Differential affinity of BsSCO for Cu(II) and Cu(I) suggests a redox role in copper transfer to the Cu(A) center of cytochrome c oxidase

Biochemical pathway for the biosynthesis of the CuA center in bacterial cytochrome c oxidase

The di-copper center Cu_A is an essential metal cofactor in cytochrome oxidase (Cox) of mitochondria and many prokaryotes, mediating one-electron transfer from cytochrome c to the site for oxygen reduction. Cu_A is located in subunit II (CoxB) of Cox and protrudes into the periplasm of Gram-negative bacteria or the mitochondrial intermembrane space. How the two copper ions are brought together to build CoxB·Cu_A is the subject of this review. It had been known that the reductase TlpA and the metallochaperones ScoI and PcuC are required for Cu_A formation in bacteria, but the mechanism of copper transfer has emerged only recently for the Bradyrhizobium diazoefficiens system. It consists of the following steps: (a) TlpA keeps the active site cysteine pair of CoxB in its dithiol state as a prerequisite for metal insertion; (b) ScoI·Cu²⁺ rapidly forms a transient complex with apo-CoxB; (c) PcuC, loaded with Cu¹⁺ and Cu²⁺ , dissociates this complex to CoxB·Cu²⁺ , and a second PcuC·Cu¹⁺ ·Cu²⁺ transfers Cu¹⁺ to CoxB·Cu²⁺ , yielding mature CoxB·Cu_A . Variants of this pathway might exist in other bacteria or mitochondria.

Biochemistry of Copper Site Assembly in Heme-Copper Oxidases: A Theme with Variations

Copper is an essential cofactor for aerobic respiration, since it is required as a redox cofactor in Cytochrome c Oxidase (COX). This ancient and highly conserved enzymatic complex from the family of heme-copper oxidase possesses two copper sites: Cu_A and Cu_B. Biosynthesis of the oxidase is a complex, stepwise process that requires a high number of assembly factors. In this review, we summarize the state-of-the-art in the assembly of COX, with special emphasis in the assembly of copper sites. Assembly of the Cu_A site is better understood, being at the same time highly variable among organisms. We also discuss the current challenges that prevent the full comprehension of the mechanisms of assembly and the pending issues in the field.

Structural basis and mechanism for metallochaperone-assisted assembly of the CuA center in cytochrome oxidase

The mechanisms underlying the biogenesis of the structurally unique, binuclear Cu^1.5+•Cu^1.5+ redox center (Cu_A) on subunit II (CoxB) of cytochrome oxidases have been a long-standing mystery. Here, we reconstituted the CoxB•Cu_A center in vitro from apo-CoxB and the holo-forms of the copper transfer chaperones ScoI and PcuC. A previously unknown, highly stable ScoI•Cu²⁺•CoxB complex was shown to be rapidly formed as the first intermediate in the pathway. Moreover, our structural data revealed that PcuC has two copper-binding sites, one each for Cu¹⁺ and Cu²⁺, and that only PcuC•Cu¹⁺•Cu²⁺ can release CoxB•Cu²⁺ from the ScoI•Cu²⁺•CoxB complex. The CoxB•Cu_A center was then formed quantitatively by transfer of Cu¹⁺ from a second equivalent of PcuC•Cu¹⁺•Cu²⁺ to CoxB•Cu²⁺. This metalation pathway is consistent with all available in vivo data and identifies the sources of the Cu ions required for Cu_A center formation and the order of their delivery to CoxB.

Palladium(II) Ion Mediated Disulfide/Thiolate Interconversion: Predicting the Disulfide Group State from First Principles

Different reactivity of homologous disulfides toward Pd²⁺ was previously reported: stepwise complexation to Pd²⁺ for l-cystine and cystamine ligands, while for dl-homocystine and 3,3'-dithiodipropionic acid, disulfide's disproportionation toward thiolate and sulfinic acid complexes is observed. The disulfide/thiolate interconversion of four different disulfide ligands in the presence of nonredox metal cation Pd²⁺ in aqueous solution has been computationally investigated. We see this different reactivity in different capacities of considered homologous disulfides to stabilize forming S,S'-binuclear complexes, which are believed to be key intermediates toward interconversion products. We thus devise a theoretical model that rationalizes experimentally observed phenomenon of disulfides different reactivity toward nonredox transition metal cation Pd²⁺.

