Chemistry with weakly-coordinating fluorinated alkoxyaluminate anions: Gas phase cations in condensed phases?

On the Synthesis and Structure of 'Naked' Ga(I) and In(I) Salts and the Surprising Stability of Simple Ga(I) and In(I) Salts in the Coordinating Solvents Ether and Acetonitrile

In this work, we present the solid-state structures of solvent-free Ga[pf] and In[pf] salts ([pf]-=[Al(ORF)4]-; RF=C(CF3)3), which are very rare examples of salts with truly 'naked' metal cations. Both salts may serve as starting materials for subvalent gallium and indium chemistry with very weakly coordinating ligands providing the freedom of choice for solvents and ligands for the future. On the other hand, we report and rationalize the formation and isolation of [M(OEt2)2][pf] and [M(MeCN)2][pf] (M=Ga, In), underlining the surprising stability of these subvalent group 13 M+ ions against disproportionation. Unexpectedly, dicoordinate and carbene analogous [M(L)2]+ ions with the [pf]- counterion are stable in L=acetonitrile and diethyl ether at room temperature, opening up possible applications for example in organic synthesis and catalysis.

Structures, Bonding Analyses and Reactivity of a Dicationic Digallene and Diindene Mimicking trans-bent Ditetrylenes

The reaction of bisdicyclohexylphosphinoethane (dcpe) and the subvalent MI sources [MI (PhF)2 ][pf] (M=Ga+ , In+ ; [pf]- =[Al(ORF )4 ]- ; RF =C(CF3 )3 ) yielded the salts [{M(dcpe)}2 ][pf]2 , containing the first dicationic, trans-bent digallene and diindene structures reported so far. The non-classical MI ⇆MI double bonds are surprisingly short and display a ditetrylene-like structure. The bonding situation was extensively analyzed by quantum chemical calculations, QTAIM (Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules) and EDA-NOCV (Energy Decomposition Analysis with the combination of Natural Orbitals for Chemical Valence) analyses and is compared to that in the isoelectronic and isostructural, but neutral digermenes and distannenes. The dissolved [{Ga(dcpe)}2 ]2+ ([pf]- )2 readily reacts with 1-hexene, cyclooctyne, diphenyldisulfide, diphenylphosphine and under mild conditions at room temperature. This reactivity is analyzed and rationalized.

Homoleptic Transition Metal Carbonyl Cations: Synthetic Approaches, Characterization and Follow-Up Chemistry

ConspectusCarbon monoxide, CO, is one of the most important ligands in organometallic chemistry. It is an excellent π-acceptor and a moderate σ-donor. Therefore, most of the known transition metal carbonyls (TMCs) exhibit a zerovalent or even negative metal oxidation state (OS) of up to -4. However, given the right conditions, the carbonyl ligand also forms homoleptic cationic complexes with one or more transition metal atoms, the transition metal carbonyl cations (TMCCs), known with an OS of up to +3. Despite their long-standing history upon discovery of the first [M(CO)6]+ examples (M = Mn, Tc, Re) by E. O. Fischer in 1962 as well as their very fundamental nature, it took until the 1990s for the scope to be widened by Aubke, Strauss and Willner. Yet, many potential TMCC entries known from gas-phase mass spectrometry work remained unknown on preparative grounds. This is due to their high reactivity, which puts scientists to new challenges and encourages the development of suitable solvents, anions and oxidants, to cope with the demands of these fundamental salts─later referred to as pseudo-gas-phase conditions and innocent deelectronators and solvents.Hence, the utilization of extremely weakly coordinating perfluorinated alkoxyaluminates [Al(ORF)4]- and [F{Al(ORF)3}2]- (ORF = -OC(CF3)3) in combination with the polar but non- or weakly coordinating innocent solvents 1,2-difluorobenzene (oDFB) and 1,2,3,4-tetrafluorobenzene (TFB) yielded the first TMCC salts containing heptacoordinate [M(CO)7]+ (M = Nb, Ta) as well as paramagnetic [M(CO)6]+· (M = Cr, Mo, W) or [Ni(CO)4]+·. However, the use of typical inorganic oxidants Ag+, [NO]+ and Ag+/0.5 I2 regularly led to unwanted side reactions. For example, the Lewis acidic silver(I) cations form Lewis pairs with various Lewis basic TMCs yielding partly clustered [Agx{TMC}y]x+ complex salts, while nitrosonium cations may substitute for carbonyl ligands, forming [M(CO)x-1(NO)]+ complexes. The synergistic oxidizing reagent Ag+/0.5 X2 can add halonium ions X+ to the TMCs (X = Cl, Br, I). This prevented the synthesis of univalent group 8 TMCC salts. Yet, the application of radical cation salts of perfluorinated arenes as innocent deelectronators finally yielded salts of [Fe(CO)5]+· and [M3(CO)14]2+ (M = Ru, Os).TMCC salts are excellent starting materials, and the reaction of [Co(CO)5]+ and [Ni(CO)4]+· with benzene led to the previously unknown bis(benzene) sandwich complexes [Co(benzene)2]+ and [Ni(benzene)2]+·. Under the right conditions, even the very weakly bound oDFB-complex salts with [M(oDFB)2]+ (M = Co, Ni) cations form, useful as naked metal(I) synthons and for small-molecule activation.

