On the application of optical forward-scattering to bacterial identification in an automated clinical analysis perspective

Bacterial Colony Phenotyping with Hyperspectral Elastic Light Scattering Patterns

The elastic light-scatter (ELS) technique, which detects and discriminates microbial organisms based on the light-scatter pattern of their colonies, has demonstrated excellent classification accuracy in pathogen screening tasks. The implementation of the multispectral approach has brought further advantages and motivated the design and validation of a hyperspectral elastic light-scatter phenotyping instrument (HESPI). The newly developed instrument consists of a supercontinuum (SC) laser and an acousto-optic tunable filter (AOTF). The use of these two components provided a broad spectrum of excitation light and a rapid selection of the wavelength of interest, which enables the collection of multiple spectral patterns for each colony instead of relying on single band analysis. The performance was validated by classifying microflora of green-leafed vegetables using the hyperspectral ELS patterns of the bacterial colonies. The accuracy ranged from 88.7% to 93.2% when the classification was performed with the scattering pattern created at a wavelength within the 473-709 nm region. When all of the hyperspectral ELS patterns were used, owing to the vastly increased size of the data, feature reduction and selection algorithms were utilized to enhance the robustness and ultimately lessen the complexity of the data collection. A new classification model with the feature reduction process improved the overall classification rate to 95.9%.

Petri-plate, bacteria, and laser optical scattering sensor

Classical microbiology has paved the path forward for the development of modern biotechnology and microbial biosensing platforms. Microbial culturing and isolation using the Petri plate revolutionized the field of microbiology. In 1887, Julius Richard Petri invented possibly the most important tool in microbiology, the Petri plate, which continues to have a profound impact not only on reliably isolating, identifying, and studying microorganisms but also manipulating a microbe to study gene expression, virulence properties, antibiotic resistance, and production of drugs, enzymes, and foods. Before the recent advances in gene sequencing, microbial identification for diagnosis relied upon the hierarchal testing of a pure culture isolate. Direct detection and identification of isolated bacterial colonies on a Petri plate with a sensing device has the potential for revolutionizing further development in microbiology including gene sequencing, pathogenicity study, antibiotic susceptibility testing , and for characterizing industrially beneficial traits. An optical scattering sensor designated BARDOT (bacterial rapid detection using optical scattering technology) that uses a red-diode laser, developed at the beginning of the 21^st century at Purdue University, some 220 years after the Petri-plate discovery can identify and study bacteria directly on the plate as a diagnostic tool akin to Raman scattering and hyperspectral imaging systems for application in clinical and food microbiology laboratories.

Spatio-temporal based deep learning for rapid detection and identification of bacterial colonies through lens-free microscopy time-lapses

Detection and identification of pathogenic bacteria isolated from biological samples (blood, urine, sputum, etc.) are crucial steps in accelerated clinical diagnosis. However, accurate and rapid identification remain difficult to achieve due to the challenge of having to analyse complex and large samples. Current solutions (mass spectrometry, automated biochemical testing, etc.) propose a trade-off between time and accuracy, achieving satisfactory results at the expense of time-consuming processes, which can also be intrusive, destructive and costly. Moreover, those techniques tend to require an overnight subculture on solid agar medium delaying bacteria identification by 12-48 hours, thus preventing rapid prescription of appropriate treatment as it hinders antibiotic susceptibility testing. In this study, lens-free imaging is presented as a possible solution to achieve a quick and accurate wide range, non-destructive, label-free pathogenic bacteria detection and identification in real-time using micro colonies (10-500 μm) kinetic growth pattern combined with a two-stage deep learning architecture. Bacterial colonies growth time-lapses were acquired thanks to a live-cell lens-free imaging system and a thin-layer agar media made of 20 μl BHI (Brain Heart Infusion) to train our deep learning networks. Our architecture proposal achieved interesting results on a dataset constituted of seven different pathogenic bacteria-Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), Enterococcus faecium (E. faecium), Enterococcus faecalis (E. faecalis), Staphylococcus epidermidis (S. epidermidis), Streptococcus pneumoniae R6 (S. pneumoniae), Streptococcus pyogenes (S. pyogenes), Lactococcus Lactis (L. Lactis). At T = 8h, our detection network reached an average 96.0% detection rate while our classification network precision and sensitivity averaged around 93.1% and 94.0% respectively, both were tested on 1908 colonies. Our classification network even obtained a perfect score for E. faecalis (60 colonies) and very high score for S. epidermidis at 99.7% (647 colonies). Our method achieved those results thanks to a novel technique coupling convolutional and recurrent neural networks together to extract spatio-temporal patterns from unreconstructed lens-free microscopy time-lapses.

