Beat the clock: paradigms for NTPases in the maintenance of biological fidelity

An ATP-independent role for Prp16 in promoting aberrant splicing

The spliceosome is assembled through a step-wise process of binding and release of its components to and from the pre-mRNA. The remodeling process is facilitated by eight DExD/H-box RNA helicases, some of which have also been implicated in splicing fidelity control. In this study, we unveil a contrasting role for the prototypic splicing proofreader, Prp16, in promoting the utilization of aberrant 5' splice sites and mutated branchpoints. Prp16 is not essential for the branching reaction in wild-type pre-mRNA. However, when a mutation is present at the 5' splice site or if Cwc24 is absent, Prp16 facilitates the reaction and encourages aberrant 5' splice site usage independently of ATP. Prp16 also promotes the utilization of mutated branchpoints while preventing the use of nearby cryptic branch sites. Our study demonstrates that Prp16 can either enhance or impede the utilization of faulty splice sites by stabilizing or destabilizing interactions with other splicing components. Thus, Prp16 exerts dual roles in 5' splice site and branch site selection, via ATP-dependent and ATP-independent activities. Furthermore, we provide evidence that these functions of Prp16 are mediated through the step-one factor Cwc25.

A Peek Inside the Machines of Bacterial Nucleotide Excision Repair

Double stranded DNA (dsDNA), the repository of genetic information in bacteria, archaea and eukaryotes, exhibits a surprising instability in the intracellular environment; this fragility is exacerbated by exogenous agents, such as ultraviolet radiation. To protect themselves against the severe consequences of DNA damage, cells have evolved at least six distinct DNA repair pathways. Here, we review recent key findings of studies aimed at understanding one of these pathways: bacterial nucleotide excision repair (NER). This pathway operates in two modes: a global genome repair (GGR) pathway and a pathway that closely interfaces with transcription by RNA polymerase called transcription-coupled repair (TCR). Below, we discuss the architecture of key proteins in bacterial NER and recent biochemical, structural and single-molecule studies that shed light on the lesion recognition steps of both the GGR and the TCR sub-pathways. Although a great deal has been learned about both of these sub-pathways, several important questions, including damage discrimination, roles of ATP and the orchestration of protein binding and conformation switching, remain to be addressed.

ATP Hydrolysis by the SNF2 Domain of Dnmt5 Is Coupled to Both Specific Recognition and Modification of Hemimethylated DNA

C.neoformans Dnmt5 is an unusually specific maintenance-type CpG methyltransferase (DNMT) that mediates long-term epigenome evolution. It harbors a DNMT domain and SNF2 ATPase domain. We find that the SNF2 domain couples substrate specificity to an ATPase step essential for DNA methylation. Coupling occurs independent of nucleosomes. Hemimethylated DNA preferentially stimulates ATPase activity, and mutating Dnmt5's ATP-binding pocket disproportionately reduces ATPase stimulation by hemimethylated versus unmethylated substrates. Engineered DNA substrates that stabilize a reaction intermediate by mimicking a "flipped-out" conformation of the target cytosine bypass the SNF2 domain's requirement for hemimethylation. This result implies that ATP hydrolysis by the SNF2 domain is coupled to the DNMT domain conformational changes induced by preferred substrates. These findings establish a new role for a SNF2 ATPase: controlling an adjoined enzymatic domain's substrate recognition and catalysis. We speculate that this coupling contributes to the exquisite specificity of Dnmt5 via mechanisms related to kinetic proofreading.

An Allosteric Network for Spliceosome Activation Revealed by High-Throughput Suppressor Analysis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Selection of suppressor mutations that correct growth defects caused by substitutions in an RNA or protein can reveal functionally important molecular structures and interactions in living cells. This approach is particularly useful for the study of complex biological pathways involving many macromolecules, such as premessenger RNA (pre-mRNA) splicing. When a sufficiently large number of suppressor mutations is obtained and structural information is available, it is possible to generate detailed models of molecular function. However, the laborious and expensive task of identifying suppressor mutations in whole-genome selections limits the utility of this approach. Here I show that a custom targeted sequencing panel can greatly accelerate the identification of suppressor mutations in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae genome. Using a panel that targets 112 genes encoding pre-mRNA splicing factors, I identified 27 unique mutations in six protein-coding genes that each overcome the cold-sensitive block to spliceosome activation caused by a substitution in U4 small nuclear RNA. When mapped to existing structures of spliceosomal complexes, the identified suppressors implicate specific molecular contacts between the proteins Brr2, Prp6, Prp8, Prp31, Sad1, and Snu114 as functionally important in an early step of catalytic activation of the spliceosome. This approach shows great promise for elucidating the allosteric cascade of molecular interactions that direct accurate and efficient pre-mRNA splicing and should be broadly useful for understanding the dynamics of other complex biological assemblies or pathways.

A central role of Cwc25 in spliceosome dynamics during the catalytic phase of pre-mRNA splicing

Splicing of precursor mRNA occurs via two consecutive steps of transesterification reaction; both require ATP and several proteins. Despite the energy requirement in the catalytic phase, incubation of the purified spliceosome under proper ionic conditions can elicit competitive reversible transesterification, debranching, and spliced-exon-reopening reactions without the necessity for ATP or other factors, suggesting that small changes in the conformational state of the spliceosome can lead to disparate chemical consequences for the substrate. We show here that Cwc25 plays a central role in modulating the conformational state of the catalytic spliceosome during normal splicing reactions. Cwc25 binds tightly to the spliceosome after the reaction and is then removed from the spliceosome, which normally requires DExD/H-box protein Prp16 and ATP hydrolysis, to allow the occurrence of the second reaction. When deprived of Cwc25, the purified first-step spliceosome catalyzes both forward and reverse splicing reactions under normal splicing conditions without requiring energy. Both reactions are inhibited when Cwc25 is added back, presumably due to the stabilization of first-step conformation. Prp16 is dispensable for the second reaction when splicing is carried out under conditions that destabilize Cwc25. We also show that the purified precatalytic spliceosome can catalyze two steps of the reaction at a low efficiency without requiring Cwc25, Slu7, or Prp18 when incubated under proper conditions. Our study reveals conformational modulation of the spliceosome by Cwc25 and Prp16 in stabilization and destabilization of first-step conformation, respectively, to facilitate the splicing process.

