In vitro analysis of various cell lines responses to electroporative electric pulses by means of electrical impedance spectroscopy

Transepithelial Electrical Impedance Increase Following Porous Substrate Electroporation Enables Label-Free Delivery

Porous substrate electroporation (PSEP) is a promising new method for intracellular delivery, yet fundamentals of PSEP are not well understood, especially the intermediate processes leading to delivery. PSEP is an electrical method, yet the relationship between PSEP and electrical impedance remains underexplored. In this study, a device capable of measuring impedance and performing PSEP is developed and the changes in transepithelial electrical impedance (TEEI) are monitored. These measurements show TEEI increases following PSEP, unlike other electroporation methods. The authors then demonstrate how cell culture conditions and electrical waveforms influence this response. More importantly, TEEI response features are correlated with viability and delivery efficiency, allowing prediction of outcomes without fluorescent cargo, imaging, or image processing. This label-free delivery also allows improved temporal resolution of transient processes following PSEP, which the authors expect will aid PSEP optimization for new cell types and cargos.

Transepithelial Electrical Impedance Increase Following Porous Substrate Electroporation Enables Label-Free Delivery

Porous substrate electroporation (PSEP) is a promising new method for intracellular delivery, yet fundamentals of the PSEP delivery process are not well understood, partly because most PSEP studies rely solely on imaging for evaluating delivery. Although effective, imaging alone limits understanding of intermediate processes leading to delivery. PSEP is an electrical process, so electrical impedance measurements naturally complement imaging for PSEP characterization. In this study, we developed a device capable of measuring impedance and performing PSEP and we monitored changes in transepithelial electrical impedance (TEEI). Our measurements show TEEI increases following PSEP, unlike other electroporation methods. We then demonstrated how cell culture conditions and electrical waveforms influence this response. More importantly, we correlated TEEI response features with viability and delivery efficiency, allowing prediction of outcomes without fluorescent cargo, imaging, or image processing. This label-free delivery also allows improved temporal resolution of transient processes following PSEP, which we expect will aid PSEP optimization for new cell types and cargos.

Design and Modeling of a Device Combining Single-Cell Exposure to a Uniform Electrical Field and Simultaneous Characterization via Bioimpedance Spectroscopy

Previous studies have demonstrated the electropermeabilization of cell membranes exposed to an electric field with moderate intensity (<2 V/cm) and a frequency of <100 MHz. Bioimpedance spectroscopy (BIS) is an electrical characterization technique that can be useful in studying this phenomenon because it is already used for electroporation. In this paper, we report a device designed to perform BIS on single cells and expose them to an electric field simultaneously. It also allows cells to be monitored by visualization through a transparent exposure electrode. This device is based on a lab-on-a-chip (LOC) with a microfluidic cell-trapping system and microelectrodes for BIS characterization. We present numerical simulations that support the design of the LOC. We also describe the fabrication of the LOC and the first electrical characterization of its measurement bandwidth. This first test, performed on reference medium with a conductivity in the same order than human cells, confirms that the measurement capabilities of our device are suitable for electrical cells characterization.

Uncertainty Quantification and Sensitivity Analysis for the Electrical Impedance Spectroscopy of Changes to Intercellular Junctions Induced by Cold Atmospheric Plasma

The influence of pertinent parameters of a Cole-Cole model in the impedimetric assessment of cell-monolayers was investigated with respect to the significance of their individual contribution. The analysis enables conclusions on characteristics, such as intercellular junctions. Especially cold atmospheric plasma (CAP) has been proven to influence intercellular junctions which may become a key factor in CAP-related biological effects. Therefore, the response of rat liver epithelial cells (WB-F344) and their malignant counterpart (WB-ras) was studied by electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Cell monolayers before and after CAP treatment were analyzed. An uncertainty quantification (UQ) of Cole parameters revealed the frequency cut-off point between low and high frequency resistances. A sensitivity analysis (SA) showed that the Cole parameters, R₀ and α were the most sensitive, while R_inf and τ were the least sensitive. The temporal development of major Cole parameters indicates that CAP induced reversible changes in intercellular junctions, but not significant changes in membrane permeability. Sustained changes of τ suggested that long-lived ROS, such as H₂O₂, might play an important role. The proposed analysis confirms that an inherent advantage of EIS is the real time observation for CAP-induced changes on intercellular junctions, with a label-free and in situ method manner.

