Analyzing and enhancing mRNA translational efficiency in an Escherichia coli in vitro expression system

Generation of ribosomal protein S1 mutants for improving of expression of difficult to translate mRNAs

Metagenomes present a source for novel enzymes, but under 1% of environmental microbes are cultivatable. Because of its useful properties, Escherichia coli has been used as a host organism in functional genomic screens. However, due to differing expression machineries in the expression host compared to the source organism of the DNA sequences, screening outcomes can be biased. Here, we focused on one of the limiting processes-translation initiation. To that end, we created an operon-like screening system in E. coli to select mutants of the ribosomal protein S1 with more relaxed sequence requirements for 5'-untranslated regions of mRNAs. We created two mutation libraries of the ribosomal protein S1, one covering domains 3 and 4 (D3-D4) and the second covering domains 3 to 5 (D3-D5). Most mutants from library D3-D4 proofed to be specific for a particular UTR sequence and improved only expression from a single construct. Only mutant 3 from library D3-D4 led to increased expression of four different reporters improving fluorescence levels by up to 21%. Mutants isolated from D3-D5 library led up to 90% higher expression compared to the control, though the mutants with highest improvements exhibited a specialist phenotype. The most promising mutant, mutant 4, exhibited a generalist phenotype and showed increased expression in all six reporter strains compared to the control. This could indicate the potential for a more promiscuous translation initiation of metagenomic sequences in E. coli although at the price of smaller increases compared to specialist mutants. KEY POINTS: • An operon-like selection system allowed to isolate generalist and specialist S1 mutants. • S1 mutants improved translation of mRNAs with 5'-UTRs from metagenomic sequences. • Use of S1 mutants could increase coverage from metagenomic libraries in functional screens.

Modifications of the 5' region of the CASPONTM tag's mRNA further enhance soluble recombinant protein production in Escherichia coli

BACKGROUND

Escherichia coli is one of the most commonly used host organisms for the production of biopharmaceuticals, as it allows for cost-efficient and fast recombinant protein expression. However, challenging proteins are often produced with low titres or as inclusion bodies, and the manufacturing process needs to be developed individually for each protein. Recently, we developed the CASPONTM technology, a generic fusion tag-based platform process for high-titer soluble expression including a standardized downstream processing and highly specific enzymatic cleavage of the fusion tag. To assess potential strategies for further improvement of the N-terminally fused CASPONTM tag, we modified the 5'UTR and 5' region of the tag-coding mRNA to optimize the ribosome-mRNA interactions.

RESULTS

In the present work, we found that by modifying the 5'UTR sequence of a pET30acer plasmid-based system, expression of the fusion protein CASPONTM-tumour necrosis factor α was altered in laboratory-scale carbon-limited fed-batch cultivations, but no significant increase in expression titre was achieved. Translation efficiency was highest for a construct carrying an expression enhancer element and additionally possessing a very favourable interaction energy between ribosome and mRNA (∆Gtotal). However, a construct with comparatively low transcriptional efficiency, which lacked the expression enhancer sequence and carried the most favourable ∆Gtotal tested, led to the highest recombinant protein formation alongside the reference pET30a construct. Furthermore, we found, that by introducing synonymous mutations within the nucleotide sequence of the T7AC element of the CASPONTM tag, utilizing a combination of rare and non-rare codons, the free folding energy of the nucleotides at the 5' end (-4 to + 37) of the transcript encoding the CASPONTM tag increased by 6 kcal/mol. Surprisingly, this new T7ACrare variant led to improved recombinant protein titres by 1.3-fold up to 5.3-fold, shown with three industry-relevant proteins in lab-scale carbon limited fed-batch fermentations under industrially relevant conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

This study reveals some of the complex interdependencies between the ribosome and mRNA that govern recombinant protein expression. By modifying the 5'UTR to obtain an optimized interaction energy between the mRNA and the ribosome (ΔGtotal), transcript levels were changed, highlighting the different translation efficiencies of individual transcripts. It was shown that the highest recombinant titre was not obtained by the construct with the most efficient translation but by a construct with a generally high transcript amount coupled with a favourable ΔGtotal. Furthermore, an unexpectedly high potential to enhance expression by introducing silent mutations including multiple rare codons into the 5'end of the CAPONTM tag's mRNA was identified. Although the titres of the fusion proteins were dramatically increased, no formation of inclusion bodies or negative impact on cell growth was observed. We hypothesize that the drastic increase in titre is most likely caused by better ribosomal binding site accessibility. Our study, which demonstrates the influence of changes in ribosome-mRNA interactions on protein expression under industrially relevant production conditions, opens the door to the applicability of the new T7ACrare tag in biopharmaceutical industry using the CASPONTM platform process.

Synthetic biology approach revealed enhancement in haeme oxygenase-1 gene expression by codon pair optimization while reduction by codon deoptimization

Haem oxygenase-1 (HO-1) is a ubiquitously expressed gene involved in cellular homoeostasis, and its imbalance in expression results in various disorders. To alleviate such disorders, HO-1 gene expression needs to be modulated. Codon usage bias results from evolutionary forces acting on any nucleotide sequence and determines the gene expression. Like codon usage bias, codon pair bias also exists, playing a role in gene expression. In the present study, HO-1 gene was recoded by manipulating codon and codon pair bias, and four such constructs were made through codon/codon pair deoptimization and codon/codon pair optimization to reduce and enhance the HO-1 gene expression. Codon usage analysis was done for these constructs for four tissues brain, heart, pancreas and liver. Based on codon usage in different tissues, gene expression of these tissues was determined in terms of the codon adaptation index. Based on the codon adaptation index, minimum free energy, and translation efficiency, constructs were evaluated for enhanced or decreased HO-1 expression. The analysis revealed that for enhancing gene expression, codon pair optimization, while for reducing gene expression, codon deoptimization is efficacious. The recoded constructs developed in the study could be used in gene therapy regimens to cure HO-1 over or underexpression-associated disorders.