Exposure of Bacillus subtilis to silver inhibits activity of cytochrome c oxidase in vivo via interaction with SCO, the CuA assembly protein

Silver has long been used as an antimicrobial agent in general and medicinal use. Here, we observe that exposure of the Gram-positive, endospore-forming bacterium Bacillus subtilis to Ag(i) effects growth in a biphasic manner. In the first phase at Ag(i) concentrations below 50 μM B. subtilis growth is not affected, but activity of the respiratory enzyme cytochrome c oxidase is disrupted completely. Between 50 to 100 μM Ag(i) B. subtilis growth is drastically diminished and completely absent above 100 μM Ag(i). Synthesis of cytochrome c oxidase, or SCO proteins, have been shown to play a role in assembly of the CuA center of cytochrome c oxidase and we suppose that the effects observed here of silver on Bacillus subtilis in culture may be explained at least in part by the interaction of Bacillus SCO (BsSCO) with Ag(i). We find that Ag(i) forms a high affinity complex with BsSCO in vitro that blocks SCO's interaction with copper indicating competition between the metals for binding BsSCO. The interaction of BsSCO with Ag(i) exhibits multiple phases and is more complex than that observed for the high-affinity, 1 : 1 copper complex with BsSCO. We propose that the initial response of B. subtilis cultures is due to high affinity binding of Ag(i) to BsSCO that blocks the functionality of BsSCO required for assembly of cytochrome c oxidase. Our results provide evidence of a specific effect of silver on Bacillus subtilis cells and implies that SCO proteins play a role in sensitivity to Ag(i).

The Cu chaperone CopZ is required for Cu homeostasis in Rhodobacter capsulatus and influences cytochrome cbb3 oxidase assembly

Cu homeostasis depends on a tightly regulated network of proteins that transport or sequester Cu, preventing the accumulation of this toxic metal while sustaining Cu supply for cuproproteins. In Rhodobacter capsulatus, Cu-detoxification and Cu delivery for cytochrome c oxidase (cbb₃ -Cox) assembly depend on two distinct Cu-exporting P_1B -type ATPases. The low-affinity CopA is suggested to export excess Cu and the high-affinity CcoI feeds Cu into a periplasmic Cu relay system required for cbb₃ -Cox biogenesis. In most organisms, CopA-like ATPases receive Cu for export from small Cu chaperones like CopZ. However, whether these chaperones are also involved in Cu export via CcoI-like ATPases is unknown. Here we identified a CopZ-like chaperone in R. capsulatus, determined its cellular concentration and its Cu binding activity. Our data demonstrate that CopZ has a strong propensity to form redox-sensitive dimers via two conserved cysteine residues. A ΔcopZ strain, like a ΔcopA strain, is Cu-sensitive and accumulates intracellular Cu. In the absence of CopZ, cbb₃ -Cox activity is reduced, suggesting that CopZ not only supplies Cu to P_1B -type ATPases for detoxification but also for cuproprotein assembly via CcoI. This finding was further supported by the identification of a ~150 kDa CcoI-CopZ protein complex in native R. capsulatus membranes.

Handling of nutrient copper in the bacterial envelope

The insertion of copper into bacterial cuproenzymesin vivodoes not always require a copper-binding metallochaperone – why?

DEPC modification of the CuA protein from Thermus thermophilus

The Cu_A center is the initial electron acceptor in cytochrome c oxidase, and it consists of two copper ions bridged by two cysteines and ligated by two histidines, a methionine, and a carbonyl in the peptide backbone of a nearby glutamine. The two ligating histidines are of particular interest as they may influence the electronic and redox properties of the metal center. To test for the presence of reactive ligating histidines, a portion of cytochrome c oxidase from the bacteria Thermus thermophilus that contains the Cu_A site (the TtCu_A protein) was treated with the chemical modifier diethyl pyrocarbonate (DEPC) and the reaction followed through UV-visible, circular dichroism, and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopies at pH 5.0-9.0. A mutant protein (H40A/H117A) with the non-ligating histidines removed was similarly tested. Introduction of an electron-withdrawing DEPC-modification onto the ligating histidine 157 of TtCu_A increased the reduction potential by over 70 mV, as assessed by cyclic voltammetry. Results from both proteins indicate that DEPC reacts with one of the two ligating histidines, modification of a ligating histidine raises the reduction potential of the Cu_A site, and formation of the DEPC adduct is reversible at room temperature. The existence of the reactive ligating histidine suggests that this residue may play a role in modulating the electronic and redox properties of TtCu_A through kinetically-controlled proton exchange with the solvent. Lack of reactivity by the metalloproteins Sco and azurin, both of which contain a mononuclear copper center, indicate that reactivity toward DEPC is not a characteristic of all ligating histidines.

