Perry (Zwelling, L. A., and Perry, W. M. (1989) Mol. Endocrinol. 3, 603-604) as a possible core for leucine-zipper formation. Our experimental studies combine cross-linking and CD analysis. Cross-linking establishes that the 1013-1056 fragment forms a stable homodimer in solution. Effects of increasing peptide concentration on CD spectra confirm that only the 1013-1056 fragment can undergo a coiled-coil stabilization from an isolated alpha-helix. Unfolding experiments further show that the coiled-coil is more stable in guanidium chloride than in urea. Values of -6.8 and -7.4 kcal/mol for the dimerization free energy are determined by thermal and urea unfolding, respectively. These are strikingly similar to the value recently found for the dissociation/reassociation of the entire yeast topoisomerase II from sedimentation equilibrium experiments (Lamhasni, S., Larsen, A. K., Barray, M., Monnot, M., Delain, E., and Fermandjian, S. (1995) Biochemistry 34, 3632-3639), although their significance relatively to topoisomerase II undoubtedly requires further analysis.

Folding of protein G B1 domain studied by the conformational characterization of fragments comprising its secondary structure elements

The solution structure of the isolated fragments 1-20 (beta-hairpin), 21-40 (alpha-helix) and 41-56 (beta-hairpin), corresponding to all the secondary structure elements of the protein G B1 domain, have been studied by circular dichroism and nuclear magnetic resonance techniques. In the protein G B1-(1-20) fragment turn-like folded structures were detected in water though low populated. In the presence of 30% aqueous trifluoroethanol there is a complex conformational behaviour in which a helical structure at the N-terminal half is formed in equilibrium with random and native-like beta-hairpin structures. The peptide corresponding to the alpha-helix is predominantly unstructured in water, while in 30% trifluoroethanol it highly populates a native alpha-helical conformation, including a (i,i + 5) interaction between hydrophobic residues at its C-terminus. The third peptide was previously reported to form a monomeric native beta-hairpin structure in water [Blanco, F. J., Rivas, G. & Serrano, L. (1994a) Nature Struc. Biol. 1, 584-590]. We show in this work that the beta-hairpin structure is further stabilized in 30% trifluoroethanol and destabilised in the presence of 6 M urea, though some folded structure persists even in these highly denaturing conditions. The conformational properties of these peptides suggests that the second beta-hairpin could be an important folding initiation site on which the rest of the chain folds. Reconstitution experiments failed to show evidence of interaction between the peptides. Algorithms designed to predict the helical and extended conformations of peptides in aqueous solution successfully describe the complicated behaviour of these peptides. Comparison of the predicted and the experimental results with those for a structurally related protein, ubiquitin, shows very strong similarities, the main difference being the switch of the most stable beta-hairpin from the N-terminus in ubiquitin to the C-terminus in protein G.

A short linear peptide that folds into a native stable beta-hairpin in aqueous solution

The conformational properties of a 16 residue peptide, corresponding to the second beta-hairpin of the B1 domain of protein G, have been studied by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR). This fragment is monomeric under our experimental conditions and in pure water adopts a population containing up to 40% native-like beta-hairpin structure. The detection by NMR of a native-like beta-hairpin in aqueous solution, reported here for the first time, indicates that these structural elements may have an important role in the early steps of protein folding. It also provides a good model to study in detail the sequence determinants of beta-hairpin structure stability, as has been done with alpha-helices.

A CD study of the alpha-helix nucleation hypothesis

One of the dilemmas in predicting the secondary structure of proteins from their amino acid propensity for a given conformation is the presence of all amino acids in all types of secondary structure, regardless of their propensity for that specific structure. One explanation is the nucleation hypothesis that only a few residues with a strong propensity for the secondary structure, such as the alpha-helix structure, initiates its formation and propagates the structure through indifferent sequences until strong breakers terminate the growth on both ends. Eight 15-mer peptides were studied to examine the alpha-helix nucleation hypothesis. The nucleation sequence of VAEAK, with high helix propensity, was mixed with an indifferent sequence of TSDSR in all possible permutations. From the percent alpha-helix structure derived from the CD at 222 nm, it appears that helicity does not propagate through the indifferent sequence.