Rapid Antibacterial Activity Assessment of Chimeric Lysins

Various chimeric lysins have been developed as efficacious antibiotics against multidrug-resistant bacteria, but direct comparisons of their antibacterial activities have been difficult due to the preparation of multiple recombinant chimeric lysins. Previously, we reported an Escherichia coli cell-free expression method to better screen chimeric lysins against Staphylococcus aureus, but we still needed to increase the amounts of expressed proteins enough to be able to detect them non-isotopically for quantity comparisons. In this study, we improved the previous cell-free expression system by adding a previously reported artificial T7 terminator and reversing the different nucleotides between the T7 promoter and start codon to those of the T7 phage. The new method increased the expressed amount of chimeric lysins enough for us to detect them using Western blotting. Therefore, the qualitative comparison of activity between different chimeric lysins has become possible via the adjustment of the number of variables between samples without protein purification. We applied this method to select more active chimeric lysins derived from our previously reported chimeric lysin (ALS2). Finally, we compared the antibacterial activities of our selected chimeric lysins with reported chimeric lysins (ClyC and ClyO) and lysostaphin and determined the rank orders of antibacterial activities on different Staphylococcus aureus strains in our experimental conditions.

Large-scale analysis of mRNA sequences localized near the start and amber codons and their impact on the diversity of mRNA display libraries

Extremely diverse libraries are essential for effectively selecting functional peptides or proteins, and mRNA display technology is a powerful tool for generating such libraries with over 1012-1013 diversity. Particularly, the protein-puromycin linker (PuL)/mRNA complex formation yield is determining for preparing the libraries. However, how mRNA sequences affect the complex formation yield remains unclear. To study the effects of N-terminal and C-terminal coding sequences on the complex formation yield, puromycin-attached mRNAs containing three random codons after the start codon (32768 sequences) or seven random bases next to the amber codon (6480 sequences) were translated. Enrichment scores were calculated by dividing the appearance rate of every sequence in protein-PuL/mRNA complexes by that in total mRNAs. The wide range of enrichment scores (0.09-2.10 for N-terminal and 0.30-4.23 for C-terminal coding sequences) indicated that the N-terminal and C-terminal coding sequences strongly affected the complex formation yield. Using C-terminal GGC-CGA-UAG-U sequences, which resulted in the highest enrichment scores, we constructed highly diverse libraries of monobodies and macrocyclic peptides. The present study provides insights into how mRNA sequences affect the protein/mRNA complex formation yield and will accelerate the identification of functional peptides and proteins involved in various biological processes and having therapeutic applications.

Ultradeep characterisation of translational sequence determinants refutes rare-codon hypothesis and unveils quadruplet base pairing of initiator tRNA and transcript

Translation is a key determinant of gene expression and an important biotechnological engineering target. In bacteria, 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR) and coding sequence (CDS) are well-known mRNA parts controlling translation and thus cellular protein levels. However, the complex interaction of 5'-UTR and CDS has so far only been studied for few sequences leading to non-generalisable and partly contradictory conclusions. Herein, we systematically assess the dynamic translation from over 1.2 million 5'-UTR-CDS pairs in Escherichia coli to investigate their collective effect using a new method for ultradeep sequence-function mapping. This allows us to disentangle and precisely quantify effects of various sequence determinants of translation. We find that 5'-UTR and CDS individually account for 53% and 20% of variance in translation, respectively, and show conclusively that, contrary to a common hypothesis, tRNA abundance does not explain expression changes between CDSs with different synonymous codons. Moreover, the obtained large-scale data provide clear experimental evidence for a base-pairing interaction between initiator tRNA and mRNA beyond the anticodon-codon interaction, an effect that is often masked for individual sequences and therefore inaccessible to low-throughput approaches. Our study highlights the indispensability of ultradeep sequence-function mapping to accurately determine the contribution of parts and phenomena involved in gene regulation.

Translation initiation site of mRNA is selected through dynamic interaction with the ribosome

SignificanceRibosomes translate the genetic codes of messenger RNA (mRNA) to make proteins. Translation must begin at the correct initiation site; otherwise, abnormal proteins will be produced. Here, we show that a short ribosome-specific sequence in the upstream followed by an unstructured downstream sequence is a favorable initiation site. Those mRNAs lacking either of these two characteristics do not associate tightly with the ribosome. Initiator transfer RNA (tRNA) and initiation factors facilitate the binding. However, when the downstream site forms structures, initiation factor 3 triggers the dissociation of the accommodated initiator tRNA and the subsequent disassembly of the ribosome-mRNA complex. Thus, initiation factors help the ribosome distinguish unfavorable structured sequences that may not act as the mRNA translation initiation site.

Optimized Heterologous Expression and Efficient Purification of a New TRAIL-Based Antitumor Fusion Protein SRH-DR5-B with Dual VEGFR2 and DR5 Receptor Specificity

In the last two decades, bifunctional proteins have been created by genetic and protein engineering methods to increase therapeutic effects in various diseases, including cancer. Unlike conventional small molecule or monotargeted drugs, bifunctional proteins have increased biological activity while maintaining low systemic toxicity. The recombinant anti-cancer cytokine TRAIL has shown a limited therapeutic effect in clinical trials. To enhance the efficacy of TRAIL, we designed the HRH–DR5-B fusion protein based on the DR5-selective mutant variant of TRAIL fused to the anti-angiogenic synthetic peptide HRHTKQRHTALH. Initially low expression of HRH–DR5-B was enhanced by the substitution of E. coli-optimized codons with AT-rich codons in the DNA sequence encoding the first 7 amino acid residues of the HRH peptide. However, the HRH–DR5-B degraded during purification to form two adjacent protein bands on the SDS-PAGE gel. The replacement of His by Ser at position P2 immediately after the initiator Met dramatically minimized degradation, allowing more than 20 mg of protein to be obtained from 200 mL of cell culture. The resulting SRH–DR5-B fusion bound the VEGFR2 and DR5 receptors with high affinity and showed increased cytotoxic activity in 3D multicellular tumor spheroids. SRH–DR5-B can be considered as a promising candidate for therapeutic applications.

