Expanding the Definition of a Benign Renal Cyst on Contrast-enhanced CT: Can Incidental Homogeneous Renal Masses Measuring 21-39 HU be Safely Ignored?

Evaluation of class II cystic renal masses proposed in Bosniak classification version 2019: a systematic review of supporting evidence

PURPOSE

The Bosniak classification of cystic renal masses version 2019 (v.2019) includes an expanded number of types of masses in class II; such masses are considered benign in clinical practice. Data supporting these additions have not been well-documented. We aim to determine the proportion of malignant or probably malignant renal masses among the types added to Bosniak v.2019 class II.

METHODS

Multiple databases were searched for studies evaluating the proportion of malignant or probably malignant renal masses among new Bosniak v.2019 class II types, four for CT and two for MRI. Risk of bias and applicability was assessed using the QUADAS-2 tool.

RESULTS

Ten studies (2068 renal masses) met inclusion criteria. Among the four added class II types at CT, the proportion of malignancy among (1) 'homogeneous hyperattenuating (≥ 70 HU) masses at unenhanced CT' was 0% (0/32) in three studies; (2) 'homogeneous masses - 9 to 20 HU at unenhanced CT' was 0% (0/1454) in two studies, and (3) 'homogeneous masses 21 to 30 HU at portal-venous phase CT' was 0% (0/454) in four studies. Masses that are homogeneous, have low attenuation, and are too small to characterize on CT had no supportive evidence. Among the two added class II types at MRI, the proportion of malignancy among (1) 'homogeneous masses markedly hyperintense at unenhanced T2-weighted MR imaging (similar to CSF) was 0% (0/72) in one study, and (2) 'homogeneous masses markedly hyperintense at T1-weighted MR imaging (~ 2.5 × renal parenchyma signal intensity)' was 0% (0/32) and 5% (2/37) in two studies. Nine studies were at risk of bias within at least one QUADAS-2 domain.

CONCLUSION

The addition of six types of cystic renal masses to Class II in the Bosniak v.2019 proposal may be justified but based on limited evidence, with no evidence for 'homogeneous low attenuation masses that are too small to characterize' on CT, and thus considering them benign is in part based on expert opinion. Protocol Registration: PROSERO CRD42020196408.

Diagnostic performance of single-phase dual-energy CT to differentiate vascular and nonvascular incidental renal lesions on portal venous phase: comparison with CT

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether single-phase dual-energy CT (DECT) differentiates vascular and nonvascular renal lesions in the portal venous phase (PVP). Optimal iodine threshold was determined and compared to Hounsfield unit (HU) measurements.

METHODS

We retrospectively included 250 patients (266 renal lesions) who underwent a clinically indicated PVP abdominopelvic CT on a rapid-kilovoltage-switching single-source DECT (rsDECT) or a dual-source DECT (dsDECT) scanner. Iodine concentration and HU measurements were calculated by four experienced readers. Diagnostic accuracy was determined using biopsy results and follow-up imaging as reference standard. Area under the curve (AUC) was calculated for each DECT scanner to differentiate vascular from nonvascular lesions and vascular lesions from hemorrhagic/proteinaceous cysts. Univariable and multivariable logistic regression analyses evaluated the association between variables and the presence of vascular lesions.

RESULTS

A normalized iodine concentration threshold of 0.25 mg/mL yielded high accuracy in differentiating vascular and nonvascular lesions (AUC 0.93, p < 0.001), with comparable performance to HU measurements (AUC 0.93). Both iodine concentration and HU measurements were independently associated with vascular lesions when adjusted for age, gender, body mass index, and lesion size (AUC 0.95 and 0.95, respectively). When combined, diagnostic performance was higher (AUC 0.96). Both absolute and normalized iodine concentrations performed better than HU measurements (AUC 0.92 vs. AUC 0.87) in differentiating vascular lesions from hemorrhagic/proteinaceous cysts.

CONCLUSION

A single-phase (PVP) DECT scan yields high accuracy to differentiate vascular from nonvascular renal lesions. Iodine concentration showed a slightly higher performance than HU measurements in differentiating vascular lesions from hemorrhagic/proteinaceous cysts.

KEY POINTS

• A single-phase dual-energy CT scan in the portal venous phase differentiates vascular from nonvascular renal lesions with high accuracy (AUC 0.93). • When combined, iodine concentration and HU measurements showed the highest diagnostic performance (AUC 0.96) to differentiate vascular from nonvascular renal lesions. • Compared to HU measurements, iodine concentration showed a slightly higher performance in differentiating vascular lesions from hemorrhagic/proteinaceous cysts.

