Inactivation and adaptation of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria when exposed to free nitrous acid

Effect of initial ammonium concentration on a one-stage partial nitrification/anammox biofilm system: Nitrogen removal performance and the microbial community

One-stage partial nitrification coupled with anammox (PN/A) technology effectively reduces the energy consumption of a biological nitrogen removal system. Inhibiting nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) is essential for this technology to maintain efficient nitrogen removal performance. Initial ammonium concentration (IAC) affects the degree of inhibited NOB. In this study, the effect of the IAC on a PN/A biofilm was investigated in a moving bed biofilm reactor. The results showed that nitrogen removal efficiency decreased from 82.49% ± 1.90% to 64.57% ± 3.96% after the IAC was reduced from 60 to 20 mg N/L, while the nitrate production ratio increased from 13.87% ± 0.90% to 26.50% ± 3.76%. NOB activity increased to 1,133.86 mg N/m2/day after the IAC decreased, approximately 4-fold, indicating that the IAC plays an important inhibitory role in NOB. The rate-limiting step in the mature biofilm of the PN/A system is the nitritation process and is not shifted by the IAC. The analysis of the microbial community structure in the biofilm indicates that the IAC was the dominant factor in changes in community structure. Ca. Brocadia and Ca. Jettenia were the main anammox bacteria, and Nitrosomonas and Nitrospira were the main AOB and NOB, respectively. IAC did not affect the difference in growth between Ca. Brocadia and Ca. Jettenia. Thus, modulating the IAC promoted the PN/A process with efficient nitrogen removal performance at medium to low ammonium concentrations.

Achieving Long-Term Stability of Partial Nitrification and Autotrophic Denitrification in an MABR via Sulfide Dosing

While partial nitrification (PN) has the potential to reduce energy for aeration, it has proven to be unstable when treating low-strength wastewater. This study introduces an innovative combined strategy incorporating a low rate of oxygen supply, pH control, and sulfide addition to selectively inhibit nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). This strategy led to a stable PN in a laboratory-scale membrane aerated biofilm reactor (MABR). Over a period of 260 days, the nitrite accumulation ratio exceeded 60% when treating synthetic sewage containing 50 mg NH4+-N/L. Through in situ activity testing and high-throughput sequencing, the combined strategy led to low levels of nitrite-oxidation activity (<5.5 mg N/m2 h), Nitrospira species (relative abundance <1%), and transcription of nitrite-oxidation genes (undetectable). The addition of sulfide led to simultaneous PN and autotrophic denitrification in the single-stage MABR, resulting in over 60% total inorganic nitrogen removal. Sulfur-based autotrophic denitrification consumed nitrite and inhibited NOB conversion of nitrite to nitrate. The combined strategy has potential to be applied in large-scale sewage treatment and deserves further exploration.

Dynamic pH regulation drives Nitrosomonas for high-rate stable acidic partial nitritation

How to intensify the ammonia oxidation rate (AOR) is still a bottleneck impeding the technology development for the innovative acidic partial nitritation because the eosinophilic ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB), such as Nitrosoglobus or Nitrosospira, were inhibited by the high-level free nitrous acid (FNA) accumulation in acidic environments. In this study, an innovative approach of dynamic acidic pH regulation control strategy was proposed to realize high-rate acidic partial nitritation driven by common AOB genus Nitrosomonas. The acidic partial nitrification process was carried out in a laboratory-scale sequencing batch moving bed biofilm reactor (SBMBBR) for long-term (700 days) to track the effect of dynamic acidic pH on nitrifying bacterial activity. The results indicated that the influent NH4+-N concentration was about 100 mg/L, the nitrite accumulation ratio was exceeding 90%, and the maximum AOR can reach 14.5 ± 2.6 mg N L-1h-1. Although the half-saturation inhibition constant of NOB (KI_FNA(AOB)) reached 0.37 ± 0.10 mg HNO2N/L and showed extreme adaptability in FNA, the inactivation effect of FNA (6.1 mg HNO2N/L) for NOB was much greater than that of AOB, with inactivation rates of 0.61 ± 0.08 h-1 and 0.06 ± 0.01 h-1, respectively. The effluent pH was gradually reduced to 4.5 by ammonia oxidation process and the periodic FNA concentration reached 6.5 mg HNO2N/L to inactivate nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) without negatively affecting Nitrosomonas during long-term operation. This result provides new insights for the future implementation of high-rate stabilized acidic partial nitritation by Nitrosomonas.

Phenacetin promoted the rapid start-up and stable maintenance of partial nitrification: Responses of nitrifiers and antibiotic resistance genes

Phenacetin (PNCT) belongs to one of the earliest synthetic antipyretics. However, impact of PNCT on nitrifying microorganisms in wastewater treatment plants and its potential microbial mechanism was still unclear. In this study, PN could be initiated within six days by PNCT anaerobic soaking treatment (8 mg/L). In order to improve the stable performance of PN, 21 times of PNCT aerobic soaking treatment every three days was conducted and PN was stabilized for 191 days. After PN was damaged, ten times of PNCT aerobic soaking treatment every three days was conducted and PN was recovered after once soaking, maintained over 88 days. Ammonia oxidizing bacteria might change the dominant oligotype to gradually adjust to PNCT, and the increase of abundance and activity of Nitrosomonas promoted the initiation of PN. For nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB), the increase of Candidatus Nitrotoga and Nitrospira destroyed PN, but PN could be recovered after once aerobic soaking illustrating NOB was not resistant to PNCT. KEGG and COG analysis suggested PNCT might disrupt rTCA cycle of Nitrospira, resulting in the decrease of relative abundance of Nitrospira. Moreover, PNCT did not lead to the sharp increase of absolute abundances of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), and the risk of ARGs transmission was negligible.

Potential directions for future development of mainstream partial nitrification-anammox processes: Ammonia-oxidizing archaea as novel functional microorganisms providing nitrite

The application of ammonia-oxidizing archaea (AOA)-based partial nitrification-anammox (PN-A) for mainstream wastewater treatment has attracted research interest because AOA can maintain higher activity in low-temperature environments and they have higher affinity for oxygen and ammonia-nitrogen compared with ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB), thus facilitating stabilized nitrite production, deep removal of low-ammonia, and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria suppression. Moreover, the low affinity of AOA for ammonia makes them more tolerant to N-shock loading and more efficiently integrated with anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox). Based on the limitations of the AOB-based PN-A process, this review comprehensively summarizes the potential and significance of AOA for nitrite supply, then gives strategies and influencing factors for replacing AOB with AOA. Additionally, the methods and key influences on the coupling of AOA and anammox are explored. Finally, this review proposes four AOA-based oxygen- or ammonia-limited autotrophic nitritation/denitrification processes to address the low effluent quality and instability of mainstream PN-A processes.

Research progress of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (Anammox) process based on integrated fixed-film activated sludge (IFAS)

The integrated fixed-film activated sludge (IFAS) process is considered one of the cutting-edge solutions to the traditional wastewater treatment challenges, allowing suspended sludge and attached biofilm to grow in the same system. In addition, the coupling of IFAS with anaerobic ammonium oxidation (Anammox) can further improve the efficiency of biological denitrification. This paper summarises the research progress of IFAS coupled with the anammox process, including partial nitrification anammox, simultaneous partial nitrification anammox and denitrification, and partial denitrification anammox technologies, and describes the factors that limit the development of related processes. The effects of dissolved oxygen, influent carbon source, sludge retention time, temperature, microbial community, and nitrite-oxidising bacteria inhibition methods on the anammox of IFAS are presented. At the same time, this paper gives an outlook on future research focus and engineering practice direction of the process.