Importance of the 5' regulatory region to bacterial synthetic biology applications

The field of synthetic biology is evolving at a fast pace. It is advancing beyond single-gene alterations in single hosts to the logical design of complex circuits and the development of integrated synthetic genomes. Recent breakthroughs in deep learning, which is increasingly used in de novo assembly of DNA components with predictable effects, are also aiding the discipline. Despite advances in computing, the field is still reliant on the availability of pre-characterized DNA parts, whether natural or synthetic, to regulate gene expression in bacteria and make valuable compounds. In this review, we discuss the different bacterial synthetic biology methodologies employed in the creation of 5' regulatory regions - promoters, untranslated regions and 5'-end of coding sequences. We summarize methodologies and discuss their significance for each of the functional DNA components, and highlight the key advances made in bacterial engineering by concentrating on their flaws and strengths. We end the review by outlining the issues that the discipline may face in the near future.

Analysis of 11,430 recombinant protein production experiments reveals that protein yield is tunable by synonymous codon changes of translation initiation sites

Recombinant protein production is a key process in generating proteins of interest in the pharmaceutical industry and biomedical research. However, about 50% of recombinant proteins fail to be expressed in a variety of host cells. Here we show that the accessibility of translation initiation sites modelled using the mRNA base-unpairing across the Boltzmann's ensemble significantly outperforms alternative features. This approach accurately predicts the successes or failures of expression experiments, which utilised Escherichia coli cells to express 11,430 recombinant proteins from over 189 diverse species. On this basis, we develop TIsigner that uses simulated annealing to modify up to the first nine codons of mRNAs with synonymous substitutions. We show that accessibility captures the key propensity beyond the target region (initiation sites in this case), as a modest number of synonymous changes is sufficient to tune the recombinant protein expression levels. We build a stochastic simulation model and show that higher accessibility leads to higher protein production and slower cell growth, supporting the idea of protein cost, where cell growth is constrained by protein circuits during overexpression.

Cell-free protein synthesis of CRISPR ribonucleoproteins (RNP)

Cell-free protein synthesis is a powerful tool to produce recombinant proteins, and as an open system, can often integrate all or part of downstream assays. Here we describe in vitro synthesis of the Streptococcus pyogenes type II-A CRISPR-Cas9 ribonucleoproteins (SpCas9 RNPs), consisting of the effector protein and the single guide RNAs (sgRNAs). In spite of its large molecular weight (160kDa), the SpCas9 effector is expressed relatively well from linear DNA templates under T7 promoter in commercial reconstituted cell-free protein synthesis systems. sgRNAs can be added before the effector synthesis reaction, or transcribed directly from linear DNA templates during the synthesis reaction. The newly synthesized SpCas9 effector forms an active RNP complex with sgRNAs. When a reconstituted cell-free system is used, the target DNA templates can also be added in the reactions, thereby combining CRISPR-Cas synthesis and activity assay.

A short translational ramp determines the efficiency of protein synthesis

Translation initiation is a major rate-limiting step for protein synthesis. However, recent studies strongly suggest that the efficiency of protein synthesis is additionally regulated by multiple factors that impact the elongation phase. To assess the influence of early elongation on protein synthesis, we employed a library of more than 250,000 reporters combined with in vitro and in vivo protein expression assays. Here we report that the identity of the amino acids encoded by codons 3 to 5 impact protein yield. This effect is independent of tRNA abundance, translation initiation efficiency, or overall mRNA structure. Single-molecule measurements of translation kinetics revealed pausing of the ribosome and aborted protein synthesis on codons 4 and 5 of distinct amino acid and nucleotide compositions. Finally, introduction of preferred sequence motifs only at specific codon positions improves protein synthesis efficiency for recombinant proteins. Collectively, our data underscore the critical role of early elongation events in translational control of gene expression.

Several factors contribute to the efficiency of protein expression. Here the authors show that the identity of amino acids encoded by codons at position 3–5 significantly impact translation efficiency and protein expression levels.

Unstructured 5'-tails act through ribosome standby to override inhibitory structure at ribosome binding sites

Initiation is the rate-limiting step in translation. It is well-known that stable structure at a ribosome binding site (RBS) impedes initiation. The ribosome standby model of de Smit and van Duin, based on studies of the MS2 phage coat cistron, proposed how high translation rates can be reconciled with stable, inhibitory structures at an RBS. Here, we revisited the coat protein system and assessed the translation efficiency from its sequestered RBS by introducing standby mutations. Further experiments with gfp reporter constructs assessed the effects of 5′-tails—as standby sites—with respect to length and sequence contributions. In particular, combining in vivo and in vitro assays, we can show that tails of CA-dinucleotide repeats—and to a lesser extent, AU-repeats—dramatically increase translation rates. Tails of increasing length reach maximal rate-enhancing effects at 16–18 nucleotides. These standby tails are single-stranded and do not exert their effect by structure changes in the neighboring RBS stem–loop. In vitro translation and toeprinting assays furthermore demonstrate that standby effects are exerted at the level of translation initiation. Finally, as expected, destabilizing mutations within the coat RBS indicate an interplay with the effects of standby tails.

The ribosomal protein S1-dependent standby site in tisB mRNA consists of a single-stranded region and a 5' structure element

Ribosome standby is a mechanism that allows translation initiation at ribosome-binding sites that display stable, inhibitory structures. It involves initiator-tRNA-independent 30S subunit binding to single-stranded RNA regions, and the subsequent relocation to the sequestered ribosome-binding sites (RBS). Direct evidence for 30S preloading had previously been elusive. We report here on a detailed characterization of the standby site in tisB mRNA. 30S subunits bind to a single-stranded region and a 5′-stem-loop structure, as shown by fluorescence anisotropy experiments and footprint mapping by cross-linking–immunoprecipitation experiments. Ribosomal protein S1, on its own and in the context of the 30S ribosome, binds to the standby site. This is required for standby-dependent translation, likely reflecting S1-dependent directional unfolding over more than ≈100 nt to reach the sequestered RBS.