Unfolding and refolding of the native structure of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor studied by computer simulations

A new procedure for studying the folding and unfolding of proteins, with an application to bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI), is reported. The unfolding and refolding of the native structure of the protein are characterized by the dimensions of the protein, expressed in terms of the three principal radii of the structure considered as an ellipsoid. A dynamic equation, describing the variations of the principal radii on the unfolding path, and a numerical procedure to solve this equation are proposed. Expanded and distorted conformations are refolded to the native structure by a dimensional-constraint energy minimization procedure. A unique and reproducible unfolding pathway for an intermediate of BPTI lacking the [30,51] disulfide bond is obtained. The resulting unfolded conformations are extended; they contain near-native local structure, but their longest principal radii are more than 2.5 times greater than that of the native structure. The most interesting finding is that the majority of expanded conformations, generated under various conditions, can be refolded closely to the native structure, as measured by the correct overall chain fold, by the rms deviations from the native structure of only 1.9-3.1 A, and by the energy differences of about 10 kcal/mol from the native structure. Introduction of the [30,51] disulfide bond at this stage, followed by minimization, improves the closeness of the refolded structures to the native structure, reducing the rms deviations to 0.9-2.0 A. The unique refolding of these expanded structures over such a large conformational space implies that the folding is strongly dictated by the interactions in the amino acid sequence of BPTI. The simulations indicate that, under conditions that favor a compact structure as mimicked by the volume constraints in our algorithm, the expanded conformations have a strong tendency to move toward the native structure; therefore, they probably would be favorable folding intermediates. The results presented here support a general model for protein folding, i.e., progressive formation of partially folded structural units, followed by collapse to the compact native structure. The general applicability of the procedure is also discussed.

Stable submolecular folding units in a non-compact form of cytochrome c

Studies of structure, dynamics, and stability of cytochrome c (cyt c) at low pH in a non-compact pre-molten globule state indicate that the protein contains submolecular folding units that are independently stable. In high salt, acid cyt c (pD 2.2; where D is deuterium) is nearly as compact as the native form. Nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) line broadening typical of the molten globule form is seen, indicating loosened packing and increased mobility not only for side-chains but also for the main chain. As NaCl concentration is decreased below 0.05 M, cyt c expands due to the deshielding of electrostatic repulsions, attaining a linear extent perhaps double that of the native protein (viscosity, fluorescence). In the extended form, tertiary structural hydrogen bonds are largely broken (hydrogen exchange rate), some normally buried parts of the protein are exposed to water (fluorescence), and many of the native side-chain contacts must be lost. Nevertheless, almost all of the helical content is retained (circular dichroism). The helices involve the same amino acid residues that are helical in the native state (hydrogen exchange labeling monitored by 2-dimensional n.m.r.). The equilibrium constant for helix formation at 20 degrees C (0.02 M-NaCl, pD 2.2) is about 10 (hydrogen exchange rate), even though the individual helical segments when isolated have little or no structure. Additional experiments were done to check assumptions and calibrate parameters that underlie the hydrogen exchange analysis of protein folding. These results indicate that the native-like helical segments in the expanded non-globular form of cyt c exist as part of somewhat larger submolecular folding units that possess significant equilibrium stability. Results from equilibrium and kinetic studies of protein folding support the generality of this conclusion. This view is contrary to the two-state paradigm for equilibrium folding and inconsistent with the idea that side-chain packing constraints determine folding motifs. The result suggests an extension of the thermodynamic hypothesis for protein structure to kinetic folding processes, so that the amino acid code for equilibrium and kinetic folding may be the same, and also seems pertinent to the biological evolution of contemporary protein structures.

Nucleation in protein folding--confusion of structure and process

The term 'nucleation' is currently used to denote two distinctly different aspects of folding: the kinetic and the structural. This gives rise to ambiguity in the use of the word 'nucleation', which is compounded by the fact that the word 'nuclei', as used in the structural sense, has more aliases than cats have lives.

Unfolding behavior of human alpha 1-acid glycoprotein is compatible with a loosely folded region in its polypeptide chain

The unfolding of human plasma alpha 1-acid glycoprotein (AGP) induced by heat or guanidine hydrochloride was studied under equilibrium conditions. In thermal unfolding, an intermediate state was detected by the appearance of unusual positive difference absorption bands in the 287-295-nm region, which occurred at lower temperatures than the common denaturation bands at 284 and 291 nm. The formation of this intermediate species apparently involves a local conformational change that perturbs the environment of tryptophyl residues, without affecting the secondary structure of the protein as judged from circular dichroism spectra. On the other hand, denaturation of the glycoprotein induced by guanidine hydrochloride seemed to follow a two-state model with no evidence of any intermediate species; however, the analysis of the transition curve indicated that the change in the accessibility to solvent of amino acid residues of AGP upon unfolding is significantly lower than those observed for other proteins. According to these results, it is proposed that part of the polypeptide chain in native AGP, namely, that from residue 122 to the C-terminus, may be "loosely" folded.