Recurrent multi-stressor floc treatments with sulphide and free ammonia enabled mainstream partial nitritation/anammox

Selective suppression of nitrite-oxidising bacteria (NOB) over aerobic and anoxic ammonium-oxidising bacteria (AerAOB and AnAOB) remains a major challenge for mainstream partial nitritation/anammox implementation, a resource-efficient nitrogen removal pathway. A unique multi-stressor floc treatment was therefore designed and validated for the first time under lab-scale conditions while staying true to full-scale design principles. Two hybrid (suspended + biofilm growth) reactors were operated continuously at 20.2 ± 0.6 °C. Recurrent multi-stressor floc treatments were applied, consisting of a sulphide-spiked deoxygenated starvation followed by a free ammonia shock. A good microbial activity balance with high AnAOB (71 ± 21 mg N L-1 d-1) and low NOB (4 ± 17 % of AerAOB) activity was achieved by combining multiple operational strategies: recurrent multi-stressor floc treatments, hybrid sludge (flocs & biofilm), short floc age control, intermittent aeration, and residual ammonium control. The multi-stressor treatment was shown to be the most important control tool and should be continuously applied to maintain this balance. Excessive NOB growth on the biofilm was avoided despite only treating the flocs to safeguard the AnAOB activity on the biofilm. Additionally, no signs of NOB adaptation were observed over 142 days. Elevated effluent ammonium concentrations (25 ± 6 mg N L-1) limited the TN removal efficiency to 39 ± 9 %, complicating a future full-scale implementation. Operating at higher sludge concentrations or reducing the volumetric loading rate could overcome this issue. The obtained results ease the implementation of mainstream PN/A by providing and additional control tool to steer the microbial activity with the multi-stressor treatment, thus advancing the concept of energy neutrality in sewage treatment plants.

Potential stimulation of nitrifying bacteria activities and genera by landfill leachate

With the increasing complexity of influent composition in wastewater treatment plants, the potential stimulating effects of refractory organic matter in wastewater on growth characteristics and genera conversion of nitrifying bacteria (ammonium-oxidizing bacteria [AOB] and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria [NOB]) need to be further investigated. In this study, domestic wastewater was co-treated with landfill leachate in the lab-scale reactor, and the competition and co-existence of NOB genera Nitrotoga and Nitrospira were observed. The results demonstrated that the addition of landfill leachate could induce the growth of Nitrotoga, whereas Nitrotoga populations remain less competitive in domestic wastewater operation. In addition, the refractory organic matter in the landfill leachate also would have a potential stimulating effect on the maximum specific growth rate of AOB genus Nitrosomonas (μmax, aob). The μmax, aob of Nitrosomonas in the control group was estimated to be 0.49 d-1 by fitting the ASM model, and the μmax, aob reached 0.66-0.71 d-1 after injection of refractory organic matter in the landfill leachate, while the maximum specific growth rate of NOB (μmax, nob) was always in the range of 1.05-1.13 d-1. These findings have positive significance for the understanding of potential stimulation on nitrification processes and the stable operation of innovative wastewater treatment process.

How to Provide Nitrite Robustly for Anaerobic Ammonium Oxidation in Mainstream Nitrogen Removal

Innovation in decarbonizing wastewater treatment is urgent in response to global climate change. The practical implementation of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) treating domestic wastewater is the key to reconciling carbon-neutral management of wastewater treatment with sustainable development. Nitrite availability is the prerequisite of the anammox reaction, but how to achieve robust nitrite supply and accumulation for mainstream systems remains elusive. This work presents a state-of-the-art review on the recent advances in nitrite supply for mainstream anammox, paying special attention to available pathways (forward-going (from ammonium to nitrite) and backward-going (from nitrate to nitrite)), key controlling strategies, and physiological and ecological characteristics of functional microorganisms involved in nitrite supply. First, we comprehensively assessed the mainstream nitrite-oxidizing bacteria control methods, outlining that these technologies are transitioning to technologies possessing multiple selective pressures (such as intermittent aeration and membrane-aerated biological reactor), integrating side stream treatment (such as free ammonia/free nitrous acid suppression in recirculated sludge treatment), and maintaining high activity of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and anammox bacteria for competing oxygen and nitrite with nitrite-oxidizing bacteria. We then highlight emerging strategies of nitrite supply, including the nitrite production driven by novel ammonia-oxidizing microbes (ammonia-oxidizing archaea and complete ammonia oxidation bacteria) and nitrate reduction pathways (partial denitrification and nitrate-dependent anaerobic methane oxidation). The resources requirement of different mainstream nitrite supply pathways is analyzed, and a hybrid nitrite supply pathway by combining partial nitrification and nitrate reduction is encouraged. Moreover, data-driven modeling of a mainstream nitrite supply process as well as proactive microbiome management is proposed in the hope of achieving mainstream nitrite supply in practical application. Finally, the existing challenges and further perspectives are highlighted, i.e., investigation of nitrite-supplying bacteria, the scaling-up of hybrid nitrite supply technologies from laboratory to practical implementation under real conditions, and the data-driven management for the stable performance of mainstream nitrite supply. The fundamental insights in this review aim to inspire and advance our understanding about how to provide nitrite robustly for mainstream anammox and shed light on important obstacles warranting further settlement.

Effect of alkaline leaching of phosphogypsum on sulfate reduction activity and bacterial community composition using different sources of anaerobic microbial inoculum

Phosphogypsum (PG), a by-product of the phosphate industry, is high in sulfate, (SO42-), which makes it an excellent substrate for sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB) to produce hydrogen sulfide. This work aimed to optimize SO42- leaching from PG to achieve a high biological reduction of SO42- and generate high sulfide concentrations for subsequent use in the biological recovery of elemental sulfur. Five SRB consortia were isolated and enriched from: IS (Industrial sludges), MS (Marine sediments), WC (Winogradsky column), SNV (petroleum industry sediments) and PG (stored Phosphogypsum). The five consortia showed reduction activity when using PG leachate (with water) as source of SO42- and lactate, acetate, or glucose as the electron donor. The highest reduction rate (81.5 %) was registered using lactate and the IS consortium (81.5 %) followed by MS (79 %) and PG (71 %). To enhance the concentration of leached SO42- from PG for future utilization with the isolated consortia, PG was treated with NaOH solutions (2 % and 5 %). SO42- release of 97 % was achieved with a 5 % concentration and the resulting leachate was further diluted to target a SO42- concentration of 12.4 g·L-1 for utilization with the isolated consortia. Compared to water leachate, a significantly higher reduction rate was registered (2 g·L-1 of SO42) using the IS consortium, demonstrating limited inhibition effect of sulfide- concentration on SRB functionalities. Moreover, metagenomic analysis of the consortia revealed that using PG as a source of SO42- increased the abundance of Deltaproteobacteria, including known SRB like Desulfovibrio, Desulfomicrobium, and Desulfosporosinus, as well as novel SRB genera (Cupidesulfovibrio, Desulfocurvus, Desulfococcus) that showed, for the first time, significant potential as novel sulfate-reducers using PG as a SO42- source.

Difference of high-salinity-induced inhibition of ammonia-oxidising bacteria and nitrite-oxidising bacteria and its applications

The difficulty in achieving stable partial nitritation (PN) is a challenge that limits the application of mainstream anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox). This study proposes high-salinity treatment as a novel strategy for inactivating nitrite-oxidising bacteria (NOB). The study indicated that NOB are more sensitive to high salinity than ammonia-oxidising bacteria (AOB). The inhibitory effect on the nitrifier gradually increased with increasing salinity from 0 to 100 g NaCl/L. After 24 h and 35 g NaCl/L inhibition, the AOB and NOB activities were 36.65% and 7.15% of their original activities, respectively. After one high-salinity treatment, nitrite accumulation rate (NAR) was above 33% during nitrification. Moreover, the sludge characteristics remained almost unchanged after suppression. A novel process for achieving mainstream PN was proposed and evaluated based on the results. An energy consumption analysis showed that mainstream PN/anammox based on the ex situ high-salinity treatment can achieve higher energy self-sufficiency compared with activated sludge.

Enhanced treatment of sludge drying condensate by A/O-MBR process: Microbial activity and community structure

With the rapid increase of sludge production from sewage treatment plants, the treatment of sludge drying condensate rich in a large amount of pollutants urgently needs to be addressed. Due to the unique characteristics of sludge drying condensate (high ammonia nitrogen and COD concentration), there are almost no reports on biological treatment methods specifically targeting sludge drying condensate. In this study, A/O-MBR process was proposed for sludge drying condensate treatment and the effects of ammonia nitrogen loads, alkalinity and aeration intensity were explored. Experimental results show that under the ammonia nitrogen load of 0.35 kg NH4+-N/(m3·d) and the aeration intensity of 0.5 m3/(m2·min), the removal rate of COD and NH4+-N could reach 94% and 99.86% with the addition of alkalinity (m(NaHCO3): m(NH4+-N) = 7:1), respectively. The distribution of living and dead microbial cells in the activated sludge of three reactors also proved that the supplement of alkalinity in the influent can ensure the feasible living conditions for microorganisms. In addition to traditional nitrifying bacteria, through the supplementation of alkalinity and the reduction of aeration intensity, the system had also domesticated high abundance heterogeneous nitrification aerobic denitrification (HN-AD) and aerobic denitrification bacteria (both more than 10% of the total bacterial count). The denitrification process of sludge drying condensate was simplified and the denitrification efficiency was greatly improved. The findings of this study could provide important theoretical guidance for the biological treatment process of sludge drying condensate.