In bacteria, stable RNA structures that sequester ribosome-binding sites (RBS) impair translation initiation, and thus protein output. In some cases, ribosome standby can overcome inhibition by structure: 30S subunits bind sequence-nonspecifically to a single-stranded region and, on breathing of the inhibitory structure, relocate to the RBS for initiation. Standby can occur over long distances, as in the active, +42 tisB mRNA, encoding a toxin. This mRNA is translationally silenced by an antitoxin sRNA, IstR-1, that base pairs to the standby site. In tisB and other cases, a direct interaction between 30S subunits and a standby site has remained elusive. Based on fluorescence anisotropy experiments, ribosome toeprinting results, in vitro translation assays, and cross-linking–immunoprecipitation (CLIP) in vitro, carried out on standby-proficient and standby-deficient tisB mRNAs, we provide a thorough characterization of the tisB standby site. 30S subunits and ribosomal protein S1 alone display high-affinity binding to standby-competent fluorescein-labeled +42 mRNA, but not to mRNAs that lack functional standby sites. Ribosomal protein S1 is essential for standby, as 30∆S1 subunits do not support standby-dependent toeprints and TisB translation in vitro. S1 alone- and 30S-CLIP followed by RNA-seq mapping shows that the functional tisB standby site consists of the expected single-stranded region, but surprisingly, also a 5′-end stem-loop structure. Removal of the latter by 5′-truncations, or disruption of the stem, abolishes 30S binding and standby activity. Based on the CLIP-read mapping, the long-distance standby effect in +42 tisB mRNA (∼100 nt) is tentatively explained by S1-dependent directional unfolding toward the downstream RBS.

Accessibility of the Shine-Dalgarno Sequence Dictates N-Terminal Codon Bias in E. coli

Despite considerable efforts, no physical mechanism has been shown to explain N-terminal codon bias in prokaryotic genomes. Using a systematic study of synonymous substitutions in two endogenous E. coli genes, we show that interactions between the coding region and the upstream Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence modulate the efficiency of translation initiation, affecting both intracellular mRNA and protein levels due to the inherent coupling of transcription and translation in E. coli. We further demonstrate that far-downstream mutations can also modulate mRNA levels by occluding the SD sequence through the formation of non-equilibrium secondary structures. By contrast, a non-endogenous RNA polymerase that decouples transcription and translation largely alleviates the effects of synonymous substitutions on mRNA levels. Finally, a complementary statistical analysis of the E. coli genome specifically implicates avoidance of intra-molecular base pairing with the SD sequence. Our results provide general physical insights into the coding-level features that optimize protein expression in prokaryotes.

Cooperation between the chloroplast psbA 5'-untranslated region and coding region is important for translational initiation: the chloroplast translation machinery cannot read a human viral gene coding region

Chloroplast mRNA translation is regulated by the 5'-untranslated region (5'-UTR). Chloroplast 5'-UTRs also support translation of the coding regions of heterologous genes. Using an in vitro translation system from tobacco chloroplasts, we detected no translation from a human immunodeficiency virus tat coding region fused directly to the tobacco chloroplast psbA 5'-UTR. This lack of apparent translation could have been due to rapid degradation of mRNA templates or synthesized protein products. Replacing the psbA 5'-UTR with the E. coli phage T7 gene 10 5'-UTR, a highly active 5'-UTR, and substituting synonymous codons led to some translation of the tat coding region. The Tat protein thus synthesized was stable during translation reactions. No significant degradation of the added tat mRNAs was observed after translation reactions. These results excluded the above two possibilities and confirmed that the tat coding region prevented its own translation. The tat coding region was then fused to the psbA 5'-UTR with a cognate 5'-coding segment. Significant translation was detected from the tat coding region when fused after 10 or more codons. That is, translation could be initiated from the tat coding region once translation had started, indicating that the tat coding region inhibits translational initiation but not elongation. Hence, cooperation/compatibility between the 5'-UTR and its coding region is important for translational initiation.

Design criteria for synthetic riboswitches acting on transcription

Riboswitches are RNA-based regulators of gene expression composed of a ligand-sensing aptamer domain followed by an overlapping expression platform. The regulation occurs at either the level of transcription (by formation of terminator or antiterminator structures) or translation (by presentation or sequestering of the ribosomal binding site). Due to a modular composition, these elements can be manipulated by combining different aptamers and expression platforms and therefore represent useful tools to regulate gene expression in synthetic biology. Using computationally designed theophylline-dependent riboswitches we show that 2 parameters, terminator hairpin stability and folding traps, have a major impact on the functionality of the designed constructs. These have to be considered very carefully during design phase. Furthermore, a combination of several copies of individual riboswitches leads to a much improved activation ratio between induced and uninduced gene activity and to a linear dose-dependent increase in reporter gene expression. Such serial arrangements of synthetic riboswitches closely resemble their natural counterparts and may form the basis for simple quantitative read out systems for the detection of specific target molecules in the cell.

Membrane protein production in Escherichia coli cell-free lysates

Cell-free protein production has become a core technology in the rapidly spreading field of synthetic biology. In particular the synthesis of membrane proteins, highly problematic proteins in conventional cellular production systems, is an ideal application for cell-free expression. A large variety of artificial as well as natural environments for the optimal co-translational folding and stabilization of membrane proteins can rationally be designed. The high success rate of cell-free membrane protein production allows to focus on individually selected targets and to modulate their functional and structural properties with appropriate supplements. The efficiency and robustness of lysates from Escherichia coli strains allow a wide diversity of applications and we summarize current strategies for the successful production of high quality membrane protein samples.

Overcoming the solubility problem in E. coli: available approaches for recombinant protein production

Despite the importance of recombinant protein production in academy and industrial fields, many issues concerning the expression of soluble and homogeneous product are still unsolved. Although several strategies were developed to overcome these obstacles, at present there is no magic bullet that can be applied for all cases. Indeed, several key expression parameters need to be evaluated for each protein. Among the different hosts for protein expression, Escherichia coli is by far the most widely used. In this chapter, we review many of the different tools employed to circumvent protein insolubility problems.