SF3B1/Hsh155 HEAT motif mutations affect interaction with the spliceosomal ATPase Prp5, resulting in altered branch site selectivity in pre-mRNA splicing

Mutations in the U2 snRNP component SF3B1 are prominent in myelodysplastic syndromes (MDSs) and other cancers and have been shown recently to alter branch site (BS) or 3' splice site selection in splicing. However, the molecular mechanism of altered splicing is not known. We show here that hsh155 mutant alleles in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, counterparts of SF3B1 mutations frequently found in cancers, specifically change splicing of suboptimal BS pre-mRNA substrates. We found that Hsh155p interacts directly with Prp5p, the first ATPase that acts during spliceosome assembly, and localized the interacting regions to HEAT (Huntingtin, EF3, PP2A, and TOR1) motifs in SF3B1 associated with disease mutations. Furthermore, we show that mutations in these motifs from both human disease and yeast genetic screens alter the physical interaction with Prp5p, alter branch region specification, and phenocopy mutations in Prp5p. These and other data demonstrate that mutations in Hsh155p and Prp5p alter splicing because they change the direct physical interaction between Hsh155p and Prp5p. This altered physical interaction results in altered loading (i.e., "fidelity") of the BS-U2 duplex into the SF3B complex during prespliceosome formation. These results provide a mechanistic framework to explain the consequences of intron recognition and splicing of SF3B1 mutations found in disease.

Regulation of gene expression through inefficient splicing of U12-type introns

U12-type introns are a rare class of nuclear introns that are removed by a dedicated U12-dependent spliceosome and are thought to regulate the expression of their target genes owing through their slower splicing reaction. Recent genome-wide studies on the splicing of U12-type introns are now providing new insights on the biological significance of this parallel splicing machinery. The new studies cover multiple different organisms and experimental systems, including human patient cells with mutations in the components of the minor spliceosome, zebrafish with similar mutations and various experimentally manipulated human cells and Arabidopsis plants. Here, we will discuss the potential implications of these studies on the understanding of the mechanism and regulation of the minor spliceosome, as well as their medical implications.

Functional roles of DExD/H-box RNA helicases in Pre-mRNA splicing

Splicing of precursor mRNA takes place via two consecutive steps of transesterification catalyzed by a large ribonucleoprotein complex called the spliceosome. The spliceosome is assembled through ordered binding to the pre-mRNA of five small nuclear RNAs and numerous protein factors, and is disassembled after completion of the reaction to recycle all components. Throughout the splicing cycle, the spliceosome changes its structure, rearranging RNA-RNA, RNA-protein and protein-protein interactions, for positioning and repositioning of splice sites. DExD/H-box RNA helicases play important roles in mediating structural changes of the spliceosome by unwinding of RNA duplexes or disrupting RNA-protein interactions. DExD/H-box proteins are also implicated in the fidelity control of the splicing process at various steps. This review summarizes the functional roles of DExD/H-box proteins in pre-mRNA splicing according to studies conducted mostly in yeast and will discuss the concept of the complicated splicing reaction based on recent findings.

The G-patch protein Spp2 couples the spliceosome-stimulated ATPase activity of the DEAH-box protein Prp2 to catalytic activation of the spliceosome

Structural rearrangement of the activated spliceosome (B^act) to yield a catalytically active complex (B*) is mediated by the DEAH-box NTPase Prp2 in cooperation with the G-patch protein Spp2. Warkocki et al. demonstrate that Spp2 is not required to recruit Prp2 to its bona fide binding site in the B^act spliceosome. However, transformation of the B^act to the B* spliceosome occurs only when Spp2 is present and is accompanied by dissociation of Prp2 and a reduction in its NTPase activity.

Structural rearrangement of the activated spliceosome (B^act) to yield a catalytically active complex (B*) is mediated by the DEAH-box NTPase Prp2 in cooperation with the G-patch protein Spp2. However, how the energy of ATP hydrolysis by Prp2 is coupled to mechanical work and what role Spp2 plays in this process are unclear. Using a purified splicing system, we demonstrate that Spp2 is not required to recruit Prp2 to its bona fide binding site in the B^act spliceosome. In the absence of Spp2, the B^act spliceosome efficiently triggers Prp2’s NTPase activity, but NTP hydrolysis is not coupled to ribonucleoprotein (RNP) rearrangements leading to catalytic activation of the spliceosome. Transformation of the B^act to the B* spliceosome occurs only when Spp2 is present and is accompanied by dissociation of Prp2 and a reduction in its NTPase activity. In the absence of spliceosomes, Spp2 enhances Prp2’s RNA-dependent ATPase activity without affecting its RNA affinity. Our data suggest that Spp2 plays a major role in coupling Prp2’s ATPase activity to remodeling of the spliceosome into a catalytically active machine.

A novel mechanism for Prp5 function in prespliceosome formation and proofreading the branch site sequence

The DEAD-box RNA helicase Prp5 is required for the formation of the prespliceosome through an ATP-dependent function to remodel U2 snRNPs and an ATP-independent function of unknown mechanism. Liang and Cheng show that Prp5 binds to the spliceosome in association with U2 by interacting with the branchpoint-interacting stem–loop and is released upon base-pairing of U2 with the branch site to allow the recruitment of the tri-snRNP.