Development of a Smartphone-Integrated Reflective Scatterometer for Bacterial Identification

We present a smartphone-based bacterial colony phenotyping instrument using a reflective elastic light scattering (ELS) pattern and the resolving power of the new instrument. The reflectance-type device can acquire ELS patterns of colonies on highly opaque media as well as optically dense colonies. The novel instrument was built using a smartphone interface and a 532 nm diode laser, and these essential optical components made it a cost-effective and portable device. When a coherent and collimated light source illuminated a bacterial colony, a reflective ELS pattern was created on the screen and captured by the smartphone camera. The collected patterns whose shapes were determined by the colony morphology were then processed and analyzed to extract distinctive features for bacterial identification. For validation purposes, the reflective ELS patterns of five bacteria grown on opaque growth media were measured with the proposed instrument and utilized for the classification. Cross-validation was performed to evaluate the classification, and the result showed an accuracy above 94% for differentiating colonies of E. coli, K. pneumoniae, L. innocua, S. enteritidis, and S. aureus.

Rapid Bacterial Detection in Urine Using Laser Scattering and Deep Learning Analysis

Images of laser scattering patterns generated by bacteria in urine are promising resources for deep learning. However, floating bacteria in urine produce dynamic scattering patterns and require deep learning of spatial and temporal features. We hypothesized that bacteria with variable bacterial densities and different Gram staining reactions would generate different speckle images. After deep learning of speckle patterns generated by various densities of bacteria in artificial urine, we validated the model in an independent set of clinical urine samples in a tertiary hospital. Even at a low bacterial density cutoff (1,000 CFU/mL), the model achieved a predictive accuracy of 90.9% for positive urine culture. At a cutoff of 50,000 CFU/mL, it showed a better accuracy of 98.5%. The model achieved satisfactory accuracy at both cutoff levels for predicting the Gram staining reaction. Considering only 30 min of analysis, our method appears as a new screening tool for predicting the presence of bacteria before urine culture. IMPORTANCE This study performed deep learning of multiple laser scattering patterns by the bacteria in urine to predict positive urine culture. Conventional urine analyzers have limited performance in identifying bacteria in urine. This novel method showed a satisfactory accuracy taking only 30 min of analysis without conventional urine culture. It was also developed to predict the Gram staining reaction of the bacteria. It can be used as a standalone screening tool for urinary tract infection.

Advancement in Salmonella Detection Methods: From Conventional to Electrochemical-Based Sensing Detection

Large-scale food-borne outbreaks caused by Salmonella are rarely seen nowadays, thanks to the advanced nature of the medical system. However, small, localised outbreaks in certain regions still exist and could possess a huge threat to the public health if eradication measure is not initiated. This review discusses the progress of Salmonella detection approaches covering their basic principles, characteristics, applications, and performances. Conventional Salmonella detection is usually performed using a culture-based method, which is time-consuming, labour intensive, and unsuitable for on-site testing and high-throughput analysis. To date, there are many detection methods with a unique detection system available for Salmonella detection utilising immunological-based techniques, molecular-based techniques, mass spectrometry, spectroscopy, optical phenotyping, and biosensor methods. The electrochemical biosensor has growing interest in Salmonella detection mainly due to its excellent sensitivity, rapidity, and portability. The use of a highly specific bioreceptor, such as aptamers, and the application of nanomaterials are contributing factors to these excellent characteristics. Furthermore, insight on the types of biorecognition elements, the principles of electrochemical transduction elements, and the miniaturisation potential of electrochemical biosensors are discussed.

Optical multi-channel interrogation instrument for bacterial colony characterization

A single instrument that includes multiple optical channels was developed to simultaneously measure various optical and associated biophysical characteristics of a bacterial colony. The multi-channel device can provide five distinct optical features without the need to transfer the sample to multiple locations or instruments. The available measurement channels are bright-field light microscopy, 3-D colony-morphology map, 2-D spatial optical-density distribution, spectral forward-scattering pattern, and spectral optical density. The series of multiple morphological interrogations is beneficial in understanding the bio-optical features of a bacterial colony and the correlations among them, resulting in an enhanced power of phenotypic bacterial discrimination. To enable a one-shot interrogation, a confocal laser scanning module was built as an add-on to an upright microscope. Three different-wavelength diode lasers were used for the spectral analysis, and high-speed pin photodiodes and CMOS sensors were utilized as detectors to measure the spectral OD and light-scatter pattern. The proposed instrument and algorithms were evaluated with four bacterial genera, Escherichia coli, Listeria innocua, Salmonella Typhimurium, and Staphylococcus aureus; their resulting data provided a more complete picture of the optical characterization of bacterial colonies.