High-level expression of LMW-GS and α-gliadin genes promoted by the expressed tag sequence of 5' end in Escherichia coli

Wheat storage protein genes, especially low molecular weight glutenin subunit (LMW-GS) and gliadin genes are difficult to be expressed in Escherichiacoli, mainly due to the presence of highly repetitive sequences. In order to establish a high efficiency expression system for these genes, five different expression plasmids combining with 9 genes, viz. 6 LMW-GS and 3 α-gliadin genes isolated from common wheat and related species, were studied for heterologous expression in E. coli. In this study, when an expressed tag sequence encoding signal peptide, His-S or GST-tag was fused to the 5' end of LMW-GS or gliadin gene as the leading sequence, all recombination genes could be stably expressed at a high level. On the contrast, as expected, the inserted genes encoding mature protein failed without an expressed tag sequence. This result indicated that using expressed tag sequences as leading sequences could promote LMW-GS and gliadin genes to be well expressed in E. coli. Further transcriptional analysis by quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR) showed transcription levels of recombination genes (e.g. GST-Glutenin, His-S-Glutenin and SP(∗)-His-Glutenin) were 4-fold to 33-fold higher than those of the LMW-GS genes, which suggested these expressed tag sequences might play an important role in stimulating transcription. The possible molecular mechanism under this phenomenon was discussed.

Protein synthesis using a reconstituted cell-free system

Most cell-free protein-synthesis systems are based on cell extracts, which often contain undesirable activities. Reconstituted systems, by contrast, are composed of a defined number of purified and recombinant components with minimal nuclease and protease activities. This unit describes the use of a particular commercial reconstituted system, PURExpress. This system allows in vitro synthesis of proteins from mRNA and circular and linear DNA templates, as well as co-translational labeling of proteins. Unique to this system, all recombinant protein components of the system are His-tagged, allowing purification of the synthesized untagged protein by removing the rest of the system's components. Newly synthesized proteins can often be visible on an SDS-PAGE gel and directly assayed for their functions without labeling and purification. Certain components of the system, such as ribosomes or release factors, can be omitted for specific applications. Such "delta" versions of the system are well suited for studies of bacterial translation, assays of ribosome function, incorporation of unnatural amino acids, and ribosome display of protein libraries.

Enhanced functional expression of aquaporin Z via fusion of in situ cleavable leader peptides in Escherichia coli cell-free system

Aquaporin Z (AqpZ) is a water channel protein from Escherichia coli and has attracted many attentions to develop the biomimetic water filtration technology. Cell-free protein synthesis (CFPS) system, one of the most complex multi-enzymatic systems, has the ability of producing the integral membrane protein in vitro. To enhance the synthesis of AqpZ in E. coli cell-free system, several natural leader peptides were respectively fused at the N-terminus and were verified to enhance the expression level significantly. Moreover, the supplementation of detergents or liposome could activate leader peptidase from the cell-free extract and provide hydrophobic environment for proper folding of AqpZ. Thus, the release of mature AqpZ via the in situ removal of leader peptide was achieved, with a specific water transport activity of (2.1 ± 0.1) × 10⁻¹⁴ cm³ s⁻¹ monomer⁻¹. Using this in situ removable leader peptide strategy, the transcription-translation, leader sequence cleavage and membrane protein folding were integrated into a simple process in the cell-free system, providing a convenient approach to enhance the expression of target proteins, especially those membrane proteins difficult to achieve.

Causes and effects of N-terminal codon bias in bacterial genes

Most amino acids are encoded by multiple codons, and codon choice has strong effects on protein expression. Rare codons are enriched at the N terminus of genes in most organisms, although the causes and effects of this bias are unclear. Here, we measure expression from >14,000 synthetic reporters in Escherichia coli and show that using N-terminal rare codons instead of common ones increases expression by ~14-fold (median 4-fold). We quantify how individual N-terminal codons affect expression and show that these effects shape the sequence of natural genes. Finally, we demonstrate that reduced RNA structure and not codon rarity itself is responsible for expression increases. Our observations resolve controversies over the roles of N-terminal codon bias and suggest a straightforward method for optimizing heterologous gene expression in bacteria.

Transcriptional abundance is not the single force driving the evolution of bacterial proteins

Background

Despite rapid progress in understanding the mechanisms that shape the evolution of proteins, the relative importance of various factors remain to be elucidated. In this study, we have assessed the effects of 16 different biological features on the evolutionary rates (ERs) of protein-coding sequences in bacterial genomes.

Results

Our analysis of 18 bacterial species revealed new correlations between ERs and constraining factors. Previous studies have suggested that transcriptional abundance overwhelmingly constrains the evolution of yeast protein sequences. This transcriptional abundance leads to selection against misfolding or misinteractions. In this study we found that there was no single factor in determining the evolution of bacterial proteins. Not only transcriptional abundance (codon adaptation index and expression level), but also protein-protein associations (PPAs), essentiality (ESS), subcellular localization of cytoplasmic membrane (SLM), transmembrane helices (TMH) and hydropathicity score (HS) independently and significantly affected the ERs of bacterial proteins. In some species, PPA and ESS demonstrate higher correlations with ER than transcriptional abundance.

Conclusions

Different forces drive the evolution of protein sequences in yeast and bacteria. In bacteria, the constraints are involved in avoiding a build-up of toxic molecules caused by misfolding/misinteraction (transcriptional abundance), while retaining important functions (ESS, PPA) and maintaining the cell membrane (SLM, TMH and HS). Each of these independently contributes to the variation in protein evolution.

Fine-mapping the contact sites of the Escherichia coli cell division proteins FtsB and FtsL on the FtsQ protein

Escherichia coli cell division is effected by a large assembly of proteins called the divisome, of which a subcomplex consisting of three bitopic inner membrane proteins, FtsQ, FtsB, and FtsL, is an essential part. These three proteins, hypothesized to link cytoplasmic to periplasmic events during cell division, contain large periplasmic domains that are of major importance for function and complex formation. The essential nature of this subcomplex, its low abundance, and its multiple interactions with key divisome components in the relatively accessible periplasm make it an attractive target for the development of protein-protein interaction inhibitors. Although the crystal structure of the periplasmic domain of FtsQ has been solved, the structure of the FtsQBL complex is unknown, with only very crude indications of the interactions in this complex. In this study, we used in vivo site-specific photo cross-linking to probe the surface of the FtsQ periplasmic domain for its interaction interfaces with FtsB and FtsL. An interaction hot spot for FtsB was identified around residue Ser-250 in the C-terminal region of FtsQ and a membrane-proximal interaction region for both proteins around residue Lys-59. Sequence alignment revealed a consensus motif overlapping with the C-terminal interaction hot spot, underlining the importance of this region in FtsQ. The identification of contact sites in the FtsQBL complex will guide future development of interaction inhibitors that block cell division.

