Mechanisms and cellular functions of intramembrane proteases

Structure and function of SPP/SPPL proteases: insights from biochemical evidence and predictive modeling

More than 20 years ago, signal peptide peptidase (SPP) and its homologues, the signal peptide peptidase-like (SPPL) proteases have been identified based on their sequence similarity to presenilins, a related family of intramembrane aspartyl proteases. Other than those for the presenilins, no high-resolution structures for the SPP/SPPL proteases are available. Despite this limitation, over the years bioinformatical and biochemical data have accumulated, which altogether have provided a picture of the overall structure and topology of these proteases, their localization in the cell, the process of substrate recognition, their cleavage mechanism, and their function. Recently, the artificial intelligence-based structure prediction tool AlphaFold has added high-confidence models of the expected fold of SPP/SPPL proteases. In this review, we summarize known structural aspects of the SPP/SPPL family as well as their substrates. Of particular interest are the emerging substrate recognition and catalytic mechanisms that might lead to the prediction and identification of more potential substrates and deeper insight into physiological and pathophysiological roles of proteolysis.

Inhibitory proteins block substrate access by occupying the active site cleft of Bacillus subtilis intramembrane protease SpoIVFB

Intramembrane proteases (IPs) function in numerous signaling pathways that impact health, but elucidating the regulation of membrane-embedded proteases is challenging. We examined inhibition of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB by proteins BofA and SpoIVFA. We found that SpoIVFB inhibition requires BofA residues in and near a predicted transmembrane segment (TMS). This segment of BofA occupies the SpoIVFB active site cleft based on cross-linking experiments. SpoIVFB inhibition also requires SpoIVFA. The inhibitory proteins block access of the substrate N-terminal region to the membrane-embedded SpoIVFB active site, based on additional cross-linking experiments; however, the inhibitory proteins did not prevent interaction between the substrate C-terminal region and the SpoIVFB soluble domain. We built a structural model of SpoIVFB in complex with BofA and parts of SpoIVFA and substrate, using partial homology and constraints from cross-linking and co-evolutionary analyses. The model predicts that conserved BofA residues interact to stabilize a TMS and a membrane-embedded C-terminal region. The model also predicts that SpoIVFA bridges the BofA C-terminal region and SpoIVFB, forming a membrane-embedded inhibition complex. Our results reveal a novel mechanism of IP inhibition with clear implications for relief from inhibition in vivo and design of inhibitors as potential therapeutics.

Conserved Proline Residues of Bacillus subtilis Intramembrane Metalloprotease SpoIVFB Are Important for Substrate Interaction and Cleavage

Intramembrane metalloproteases regulate diverse biological processes by cleaving membrane-associated substrates within the membrane or near its surface. SpoIVFB is an intramembrane metalloprotease of Bacillus subtilis that cleaves Pro-σ^K during endosporulation. Intramembrane metalloproteases have a broadly conserved NPDG motif, which in the structure of an archaeal enzyme is located in a short loop that interrupts a transmembrane segment facing the active site. The aspartate residue of the NPDG motif acts as a ligand of the zinc ion involved in catalysis. The functions of other residues in the short loop are less well understood. We found that the predicted short loop of SpoIVFB contains two highly conserved proline residues, P132 of the NPDG motif and P135. Mutational analysis revealed that both proline residues are important for Pro-σ^K cleavage in Escherichia coli engineered to synthesize the proteins. Substitutions for either residue also impaired Pro-σ^K interaction with SpoIVFB in co-purification assays. Disulfide cross-linking experiments showed that the predicted short loop of SpoIVFB is in proximity to the Proregion of Pro-σ^K. Alanine substitutions for N129 and P132 of the SpoIVFB NPDG motif reduced cross-linking between its predicted short loop and the Proregion more than a P135A substitution. Conversely, the SpoIVFB P135A substitution reduced Pro-σ^K cleavage more than the N129A and P132A substitutions during sporulation of B. subtilis. We conclude that all three conserved residues of SpoIVFB are important for substrate interaction and cleavage, and we propose that P135 is necessary to position D137 to act as a zinc ligand. IMPORTANCE Intramembrane metalloproteases (IMMPs) function in numerous signaling pathways. Bacterial IMMPs govern stress responses, including sporulation of some species, thus enhancing the virulence and persistence of pathogens. Knowledge of IMMP-substrate interactions could aid therapeutic design, but structures of IMMP·substrate complexes are unknown. We examined interaction of the IMMP SpoIVFB with its substrate Pro-σ^K, whose cleavage is required for Bacillus subtilis endosporulation. We found that conserved proline residues in a short loop predicted to interrupt a SpoIVFB transmembrane segment are important for Pro-σ^K binding and cleavage. Corresponding residues of the Escherichia coli IMMP RseP have also been shown to be important for substrate interaction and cleavage, suggesting this is a broadly conserved feature of IMMPs, potentially suitable as a therapeutic target.

