The bilayer enhances rhodopsin kinetic stability in bovine rod outer segment disk membranes

Enhanced structure/function of mTSPO translocator in lipid:surfactant mixed micelles

TSPO is a ubiquitous transmembrane protein used as a pharmacological marker in neuroimaging. The only known atomic structure of mammalian TSPOs comes from the solution NMR of mouse TSPO (mTSPO) bound to the PK11195 ligand and in a DPC surfactant environment. No structure is available in a biomimetic environment and without PK11195 which strongly stiffens the protein. We measured the effect of different amphiphilic environments on ligand-free mTSPO to study its structure/function and find optimal solubilization conditions. By replacing the SDS surfactant, where the recombinant protein is purified, with mixed lipid:surfactant (DMPC:DPC) micelles at different ratios (0:1, 1:2, and 2:1, w:w), the α-helix content and interactions and the intrinsic tryptophan (Trp) fluorescence of mTSPO are gradually increased. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) shows a more extended mTSPO/belt complex with the addition of lipids: Dmax ∼95 Å in DPC alone versus ∼142 Å in DMPC:DPC (1:2). SEC-MALLS shows that the molecular composition of the mTSPO belt is ∼98 molecules for DPC alone and ∼58 DMPC and ∼175 DPC for DMPC:DPC (1:2). Additionally, DMPC:DPC micelles stabilize mTSPO compared to DPC alone, where the protein has a greater propensity to aggregate. These structural changes are consistent with the increased affinity of mTSPO for the PK11195 ligand in presence of lipids (Kd ∼70 μM in DPC alone versus ∼0.91 μM in DMPC:DPC, 1:2), as measured by microscale thermophoresis (MST). In conclusion, mixed lipid:surfactant micelles open new possibilities for the stabilization of membrane proteins and for their study in solution in a more biomimetic amphiphilic environment.

Functional Impact of the G279S Substitution in the Adenosine A1-Receptor (A1R-G279S7.44), a Mutation Associated with Parkinson's Disease

In medium-size, spiny striatal neurons of the direct pathway, dopamine D₁- and adenosine A₁-receptors are coexpressed and are mutually antagonistic. Recently, a mutation in the gene encoding the A₁-receptor (A₁R), A₁R-G279S^7.44, was identified in an Iranian family: two affected offspring suffered from early-onset l-DOPA-responsive Parkinson's disease. The link between the mutation and the phenotype is unclear. Here, we explored the functional consequence of the G279S substitution on the activity of the A₁-receptor after heterologous expression in HEK293 cells. The mutation did not affect surface expression and ligand binding but changed the susceptibility to heat denaturation: the thermodynamic stability of A₁R-G279S^7.44 was enhanced by about 2 and 8 K when compared with wild-type A₁-receptor and A₁R-Y288A^7.53 (a folding-deficient variant used as a reference), respectively. In contrast, the kinetic stability was reduced, indicating a lower energy barrier for conformational transitions in A₁R-G279S^7.44 (73 ± 23 kJ/mol) than in wild-type A₁R (135 ± 4 kJ/mol) or in A₁R-Y288A^7.53 (184 ± 24 kJ/mol). Consistent with this lower energy barrier, A₁R-G279S^7.44 was more effective in promoting guanine nucleotide exchange than wild-type A₁R. We detected similar levels of complexes formed between D₁-receptors and wild-type A₁R or A₁R-G279S^7.44 by coimmunoprecipitation and bioluminescence resonance energy transfer. However, lower concentrations of agonist were required for half-maximum inhibition of dopamine-induced cAMP accumulation in cells coexpressing D₁-receptor and A₁R-G279S^7.44 than in those coexpressing wild-type A₁R. These observations predict enhanced inhibition of dopaminergic signaling by A₁R-G279S^7.44 in vivo, consistent with a pathogenic role in Parkinson's disease. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Parkinson's disease is caused by a loss of dopaminergic input from the substantia nigra to the caudate nucleus and the putamen. Activation of the adenosine A₁-receptor antagonizes responses elicited by dopamine D₁-receptor. We show that this activity is more pronounced in a mutant version of the A₁-receptor (A₁R-G279S^7.44), which was identified in individuals suffering from early-onset Parkinson's disease.

