Native mass spectrometry and ion mobility characterize the orange carotenoid protein functional domains

CIUSuite 3: Next-Generation CCS Calibration and Automated Data Analysis Tools for Gas-Phase Protein Unfolding Data

Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) has become a technology deployed across a wide range of structural biology applications despite the challenges in characterizing closely related protein structures. Collision-induced unfolding (CIU) has emerged as a valuable technique for distinguishing closely related, iso-cross-sectional protein and protein complex ions through their distinct unfolding pathways in the gas phase. With the speed and sensitivity of CIU analyses, there has been a rapid growth of CIU-based assays, especially regarding biomolecular targets that remain challenging to assess and characterize with other structural biology tools. With information-rich CIU data, many software tools have been developed to automate laborious data analysis. However, with the recent development of new IM-MS technologies, such as cyclic IM-MS, CIU continues to evolve, necessitating improved data analysis tools to keep pace with new technologies and facilitating the automation of various data processing tasks. Here, we present CIUSuite 3, a software package that contains updated algorithms that support various IM-MS platforms and supports the automation of various data analysis tasks such as peak detection, multidimensional classification, and collision cross section (CCS) calibration. CIUSuite 3 uses local maxima searches along with peak width and prominence filters to detect peaks to automate CIU data extraction. To support both the primary CIU (CIU1) and secondary CIU (CIU2) experiments enabled by cyclic IM-MS, two-dimensional data preprocessing is deployed, which allows multidimensional classification. Our data suggest that additional dimensions in classification improve the overall accuracy of class assignments. CIUSuite 3 also supports CCS calibration for both traveling wave and drift tube IM-MS, and we demonstrate the accuracy of a new single-field CCS calibration method designed for drift tube IM-MS leveraging calibrant CIU data. Overall, CIUSuite 3 is positioned to support current and next-generation IM-MS and CIU assay development deployed in an automated format.

Oligomerization processes limit photoactivation and recovery of the Orange Carotenoid Protein

The Orange Carotenoid Protein (OCP) is a photoactive protein involved in cyanobacterial photoprotection, by quenching of the excess of light harvested energy. The photoactivation mechanism remains elusive, in part due to absence of data pertaining to the timescales over which protein structural changes take place. It also remains unclear whether or not oligomerization of the dark-adapted and light-adapted OCP could play a role in the regulation of its energy quenching activity. Here, we probed photo-induced structural changes in OCP by a combination of static and time-resolved X-ray scattering and steady-state and transient optical spectroscopy in the visible range. Our results suggest that oligomerization partakes in regulation of the OCP photocycle, with different oligomers slowing down the overall thermal recovery of the dark-adapted state of OCP. They furthermore reveal that upon non-photoproductive excitation, a numbed-state forms, which remains in a non-photoexcitable structural state for at least ∼0.5 μs after absorption of a first photon.

Mass Spectrometry Methods for Measuring Protein Stability

Mass spectrometry is a central technology in the life sciences, providing our most comprehensive account of the molecular inventory of the cell. In parallel with developments in mass spectrometry technologies targeting such assessments of cellular composition, mass spectrometry tools have emerged as versatile probes of biomolecular stability. In this review, we cover recent advancements in this branch of mass spectrometry that target proteins, a centrally important class of macromolecules that accounts for most biochemical functions and drug targets. Our efforts cover tools such as hydrogen-deuterium exchange, chemical cross-linking, ion mobility, collision induced unfolding, and other techniques capable of stability assessments on a proteomic scale. In addition, we focus on a range of application areas where mass spectrometry-driven protein stability measurements have made notable impacts, including studies of membrane proteins, heat shock proteins, amyloidogenic proteins, and biotherapeutics. We conclude by briefly discussing the future of this vibrant and fast-moving area of research.

High-Resolution Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) involves the analysis and characterization of macromolecules, predominantly intact proteins and protein complexes, whereby as much as possible the native structural features of the analytes are retained. As such, native MS enables the study of secondary, tertiary, and even quaternary structure of proteins and other biomolecules. Native MS represents a relatively recent addition to the analytical toolbox of mass spectrometry and has over the past decade experienced immense growth, especially in enhancing sensitivity and resolving power but also in ease of use. With the advent of dedicated mass analyzers, sample preparation and separation approaches, targeted fragmentation techniques, and software solutions, the number of practitioners and novel applications has risen in both academia and industry. This review focuses on recent developments, particularly in high-resolution native MS, describing applications in the structural analysis of protein assemblies, proteoform profiling of─among others─biopharmaceuticals and plasma proteins, and quantitative and qualitative analysis of protein-ligand interactions, with the latter covering lipid, drug, and carbohydrate molecules, to name a few.

