Effects of H3PO4 modified biochar on heavy metal mobility and resistance genes removal during swine manure composting

New challenge: Mitigation and control of antibiotic resistant genes in aquatic environments by biochar

With an increase of diverse contaminants in the environment, particularly antibiotics, the maintenance and propagation of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) are promoted by co-selection mechanisms. ARGs are difficult to degrade, cause long-lasting pollution, and are widely transmitted in aquatic environments. Biochar is frequently used to remove various pollutants during environmental remediation. Thus, this review provides a thorough analysis of the current state of ARGs in the aquatic environment as well as their removal by using biochar. This article summarizes the research and application of biochar and modified biochar to remove ARGs in aquatic environments, in order to refine the following contents: 1) fill gaps in the research on the various ARG behaviors mediated by biochar and some influence factors, 2) further investigate the mechanisms involved in effects of biochar on extracellular ARGs (eARGs) and intracellular ARGs (iARGs) in aquatic environments, including direct and the indirect effects, 3) describe the propagation process and resistance mechanisms of ARGs, 4) propose the challenges and prospects of feasibility of application and subsequent treatment in actual aquatic environment. Here we highlight the most recent research on the use of biochar to remove ARGs from aquatic environments and suggest future directions for optimization, as well as current perspectives to guide future studies on the removal of ARGs from aquatic environments.

A comprehensive review on agricultural waste utilization through sustainable conversion techniques, with a focus on the additives effect on the fate of phosphorus and toxic elements during composting process

The increasing trend of using agricultural wastes follows the concept of "waste to wealth" and is closely related to the themes of sustainable development goals (SDGs). Carbon-neutral technologies for waste management have not been critically reviewed yet. This paper reviews the technological trend of agricultural waste utilization, including composting, thermal conversion, and anaerobic digestion. Specifically, the effects of exogenous additives on the contents, fractionation, and fate of phosphorus (P) and potentially toxic elements (PTEs) during the composting process have been comprehensively reviewed in this article. The composting process can transform biomass-P and additive-born P into plant available forms. PTEs can be passivated during the composting process. Biochar can accelerate the passivation of PTEs in the composting process through different physiochemical interactions such as surface adsorption, precipitation, and cation exchange reactions. The addition of exogenous calcium, magnesium and phosphate in the compost can reduce the mobility of PTEs such as copper, cadmium, and zinc. Based on critical analysis, this paper recommends an eco-innovative perspective for the improvement and practical application of composting technology for the utilization of agricultural biowastes to meet the circular economy approach and achieve the SDGs.

Effect of aqueous phase from hydrothermal carbonization of sewage sludge on heavy metals and heavy metal resistance genes during chicken manure composting

Livestock manure is often contaminated with heavy metals (HMs) and HM resistance genes (HMRGs), which pollute the environment. In this study, we aimed to investigate the effects of the aqueous phase (AP) produced by hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) of sewage sludge (SS) alone and the AP produced by co-HTC of rice husk (RH) and SS (RH-SS) on humification, HM bioavailability, and HMRGs during chicken manure composting. RH-SS and SS increased the humic acid content of the compost products by 18.3 % and 9.7 %, respectively, and significantly increased the humification index (P < 0.05) compared to the CK (addition of tap water). The passivation of HMs (Zn, Cu, As, Pb, and Cr) increased by 12.17-23.36 % and 9.74-15.95 % for RH-SS and SS, respectively, compared with that for CK. RH-SS and SS reduced the HMRG abundance in composted products by 22.29 % and 15.07 %, respectively. The partial least squares path modeling results showed that SS and RH-SS promoted compost humification while simultaneously altering the bacterial community and reducing the bioavailability of metals and host abundance of HMRGs, which has a direct inhibitory effect on the production and distribution of HMRGs. These findings support a new strategy to reduce the environmental risk of HMs and HMRGs in livestock manure utilization.