The DEAD-box RNA helicase Prp5 is required for the formation of the prespliceosome through an ATP-dependent function to remodel U2 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particles (snRNPs) and an ATP-independent function of unknown mechanism. Prp5 has also been implicated in proofreading the branch site sequence, but the molecular mechanism has not been well characterized. Using actin precursor mRNA (pre-mRNA) carrying branch site mutations, we identified a Prp5-containing prespliceosome with Prp5 directly bound to U2 small nuclear RNA (snRNA). Prp5 is in contact with U2 in regions on and near the branchpoint-interacting stem–loop (BSL), suggesting that Prp5 may function in stabilizing the BSL. Regardless of its ATPase activity, Prp5 mutants that suppress branch site mutations associate with the spliceosome less tightly and allow more tri-snRNP binding for the reaction to proceed. Our results suggest a novel mechanism for how Prp5 functions in prespliceosome formation and proofreading of the branch site sequence. Prp5 binds to the spliceosome in association with U2 by interacting with the BSL and is released upon the base-pairing of U2 with the branch site to allow the recruitment of the tri-snRNP. Mutations impairing U2–branch site base-pairing retard Prp5 release and impede tri-snRNP association. Prp5 mutations that destabilize the Prp5–U2 interaction suppress branch site mutations by allowing progression of the pathway.

Global analysis of the nuclear processing of transcripts with unspliced U12-type introns by the exosome

U12-type introns are a rare class of introns in the genomes of diverse eukaryotes. In the human genome, they number over 700. A subset of these introns has been shown to be spliced at a slower rate compared to the major U2-type introns. This suggests a rate-limiting regulatory function for the minor spliceosome in the processing of transcripts containing U12-type introns. However, both the generality of slower splicing and the subsequent fate of partially processed pre-mRNAs remained unknown. Here, we present a global analysis of the nuclear retention of transcripts containing U12-type introns and provide evidence for the nuclear decay of such transcripts in human cells. Using SOLiD RNA sequencing technology, we find that, in normal cells, U12-type introns are on average 2-fold more retained than the surrounding U2-type introns. Furthermore, we find that knockdown of RRP41 and DIS3 subunits of the exosome stabilizes an overlapping set of U12-type introns. RRP41 knockdown leads to slower decay kinetics of U12-type introns and globally upregulates the retention of U12-type, but not U2-type, introns. Our results indicate that U12-type introns are spliced less efficiently and are targeted by the exosome. These characteristics support their role in the regulation of cellular mRNA levels.

The DExD/H-box ATPase Prp2p destabilizes and proofreads the catalytic RNA core of the spliceosome

After undergoing massive RNA and protein rearrangements during assembly, the spliceosome undergoes a final, more subtle, ATP-dependent rearrangement that is essential for catalysis. This rearrangement requires the DEAH-box protein Prp2p, an RNA-dependent ATPase. Prp2p has been implicated in destabilizing interactions between the spliceosome and the protein complexes SF3 and RES, but a role for Prp2p in destabilizing RNA-RNA interactions has not been explored. Using directed molecular genetics in budding yeast, we have found that a cold-sensitive prp2 mutation is suppressed not only by mutations in SF3 and RES components but also by a range of mutations that disrupt the spliceosomal catalytic core element U2/U6 helix I, which is implicated in juxtaposing the 5' splice site and branch site and in positioning metal ions for catalysis within the context of a putative catalytic triplex; indeed, mutations in this putative catalytic triplex also suppressed a prp2 mutation. Remarkably, we also found that prp2 mutations rescue lethal mutations in U2/U6 helix I. These data provide evidence that RNA elements that comprise the catalytic core are already formed at the Prp2p stage and that Prp2p destabilizes these elements, directly or indirectly, both to proofread spliceosome activation and to promote reconfiguration of the spliceosome to a fully competent, catalytic conformation.

Ribosome biogenesis in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Ribosomes are highly conserved ribonucleoprotein nanomachines that translate information in the genome to create the proteome in all cells. In yeast these complex particles contain four RNAs (>5400 nucleotides) and 79 different proteins. During the past 25 years, studies in yeast have led the way to understanding how these molecules are assembled into ribosomes in vivo. Assembly begins with transcription of ribosomal RNA in the nucleolus, where the RNA then undergoes complex pathways of folding, coupled with nucleotide modification, removal of spacer sequences, and binding to ribosomal proteins. More than 200 assembly factors and 76 small nucleolar RNAs transiently associate with assembling ribosomes, to enable their accurate and efficient construction. Following export of preribosomes from the nucleus to the cytoplasm, they undergo final stages of maturation before entering the pool of functioning ribosomes. Elaborate mechanisms exist to monitor the formation of correct structural and functional neighborhoods within ribosomes and to destroy preribosomes that fail to assemble properly. Studies of yeast ribosome biogenesis provide useful models for ribosomopathies, diseases in humans that result from failure to properly assemble ribosomes.

Structural analyses of the pre-mRNA splicing machinery

Pre-mRNA splicing is a critical event in the gene expression pathway of all eukaryotes. The splicing reaction is catalyzed by the spliceosome, a huge protein-RNA complex that contains five snRNAs and hundreds of different protein factors. Understanding the structure of this large molecular machinery is critical for understanding its function. Although the highly dynamic nature of the spliceosome, in both composition and conformation, posed daunting challenges to structural studies, there has been significant recent progress on structural analyses of the splicing machinery, using electron microscopy, crystallography, and nuclear magnetic resonance. This review discusses key recent findings in the structural analyses of the spliceosome and its components and how these findings advance our understanding of the function of the splicing machinery.