Kinetic control of translation initiation in bacteria

Translation initiation is a crucial step of protein synthesis which largely defines how the composition of the cellular transcriptome is converted to the proteome and controls the response and adaptation to environmental stimuli. The efficiency of translation of individual mRNAs, and hence the basal shape of the proteome, is defined by the structures of the mRNA translation initiation regions. Initiation efficiency can be regulated by small molecules, proteins, or antisense RNAs, underscoring its importance in translational control. Although initiation has been studied in bacteria for decades, many aspects remain poorly understood. Recent evidence has suggested an unexpected diversity of pathways by which mRNAs can be recruited to the bacterial ribosome, the importance of structural dynamics of initiation intermediates, and the complexity of checkpoints for mRNA selection. In this review, we discuss how the ribosome shapes the landscape of translation initiation by non-linear kinetic processing of the transcriptome information. We summarize the major pathways by which mRNAs enter the ribosome depending on the structure of their 5' untranslated regions, the assembly and the structure of initiation intermediates, the individual and synergistic roles of initiation factors, and the mechanisms of mRNA and initiator tRNA selection.

The statistics of protein expression ratios for cellular fluorescence studies

Fluorescence studies of cellular protein-protein interactions commonly employ transient cotransfection to express two proteins carrying distinct fluorescent labels. Because transiently transfected cells differ significantly in their expression level, the concentration ratio of the two expressed proteins varies, which in turn influences the measured fluorescence signal. Knowledge of the statistics of protein expression ratios is of considerable interest both from a fundamental point of view and for cellular fluorescence studies. Despite the perceived randomness of transient transfection, we were able to develop a quantitative model that describes the average and distribution of the protein expression ratio from a cell population. We show that the expression ratio is proportional to the molar plasmid ratio and relate the distribution to the finite number of active plasmids in the cell. The process of cationic lipid-mediated transfection is explored in more detail. Specifically, the influence of lipoplexes on the statistics of the expression ratio is examined. We further demonstrate that the transfection model provides a quantitative description of fluorescence fluctuation experiments, where only a fraction of the proteins are labeled.

Expressivity tag: a novel tool for increased expression in Escherichia coli

Protein expression in Escherichia coli is rarely trivial as low expression and insolubility are common problems. In this work we define a fusion partner, which increases expression levels similarly to the distinct function of solubility and affinity tags. This type of fusion tag we term an expressivity tag. Our work is based on earlier observations where 3' deletions of the InfB gene displays strongly increased expression levels. We have constructed progressively shortened fragments of the InfB(1-471) gene and fused gene fragments to a gfp reporter gene. A 5-fold increase in GFP expression was seen for an optimal 21 nucleotide InfB(1-21) sequence compared to gfp independently. We defined the InfB(1-21) sequence as an expressivity tag. The tag was tested for improved expression of two biotechnological important proteins streptavidin and a single chain antibody (scFv). Expression of both streptavidin and scFv(L32) was improved as evaluated by SDS-PAGE. Calculation of folding energies in the translation initiation region gave higher free energies for gfp, L32 and streptavidin when linked to InfB(1-21) than independently. InfB(1-21) did however not improve the codon usage or codon adaptation index. The expressivity tag is an important addition to the box of tools available for optimizing heterologous protein expression.

Codon usage: nature's roadmap to expression and folding of proteins

Biomedical and biotechnological research relies on processes leading to the successful expression and production of key biological products. High-quality proteins are required for many purposes, including protein structural and functional studies. Protein expression is the culmination of multistep processes involving regulation at the level of transcription, mRNA turnover, protein translation, and post-translational modifications leading to the formation of a stable product. Although significant strides have been achieved over the past decade, advances toward integrating genomic and proteomic information are essential, and until such time, many target genes and their products may not be fully realized. Thus, the focus of this review is to provide some experimental support and a brief overview of how codon usage bias has evolved relative to regulating gene expression levels.

Enhanced expression and purification of fungal galactose oxidase in Escherichia coli and use for analysis of a saturation mutagenesis library

Galactose oxidase (GO) displays broad primary alcohol substrate specificity and so offers potential for engineering new substrate specificity by directed evolution. Producing variant libraries of sufficient complexity ideally requires expression of functional protein in a host such as Escherichia coli. Wild-type GO is produced by the fungus Fusarium graminiarum and is expressed poorly in E. coli. We introduced silent mutations within codons 2-7 of the mature GO coding sequence to enhance GO translation and have combined these with other expression-enhancing mutations. We selected the best E. coli host strain, autoinduction medium, induction temperature, harvest time and cell lysis procedure to produce active recombinant GO. Although normally secreted by the fungus, we have expressed GO in the cytoplasm of E. coli and have used a C-terminal Streptag II sequences for single-step affinity purification. This resulted in purification of 240 mg of functional GO per litre of shake flask culture. We have generated a saturation mutagenesis library at residue Cys383, known to influence substrate binding, and have used the optimised expression conditions to purify and characterise the resulting enzymes.

Synonymous but not the same: the causes and consequences of codon bias

Despite their name, synonymous mutations have significant consequences for cellular processes in all taxa. As a result, an understanding of codon bias is central to fields as diverse as molecular evolution and biotechnology. Although recent advances in sequencing and synthetic biology have helped to resolve longstanding questions about codon bias, they have also uncovered striking patterns that suggest new hypotheses about protein synthesis. Ongoing work to quantify the dynamics of initiation and elongation is as important for understanding natural synonymous variation as it is for designing transgenes in applied contexts.

Multifactorial determinants of protein expression in prokaryotic open reading frames

A quantitative description of the relationship between protein expression levels and open reading frame (ORF) nucleotide sequences is important for understanding natural systems, designing synthetic systems, and optimizing heterologous expression. Codon identity, mRNA secondary structure, and nucleotide composition within ORFs markedly influence expression levels. Bioinformatic analysis of ORF sequences in 816 bacterial genomes revealed that these features show distinct regional trends. To investigate their effects on protein expression, we designed 285 synthetic genes and determined corresponding expression levels in vitro using Escherichia coli extracts. We developed a mathematical function, parameterized using this synthetic gene data set, which enables computation of protein expression levels from ORF nucleotide sequences. In addition to its practical application in the design of heterologous expression systems, this equation provides mechanistic insight into the factors that control translation efficiency. We found that expression is strongly dependent on the presence of high AU content and low secondary structure in the ORF 5' region. Choice of high-frequency codons contributes to a lesser extent. The 3' terminal AU content makes modest, but detectable contributions. We present a model for the effect of these factors on the three phases of ribosomal function: initiation, elongation, and termination.