Collision-Induced Unfolding Reveals Stability Differences in Infliximab Therapeutics under Native and Heat Stress Conditions

Ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS) and collision-induced unfolding (CIU) assays of monoclonal antibody (mAb)-based biotherapeutics have proven sensitive to disulfide bridge structures, glycosylation patterns, and small molecule conjugation levels. Despite promising prior reports detailing the capabilities of IM-MS and CIU to differentiate biosimilars, generic mAb therapeutics, there remain questions surrounding the sensitivity of CIU to mAb structure changes that occur upon stress, the reproducibility of such measurements across IM-MS platforms, and the correlation between CIU and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) datasets. In this report, we describe a comprehensive IM-MS and CIU dataset acquired for three Infliximabs: Remicade, Inflectra, and Renflexis. We subject each infliximab sample to forced degradation through heat stress and observe broadly similar yet subtly different stability patterns for these three biotherapeutics. We find that CIU is capable of tracking differences in mAb higher-order structure (HOS) imparted during forced heat stress degradation and that DSC is less sensitive to these alterations in comparison. Furthermore, we collected our comprehensive IM-MS and CIU data across two instrument platforms (Waters G2 and Agilent 6560), with both producing similar abilities to differentiate mAbs while also revealing minor differences between the results obtained on the two instruments. Finally, we demonstrate that CIU-based heatmaps and classification allow for rapid assessment of the most differentiating charge states for the analysis of infliximab, and using multiplexed classification, we conservatively estimate a 30-fold improvement in the time required to perform mAb stability and HOS measurements over standard DSC tools.

A Modified Drift Tube Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometer for Charge-Multiplexed Collision-Induced Unfolding

Collision-induced unfolding (CIU) of protein ions and their noncovalent complexes offers relatively rapid access to a rich portfolio of biophysical information, without the need to tag or purify proteins prior to analysis. Such assays have been characterized extensively for a range of therapeutic proteins, proving exquisitely sensitive to alterations in protein sequence, structure, and post-translational modification state. Despite advantages over traditional probes of protein stability, improving the throughput and information content of gas-phase protein unfolding assays remains a challenge for current instrument platforms. In this report, we describe modifications to an Agilent 6560 drift tube ion mobility-mass spectrometer in order to perform robust, simultaneous CIU across all precursor ions detected. This approach dramatically increases the speed associated with typical CIU assays, which typically involve mass selection of narrow m/ z regions prior to collisional activation, and thus their development requires a comprehensive assessment of charge-stripping reactions that can unintentionally pollute CIU data with chemical noise when more than one precursor ion is allowed to undergo simultaneous activation. By studying the unfolding and dissociation of intact antibody ions, a key analyte class associated with biotherapeutics, we reveal a predictive relationship between the precursor charge state, the amount of buffer components bound to the ions of interest, and the amount of charge stripping detected. We then utilize our knowledge of antibody charge stripping to rapidly capture CIU data for a range of antibody subclasses and subtypes across all charge states simultaneously, demonstrating a strong charge state dependence on the information content of CIU. Finally, we demonstrate that CIU data collection times can be further reduced by scanning fewer voltage steps, enabling us to optimize the throughput of our improved CIU methods and confidently differentiate antibody variant ions using ∼20% of the data typically collected during CIU. Taken together, our results characterize a new instrument platform for biotherapeutic stability measurements with dramatically improved throughput and information content.

Features of Protein-Protein Interactions in the Cyanobacterial Photoprotection Mechanism

Photoprotective mechanisms of cyanobacteria are characterized by several features associated with the structure of their water-soluble antenna complexes - the phycobilisomes (PBs). During energy transfer from PBs to chlorophyll of photosystem reaction centers, the "energy funnel" principle is realized, which regulates energy flux due to the specialized interaction of the PBs core with a quenching molecule capable of effectively dissipating electron excitation energy into heat. The role of the quencher is performed by ketocarotenoid within the photoactive orange carotenoid protein (OCP), which is also a sensor for light flux. At a high level of insolation, OCP is reversibly photoactivated, and this is accompanied by a significant change in its structure and spectral characteristics. Such conformational changes open the possibility for protein-protein interactions between OCP and the PBs core (i.e., activation of photoprotection mechanisms) or the fluorescence recovery protein. Even though OCP was discovered in 1981, little was known about the conformation of its active form until recently, as well as about the properties of homologs of its N and C domains. Studies carried out during recent years have made a breakthrough in understanding of the structural-functional organization of OCP and have enabled discovery of new aspects of the regulation of photoprotection processes in cyanobacteria. This review focuses on aspects of protein-protein interactions between the main participants of photoprotection reactions and on certain properties of representatives of newly discovered families of OCP homologs.