Effect of free nitrous acid on extracellular polymeric substances production and membrane fouling in a nitritation membrane bioreactor

The membrane bioreactor (MBR) with nitritation based nitrogen removal processes has attracted growing interest in recent years, although membrane fouling in the nitritation MBR is a challenging issue. In this study, the inhibitory effect of free nitrous acid (FNA) on microbial extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) production and membrane fouling in a nitritation MBR was investigated. Results showed that EPS played a critical role in the biofouling process, and EPS production was affected by FNA concentration. As FNA concentration increased from 5.10 × 10-3 mg N/L to 1.34 × 10-2 mg N/L, protein (PN) and polysaccharide (PS) contents increased from 8.20 to 60.28 mg/g VSS and 4.74-30.46 mg/g VSS, respectively. However, when FNA concentration was 1.48 × 10-2 mg N/L, PN and PS reduced by 20.0% and 10.9%, respectively, indicating that the higher FNA concentration could reduce EPS production. The EPS reduction could be attributed to reduction in the loosely bound (LB) and tightly bound (TB) EPS but not the soluble microbial products (SMP). It was further revealed that higher FNA concentrations up to 1.48 × 10-2 mg N/L consequently mitigate trans-membrane pressure (TMP) rate in terms of dTMP/dt by 25.5% in the nitritation MBR. High throughput sequencing analysis revealed that the increase in FNA led to enrichment of Nitrosomonas but reduction in heterotrophic bacteria. This study showed that the appropriate FNA concentration affected EPS production and hence membrane fouling, leading to the possibility of membrane fouling mitigation by in-situ generated FNA in the nitritation MBR.

Increasing specific biomass nitrogen load facilitated nitrite accumulation in mainstream wastewater treatment

By regulating influent nitrogen loading rate (NLR) and solids retention time (SRT), the effect of specific biomass nitrogen load (BNL) on the start-up of mainstream partial nitrification (PN) was investigated in five parallel sequencing batch reactors inoculated with ordinary nitrification sludge. The results showed that increasing BNL by both methods could achieve nitrite accumulation. Moreover, a high initial activity of ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AOB) accelerated nitrite accumulation. Increasing influent NLR (ammonium: 55-70 mg N/L) achieved only 30%-40% of nitrite accumulation ratio (NAR) and gradually decreased with reactor operation. By increasing BNL via controlling SRT (30 days), desirable PN with an average NAR of 81.7 ± 4.4% (effluent nitrite: ∼10 mg N/L) was obtained. Nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) were effectively inhibited, and the AOB to NOB activity ratio increased from 1.5 to 7.8, promoting efficient nitrite accumulation. Overall, increasing BNL by regulating SRT was a potential method for start-up of mainstream PN.

Nitrite Oxidation in Wastewater Treatment: Microbial Adaptation and Suppression Challenges

Microbial nitrite oxidation is the primary pathway that generates nitrate in wastewater treatment systems and can be performed by a variety of microbes: namely, nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). Since NOB were first isolated 130 years ago, the understanding of the phylogenetical and physiological diversities of NOB has been gradually deepened. In recent endeavors of advanced biological nitrogen removal, NOB have been more considered as a troublesome disruptor, and strategies on NOB suppression often fail in practice after long-term operation due to the growth of specific NOB that are able to adapt to even harsh conditions. In line with a review of the history of currently known NOB genera, a phylogenetic tree is constructed to exhibit a wide range of NOB in different phyla. In addition, the growth behavior and metabolic performance of different NOB strains are summarized. These specific features of various NOB (e.g., high oxygen affinity of Nitrospira, tolerance to chemical inhibitors of Nitrobacter and Candidatus Nitrotoga, and preference to high temperature of Nitrolancea) highlight the differentiation of the NOB ecological niche in biological nitrogen processes and potentially support their adaptation to different suppression strategies (e.g., low dissolved oxygen, chemical treatment, and high temperature). This review implicates the acquired physiological characteristics of NOB to their emergence from a genomic and ecological perspective and emphasizes the importance of understanding physiological characterization and genomic information in future wastewater treatment studies.

Nitrite-resistance mechanisms on wastewater treatment in denitrifying phosphorus removal process revealed by machine learning, co-occurrence, and metagenomics analysis

Nitrite is a key intermediate in nitrogen metabolism that determines microbial transformations of N and P, greenhouse gas (N₂O) emissions, and system nutrient removal efficiency. However, nitrite also exerts toxic effects on microorganisms. A lack of understanding of high nitrite-resistance mechanisms at community- and genome-scale resolutions hinders the optimization for robustness of wastewater treatment systems. Here, we established nitrite-dependent denitrifying and phosphorus removal (DPR) systems under a gradient concentration of nitrite (0, 5, 10, 15, 20, and 25 mg N/L), relying on 16S rRNA gene amplicon and metagenomics to explore high nitrite-resistance mechanism. The results demonstrated that specific taxa were adopted to change the metabolic relationship of the community through phenotypic evolution to resist toxic nitrite contributing to the enhancement of denitrification and inhibition of nitrification and phosphorus removal. The key specific species, Thauera enhanced denitrification, whereas Candidatus Nitrotoga decreased in abundance to maintain partial nitrification. The extinction of Candidatus Nitrotoga induced a simpler restructuring-community, forcing high nitrite-stimulating microbiome to establish a more focused denitrification rather than nitrification or P metabolism in response to nitrite toxicity. Our work provides insights for understanding microbiome adaptation to toxic nitrite and giving theoretical support for operation strategy of nitrite-based wastewater treatment technology.

Achieving advanced nitrogen removal from low-carbon municipal wastewater using partial-nitrification/anammox and endogenous partial-denitrification/anammox

To achieve advanced nitrogen removal from low-carbon wastewater, a partial-nitrification/anammox and endogenous partial-denitrification/ anammox (PN/A-EPD/A) process was developed in a sequential batch biofilm reactor (SBBR). Advanced nitrogen was achieved with the effluent total nitrogen (TN) of 3.29 mg/L when the influent COD/TN and the TN were 2.86 and 59.59 mg/L, respectively. This was attributed to a stable PN/A-EPD/A, which was achieved through the integration of four strategies, including treating the inoculated sludge with free nitrous acid, inoculating anammox biofilm, discharging excess activated sludge and residual ammonium at the end of oxic stage. The 16S rRNA high-throughput sequencing results demonstrated that anammox bacteria coexisted with ammonia oxidizing bacteria, nitrite oxidizing bacteria, denitrifying glycogen accumulating organisms (DGAOs) and denitrifying phosphorus accumulating organisms (DPAOs) in biofilms. The abundance of anammox bacteria in the inner layer of the biofilm is higher, while that of DGAOs and DPAOs is higher in the outer layer.

One-year stable pilot-scale operation demonstrates high flexibility of mainstream anammox application

Mainstream nitrogen removal via anammox is widely recognized as a promising wastewater treatment process. However, its application is challenging at large scale due to unstable suppression of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). In this study, a pilot-scale mainstream anammox process was implemented in an Integrated Fixed-film Activated Sludge (IFAS) configuration. Stable operation with robust NOB suppression was maintained for over one year. This was achieved through integration of three key control strategies: i) low dissolved oxygen (DO = 0.4 ± 0.2 mg O₂/L), ii) regular free nitrous acid (FNA)-based sludge treatment, and iii) residual ammonium concentration control (NH₄ ⁺ with a setpoint of ∼8 mg N/L). Activity tests and FISH demonstrated that NOB barely survived in sludge flocs and were inhibited in biofilms. Despite receiving organic-deficient wastewater from a pilot-scale High-Rate Activated Sludge (HRAS) system as the feed, the system maintained a stable effluent total nitrogen concentration mostly below 10 mg N/L, which was attributed to the successful retention of anammox bacteria. This study successfully demonstrated large-scale long-term mainstream anammox application and generated new practical knowledge for NOB control and anammox retention.