Reconstitution of the Cpx signaling system from cell-free synthesized proteins

Cell-free expression has received growing attention as an effective system to produce integral membrane proteins for biochemical studies. We have applied this technology for the production of the histidine kinase CpxA, an integral membrane sensor that regulates an envelope stress response in Escherichia coli. All phosphotransfer activities of detergent-solubilized CpxA synthesized in vitro have been characterized and compared with those of CpxA solubilized from bacterial membranes. The results demonstrate the simplicity and efficiency of this technology for purifying large quantities of functional membrane proteins.

A new window onto translational repression by bacterial sRNAs

In this issue of Molecular Cell, Bouvier et al. (2008) show that bacterial sRNAs can repress mRNA translation not only by binding to the Shine-Dalgarno element but also by base pairing anywhere within the first few codons of the protein-coding region.

Small RNA binding to 5' mRNA coding region inhibits translational initiation

Small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs) have predominantly been shown to repress bacterial mRNAs by masking the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) or AUG start codon sequence, thereby preventing 30S ribosome entry and, consequently, translation initiation. However, many recently identified sRNAs lack obvious SD and AUG complementarity, indicating that sRNA-mediated translational control could also take place at other mRNA sites. We report that Salmonella RybB sRNA represses ompN mRNA translation by pairing with the 5' coding region. Results of systematic antisense interference with 30S binding to ompN and unrelated mRNAs suggest that sRNAs can act as translational repressors by sequestering sequences within the mRNA down to the fifth codon, even without SD and AUG start codon pairing. This "five codon window" for translational control in the 5' coding region of mRNA not only has implications for sRNA target predictions but might also apply to cis-regulatory systems such as RNA thermosensors and riboswitches.

Production of membrane proteins using cell-free expression systems

Production of membrane proteins (MPs) is a challenging task as their hydrophobic nature and their specific requirements in cellular expression systems frequently prevent an efficient synthesis. Cell-free (CF) expression systems have been developed in recent times as promising tools by offering completely new approaches to synthesize MPs directly into artificial hydrophobic environments. A considerable variety of CF produced MPs has been characterized by functional and structural approaches and the high success rates and the rapidly accumulating data on quality and expression efficiencies increasingly attract attention. In addition, CF expression is a highly dynamic and versatile technique and new modifications for improved performance as well as for extended applications for the labeling, throughput expression and proteomic analysis of MPs are rapidly emerging.

Transfer of the high-GC cyclohexane carboxylate degradation pathway from Rhodopseudomonas palustris to Escherichia coli for production of biotin

This work demonstrates the transfer of the five-gene cyclohexane carboxylate (CHC) degradation pathway from the high-GC alphaproteobacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris to Escherichia coli, a gammaproteobacterium. The degradation product of this pathway is pimeloyl-CoA, a key metabolite in E. coli's biotin biosynthetic pathway. This pathway is useful for biotin overproduction in E. coli; however, the expression of GC-rich genes is troublesome in this host. When the native R. palustris CHC degradation pathway is transferred to a DeltabioH pimeloyl-CoA auxotroph of E. coli, it is unable to complement growth in the presence of CHC. To overcome this expression problem we redesigned the operon with decreased GC content and removed stretches of high-GC intergenic DNA which comprise the 5' untranslated region of each gene, replacing these features with shorter low-GC sequences. We show this synthetic construct enables growth of the DeltabioH strain in the presence of CHC. When the synthetic degradation pathway is overexpressed in conjunction with the downstream genes for biotin biosynthesis, we measured significant accumulation of biotin in the growth medium, showing that the pathway transfer is successfully integrated with the host metabolism.

Optimization of the AT-content of codons immediately downstream of the initiation codon and evaluation of culture conditions for high-level expression of recombinant human G-CSF in Escherichia coli

Enhanced therapeutic importance of recombinant human granulocyte colony stimulating factor (rhG-CSF) has encouraged us to develop a processing method for its high-level expression in E. coli. In this study, we established a high-yielding clone by incorporation of silent mutations at N-terminal region of human G-CSF gene. We studied and optimized various parameters of culture conditions connected with the expression of rhG-CSF. The maximum expression was obtained in a defined medium supplemented with 1% glucose. The gene in pET-3a vector in E. coli BL21 (DE3) PLysS host strain was induced with 2 mM isopropyl beta-D: -1-thiogalacto pyronoside. The cell growth and productivity was enhanced about 1.6- and 1.5-folds, respectively when inducing the culture at OD(600) value of 6 than 2. The protein expression was significantly increased by addition of rifampicin at concentration of 200 microg/ml. The AT content of 51.8% with suitable codon sequences at N-terminal region and the concentration of rifampicin were identified as the key factors with a significant impact on protein expression. The specific productivity of 104 mg/OD/l (68.7% of total cellular protein) of rhG-CSF was obtained toward the end of the study, which is almost 1.5 times higher yield than reported so far in the literature.

The use of systematic N- and C-terminal deletions to promote production and structural studies of recombinant proteins

Bacterial over-expression of proteins is a powerful tool to obtain soluble protein amenable to biochemical, biophysical and/or structural characterization. However, it is well established that many recombinant proteins cannot be produced in a soluble form. Several theoretical and empirical methods to improve soluble production have been suggested, although there is to date no universally accepted protocol. This report describes, and quantitatively analyses, a systematic multi-construct approach to obtain soluble protein. Although commonly used in several laboratories, quantitative analyses of the merits of the strategy applied to a larger number of target proteins are missing from the literature. In this study, typically 10 different protein constructs were tested for each targeted domain of nearly 400 human proteins. Overall, soluble expression was obtained for nearly 50% of the human target proteins upon over-expression in Escherichia coli. The chance of obtaining soluble expression was almost doubled using the multi-construct method as compared to more traditional approaches. Soluble protein constructs were subsequently subjected to crystallization trials and the multi-construct approach yielded a more than fourfold increase, from 15 proteins to 65, for the likelihood of obtaining well-diffracting crystals. The results also demonstrate the value of testing multiple constructs in crystallization trials. Finally, a retrospective analysis of gel filtration profiles indicates that these could be used with caution to prioritize protein targets for crystallization trials.

