Removal of false positive features to generate authentic peak table for high-resolution mass spectrometry-based metabolomics study

A stochastic approach for parameter optimization of feature detection algorithms for non-target screening in mass spectrometry

Feature detection plays a crucial role in non-target screening (NTS), requiring careful selection of algorithm parameters to minimize false positive (FP) features. In this study, a stochastic approach was employed to optimize the parameter settings of feature detection algorithms used in processing high-resolution mass spectrometry data. This approach was demonstrated using four open-source algorithms (OpenMS, SAFD, XCMS, and KPIC2) within the patRoon software platform for processing extracts from drinking water samples spiked with 46 per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). The designed method is based on a stochastic strategy involving random sampling from variable space and the use of Pearson correlation to assess the impact of each parameter on the number of detected suspect analytes. Using our approach, the optimized parameters led to improvement in the algorithm performance by increasing suspect hits in case of SAFD and XCMS, and reducing the total number of detected features (i.e., minimizing FP) for OpenMS. These improvements were further validated on three different drinking water samples as test dataset. The optimized parameters resulted in a lower false discovery rate (FDR%) compared to the default parameters, effectively increasing the detection of true positive features. This work also highlights the necessity of algorithm parameter optimization prior to starting the NTS to reduce the complexity of such datasets.

Using Machine Learning to Construct the Blood-Follicle Distribution Models of Various Trace Elements and Explore the Transport-Related Pathways with Multiomics Data

Permeabilities of various trace elements (TEs) through the blood-follicle barrier (BFB) play an important role in oocyte development. However, it has not been comprehensively described as well as its involved biological pathways. Our study aimed to construct a blood-follicle distribution model of the concerned TEs and explore their related biological pathways. We finally included a total of 168 women from a cohort of in vitro fertilization-embryo transfer conducted in two reproductive centers in Beijing City and Shandong Province, China. The concentrations of 35 TEs in both serum and follicular fluid (FF) samples from the 168 women were measured, as well as the multiomics features of the metabolome, lipidome, and proteome in both plasma and FF samples. Multiomics features associated with the transfer efficiencies of TEs through the BFB were selected by using an elastic net model and further utilized for pathway analysis. Various machine learning (ML) models were built to predict the concentrations of TEs in FF. Overall, there are 21 TEs that exhibited three types of consistent BFB distribution characteristics between Beijing and Shandong centers. Among them, the concentrations of arsenic, manganese, nickel, tin, and bismuth in FF were higher than those in the serum with transfer efficiencies of 1.19-4.38, while a reverse trend was observed for the 15 TEs with transfer efficiencies of 0.076-0.905, e.g., mercury, germanium, selenium, antimony, and titanium. Lastly, cadmium was evenly distributed in the two compartments with transfer efficiencies of 0.998-1.056. Multiomics analysis showed that the enrichment of TEs was associated with the synthesis and action of steroid hormones and the glucose metabolism. Random forest model can provide the most accurate predictions of the concentrations of TEs in FF among the concerned ML models. In conclusion, the selective permeability through the BFB for various TEs may be significantly regulated by the steroid hormones and the glucose metabolism. Also, the concentrations of some TEs in FF can be well predicted by their serum levels with a random forest model.

Combination of in silico prediction and convolutional neural network framework for targeted screening of metabolites from LC-HRMS fingerprints: A case study of "Pericarpium Citri Reticulatae - FructusAurantii"

In this study, a novel approach is introduced, merging in silico prediction with a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) framework for the targeted screening of in vivo metabolites in Liquid Chromatography-High Resolution Mass Spectrometry (LC-HRMS) fingerprints. Initially, three predictive tools, supplemented by literature, identify potential metabolites for target prototypes derived from Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCMs) or functional foods. Subsequently, a CNN is developed to minimize false positives from CWT-based peak detection. The Extracted Ion Chromatogram (EIC) peaks are then annotated using MS-FINDER across three levels of confidence. This methodology focuses on analyzing the metabolic fingerprints of rats administered with "Pericarpium Citri Reticulatae - Fructus Aurantii" (PCR-FA). Consequently, 384 peaks in positive mode and 282 in negative mode were identified as true peaks of probable metabolites. By contrasting these with "blank serum" data, EIC peaks of adequate intensity were chosen for MS/MS fragment analysis. Ultimately, 14 prototypes (including flavonoids and lactones) and 40 metabolites were precisely linked to their corresponding EIC peaks, thereby providing deeper insight into the pharmacological mechanism. This innovative strategy markedly enhances the chemical coverage in the targeted screening of LC-HRMS metabolic fingerprints.