Splicing proofreading at 5' splice sites by ATPase Prp28p

Fidelity and efficiency of pre-mRNA splicing are critical for generating functional mRNAs, but how such accuracy in 5′ splice site (SS) selection is attained is not fully clear. Through a series of yeast genetic screens, we isolated alleles of prp28 that improve splicing of suboptimal 5′SS substrates, demonstrating that WT-Prp28p proofreads, and consequently rejects, poor 5′SS. Prp28p is thought to facilitate the disruption of 5′SS–U1 snRNA pairing to allow for 5′SS–U6 snRNA pairing in the catalytic spliceosome; unexpectedly, 5′SS proofreading by Prp28p is dependent on competition with the stability of the 5′SS:U6 duplex, but not the 5′SS:U1 duplex. E404K, the strongest prp28 allele containing a mutation located in the linker region between adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) subdomains, exhibited lower RNA-binding activity and enhanced splicing of suboptimal substrates before first-step catalysis, suggesting that decreased Prp28p activity allows longer time for suboptimal 5′SS substrates to pair with U6 snRNA and thereby reduces splicing fidelity. Residue E404 is critical for providing high splicing activity, demonstrated here in both yeast and Drosophila cells. Thus, the subdomain linker in Prp28p plays important roles both in splicing efficiency across species and in proofreading of 5′SS.

Functions of the DExD/H-box proteins in nuclear pre-mRNA splicing

In eukaryotes, many genes are transcribed as precursor messenger RNAs (pre-mRNAs) that contain exons and introns, the latter of which must be removed and exons ligated to form the mature mRNAs. This process is called pre-mRNA splicing, which occurs in the nucleus. Although the chemistry of pre-mRNA splicing is identical to that of the self-splicing Group II introns, hundreds of proteins and five small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs), U1, U2, U4, U5, and U6, are essential for executing pre-mRNA splicing. Spliceosome, arguably the most complex cellular machine made up of all those proteins and snRNAs, is responsible for carrying out pre-mRNA splicing. In contrast to the transcription and the translation machineries, spliceosome is formed anew onto each pre-mRNA and undergoes a series of highly coordinated reconfigurations to form the catalytic center. This amazing process is orchestrated by a number of DExD/H-proteins that are the focus of this article, which aims to review the field in general and to project the exciting challenges and opportunities ahead. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: The Biology of RNA helicases - Modulation for life.

Link of NTR-mediated spliceosome disassembly with DEAH-box ATPases Prp2, Prp16, and Prp22

The DEAH-box ATPase Prp43 is required for disassembly of the spliceosome after the completion of splicing or after the discard of the spliceosome due to a splicing defect. Prp43 associates with Ntr1 and Ntr2 to form the NTR complex and is recruited to the spliceosome via the interaction of Ntr2 and U5 component Brr2. Ntr2 alone can bind to U5 and to the spliceosome. To understand how NTR might mediate the disassembly of spliceosome intermediates, we arrested the spliceosome at various stages of the assembly pathway and assessed its susceptibility to disassembly. We found that NTR could catalyze the disassembly of affinity-purified spliceosomes arrested specifically after the ATP-dependent action of DEAH-box ATPase Prp2, Prp16, or Prp22 but not at steps before the action of these ATPases or upon their binding to the spliceosome. These results link spliceosome disassembly to the functioning of splicing ATPases. Analysis of the binding of Ntr2 to each splicing complex has revealed that the presence of Prp16 and Slu7, which also interact with Brr2, has a negative impact on Ntr2 binding. Our study provides insights into the mechanism by which NTR can be recruited to the spliceosome to mediate the disassembly of spliceosome intermediates when the spliceosome pathway is retarded, while disassembly is prevented in normal reactions.

Staying on message: ensuring fidelity in pre-mRNA splicing

The faithful expression of genes requires that cellular machinery select substrates with high specificity at each step in gene expression. High specificity is particularly important at the stage of nuclear pre-mRNA splicing, during which the spliceosome selects splice sites and excises intervening introns. With low specificity, the usage of alternative sites would yield insertions, deletions and frame shifts in mRNA. Recently, biochemical, genetic and genome-wide approaches have significantly advanced our understanding of splicing fidelity. In particular, we have learned that DExD/H-box ATPases play a general role in rejecting and discarding suboptimal substrates and that these factors serve as a paradigm for proofreading NTPases in other systems. Recent advances have also defined fundamental questions for future investigations.

Nuclear quality control of RNA polymerase II transcripts

Eukaryotic RNA polymerase II produces an astounding diversity of transcripts. These may need to be 5(') capped, spliced, polyadenylated, and packaged with proteins before their export to the cytoplasm. Unscheduled accumulation of any RNA species can interfere with normal RNA metabolism and poses a serious hazard to cells. Yet, given the amount of primary transcripts and the complexity of the RNA maturation process, production of aberrant RNA species is unavoidable. Cells, therefore, employ nuclear RNA quality control mechanisms to rapidly degrade, actively retain, or transcriptionally silence unwanted RNAs. Pathways that monitor mRNA production are best understood and similar pathways are employed to destroy transcriptional noise. Finally, related mechanisms also contribute to gene regulation during normal growth.

Spliceosome structure and function

Pre-mRNA splicing is catalyzed by the spliceosome, a multimegadalton ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex comprised of five snRNPs and numerous proteins. Intricate RNA-RNA and RNP networks, which serve to align the reactive groups of the pre-mRNA for catalysis, are formed and repeatedly rearranged during spliceosome assembly and catalysis. Both the conformation and composition of the spliceosome are highly dynamic, affording the splicing machinery its accuracy and flexibility, and these remarkable dynamics are largely conserved between yeast and metazoans. Because of its dynamic and complex nature, obtaining structural information about the spliceosome represents a major challenge. Electron microscopy has revealed the general morphology of several spliceosomal complexes and their snRNP subunits, and also the spatial arrangement of some of their components. X-ray and NMR studies have provided high resolution structure information about spliceosomal proteins alone or complexed with one or more binding partners. The extensive interplay of RNA and proteins in aligning the pre-mRNA's reactive groups, and the presence of both RNA and protein at the core of the splicing machinery, suggest that the spliceosome is an RNP enzyme. However, elucidation of the precise nature of the spliceosome's active site, awaits the generation of a high-resolution structure of its RNP core.