Phosphatidylglyerol Lipid Binding at the Active Site of an Intramembrane Protease

Transmembrane substrate cleavage by the small Escherichia coli rhomboid protease GlpG informs on mechanisms by which lipid interactions shape reaction coordinates of membrane-embedded enzymes. Here, I review and discuss new work on the molecular picture of protein-lipid interactions that might govern the formation of the substrate-enzyme complex in fluid lipid membranes. Negatively charged PG-type lipids are of particular interest, because they are a major component of bacterial membranes. Atomistic computer simulations indicate POPG and DOPG lipids bridge remote parts of GlpG and might pre-occupy the substrate-docking site. Inhibition of catalytic activity by PG lipids could arise from ligand-like lipid binding at the active site, which could delay or prevent substrate docking. Dynamic protein-lipid H-bond networks, water access to the active site, and fluctuations in the orientation of GlpG suggest that GlpG has lipid-coupled dynamics that could shape the energy landscape of transmembrane substrate docking.

Interaction of intramembrane metalloprotease SpoIVFB with substrate Pro-σK

Intramembrane proteases (IPs) cleave membrane-associated substrates in nearly all organisms and regulate diverse processes. A better understanding of how these enzymes interact with their substrates is necessary for rational design of IP modulators. We show that interaction of Bacillus subtilis IP SpoIVFB with its substrate Pro-σ^K depends on particular residues in the interdomain linker of SpoIVFB. The linker plus either the N-terminal membrane domain or the C-terminal cystathione-β-synthase (CBS) domain of SpoIVFB was sufficient for the interaction but not for cleavage of Pro-σ^K Chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry of purified, inactive SpoIVFB-Pro-σ^K complex indicated residues of the two proteins in proximity. A structural model of the complex was built via partial homology and by using constraints based on cross-linking data. In the model, the Proregion of Pro-σ^K loops into the membrane domain of SpoIVFB, and the rest of Pro-σ^K interacts extensively with the linker and the CBS domain of SpoIVFB. The extensive interaction is proposed to allow coordination between ATP binding by the CBS domain and Pro-σ^K cleavage by the membrane domain.

Bacillus subtilis Intramembrane Protease RasP Activity in Escherichia coli and In Vitro

RasP is a predicted intramembrane metalloprotease of Bacillus subtilis that has been proposed to cleave the stress response anti-sigma factors RsiW and RsiV, the cell division protein FtsL, and remnant signal peptides within their transmembrane segments. To provide evidence for direct effects of RasP on putative substrates, we developed a heterologous coexpression system. Since expression of catalytically inactive RasP E21A inhibited expression of other membrane proteins in Escherichia coli, we added extra transmembrane segments to RasP E21A, which allowed accumulation of most other membrane proteins. A corresponding active version of RasP appeared to promiscuously cleave coexpressed membrane proteins, except those with a large periplasmic domain. However, stable cleavage products were not observed, even in clpP mutant E. coli Fusions of transmembrane segment-containing parts of FtsL and RsiW to E. coli maltose-binding protein (MBP) also resulted in proteins that appeared to be RasP substrates upon coexpression in E. coli, including FtsL with a full-length C-terminal domain (suggesting that prior cleavage by a site 1 protease is unnecessary) and RsiW designed to mimic the PrsW site 1 cleavage product (suggesting that further trimming by extracytoplasmic protease is unnecessary). Purified RasP cleaved His₆-MBP-RsiW(73-118) in vitro within the RsiW transmembrane segment based on mass spectrometry analysis, demonstrating that RasP is an intramembrane protease. Surprisingly, purified RasP failed to cleave His₆-MBP-FtsL(23-117). We propose that the lack of α-helix-breaking residues in the FtsL transmembrane segment creates a requirement for the membrane environment and/or an additional protein(s) in order for RasP to cleave FtsL.IMPORTANCE Intramembrane proteases govern important signaling pathways in nearly all organisms. In bacteria, they function in stress responses, cell division, pathogenesis, and other processes. Their membrane-associated substrates are typically inferred from genetic studies in the native bacterium. Evidence for direct effects has come sometimes from coexpression of the enzyme and potential substrate in a heterologous host and rarely from biochemical reconstitution of cleavage in vitro We applied these two approaches to the B. subtilis enzyme RasP and its proposed substrates RsiW and FtsL. We discovered potential pitfalls and solutions in heterologous coexpression experiments in E. coli, providing evidence that both substrates are cleaved by RasP in vivo but, surprisingly, that only RsiW was cleaved in vitro, suggesting that FtsL has an additional requirement.

