Novel PTP1B inhibitors identified by DNA display of fragment pairs

Activity-Based DNA-Encoded Library Screening for Selective Inhibitors of Eukaryotic Translation

Small molecule probes exist for only ∼2% of human proteins because most lack functional binding pockets or cannot be assayed for high-throughput screening. Selective translation modulation circumvents canonical druggability and assay development constraints by using in vitro transcription-translation (IVTT) as a universal biochemical screening assay. We developed an IVTT activity assay by fusing a GFP reporter to various target gene sequences and screened the target sequences for inhibitors in microfluidic picoliter-scale droplets using a 5,348-member translation inhibitor DNA-encoded library (DEL). Screening a proof-of-concept PCSK9-GFP reporter yielded many hits; 6/7 hits inhibited PCSK9-GFP IVTT (IC50 1-20 μM), and the lead hit reduced PCSK9 levels in HepG2 cells. Preliminary selectivity was informed by counterscreening the DEL against a frameshift mutant PCSK9-GFP reporter. A plug-and-play approach to assay development and screening was demonstrated by scouting the DEL for activity using reporter genes of targets with difficult-to-assay or even unknown function (RPL27, KRASG12D, MST1, USO1). This microfluidic IVTT DEL screening platform could scale probe discovery to the human proteome and perhaps more broadly across the tree of life.

Using DNA-encoded libraries of fragments for hit discovery of challenging therapeutic targets

INTRODUCTION

The effectiveness of Fragment-based drug design (FBDD) for targeting challenging therapeutic targets has been hindered by two factors: the small library size and the complexity of the fragment-to-hit optimization process. The DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology offers a compelling and robust high-throughput selection approach to potentially address these limitations.

AREA COVERED

In this review, the authors propose the viewpoint that the DEL technology matches perfectly with the concept of FBDD to facilitate hit discovery. They begin by analyzing the technical limitations of FBDD from a medicinal chemistry perspective and explain why DEL may offer potential solutions to these limitations. Subsequently, they elaborate in detail on how the integration of DEL with FBDD works. In addition, they present case studies involving both de novo hit discovery and full ligand discovery, especially for challenging therapeutic targets harboring broad drug-target interfaces.

EXPERT OPINION

The future of DEL-based fragment discovery may be promoted by both technical advances and application scopes. From the technical aspect, expanding the chemical diversity of DEL will be essential to achieve success in fragment-based drug discovery. From the application scope side, DEL-based fragment discovery holds promise for tackling a series of challenging targets.

Protein-templated ligand discovery via the selection of DNA-encoded dynamic libraries

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DELs) have become a powerful technology platform in drug discovery. Dual-pharmacophore DELs display two sets of small molecules at the termini of DNA duplexes, thereby enabling the identification of synergistic binders against biological targets, and have been successfully applied in fragment-based ligand discovery and affinity maturation of known ligands. However, dual-pharmacophore DELs identify separate binders that require subsequent linking to obtain the full ligands, which is often challenging. Here we report a protein-templated DEL selection approach that can identify full ligand/inhibitor structures from DNA-encoded dynamic libraries (DEDLs) without the need for subsequent fragment linking. Our approach is based on dynamic DNA hybridization and target-templated in situ ligand synthesis, and it incorporates and encodes the linker structures in the library, along with the building blocks, to be sampled by the target protein. To demonstrate the performance of this method, 4.35-million- and 3.00-million-member DEDLs with different library architectures were prepared, and hit selection was achieved against four therapeutically relevant target proteins.

Asymmetry of Dual-Display DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries

While dual-display DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DELs) are increasingly employed for ligand discovery, some of their fundamental properties have not yet been studied in-depth. Aided with fluorescence polarization experiments, we demonstrate that dual-display DELs are intrinsically asymmetrical entities, and we deduce practical guidelines to perform better-informed on-DNA hit validation from these libraries.