Electroporation Microchip with Integrated Conducting Polymer Electrode Array for Highly Sensitive Impedance Measurement

OBJECTIVE

Monitoring of impedance changes during electroporation-based treatments can be used to study the biological response and provide feedback regarding treatment progression. However, seamless integration of the sensing electrodes with the setup can be challenging and high impedance sensing electrodes limit the recording sensitivity as well as the spatial resolution. Here, we present an all-in-one microchip containing stimulation electrodes, as well as an array of low impedance, micro-scale sensing electrodes for highly sensitive electrical impedance spectroscopy.

METHODS

An in vitro platform is fabricated with integrated stimulation and sensing electrodes. To reduce the impedance, the sensing electrodes are coated with the conducting polymer PEDOT:PSS. The performance is studied during the growth of a confluent cell layer and treatment with electrical pulses.

RESULTS

Coated electrodes, compared to uncoated electrodes, show more pronounced impedance changes in a broader frequency range throughout the formation of a confluent cell layer and electrical treatment.

CONCLUSION

PEDOT:PSS coatings enhance monitoring of impedance changes with micro-scale electrodes, enabling high spatial resolution and increased sensitivity.

SIGNIFICANCE

Enhanced monitoring techniques can be utilized to study electroporation dynamics and monitor treatment progression for better understanding of underlying mechanisms and improved outcomes.

Rapid Impedance Spectroscopy for Monitoring Tissue Impedance, Temperature, and Treatment Outcome During Electroporation-Based Therapies

OBJECTIVE

Electroporation-based therapies (EBTs) employ high voltage pulsed electric fields (PEFs) to permeabilize tumor tissue; this results in changes in electrical properties detectable using electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Currently, commercial potentiostats for EIS are limited by impedance spectrum acquisition time (  ∼ 10 s); this timeframe is much larger than pulse periods used with EBTs (  ∼ 1 s). In this study, we utilize rapid EIS techniques to develop a methodology for characterizing electroporation (EP) and thermal effects associated with high-frequency irreversible EP (H-FIRE) in real-time by monitoring inter-burst impedance changes.

METHODS

A charge-balanced, bipolar rectangular chirp signal is proposed for rapid EIS. Validation of rapid EIS measurements against a commercial potentiostat was conducted in potato tissue using flat-plate electrodes and thereafter for the measurement of impedance changes throughout IRE treatment. Flat-plate electrodes were then utilized to uniformly heat potato tissue; throughout high-voltage H-FIRE treatment, low-voltage inter-burst impedance measurements were used to continually monitor impedance change and to identify a frequency at which thermal effects are delineated from EP effects.

RESULTS

Inter-burst impedance measurements (1.8 kHz - 4.93 MHz) were accomplished at 216 discrete frequencies. Impedance measurements at frequencies above  ∼ 1 MHz served to delineate thermal and EP effects in measured impedance.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrate rapid-capture ( 1 s) EIS which enables monitoring of inter-burst impedance in real-time. For the first time, we show impedance analysis at high frequencies can delineate thermal effects from EP effects in measured impedance.

SIGNIFICANCE

The proposed waveform demonstrates the potential to perform inter-burst EIS using PEFs compatible with existing pulse generator topologies.

Continuum analysis to assess field enhancements for tailoring electroporation driven by monopolar or bipolar pulsing based on nonuniformly distributed nanoparticles

Recent reports indicate that nanoparticle (NP) clusters near cell membranes could enhance local electric fields, leading to heightened electroporation. This aspect is quantitatively analyzed through numerical simulations whereby time dependent transmembrane potentials are first obtained on the basis of a distributed circuit mode, and the results then used to calculate pore distributions from continuum Smoluchowski theory. For completeness, both monopolar and bipolar nanosecond-range pulse responses are presented and discussed. Our results show strong increases in TMP with the presence of multiple NP clusters and demonstrate that enhanced poration could be possible even over sites far away from the poles at the short pulsing regime. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that nonuniform distributions would work to enable poration at regions far away from the poles. The NP clusters could thus act as distributed electrodes. Our results were roughly in line with recent experimental observations.

