Pyrimidine dimer splitting in covalently linked dimer-arylamine systems

DFT/MM Simulations for Cycloreversion Reaction of Cyclobutane Pyrimidine Dimer with Deprotonated and Protonated E283

DNA photolyase targets the primary ultraviolet (UV)-induced DNA lesion─cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD), attaches to it, and catalyzes its dissociation. The catalytic mechanism of DNA photolyase and the role of the conserved residue E283 remain subjects of debate. This study employs two-dimensional potential energy surface maps and minimum free energy paths calculated at the ωB97XD/6-31G/MM level to elucidate these mechanisms. Results suggest that the catalytic process follows a sequential, stepwise reaction in which the C5-C5 and C6-C6 bonds are cleaved in order, facilitated by a protonated E283. Activation free energies for these cleavages are calculated at 4.4 and 4.2 kcal·mol-1, respectively. Protonation of E283 reduces electrostatic repulsion with CPD and forms dual hydrogen bonds with it and provides better solvation, stabilizing the CPD radical anion, particularly during intermediate state. This stabilization renders the initial splitting step exergonic, slows reverse reactions of the C5-C5 bond cleavage and electron transfer, and ensures a high quantum yield. Furthermore, the protonation state of E283 significantly affects the type of bond cleavage. Other residues in the active site were also investigated for their roles in the mechanism.

Substituent effects on photosensitized splitting of thymine cyclobutane dimer by an attached indole

In chromophore-containing cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) model systems, solvent effects on the splitting efficiency may depend on the length of the linker, the molecular conformation, and the oxidation potential of the donor. To further explore the relationship between chromophore structure and splitting efficiency, we prepared a series of substituted indole-T< >T model compounds 2 a-2 g and measured their splitting quantum yields in various solvents. Two reverse solvent effects were observed: an increase in splitting efficiency in solvents of lower polarity for models 2 a-2 d with an electron-donating group (EDG), and vice versa for models 2 e-2 g with an electron-withdrawing group (EWG). According to the Hammett equation, the negative value of the slope of the Hammett plot indicates that the indole moiety during the T< >T-splitting reaction loses negative charge, and the larger negative value implies that the repair reaction is more sensitive to substituent effects in low-polarity solvents. The EDGs of the models 2 a-2 d can delocalize the charge-separated state, and low-polarity solvents make it more stable, which leads to higher splitting efficiency in low-polarity solvents. Conversely, the EWGs of models 2 e-2 g favor destabilization of the charge-separated state, and high-polarity solvents decrease the destabilization and hence lead to more efficient splitting in high-polarity solvents.

Photosensitized splitting of thymine dimer or oxetane unit by a covalently N-linked carbazole via electron transfer in different marcus regions

Although many similarities exist between the two classes of enzymes, cyclobutane photolyases and (6-4) photolyases have certain important differences. The most significant difference is in their repair quantum yields, cyclobutane photolyases with a uniformly high efficiency (0.7-0.98) and very low repair efficiency for (6-4) photolyases (0.05-0.1). To understand the significant difference, we prepared two classes of model compounds, covalently N-linked dimer- (1) or oxetane-carbazole (2) compounds with a dimethylene or trimethylene group as a linker. Under light irradiation, the dimer or oxetane unit of model compounds can be sensitized to split by the excited carbazole via an intramolecular electron transfer. The splitting reaction of dimer or oxetane unit in model compounds is strongly solvent dependent. In nonpolar solvents, such as cyclohexane or THF, no fluorescence quenching of the carbazole moiety of model compounds relative to a free carbazole, N-methylcarbazole, was observed and thus no splitting occurred. In polar solvents, two classes of model compounds reveal two reverse solvent effects on the splitting quantum yield. One is an inverse relation between the quantum yield and the polarity of the solvent for dimer-model systems, and another is a normal relation for oxetane-model systems. This phenomenon was also observed with another two classes of model compounds, covalently linked dimer- or oxetane-indole. Based on Marcus theory and thermodynamic data, it has been rationalized that the two reverse solvent effects derive from back electron transfer in the splitting process lying in the different Marcus regions. Back electron transfer lies in the Marcus inverted region for dimer-model systems and the normal region for oxetane-model systems. From repair solvent behavior of the two classes of model compounds, we gained some insights into the major difference in the repair efficiency for the two classes of photolyases.