Advancing small-molecule drug discovery by encoded dual-display technologies

DNA-encoded chemical library technology (DECL or DEL) has become an important pillar for small-molecule drug discovery. The technology rapidly identifies small-molecule hits for relevant target proteins at low cost and with a high success rate, including ligands for targeted protein degradation (TPD). More recently, the setup of DNA- or peptide nucleic acid (PNA)-encoded chemical libraries based on the simultaneous display of ligand pairs, termed dual-display, allows for more sophisticated applications which will be reviewed herein. Both stable and dynamic dual-display DEL technologies enable innovative affinity-based selection modalities, even on and in cells. Novel methods for a seamless conversion between single- and double-stranded library formats allow for even more versatility. We present the first candidates emerging from dual-display technologies and discuss the future potential of dual-display for drug discovery.

Recent advances in DNA-encoded dynamic libraries

The DNA-encoded chemical library (DEL) has emerged as a powerful technology platform in drug discovery and is also gaining momentum in academic research. The rapid development of DNA-/DEL-compatible chemistries has greatly expanded the chemical space accessible to DELs. DEL technology has been widely adopted in the pharmaceutical industry and a number of clinical drug candidates have been identified from DEL selections. Recent innovations have combined DELs with other legacy and emerging techniques. Among them, the DNA-encoded dynamic library (DEDL) introduces DNA encoding into the classic dynamic combinatorial libraries (DCLs) and also integrates the principle of fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD), making DEDL a novel approach with distinct features from static DELs. In this Review, we provide a summary of the recently developed DEDL methods and their applications. Future developments in DEDLs are expected to extend the application scope of DELs to complex biological systems with unique ligand-discovery capabilities.

Strategies for developing DNA-encoded libraries beyond binding assays

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DELs) have emerged as a powerful technology in drug discovery. The wide adoption of DELs in the pharmaceutical industry and the rapid advancements of DEL-compatible chemistry have further fuelled its development and applications. In general, a DEL has been considered as a massive binding assay to identify physical binders for individual protein targets. However, recent innovations demonstrate the capability of DELs to operate in the complex milieu of biological systems. In this Perspective, we discuss the recent progress in using DNA-encoded chemical libraries to interrogate complex biological targets and their potential to identify structures that elicit function or possess other useful properties. Future breakthroughs in these aspects are expected to catapult DEL to become a momentous technology platform not only for drug discovery but also to explore fundamental biology.

Modular assembly and encoding strategies for dual-display DNA-encoded chemical libraries

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DELs) are increasingly being used for the discovery of protein ligands and can be constructed displaying either one or two molecules at the extremities of the two complementary DNA strands. Here, we describe that DELs, featuring the simultaneous display of two molecules, can be encoded using various types of DNA structures, which go beyond the use of conventional double-stranded DNA fragments. Specifically, we compared dual-display methodologies in hairpin, circular or linear formats in terms of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplifiability and performance in affinity capture selections. The methods reported in this article highlight the feasibility and modularity of the described encoding strategies and may thus further expand the scope of DNA-encoded chemistry, particularly for the identification of compounds which recognize adjacent epitopes on the surface of target proteins of interest.

Evolution of the Selection Methods of DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries

In the past two decades, a DNA-encoded chemical library (DEL or DECL) has emerged and has become a major technology platform for ligand discovery in drug discovery as well as in chemical biology research. Although based on a simple concept, i.e., encoding each compound with a unique DNA tag in a combinatorial chemical library, DEL has been proven to be a powerful tool for interrogating biological targets by accessing vast chemical space at a fraction of the cost of traditional high-throughput screening (HTS). Moreover, the recent technological advances and rapid developments of DEL-compatible reactions have greatly enhanced the chemical diversity of DELs. Today, DELs have been adopted by nearly all major pharmaceutical companies and are also gaining momentum in academia. However, this field is heavily biased toward library encoding and synthesis, and an underexplored aspect of DEL research is the selection methods. Generally, DEL selection is considered to be a massive binding assay conducted over an immobilized protein to identify the physical binders using the typical bind-wash-elute procedure. In recent years, we and other research groups have developed new approaches that can perform DEL selections in the solution phase, which has enabled the selection against complex biological targets beyond purified proteins. On the one hand, these methods have significantly widened the target scope of DELs; on the other hand, they have enabled the functional and potentially phenotypic assays of DELs beyond simple binding. An overview of these methods is provided in this Account.Our laboratory has been using DNA-programmed affinity labeling (DPAL) as the main strategy to develop new DEL selection methods. DPAL is based on DNA-templated synthesis; by using a known ligand to guide the target binding, DPAL is able to specifically establish a stable linkage between the target protein and the ligand. The DNA tag of the target-ligand conjugates serves as a programmable handle for protein characterization or hit compound decoding in the case of DEL selections. DPAL also takes advantage of the fast reaction kinetics of photo-cross-linking to achieve high labeling specificity and fidelity, especially in the selection of DNA-encoded dynamic libraries (DEDLs). DPAL has enabled DEL selections not only in buffer and cell lysates but also with complex biological systems, such as large protein complexes and live cells. Moreover, this strategy has also been employed in other biological applications, such as site-specific protein labeling, protein detection, protein profiling, and target identification. In the Account, we describe these methods, highlight their underlying principles, and conclude with perspectives of the development of the DEL technology.

Dual Bcl-XL /Bcl-2 inhibitors discovered from DNA-encoded libraries using a fragment pairing strategy

A dual Bcl-X_L / Bcl-2 inhibitor was discovered from DNA-encoded libraries using a two steps process. In the first step, DNA was used to pair PNA-encoded fragments exploring > 250 000 combinations. In the second step, a focused library combining the selected fragments with linkers of different lengths and geometries led to the identification of tight binding adducts that were further investigated for their selective target engagement in pull-down assays, for their affinity by SPR, and their selectivity in a cytotoxicity assay. The best compound showed comparable cellular activity to venetoclax, the first-in-class therapeutic targeting Bcl-2.

PNA-Encoded Synthesis (PES) and DNA Display of Small Molecule Libraries

DNA-encoded library technologies have emerged as a powerful platform to rapidly screen for binders to a protein of interest. These technologies are underpinned by the ability to encode a rich diversity of small molecules. While large libraries are accessible by cycles of mix and split synthesis, libraries based on single chemistries tend to be redundant. Furthermore, the quality of libraries generally decreases with the number of synthetic transformations performed in its synthesis. An alternative approach is to use hybridization to program the combinatorial assembly of fragment pairs onto a library of DNA templates. A broad molecular diversity is more easily sampled since it arises from the pairing of diverse fragments. Upon identification of productive fragment pairs, a focused library covalently linking the fragments is prepared. This focused library includes linker of different length and geometry and offers the opportunity to enrich the selected fragment set with close neighbors. Herein we describe detailed protocols to covalently link diverse fragments and screen fragment-based libraries using commercially available microarray platform.

Influence of the geometry of fluorescently labelled DNA constructs on fluorescence anisotropy assay

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) are powerful tools for modern drug discovery. A DECL is a pooled mixture of small molecule compounds, each of which is tagged with a unique DNA sequence which functions as a barcode. After incubation with a drug target and washing to remove non-binders, the bound molecules are eluted and submitted for DNA sequencing to determine which molecules are binding the target. While the DECL technology itself is ultra-high throughput, the following re-synthesis of identified compounds for orthogonal validation experiments remains the bottleneck. Using existing DNA-small molecule conjugates directly for affinity measurements, as opposed to complete compound resynthesis, could accelerate the discovery process. To this end, we have tested various geometries of fluorescently-labelled DNA constructs for fluorescence anisotropy (FA) experiments. Minimizing the distance between the fluorescent moiety and ligand can maximize the correlation between ligand-protein interaction and corresponding change in fluorophore rotational freedom, thus leading to larger, easier to interpret changes in FA values. However, close proximity can also cause artifacts due to potentially promiscuous interactions between fluorophore and protein. By balancing these two opposite effects, we have identified applicable fluorescently labelled DNA constructs displaying either a single ligand or pairs of fragments for affinity measurement using a FA assay.