Deciphering and predicting changes in antibiotic resistance genes during pig manure aerobic composting via machine learning model

Livestock manure is one of the most important pools of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in the environment. Aerobic composting can effectively reduce the spread of antibiotic resistance risk in livestock manure. Understanding the effect of aerobic composting process parameters on manure-sourced ARGs is important to control their spreading risk. In this study, the effects of process parameters on ARGs during aerobic composting of pig manure were explored through data mining based on 191 valid data collected from literature. Machine learning (ML) models (XGBoost and Random Forest) were utilized to predict the rate of ARGs changes during pig manure composting. The model evaluation index of the XGBoost model (R2 = 0.651) was higher than that of the Random Forest (R2 = 0.490), indicating that XGBoost had better prediction performance. Feature importance was further calculated for the XGBoost model, and the XGBoost black box model was interpreted by Shapley additive explanations analysis. Results indicated that the influencing factors on the ARGs variation in pig manure were sequentially divided into thermophilic period, total composting period, composting real time, and thermophilic stage average temperature. The findings gave an insight into the application of ML models to predict and decipher the ARG changes during manure composting and provided suggestions for better composting manipulation and optimization of process parameters.

Potential of combined reactor and static composting applications for the removal of heavy metals and antibiotic resistance genes from chicken manure

Chicken manure (CM) can pose a serious threat to environmental and human health, and need to be managed properly. The compost can effectively treat CM. However, there is limited research on the heavy metals and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) during compost CM. In this study, the combined application of reactor and static composting (RSC) was used to produce organic fertilizer of CM (OCM), and heavy metals, ARGs and bacterial community structure was investigated. The results show that RSC could be used to produce OCM, and OCM meet the National organic fertilizer standard (NY/T525-2021). Compared to the initial CM, DTPA-Cu, DTPA-Zn, DTPA-Pb, DTPA-Cr, DTPA-Ni and DTPA-As in OCM decreased by 40.83%, 23.73%, 34.27%, 38.62%, 16.26%, and 43.35%, respectively. RSC decreased the relative abundance of ARGs in CM by 84.06%, while the relative abundance of sul1 and ermC increased. In addition, the relative abundance and diversity of ARGs were mainly influenced by the bacterial community, with Actinobacteria, Firmicutes, and Proteobacteria becoming the dominant phyla during composting, and probably being the main carriers and dispersers of most of the ARGs. Network analyses confirmed that Gracilibacillus, Lactobacillus, Nocardiopsis, Mesorhizobium and Salinicoccus were the main potential hosts of ARGs, with the main potential hosts of sul1 and ermC being Mesorhizobium and Salinicoccus. The passivation and physicochemical properties of heavy metals contribute to the removal of ARGs, with sul1 and ermC being affected by the toal heavy metals. Application of RSC allows CM to produce mature, safe organic fertilizer after 32 d and reduces the risk of rebound from ARGs, but the issues of sul1 and ermC gene removal cannot be ignored.

Effect of biochar on the fate of antibiotic resistant genes and integrons in compost amended agricultural soil

The persistence and transmission of emerging pollutants such as antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) via mobile genetic elements (MGEs) have caused concern to scientific community. Composting practises are often adapted for the reduction of organic waste or to enhance fertility in agriculture soil but its continuous usage has posed a potential risk of increased abundance of ARGs in soil. Thus, the present study scrutinises the emerging risk of ARGs and MGEs in agriculture soil and its potential mitigation using biochar owing to its proven environmental sustainability and performance. After 30 days incubation, ARG distribution of SulI, SulII, dfrA1, dfrA12, tetA, flor, and ErmA was 50, 37.5, 37.5, 62.5, 42.11, 62.5, and 52.63% in control samples whereas it was 5, 15.78, 21.05, 15.79, 10.53, 21.05, and 31.58%, respectively, for biochar amended samples. Similarly, IntI1 and IntI2 in control and biochar amended samples were 18.75 and 6.25% and 10.53 and 5.26%, respectively. Principal component analysis (PCA) factor suggests that biochar amendment samples showed enhanced value for pH, organic matter, and organic carbon over control samples. Furthermore, Pearson's correlation analysis performed between detected ARGs and MGEs demonstrated the positive and significant correlation at p < 0.05 for both control and biochar amended samples.

