Introduction of guanidinium-modified deoxyuridine into the substrate binding regions of DNAzyme 10–23 to enhance target affinity: Implications for DNAzyme design

DNAzymes: Expanding the Potential of Nucleic Acid Therapeutics

Nucleic acids drugs have been proven in the clinic as a powerful modality to treat inherited and acquired diseases. However, key challenges including drug stability, renal clearance, cellular uptake, and movement across biological barriers (foremost the blood-brain barrier) limit the translation and clinical efficacy of nucleic acid-based therapies, both systemically and in the central nervous system. In this study we provide an overview of an emerging class of nucleic acid therapeutic, called DNAzymes. In particular, we review the use of chemical modifications and carrier molecules for the stabilization and/or delivery of DNAzymes in cell and animal models. Although this review focuses on DNAzymes, the strategies described are broadly applicable to most nucleic acid technologies. This review should serve as a general guide for selecting chemical modifications to improve the therapeutic performance of DNAzymes.

Nucleic acid enzymes based on functionalized nucleosides

Nucleic acid-based enzymes have recently joined their proteinaceous counterparts as important biocatalysts. While RNA enzymes (ribozymes) are found in nature, deoxyribozymes or DNAzymes are man-made entities. Numerous ribozymes and DNAzymes have been identified by Darwinian selection methods to catalyze a broad array of chemical transformations. Despite these important advances, practical applications involving nucleic acid enzymes are often plagued by relatively poor pharmacokinetic properties and cellular uptake, rapid degradation by nucleases and/or by the limited chemical arsenal carried by natural DNA and RNA. In this review, the two main chemical approaches for the modification of nucleic acid-based catalysts, particularly DNAzymes, are described. These methods aim at improving the functional properties of nucleic acid enzymes by mitigating some of these shortcomings. In this context, recent developments in the post-SELEX processing of existing nucleic acid catalysts as well as efforts for the selection of DNAzymes and ribozymes with modified nucleoside triphosphates are summarized.

Enhancing Catalytic Activity of Uranyl-Dependent DNAzyme by Flexible Linker Insertion for More Sensitive Detection of Uranyl Ion

The uranyl-dependent DNAzyme 39E cleaves its nucleic acid substrate in the presence of uranyl ion (UO₂²⁺). It has been widely utilized in many sensor designs for selective and sensitive detection of UO₂²⁺ in the environment and inside live cells. In this work, by inserting a flexible linker (C3 Spacer) into one critical site (A₂₀) of the 39E catalytic core, we successfully enhanced the original catalytic activity of 39E up to 8.1-fold at low UO₂²⁺ concentrations. Applying such a modified DNAzyme (39E-A₂₀-C3) in a label-free fluorescent sensor for UO₂²⁺ detection achieved more than 1 order of magnitude sensitivity enhancement over using native 39E, with the UO₂²⁺ detection limit improved from 2.6 nM (0.63 ppb) to 0.19 nM (0.047 ppb), while the high selectivity to UO₂²⁺ over other metal ions was fully preserved. The method was also successfully applied for the detection of UO₂²⁺-spiked environmental water samples to demonstrate its practical usefulness.

Early growth response factor-1 DNA enzyme 1 inhibits the formation of abdominal aortic aneurysm in rats

The aim of the present study was to characterize the effects of early growth response factor-1 DNA enzyme (EDRz) in a rat abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) model to determine the mechanism by which EDRz inhibits AAA and affects the formation of AAA by regulating the activity of matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)-2 and MMP-9. EDRz was transfected into the abdominal aorta of rats using the jetPRIME transfection reagent following infusion with elastase. Fluorescent microscopy, hematoxylin and eosin staining, ultrastructural analysis, reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction, western blotting and immunohistochemical analysis were performed to characterize the response to EDRz. The EDRz group showed minimal aneurysm formation when compared with the control group, with significantly lower aortic diameter expansion (2.5±0.1 vs. 3.5±0.1 mm; P<0.05). Early growth response factor 1 (Egr-1) mRNA and protein levels were significantly decreased in the EDRz group, as expected. The decrease in Egr-1 was accompanied by decreases in the mRNA and protein levels of MMP-2 and MMP-9 (P<0.05). Transfection of the Egr-1 specific synthetic DNA enzyme EDRz significantly reduced AAA following elastase infusion in rats, at least in part due to the decreased expression of downstream MMP-2 and MMP-9.