Proofreading and spellchecking: a two-tier strategy for pre-mRNA splicing quality control

Multi-tier strategies exist in many biochemical processes to ensure a maximal fidelity of the reactions. In this review, we focus on the two-tier quality control strategy that ensures the quality of the products of the pre-mRNA splicing reactions catalyzed by the spliceosome. The first step in the quality control process relies on kinetic proofreading mechanisms that are internal to the spliceosome and that are performed by ATP-dependent RNA helicases. The second quality control step, spellchecking, involves recognition of unspliced pre-mRNAs or aberrantly spliced mRNAs that have escaped the first proofreading mechanisms, and subsequent degradation of these molecules by degradative enzymes in the nucleus or in the cytoplasm. This two-tier quality control strategy highlights a need for high fidelity and a requirement for degradative activities that eliminate defective molecules. The presence of multiple quality control activities during splicing underscores the importance of this process in the expression of genetic information.

DEAH-box ATPase Prp16 has dual roles in remodeling of the spliceosome in catalytic steps

The assembly of the spliceosome involves dynamic rearrangements of interactions between snRNAs, protein components, and the pre-mRNA substrate. DExD/H-box ATPases are required to mediate structural changes of the spliceosome, utilizing the energy of ATP hydrolysis. Two DExD/H-box ATPases are required for the catalytic steps of the splicing pathway, Prp2 for the first step and Prp16 for the second step, both belonging to the DEAH subgroup of the protein family. The detailed mechanism of their action was not well understood until recently, when Prp2 was shown to be required for the release of U2 components SF3a and SF3b, presumably to allow the binding of Cwc25 to promote the first transesterification reaction. We show here that Cwc25 and Yju2 are released after the reaction in Prp16- and ATP-dependent manners, possibly to allow for the binding of Prp22, Prp18, and Slu7 to promote the second catalytic reaction. The binding of Cwc25 to the spliceosome is destabilized by mutations at the branchpoint sequence, suggesting that Cwc25 may bind to the branch site. We also show that Prp16 has an ATP-independent role in the first catalytic step, in addition to its known role in the second step. In the absence of ATP, Prp16 stabilizes the binding of Cwc25 to the spliceosome formed with branchpoint mutated pre-mRNAs to facilitate their splicing. Our results uncovered novel functions of Prp16 in both catalytic steps, and provide mechanistic insights into splicing catalysis.

Nucleocytoplasmic mRNP export is an integral part of mRNP biogenesis

Nucleocytoplasmic export and biogenesis of mRNPs are closely coupled. At the gene, concomitant with synthesis of the pre-mRNA, the transcription machinery, hnRNP proteins, processing, quality control and export machineries cooperate to release processed and export competent mRNPs. After diffusion through the interchromatin space, the mRNPs are translocated through the nuclear pore complex and released into the cytoplasm. At the nuclear pore complex, defined compositional and conformational changes are triggered, but specific cotranscriptionally added components are retained in the mRNP and subsequently influence the cytoplasmic fate of the mRNP. Processes taking place at the gene locus and at the nuclear pore complex are crucial for integrating export as an essential part of gene expression. Spatial, temporal and structural aspects of these events have been highlighted in analyses of the Balbiani ring genes.

The DEAH box ATPases Prp16 and Prp43 cooperate to proofread 5' splice site cleavage during pre-mRNA splicing

To investigate the mechanisms underlying accurate pre-mRNA splicing, we developed an in vitro assay sensitive to proofreading of 5' splice site cleavage. We inactivated spliceosomes by disrupting a metal-ligand interaction at the catalytic center and discovered that, when the DEAH box ATPase Prp16 was disabled, these spliceosomes catalyzed 5' splice site cleavage but at a reduced rate. Although Prp16 does not promote splicing of a genuine substrate until after 5' splice site cleavage, we found that Prp16 can associate with spliceosomes before 5' splice site cleavage, consistent with a role for Prp16 in proofreading 5' splice site cleavage. We established that Prp16-mediated rejection is reversible, necessitating a downstream discard pathway that we found requires the DEAH box ATPase Prp43, a spliceosome disassembly factor. These data indicate that spliceosomes distinguish slow substrates and that the mechanisms for establishing the fidelity of 5' splice site cleavage and exon ligation share a common ATP-dependent framework.

A conformational rearrangement in the spliceosome sets the stage for Prp22-dependent mRNA release

An essential step in pre-mRNA splicing is the release of the mRNA product from the spliceosome. The DEAH box RNA helicase Prp22 catalyzes mRNA release by remodeling contacts within the spliceosome that involve the U5 snRNP. Spliceosome disassembly requires a segment of more than 13 ribonucleotides downstream of the 3' splice site. I show here by site-specific crosslinking and RNase H protection that Prp22 interacts with the mRNA downstream of the exon-exon junction prior to mRNA release. The findings support a model for Prp22-catalyzed mRNA release from the spliceosome wherein a rearrangement that accompanies the second transesterification step deposits Prp22 on the mRNA downstream of the exon-exon junction. Bound to its target RNA, the 3'-->5' helicase acts to disrupt mRNA/U5 snRNP contacts, thereby liberating the mRNA from the spliceosome.