Tracing the transfer characteristics of antibiotic resistance genes from swine manure to biogas residue and then to soil

Based on laboratory simulation experiments and metagenomic analysis, this study tracked the transmission of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) from swine manure (SM) to biogas residue and then to soil (biogas residue as organic fertilizer (OF) application). ARGs were abundant in SM and they were assigned to 11 categories of antibiotics. Among the 383 ARG subtypes in SM, 43 % ARG subtypes were absent after anaerobic digestion (AD), which avoided the transfer of these ARGs from SM to soil. Furthermore, 9 % of the ARG subtypes in SM were introduced into soil after amendment with OF. Moreover, 43 % of the ARG subtypes in SM were present in OF and soil, and their abundances increased slightly in the soil amended with OF. The bacterial community in the soil treated with OF was restored to its original state within 60 to 90 days, probably because the abundances of ARGs were elevated but not significantly in the soil. Network analysis identified 31 potential co-host bacteria of ARGs based on the relationships between the bacteria community members, where they mainly belonged to Firmicutes, followed by Bacteroidetes, Actinobacteria, and Proteobacteria. This study provides a basis for objectively evaluating pollution by ARGs in livestock manure for agricultural use.

Reduction of mobile genetic elements determines the removal of antibiotic resistance genes during pig manure composting after thermal pretreatment

Animal manure is a primary repository of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) and mobile genetic elements (MGEs). This work explored the efficiency of ARGs and MGEs removal during pig manure composting after thermal pretreatment (TPC) and the underlying mechanisms. TPC resulted in a decrease of 94.7% and 92.3% in the relative abundance of ARGs and MGEs which was 48.9% and 76.6% lower than control, respectively. Network analysis indicated that reductions of ARGs and MGEs in TPC were relevant to decrease in the amount and abundance of bacterial hosts. Furthermore, total ARGs abundance in TPC was correlated with that of intI1 and Tn916/1545 (P < 0.001). Redundancy analysis supported a leading role of MGEs in ARGs dynamics in TPC. Reduction of MGEs rather than bacterial hosts contributed mainly to ARGs removal in TPC, as revealed by structural equation modeling. In conclusion, TPC was an effective method to treat animal manure containing ARGs.

Insights into the reduction of antibiotic-resistant bacteria and mobile antibiotic resistance genes by black soldier fly larvae in chicken manure

The increasing prevalence of antibiotic-resistant bacteria (ARB) from animal manure has raised concerns about the potential threats to public health. The bioconversion of animal manure with insect larvae, such as the black soldier fly larvae (BSFL, Hermetia illucens [L.]), is a promising technology for quickly attenuating ARB while also recycling waste. In this study, we investigated BSFL conversion systems for chicken manure. Using metagenomic analysis, we tracked ARB and evaluated the resistome dissemination risk by investigating the co-occurrence of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), mobile genetic elements (MGEs), and bacterial taxa in a genetic context. Our results indicated that BSFL treatment effectively mitigated the relative abundance of ARB, ARGs, and MGEs by 34.9%, 53.3%, and 37.9%, respectively, within 28 days. Notably, the transferable ARGs decreased by 30.9%, indicating that BSFL treatment could mitigate the likelihood of ARG horizontal transfer and thus reduce the risk of ARB occurrence. In addition, the significantly positive correlation links between antimicrobial concentration and relative abundance of ARB reduced by 44.4%. Moreover, using variance partition analysis (VPA), we identified other bacteria as the most important factor influencing ARB, explaining 20.6% of the ARB patterns. Further analysis suggested that antagonism of other bacteria on ARB increased by 1.4 times, while nutrient competition on both total nitrogen and crude fat increased by 2.8 times. Overall, these findings provide insight into the mechanistic understanding of ARB reduction during BSFL treatment of chicken manure and provide a strategy for rapidly mitigating ARB in animal manure.

