Development and comparison of three cell-based potency assays for anti-respiratory syncytial virus monoclonal antibody

Clinical validation of an RSV neutralization assay and analysis of cross-sectional sera associated with 2021-2023 RSV outbreaks to investigate the immunity debt hypothesis

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a leading cause of acute respiratory infections and hospitalization in infants and the elderly. Newly approved vaccines and the prophylactic antibody nirsevimab have heightened interest in RSV immunologic surveillance, necessitating the development of high-throughput assays assessing anti-RSV neutralizing activity. Quantitative viral neutralization remains the best correlate of protection for RSV infection and the gold standard for RSV immunological testing. Here, we developed a high-throughput RSV strain A2 focus-reduction neutralization test validated to Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA)/ Good Clinical Laboratory Practices (GCLP) standards using both clinical specimens and commercially available reference sera. The assay is highly accurate, generating reference serum neutralizing titers within twofold of established assays, with an analytical measurement range between 8 and 1,798 international units per mL (IU/mL). Neutralizing activity measured by the assay strongly correlated with antibody titer determined via indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) (ρ = 1.0, P = 0.0014). Individuals recently having tested positive via quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) for RSV had a 9.1-fold higher geometric mean neutralizing titer relative to RSV PCR negatives (P-value = 0.09). The validated assay was then used to investigate the immunity debt hypothesis for resurgent RSV outbreaks in the 2022-2023 season, using adult clinical remnant sera sent for herpes simplex virus (HSV)-1/2 antibody testing. There was no difference in geometric mean anti-RSV neutralizing titers between sera sampled before and after the 2022-2023 RSV outbreak (P = 0.68). These data are consistent with limited changes in RSV-neutralizing antibody levels in adults across the 2022-23 RSV outbreak.

IMPORTANCE

Population surveillance studies of serum-neutralizing activity against RSV are crucial for evaluating RSV vaccine efficacy and vulnerabilities to new strains. Here, we designed and validated a high-throughput assay for assessing anti-RSV neutralizing activity, standardized its measurements for comparison with other methodologies, and demonstrated its applicability to real-world samples. Our assay is precise, linear, and yields measurements consistent with other standardized assays, offering a methodology useful for large-scale studies of RSV immunity. We also find no significant difference in neutralizing titers among adults between those taken before and after large RSV outbreaks associated with the latter stages of the coronavirus disease of 2019 (COVID-19) public health emergency, underlining the need for a greater understanding of the dynamics of serological responses to RSV infection.

Development of a Cell-Based Reporter Potency Assay for Live Virus Vaccines

The rapid development of potency assays is critical in the development of life-saving vaccines. The traditional plaque assay or fifty percent tissue culture infectious dose (TCID50) assay used to measure the potency of live virus vaccines is time consuming, labor intensive, low throughput and with high variability. Described here is the development and qualification of a cell-based reporter potency assay for two vaccines for respiratory viral infection, one based on the recombinant vesicular stomatitis virus (rVSV) backbone, termed Vaccine 1 in this paper, and the other based on the measles virus vector, termed Vaccine 2. The reporter potency assay used a Vero E6 cell line engineered to constitutively express NanuLuc® luciferase, termed the VeroE6-NLuc or JM-1 cell line. Infection of JM-1 cells by a live virus, such as rVSV or measles virus, causes a cytopathic effect (CPE) and release of NanuLuc® from the cytoplasm into the supernatant, the amount of which reflects the intensity of the viral infection. The relative potency was calculated by comparison to a reference standard using parallel line analysis (PLA) in a log-log linear model. The reporter assay demonstrated good linearity, accuracy, and precision, and is therefore suitable for a vaccine potency assay. Further evaluation of the Vaccine 1 reporter assay demonstrated the robustness to a range of deliberate variation of the selected assay parameters and correlation with the plaque assay. In conclusion, we have demonstrated that the reporter assay using the JM-1 cell line could be used as a potency assay to support the manufacturing and release of multiple live virus vaccines.