Systematic study of constraints imposed by modified nucleoside triphosphates with protein-like side chains for use in in vitro selection

Successful selection of modified DNAzymes depends on the potential for modified nucleoside triphosphates (dNTPs) to replace their unmodified counterparts in enzyme catalyzed primer extension reactions and, once incorporated, to serve as template bases for information transfer prior to PCR amplification. To date, the most densely modified DNAzymes have been selected from three modified dNTPs: 8-histaminyl-deoxyadenosine (dA^imTP), 5-guanidinoallyl-deoxyuridine (dU^gaTP), and 5-aminoallyl-deoxycytidine (dC^aaTP) to provide several RNA-cleaving DNAzymes with greatly enhanced rate constants compared to unmodified counterparts. Here we report biophysical and enzymatic properties of these three modified nucleosides in the context of specific oligonucleotide sequences to understand how these three modified nucleobases function in combinatorial selection. The base-pairing abilities of oligonucleotides bearing one or three modified nucleosides were investigated by thermal denaturation studies and as templates for enzymatic polymerization with both modified and unmodified dNTPs. While we address certain shortcomings in the use of modified dNTPs, we also provide key evidence of faithful incorporation and enzymatic read-out, which strongly supports their continued use in in vitro selection.

Delivery of therapeutic RNA-cleaving oligodeoxyribonucleotides (deoxyribozymes): from cell culture studies to clinical trials

INTRODUCTION

Development of efficient in vivo delivery systems remains a major challenge en route to clinical application of antisense technology, including RNA-cleaving molecules such as deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes). The mechanisms of oligonucleotide uptake and trafficking are clearly dependent on cell type and the type of oligonucleotide analogue. It appears likely that each particular disease target would pose its own specific requirements for a delivery method. Areas covered. In this review we will discuss the available options for DNAzyme delivery in vitro and in vivo, outline various exogenous and endogenous strategies that have been, or are still being, developed and ascertain their applicability with emphasis on those methods that are currently being used in clinical trials. Expert opinion. The available information suggests that a practical system for in vivo delivery has to be biodegradable, as to minimize concerns over long-term toxicity, it should not accumulate in the organism. Extracellular vesicles may offer the most organic way for drug delivery especially as they can be fused with artificial liposomes to produce hybrid nanoparticles. Chemical modification of DNAzymes holds great potential to apply oligonucleotide analogs that would not only be resistant to nuclease digestion, but also able to penetrate cells without external delivery agents.

Probing the effect of minor groove interactions on the catalytic efficiency of DNAzymes 8-17 and 10-23

DNAzymes (Dz) 8-17 and 10-23 are two widely studied and well-characterized RNA-cleaving DNA catalysts. In an effort to further improve the understanding of the fragile interactions and dynamics of the enzymatic mechanism, this study examines the catalytic efficiency of minimally modified DNAzymes. Five single mutants of Dz8-17 and Dz10-23 were prepared by replacing the adenine residues in the corresponding catalytic cores with 3-deazaadenine units. Kinetic assays were used to assess the effect on the catalytic activity and thereby identify the importance of hydrogen bonding that arises from the N3 atoms. The results suggest that modifications at A15 and A15.0 of Dz8-17 have a significant influence and show a reduction in catalytic activity. Modification at each location in Dz10-23 results in a decrease of the observed rate constants, with A12 appearing to be the most affected with a reduction of ∼80% of kobs and ∼25% of the maximal cleavage rate compared to the wild-type DNAzyme. On the other hand, modification of A12 in Dz8-17 showed an ∼130% increase in kobs, thus unraveling a new potential site for the introduction of chemical modifications. A pH-profile analysis showed that the chemical cleavage step is rate-determining, regardless of the presence and/or location of the mutation. These findings point towards the importance of the N3-nitrogens of certain adenine nucleotides located within the catalytic cores of the DNAzymes for efficient catalytic activity and further suggest that they might directly partake in maintaining the appropriate tertiary structure. Therefore, it appears that minor groove interactions constitute an important feature of DNAzymes as well as ribozymes.

Studies on the preferred uracil-adenine base pair at the cleavage site of 10-23 DNAzyme by functional group modifications on adenine

10-23 DNAzyme is capable of catalytically cleaving RNA substrates with the preferred cleavage sites rAU and rGU, in which the common base pair U-dA0 forms between the substrate and the DNAzyme in the cleavage reaction. Here its conservation was studied with base modifications on dA and extra functional groups introduced. The nitrogen atom at 7- or 8-position of adenine was demonstrated to be equally important for the cleavage reaction, although it is not related to the thermal stability of the base pair. Deletion of 6-amino group led to decreased stability of the base pair and a slight slower reaction rate. Extra functional groups through 6-amino group were not favorably accommodated in the cleavage site. From these modifications at the level of functional groups, it demonstrated that the base pair U-dA0 not only contributes to the recognition and binding stability, but also it is involved in the active catalytic center by its functional groups and base stacking. This kind of chemical modifications with 7-substituted 8-aza-7-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine at dA0 is favorable for the introduction of signal molecules for mechanistic studies and biological applications, without significant loss of the catalytic function and structural destruction.