Effects of magnesium-modified biochar on antibiotic resistance genes and microbial communities in chicken manure composting

Abatement of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in livestock manure by composting has attracted attention. This study investigated the effect of adding magnesium-modified biochar (MBC) on ARGs and microbial communities in chicken manure composting. Twelve genes for tetracyclines, sulfonamides, and macrolides, and mobile genetic elements were measured in the compost pile. The results showed that after 45 days of the composting, the treatment groups of MBC had longer high temperature periods, significantly higher germination indices (GI) and lower phytotoxicity. There were four major dominant phyla (Firmicutes, Actinobacteriota, Proteobacteria, and Bacteroidota) in the compost. The abundance of Firmicutes decreased significantly during the compost cooling period; tetracycline resistance genes demonstrated an extremely significant positive correlation with Firmicutes, showing a trend of the same increase and decrease with composting time; tetT, tetO, tetM, tetW, ermB, and intI2 were reduced in the MBC group; the total abundance of resistance genes in the 2% MBC addition group was 0.67 times that of the control; Proteobacteria and Chloroflexi were also significantly lower than the other treatment groups. Most ARGs were significantly associated with mobile genetic elements (MGEs); MBC can reduce the spread and diffusion of ARGs by reducing the abundance of MGEs and inhibiting horizontal gene transfer (HGT).

Mitigation of antibiotic resistome in swine manure by black soldier fly larval conversion combined with composting

The increasing prevalence of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in animal manure has attracted considerable attention because of their potential contribution to the development of multidrug resistance worldwide. Insect technology may be a promising alternative for the rapid attenuation of ARGs in manure; however, the underlying mechanism remains unclear. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of black soldier fly (BSF, Hermetia illucens [L.]) larvae conversion combined with composting on ARGs dynamics in swine manure and to uncover the mechanisms through metagenomic analysis. Compared to natural composting (i.e. without BSF), BSFL conversion combined with composting reduced the absolute abundance of ARGs by 93.2 % within 28 days. The rapid degradation of antibiotics and nutrient reformulation during BSFL conversion combined with composting indirectly altered manure bacterial communities, resulting in a lower abundance and richness of ARGs. The number of main antibiotic-resistant bacteria (e.g., Prevotella, Ruminococcus) decreased by 74.9 %, while their potential antagonistic bacteria (e.g., Bacillus, Pseudomonas) increased by 128.7 %. The number of antibiotic-resistant pathogenic bacteria (e.g., Selenomonas, Paenalcaligenes) decreased by 88.3 %, and the average number of ARGs carried by each human pathogenic bacterial genus declined by 55.8 %. BSF larvae gut microbiota (e.g., Clostridium butyricum, C. bornimense) could help reduce the risk of multidrug-resistant pathogens. These results provide insight into a novel approach to mitigate multidrug resistance from the animal industry in the environment by using insect technology combined with composting, in particular in light of the global "One Health" requirements.

Bioremediation system consisted with Leclercia adecarboxylata and nZVI@Carbon/Phosphate for lead immobilization: The passivation mechanisms of chemical reaction and biological metabolism in soil

Bioremediation is one of the most promising strategies for heavy metal immobilization. A new remediation system was demonstrated in this research, which combined phosphate solubilizing bacteria (PSB) with nZVI@Carbon/Phosphate (nZVI@C/P) composite to remediate lead contaminated soil. Experimental results indicated that the new system (nZVI@C/P + PSB) could effectively convert the labile Pb into the stable fraction after 30 days of incubation, which increased the maximum residual fraction percentage of Pb by 70.58%. The characterization results showed that lead may exist in the forms of Pb₅(PO₄)₃Cl, PbSO₄ and 3PbCO₃·2Pb(OH)₂·H₂O in the soil treated with nZVI@C/P + PSB. Meanwhile, soil enzyme activities and Leclercia abundance were enhanced in the treated soil compared with CK during the incubation time. In addition, the specialized functions (e.g. ABC transporters, siderophore metabolism, sulfur metabolism and phosphorus metabolism) in PSB and nZVI@C/P + PSB group were also enhanced. These phenomena proved that the key soil metabolic functions may be maintained and enhanced through the synergistic effect of incubated PSB and nZVI@C/P. The study demonstrated that this new bioremediation system provided feasible way to improve the efficacy for lead contaminated soil remediation.