In a quest for high-efficiency mainstream partial nitritation-anammox (PN/A) implementation: One-stage or two-stage?

Partial nitritation-anammox (PN/A) process is known as an energy-efficient technology for wastewater nitrogen removal, which possesses a great potential to bring wastewater treatment plants close to energy neutrality with reduced carbon footprint. To achieve this goal, various PN/A processes implemented in a single reactor configuration (one-stage system) or two separately dedicated reactors configurations (two-stage system) were explored over the past decades. Nevertheless, large-scale implementation of these PN/A processes for low-strength municipal wastewater treatment has a long way to go owing to the low efficiency and effectiveness in nitrogen removal. In this work, we provided a comprehensive analysis of one-stage and two-stage PN/A processes with a focus on evaluating their engineering application potential towards mainstream implementation. The difficulty for nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) out-selection was revealed as the critical operational challenge to achieve the desired effluent quality. Additionally, the operational strategies of low oxygen commonly adopted in one-stage systems for NOB suppression and facilitating anammox bacteria growth results in a low nitrogen removal rate (NRR). Introducing denitrification into anammox system was found to be necessary to improve the nitrogen removal efficiency (NRE) by reducing the produced nitrate with in-situ utilizing the organics from wastewater itself. However, this may lead to part of organics oxidized with additional oxygen consumed in one-stage system, further compromising the NRR. By applying a relatively high dissolved oxygen in PN reactor with residual ammonium control, and followed by a granules-based anammox reactor feeding with a small portion of raw municipal wastewater, it appeared that two-stage system could achieve a good effluent quality as well as a high NRR. In contrast to the widely studied one-stage system, this work provided a unique perspective that more effort should be devoted to developing a two-stage PN/A process to evaluate its application potential of high efficiency and economic benefits towards mainstream implementation.

Effects mechanism of bio-carrier filling rate on rotating biofilms and the reactor performance optimization method

Benefited from the massive filling bio-carriers, the packed cage rotating biological contactors (RBCs) have better performance and application potentiality in wastewater treatment. Investigating the effects mechanism of bio-carrier filling rate is crucial for such reactors management. In this study, the pollutants removal performance, biofilms physical characteristics, and microbial communities of the biofilms under a series of bio-carrier filling rates were analyzed. The results shown, the pollutant removal rate and amount were quite different under different filling rates, and biofilms structure and microbial composition were the main factors affecting the pollutants removal performance. With the increasing filling rates, the biofilms were more mass increased (dry weight from 0.066 to 0.148 g/per carrier), thicker (from 340.30 to 850.84 μm) and lower dense (from 0.068 to 0.060 g/cm³). The microbial community composition of those biofilms was also quite different at the genus level. The effects mechanism of bio-carrier filling rate can be summarized: the filling rates affect the physical and biological characteristics of biofilms, which will further affect the microenvironment and microbial distribution in biofilms, and then determines the pollutant metabolic rate and metabolic pathway. This study will contribute to design better bio-carrier filling rate according to different wastewater treatment scenario, and promote the performance optimization of packed cage RBCs.

A review of enhanced municipal wastewater treatment through energy savings and carbon recovery to reduce discharge and CO2 footprint

Municipal wastewater treatment that mainly performed by conventional activated sludge (CAS) process faces the challenge of intensive aeration-associated energy consumption for oxidation of organics and ammonium, contributing to significant directly/indirectly greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from energy use, which hinders the achievement of carbon neutral, the top priority mission in the coming decades to cope with the global climate change. Therefore, this article aimed to offer a comprehensive analysis of recently developed biological treatment processes with the focus on reducing discharge and CO2 footprint. The biotechnologies including "Zero Carbon", "Low Carbon", "Carbon Capture and Utilization" are discussed, it suggested that, by integrating these processes with energy-saving and carbon recovery, the challenges faced in current wastewater treatment plants can be overcome, and a carbon-neutral even be possible. Future research should investigate the integration of these methods and improve anammox contribution as well as minimize organics lost under different scales.

State-Space-Based Framework for Predicting Microbial Interaction Variability in Wastewater Treatment Plants

Substantial attempts have been made to control microbial communities for environmental integrity, biosystem performance, and human health. However, it is difficult to manipulate microbial communities in practice due to the varying and nonlinear nature of interspecific interaction networks. Here, we develop a manifold-based framework to investigate the patterns of microbial interaction variability in wastewater treatment plants using manifold geometric properties and design a simple control strategy to manipulate the microbes in nonlinear communities. We validate our framework using the readily available and nonsequential microbiome profiles of wastewater treatment plants. Our results show that some microbes in the activated sludge and anammox communities display deterministic rival or cooperative relationships and constitute a stable subnetwork within the whole nonlinear community network. We further use a simulation to demonstrate that these microbes can be used to drive a microbe in a target direction regardless of the community dynamics. Overall, our framework can provide a time-efficient solution to select effective control inputs for reliable manipulation in varying microbial networks, opening up new possibilities across a range of biological fields, including wastewater treatment plants.

Achieving robust mainstream nitrite shunt at pilot-scale with integrated sidestream sludge treatment and step-feed

As a promising energy- and carbon efficient process for nitrogen removal from wastewater, mainstream nitrite shunt has been extensively researched. However, beyond the laboratory it is challenging to maintain stable performance by suppressing nitrite-oxidising bacteria (NOB). In this study, a pilot-scale reactor system receiving real sewage was operated in two stages for >850 days to evaluate two novel NOB suppression strategies for achieving nitrite shunt: i) sidestream sludge treatment based on alternating free nitrous acid (FNA) and free ammonia (FA) and ii) sidestream FNA/FA sludge treatment integrated with in-situ NOB suppression via step-feed. The results showed that, with sidestream sludge treatment alone, NOB developed resistance relatively quickly to the treatment, leading to unstable nitrite shunt. In contrast, robust nitrite shunt was achieved and stably maintained for more than a year when sidestream sludge treatment was integrated with a step-feed strategy. Kinetic analyses suggested that sludge treatment and step-feed worked in synergy, leading to stable NOB suppression. The integrated strategy demonstrated in this study removes a key barrier to the implementation of stable mainstream nitrite shunt.

Determining Factors for Nitrite Accumulation in an Acidic Nitrifying System: Influent Ammonium Concentration, Operational pH, and Ammonia-Oxidizing Community

Acidic nitrification is attracting wide attention because it can enable robust suppression of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) in wastewater treatment. This study reports a comprehensive assessment of the novel acidic nitrification process to identify the key factors that govern stable nitrite accumulation. A laboratory-scale moving-bed biofilm reactor receiving low-alkalinity wastewater was continuously operated under acidic conditions (pH < 6) for around two years, including nine stages varying influent and operational conditions. The results revealed that nitrite accumulation was related to three factors, i.e., influent ammonium concentration, operating pH, and ammonia-oxidizing microbial community. These three factors impact nitrite accumulation by altering the in situ concentration of free nitrous acid (FNA), which is a potent inhibitor of NOB. The critical FNA concentration is approximately one part per million (ppm, ∼1 mg HNO₂-N/L), above which nitrite accumulation is stably maintained in an acidic nitrifying system. The findings of this study suggest that stable nitrite accumulation via acidic ammonia oxidation can be maintained under a range of influent and operational conditions, as long as a ppm-level of FNA is established. Taking low-strength mainstream wastewater (40-50 mg NH₄⁺-N/L) with limited alkalinity as an example, stable nitrite accumulation was experimentally demonstrated at a pH of 4.35, under which an in situ FNA of 2.3 ± 0.6 mg HNO₂-N/L was attained. Under these conditions, Candidatus Nitrosoglobus became the only ammonia oxidizer detectable by 16S rRNA gene sequencing. The results of this study deepen our understanding of acidic nitrifying systems, informing further development of novel wastewater treatment technologies.