Competition between the ATPase Prp5 and branch region-U2 snRNA pairing modulates the fidelity of spliceosome assembly

ATPase-facilitated steps during spliceosome function have been postulated to afford opportunities for kinetic proofreading. Spliceosome assembly requires the ATPase Prp5p, whose activity might thus impact fidelity during initial intron recognition. Using alanine mutations in S. cerevisiae Prp5p, we identified a suboptimal intron whose splicing could be improved by altered Prp5p activity and then, using this intron, screened for potent prp5 mutants. These prp5 alleles specifically alter branch region selectivity, with improved splicing in vivo of suboptimal substrates correlating with reduced ATPase activity in vitro for a series of mutants in ATPase motif III (SAT). Because these effects are abrogated by compensatory U2 snRNA mutations or other changes that increase branch region-U2 pairing, these results explicitly link a fidelity event with a defined physical structure, the branch region-U2 snRNA duplex, and provide strong evidence that progression of the splicing pathway requires branch region-U2 snRNA pairing prior to Prp5p-facilitated conformational change.

Evolution of small nuclear RNAs in S. cerevisiae, C. albicans, and other hemiascomycetous yeasts

The spliceosome is a large, dynamic ribonuclear protein complex, required for the removal of intron sequences from newly synthesized eukaryotic RNAs. The spliceosome contains five essential small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs): U1, U2, U4, U5, and U6. Phylogenetic comparisons of snRNAs from protists to mammals have long demonstrated remarkable conservation in both primary sequence and secondary structure. In contrast, the snRNAs of the hemiascomycetous yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae have highly unusual features that set them apart from the snRNAs of other eukaryotes. With an emphasis on the pathogenic yeast Candida albicans, we have now identified and compared snRNAs from newly sequenced yeast genomes, providing a perspective on spliceosome evolution within the hemiascomycetes. In addition to tracing the origins of previously identified snRNA variations present in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, we have found numerous unexpected changes occurring throughout the hemiascomycetous lineages. Our observations reveal interesting examples of RNA and protein coevolution, giving rise to altered interaction domains, losses of deeply conserved snRNA-binding proteins, and unique snRNA sequence changes within the catalytic center of the spliceosome. These same yeast lineages have experienced exceptionally high rates of intron loss, such that modern hemiascomycetous genomes contain introns in only approximately 5% of their genes. Also, the splice site sequences of those introns that remain adhere to an unusually strict consensus. Some of the snRNA variations we observe may thus reflect the altered intron landscape with which the hemiascomycetous spliceosome must contend.

Spliceosome assembly and composition

Cells control alternative splicing by modulating assembly of the pre-mRNA splicing machinery at competing splice sites. Therefore, a working knowledge of spliceosome assembly is essential for understanding how alternative splice site choices are achieved. In this chapter, we review spliceosome assembly with particular emphasis on the known steps and factors subject to regulation during alternative splice site selection in mammalian cells. We also review recent advances regarding similarities and differences between the in vivo and in vitro assembly pathways, as well as proofreading mechanisms contributing to the fidelity of splice site selection.

Exon ligation is proofread by the DExD/H-box ATPase Prp22p

To produce messenger RNA, the spliceosome excises introns from precursor (pre)-mRNA and splices the flanking exons. To establish fidelity, the spliceosome discriminates against aberrant introns, but current understanding of such fidelity mechanisms is limited. Here we show that an ATP-dependent activity represses formation of mRNA from aberrant intermediates having mutations in any of the intronic consensus sequences. This proofreading activity is disabled by mutations that impair the ATPase or RNA unwindase activity of Prp22p, a conserved spliceosomal DExD/H-box ATPase. Further, cold-sensitive prp22 mutants permit aberrant mRNA formation from a mutated 3' splice-site intermediate in vivo. We conclude that Prp22p generally represses splicing of aberrant intermediates, in addition to its known ATP-dependent role in promoting release of genuine mRNA. This dual function for Prp22p validates a general model in which fidelity can be enhanced by a DExD/H-box ATPase.

Discriminatory RNP remodeling by the DEAD-box protein DED1

DExH/D proteins catalyze NTP-driven rearrangements of RNA and RNA-protein complexes during most aspects of RNA metabolism. Although the vast majority of DExH/D proteins displays virtually no sequence-specificity when remodeling RNA complexes in vitro, the enzymes clearly distinguish between a large number of RNA and RNP complexes in a physiological context. It is unknown how this discrimination between potential substrates is achieved. Here we show one possible way by which a non-sequence specific DExH/D protein can discriminately remodel similar RNA complexes. We have measured in vitro the disassembly of model RNPs by two distinct DExH/D proteins, DED1 and NPH-II. Both enzymes displace the U1 snRNP from a tightly bound RNA in an active, ATP-dependent fashion. However, DED1 cannot actively displace the protein U1A from its binding site, whereas NPH-II can. The dissociation rate of U1A dictates the rate by which DED1 remodels RNA complexes with U1A bound. We further show that DED1 disassembles RNA complexes with slightly altered U1A binding sites at different rates, but only when U1A is bound to the RNA. These findings suggest that the "inability" to actively displace other proteins from RNA can provide non-sequence specific DExH/D proteins with the capacity to disassemble similar RNA complexes in a discriminatory fashion. In addition, our study illuminates possible mechanisms for protein displacement by DExH/D proteins.