Solution structure of the isolated ribonuclease C-terminal 112-124 fragment

The conformational properties of the ribonuclease C-terminal 112-124 fragment have been studied by CD and 1H- and 13C-NMR in an attempt to determine whether native secondary structure elements other than alpha-helices have stability enough to be detected when isolated in aqueous solution. Only sequential alpha N and intraresidue NOE cross-peaks are observed in the NOESY spectra, a fact which points towards an essentially extended polypeptidic chain. Observed spectral variations with temperature, pH and urea addition allowed the identification of two non-random regions within the chain. The first one is located within residues 119-121, the same region where a native salt bridge (H119...D121) exists in the native protein, and the stability of that structure is affected by the protonation state of carboxylate groups. The second one involves the S123 and V124 residues at the C-terminal end. No signs of the native 112-115 beta-turn were detected which suggests that, in contrast to alpha-helices, long range interactions may be needed to stabilize these secondary structure elements.

Characterization of low populated peptide helical structures in solution by means of NMR proton conformational shifts

A NOE independent NMR method is proposed to characterize unambiguously residues involved in low populated isolated peptide helices. The method is based on the comparison of amide and H alpha chemical shift changes originated upon the addition of stabilizing or denaturing agents with true helical conformational shifts that have been measured for the first time using an isolated model peptide helix, the one formed by Ac-(Leu-Lys-Lys-Leu)3-NHEt in aqueous solution.

Synthesis and biophysical characterization of engineered topographic immunogenic determinants with alpha alpha topology

Model peptides with predetermined secondary, tertiary, and quaternary conformation have been successfully designed, synthesized, and characterized in an attempt to mimic the three-dimensional structure of an antigenic determinant. This work is a continuing effort to map the antigenic structure of the protein antigen lactate dehydrogenase C4 (LDH-C4) to develop a contraceptive vaccine. A putative topographic determinant with alpha alpha topology which associates into four-helix bundles was designed on the basis of the framework model of protein folding. An idealized amphiphilic 18-residue sequence (alpha 1) and a 40-residue alpha alpha fold (alpha 3) have been shown to form stable 4-helix structures in solution with a free energy of association on the order of -20.8 kcal/mol (tetramerization of alpha 1) and -7.8 kcal/mol (dimerization of alpha 3). Both alpha 1 and alpha 3 form stable monolayers at the air-water interface. The CD spectra of Langmuir-Blodgett monolayers are characteristically alpha-helical. Both CD and FTIR spectroscopic studies reval a high degree of secondary structure. The SAXS data strongly suggest that the helices are arranged in a four-helix bundle since the radius of gyration of 17.2 A and the vector distribution function are indicative of a prolate ellipsoid of axial dimensions and molecular weight appropriate for the four-helix bundle. The major contribution to the formation and stabilization of alpha 1 and alpha 3 is believed to be hydrophobic interaction between the amphiphilic alpha-helices. The displayed heptad repeat, helix dipole, ion pairs, and the loop sequence may have also contributed to the overall stability and antiparallel packing of the helices. A detailed structural analysis of a relevant topographic immunogenic determinant will elucidate the nature of antigen-antibody interactions as well as provide insight into protein folding intermediates.

The construction of new proteins: V. A template-assembled synthetic protein (TASP) containing both a 4-helix bundle and beta-barrel-like structure

The construction of a template-assembled synthetic protein (TASP) designed to contain both a 4-helix bundle and a beta-barrel as two folding "domains" is described. For the de novo design of proteins, amphiphilic helices (alpha) and beta-sheets (beta) are covalently attached to a template peptide (T) carrying functional side chains suitably oriented to promote intramolecular folding of the secondary structure blocks into a characteristic packing arrangement, i.e., T8-(4 alpha)(4 beta). The design of this new macromolecule was assisted by computer modeling, which suggested a low-energy conformation with tight hydrophobic packing of the secondary structure subunits. Solid-phase synthesis of the "two-domain" TASP molecule was achieved using orthogonal protection techniques. The solution properties as well as circular dichroism (CD) and infrared spectroscopy (IR) data under various experimental conditions are consistent with the folded conformation suggested by modeling.