Augmented region of interest for untargeted metabolomics mass spectrometry (AriumMS) of multi-platform-based CE-MS and LC-MS data

In mass spectrometry (MS)-based metabolomics, there is a great need to combine different analytical separation techniques to cover metabolites of different polarities and apply appropriate multi-platform data processing. Here, we introduce AriumMS (augmented region of interest for untargeted metabolomics mass spectrometry) as a reliable toolbox for multi-platform metabolomics. AriumMS offers augmented data analysis of several separation techniques utilizing a region-of-interest algorithm. To demonstrate the capabilities of AriumMS, five datasets were combined. This includes three newly developed capillary electrophoresis (CE)-Orbitrap MS methods using the recently introduced nanoCEasy CE-MS interface and two hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC)-Orbitrap MS methods. AriumMS provides a novel mid-level data fusion approach for multi-platform data analysis to simplify and speed up multi-platform data processing and evaluation. The key feature of AriumMS lies in the optimized data processing strategy, including parallel processing of datasets and flexible parameterization for processing of individual separation methods with different peak characteristics. As a case study, Saccharomyces cerevisiae (yeast) was treated with a growth inhibitor, and AriumMS successfully differentiated the metabolome based on the augmented multi-platform CE-MS and HILIC-MS investigation. As a result, AriumMS is proposed as a powerful tool to improve the accuracy and selectivity of metabolome analysis through the integration of several HILIC-MS/CE-MS techniques.

MetEx: A Targeted Extraction Strategy for Improving the Coverage and Accuracy of Metabolite Annotation in Liquid Chromatography-High-Resolution Mass Spectrometry Data

Liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS) is the most popular platform for untargeted metabolomics studies, but compound annotation is a challenge. In this work, we developed a new LC-HRMS data-targeted extraction method called MetEx for metabolite annotation. MetEx contains the retention time (t_R), MS1, and MS2 information of 30 620 metabolites from freely available spectral databases, including MoNA and KEGG. The t_R values of 95.4% of the compounds in our database were calculated by the GNN-RT model. The MS2 spectra of 39.4% compounds were also predicted using CFM-ID. MetEx was initially examined on a mixture of 634 standards, considering chemical coverage and accurate metabolite assignment, and later applied to human plasma (NIST SRM 1950), human urine, HepG2 cells, mouse liver tissue, and mouse feces. MetEx correctly assigned 252 out of 253 standards detected in our instruments. The platform also provided 8.0-44.2% more compounds in the biological samples compared to XCMS, MS-DIAL, and MZmine 2. MetEx is implemented and visualized in R and freely available at http://www.metaboex.cn/MetEx.

Detecting Water Constituents Unique to Septic Tanks as a Wastewater Source in the Environment by Nontarget Analysis: South Florida's Deering Estate Rehydration Project Case Study

The present study has generated a workflow based on nontarget analysis (NTA) with Compound Discoverer Ver 3.1 to characterize a set of source-discriminating compounds identified in water samples from locations in South Florida (USA), particularly those describing a freshwater environment (Everglades based), urban impacted areas (septic tank driven), and coastal (Biscayne Bay) endmembers in and around the Charles Deering Estate property in the Village of Palmetto Bay. Waters from an interconnected managed canal system were assessed to evaluate the influence of localized emissions. Septic tank effluents influence the water in many Southeast Florida environments due to their diminished onsite treatment capacity based on the limestone-dominated geology and canal systems providing a relatively unobstructed connection pathway. Through a combination of high-resolution mass spectrometry and statistical analyses, a set of tracers and indicators was determined (azelaic acid, decanophenone, galaxolidone, methyl violet, monoolein, metoprolol, and 1-stearoylglycerol). Tentatively identified compounds were generally assigned to various categories such as dyes, personal care products, and pharmaceuticals. The NTA Compound Discoverer Ver 3.1 compound data (presented as principal component analysis and Kendrick mass defect plots) showed apparent differences between wastewater-influenced sites and non-wastewater-influenced sites along with the ranked "Top10" compounds found at each location. Waters from different locations were also compared using the presence of sucralose to further inform the NTA. The most septic-influenced site contained 3594 ± 94 ng/L of sucralose with concentrations declining steadily and reaching the lowest concentrations in Biscayne Bay of 122 ± 94 ng/L. The sucralose concentrations provided further evidence of septic influence on this system. Sucralose was determined to be a conservative tracer between the freshwater and coastal sources and complementary to other probable unique tracers of septic tank effluent identified by the NTA. Environ Toxicol Chem 2022;41:1165-1178. © 2022 SETAC.