The Unified Redox Scale for All Solvents: Consistency and Gibbs Transfer Energies of Electrolytes from their Constituent Single Ions

We have devised the unified redox scale Eabs H2O , which is valid for all solvents. The necessary single ion Gibbs transfer energy between two different solvents, which only can be determined with extra-thermodynamic assumptions so far, must clearly satisfy two essential conditions: First, the sum of the independent cation and anion values must give the Gibbs transfer energy of the salt they form. The latter is an observable and measurable without extra-thermodynamic assumptions. Second, the values must be consistent for different solvent combinations. With this work, potentiometric measurements on silver ions and on chloride ions show that both conditions are fulfilled using a salt bridge filled with the ionic liquid [N2225 ][NTf2 ]: if compared to the values resulting from known pKL values, the silver and chloride single ion magnitudes combine within a uncertainty of 1.5 kJ mol-1 to the directly measurable transfer magnitudes of the salt AgCl from water to the solvents acetonitrile, propylene carbonate, dimethylformamide, ethanol, and methanol. The resulting values are used to further develop the consistent unified redox potential scale Eabs H2O that now allows to assess and compare redox potentials in and over six different solvents. We elaborate on its implications.

The Preparation, Characterization, and Pressure-Influenced Dihydrogen Interactions of Tetramethylphosphonium Borohydride

Tetramethylphosphonium borohydride was synthesized via an ion metathesis reaction in a weakly-coordinating aprotic environment. [(CH3)4P]BH4, in contrast to related [(CH3)4N]+ compounds which tend to crystallize in a tetragonal system, adopts the distorted wurtzite structure (P63mc), resembling some salts containing analogous ions of As and Sb. [(CH3)4P]BH4 decomposes thermally in several endo- and exothermic steps above ca. 240 °C. This renders it more stable than [(CH3)4N]BH4, with a lowered temperature of decomposition onset by ca. 20 °C and solely exothermic processes observed. Raman spectra measured at the 0-10 GPa range indicate that a polymorphic transition occurs within 0.53-1.86 GPa, which is further confirmed by the periodic DFT calculations. The latter suggests a phase transition around 0.8 GPa to a high-pressure phase of [(CH3)4N]BH4. The P63mc phase seems to be destabilized under high pressure by relatively closer dihydrogen interactions, including the C-H…H-C contacts.

The perfluoroadamantoxy aluminate as an ideal weakly coordinating anion? - synthesis and first applications

Weakly coordinating anions (WCAs) facilitate the stabilization and isolation of highly reactive and almost "naked" cations. Alkoxyaluminate-based WCAs such as [Al(OC(CF₃)₃)₄]^- ([pf]^-) are widely used due to their synthetic accessibility and their high stability. However, small cations are still able to coordinate the oxygen atoms of the [pf]^- anion or even to abstract an alkoxy ligand. The novel WCA [Al(OC₁₀F₁₅)₄]^- ([pfAd]^-; OC₁₀F₁₅ = perfluoro-1-adamantoxy) is characterized by a very rigid core framework, thus indicating a higher stability towards fluoride-ion abstraction (DFT calculations) and providing hope to generate less disordered crystal structures. The [pfAd]^- anion was generated by the reaction of the highly acidic alcohol perfluoro-1-adamantanol C₁₀F₁₅OH with LiAlH₄ in o-DFB. Li[pfAd] could not be synthesized free of impurities (and still contains unreacted alcohol). Yet, starting from contaminated Li[pfAd], the very useful pure salts Ag[pfAd], [Ph₃C][pfAd] and [H(OEt₂)₂][pfAd] could be synthesized. The salts were characterized by NMR spectroscopy, single-crystal X-ray diffraction and IR spectroscopy. Additionally, [NO][pfAd] could be synthesized containing alcohol impurities but nonetheless enabled the synthesis of the salt P₉⁺[pfAd]^-. The synthesis of Tl[pfAd] in a mixture of H₂O/acetone/o-DFB demonstrated the water stability of the [pfAd]^- anion.