Renaturation of guanidine-unfolded tryptophan synthase by multi-mixing stopped-flow dilution in D2O

Guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) at high concentrations, e.g. 4 to 8 M, has been used extensively to promote reversible denaturation of several proteins. The refolding is induced by removal of the denaturing agent by diluting the denatured protein at least 50-100-fold in a 'renaturation buffer'. Fast kinetic studies, using a stopped-flow apparatus to achieve such dilutions, are difficult for two reasons: firstly, injecting widely different volumes of the two reagents does not afford a proper mixing. Secondly, the density differences existing between the concentrated GdnHCl solution and the renaturation buffer often causes important mixing and redistribution artefacts particularly in vertical stopped-flows. Here, it is shown that these difficulties can be overcome by using a multi-mixing stopped-flow to achieve 2 successive 7-fold dilutions and by using heavy water (D2O) to adjust the density of the renaturation buffer. This enabled us to study the appearance of a short-lived intermediate during the folding of the beta 2-subunit of Escherichia coli tryptophan synthase.

Conformational properties of the isolated 1-23 fragment of human hemoglobin alpha-chain

With the purpose of establishing whether, as a general rule, regions of a protein chain that are helical in the native structure maintain, at least partially, the same helical structure when isolated in solution, we have prepared the 1-23 fragment of human hemoglobin alpha-chain, and studied its conformational properties in aqueous solution by CD and 1H-NMR. From the analysis of CD and NMR spectral changes with temperature, salt and addition of trifluoroethanol (TFE) it can be concluded that the 1-23 peptide forms a measurable population (18% at 22 degrees C (pH 5.6) TFE/H2O, 30:70 (v/v)) of an alpha-helix structure that spans the same residues that are helical in the native protein (namely, 6 to 17). These results, taken together with similar ones obtained previously in the 1-19, 21-42 and 50-61 RNAase fragments, support the idea that no helices other than the native ones are actually formed in solution by protein fragments. This implies that the final helical structure of a protein is present from the very beginning of the folding process, and also that such elements of secondary structure can act as primary nucleation centers.

Refolding of bacteriorhodopsin. Protease V8 fragmentation and chromophore reconstitution from proteolytic V8 fragments

Staphylococcus aureus protease V8 cleaves bacteriorhodopsin to two main fragments, V-1 and V-2. Proteolytic digestion of the purple membrane integrated protein is carried out in the presence of limited amounts of sodium dodecyl sulfate (0.5 g detergent/g bacteriorhodopsin). The fragment V-1 includes the arylisothiocyanate binding site (Lys41). The V-2 fragment comprises the two C-terminal transmembrane segments of bacteriorhodopsin. Improved renaturation of bacteriorhodopsin and the ternary complex, reformed from its V8 proteolytic fragments, is attained by peptide extraction in chloroform/methanol/0.1 M ammonium acetate and subsequent incorporation into phospholipid/detergent micelles. In the presence of retinal, V8 fragments reform chromophoric ternary complexes. Light-adapted reconstituted chromophores absorb incident light at 560 nm. Protein secondary structures are partially conserved in the course of solvent extraction and are restored in the reconstituted system. Vesicles prepared from the reconstituted complexes show light-dependent proton translocation activity.

Conformation of peptide fragments of proteins in aqueous solution: implications for initiation of protein folding

Applications of sensitive new technologies, in particular, two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy, have allowed detection of folded structures in short peptide fragments of proteins in aqueous solution under conditions where native proteins fold. These structures are in rapid dynamic exchange with unfolded states. These observations provide evidence in support of models for protein folding which postulate localized regions of folded structure as initiation sites for the folding process. Since these initiation processes are expected to be rapid, such models are consistent with kinetic evidence that the rate-determining steps of protein folding occur late in the process and probably involve rearrangement of incorrectly folded intermediates.

On the relevance of non-random polypeptide conformations for protein folding

The possibility that any non-random conformation in reduced bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI) and ribonuclease A might be significant for folding has been considered, using the experimental data available on forming the first disulphide bond in each. It is a thermodynamic necessity that whatever conformation stabilises a particular disulphide bond be stabilised to the same extent by the presence of the disulphide. The stabilising effects of disulphides are known approximately, so the stability of any non-random conformation found in a one-disulphide intermediate can be estimated in the absence of the disulphide bond. The non-random conformation in the BPTI intermediates is sufficiently labile to indicate that it would be expected to be present in no more than 5% of the reduced BPTI molecules. There is much less non-random conformation apparent in ribonuclease A. Whatever conformations are represented in the bulk of these two reduced proteins cannot favour disulphide formation and further productive folding.