Single-cell individualized electroporation with real-time impedance monitoring using a microelectrode array chip

The ability to precisely deliver molecules into single cells while maintaining good cell viability is of great importance to applications in therapeutics, diagnostics, and drug delivery as it is an advancement toward the promise of personalized medicine. This paper reports a single-cell individualized electroporation method with real-time impedance monitoring to improve cell perforation efficiency and cell viability using a microelectrode array chip. The microchip contains a plurality of sextupole-electrode units patterned in an array, which are used to perform in situ electroporation and real-time impedance monitoring on single cells. The dynamic recovery processes of single cells under electroporation are tracked in real time via impedance measurement, which provide detailed transient cell states and facilitate understanding the whole recovery process at the level of single cells. We define single-cell impedance indicators to characterize cell perforation efficiency and cell viability, which are used to optimize electroporation. By applying the proposed electroporation method to different cell lines, including human cancer cell lines and normal human cell lines individually, optimum stimuli are determined for these cells, by which high transfection levels of enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) plasmid into cells are achieved. The results validate the effectiveness of the proposed single-cell individualized electroporation/transfection method and demonstrate promising potential in applications of cell reprogramming, induced pluripotent stem cells, adoptive cell therapy, and intracellular drug delivery technology.

Single-Cell Electroporation with Real-Time Impedance Assessment Using a Constriction Microchannel

The electroporation system can serve as a tool for the intracellular delivery of foreign cargos. However, this technique is presently limited by the inaccurate electric field applied to the single cells and lack of a real-time electroporation metrics subsystem. Here, we reported a microfluidic system for precise and rapid single-cell electroporation and simultaneous impedance monitoring in a constriction microchannel. When single cells (A549) were continuously passing through the constriction microchannel, a localized high electric field was applied on the cell membrane, which resulted in highly efficient (up to 96.6%) electroporation. During a single cell entering the constriction channel, an abrupt impedance drop was noticed and demonstrated to be correlated with the occurrence of electroporation. Besides, while the cell was moving in the constriction channel, the stabilized impedance showed the capability to quantify the electroporation extent. The correspondence of the impedance variation and electroporation was validated by the intracellular delivery of the fluorescence indicator (propidium iodide). Based on the obtained results, this system is capable of precise control of electroporation and real-time, label-free impedance assessment, providing a potential tool for intracellular delivery and other biomedical applications.

Physiological changes may dominate the electrical properties of liver during reversible electroporation: Measurements and modelling

This study presents electrical measurements (both conductivity during the pulses and impedance spectroscopy before and after) performed in liver tissue of mice during electroporation with classical electrochemotherapy conditions (8 pulses of 100 µs duration). A four-needle electrode arrangement inserted in the tissue was used for the measurements. The undesirable effects of the four-electrode geometry, notably concerning its sensitivity, were quantified and discussed showing how the electrode geometry chosen for the measurements can impact the results. Numerical modelling was applied to the information collected during the pulse, and to the impedance spectra acquired before and after the pulses sequence. Our results show that the numerical results were not consistent, suggesting that other collateral phenomena not considered in the model are at work during electroporation in vivo. We show how the modification in the volume of the intra and extra cellular media, likely caused by the vascular lock effect, could at least partially explain the recorded impedance evolution. In the present study we demonstrate the significant impact that physiological effects have on impedance changes following electroporation at the tissue scale and the potential need of introducing them into the numerical models. The code for the numerical model is publicly available at https://gitlab.inria.fr/poignard/4-electrode-system.

Enhanced resolution impedimetric analysis of cell responses from the distribution of relaxation times

A universal strategy for the sensitive investigation of cell responses to external stimuli, in particular nanosecond pulsed electric fields (nsPEFs), was developed based on electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) in combination with a multi-peak analysis for the distribution of relaxation times (DRT). The DRT method provides high resolution for the identification of different polarization processes without a priori assumptions, as they are needed by more conventional approaches, such as an evaluation by equivalent circuit models. Accordingly, the physical properties of cells and their changes due to external stimuli can be uncovered and visualized and dispersion mechanisms introduced by Schwan et al. clearly identified. These are in particular relaxation processes at about 100 kHz that are associated with cell membrane characteristics and dominating respective changes of the distribution function for epithelial cell monolayers after exposure. A relatively moderate evolution at about 10 kHz may represent the polarization of extracellular matrices. Relaxation processes at around 1 MHz were suggested to be associated with intracellular changes. Conversely, the distribution of relaxation times can aid the optimization of the experimental design with respect to intended responses by an external stimulus.