Kinetic stability of membrane proteins

Although membrane proteins constitute an important class of biomolecules involved in key cellular processes, study of the thermodynamic and kinetic stability of their structures is far behind that of soluble proteins. It is known that many membrane proteins become unstable when removed by detergent extraction from the lipid environment. In addition, most of them undergo irreversible denaturation, even under mild experimental conditions. This process was found to be associated with partial unfolding of the polypeptide chain exposing hydrophobic regions to water, and it was proposed that the formation of kinetically trapped conformations could be involved. In this review, we will describe some of the efforts toward understanding the irreversible inactivation of membrane proteins. Furthermore, its modulation by phospholipids, ligands, and temperature will be herein discussed.

Measurement of Slow Spontaneous Release of 11-cis-Retinal from Rhodopsin

The vertebrate visual photoreceptor rhodopsin (Rho) is a unique G protein-coupled receptor as it utilizes a covalently tethered inverse agonist (11-cis-retinal) as the native ligand. Previously, electrophysiological studies showed that ligand binding of 11-cis-retinal in dark-adapted Rho was essentially irreversible with a half-life estimated to be 420 years, until after thermal isomerization to all-trans-retinal, which then slowly dissociates. This long lifetime of 11-cis-retinal binding was considered to be physiologically important for minimizing background signal (dark noise) of the visual system. However, in vitro biochemical studies on the thermal stability of Rho showed that Rho decays with a half-life on the order of days. In this study, we resolve the discrepancy by measuring the chromophore exchange rate of the bound 11-cis-retinal chromophore with free 9-cis-retinal from Rho in an in vitro phospholipid/detergent bicelle system. We conclude that the thermal decay of Rho primarily proceeds through spontaneous breaking of the covalent linkage between opsin and 11-cis-retinal, which was overlooked in the electrophysiological recording. We estimate that this slow spontaneous release of 11-cis-retinal from Rho should result in 10⁴ to 10⁵ free opsin molecules in a dark-adapted rod cell-a number that is three orders of magnitude higher than previously expected. We also discuss the physiological implications of these findings on the basal activity of opsins and the associated dark noise in the visual system.

Selection for Protein Kinetic Stability Connects Denaturation Temperatures to Organismal Temperatures and Provides Clues to Archaean Life

The relationship between the denaturation temperatures of proteins (T_m values) and the living temperatures of their host organisms (environmental temperatures: T_ENV values) is poorly understood. Since different proteins in the same organism may show widely different T_m’s, no simple universal relationship between T_m and T_ENV should hold, other than T_m≥T_ENV. Yet, when analyzing a set of homologous proteins from different hosts, T_m’s are oftentimes found to correlate with T_ENV’s but this correlation is shifted upward on the T_m axis. Supporting this trend, we recently reported T_m’s for resurrected Precambrian thioredoxins that mirror a proposed environmental cooling over long geological time, while remaining a shocking ~50°C above the proposed ancestral ocean temperatures. Here, we show that natural selection for protein kinetic stability (denaturation rate) can produce a T_m↔T_ENV correlation with a large upward shift in T_m. A model for protein stability evolution suggests a link between the T_m shift and the in vivo lifetime of a protein and, more specifically, allows us to estimate ancestral environmental temperatures from experimental denaturation rates for resurrected Precambrian thioredoxins. The T_ENV values thus obtained match the proposed ancestral ocean cooling, support comparatively high Archaean temperatures, and are consistent with a recent proposal for the environmental temperature (above 75°C) that hosted the last universal common ancestor. More generally, this work provides a framework for understanding how features of protein stability reflect the environmental temperatures of the host organisms.