Characterization and effect of metal ions on the formation of the Thermus thermophilus Sco mixed disulfide intermediate

The Sco protein from Thermus thermophilus has previously been shown to perform a disulfide bond reduction in the Cu_A protein from T. thermophilus, which is a soluble protein engineered from subunit II of cytochrome ba ₃ oxidase that lacks the transmembrane helix. The native cysteines on TtSco and TtCu_A were mutated to serine residues to probe the reactivities of the individual cysteines. Conjugation of TNB to the remaining cysteine in TtCu_A and subsequent release upon incubation with the complementary TtSco protein demonstrated the formation of the mixed disulfide intermediate. The cysteine of TtSco that attacks the disulfide bond in the target TtCu_A protein was determined to be TtSco Cysteine 49. This cysteine is likely more reactive than Cysteine 53 due to a higher degree of solvent exposure. Removal of the metal binding histidine, His 139, does not change MDI formation. However, altering the arginine adjacent to the reactive cysteine in Sco (Arginine 48) does alter the formation of the MDI. Binding of Cu²⁺ or Cu⁺ to TtSco prior to reaction with TtCu_A was found to preclude formation of the mixed disulfide intermediate. These results shed light on a mechanism of disulfide bond reduction by the TtSco protein and may point to a possible role of metal binding in regulating the activity. IMPORTANCE: The function of Sco is at the center of many studies. The disulfide bond reduction in Cu_A by Sco is investigated herein and the effect of metal ions on the ability to reduce and form a mixed disulfide intermediate are also probed.

The copper-deprivation stimulon of Corynebacterium glutamicum comprises proteins for biogenesis of the actinobacterial cytochrome bc 1-aa 3 supercomplex

Aerobic respiration in Corynebacterium glutamicum involves a cytochrome bc ₁-aa ₃ supercomplex with a diheme cytochrome c ₁, which is the only c-type cytochrome in this species. This organization is considered as typical for aerobic Actinobacteria. Whereas the biogenesis of heme-copper type oxidases like cytochrome aa ₃ has been studied extensively in α-proteobacteria, yeast, and mammals, nothing is known about this process in Actinobacteria. Here, we searched for assembly proteins of the supercomplex by identifying the copper-deprivation stimulon, which might include proteins that insert copper into cytochrome aa ₃ Using gene expression profiling, we found two copper starvation-induced proteins for supercomplex formation. The Cg2699 protein, named CtiP, contained 16 predicted transmembrane helices, and its sequence was similar to that of the copper importer CopD of Pseudomonas syringae in the N-terminal half and to the cytochrome oxidase maturation protein CtaG of Bacillus subtilis in its C-terminal half. CtiP deletion caused a growth defect similar to that produced by deletion of subunit I of cytochrome aa ₃, increased copper tolerance, triggered expression of the copper-deprivation stimulon under copper sufficiency, and prevented co-purification of the supercomplex subunits. The secreted Cg1884 protein, named CopC, had a C-terminal transmembrane helix and contained a Cu(II)-binding motif. Its absence caused a conditional growth defect, increased copper tolerance, and also prevented co-purification of the supercomplex subunits. CtiP and CopC are conserved among aerobic Actinobacteria, and we propose a model of their functions in cytochrome aa ₃ biogenesis. Furthermore, we found that the copper-deprivation response involves additional regulators besides the ECF sigma factor SigC.

Unusual Reduction Mechanism of Copper in Cysteine-Rich Environment

Copper-cysteine interactions play an important role in Biology and herein we used the copper-substituted rubredoxin (Cu-Rd) from Desulfovibrio gigas to gain further insights into the copper-cysteine redox chemistry. EPR spectroscopy results are consistent with Cu-Rd harboring a Cu^II center in a sulfur-rich coordination, in a distorted tetrahedral structure ( g_∥,⊥ = 2.183 and 2.032 and A_∥,⊥ = 76.4 × 10^-4 and 12 × 10^-4 cm^-1). In Cu-Rd, two oxidation states at Cu-center (Cu^II and Cu^I) are associated with Cys oxidation-reduction, alternating in the redox cycle, as pointed by electrochemical studies that suggest internal geometry rearrangements associated with the electron transfer processes. The midpoint potential of [Cu^I(S-Cys)₂(Cys-S-S-Cys)]/[Cu^II(S-Cys)₄] redox couple was found to be -0.15 V vs NHE showing a large separation of cathodic and anodic peaks potential (Δ E_p = 0.575 V). Interestingly, sulfur-rich Cu^II-Rd is highly stable under argon in dark conditions, which is thermodynamically unfavorable to Cu-thiol autoreduction. The reduction of copper and concomitant oxidation of Cys can both undergo two possible pathways: oxidative as well as photochemical. Under O₂, Cu^II plays the role of the electron carrier from one Cys to O₂ followed by internal geometry rearrangement at the Cu site, which facilitates reduction at Cu-center to yield Cu^I(S-Cys)₂(Cys-S-S-Cys). Photoinduced (irradiated at λ_ex = 280 nm) reduction of the Cu^II center is observed by UV-visible photolysis (above 300 nm all bands disappeared) and tryptophan fluorescence (∼335 nm peak enhanced) experiments. In both pathways, geometry reorganization plays an important role in copper reduction yielding an energetically compatible donor-acceptor system. This model system provides unusual stability and redox chemistry rather than the universal Cu-thiol auto redox chemistry in cysteine-rich copper complexes.