A 20-Year Journey of Partial Nitritation and Anammox (PN/A): from Sidestream toward Mainstream

Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) was discovered as a new microbial reaction in the late 1990s, which led to the development of an innovative energy- and carbon-efficient technology─partial nitritation and anammox (PN/A)─for nitrogen removal. PN/A was first applied to remove the nitrogen from high-strength wastewaters, e.g., anaerobic digestion liquor (i.e., sidestream), and further expanded to the main line of wastewater treatment plants (i.e., mainstream). While sidestream PN/A has been well-established with extensive full-scale installations worldwide, practical application of PN/A in mainstream treatment has been proven extremely challenging to date. A key challenge is achieving stable suppression of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). This study examines the progress of NOB suppression in both sidestream- and mainstream PN/A over the past two decades. The successful NOB suppression in sidestream PN/A was reviewed, and these successes were evaluated in terms of their transferability into mainstream PN/A. Drawing on the learning over the past decades, we anticipate that a hybrid process, comprised of biofilm and floccular sludge, bears great potential to achieve efficient mainstream PN/A, while a combination of strategies is entailed for stable NOB suppression. Furthermore, the recent discovery of novel nitrifiers would trigger new opportunities and new challenges for mainstream PN/A.

Wastewater Primary Treatment Using Forward Osmosis Introduces Inhibition to Achieve Stable Mainstream Partial Nitrification

Achieving stable long-term mainstream nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) suppression is the bottleneck for the novel partial nitrification (PN) process toward energy- and carbon-efficient wastewater treatment. However, long-term PN stability remains a challenge due to NOB adaptation. This study proposed and demonstrated a novel strategy for achieving NOB suppression by the primary treatment of mainstream wastewater with a forward osmosis (FO) membrane process, which facilitated two external NOB inhibition factors (salinity and free nitrous acid, FNA). To evaluate the proposed strategy, a lab-scale sequencing batch reactor was operated for 200 days. A stable PN operation was achieved with a nitrite accumulation ratio of 97.7 ± 2.8%. NOB were suppressed under the combined inhibition effect of NaCl (7.9 ± 0.2 g/L, as introduced by the FO direct filtration) and FNA (0.11 ± 0.02 mg of HNO₂-N/L, formed as a result of the increased NH₄⁺-N concentration after the FO process). The two inhibition factors worked in synergy to achieve a more stable PN operation. The microbial analysis showed that the elevated salinity and accumulation of FNA reshaped the microbial community and selectively eliminated NOB. Finally, an economic and feasibility analysis was conducted, which suggests that the integration of an FO unit into PN/A is a feasible and economically viable wastewater treatment process.

Feeding low-level benzethonium chloride can promote the start-up, fast recovery and long-term stable maintenance of partial nitrification for low-ammonium wastewater

The establishment of stable partial nitrification (PN) is beneficial to promote the application of anaerobic ammonium oxidation, especially for low-ammonium wastewater. This study demonstrated an innovative approach for achieving PN through feeding low-level benzethonium chloride (BZC). PN was started and maintained for 125 days after the sequential feeding of 0.2 and 1 mg/L BZC for 50 days. The damaged PN recovered rapidly within eight days by feeding 2 mg/L BZC, and it thrived for more than 172 days, indicating that nitrite-oxidizing bacteria did not adapt to BZC. The removal of BZC changed from adsorption to degradation gradually. Increased extracellular polymeric substances secretion and altered protein secondary structures explained sludge granulation during BZC feeding, which may be closely related to long-term stable maintenance of PN. PICRUSt2 revealed the underlying microbial mechanisms in depth. Overall, this research proposed a novel scheme to achieve robust PN treating low-ammonium wastewater through feeding low-level BZC.

Elucidating nitrifying performance, nitrite accumulation and microbial community in a three-stage plug flow moving bed biofilm reactor (PF - MBBR)

A three-stage plug flow moving bed biofilm reactor (PF - MBBR, consisting of three identical chambers of N1, N2 and N3) was proposed for nitrifier enrichment using synthetic wastewater. During the stable operation, the average NH₄⁺-N effluent was 0.67 mg/L and NH₄⁺-N removal was as high as 97.19% with the nitrite accumulation ratio (NAR) of 54.23%, although the biofilm thickness and biomass both presented downward trends from N1 (296 μm, 2280 mg/L), N2 (248 μm, 1850 mg/L) to N3 (198 μm, 1545 mg/L). Particularly, the comparative results of three stages revealed that N2 showed the optimum NH₄⁺-N removal (77.27%) and NAR (75.21%) in the continuous-flow, while NAR of N3 unexpectedly maintained a high level of 65.83% in the batch test, suggesting that ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) accounted for absolute advantage over nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB). High-throughput sequencing initially verified different distribution of bacterial community structure, where N2 was far away from N1 and N3 with the lowest community richness and community diversity (operational taxonomic units (OTUs): 454(N2)<527(N3)<621(N1)). Proteobacteria (77.60%-83.09%), Bacteroidetes (1.66%-3.66%), Acidobacteria (2.28%-4.67%), and Planctomycetes (1.19%-6.63%) were the major phyla. At the genus level, AOB (mainly Nitrosomonas) accounted for 5.08% (N1), 20.74% (N2) and 14.24% (N3) while NOB (mainly Nitrospira) increased from 0.14% (N1), 7.06% (N2) to 4.91% (N3) with the total percentages of 5.22%, 27.80% and 19.15%. Finally, the application feasibility of MBBR optimization linked with nitrite (NO₂^--N) accumulation for deep-level nutrient removal was discussed.

Some like it cold: The cellular organization and physiological limits of cold-tolerant nitrite-oxidizing Nitrotoga

Chemolithoautotrophic production of nitrate is accomplished by the polyphyletic functional group of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). A widely distributed and important NOB clade in nitrogen removal processes at low temperatures is Nitrotoga, which however remains understudied due to the scarcity of cultivated representatives. Here, we present physiological, ultrastructural and genomic features of Nitrotoga strains from various habitats, including the first marine species enriched from an aquaculture system. Immunocytochemical analyses localized the nitrite-oxidizing enzyme machinery in the wide irregularly shaped periplasm, apparently without contact to the cytoplasmic membrane, confirming previous genomic data suggesting a soluble nature. Interestingly, in two strains we also observed multicellular complexes with a shared periplasmic space, which seem to form through incomplete cell division and might enhance fitness or survival. Physiological tests revealed differing tolerance limits towards dissolved inorganic nitrogen concentrations and confirmed the generally psychrotolerant nature of the genus was. Moreover, comparative analysis of 15 Nitrotoga genomes showed, e.g., a unique gene repertoire of the marine strain that could be advantageous in its natural habitat and confirmed the lack of genes for assimilatory nitrite reduction in a strain found to require ammonium for growth. Overall, these novel insights largely broaden our knowledge of Nitrotoga and elucidate the metabolic variability, physiological limits and thus potential ecological roles of this group of nitrite oxidizers. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

NOB suppression strategies in a mainstream membrane aerated biofilm reactor under exceptionally low lumen pressure

Integrating the aeration-efficient membrane aerated biofilm reactor (MABR) with anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) could yield further reduction in energy in wastewater treatment facilities. However, nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) suppression remained challenging due to the absence of intrinsic inhibition factors in mainstream conditions. This study investigated selective NOB suppression strategies in MABR under <5 kPa lumen pressure. Three MABRs were seeded from different seeding sludge, and operated under various ammonium loading rates, aeration pressure, and temporary inhibitory shock conditions. The three reactors were operated for 170-456 days depending on studied parameters. The results showed that higher ammonium loading could create a substrate-oxygen imbalance and quickly contain emergent NOB activity when aeration pressure was not excessive. In addition, lowering of aeration pressure reversed nitrite oxidizing activities without affecting ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AOB). Cultivating partial nitritation biofilm under zero positive aeration pressure slowed down the growth of NOB yet resulted in self-induced anammox activities. With the aid of temporary free ammonia (FA)/free nitrous acid (FNA) treatment, full-nitrifying biofilm could be transformed to stable partial nitritation biofilm. More than 84% nitrite accumulation ratio (NAR) was sustained during stable operation in each reactor together with an ammonium removal rate of more than 100 mg-N/L/d. Microbial analysis revealed that Nitrosomonas was the main AOB taxon in the three reactors while K-strategist Nitrospira showed presence despite low nitrite oxidizing activities. Under zero positive pressure, proliferation of Nitrospira was much slower while Candidatus Brocadia was self-induced. Furthermore, Nitrospira showed downturn after temporary inhibition treatment.