Coupled rows of PBS cores and PSII dimers in cyanobacteria: symmetry and structure

Phycobilisome (PBS) is a giant water-soluble photosynthetic antenna transferring the energy of absorbed light mainly to the photosystem II (PSII) in cyanobacteria. Under the low light conditions, PBSs and PSII dimers form coupled rows where each PBS is attached to the cytoplasmic surface of PSII dimer, and PBSs come into contact with their face surfaces (state 1). The model structure of the PBS core that we have developed earlier by comparison and combination of different fine allophycocyanin crystals, as reported in Zlenko et al. (Photosynth Res 130(1):347-356, 2016b), provides a natural way of the PBS core face-to-face stacking. According to our model, the structure of the protein-protein contact between the neighboring PBS cores in the rows is the same as the contact between the APC hexamers inside the PBS core. As a result, the rates of energy transfer between the cores can occur, and the row of PBS cores acts as an integral PBS "supercore" providing energy transfer between the individual PBS cores. The PBS cores row pitch in our elaborated model (12.4 nm) is very close to the PSII dimers row pitch obtained by the electron microscopy (12.2 nm) that allowed to unite a model of the PBS cores row with a model of the PSII dimers row. Analyzing the resulting model, we have determined the most probable locations of ApcD and ApcE terminal emitter subunits inside the bottom PBS core cylinders and also revealed the chlorophyll molecules of PSII gathering energy from the PBS.

The Unique Protein-to-Protein Carotenoid Transfer Mechanism

Orange Carotenoid Protein (OCP) is known as an effector and regulator of cyanobacterial photoprotection. This 35 kDa water-soluble protein provides specific environment for blue-green light absorbing keto-carotenoids, which excitation causes dramatic but fully reversible rearrangements of the OCP structure, including carotenoid translocation and separation of C- and N-terminal domains upon transition from the basic orange to photoactivated red OCP form. Although recent studies greatly improved our understanding of the OCP photocycle and interaction with phycobilisomes and the fluorescence recovery protein, the mechanism of OCP assembly remains unclear. Apparently, this process requires targeted delivery and incorporation of a highly hydrophobic carotenoid molecule into the water-soluble apoprotein of OCP. Recently, we introduced, to our knowledge, a novel carotenoid carrier protein, COCP, which consists of dimerized C-domain(s) of OCP and can combine with the isolated N-domain to form transient OCP-like species. Here, we demonstrate that in vitro COCP efficiently transfers otherwise tightly bound carotenoid to the full-length OCP apoprotein, resulting in formation of photoactive OCP from completely photoinactive species. We accurately analyze the peculiarities of this process that, to the best of our knowledge, appears unique, a previously uncharacterized protein-to-protein carotenoid transfer mechanism. We hypothesize that a similar OCP assembly can occur in vivo, substantiating specific roles of the COCP carotenoid carrier in cyanobacterial photoprotection.

Fluorescent Labeling Preserving OCP Photoactivity Reveals Its Reorganization during the Photocycle

Orange carotenoid protein (OCP), responsible for the photoprotection of the cyanobacterial photosynthetic apparatus under excessive light conditions, undergoes significant rearrangements upon photoconversion and transits from the stable orange to the signaling red state. This is thought to involve a 12-Å translocation of the carotenoid cofactor and separation of the N- and C-terminal protein domains. Despite clear recent progress, the detailed mechanism of the OCP photoconversion and associated photoprotection remains elusive. Here, we labeled the OCP of Synechocystis with tetramethylrhodamine-maleimide (TMR) and obtained a photoactive OCP-TMR complex, the fluorescence of which was highly sensitive to the protein state, showing unprecedented contrast between the orange and red states and reflecting changes in protein conformation and the distances from TMR to the carotenoid throughout the photocycle. The OCP-TMR complex was sensitive to the light intensity, temperature, and viscosity of the solvent. Based on the observed Förster resonance energy transfer, we determined that upon photoconversion, the distance between TMR (donor) bound to a cysteine in the C-terminal domain and the carotenoid (acceptor) increased by 18 Å, with simultaneous translocation of the carotenoid into the N-terminal domain. Time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy revealed a significant decrease of the OCP rotation rate in the red state, indicating that the light-triggered conversion of the protein is accompanied by an increase of its hydrodynamic radius. Thus, our results support the idea of significant structural rearrangements of OCP, providing, to our knowledge, new insights into the structural rearrangements of OCP throughout the photocycle and a completely novel approach to the study of its photocycle and non-photochemical quenching. We suggest that this approach can be generally applied to other photoactive proteins.