The Isy1p component of the NineTeen complex interacts with the ATPase Prp16p to regulate the fidelity of pre-mRNA splicing

Prp16p is a DEAH-box ATPase that transiently associates with the spliceosome to promote the structural transition required for the second chemical step. Yeast strains carrying the cold-sensitive allele prp16-302 stall the release of Prp16p at low temperatures, yet splice precursors with aberrant branchpoints at increased frequency. To identify new factors involved in the regulation of splicing fidelity, we sought suppressors of the prp16-302 growth phenotype. Deletion of the nonessential ISY1 gene (1) improves growth of prp16-302 strains, (2) alleviates stalling, and (3) restores fidelity of branchpoint usage to wild-type levels. Isy1p is a subunit of the NineTeen Complex containing Prp19p, an essential E3 ubiquitin ligase homolog required for splicing. Notably, Deltaisy1 PRP16 strains display reduced fidelity of 3'-splice site selection. Consistent with a recent two-state model of the spliceosome, our genetic and biochemical results suggest that Isy1p acts together with U6 snRNA to promote a spliceosomal conformation favorable for first-step chemistry. We propose that deletion of ISY1 favors the premature release of Prp16p, thus promoting second-step chemistry of precursors with inappropriate 3'-splice sites.

Kinetic proofreading by the cavity system of myoglobin: protection from poisoning

Throughout its matrix of atoms, myoglobin has a network of cavities that are inhabited for short lengths of time by ligands released by photolysis from the myoglobin heme. The purpose or effect of this cavity network is not clear. A recently published kinetic scheme that fits data from many native and mutant myoglobin oxygen photolysis experiments can be modified easily into a kinetic scheme that includes kinetic proofreading. Proofreading would provide protection against contaminants and, specifically, might help protect the cell from carbon monoxide poisoning. Here we present a two-part model: (1) myoglobin represented by a kinetic description, which includes proofreading reactions associated with the cavities, and (2) a reaction-diffusion description of a myocyte model in which the part 1 myoglobin acts as a mobile buffer in simultaneous carbon monoxide and oxygen gradients. The non-equilibrium nature of part 2 should promote the proofreading function of part 1. A simulation using the model demonstrates that the cavity system can in principle proofread, reducing mitochondrial enzyme contamination.

From RNA helicases to RNPases

In eukaryotic cells, all aspects of cellular RNA metabolism require putative RNA helicases of the DEAD and DExH protein families (collectively known as DExD/H families). Based on data from biochemical studies of a few of these RNA helicases, they are generally considered to be involved in the unwinding of duplex RNA molecules. However, recent reports provide evidence indicating that these proteins might also be involved in the active disruption of RNA-protein interactions.

Further characterization of the helicase activity of eIF4A. Substrate specificity

Eukaryotic initiation factor (eIF) 4A is the archetypal member of the DEAD box family of RNA helicases and is proposed to unwind structures in the 5'-untranslated region of mRNA to facilitate binding of the 40 S ribosomal subunit. The helicase activity of eIF4A has been further characterized with respect to substrate specificity and directionality. Results confirm that the initial rate and amplitude of duplex unwinding by eIF4A is dependent on the overall stability, rather than the length or sequence, of the duplex substrate. eIF4A helicase activity is minimally dependent on the length of the single-stranded region adjacent to the double-stranded region of the substrate. Interestingly, eIF4A is able to unwind blunt-ended duplexes. eIF4A helicase activity is also affected by substitution of 2'-OH (RNA) groups with 2'-H (DNA) or 2'-methoxyethyl groups. These observations, taken together with results from competitive inhibition experiments, suggest that eIF4A may interact directly with double-stranded RNA, and recognition of helicase substrates occurs via chemical and/or structural features of the duplex. These results allow for refinement of a previously proposed model for the mechanism of action of eIF4A helicase activity.

Functional recognition of 5' splice site by U4/U6.U5 tri-snRNP defines a novel ATP-dependent step in early spliceosome assembly

A sensitive assay based on competition between cis-and trans-splicing suggested that factors in addition to U1 snRNP were important for early 5' splice site recognition. Cross-linking and physical protection experiments revealed a functionally important interaction between U4/U6.U5 tri-snRNP and the 5' splice site, which unexpectedly was not dependent upon prior binding of U2 snRNP to the branch point. The early 5' splice site/tri-snRNP interaction requires ATP, occurs in both nematode and HeLa cell extracts, and involves sequence-specific interactions between the highly conserved splicing factor Prp8 and the 5' splice site. We propose that U1 and U5 snRNPs functionally collaborate to recognize and define the 5' splice site prior to establishment of communication with the 3' splice site.

Mechanisms of mRNA surveillance in eukaryotes

A conserved mRNA degradation system, referred to as mRNA surveillance, exists in eukaryotic cells to degrade aberrant mRNAs. A defining aspect of aberrant transcripts is that the spatial relationship between the termination codon and specific downstream sequence information has been altered. A key, yet unknown, feature of the mRNA surveillance system is how this spatial relationship is assessed in individual transcripts. Two views have emerged to describe how discrimination between proper and improper termination might occur. In the first view, a surveillance complex assembles onto the mRNA after translation termination, and scans the mRNA in a 3' to 5' direction for a limited distance. If specific downstream sequence information is encountered during this scanning, then the surveillance complex targets the transcript for rapid decay. An alternate view suggests that the downstream sequence information influences how translation termination occurs. This view encompasses several ideas including: (a) The architecture of the mRNP can alter the rate of key steps in translation termination; (b) the discrimination between a proper and improper termination occurs via an internal, Upf1-dependent, timing mechanism; and (c) proper termination results in the restructuring of the mRNP to a form that promotes mRNA stability. This proposed model for mRNA surveillance is similar to other systems of kinetic proofreading that monitor the accuracy of other biogenic processes such as translation and spliceosome assembly.