A novel stable nitritation process: Treating sludge by alternating free nitrous acid/heat shock

The feasibility of stable nitritation of sludge alternately treated by free nitrous acid (FNA) and heat shock in a sequencing batch reactor (SBR) was investigated in this study. The linear regression method was used to determine the optimal treatment conditions. Results revealed that an FNA concentration of 2.20 mg HNO₂-N/L, exposure time of 24 h, and treatment ratio of 20% could inhibit nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) activity to the greatest extent while maintaining the maximum ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AOB) activity; after heat shock at 60 °C for 20 min, NOB were inhibited while AOB still had certain activity. In the long-term continuous-flow experiment, the single FNA or heat shock treatments easily allowed adapt NOB to affect the stability of nitritation. The alternating FNA/heat shock treatment can achieve long-term stability of nitritation. Microbial community analysis revealed that the alternating FNA/heat shock treatment could inhibit NOB while maintaining high AOB abundance.

Metagenomics insights into the selective inhibition of NOB and comammox by phenacetin: Transcriptional activity, nitrogen metabolism and mechanistic understanding

Phenacetin (PNCT), a common antipyretic and analgesic drug, is often used to treat fever and headache. However, the effect of PNCT on nitrifiers in wastewater treatment processes remains unclear. The practicability of attaining partial nitrification (PN) through inhibitor-PNCT was investigated in this study. The optimal treatment conditions of soaking once for 18 h with 2.50 × 10^-3 g PNCT/(g MLSS) were applied to the PN stability experiment. The results showed that ammonia oxidation activity recovered quickly after 3 cycles of operation, while nitrite oxidation activity was suppressed steadily. In addition, average ammonium removal efficiency and nitrite accumulation ratio during 138 cycles could reach 94.94% and 85.38%, respectively. Complimentary DNA high-throughput sequencing and oligotyping analysis showed that the activity of Nitrosomonas would gradually surpass Nitrospira after PNCT treatment only once. The decrease of Nitrospira activity was accompanied by the simplification of oligotypes after PNCT treatment, while Nitrosomonas could adapt to PNCT stress by reducing the differences between oligotypes. Metagenomics revealed that the decrease in the number of NXR in the nitrogen metabolism pathways was the key reason for achieving PN. The potential mechanisms might be that the dominant nitrite-oxidizing bacteria and complete ammonia oxidizers were bio-killed by PNCT.

A successful start-up of an anaerobic membrane bioreactor (AnMBR) coupled mainstream partial nitritation-anammox (PN/A) system: A pilot-scale study on in-situ NOB elimination, AnAOB growth kinetics, and mainstream treatment performance

In this pilot-scale study, an innovative mainstream treatment process that couples the anaerobic membrane reactor (AnMBR) with a one-stage PN/A system was proposed for advancing the concept of carbon neutrality in the municipal wastewater treatment plant. This work demonstrates the start-up procedure of a pilot-scale one-stage PN/A system for mainstream treatment. The 255-day start-up of the one-stage PN/A system involved the cultivation of ammonium-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) from the activated sludge, suppression of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB), investigation of in-situ growth kinetics of anammox bacteria (AnAOB), and the 50-day operation of the pilot-scale AnMBR-PN/A process for natural mainstream treatment. It is verified in the pilot-scale system for the first time that the in-situ free ammonia (FA) and free nitrous acid (FNA) exposure could effectively eliminate the Nitrospira (the NOB genus) while retaining the Nitosonomas (the AOB genus) community in the suspended sludge. NOB community rebounding was not detected even at the mainstream conditions with low nitrogen concentrations (Influent ammonium concentration=38±6 mg-NH₄⁺-N/L) by intermittent aeration to control the system dissolved oxygen (DO) below 0.5 mg/L. The results of the mainstream treatment showed that the average effluent total nitrogen (TN) in the coupled process was generally lower than 10 mg-N/L, which meets the discharge limits of most prefectures in Japan. The investigated results of the in-situ anammox bacteria (AnAOB) growth kinetics suggested that the promoted start-up strategy of taking advantage of the warm months with higher mainstream temperature to achieve the rapid in-situ growth of the AnAOB is applicable in the investigated regions. From the perspective of the removal performance of the TN and organic substance, the AnMBR-PN/A process has great potential as the layouts of the carbon-neutral mainstream wastewater treatment plants.

Oxygen control and stressor treatments for complete and long-term suppression of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria in biofilm-based partial nitritation/anammox

Mainstream nitrogen removal by partial nitritation/anammox (PN/A) can realize energy and cost savings for sewage treatment. Selective suppression of nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) remains a key bottleneck for PN/A implementation. A rotating biological contactor was studied with an overhead cover and controlled air/N₂ inflow to regulate oxygen availability at 20 °C. Biofilm exposure to dissolved oxygen concentrations < 0.51 ± 0.04 mg O₂ L^-1 when submerged in the water and < 1.41 ± 0.31 mg O₂ L^-1 when emerged in the headspace (estimated), resulted in complete and long-term NOB suppression with a low relative nitrate production ratio of 10 ± 4%. Additionally, weekly biofilm stressor treatments with free ammonia (FA) (29 ± 1 mg NH₃-N L^-1 for 3 h) could improve the NOB suppression while free nitrous acid treatments had insufficient effect. This study demonstrated the potential of managing NOB suppression in biofilm-based systems by oxygen control and recurrent FA exposure, opening opportunities for resource efficient nitrogen removal.

Achieving stable and long-term partial nitrification of domestic wastewater by side-stream sludge treatment using a novel nitrite oxidation inhibitor chloroxylenol

Using inhibitors to selectively suppress the activity of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) was an emerging way to rapidly achieve partial nitrification (PN). This study explored the feasibility of inactivating NOB by a novel inhibitor chloroxylenol (PCMX) in real domestic wastewater. Different frequencies (periodic strategy and concentrative time strategy) of PCMX side-stream sludge treatment were used to achieve and maintain PN during 250 days. PN was realized by PCMX treatment once a day about 20 days, due to the inhibition of Nitrospira. PN was completely destroyed after 212 days by periodic strategy, caused by the increase of Candidatus Nitrotoga. PN maintained without PCMX in following 201 days by concentrative time strategy. The risks of PCMX were assessed and almost no PCMX was detected in the effluent of mainstream sequencing batch reactors. These results meant PN realized by PCMX side-stream sludge treatment was feasible and concentrative time strategy was a better operating strategy.

Centralized iron-dosing into returned sludge brings multifaceted benefits to wastewater management

Iron salts (i.e. FeCl₃) are the most used chemicals in the urban wastewater system. Iron is commonly dosed into sewage or the mainstream system, which provides multiple benefits such as enhanced phosphorus removal and improved sludge settleability/dewaterability. This study reported and demonstrated a new approach that dosed FeCl₃ into returned sludge in order to bring two more benefits to wastewater management: short-cut nitrogen removal via the nitrite pathway and less biomass production. This approach is achieved based on our findings that with similar amount of FeCl₃, centralized iron dosing into a sidestream sludge unit generated iron concentration two orders of magnitude higher than the common mainstream dosing (e.g. 10-40 mg Fe/L-wastewater), leading to sludge acidification (pH = 2.1) with Fe (III) hydrolysis. Together with accumulated nitrite in the supernatant of the sludge, ppm-level of free nitrous acid was generated and thus enabled sludge disintegration, cell lysis, and selective elimination of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). Long-term effects on nitrifying bacteria and overall reactor performance were evaluated using two laboratory reactor experiments for over one year. The experimental reactor showed stable nitrite accumulation with an average NO₂^-/(NO₂^- + NO₃^-) ratio above 80% and ∼30% observed biomass yield reduction compared to those in control reactors. In addition, the centralized sludge dosing strategy still provided benefits such as improved settleability and dewaterability of sludge and enhanced phosphorus removal.