Cholesterol in the rod outer segment: A complex role in a "simple" system

The rod outer segment (ROS) of retinal photoreceptor cells consists of disk membranes surrounded by the plasma membrane. It is a relatively uncomplicated system in which to investigate cholesterol distribution and its functional consequences in biologically relevant membranes. The light sensitive protein, rhodopsin is the major protein in both membranes, but the lipid compositions are significantly different in the disk and plasma membranes. Cholesterol is high in the ROS plasma membrane. Disk membranes are synthesized at the base of the ROS and are also high in cholesterol. However, cholesterol is rapidly depleted as the disks are apically displaced. During this apical displacement the disk phospholipid fatty acyl chains become progressively more unsaturated, which creates an environment unfavorable to cholesterol. Membrane cholesterol has functional consequences. The high cholesterol found in the plasma membrane and in newly synthesized disks inhibits the activation of rhodopsin. As disks are apically displaced and cholesterol is depleted rhodopsin becomes more responsive to light. This effect of cholesterol on rhodopsin activation has been shown in both native and reconstituted membranes. The modulation of activity can be at least partially explained by the effect of cholesterol on bulk lipid properties. Cholesterol decreases the partial free volume of the hydrocarbon region of the bilayer and thereby inhibits rhodopsin conformational changes required for activation. However, cholesterol binds to rhodopsin and may directly affect the protein also. Furthermore, cholesterol stabilizes rhodopsin to thermal denaturation. The membrane must provide an environment that allows rhodopsin conformational changes required for activation while also stabilizing the protein to thermal denaturation. Cholesterol thus plays a complex role in modulating the activity and stability of rhodopsin, which have implications for other G-protein coupled receptors.

Disruption of Rhodopsin Dimerization with Synthetic Peptides Targeting an Interaction Interface

Although homo- and heterodimerizations of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are well documented, GPCR monomers are able to assemble in different ways, thus causing variations in the interactive interface between receptor monomers among different GPCRs. Moreover, the functional consequences of this phenomenon, which remain to be clarified, could be specific for different GPCRs. Synthetic peptides derived from transmembrane (TM) domains can interact with a full-length GPCR, blocking dimer formation and affecting its function. Here we used peptides corresponding to TM helices of bovine rhodopsin (Rho) to investigate the Rho dimer interface and functional consequences of its disruption. Incubation of Rho with TM1, TM2, TM4, and TM5 peptides in rod outer segment (ROS) membranes shifted the resulting detergent-solubilized protein migration through a gel filtration column toward smaller molecular masses with a reduced propensity for dimer formation in a cross-linking reaction. Binding of these TM peptides to Rho was characterized by both mass spectrometry and a label-free assay from which dissociation constants were calculated. A BRET (bioluminescence resonance energy transfer) assay revealed that the physical interaction between Rho molecules expressed in membranes of living cells was blocked by the same four TM peptides identified in our in vitro experiments. Although disruption of the Rho dimer/oligomer had no effect on the rates of G protein activation, binding of Gt to the activated receptor stabilized the dimer. However, TM peptide-induced disruption of dimer/oligomer decreased receptor stability, suggesting that Rho supramolecular organization could be essential for ROS stabilization and receptor trafficking.

Irreversible denaturation of maltodextrin glucosidase studied by differential scanning calorimetry, circular dichroism, and turbidity measurements

Thermal denaturation of Escherichia coli maltodextrin glucosidase was studied by differential scanning calorimetry, circular dichroism (230 nm), and UV-absorption measurements (340 nm), which were respectively used to monitor heat absorption, conformational unfolding, and the production of solution turbidity. The denaturation was irreversible, and the thermal transition recorded at scan rates of 0.5–1.5 K/min was significantly scan-rate dependent, indicating that the thermal denaturation was kinetically controlled. The absence of a protein-concentration effect on the thermal transition indicated that the denaturation was rate-limited by a mono-molecular process. From the analysis of the calorimetric thermograms, a one-step irreversible model well represented the thermal denaturation of the protein. The calorimetrically observed thermal transitions showed excellent coincidence with the turbidity transitions monitored by UV-absorption as well as with the unfolding transitions monitored by circular dichroism. The thermal denaturation of the protein was thus rate-limited by conformational unfolding, which was followed by a rapid irreversible formation of aggregates that produced the solution turbidity. It is thus important to note that the absence of the protein-concentration effect on the irreversible thermal denaturation does not necessarily means the absence of protein aggregation itself. The turbidity measurements together with differential scanning calorimetry in the irreversible thermal denaturation of the protein provided a very effective approach for understanding the mechanisms of the irreversible denaturation. The Arrhenius-equation parameters obtained from analysis of the thermal denaturation were compared with those of other proteins that have been reported to show the one-step irreversible thermal denaturation. Maltodextrin glucosidase had sufficiently high kinetic stability with a half-life of 68 days at a physiological temperature (37°C).