Computational Workflow to Study the Diversity of Secondary Metabolites in Fourteen Different Isatis Species

The screening of real features among thousands of ions remains a great challenge in the study of metabolomics. In this research, a workflow designed based on the MetaboFR tool and “feature-rating” rule was developed to screen the real features in large-scale data analyses. Seventy-four reference standards were used to test the feasibility, with 83.21% of real features being obtained after MetaboFR processing. Moreover, the full workflow was applied for systematic characterization of 14 species of the genus Isatis, with the result that 87.72% of real features were retained and 69.19% of the in-source fragments were removed. To gain insights into metabolite diversity within this plant family, 1697 real features were tentatively identified, including lipids, phenylpropanoids, organic acids, indole derivatives, etc. Indole derivatives were demonstrated to be the best chemical markers with which to differentiate different species. The rare existence of indole derivatives in Isatis cappadocica (cap) and Isatis cappadocica subsp. Steveniana (capS) indicates that the biosynthesis of indole derivatives could play a key role in driving the chemical diversity and evolution of genus Isatis. Our workflow provides the foundations for the exploration of real features in metabolomics, and has the potential to reveal the chemical composition and marker metabolites of secondary metabolites in plant fields.

Mining plant metabolomes: Methods, applications, and perspectives

Plants produce a variety of metabolites that are essential for plant growth and human health. To fully understand the diversity of metabolites in certain plants, lots of methods have been developed for metabolites detection and data processing. In the data-processing procedure, how to effectively reduce false-positive peaks, analyze large-scale metabolic data, and annotate plant metabolites remains challenging. In this review, we introduce and discuss some prominent methods that could be exploited to solve these problems, including a five-step filtering method for reducing false-positive signals in LC-MS analysis, QPMASS for analyzing ultra-large GC-MS data, and MetDNA for annotating metabolites. The main applications of plant metabolomics in species discrimination, metabolic pathway dissection, population genetic studies, and some other aspects are also highlighted. To further promote the development of plant metabolomics, more effective and integrated methods/platforms for metabolite detection and comprehensive databases for metabolite identification are highly needed. With the improvement of these technologies and the development of genomics and transcriptomics, plant metabolomics will be widely used in many fields.

A graph density-based strategy for features fusion from different peak extract software to achieve more metabolites in metabolic profiling from high-resolution mass spectrometry

In metabolomics study, it is not easy to extract the metabolites from data of ultra high-performance liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry, especially for those with low abundance. Different software for peak recognition and matching use different algorithms, leading to different extract results. Therefore, integration of results from different software can obtain richer metabolome information, but the redundant features should be removed. In this study, an integrated strategy of fusing features and removing redundancy based on graph density (FRRGD) was proposed. A graph is used to cover the ion features generated by two open access software (XCMS, MZmine 2) and a software (SIEVE) from an instrument vendor, and redundant features were removed by searching the maximal complete sub-graphs. A standard mixture containing 41 metabolites and a spontaneous urine were utilized to develop the method and demonstrate its usefulness. For the standard mixture, 19, 19 and 27 metabolites were extracted by XCMS, MZmine 2 and SIEVE, respectively. After fusion by FRRGD, 37 metabolites were obtained. For the diluted spontaneous urine sample, 1103, 1500 and 387 metabolites were extracted by XCMS, MZmine 2 and SIEVE, respectively, FRRGD produced 1619 metabolites which were much more than individual software, significantly increasing metabolome coverage. The proposed FRRGD shows a great prospect as a new data processing strategy for metabolomics study.

Metabolomics biotechnology, applications, and future trends: a systematic review

Given the highly increased incidence of human diseases, a better understanding of the related mechanisms regarding endogenous metabolism is urgently needed. Mass spectrometry-based metabolomics has been used in a variety of disease research areas. However, the deep research of metabolites remains a difficult and lengthy process. Fortunately, mass spectrometry is considered to be a universal tool with high specificity and sensitivity and is widely used around the world. Mass spectrometry technology has been applied to various basic disciplines, providing technical support for the discovery and identification of endogenous substances in living organisms. The combination of metabolomics and mass spectrometry is of great significance for the discovery and identification of metabolite biomarkers. The mass spectrometry tool could further improve and develop the exploratory research of the life sciences. This mini review discusses metabolomics biotechnology with a focus on recent applications of metabolomics as a powerful tool to elucidate metabolic disturbances and the related mechanisms of diseases.

Given the highly increased incidence of human diseases, a better understanding of the related mechanisms regarding endogenous metabolism is urgently needed.