Relevance of Candidatus Nitrotoga for nitrite oxidation in technical nitrogen removal systems

Abstract

Many biotechnological applications deal with nitrification, one of the main steps of the global nitrogen cycle. The biological oxidation of ammonia to nitrite and further to nitrate is critical to avoid environmental damage and its functioning has to be retained even under adverse conditions. Bacteria performing the second reaction, oxidation of nitrite to nitrate, are fastidious microorganisms that are highly sensitive against disturbances. One important finding with relevance for nitrogen removal systems was the discovery of the mainly cold-adapted Cand. Nitrotoga, whose activity seems to be essential for the recovery of nitrite oxidation in wastewater treatment plants at low temperatures, e.g., during cold seasons. Several new strains of this genus have been recently described and ecophysiologically characterized including genome analyses. With increasing diversity, also mesophilic Cand. Nitrotoga representatives have been detected in activated sludge. This review summarizes the natural distribution and driving forces defining niche separation in artificial nitrification systems. Further critical aspects for the competition with Nitrospira and Nitrobacter are discussed. Knowledge about the physiological capacities and limits of Cand. Nitrotoga can help to define physico-chemical parameters for example in reactor systems that need to be run at low temperatures.

Key points

• Characterization of the psychrotolerant nitrite oxidizer Cand. Nitrotoga

• Comparison of the physiological features of Cand. Nitrotoga with those of other NOB

• Identification of beneficial environmental/operational parameters for proliferation

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00253-021-11487-5.

Novel insights into overcoming nitrite oxidation bacteria acclimatization problem in treatment of high-ammonia wastewater through partial nitrification

A partial nitrification sequencing batch reactor was operated to reveal mechanisms behind nitrite oxidation bacteria (NOB) acclimatization in high-ammonia wastewater treatment. The influent NH₄⁺-N increased stepwise from 499.7 ± 4.2 mg/L to 6994.5 ± 7.5 mg/L with initial free ammonia (FA) concentration rising from 37.9 ± 3.2 mg NH₃-N/L to 715.3 ± 47.3 mg NH₃-N/L, respectively. NOB acclimatized this FA range with NO₃^--N production increasing from 29.2 ± 2.6 mg/L to 144.1 ± 31.0 mg/L in a cycle, which was caused by the shift of dominant NOB genus from Nitrospira to Nitrolencea. Nitrosomonas as ammonia oxidation bacteria, could sustain its activity of 62.1 ± 0.1 mg NH₄⁺-N/(gVSS∙L∙h) under the same condition. Hydroxylamine addition could be implemented as an emergency measure to alleviate NOB acclimatization in short-term operation. The findings expanded knowledge about NOB acclimatization types and provided novel insights for addressing this problem in a targeted way.

New insights into co-treatment of mature landfill leachate with municipal sewage via integrated partial nitrification, Anammox and denitratation

As a low consumption and high efficiency process, Partial Nitrification-Anammox/denitratation (PNAD) was applied to co-treat mature landfill leachate with municipal sewage for 300 days. Specifically, ammonia (670.2 ± 63.7 mg N/L) contained in mature landfill leachate was firstly oxidized to nitrite (611.5 ± 28.1 mg N/L) in sequence batch reactor (SBR_PN); meanwhile, organic matter in municipal sewage was partially removed in another reactor (SBR_OMR); finally, nitrite produced (611.5 ± 28.1 mg N/L) in SBR_PN and ammonia (53.1 ± 6.4 mg N/L) residing in pretreated municipal sewage were simultaneously degraded through combined Anammox-denitratation process in an up-flow anaerobic sludge bed (UASB_AD). A satisfactory effluent quality of 10.3 mg/L TN was obtained after long-term operation, with Anammox and denitrification contributing to 86.2% and 5.8% nitrogen removal efficiency, respectively. Mass balance confirmed 67.2% nitrate generated from Anammox could be reduced to nitrite and in-situ reused. Anammox bacteria genes and nitrate reductase/nitrite reductase ratio were highly detected, accelerating combined Anammox-denitratation. Further, Ca. Brocadia triumph among various Anammox bacteria groups, increasing from 1.2% (day 120) to 3.6% (day 280).

Enhancing nitrogen removal from anaerobically-digested swine wastewater through integration of Myriophyllum aquaticum and free nitrous acid-based technology in a constructed wetland

Despite of low operation costs and convenient maintenance, the application of natural systems for swine wastewater treatment has been limited by large construction area and unsatisfactory effluent quality. Introducing ammonium high uptake aquatic plants and shifting nitrogen removal pathway from nitrate to nitrite in constructed wetlands (CWs) has been regarded as promising approach to promote their performances. This study aimed to establish nitrite pathway and enhance N removal via free nitrous acid (FNA)-sediment treatment and Myriophyllum aquaticum vegetation in the CWs treating anaerobically digested swine wastewater. Nitrite pathway was successfully and stably achieved in the M. aquaticum CW with FNA-treated sediment. The overall removal efficiencies of ammonium nitrogen and total nitrogen were 42.3 ± 10.2% and 37.7 ± 9.3% in the planted CWs with FNA-treated sediment, which were 76.3% and 65.4% higher than those in the conventional oxidation pond system, respectively. Microbial community analysis (qPCR and metagenomics) suggested that the nitrite pathway established through FNA-sediment treatment was based on the inactivation of nitrite oxidizing bacteria (lower nxrA gene abundance) and the reduction of relative abundances of NOB (especially Nitrobacter and Nitrospira). During the denitrification processes, the integration of M. aquaticum vegetation with FNA-sediment treatment can lower the nitrate reduction by decreasing narG gene abundances and decreasing the relative abundances of napA affiliated bacteria (especially Bradyrhizobium), while strengthening reduction of nitrite and nitrous oxide by increasing nirK and nosZ gene abundances and enriching the corresponding affiliated microbial taxa, Mycobacterium and Bacillus, respectively. Our findings suggest that applying FNA-based technology in CW systems is technically and economically feasible, which holds promise for upgrading current CW systems treating swine wastewater to meet future water quality requirements.

A review of partial nitrification in biological nitrogen removal processes: from development to application

To further reduce the energy consumption in the wastewater biological nitrogen removal process, partial nitrification and its integrated processes have attracted increasing attentions owing to their economy and efficiency. Shortening the steps of ammonia oxidation to nitrate saves a large amount of aeration, and the accumulated nitrite could be reduced by denitritation or anammox, which requires less electron donors compared with denitrification. Therefore, the strategies through mainstream suppression and sidestream inhibition for the achievement of partial nitrification in recent years are reviewed. Specifically, the enrichment strategies of functional microorganisms are obtained on the basis of their growth and metabolic characteristics under different selective pressures. Furthermore, the promising developments, current application bottlenecks and possible future trends of some biological nitrogen removal processes integrating partial nitrification are discussed. The obtained knowledge would provide a new idea for the fast realization of economic, efficient and long-term stable partial nitrification and biological nitrogen removal process.

Improvement of nitrogen removal with iron scraps in floating treatment wetlands

Floating treatment wetland (FTW) in restoration of low C/N ratio wastewater was deemed to a frequently used method. However, the nitrate removal performance in floating beds was limited due to insufficient organic carbon sources. Iron scraps as a potential electron donor was beneficial to the NO₃^--N reduction. To research the removal performance and mechanism of denitrification in FTW with iron scraps, FTW with Iris pseudacorus was built, and iron scraps were added as an electron donor to improve nitrogen removal efficiency. The batch experimental results demonstrated that the proper mass ratio of iron scraps to NO₃^--N was 500:1. With iron scraps, the NO₃^--N removal efficiency of FTW and control system increased significantly to 98.04% and 44.42% respectively in 2 weeks, while there was no obvious influence on the removal of NH₄⁺-N. After adding iron scraps, the proportion of bacteria in the systems related to iron cycle and the relative abundance of nitrifying and denitrifying bacteria have increased obviously. By calculating the nitrogen balance, nitrogen reduction via plant uptake accounted for 8.79%, and the microbial denitrification was the main nitrogen removal pathway in FTW.