Effect of biochar addition on copper and zinc passivation pathways mediated by humification and microbial community evolution during pig manure composting

The mobility and bioavailability of Cu and Zn are the main threats associated with the land application of pig manure (PM) compost products. This study investigated the impacts of biochar (BC) concentration on passivation of Cu and Zn associated with the compost maturity. The results indicated that 15% and 10% BC favoured the passivation of Cu and Zn, respectively. BC promoted passivation of Cu by accelerating HA production and optimized the abundance of Firmicutes. BC promoted the passivation of Zn by increasing the high temperature peak and the corresponding pH (8-8.5). A higher level (15% and 20%) of BC altered the dominant bacterial phylum from Firmicutes to Proteobacteria. 20% BC inhibited the passivation of Cu and Zn by reducing the highest temperature and lowering the alkalinity of substrate. These results offer new insights into understanding how the addition of BC could reduce the risk of hazardous products during PM composting.

Improving suppressive activity of compost on phytopathogenic microbes by inoculation of antagonistic microorganisms for secondary fermentation

Antimicrobial activity contributes to plant disease control property of composts but its source is still not clear. From composting cow manure during secondary fermentation, 50 microbial strains with antifungal activity were isolated and identified. Two bacterial strains Bacillus mojavensis B282 and Pseudomonas aeruginosa F288, antagonistic against both phytopathogenic fungi and bacteria, were respectively used as the inoculum of compost for secondary fermentation. Inoculation of B282 or F288 significantly shifted microbial community structure of compost and genera functionally linked to antagonistic activity and plant growth promotion were enriched. Notably, culturable cells of B282 increased by about 40 times during secondary fermentation. The inoculation of each strain significantly increased antifungal activity of compost extracts and enhanced disease suppressive effects of compost on wheat root rot. This study demonstrates that inoculation of compost-indigenous microorganisms could improve antimicrobial activity of compost and provides a low-cost strategy for producing bio-organic fertilizers with biocontrol function.

The effects of biochar on antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) removal during different environmental governance processes: A review

Antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) pollution has been considered as one of the most significant emerging environmental and health challenges in the 21st century, many efforts have been paid to control the proliferation and dissemination of ARGs in the environment. Among them, the biochar performs a positive effect in reducing the abundance of ARGs during different environmental governance processes and has shown great application prospects in controlling the ARGs. Although there are increasing studies on employing biochar to control ARGs, there is still a lack of review paper on this hotspot. In this review, firstly, the applications of biochar to control ARGs in different environmental governance processes were summarized. Secondly, the processes and mechanisms of ARGs removal promoted by biochar were proposed and discussed. Then, the effects of biochar properties on ARGs removal were highlighted. Finally, the future prospects and challenges of using biochar to control ARGs were proposed. It is hoped that this review could provide some new guidance for the further research of this field.

A review of pristine and modified biochar immobilizing typical heavy metals in soil: Applications and challenges

In recent years, the application of biochar in the remediation of heavy metals (HMs) contaminated soil has received tremendous attention globally. We reviewed the latest research on the immobilization of soil HMs by biochar almost in the last 5 years (until 2021). The methods, effects and mechanisms of biochar and modified biochar on the immobilization of typical HMs in soil have been systematically summarized. In general, the HMs contaminating the soil can be categorized into two groups, the oxy-anionic HMs (As and Cr) and the cationic HMs (Pb, Cd, etc.). Reduction and precipitation of oxy-anionic HMs by biochar/modified biochar are the dominant mechanism for reducing HMs toxicity. Pristine biochar can effectively immobilize cationic HMs. The commonly applied modification method is to add substances that can precipitate HMs to the biochar. In addition, we assessed the risks of biochar applications. For instance, biochar may cause the leaching of certain HMs; biochar aging; co-transportation of biochar nanoparticles with HMs. Future work should focus on the artificial/intelligent design of biochar to make it suitable for remediation of multiple HMs contaminated soil.