Origin of solvent dependence of photosensitized splitting of a cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer by a covalently linked chromophore

In model studies involving the mechanisms of DNA photolyases, two reverse solvent effects on the quantum yield of photosensitized splitting of a cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD) by a covalently linked chromophore have been reported. One is an increase in the splitting efficiency in lower polarity solvents for model compounds with a short linker between the dimer and the chromophore. Another is more efficient splitting in higher polarity solvents for model compounds with a flexible and long linker. To unravel mechanisms of two opposite solvent effects, five covalently linked indole-dimer compounds with different-length linkers were prepared. Two solvent effects as described above were observed through measuring quantum yields of dimer splitting of these model compounds in four solvents. According to Marcus theory, back electron transfer in the splitting reaction was analyzed quantitatively in light of relative data of a model compound in four solvents. It was demonstrated that the dependence of the quantum yield on solvent polarity for the flexible long-linker system would derive from the change in the distance between a dimer unit (acceptor) and an indole moiety (electron donor) in different solvents. With increasing solvent polarity, a U-shaped conformation of the model compound would become a preferred conformation because of the hydrophobic interaction between indole and dimer moiety, and their distances would become closer. On the basis of Marcus theory, calculated results reveal that the rate of back electron transfer would be slowed down with increasing solvent polarity and the distance reduced, giving a more efficient splitting. Meanwhile, some new insights into mechanisms of DNA photoreactivation mediated by photolyases were gained.

Model studies of the (6-4) photoproduct photoreactivation: efficient photosensitized splitting of thymine oxetane units by covalently linked tryptophan in high polarity solvents

Three covalently linked tryptophan-thymine oxetane compounds used as a model of the (6-4) photolyase-substrate complex have been prepared. Under 290 nm light, efficient splitting of the thymine oxetane with aromatic carbonyl compounds gives the thymine monomer and the corresponding carbonyl compounds by the covalently linked tryptophan via an intramolecular electron transfer, and exhibits a strong solvent dependence: the quantum yield (Phi) is ca. 0.1 in dioxane, and near 0.3 in water. Electron transfer from the excited tryptophan residue to the oxetane unit is the origin of fluorescence quenching of the tryptophan residue, and is more efficient in strong polar solvents. The splitting efficiency of the oxetane radical anion within the tryptophan.+-oxetane.- species is also solvent-dependent, ranging from ca. 0.2 in dioxane to near 0.35 in water. Thus, the back electron transfer reaction in the charge-separated species would be suppressed in water, but is still a main factor causing low splitting efficiencies in the tryptophan-oxetane systems. In contrast to the tryptophan-oxetane system, fast nonradiation processes are the main causes of low efficiency in the flavin-oxetane system. Hence, nonradiative processes of the excited FADH-, rather than electron transfer to oxetane, may be an important factor for the low repair efficiency of (6-4) photolyase.

Light-driven enzymatic catalysis of DNA repair: a review of recent biophysical studies on photolyase

More than 50 years ago, initial experiments on enzymatic photorepair of ultraviolet (UV)-damaged DNA were reported [Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 35 (1949) 73]. Soon after this discovery, it was recognized that one enzyme, photolyase, is able to repair UV-induced DNA lesions by effectively reversing their formation using blue light. The enzymatic process named DNA photoreactivation depends on a non-covalently bound cofactor, flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD). Flavins are ubiquitous redox-active catalysts in one- and two-electron transfer reactions of numerous biological processes. However, in the case of photolyase, not only the ground-state redox properties of the FAD cofactor are exploited but also, and perhaps more importantly, its excited-state properties. In the catalytically active, fully reduced redox form, the FAD absorbs in the blue and near-UV ranges of visible light. Although there is no direct experimental evidence, it appears generally accepted that starting from the excited singlet state, the chromophore initiates a reductive cleavage of the two major DNA photodamages, cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers and (6-4) photoproducts, by short-distance electron transfer to the DNA lesion. Back electron transfer from the repaired DNA segment is believed to eventually restore the initial redox states of the cofactor and the DNA nucleobases, resulting in an overall reaction with net-zero exchanged electrons. Thus, the entire process represents a true catalytic cycle. Many biochemical and biophysical studies have been carried out to unravel the fundamentals of this unique mode of action. The work has culminated in the elucidation of the three-dimensional structure of the enzyme in 1995 that revealed remarkable details, such as the FAD-cofactor arrangement in an unusual U-shaped configuration. With the crystal structure of the enzyme at hand, research on photolyases did not come to an end but, for good reason, intensified: the geometrical structure of the enzyme alone is not sufficient to fully understand the enzyme's action on UV-damaged DNA. Much effort has therefore been invested to learn more about, for example, the geometry of the enzyme-substrate complex, and the mechanism and pathways of intra-enzyme and enzyme <-->DNA electron transfer. Many of the key results from biochemical and molecular biology characterizations of the enzyme or the enzyme-substrate complex have been summarized in a number of reviews. Complementary to these articles, this review focuses on recent biophysical studies of photoreactivation comprising work performed from the early 1990s until the present.