Robust Nitritation of Anaerobic Digester Centrate Using Dual Stressors and Timed Alkali Additions

Nitrogen is commonly removed from wastewater by nitrification to nitrate followed by nitrate reduction to N₂. Shortcut N removal saves energy by limiting ammonia oxidation to nitrite, but nitrite accumulation can be unstable. We hypothesized that repeated short-term exposures of ammonia-oxidizing communities to free ammonia (FA) and free nitrous acid (FNA) would stabilize nitritation by selecting against nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB). Accordingly, we evaluated ammonium oxidation of anaerobic digester centrate in two bench-scale sequencing batch reactors (SBRs), seeded with the same inoculum and operated identically but with differing pH-control strategies. A single stressor SBR (SS/SBR) using pH set-point control produced HNO₃, while a dual stressor SBR (DS/SBR) using timed alkalinity addition (TAA) produced HNO₂ (ammonium removal efficiency of 97 ± 2%; nitrite accumulation ratio of 98 ± 1%). The TAA protocol was developed during an adaptation period with continuous pH monitoring. After adaptation, automated TAA enabled stable nitritation without set-point control. In the SS/SBR, repeatedly exposing the community to FA (8-10 h/exposure, one exposure/cycle) selected for FA-tolerant ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (Nitrosomonas sp. NM107) and NOB (Nitrobacter sp.). In the DS/SBR, repeatedly exposing the community to FA (2-4 h/exposure, three exposures/cycle) and FNA (4-6 h/exposure, two exposures/cycle) selected for FA- and FNA-resistant AOB (Nitrosomonas IWT514) and against NOB, stabilizing nitritation.

Robust Nitritation Sustained by Acid-Tolerant Ammonia-Oxidizing Bacteria

Oxidation of ammonium to nitrite rather than nitrate, i.e., nitritation, is critical for autotrophic nitrogen removal. This study demonstrates a robust nitritation process in treating low-strength wastewater, obtained from a mixture of real mainstream sewage with sidestream anaerobic digestion liquor. This is achieved through cultivating acid-tolerant ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) in a laboratory nitrifying bioreactor at pH 4.5-5.0. It was shown that nitrite accumulation with a high NO₂^-/(NO₂^- + NO₃^-) ratio of 95 ± 5% was stably maintained for more than 300 days, and the obtained volumetric NH₄⁺ removal rate (i.e., 188 ± 14 mg N L^-1 d^-1) was practically useful. 16S rRNA gene sequencing analyses indicated the dominance of new AOB, "Candidatus Nitrosoglobus," in the nitrifying guild (i.e., 1.90 ± 0.08% in the total community), with the disappearance of typical activated sludge nitrifying microorganisms, including Nitrosomonas, Nitrospira, and Nitrobacter. This is the first identification of Ca. Nitrosoglobus as key ammonia oxidizers in a wastewater treatment system. It was found that Ca. Nitrosoglobus can tolerate low pH (<5.0), and free nitrous acid (FNA) at levels that inhibit AOB and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) commonly found in wastewater treatment processes. The in situ inhibition of NOB leads to accumulation of nitrite (NO₂^-), which along with protons (H⁺) also produced in ammonium oxidation generates and sustains FNA at 3.0 ± 1.4 mg HNO₂-N L^-1. As such, robust PN was achieved under acidic conditions, with a complete absence of NOB. Compared to previous nitritation systems, this acidic nitritation process is featured by a higher nitric oxide (NO) but a lower nitrous oxide (N₂O) emission level, with the emission factors estimated at 1.57 ± 0.08 and 0.57 ± 0.03%, respectively, of influent ammonium nitrogen load.

An integrated mainstream and sidestream strategy for overcoming nitrite oxidizing bacteria adaptation in a continuous plug-flow nutrient removal process

An integrated mainstream aeration and sidestream sludge treatment was demonstrated to be effective in overcoming the adaptationof nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) in an anoxic/oxic process. Results showed that by employing the alternating free nitrous acid and free ammonia (FNA/FA) sidestream sludge treatment alone, nitritation was established but varied, which was addressed by integrating alternating aeration with step feeding (ALASF) in reactor. Two critical considerations contributed to stable effluent nitrite accumulation (>83.8 %)and nitrogen removal (>83.0 %): 1) aerobic sludge rather than return sludge should be taken for FNA/FA treatment to avoid anoxic starvation which facilitated NOB recovery; 2) ALASF ensured timely denitritation and created constant anoxic disturbance for NOB inhibition. Nitrospira and Nitrobacter after 540-day operation were 0.38 % of seed sludge.A20 % reduction of operating cost was obtained in this nitritation process. This study moved nitritation one step closer to application in continuous plug-flow process from municipal wastewater.

Critical Factors Facilitating Candidatus Nitrotoga To Be Prevalent Nitrite-Oxidizing Bacteria in Activated Sludge

Nitrite oxidation is the primary pathway that generates nitrate in engineered systems. However, little is known about the role of a novel nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) genus Candidatus Nitrotoga in activated sludge systems. To elucidate key factors that impact NOB community composition, laboratory-scale sequencing batch reactors (SBRs) were designed and operated under the same conditions as real wastewater treatment plants to achieve considerable nitrogen removal and similar community; then, different conditions including temperature (T), dissolved oxygen (DO), free nitrous acid (FNA), and free ammonia (FA) were applied. The 16S rRNA gene-based PCR and sequence analysis illustrated that Ca. Nitrotoga were abundant even at ambient temperature, thus further challenging the previous conception of them being solely cold-adapted. Ca. Nitrotoga are less competitive than Nitrospira during oxygen deficiency, indicating its lower affinity to dissolved oxygen. Ca. Nitrotoga are the dominant nitrite oxidizers under regular exposure to FNA and FA due to their relatively higher resistance than other NOB toward these two effective biocides. Therefore, this study demonstrates that Ca. Nitrotoga can play an important role in biological nitrogen removal and also highlights the need for multiple strategies for NOB suppression for the next-generation, shortcut nitrogen removal.

Low-dose Ultraviolet-A irradiation selectively eliminates nitrite oxidizing bacteria for mainstream nitritation

Nitritation is currently known as a bottleneck for mainstream nitrite shunt or partial nitritation/anammox (PN/A). Here we propose a new approach to selectively eliminate nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) for mainstream nitritation by low-dose ultraviolet-A (UVA) irradiation. The results showed that mainstream nitritation was rapidly achieved within 10 days with UVA irradiation at the dose of 0.87 μE L^-1 s^-1, and nitrite accumulation ratio (NO₂^--N/(NO₂^--N + NO₃^--N) ×100%) stabilized over 80%. Microbial community analysis revealed that two typical NOB populations (Nitrospira and Ca. Nitrotoga) detected in the control reactor were suppressed efficiently in UVA irradiation reactor, whereas the Nitrosomonas genus of ammonium oxidizing bacteria (AOB) remained at similar level. Intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) analysis indicated that NOB-dominant sludge tends to generate more intracellular ROS compared with AOB-dominant sludge in the presence of UVA, leading to the inactivation and elimination of NOB. Additionally, amounts of microalgae found in UVA irradiation reactor could help to suppress NOB by generating ROS during photosynthesis. Briefly, the UVA irradiation approach proposed in this study was shown to be promising in NOB suppression for reliable mainstream nitritation.

Adaptation of nitrifying community in activated sludge to free ammonia inhibition and inactivation

Sludge treatment using free ammonia (FA) is an innovative approach that was recently reported effective achieving stable mainstream nitrogen removal via the nitrite pathway. This study aims to investigate the adaptation of nitrifying community and the response of nitrification performance to high-level of FA exposure under real wastewater conditions. Two parallel lab-scale sequencing batch reactors were operated and fed with real municipal wastewater, with one receiving sludge treatment by FA and another as a control. While the FA approach rapidly achieved partial nitrification with a nitrite accumulation ratio (NAR) of approximately 60%, the partial nitrification eventually failed due to nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) adaptation to FA inactivation. NOB activity in the inoculum was suppressed by 82% after exposure to FA at ~220 mg NH₃-N/L. However, towards the end of the experiments, significantly higher NOB activities were observed after exposure to the same level of FA. Distinct behaviours of NOB observed in batch tests during the study supported the reactor operational data and strongly suggested the adaptation of NOB under the FA stress. Furthermore, microbial community analysis revealed the underlying mechanism of the observed adaptation: the dominant NOB changed from Nitrospira to Candidatus Nitrotoga. It is for the first time shown that Ca. Nitrotoga are highly resistant to FA inhibition and inactivation in comparison to Nitrospira and Nitrobacter. In addition, while the Nitrosomonas genus was always the dominant ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) throughout the study, different shift in a species level was observed.