Enzymatic Assays for Studying Intramembrane Proteolysis

Proteolysis within the membrane is catalyzed by a diverse family of proteases immersed within the hydrophobic environment of cellular membranes. These ubiquitous intramembrane-cleaving proteases (I-CLiPs) hydrolyze the transmembrane domains of a large variety of membrane-embedded proteins to facilitate signaling events essential to normal biological functions found in all forms of life. The importance of this unique class of enzyme is highlighted by its central involvement in a variety of human pathologies, including Alzheimer's disease (AD), Parkinson's disease, cancer, and the virulence of a number of viral, bacterial, and fungal pathogens. I-CLiPs therefore represent promising targets for the therapeutic treatment of numerous diseases. The key to understanding the normal biological function of I-CLiPs and capitalizing on their therapeutic potential is through a thorough understanding of the complex catalytic mechanisms that govern this unusual class of enzyme. This is an intrinsically difficult endeavor, given that these enzymes and their substrates reside within lipid membranes, making any in vitro assay technically challenging to design and execute. Here, we describe several in vitro enzymatic assays for the study of the AD-associated γ-secretase protease, which have aided the development of potent γ-secretase-targeting compounds as candidate therapeutics. These assays have also been applied in various forms for the study of other I-CLiPs, providing valuable mechanistic insights into some of the functional similarities and differences between several members of this fascinating family of proteases.

Biochemical Characterization of Function and Structure of RseP, an Escherichia coli S2P Protease

Intramembrane-cleaving proteases (I-CLiPs) are a group of membrane-associated proteases with a unique feature: they are believed to cleave their substrate within the hydrophobic lipid bilayer, even though peptide bond hydrolysis requires a water molecule. Escherichia coli RseP, which belongs to the S2P zinc metalloprotease family of I-CLiPs, plays an essential role in activation of a cell envelope stress response through cleavage of anti-σ^E protein RseA, a single-span transmembrane protein. A recent study showed that it also cleaves remnant signal peptides generated upon membrane translocation of secretory proteins. Here, we describe several methods for characterization of the proteolytic functions and structure of RseP mainly in vivo, including a proteolytic activity assay using model substrates, an in vitro analysis of cleavage of signal peptides in a detergent solution and in the membrane vesicles, structural analysis of membrane-embedded RseP based on the thiol modifiability of introduced cysteine residues, and the protein interaction analysis by in vivo cross-linking protocols.

Nicastrin functions to sterically hinder γ-secretase-substrate interactions driven by substrate transmembrane domain

γ-Secretase is an intramembrane-cleaving protease that processes many type-I integral membrane proteins within the lipid bilayer, an event preceded by shedding of most of the substrate's ectodomain by α- or β-secretases. The mechanism by which γ-secretase selectively recognizes and recruits ectodomain-shed substrates for catalysis remains unclear. In contrast to previous reports that substrate is actively recruited for catalysis when its remaining short ectodomain interacts with the nicastrin component of γ-secretase, we find that substrate ectodomain is entirely dispensable for cleavage. Instead, γ-secretase-substrate binding is driven by an apparent tight-binding interaction derived from substrate transmembrane domain, a mechanism in stark contrast to rhomboid--another family of intramembrane-cleaving proteases. Disruption of the nicastrin fold allows for more efficient cleavage of substrates retaining longer ectodomains, indicating that nicastrin actively excludes larger substrates through steric hindrance, thus serving as a molecular gatekeeper for substrate binding and catalysis.