Development of the Correction Algorithm to Limit the Deformation of Bacterial Colonies Diffraction Patterns Caused by Misalignment and Its Impact on the Bacteria Identification in the Proposed Optical Biosensor

Recently proposed methods of bacteria identification in optical biosensors based on the phenomenon of light diffraction on macro-colonies offer over 98% classification accuracy. However, such high accuracy relies on the comparable and repeatable spatial intensity distribution of diffraction patterns. Therefore, it is essential to eliminate all non-species/strain-dependent factors affecting the diffraction patterns. In this study, the impact of the bacterial colony and illuminating beam misalignment on the variation of classification features extracted from diffraction patterns was examined. It was demonstrated that misalignment introduced by the scanning module significantly affected diffraction patterns and extracted classification features used for bacteria identification. Therefore, it is a crucial system-dependent factor limiting the identification accuracy. The acceptable misalignment level, when the accuracy and quality of the classification features are not affected, was determined as no greater than 50 µm. Obtained results led to development of image-processing algorithms for determination of the direction of misalignment and concurrent alignment of the bacterial colonies’ diffraction patterns. The proposed algorithms enable the rigorous monitoring and controlling of the measurement’s conditions in order to preserve the high accuracy of bacteria identification.

Generalized spectral light scatter models of diverse bacterial colony morphologies

An optical forward-scatter model was generalized to encompass the diverse nature of bacterial colony morphologies and the spectral information. According to the model, the colony shape and the wavelength of incident light significantly affect the characteristics of a forward elastic-light-scattering pattern. To study the relationship between the colony morphology and the scattering pattern, three-dimensional colony models were generated in various morphologies. The propagation of light passing through the colony model was then simulated. In validation of the theoretical modeling, the scattering patterns of three bacterial genera, Staphylococcus, Exiguobacterium and Bacillus, which grow into colonies having convex, crateriform and flat elevations, respectively, were qualitatively compared to the simulated scattering patterns. The strong correlations observed between simulated and experimental patterns validated the scatter model. In addition, spectral effect on the scattering pattern was studied using the scatter model, and experimentally investigated using Staphylococcus, whose colony has circular form and convex elevation. Both simulation and experiment showed that changes in wavelength affected the overall pattern size and the number of rings.

Integrated multi-channel optical system for bacteria characterization and its potential use for monitoring of environmental bacteria

The potential use of a novel multichannel optical system towards fast and non-destructive bacteria identification and its application for environmental bacteria characterisation on the strain level is presented. It is the first attempt to use the proposed optical method to study various bacteria species (Gram-negative, Gram-positive) commonly present in the environment. The novel configuration of the optical system enables multichannel examination of bacterial colonies and provides additional functionality such as registration of two-dimensional (2D) distribution of monochromatic transmission coefficient of examined colonies, what can be used as a novel optical signature for bacteria characterization. Performed statistical analysis indicates that it is possible to identify representatives of environmental soil bacteria on the species level with the 98.51% accuracy and in case of two strains of Rahnella aquatilis bacteria on the strain level with the 98.8% accuracy. The proposed method is an alternative to the currently used preliminary bacteria examination in environment safety control with the advantage of being fast, reliable, non-destructive and requiring minimal sample preparation.

Automatic hemolysis identification on aligned dual-lighting images of cultured blood agar plates

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The recent introduction of Full Laboratory Automation systems in clinical microbiology opens to the availability of streams of high definition images representing bacteria culturing plates. This creates new opportunities to support diagnostic decisions through image analysis and interpretation solutions, with an expected high impact on the efficiency of the laboratory workflow and related quality implications. Starting from images acquired under different illumination settings (top-light and back-light), the objective of this work is to design and evaluate a method for the detection and classification of diagnostically relevant hemolysis effects associated with specific bacteria growing on blood agar plates. The presence of hemolysis is an important factor to assess the virulence of pathogens, and is a fundamental sign of the presence of certain types of bacteria.

METHODS

We introduce a two-stage approach. Firstly, the implementation of a highly accurate alignment of same-plate image scans, acquired using top-light and back-light illumination, enables the joint spatially coherent exploitation of the available data. Secondly, from each segmented portion of the image containing at least one bacterial colony, specifically designed image features are extracted to feed a SVM classification system, allowing detection and discrimination among different types of hemolysis.

RESULTS

The fine alignment solution aligns more than 98.1% images with a residual error of less than 0.13 mm. The hemolysis classification block achieves a 88.3% precision with a recall of 98.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

The results collected from different clinical scenarios (urinary infections and throat swab screening) together with accurate error analysis demonstrate the suitability of our system for robust hemolysis detection and classification, which remains feasible even in challenging conditions (low contrast or illumination changes).