Functional design of experiment for potency assay optimization and in-silico simulation

For biotherapeutic analytics, robust and reliable potency assays are required. Design of experiment (DoE) approaches are used to investigate the impact of multiple assay parameters. Currently, specific assay features (e.g., half effective concentration) are modelled independently from each other. A joint interpretation of several assay features is thus difficult. In our functional DoE approach, we use the functional relationship of the assay features to describe the sigmoidal dose-response curve. With the composed functional form, the direct impact of assay parameters on the dose-response curve shape was modelled. Moreover, a multivariate desirability was defined and used for assay optimization. We believe that functional modelling contributes to understanding the joint influence of assay parameters and helps to design robust biotherapeutic analytics.

Optimising cell-based bioassays via integrated design of experiments (ixDoE) - A practical guide

For process optimisation Design of Experiments (DoE) has long been established as a more powerful strategy than a One Factor at a Time approach. Nevertheless, DoE is not widely used especially in the field of cell-based bioassay development although it is known that complex interactions often exist. We believe that biopharmaceutical manufacturers are reluctant to move beyond standard practices due to the perceived costs, efforts, and complexity. We therefore introduce the integrated DoE (ixDoE) approach to target a smarter use of DoEs in the bioassay setting, specifically in optimising resources and time. Where in a standard practice 3 to 4 separate DoEs would be performed, our ixDoE approach includes the necessary statistical inference from only a single experimental set. Hence, we advocate for an innovative, ixDoE approach accompanied by a suitable statistical analysis strategy and present this as a practical guide for a typical bioassay development from basic research to biopharmaceutical industry.

Prediction of frozen virus stability based on degradation mechanisms, real-time data and modeling

Aim: Critical virus reagents in regulated bioanalytical assays require stability monitoring. Although stability at ultralow frozen temperatures is generally assumed, published data are limited and real-time studies are time consuming. Materials & methods: The authors reviewed literature data, typical mechanisms of molecular degradation, glass transition temperatures of commonly used buffers and available real-time storage data to model frozen virus reagent stability. Results: Storage at ultralow temperatures below the glass transition temperature was critical for virus stability. Modeling of real-time data suggested that virus potency remained within 0.5 log10 of its starting potency at a probability of >99, 90 and 73% after 10, 20 and 30 years, respectively. Conclusion: The study supports the practice of virus storage at -70°C or below for 20–30 years.

Neutralization Activity of Anti-drug Antibodies Against a Biotherapeutic Can Be Predicted from a Comprehensive Pharmacokinetics, Pharmacodynamics, and Anti-drug Antibody Data Analysis

Historically, a neutralization antibody (NAb) assay is considered critical in immunogenicity assessment of biologic therapeutics, even with low anti-drug antibody (ADA) positive rates. In 2019, FDA new guidelines issued on immunogenicity testing acknowledged the possibility of using "a highly sensitive PD marker or an appropriately designed PK assay or both that generate data that inform clinical activity" to replace a NAb assay. In the current manuscript, we present data for PK, PD, and ADA assays which collectively succeed to replace the standalone NAb assay. The data include a total LC/MS-based PK assay, a serum neutralization antibody (SNA) assay that essentially measures pharmacodynamically functional PK and can detect NAb activity in the presence of 1:1 ratio of drug, and a highly drug-tolerant ADA assay. In addition, a model-based meta-analysis (MBMA) demonstrated that the ability of SNA assay to detect NAb at 1:1 ratio of drug is sensitive enough to monitor clinically meaningful efficacy change, which is 50% reduction of SNA titer. Our strategy of preparing a holistic data package discussed here may provide a roadmap to the community for alternatives in assaying neutralizing activity of ADA.

Virus reduction neutralization test and LI-COR microneutralization assay bridging and WHO international standard calibration studies for respiratory syncytial virus

Background: Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) vaccine is an unmet medical need. The virus reduction neutralization test (VRNT) was developed to replace the LI-COR microneutralization assay to measure RSV neutralization titers. Methods: A bridging study using selected V171 phase I samples and calibration studies using the WHO international standard antiserum to RSV were performed to compare VRNT and LI-COR. Results: From the bridging study, we showed good concordance between VRNT and LI-COR titers, and similar post-/pre-vaccination titer ratios. From the calibration studies, we can convert VRNT and LI-COR titers into similar IU/ml. Conclusion: The VRNT and LI-COR microneutralization assay correlate well and the titers can be standardized as similar IU/ml, enabling direct comparison of titers from different assays.