Selection of DNA-Encoded Dynamic Chemical Libraries for Direct Inhibitor Discovery

Dynamic combinatorial libraries (DCLs) is a powerful tool for ligand discovery in biomedical research; however, the application of DCLs has been hampered by their low diversity. Recently, the concept of DNA encoding has been employed in DCLs to create DNA-encoded dynamic libraries (DEDLs); however, all current DEDLs are limited to fragment identification, and a challenging process of fragment linking is required after selection. We report an anchor-directed DEDL approach that can identify full ligand structures from large-scale DEDLs. This method is also able to convert unbiased libraries into focused ones targeting specific protein classes. We demonstrated this method by selecting DEDLs against five proteins, and novel inhibitors were identified for all targets. Notably, several selective BD1/BD2 inhibitors were identified from the selections against bromodomain 4 (BRD4), an important anti-cancer drug target. This work may provide a broadly applicable method for inhibitor discovery.

Identifying Oxacillinase-48 Carbapenemase Inhibitors Using DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries

Bacterial resistance to β-lactam antibiotics is largely mediated by β-lactamases, which catalyze the hydrolysis of these drugs and continue to emerge in response to antibiotic use. β-Lactamases that hydrolyze the last resort carbapenem class of β-lactam antibiotics (carbapenemases) are a growing global health threat. Inhibitors have been developed to prevent β-lactamase-mediated hydrolysis and restore the efficacy of these antibiotics. However, there are few inhibitors available for problematic carbapenemases such as oxacillinase-48 (OXA-48). A DNA-encoded chemical library approach was used to rapidly screen for compounds that bind and potentially inhibit OXA-48. Using this approach, a hit compound, CDD-97, was identified with submicromolar potency (Ki = 0.53 ± 0.08 μM) against OXA-48. X-ray crystallography showed that CDD-97 binds noncovalently in the active site of OXA-48. Synthesis and testing of derivatives of CDD-97 revealed structure-activity relationships and informed the design of a compound with a 2-fold increase in potency. CDD-97, however, synergizes poorly with β-lactam antibiotics to inhibit the growth of bacteria expressing OXA-48 due to poor accumulation into E. coli. Despite the low in vivo activity, CDD-97 provides new insights into OXA-48 inhibition and demonstrates the potential of using DNA-encoded chemistry technology to rapidly identify β-lactamase binders and to study β-lactamase inhibition, leading to clinically useful inhibitors.

A DNA-encoded library for the identification of natural product binders that modulate poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase 1, a validated anti-cancer target

Natural products have been an invaluable source of drug discovery, but their targets remain largely unknown. Natural products enriched DNA-encoded chemical libraries (nDELs) empower the researchers to rapidly and economically screen numerous natural products against various protein targets, and therefore promote the elucidation of the molecular mechanisms. In this work, we used poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase 1 (PARP1), as an example to explore the usage of nDEL for the functional natural products selection. We used late-stage modification approach to label three positive binders with unique DNA barcodes, whose dissociation constants range from sub-micromolar to micromolar. The selection criterion was set up according to the enrichment of these controls. Five natural products selected by this criterion directly bind to PARP1 in SPR, among which luteolin exhibits the highest inhibitory activity against PARP1. Moreover, luteolin selectively induces accumulation of DNA double-strand breaks and G2/M phase arrest in BRCA-deficient cells. All the findings from these investigations on luteolin support that PARP1 inhibition is one of the mechanisms for its anti-cancer activity.