Bosniak Classification of Cystic Renal Masses, Version 2019: A Pictorial Guide to Clinical Use

Cystic renal masses are commonly encountered in clinical practice. In 2019, the Bosniak classification of cystic renal masses, originally developed for CT, underwent a major revision to incorporate MRI and is referred to as the Bosniak Classification, version 2019. The proposed changes attempt to (a) define renal masses (ie, cystic tumors with less than 25% enhancing tissue) to which the classification should be applied; (b) emphasize specificity for diagnosis of cystic renal cancers, thereby decreasing the number of benign and indolent cystic masses that are unnecessarily treated or imaged further; (c) improve interobserver agreement by defining imaging features, terms, and classes of cystic renal masses; (d) reduce variation in reported malignancy rates for each of the Bosniak classes; (e) incorporate MRI and to some extent US; and (f) be applicable to all cystic renal masses encountered in clinical practice, including those that had been considered indeterminate with the original classification. The authors instruct how, using CT, MRI, and to some extent US, the revised classification can be applied, with representative clinical examples and images. Practical tips, pitfalls to avoid, and decision tree rules are included to help radiologists and other physicians apply the Bosniak Classification, version 2019 and better manage cystic renal masses. An online resource and mobile application are also available for clinical assistance. An invited commentary by Siegel and Cohan is available online. ^©RSNA, 2021.

ACR Appropriateness Criteria® Indeterminate Renal Mass

Renal masses are increasingly detected in asymptomatic individuals as incidental findings. CT and MRI with intravenous contrast and a dedicated multiphase protocol are the mainstays of evaluation for indeterminate renal masses. A single-phase postcontrast dual-energy CT can be useful when a dedicated multiphase renal protocol CT is not available. Contrast-enhanced ultrasound with microbubble agents is a useful alternative for characterizing renal masses, especially for patients in whom iodinated CT contrast or gadolinium-based MRI contrast is contraindicated. The American College of Radiology Appropriateness Criteria are evidence-based guidelines for specific clinical conditions that are reviewed annually by a multidisciplinary expert panel. The guideline development and revision include an extensive analysis of current medical literature from peer reviewed journals and the application of well-established methodologies (RAND/UCLA Appropriateness Method and Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation or GRADE) to rate the appropriateness of imaging and treatment procedures for specific clinical scenarios. In those instances where evidence is lacking or equivocal, expert opinion may supplement the available evidence to recommend imaging or treatment.

Clinical Importance of Incidental Homogeneous Renal Masses That Measure 10-40 mm and 21-39 HU at Portal Venous Phase CT: A 12-Institution Retrospective Cohort Study

BACKGROUND. Incidental homogeneous renal masses are frequently encountered at portal venous phase CT. The American College of Radiology Incidental Findings Committee's white paper on renal masses recommends additional imaging for incidental homogeneous renal masses greater than 20 HU, but single-center data and the Bosniak classification version 2019 suggest the optimal attenuation threshold for detecting solid masses should be higher. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this article is to determine the clinical importance of small (10-40 mm) incidentally detected homogeneous renal masses measuring 21-39 HU at portal venous phase CT. METHODS. We performed a 12-institution retrospective cohort study of adult patients who underwent portal venous phase CT for a nonrenal indication. The date of the first CT at each institution ranged from January 1, 2008, to January 1, 2014. Consecutive reports from 12,167 portal venous phase CT examinations were evaluated. Images were reviewed for 4529 CT examinations whose report described a focal renal mass. Eligible masses were 10-40 mm, well-defined, subjectively homogeneous, and 21-39 HU. Of these, masses that were shown to be solid without macroscopic fat; classified as Bosniak IIF, III, or IV; or confirmed to be malignant were considered clinically important. The reference standard was renal mass protocol CT or MRI, ultrasound of definitively benign cysts or solid masses, single-phase contrast-enhanced CT or unenhanced MRI showing no growth or morphologic change for 5 years or more, or clinical follow-up 5 years or greater. A reference standard was available for 346 masses in 300 patients. The 95% CIs were calculated using the binomial exact method. RESULTS. Eligible masses were identified in 4.2% of patients (514/12,167; 95% CI, 3.9-4.6%). Of 346 masses with a reference standard, none were clinically important (0%; 95% CI, 0-0.9%). Mean mass size was 17 mm; 72% (248/346) measured 21-30 HU, and 28% (98/346) measured 31-39 HU. CONCLUSION. Incidental small homogeneous renal masses measuring 21-39 HU at portal venous phase CT are common and highly likely benign. CLINICAL IMPACT. The change in attenuation threshold signifying the need for additional imaging from greater than 20 HU to greater than 30 HU proposed by the Bosniak classification version 2019 is supported.