Development of a multispectral light-scatter sensor for bacterial colonies

We report a multispectral elastic-light-scatter instrument that can simultaneously detect three-wavelength scatter patterns and associated optical densities from individual bacterial colonies, overcoming the limits of the single-wavelength predecessor. Absorption measurements on liquid bacterial samples revealed that the spectroscopic information can indeed contribute to sample differentiability. New optical components, including a pellicle beam splitter and an optical cage system, were utilized for robust acquisition of multispectral images. Four different genera and seven shiga toxin producing E. coli serovars were analyzed; the acquired images showed differences in scattering characteristics among the tested organisms. In addition, colony-based spectral optical-density information was also collected. The optical model, which was developed using diffraction theory, correctly predicted wavelength-related differences in scatter patterns, and was matched with the experimental results. Scatter-pattern classification was performed using pseudo-Zernike (GPZ) polynomials/moments by combining the features collected at all three wavelengths and selecting the best features via a random-forest method. The data demonstrate that the selected features provide better classification rates than the same number of features from any single wavelength. Three wavelength-merged scatter pattern from E. coli.

Reflected scatterometry for noninvasive interrogation of bacterial colonies

A phenotyping of bacterial colonies on agar plates using forward-scattering diffraction-pattern analysis provided promising classification of several different bacteria such as Salmonella, Vibrio, Listeria, and E. coli. Since the technique is based on forward-scattering phenomena, light transmittance of both the colony and the medium is critical to ensure quality data. However, numerous microorganisms and their growth media allow only limited light penetration and render the forward-scattering measurement a challenging task. For example, yeast, Lactobacillus, mold, and several soil bacteria form colorful and dense colonies that obstruct most of the incoming light passing through them. Moreover, blood agar, which is widely utilized in the clinical field, completely blocks the incident coherent light source used in forward scatterometry. We present a newly designed reflection scatterometer and validation of the resolving power of the instrument. The reflectance-type instrument can acquire backward elastic scatter patterns for both highly opaque media and colonies and has been tested with three different bacterial genera grown on blood agar plates. Cross-validation results show a classification rate above 90% for four genera.

Automatic Digital Plate Reading for Surveillance Cultures

The automation of specimen processing and culture workup has rapidly emerged in clinical microbiology laboratories throughout the world and more recently in the United States. While many U.S. laboratories have implemented some form of automated specimen processing and some have begun performing digital plate reading, automated colony analysis is just beginning to be utilized clinically. In this issue of the Journal of Clinical Microbiology, M. L. Faron et al. (J Clin Microbiol 54:2470-2475, 2016, http://dx.doi.org/10.1128/JCM.01040-16) report the results of their evaluation of the performance of the WASPLab Chromogenic Detection Module (CDM) for categorizing chromogenic agar plates as negative or "nonnegative" for vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE). Their major finding was 100% sensitivity for detection of "nonnegative" specimens using CDM compared to manual methods for specimens plated on two different types of VRE chromogenic agar plates. Additionally, utilization of digital plate reading in conjunction with automated colony analysis was predicted to result in significant savings based on greatly reduced labor costs.

Novel Perspectives on the Characterization of Species-Dependent Optical Signatures of Bacterial Colonies by Digital Holography

The use of light diffraction for the microbiological diagnosis of bacterial colonies was a significant breakthrough with widespread implications for the food industry and clinical practice. We previously confirmed that optical sensors for bacterial colony light diffraction can be used for bacterial identification. This paper is focused on the novel perspectives of this method based on digital in-line holography (DIH), which is able to reconstruct the amplitude and phase properties of examined objects, as well as the amplitude and phase patterns of the optical field scattered/diffracted by the bacterial colony in any chosen observation plane behind the object from single digital hologram. Analysis of the amplitude and phase patterns inside a colony revealed its unique optical properties, which are associated with the internal structure and geometry of the bacterial colony. Moreover, on a computational level, it is possible to select the desired scattered/diffracted pattern within the entire observation volume that exhibits the largest amount of unique, differentiating bacterial features. These properties distinguish this method from the already proposed sensing techniques based on light diffraction/scattering of bacterial colonies. The reconstructed diffraction patterns have a similar spatial distribution as the recorded Fresnel patterns, previously applied for bacterial identification with over 98% accuracy, but they are characterized by both intensity and phase distributions. Our results using digital holography provide new optical discriminators of bacterial species revealed in one single step in form of new optical signatures of bacterial colonies: digital holograms, reconstructed amplitude and phase patterns, as well as diffraction patterns from all observation space, which exhibit species-dependent features. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on bacterial colony analysis via digital holography and our study represents an innovative approach to the subject.