Phosphotyrosine isosteres: past, present and future

Tyrosine phosphorylation is a critical component of signal transduction for multicellular organisms, particularly for pathways that regulate cell proliferation and differentiation. While tyrosine kinase inhibitors have become FDA-approved drugs, inhibitors of the other important components of these signaling pathways have been harder to develop. Specifically, direct phosphotyrosine (pTyr) isosteres have been aggressively pursued as inhibitors of Src homology 2 (SH2) domains and protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTPs). Medicinal chemists have produced many classes of peptide and small molecule inhibitors that mimic pTyr. However, balancing affinity with selectivity and cell penetration has made this an extremely difficult space for developing successful clinical candidates. This review will provide a comprehensive picture of the field of pTyr isosteres, from early beginnings to the current state and trajectory. We will also highlight the major protein targets of these medicinal chemistry efforts, the major classes of peptide and small molecule inhibitors that have been developed, and the handful of compounds which have been tested in clinical trials.

Small-Molecule Modulators of the ATPase VCP/p97 Affect Specific p97 Cellular Functions

VCP/p97 belongs to the AAA+ ATPase family and has an essential role in several cellular processes ranging from cell division to protein homeostasis. Compounds targeting p97 inhibit the main ATPase domain and cause cell death. Here, using PNA-encoded chemical libraries, we have identified two small molecules that target the regulatory domain of p97, comprising the N-terminal and the D1 ATPase domains, and do not cause cell death. One molecule, NW1028, inhibits the degradation of a p97-dependent reporter, whereas the other, NW1030, increases it. ATPase assays show that NW1028 and NW1030 do not affect the main catalytic domain of p97. Mapping of the binding site using a photoaffinity conjugate points to a cleft at the interface of the N-terminal and the D1 ATPase domains. We have therefore discovered two new compounds that bind to the regulatory domain of p97 and modulate specific p97 cellular functions. Using these compounds, we have revealed a role for p97 in the regulation of mitotic spindle orientation in HeLa cells.

Second generation DNA-encoded dynamic combinatorial chemical libraries

A novel DNA-encoded chemical library architecture can mimic the mechanisms of immunity to evolve binders through recombination, dynamics and adaption.

Versatile protein recognition by the encoded display of multiple chemical elements on a constant macrocyclic scaffold

In nature, specific antibodies can be generated as a result of an adaptive selection and expansion of lymphocytes with suitable protein binding properties. We attempted to mimic antibody-antigen recognition by displaying multiple chemical diversity elements on a defined macrocyclic scaffold. Encoding of the displayed combinations was achieved using distinctive DNA tags, resulting in a library size of 35,393,112. Specific binders could be isolated against a variety of proteins, including carbonic anhydrase IX, horseradish peroxidase, tankyrase 1, human serum albumin, alpha-1 acid glycoprotein, calmodulin, prostate-specific antigen and tumour necrosis factor. Similar to antibodies, the encoded display of multiple chemical elements on a constant scaffold enabled practical applications, such as fluorescence microscopy procedures or the selective in vivo delivery of payloads to tumours. Furthermore, the versatile structure of the scaffold facilitated the generation of protein-specific chemical probes, as illustrated by photo-crosslinking.

DNA-Compatible Solid-Phase Combinatorial Synthesis of β-Cyanoacrylamides and Related Electrophiles

We demonstrate that the Knoevenagel condensation can be exploited in combinatorial synthesis on the solid phase. Condensation products from such reactions were structurally characterized, and their Michael reactivity with thiol and phosphine nucleophiles is described. Cyanoacrylamides were previously reported to react reversibly with thiols, and notably, we show that dilution into low pH buffer can trap covalent adducts, which are isolable via chromatography. Finally, we synthesized both traditional and DNA-encoded one-bead, one-compound libraries containing cyanoacrylamides as a source of cysteine-reactive reversibly covalent protein ligands.