Decoding of sorting signals by coatomer through a GTPase switch in the COPI coat complex

Sorting signals on cargo proteins are recognized by coatomer for selective uptake into COPI (coatomer)-coated vesicles. This study shows that coatomer couples sorting signal recognition to the GTP hydrolysis reaction on ARF1. Coatomer responds differently to different signals. The cytoplasmic signal sequence of hp24a inhibits coatomer-dependent GTP hydrolysis. By contrast, the dilysine retrieval signal, which competes for the same binding site on coatomer, has no effect on GTPase activity. It is inferred that, in vivo, sorting signal selection is under kinetic control, with coatomer governing a GTPase discard pathway that excludes dilysine-tagged proteins from one class of COPI-coated vesicles. The concept of competing sets of sorting signals that act positively and negatively during vesicle budding through a GTPase switch in the COPI coat complex suggests mechanisms for cargo segregation in which specificity is conferred by GTP hydrolysis.

Elevated levels of a U4/U6.U5 snRNP-associated protein, Spp381p, rescue a mutant defective in spliceosome maturation

U4 snRNA release from the spliceosome occurs through an essential but ill-defined Prp38p-dependent step. Here we report the results of a dosage suppressor screen to identify genes that contribute to PRP38 function. Elevated expression of a previously uncharacterized gene, SPP381, efficiently suppresses the growth and splicing defects of a temperature-sensitive (Ts) mutant prp38-1. This suppression is specific in that enhanced SPP381 expression does not alter the abundance of intronless RNA transcripts or suppress the Ts phenotypes of other prp mutants. Since SPP381 does not suppress a prp38::LEU2 null allele, it is clear that Spp381p assists Prp38p in splicing but does not substitute for it. Yeast SPP381 disruptants are severely growth impaired and accumulate unspliced pre-mRNA. Immune precipitation studies show that, like Prp38p, Spp381p is present in the U4/U6.U5 tri-snRNP particle. Two-hybrid analyses support the view that the carboxyl half of Spp381p directly interacts with the Prp38p protein. A putative PEST proteolysis domain within Spp381p is dispensable for the Spp381p-Prp38p interaction and for prp38-1 suppression but contributes to Spp381p function in splicing. Curiously, in vitro, Spp381p may not be needed for the chemistry of pre-mRNA splicing. Based on the in vivo and in vitro results presented here, we propose that two small acidic proteins without obvious RNA binding domains, Spp381p and Prp38p, act in concert to promote U4/U5.U6 tri-snRNP function in the spliceosome cycle.

SPLICE SITE SELECTION IN PLANT PRE-mRNA SPLICING

The purpose of this review is to highlight the unique and common features of splice site selection in plants compared with the better understood yeast and vertebrate systems. A key question in plant splicing is the role of AU sequences and how and at what stage they are involved in spliceosome assembly. Clearly, intronic U- or AU-rich and exonic GC- and AG-rich elements can influence splice site selection and splicing efficiency and are likely to bind proteins. It is becoming clear that splicing of a particular intron depends on a fine balance in the "strength" of the multiple intron signals involved in splice site selection. Individual introns contain varying strengths of signals and what is critical to splicing of one intron may be of less importance to the splicing of another. Thus, small changes to signals may severely disrupt splicing or have little or no effect depending on the overall sequence context of a specific intron/exon organization.

The DEAH-box splicing factor Prp16 unwinds RNA duplexes in vitro

BACKGROUND

During pre-mRNA splicing, dynamic rearrangement of RNA secondary structure within the spliceosome is crucial for intron recognition and formation of the catalytic core. Splicing factors belonging to the DExD/DExH-box family of RNA-dependent ATPases are thought to have a central role in directing these rearrangements by unwinding RNA helices. Proof of this hypothesis has, however, been conspicuously lacking.

RESULTS

Prp16 is a DEAH-box protein that functions in the second step of splicing in vitro. Using various RNA duplexes as substrate, we have shown that Prp16 has an ATP-dependent RNA unwinding activity. This activity is independent of sequence in either the single-stranded or duplexed regions of the RNA substrate. A mutation (prp16-1) near the ATP-binding motif of Prp16 inhibits both the RNA-dependent ATPase activity and the ATP-dependent RNA unwinding activity.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings provide strong biochemical evidence that Prp16 can disrupt a duplexed RNA structure on the spliceosome. Because the purified protein lacks sequence specificity in unwinding RNA duplexes, targeting of the unwinding activity of Prp16 in the spliceosome is likely to be determined by other interacting protein factors. The demonstration of unwinding activity will also help our understanding of how the fidelity of branchpoint recognition is controlled by Prp16.

The Mof2/Sui1 protein is a general monitor of translational accuracy

Although it is essential for protein synthesis to be highly accurate, a number of cases of directed ribosomal frameshifting have been reported in RNA viruses, as well as in procaryotic and eucaryotic genes. Changes in the efficiency of ribosomal frameshifting can have major effects on the ability of cells to propagate viruses which use this mechanism. Furthermore, studies of this process can illuminate the mechanisms involved in the maintenance of the normal translation reading frame. The yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae killer virus system uses programmed -1 ribosomal frameshifting to synthesize its gene products. Strains harboring the mof2-1 allele demonstrated a fivefold increase in frameshifting and prevented killer virus propagation. In this report, we present the results of the cloning and characterization of the wild-type MOF2 gene. mof2-1 is a novel allele of SUI1, a gene previously shown to play a role in translation initiation start site selection. Strains harboring the mof2-1 allele demonstrated a mutant start site selection phenotype and increased efficiency of programmed -1 ribosomal frameshifting and conferred paromomycin sensitivity. The increased frameshifting observed in vivo was reproduced in extracts prepared from mof2-1 cells. Addition of purified wild-type Mof2p/Sui1p reduced frameshifting efficiencies to wild-type levels. Expression of the human SUI1 homolog in yeast corrects all of the mof2-1 phenotypes, demonstrating that the function of this protein is conserved throughout evolution. Taken together, these results suggest that Mof2p/Sui1p functions as a general modulator of accuracy at both the initiation and elongation phases of translation.