Roles of the membrane-reentrant β-hairpin-like loop of RseP protease in selective substrate cleavage

Molecular mechanisms underlying substrate recognition and cleavage by Escherichia coli RseP, which belongs to S2P family of intramembrane-cleaving proteases, remain unclear. We examined the function of a conserved region looped into the membrane domain of RseP to form a β-hairpin-like structure near its active site in substrate recognition and cleavage. We observed that mutations disturbing the possible β-strand conformation of the loop impaired RseP proteolytic activity and that some of these mutations resulted in the differential cleavage of different substrates. Co-immunoprecipitation and crosslinking experiments suggest that the loop directly interacts with the transmembrane segments of substrates. Helix-destabilising mutations in the transmembrane segments of substrates suppressed the effect of loop mutations in an allele-specific manner. These results suggest that the loop promotes substrate cleavage by selectively recognising the transmembrane segments of substrates in an extended conformation and by presenting them to the proteolytic active site, which contributes to substrate discrimination.

A century of cholesterol and coronaries: from plaques to genes to statins

One-fourth of all deaths in industrialized countries result from coronary heart disease. A century of research has revealed the essential causative agent: cholesterol-carrying low-density lipoprotein (LDL). LDL is controlled by specific receptors (LDLRs) in liver that remove it from blood. Mutations that eliminate LDLRs raise LDL and cause heart attacks in childhood, whereas mutations that raise LDLRs reduce LDL and diminish heart attacks. If we are to eliminate coronary disease, lowering LDL should be the primary goal. Effective means to achieve this goal are currently available. The key questions are: who to treat, when to treat, and how long to treat.

Protein maturation and proteolysis in plant plastids, mitochondria, and peroxisomes

Plastids, mitochondria, and peroxisomes are key organelles with dynamic proteomes in photosynthetic eukaryotes. Their biogenesis and activity must be coordinated and require intraorganellar protein maturation, degradation, and recycling. The three organelles together are predicted to contain ∼200 presequence peptidases, proteases, aminopeptidases, and specific protease chaperones/adaptors, but the substrates and substrate selection mechanisms are poorly understood. Similarly, lifetime determinants of organellar proteins, such as N-end degrons and tagging systems, have not been identified, but the substrate recognition mechanisms likely share similarities between organelles. Novel degradomics tools for systematic analysis of protein lifetime and proteolysis could define such protease-substrate relationships, degrons, and protein lifetime. Intraorganellar proteolysis is complemented by autophagy of whole organelles or selected organellar content, as well as by cytosolic protein ubiquitination and degradation by the proteasome. This review summarizes (putative) plant organellar protease functions and substrate-protease relationships. Examples illustrate key proteolytic events.

Plastid intramembrane proteolysis

Progress in the field of regulated intramembrane proteolysis (RIP) in recent years has not surpassed plant biology. Nevertheless, reports on RIP in plants, and especially in chloroplasts, are still scarce. Of the four different families of intramembrane proteases, only two have been linked to chloroplasts so far, rhomboids and site-2 proteases (S2Ps). The lack of chloroplast-located rhomboid proteases was associated with reduced fertility and aberrations in flower morphology, probably due to perturbations in jasmonic acid biosynthesis, which occurs in chloroplasts. Mutations in homologues of S2P resulted in chlorophyll deficiency and impaired chloroplast development, through a yet unknown mechanism. To date, the only known substrate of RIP in chloroplasts is a PHD transcription factor, located in the envelope. Upon proteolytic cleavage by an unknown protease, the soluble N-terminal domain of this protein is released from the membrane and relocates to the nucleus, where it activates the transcription of the ABA response gene ABI4. Continuing studies on these proteases and substrates, as well as identification of the genes responsible for different chloroplast mutant phenotypes, are expected to shed more light on the roles of intramembrane proteases in chloroplast biology.

A subset of membrane-altering agents and γ-secretase modulators provoke nonsubstrate cleavage by rhomboid proteases

Rhomboid proteases are integral membrane enzymes that regulate cell signaling, adhesion, and organelle homeostasis pathways, making substrate specificity a key feature of their function. Interestingly, we found that perturbing the membrane pharmacologically in living cells had little effect on substrate processing but induced inappropriate cleavage of nonsubstrates by rhomboid proteases. A subclass of drugs known to modulate γ-secretase activity acted on the membrane directly and induced nonsubstrate cleavage by rhomboid proteases but left true substrate cleavage sites unaltered. These observations highlight an active role for the membrane in guiding rhomboid selectivity and caution that membrane-targeted drugs should be evaluated for cross-activity against membrane-resident enzymes that are otherwise unrelated to the intended drug target. Furthermore, some γ-secretase-modulating activity or toxicity could partly result from global membrane effects.