Computational Predictions of the Stability of Fluorinated Calcium Aluminate and Borate Salts

Energy storage concepts based on multivalent ions, such as calcium, have great potential to become next-generation batteries due to their low cost and comparable cell voltage and energy density to Li-ion batteries. However, the development of Ca batteries is still hindered by the lack of suitable materials that grant a long cycle life. Specific to electrolyte materials, developing a calcium salt that is chemically stable under ambient conditions and enables reversible electrodeposition of Ca is critical. In this work, we use first-principles calculations to study the intrinsic and reductive stability of twelve Ca salts with fluorinated aluminate and borate anions and analyze the decomposition products formed on the metal anode surface that are critical to early-stage solid electrolyte interphase formation. We found anions with significant steric hindrance and a high degree of fluorination are intrinsically less stable and deemed unviable designs for Ca salt. Aluminate salts are generally less reactive with the Ca anode than their borate counterparts, and a high degree of fluorination leads to weaker reductive stability. Calcium fluoride is the most prominent decomposition product on the anode surface, and carbide-like motifs were also found from the decomposition of the designed salts.

How long are Ga⇆Ga double bonds and Ga-Ga single bonds in dicationic gallium dimers?

Syntheses and characterization of two salts [(L)GaGa(L)][pf]₂ ([pf]^- = [Al(OR^F)₄]^-; R^F = C(CF₃)₃) are reported. They include the first dicationic digallene [(L)Ga⇆Ga(L)]²⁺ (L = CDP^Ph = C(PPh₃)₂) and a digallane [(L)Ga-Ga(L)]²⁺ (L = [NacNac^Mes]^-). The CDP^Ph-supported digallene dication includes a trans-bent [L-GaGa-L]²⁺ bond that is analogous to neutral R-GaGa-R molecules and related to Robinson's famous "Digallyne" [R-GaGa-R]^2-. The dicationic digallane [(L)Ga-Ga(L)]²⁺ is analogous to the widely used "Jones magnesium dimer", but includes a very short Ga^II-Ga^II single bond.

Coordination of Pnictogenylboranes Towards Tl(I) Salts and a Tl- Mediated P-P Coupling

The coordination chemistry of only Lewis-base (LB)-stabilized pnictogenylboranes EH₂ BH₂ ⋅NMe₃ (E=P, As) towards Tl(I) salts has been studied. The reaction of Tl[BAr^Cl ] (BAr^Cl =[B(3,5-C₆ H₃ Cl₂ )₄ ]^- ) with the corresponding pnictogenylborane results in the formation of [Tl(EH₂ BH₂ ⋅NMe₃ )][BAr^Cl ] (1 a: E=P; 1 b: E=As). Whereas the Tl ion in 1 a/b is monocoordinated, the exchange of the weakly coordinating anion (WCA) in the Tl(I) salt leads to the formation of a trigonal pyramidal coordination mode at the Tl atom by coordination of three equivalents of EH₂ BH₂  ⋅ NMe₃ in [Tl(EH₂ BH₂  ⋅ NMe₃ )₃ ][WCA] (2 a: E=P, WCA=TEF^Cl ; 2 b: E=As, WCA=TEF) (TEF=[Al{OC(CF₃ )₃ }₄ ]^- , TEF^Cl =[Al{(OC(CF₃ )₂ (CCl₃ )}₄ ]^- ). Furthermore, by using two equivalents of PH₂ BH₂ ⋅NMe₃ , a Tl(I)-mediated P-P coupling takes place in CH₂ Cl₂ as solvent resulting in [Me₃ N⋅BH₂ PH₂ PHBH₂ ⋅NMe₃ ][WCA] (WCA=TEF, 3 a; BAr^Cl , 3 b; TEF^Cl , 3 c). In contrast, for the arsenic derivatives 1 b and 2 b, no coupling reaction is observed. The underlying chemical processes are elucidated by quantum chemical computations.

Structural Diversity in Divalent Group 14 Triflate Complexes Involving Endocyclic Thia-Macrocyclic Coordination