Influence of protein-micelle ratios and cysteine residues on the kinetic stability and unfolding rates of human mitochondrial VDAC-2

Delineating the kinetic and thermodynamic factors which contribute to the stability of transmembrane β-barrels is critical to gain an in-depth understanding of membrane protein behavior. Human mitochondrial voltage-dependent anion channel isoform 2 (hVDAC-2), one of the key anti-apoptotic eukaryotic β-barrel proteins, is of paramount importance, owing to its indispensable role in cell survival. We demonstrate here that the stability of hVDAC-2 bears a strong kinetic contribution that is dependent on the absolute micellar concentration used for barrel folding. The refolding efficiency and ensuing stability is sensitive to the lipid-to-protein (LPR) ratio, and displays a non-linear relationship, with both low and high micellar amounts being detrimental to hVDAC-2 structure. Unfolding and aggregation process are sequential events and show strong temperature dependence. We demonstrate that an optimal lipid-to-protein ratio of 2600∶1 – 13000∶1 offers the highest protection against thermal denaturation. Activation energies derived only for lower LPRs are ∼17 kcal mol⁻¹ for full-length hVDAC-2 and ∼23 kcal mol⁻¹ for the Cys-less mutant, suggesting that the nine cysteine residues of hVDAC-2 impart additional malleability to the barrel scaffold. Our studies reveal that cysteine residues play a key role in the kinetic stability of the protein, determine barrel rigidity and thereby give rise to strong micellar association of hVDAC-2. Non-linearity of the Arrhenius plot at high LPRs coupled with observation of protein aggregation upon thermal denaturation indicates that contributions from both kinetic and thermodynamic components stabilize the 19-stranded β-barrel. Lipid-protein interaction and the linked kinetic contribution to free energy of the folded protein are together expected to play a key role in hVDAC-2 recycling and the functional switch at the onset of apoptosis.

Chemical kinetic analysis of thermal decay of rhodopsin reveals unusual energetics of thermal isomerization and hydrolysis of Schiff base

The thermal properties of rhodopsin, which set the threshold of our vision, have long been investigated, but the chemical kinetics of the thermal decay of rhodopsin has not been revealed in detail. To understand thermal decay quantitatively, we propose a kinetic model consisting of two pathways: 1) thermal isomerization of 11-cis-retinal followed by hydrolysis of Schiff base (SB) and 2) hydrolysis of SB in dark state rhodopsin followed by opsin-catalyzed isomerization of free 11-cis-retinal. We solve the kinetic model mathematically and use it to analyze kinetic data from four experiments that we designed to assay thermal decay, isomerization, hydrolysis of SB using dark state rhodopsin, and hydrolysis of SB using photoactivated rhodopsin. We apply the model to WT rhodopsin and E181Q and S186A mutants at 55 °C, as well as WT rhodopsin in H(2)O and D(2)O at 59 °C. The results show that the hydrogen-bonding network strongly restrains thermal isomerization but is less important in opsin and activated rhodopsin. Furthermore, the ability to obtain individual rate constants allows comparison of thermal processes under various conditions. Our kinetic model and experiments reveal two unusual energetic properties: the steep temperature dependence of the rates of thermal isomerization and SB hydrolysis in the dark state and a strong deuterium isotope effect on dark state SB hydrolysis. These findings can be applied to study pathogenic rhodopsin mutants and other visual pigments.