Universal patterns of purifying selection at noncoding positions in bacteria

To investigate the dependence of the number of regulatory sites per intergenic region on genome size, we developed a new method for detecting purifying selection at noncoding positions in clades of related bacterial genomes. We comprehensively quantified evidence of purifying selection at noncoding positions across bacteria and found several striking universal patterns. Consistent with selection acting at transcriptional regulatory elements near the transcription start, we find a universal positional profile of selection with respect to gene starts and ends, showing most evidence of selection immediately upstream and least immediately downstream from genes. A further set of universal features indicates that selection for translation initiation efficiency is the major determinant of the sequence composition around translation start in all clades. In addition to a peak in selection at ribosomal binding sites, the region immediately around translation start shows a universal pattern of high adenine frequency, significant selection at silent positions, and avoidance of RNA secondary structure. Surprisingly, although the number of transcription factors (TF) increases quadratically with genome size, we present several lines of evidence that small and large genomes have the same average number of regulatory sites per intergenic region. By comparing the sequence diversity of the most and least conserved DNA words in intergenic regions across clades we provide evidence that the structure of transcription regulatory networks changes dramatically with genome size: Small genomes have a small number of TFs with a large number of target sites, whereas large genomes have a large number of TFs with a small number of target sites each.

A systematic approach for testing expression of human full-length proteins in cell-free expression systems

BACKGROUND

The growing field of proteomics and systems biology is resulting in an ever increasing demand for purified recombinant proteins for structural and functional studies. Here, we show a systematic approach to successfully express a full-length protein of interest by using cell-free and cell-based expression systems.

RESULTS

In a pre-screen, we evaluated the expression of 960 human full-length open reading frames in Escherichia coli (in vivo and in vitro). After analysing the protein expression rate and solubility, we chose a subset of 87 plasmids yielding no protein product in E. coli in vivo. These targets were subjected to a more detailed analysis comparing a prokaryotic cell-free E. coli system with an eukaryotic wheat germ system. In addition, we determined the expression rate, yield and solubility of those proteins. After sequence optimisation for the E. coli in vitro system and generating linear templates for wheat germ expression, the success rate of cell-free protein expression reached 93%.

CONCLUSION

We have demonstrated that protein expression in cell-free systems is an appropriate technology for the successful expression of soluble full-length proteins. In our study, wheat germ expression using a two compartment system is the method of choice as it shows high solubility and high protein yield.

Optimization of the inefficient translation initiation region of the cpxP gene from Escherichia coli

The Escherichia coli Cpx envelope stress system is comprised of three proteins; the periplasmic regulatory CpxP, the inner membrane sensor kinase CpxA, and the cytoplasmic transcriptional activator CpxR. Although misfolded envelope proteins activate the Cpx system, the molecular mechanism by which this signal is sensed remains largely unknown. In an attempt to reconstitute the Cpx system from purified proteins, we failed to produce the small CpxP protein in its natural periplasmic compartment, but a high protein level was achieved when it was produced in the cytoplasm. Silent base mutations in the first codons of the cpxP gene encoding the signal sequence or substitution by two well-characterized signal sequences, those of MalE and DsbA, resulted in a large increase of the CpxP level in the periplasm. Our results support the hypothesis that periplasmic expression could be inhibited by sequence elements in the early coding signal sequence region of cpxP.

An automated high-throughput screening method for the identification of high-yield, soluble protein variants using cell-free expression and systematic truncation

A highly automated method for rapidly identifying soluble protein variants with good expression yields has been developed. This method is based on a commercially available in vitro protein expression system. It consists of two polymerase chain reactions (PCR) followed by in vitro protein expression and protein quantification by dot blot. The PCR protocols have been improved and optimized to allow automation using commercial fluid handling devices. A PCR primer design program has also been implemented to streamline protein variant design. This automated protocol is highly reliable and has tremendously improved the throughput of expression screening as compared to conventional cell-based methods and manual in vitro methods. We have applied this method to 32 problematic targets from the TB Structural Genomics Consortium. Experimental results of these studies are reported.

Directed evolution of ribosomal protein S1 for enhanced translational efficiency of high GC Rhodopseudomonas palustris DNA in Escherichia coli

The expression of foreign DNA in Escherichia coli is important in biotechnological applications. However, the translation of genes from GC-rich organisms is inefficient in E. coli. To overcome this problem, we applied directed evolution to E. coli ribosomal protein S1. Two selected mutants enabled 12- and 8-fold higher expression levels from GC-rich DNA targets. General improvements in translation efficiency over a range of genes from Rhodopseudomonas palustris and E. coli was achieved using an S1 mutant selected against multiple genes from R. palustris. This method opens new opportunities for the expression of GC-rich genes in E. coli.

Directed evolution of the 5'-untranslated region of the phoA gene in Escherichia coli simultaneously yields a stronger promoter and a stronger Shine-Dalgarno sequence

Directed evolution has been widely applied for gene improvement through random mutagenesis of coding sequences. Through error-prone PCR both in the coding sequence and the regulatory sequence of E. coli alkaline phosphatase, the cellular enzyme activity has been efficiently enhanced. Sequence analysis revealed that the resultant mutant 34-B12, which showed a sevenfold increased enzyme activity at the cellular level, contains three mutations in the regulatory sequence and another three mutations in the coding sequence. Activity assays of the enzyme containing the corresponding amino acid substitutions proved that the amino acid mutations contribute only to a small portion to the increased cellular enzyme activity. So the mutations in the 5'-untranslated region were analyzed separately and combinationally. The results suggested that one mutation yielded a stronger promoter and the other two mutations both elevated the E. coli alkaline phosphatase expression at the translational level; moreover, a stronger Shine-Dalgarno sequence was generated.