Structure of P401 (mast cell degranulating peptide) in solution

P401 (also known as mast cell degranulating protein, MCD) is a minor component of honeybee venom. Its primary structure is related to that of apamin. We have studied the structure of P401 in solution by high-resolution two-dimensional 1H-NMR spectroscopy. Almost all the backbone proton resonances have been assigned by sequential assignment strategy. Analysis of NOEs shows that P401 has a conformation very similar to that of apamin. N-terminal residues Ile-1-Cys-5 are in an extended conformation and residues His-13-Asn-22 on the C-terminus are in an alpha-helical structure. These two secondary structural elements are connected by two tight turns.

Conformational role of His-12 in C-peptide of ribonuclease A

Possible interactions of the His-12 ring with other side chain and backbone groups of C-peptide lactone (CPL) are discussed. The works published so far are critically reviewed and compared with the latest results obtained by the authors. The main new conclusion is that in the helical conformation of CPL, the Phe-8 and His-12 rings are clustered together. Studies of Phe-8----Ala analogs of CPL and calculations of ring current effects satisfactorily explain the observed environmental shifts of Phe-8 and His-12 protons in NMR spectra of CPL. Interaction between both rings is favorable for alpha-helix formation, but cannot explain an increase in helix stability related with protonation of His-12. This effect arises from favorable interactions of the charged His+-12 ring with the helix backbone.

Strategy for obtaining non-native protein structures using antibody cross-reactions

Antibodies made to short peptides or to unfolded forms of proteins are often found to cross-react with intact proteins. These cross-reactions can be used to populate non-native protein conformations, possibly including protein folding intermediates, and the structures of the non-native conformations can be characterized using amide proton exchange and two-dimensional NMR.

Thermodynamic study of the apomyoglobin structure

Sperm whale apomyoglobin has been studied thermodynamically in solutions with different pH and temperature by scanning microcalorimetry, viscosimetry, nuclear magnetic resonance and circular dichroism spectrometry, and by electrometric and calorimetric titration. It has been shown that apomyoglobin in solutions with pH close to neutral has a compact and unique spatial structure with an extended hydrophobic core. This structure is maximally stable at about 30 degrees C and breaks down reversibly both upon heating or cooling from this temperature. The process of breakdown of this structure is highly co-operative and can be regarded as a transition between two macroscopic states of protein, the native and denatured states. In contrast to the native state, which is specified by definite values of compactness and ellipticity, the compactness and ellipticity of the denatured state of apomyoglobin depend strongly on pH; with a decrease of pH below 4.0, these parameters gradually approach the values of the random coil.

Helix signals in proteins

The alpha helix, first proposed by Pauling and co-workers, is a hallmark of protein structure, and much effort has been directed toward understanding which sequences can form helices. The helix hypothesis, introduced here, provides a tentative answer to this question. The hypothesis states that a necessary condition for helix formation is the presence of residues flanking the helix termini whose side chains can form hydrogen bonds with the initial four-helix greater than N-H groups and final four-helix greater than C-O groups; these eight groups would otherwise lack intrahelical partners. This simple hypothesis implies the existence of a stereochemical code in which certain sequences have the hydrogen-bonding capacity to function as helix boundaries and thereby enable the helix to form autonomously. The three-dimensional structure of a protein is a consequence of the genetic code, but the rules relating sequence to structure are still unknown. The ensuing analysis supports the idea that a stereochemical code for the alpha helix resides in its boundary residues.

Folding of the nascent peptide chain into a biologically active protein

The refolding of denatured proteins with complete sequences may not be fast enough to account for the in vivo folding of growing peptide chains during biosynthesis. As some peptide fragments have secondary structures not unlike those of the corresponding segments in the intact molecules and native disulfide bonds of some proteins can form cotranslationally, it is suggested that the folding of the nascent chain begins early during synthesis. However, further adjustments may be necessary during chain elongation and after posttranslational modifications of the completed peptide chain to generate the native conformation of a biologically active protein.

Preferred conformational state of the N-terminus section of a bovine growth hormone fragment (residues 96-133) in water is an omega loop

The solution structure of a 38-amino-acid-residue, biologically active fragment of bovine growth hormone (bGH96-133) was investigated with a combined nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and computer modeling approach. With the distance geometry program DISGEO and distance constraints derived from nuclear Overhauser enhancement (NOE) experiments, it was found that residues Ser-100 to Tyr-110 circumscribe and omega-loop, a recently categorized feature of nonregular secondary protein structure.