Mimics and Pitfalls in Renal Imaging

There are several potential pitfalls that radiologists face when interpreting images of the kidneys. Some result from image acquisition and can arise from the imaging equipment or imaging technique, whereas others are patient related. Another category of pitfalls relates to image interpretation. Some difficulties stem from methods to detect enhancement after contrast administration, whereas others are benign entities that can mimic a renal tumor. Finally, interpretation and diagnosis of fat-containing renal masses may be tricky due to the complexities discerning the pattern of fat within a mass and how that translates to an accurate diagnosis.

Approach to Renal Cystic Masses and the Role of Radiology

Most renal masses are benign cysts; a subset are malignant. Most renal masses are incidental findings. Evaluation of renal cysts has evolved with updates to the Bosniak classification system and other guidelines. The Bosniak classification provides detailed definitions and extends the system from computed tomography to MR imaging. This article provides a simple approach to the evaluation of cystic or potentially cystic renal masses. The radiologist is central to this process. Key elements include confirming that a renal lesion is cystic and not solid, determining the need for further characterization by imaging, and judicious application of the Bosniak classification system.

Outcomes and predictors of benign histology in patients undergoing robotic partial or radical nephrectomy for renal masses: a multicenter study

Introduction

Theaim of this study was to assess preoperative factors associated with benign histology in patients undergoing surgical removal of a renal mass and to analyze outcomes of robotic partial nephrectomy (PN) and radical nephrectomy (RN) for these masses.

Material and methods

Overall, 2,944 cases (543 benign and 2,401 malignant) who underwent robotic PN and RN between 2003–2018 at 10 institutions worldwide were included. The assessment of the predictors of benign histology was made at the final surgical pathology report. Descriptive statistics, Mann-Whitney U, Pearson’s χ², and logistic regression analysis were used.

Results

Patients in the benign group were mostly female (61 vs. 33%; p <0.001), with lower body mass index (BMI) (26.0 vs. 27.1 kg/m²; p <0.001). The benign group presented smaller tumor size (2.8 vs. 3.5 cm; p <0.001), R.E.N.A.L. score (6.0 vs. 7.0; p <0.001). There was a lower rate of hilar (11 vs.18%; p = 0.001), cT≥3 (1 vs. 4.5%; p <0.001) tumors in the benign group. There was a statistically significant higher rate of PN in the benign group (97 vs. 86%; p <0.001) as well as a statistically significant lower 30-day re-admission rate (2 vs. 5%; p = 0.081). Multivariable analysis showed male gender (OR: 0.52; p <0.001), BMI (OR: 0.95; p <0.001), and cT3a (OR: 0.22; p = 0.005) to be inversely associated to benign histology.

Conclusions

In 18% of cases, a benign histologic type was found. Only 3% of these tumors were treated with RN. Female gender, lower BMI, and higher T staging showed to be independent predictors of benign histology.

Bosniak Classification of Cystic Renal Masses, Version 2019: An Update Proposal and Needs Assessment

Cystic renal cell carcinoma (RCC) is almost certainly overdiagnosed and overtreated. Efforts to diagnose and treat RCC at a curable stage result in many benign neoplasms and indolent cancers being resected without clear benefit. This is especially true for cystic masses, which compared with solid masses are more likely to be benign and, when malignant, less aggressive. For more than 30 years, the Bosniak classification has been used to stratify the risk of malignancy in cystic renal masses. Although it is widely used and still effective, the classification does not formally incorporate masses identified at MRI or US or masses that are incompletely characterized but are highly likely to be benign, and it is affected by interreader variability and variable reported malignancy rates. The Bosniak classification system cannot fully differentiate aggressive from indolent cancers and results in many benign masses being resected. This proposed update to the Bosniak classification addresses some of these shortcomings. The primary modifications incorporate MRI, establish definitions for previously vague imaging terms, and enable a greater proportion of masses to enter lower-risk classes. Although the update will require validation, it aims to expand the number of cystic masses to which the Bosniak classification can be applied while improving its precision and accuracy for the likelihood of cancer in each class.