Position-specific modification with imidazolyl group on10-23 DNAzyme realized catalytic activity enhancement

Nucleoside analogues with imidazolyl and histidinyl groups were synthesized for site-specific modification on the catalytic core of 10-23 DNAzyme. The distinct position-dependent effect of imidazolyl group was observed. Positive effect at A9 position was always observed. The pH- and Mg(2+)-dependence of the imidazolyl-modified DNAzymes suggested that imidazolyl group in 10-23 DNAzyme probably plays a dual role, its hydrogen bonding ability and spacial occupation play the favorable influence on the catalytic conformation of the modified DNAzymes. This research demonstrated that the catalytic performance of DNAzymes could be enhanced by incorporation of additional functional groups. Chemical modification is a feasible approach toward more efficient DNAzymes for therapeutic and biotechnological applications.

Transfected early growth response gene-1 DNA enzyme prevents stenosis and occlusion of autogenous vein graft in vivo

The aim of this study was to detect the inhibitory action of the early growth response gene-1 DNA enzyme (EDRz) as a carrying agent by liposomes on vascular smooth muscle cell proliferation and intimal hyperplasia. An autogenous vein graft model was established. EDRz was transfected to the graft vein. The vein graft samples were obtained on each time point after surgery. The expression of the EDRz transfected in the vein graft was detected using a fluorescent microscope. Early growth response gene-1 (Egr-1) mRNA was measured using reverse transcription-PCR and in situ hybridization. And the protein expression of Egr-1 was detected by using western blot and immunohistochemistry analyses. EDRz was located at the media of the vein graft from 2 to 24 h, 7 h after grafting. The Egr-1 protein was mainly located in the medial VSMCs, monocytes, and endothelium cells during the early phase of the vein graft. The degree of VSMC proliferation and thickness of intima were obviously relieved compared with the no-gene therapy group. EDRz can reduce Egr-1 expression in autogenous vein grafts, effectively restrain VSMC proliferation and intimal hyperplasia, and prevent vascular stenosis and occlusion after vein graft.

A structure-activity relationship study for 2'-deoxyadenosine analogs at A9 position in the catalytic core of 10-23 DNAzyme for rate enhancement

Modification on the catalytic core of 10-23 DNAzyme with protein-like functional groups is a potential approach to obtain its more efficient analogs. In our efforts for this purpose, a lead structure (DZ-2-9) with 8-aza-7-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine at the A9 position in its catalytic core was obtained. Here we report our structure-activity relationship studies on this lead structure. Various functional groups of different chemical properties were introduced through the 7-substituents of 8-aza-7-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine to DZ-2-9. The functional groups capable of forming hydrogen bonds, like amino and hydroxyl groups, are more favorable for catalytic rate enhancement than the large groups with spacial occupation, like phenyl and tert-butylphenyl groups, and the flexible alkyl linkage was the more preferred choice for optimizing their positive effect. Furthermore, they exerted positive effect cooperatively with the N8 atom. These results give us a clear hint in the design of compounds for A9 substitution of 10-23 DNAzyme for more efficient DNAzymes.

The chemistry and biology of organic guanidine derivatives

The chemistry and biology of organic natural guanidines are reviewed, including the isolation, structure determination, synthesis, biosynthesis and biological activities of alkaloids, non-ribosomal peptides, guanidine-bearing terpenes, polyketides and shikimic acid derivatives from natural sources.

Targeting insulin-like growth factor I with 10-23 DNAzymes: 2'-O-methyl modifications in the catalytic core enhance mRNA cleavage

Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) and its cognate receptor (IGF-1R) contribute to normal cell function and to tumorigenesis. The role of IGF-I signaling in tumor growth has been demonstrated in vivo using nucleic acid-based strategies. Here, we designed the first 10-23 DNAzymes directed against IGF-I mRNA. Unlike antisense approaches and RNA interference that require protein catalysis, DNAzymes catalyze protein-free RNA cleavage. We identified target sequences and measured catalytic properties of differently designed DNAzymes on short synthetic RNA targets and on in vitro transcribed IGF-I mRNA. The most efficient cleavers were then transfected into cells, and their inhibitory effect was analyzed using reporter gene assays. We found that increasing the size of DNAzyme flanking sequences and modifications of the termini with 2'-O-methyl residues improved cleavage rates of target RNAs. Modification of the catalytic loop with six 2'-O-methyl ribonucleotides at nonessential positions increased or decreased catalytic efficiency depending on the mRNA target site. In cells, DNAzymes with 2'-O-methyl-modified catalytic cores and flanking sequences were able to inhibit reporter gene activity because of specific recognition and cleavage of IGF-I mRNA sequences. Mutant DNAzymes with inactive catalytic cores were unable to block reporter gene expression, demonstrating that the RNA cleaving ability of 10-23 DNAzymes contributed to inhibitory mechanisms. Our results show that nuclease-resistant 2'-O-methyl-modified DNAzymes with high catalytic efficiencies are useful for inhibiting IGF-I gene function in cells.