Application of bioimpedance spectroscopy to characterize chemoresistant tumor cell selectivity of nanosecond pulse stimulation

The discriminating effects of nanosecond pulsed electric fields (nsPEFs) between chemoresistant tumor cells (CRTCs) and their respective homologous chemosensitive tumor cells (CSTCs) were investigated based on bioimpedance spectroscopy (BIS). The electrical properties of individual untreated cells were determined by fitting the impedance spectra to an equivalent circuit model and then using aided simulations to calculate the nuclear envelope transmembrane potential (nTMP) and electroporation area on the nuclear envelope. Additionally, fluorescence staining assays of cell monolayers after nanopulse stimulation (80 pulses, 200 ns, 3 kV) were conducted to validate the simulation results. The staining results indicated that CRTCs showed a larger ablation area and lower lethal threshold compared to CSTCs after exposure to the same nsPEF energy, which was in accordance with the higher nTMP and larger electroporation area calculated for CRTCs. The increase in the lethal effects of nsPEFs on CRTCs compared to CSTCs mainly resulted from the superposition of the changes in the electrical properties and nuclear size. The work shows that BIS can distinguish CRTCs and CSTCs and the corresponding nsPEF effects, suggesting potential applications for the optimization of novel anti-chemoresistance methods, including nsPEF-treatments.

Application of Impedance-Based Techniques in Hepatology Research

There are a variety of end-point assays and techniques available to monitor hepatic cell cultures and study toxicity within in vitro models. These commonly focus on one aspect of cell metabolism and are often destructive to cells. Impedance-based cellular assays (IBCAs) assess biological functions of cell populations in real-time by measuring electrical impedance, which is the resistance to alternating current caused by the dielectric properties of proliferating of cells. While the uses of IBCA have been widely reported for a number of tissues, specific uses in the study of hepatic cell cultures have not been reported to date. IBCA monitors cellular behaviour throughout experimentation non-invasively without labelling or damage to cell cultures. The data extrapolated from IBCA can be correlated to biological events happening within the cell and therefore may inform drug toxicity studies or other applications within hepatic research. Because tight junctions comprise the blood/biliary barrier in hepatocytes, there are major consequences when these junctions are disrupted, as many pathologies centre around the bile canaliculi and flow of bile out of the liver. The application of IBCA in hepatology provides a unique opportunity to assess cellular polarity and patency of tight junctions, vital to maintaining normal hepatic function. Here, we describe how IBCAs have been applied to measuring the effect of viral infection, drug toxicity /IC50, cholangiopathies, cancer metastasis and monitoring of the gut-liver axis. We also highlight key areas of research where IBCAs could be used in future applications within the field of hepatology.

Impact of the number of electric pulses on cell electrochemotherapy in vitro: Limits of linearity and saturation

In this study the evolution in the efficiency of electrochemotherapy (reversible electroporation) with pulse number was assessed in vitro. Experiments were performed using 100 μs pulses at different electric field intensities and the chemotherapeutic agent bleomycin. Additionally, electrical impedance spectroscopy measurements were used as a different method to study in real time the changes produced on cells with pulse number during trains of consecutive pulses. Our results show that the relation between pulse number and the observed outcome is complex and difficult to fully characterize. This relation can display a highly linear behaviour up to a certain number of pulses and/or field intensity applied. However, the relation between the number of pulses and the observed outcome always evolves to a saturation or at least a reduction in the electric field effects that is displayed when either electric field intensity or pulse number are increased. An exponential model was found to best describe this relation within the range of experimental conditions considered. Electrical impedance measurements confirmed the results and gave a more precise quantification of this dependence. The study highlights the importance that pulse number has in the electrochemotherapy protocols and establishes some limits in the use of this parameter.

Cell-line characterization by infrared-induced pyroelectric effect

Evaluation of cellular thermodynamics has recently received a high interest because of its implication in many mechanisms related with function, structure and health of cells. Recent literature reported significant efforts to provide affordable intracellular thermal components of absorption, such as thermal conductivity, to overcome the lack of experimental data. Herein, we provide lines of evidence towards the fabrication of an electronic system, using a rapid thermoelectric technique based on infrared-induced pyroelectric effect for in-vitro cell model characterization. Results demonstrated that the assessment of the average single cell thermal conductivity, sample concentration, and information on cell viability is possible over a wide concentration range. The proposed electronic system establishes a different analysis paradigm if compared to those reported in the literature, with consistent results, demonstrating that the adopted technique can provide cell-specific information and knowledge, closely linked to cell viability and its vital functions.