Structure and functions of Orange Carotenoid Protein homologs in cyanobacteria

Rapidly-induced photoprotection in cyanobacteria involves thermal dissipation of excess energy absorbed by the phycobilisome (PBS), the primary light-harvesting antenna. This process is called non-photochemical quenching (NPQ), and is mediated by a water-soluble photoactive protein, the Orange Carotenoid Protein (OCP). The OCP is structurally and functionally modular, consisting of a sensor domain, an effector domain, and a carotenoid. Blue-green light induces a structural transition of the OCP from the orange inactive form, OCP^o, to the red active form, OCP^R. Translocation of the carotenoid into the effector domain accompanies photoactivation. The OCP^R binds to the PBS core, where it triggers dissipation of excitation energy and quenches fluorescence. To recover the antenna capacity under low light conditions, the Fluorescence Recovery Protein (FRP) participates in detaching the OCP from the PBS and accelerates back-conversion of OCP^R to OCP^o. Increased sequencing of cyanobacterial genomes has allowed the identification of new paralogous families of the OCP and its domain homologs, the Helical Carotenoid Proteins (HCPs), which have been found distributed widely among taxonomically and ecophysiologically diverse cyanobacteria. Distinct functions from the canonical OCP have been revealed for some of these paralogs by recent structural and functional studies.

Deletion of the short N-terminal extension in OCP reveals the main site for FRP binding

The orange carotenoid protein (OCP) plays a key role in cyanobacterial photoprotection. Photoconversion entails structural rearrangements in OCP that are required for its binding to phycobilisome, thereby inducing excitation energy dissipation. Detachment of OCP from phycobilisome requires the fluorescence recovery protein (FRP). It is considered that OCP interacts with FRP only in the photoactivated state; however, the binding site for FRP is currently unknown. As an important stabilizing element in orange OCP, the short αA-helix within the N-terminal extension (NTE) binds to the C-terminal domain (CTD), but unfolds upon photoactivation and interferes with phycobilisome binding. Here, we demonstrate that the NTE shares specific structural and functional similarities with FRP and discover the main site of OCP-FRP interactions in the OCP-CTD.

A Molecular Mechanism for Nonphotochemical Quenching in Cyanobacteria

The cyanobacterial orange carotenoid protein (OCP) protects photosynthetic cyanobacteria from photodamage by dissipating excess excitation energy collected by phycobilisomes (PBS) as heat. Dissociation of the PBS-OCP complex in vivo is facilitated by another protein known as the fluorescence recovery protein (FRP), which primarily exists as a dimeric complex. We used various mass spectrometry (MS)-based techniques to investigate the molecular mechanism of this FRP-mediated process. FRP in the dimeric state (dFRP) retains its high affinity for the C-terminal domain (CTD) of OCP in the red state (OCP^r). Site-directed mutagenesis and native MS suggest the head region on FRP is a candidate to bind OCP. After attachment to the CTD, the conformational changes of dFRP allow it to bridge the two domains, facilitating the reversion of OCP^r into the orange state (OCP^o) accompanied by a structural rearrangement of dFRP. Interestingly, we found a mutual response between FRP and OCP; that is, FRP and OCP^r destabilize each other, whereas FRP and OCP^o stabilize each other. A detailed mechanism of FRP function is proposed on the basis of the experimental results.

The purple Trp288Ala mutant of Synechocystis OCP persistently quenches phycobilisome fluorescence and tightly interacts with FRP

In Cyanobacteria, the Orange Carotenoid Protein (OCP) and Fluorescence Recovery Protein (FRP) are central to the photoprotective mechanism consisting in regulated quenching of phycobilisome (PBs) fluorescence. Due to a transient and flexible nature of the light-activated red quenching form, OCP^R, which is obtained from the stable dark-adapted orange form, OCP^O, by photoconversion, the detailed mechanism of photoprotection remains unclear. Here we demonstrate that our recently described W288A mutant of the Synechocystis OCP (hereinafter called OCP^W288A) is a fully functional analogue of the OCP^R form which is capable of constitutive PBs fluorescence quenching in vitro with no need of photoactivation. This PBs quenching effect is abolished in the presence of FRP, which interacts with OCP^W288A with micromolar affinity and an apparent stoichiometry of 1:1, unexpectedly, implying dissociation of the FRP dimers. This establishes OCP^W288A as a robust model system providing novel insights into the interplay between OCP and FRP to regulate photoprotection in cyanobacteria.