Model compounds for (6–4) photolyases: a comparative flavin induced cleavage study of oxetanes and thietanes

Thietanes were used in the past as mimics for an unstable oxetane intermediate formed during the repair of mutagenic (6-4) lesions. The thietane derivatives were found to be not repaired, raising the question of how well thietanes are cleaved by single electron donation compared to oxetanes. We have prepared two flavin-containing oxetane and thietane model compounds for the (6-4) photolyase catalyzed repair process and we show that both are efficiently cleaved by a reduced and deprotonated flavin. Thietanes are therefore excellent models. The lack of their repair can be attributed to lack of binding.

Time-resolved EPR studies with DNA photolyase: excited-state FADH0 abstracts an electron from Trp-306 to generate FADH-, the catalytically active form of the cofactor

Photolyase repairs UV-induced cyclobutane-pyrimidine dimers in DNA by photoinduced electron transfer. The enzyme isolated from Escherichia coli contains 5,10-methenyltetrahydrofolate, which functions as the light-harvesting chromophore, and fully reduced flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), which functions as the redox catalyst. During enzyme preparation, the flavin is oxidized to FADH0, which is catalytically inert. Illumination of the enzyme with 300- to 600-nm light converts the flavin to the fully reduced form in a reaction that involves photooxidation of an amino acid in the apoenzyme. The results of earlier optical studies had indicated that the redox-active amino acid in this photoactivation process was tryptophan. We have now used time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to investigate the photoactivation reaction. Excitation of the flavin-radical-containing inactive enzyme produces a spin-polarized radical that we identify by 2H and 15N labeling as originating from a tryptophan residue, confirming the inferences from the optical work. These results and Trp-->Phe replacement by site-directed mutagenesis reveal that flavin radical photoreduction is achieved by electron abstraction from Trp-306 by the excited-state FADH0. Analysis of the hyperfine couplings and spin density distribution deduced from the isotopic-labeling results shows that the product of the light-driven redox chemistry is the Trp-306 cation radical. The results strongly suggest that the active form of photolyase contains FADH- and not FADH2.

Photochemistry, photophysics, and mechanism of pyrimidine dimer repair by DNA photolyase

DNA photolyases photorepair pyrimidine dimers (Pyr < > Pyr) in DNA as well as RNA and thus reverse the harmful effects of UV-A (320-400 nm) and UV-B (280-320 nm) radiations. Photolyases from various organisms have been found to contain two noncovalently bound cofactors; one is a fully reduced flavin adenine dinucleotide (FADH-) and the other, commonly known as second chromophore, is either methenyltetrahydrofolate (MTHF) or 8-hydroxydeazaflavin (8-HDF). The second chromophore in photolyase is a light-harvesting molecule that absorbs mostly in the near-UV and visible wavelengths (300-500 nm) with its high extinction coefficient. The second chromophore then transfers its excitation energy to the FADH-. Subsequently, the photoexcited FADH- transfers an electron to the Pyr < > Pyr generating a dimer radical anion (Pyr < > Pyr.-) and a neutral flavin radical (FADH.). The Pyr < > Pyr.- is very unstable and undergoes spontaneous splitting followed by a back electron transfer to the FADH.. In addition to the main catalytic cofactor FADH-, a Trp (Trp277 in Escherichia coli) in apophotolyase, independent of other chromophores, also functions as a sensitizer to repair Pyr < > Pyr by direct electron transfer.