Diagnostic Accuracy of Attenuation Difference and Iodine Concentration Thresholds at Rapid-Kilovoltage-Switching Dual-Energy CT for Detection of Enhancement in Renal Masses

OBJECTIVE. The objective of our study was to evaluate iodine concentration and attenuation change in Hounsfield unit (ΔHU) thresholds to diagnose enhancement in renal masses at rapid-kilovoltage-switching dual-energy CT (DECT). MATERIALS AND METHODS. We evaluated 30 consecutive histologically confirmed solid renal masses (including nine papillary renal cell carcinomas [RCCs]) and 27 benign cysts (17 simple and 10 hemorrhagic or proteinaceous cysts) with DECT December 2016 and May 2018. A blinded radiologist measured iodine concentration (in milligrams per milliliter) and ΔHU (attenuation on enhanced CT - attenuation on unenhanced CT) using 70-keV corticomedullary (CM) phase virtual monochromatic and 120-kVp nephrographic (NG) phase images. The accuracies of previously described enhancement thresholds were compared by ROC curve analysis. RESULTS. An iodine concentration of ≥ 2.0 mg/mL and an iodine concentration of ≥ 1.2 mg/mL achieved sensitivity, specificity, and the area under the ROC curve (AUC) of 73.3%, 100.0%, and 0.87 and 86.7%, 100.0%, and 0.93, respectively. On 70-keV CM phase images, ΔHU ≥ 20 HU and ΔHU ≥ 15 HU yielded sensitivity, specificity, and AUC of 80.0%, 100.0%, and 0.90 and 90.0%, 100.0%, and 0.95, respectively. The numbers of incorrectly classified papillary RCCs were as follows: iodine concentration of ≥ 2.0 mg/mL, 77.8% (7/9; range, 0.7-1.6 mg/mL); iodine concentration of ≥ 1.2 mg/mL, 44.4% (4/9; range, 0.7-0.9 mg/mL); ΔHU ≥ 20 HU on 70-keV CM phase images, 66.7% (6/9; range, 4-17 HU); and ΔHU ≥ 15 HU on 70-keV DECT images, 33.3% (3/9; 4-12 HU). No cyst pseudoenhancement occurred on DECT. For 120-kVp NG phase DECT, ΔHU ≥ 20 HU and ΔHU ≥ 15 HU yielded sensitivity, specificity, and AUC of 93.3%, 96.3%, and 0.95 and 100.0%, 88.9%, and 0.94, respectively. With ΔHU ≥ 20 HU, 22.2% (2/9) (range, 15-18 HU) of papillary RCCs were misclassified and there was one pseudoenhancing cyst. With ΔHU ≥ 15 HU, no papillary RCCs were misclassified but 11.1% (3/27) of cysts showed pseudoenhancement. Only an iodine concentration of ≥ 2.0 mg/mL showed significantly lower accuracy than other measures (p = 0.031-0.045). CONCLUSION. DECT applied in the CM phase performed best using an iodine concentration of ≥ 1.2 mg/mL or a 70-keV ΔHU ≥ 15 HU; these parameters improved sensitivity for the detection of enhancement in renal masses without instances of cyst pseudoenhancement.

Society of Abdominal Radiology disease-focused panel on renal cell carcinoma: update on past, current, and future goals

The disease-focused panel (DFP) program was created by the Society of Abdominal Radiology (SAR) as a mechanism to "improve patient care, education, and research" in a "particular disease or a particular aspect of a disease". The DFP on renal cell carcinoma (RCC) was proposed in 2014 and has been functional for 4 years. Although nominally focused on RCC, the scope of the DFP has included indeterminate renal masses because many cannot be assigned a specific diagnosis when detected. Since its founding, the DFP has been active in a variety of clinical, research, and educational projects to optimize the care of patients with known or suspected RCC. The DFP is utilizing multi-institutional and cross-disciplinary collaboration to differentiate benign from malignant disease, optimize the management of early stage RCC, and ultimately to differentiate indolent from aggressive cancers. Several additional projects have worked to develop a quantitative biomarker that predicts metastatic RCC response to anti-angiogenic therapy. While disease focus is the premise by which all DFPs are created, it is likely that in the future the RCC DFP will need to expand or create new panels that will focus on other specific aspects of RCC-a result that the program's founders envisioned. New knowledge creates a need for more focus.