A Copper Relay System Involving Two Periplasmic Chaperones Drives cbb3-Type Cytochrome c Oxidase Biogenesis in Rhodobacter capsulatus

PccA and SenC are periplasmic copper chaperones required for the biogenesis of cbb₃-type cytochrome c oxidase ( cbb₃-Cox) in Rhodobacter capsulatus at physiological Cu concentrations. However, both proteins are dispensable for cbb₃-Cox assembly when the external Cu concentration is high. PccA and SenC bind Cu using Met and His residues and Cys and His residues as ligands, respectively, and both proteins form a complex during cbb₃-Cox biogenesis. SenC also interacts directly with cbb₃-Cox, as shown by chemical cross-linking. Here we determined the periplasmic concentrations of both proteins in vivo and analyzed their Cu binding stoichiometries and their Cu(I) and Cu(II) binding affinity constants ( K_D) in vitro. Our data show that both proteins bind a single Cu atom with high affinity. In vitro Cu transfer assays demonstrate Cu transfer both from PccA to SenC and from SenC to PccA at similar levels. We conclude that PccA and SenC constitute a Cu relay system that facilitates Cu delivery to cbb₃-Cox.

The affinity of yeast and bacterial SCO proteins for CU(I) and CU(II). A capture and release strategy for copper transfer

SCO (Synthesis of Cytochrome c Oxidase) proteins are present in prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells, and are often required for efficient synthesis of the respiratory enzyme cytochrome c oxidase. The Bacillus subtilis version of SCO (i.e., BsSCO) has much greater affinity for Cu(II) than it does for Cu(I) (Davidson and Hill, 2009), and this has been contrasted to mitochondrial SCO proteins that are characterized as being specific for Cu(I) (Nittis, George and Winge, 2001). This differential affinity has been proposed to reflect the different physiological environments in which these two members of the SCO protein family reside. In this study the affinity of mitochondrial SCO1 from yeast is compared directly to that of BsSCO in vitro. We find that the yeast SCO1 protein has similar preference for Cu(II) over Cu(I), as does BsSCO. We propose a mechanism for SCO function which would involve high-affinity binding to capture Cu(II), and relatively weak binding of Cu(I) to facilitate copper transfer.

•

Yeast SCO1 prefers Cu(II) over Cu(I) by many orders of magnitude.

•

Yeast SCO1 has similar copper-species preference as a bacterial SCO protein.

•

High affinity binding of Cu(II) by SCO may be initial step in copper transfer.

•

Conversion of SCO-Cu(II) to SCO-Cu(I) is required for copper transfer.

•

A second cysteine pair in yeast SCO1 may be involved in redox sensing.

Protein chaperones mediating copper insertion into the CuA site of the aa3-type cytochrome c oxidase of Paracoccus denitrificans

The biogenesis of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase is a complex process involving the stepwise assembly of its multiple subunits encoded by two genetic systems. Moreover, several chaperones are required to recruit and insert the redox-active metal centers into subunits I and II, two a-type hemes and a total of three copper ions, two of which form the CuA center located in a hydrophilic domain of subunit II. The copper-binding Sco protein(s) have been implicated with the metallation of this site in various model organisms. Here we analyze the role of the two Sco homologues termed ScoA and ScoB, along with two other copper chaperones, on the biogenesis of the cytochrome c oxidase in the bacterium Paracoccus denitrificans by deleting each of the four genes individually or pairwise, followed by assessing the functionality of the assembled oxidase both in intact membranes and in the purified enzyme complex. Copper starvation leads to a drastic decrease of oxidase activity in membranes from strains involving the scoB deletion. This loss is shown to be of dual origin, (i) a severe drop in steady-state oxidase levels in membranes, and (ii) a diminished enzymatic activity of the remaining oxidase complex, traced back to a lower copper content, specifically in the CuA site of the enzyme. Neither of the other proteins addressed here, ScoA or the two PCu proteins, exhibit a direct effect on the metallation of the CuA site in P. denitrificans, but are discussed as potential interaction partners of ScoB.