A Specific and Covalent JNK-1 Ligand Selected from an Encoded Self-Assembling Chemical Library

We describe the construction of a DNA-encoded chemical library comprising 148 135 members, generated through the self-assembly of two sub-libraries, containing 265 and 559 members, respectively. The library was designed to contain building blocks potentially capable of forming covalent interactions with target proteins. Selections performed with JNK1, a kinase containing a conserved cysteine residue close to the ATP binding site, revealed the preferential enrichment of a 2-phenoxynicotinic acid moiety (building block A82) and a 4-(3,4-difluorophenyl)-4-oxobut-2-enoic acid moiety (building block B272). When the two compounds were joined by a short PEG linker, the resulting bidentate binder (A82-L-B272) was able to covalently modify JNK1 in the presence of a large molar excess of glutathione (0.5 mm), used to simulate intracellular reducing conditions. By contrast, derivatives of the individual building blocks were not able to covalently modify JNK1 in the same experimental conditions. The A82-L-B272 ligand was selective over related kinases (BTK and GAK), which also contain targetable cysteine residues in the vicinity of the active site.

Stability of Oligonucleotide-Small Molecule Conjugates to DNA-Deprotection Conditions

Oligonucleotide conjugates of small molecules are widely used in chemical biology and have found increasing interest in the context of DNA-encoded chemical libraries for drug discovery. Attachment of molecules to DNA bound to the solid support is an attractive small-molecule conjugation method that permits the use of organic solvents, rigorous reaction conditions, and simple workup. However, the conjugated structures must be resistant to the harsh DNA deprotection/cleavage conditions and the stabilities of building blocks under various deprotection conditions are mostly unexplored. In the present study, we analyzed the stability of 131 structurally diverse fragments that contain amides and amide-like elements during DNA deprotection protocols. Structural features susceptible to decomposition in DNA deprotection conditions were identified and a protocol that enabled the synthesis of DNA conjugates with labile fragments on solid support was identified.

DNA-encoded chemistry: enabling the deeper sampling of chemical space

DNA-encoded chemical library technologies are increasingly being adopted in drug discovery for hit and lead generation. DNA-encoded chemistry enables the exploration of chemical spaces four to five orders of magnitude more deeply than is achievable by traditional high-throughput screening methods. Operation of this technology requires developing a range of capabilities including aqueous synthetic chemistry, building block acquisition, oligonucleotide conjugation, large-scale molecular biological transformations, selection methodologies, PCR, sequencing, sequence data analysis and the analysis of large chemistry spaces. This Review provides an overview of the development and applications of DNA-encoded chemistry, highlighting the challenges and future directions for the use of this technology.

Recent advances on the encoding and selection methods of DNA-encoded chemical library

DNA-encoded chemical library (DEL) has emerged as a powerful and versatile tool for ligand discovery in chemical biology research and in drug discovery. Encoding and selection methods are two of the most important technological aspects of DEL that can dictate the performance and utilities of DELs. In this digest, we have summarized recent advances on the encoding and selection strategies of DEL and also discussed the latest developments on DNA-encoded dynamic library, a new frontier in DEL research.

DNA-encoded chemical libraries: foundations and applications in lead discovery

DNA-encoded chemical libraries have emerged as a powerful tool for hit identification in the pharmaceutical industry and in academia. Similar to biological display techniques (such as phage display technology), DNA-encoded chemical libraries contain a link between the displayed chemical building block and an amplifiable genetic barcode on DNA. Using routine procedures, libraries containing millions to billions of compounds can be easily produced within a few weeks. The resulting compound libraries are screened in a single test tube against proteins of pharmaceutical interest and hits can be identified by PCR amplification of DNA barcodes and subsequent high-throughput sequencing.

Screening for covalent inhibitors using DNA-display of small molecule libraries functionalized with cysteine reactive moieties

Discriminating between non-covalent and covalent inhibitors with SDS wash in microarray-based screen.