A highly unusual series of M(II) (M = Ge, Sn, Pb) complexes with endocyclic thioether macrocyclic coordination and with coordination numbers ranging from three to nine have been prepared by the reaction of [9]aneS₃ (1,4,7-trithiacyclononane), [12]aneS₄ (1,4,7,10-tetrathiacyclododecane), or [24]aneS₈ (1,4,7,10,13,16,19,22-octathiacyclotetracosane) with M(OTf)₂ (M = Sn and Pb; OTf = CF₃SO₃^-) or with GeCl₂·dioxane and 2 mol equiv of TMSOTf (Me₃SiO₃SCF₃) in a mixture of anhydrous CH₂Cl₂ and MeCN. The isolated bulk products are characterized by ¹H, ¹³C{¹H}, ¹⁹F{¹H}, and ¹¹⁹Sn{¹H} NMR and IR spectroscopy, high-resolution ESI⁺ MS, and microanalytical data. Crystal structures are also reported for [M(L)][OTf]₂ (M = Ge, Sn, Pb; L = [9]aneS₃, [12]aneS₄) and for [M([24]aneS₈)][OTf]₂ (M = Sn, Pb). In all cases, the ligand is bound in an endocyclic fashion, but the coordination environment and number are highly dependent on the group 14 ion, the macrocyclic ring size, and the number of S-donor atoms it presents. Solution NMR spectroscopic data suggest that the metal-macrocycle coordination is retained in solution but that the triflate anions are extensively dissociated on the NMR timescale. Density functional theory calculations on the [M([9]aneS₃)]²⁺ and [M([12]aneS₄)]²⁺ (M = Ge, Sn, Pb) dications reveal that the HOMO is centered on the group 14 atom as a directional "lone pair"; it also retains a significant amount of positive charge.

Direct Comparison of Subvalent, Polycationic Group 13 Cluster Compounds: Lessons learned on Isoelectronic DMPE Substituted Gallium and Indium Tetracation Salts

The tetracationic, univalent cluster compounds [{M(dmpe)}₄ ]⁴⁺ (M=Ga, In; dmpe=bis(dimethylphosphino)ethane) were synthesized as their pf salts ([pf]^- =[Al(OR^F )₄ ]^- ; R^F =C(CF₃ )₃ ). The four-membered ring in [{M(dmpe)}₄ ]⁴⁺ is slightly puckered for M=Ga and almost square planar for M=In. Yet, although structurally similar, only the gallium cluster is prevalent in solution, while the indium cluster forms temperature dependent equilibria that include even the monomeric cation [In(dmpe)]⁺ . This system is the first report of one and the same ligand inducing formation of isoelectronic and isostructural gallium/indium cluster cations. The system allows to study systematically analogies and differences with thermodynamic considerations and bonding analyses, but also to outline perspectives for bond activation using cationic, subvalent group 13 clusters.

Measurements and Utilization of Consistent Gibbs Energies of Transfer of Single Ions: Towards a Unified Redox Potential Scale for All Solvents

Utilizing the “ideal” ionic liquid salt bridge to measure Gibbs energies of transfer of silver ions between the solvents water, acetonitrile, propylene carbonate and dimethylformamide results in a consistent data set with a precision of 0.6 kJ mol⁻¹ over 87 measurements in 10 half‐cells. This forms the basis for a coherent experimental thermodynamic framework of ion solvation chemistry. In addition, we define the solvent independent peabsH2O ‐ and the EabsH2O values that account for the electronating potential of any redox system similar to the pHabsH2O value of a medium that accounts for its protonating potential. This EabsH2O scale is thermodynamically well‐defined enabling a straightforward comparison of the redox potentials (reducities) of all media with respect to the aqueous redox potential scale, hence unifying all conventional solvents′ redox potential scales. Thus, using the Gibbs energy of transfer of the silver ion published herein, one can convert and unify all hitherto published redox potentials measured, for example, against ferrocene, to the EabsH2O scale.

Free Difluorobis(pentafluoroethyl)phosphoranide Ion and Its Ligand Properties

In this contribution, we report on the "free" [P(C₂F₅)₂F₂]^- ion and its ligand properties in transition metal complex chemistry. For this purpose, Ag[P(C₂F₅)₂F₂] was treated with [{(Et₂N)₃P═N}₃P═NHC(CH₃)₃]Cl ([EtP₄H]Cl) to yield [EtP₄H][P(C₂F₅)₂F₂], featuring a weakly coordinating phosphazenium cation. Due to the weak interaction between the cation and anion, the [P(C₂F₅)₂F₂]^- ion meets the so-called pseudo-gas-phase conditions. To determine the Tolman electronic parameter, [EtP₄H][Ni(CO)₃{P(C₂F₅)₂F₂}] was prepared from [EtP₄H][P(C₂F₅)₂F₂] and [Ni(CO)₄], facilitating the classification of the P(C₂F₅)₂F₂ moiety as a moderately π-acidic ligand. By treatment of [EtP₄H][P(C₂F₅)₂F₂] with [AuCl(tht)], the neutral tetrahydrothiophene ligand was substituted by the phosphoranide ion, yielding [EtP₄H][AuCl{P(C₂F₅)₂F₂}]. When Ag[P(C₂F₅)₂F₂] was treated with [AuCl(tht)], on the other hand, the chloride was substituted. Transmetalation reactions of this type proved to be an efficient transfer method of the P(C₂F₅)₂F₂ moiety, as further demonstrated by the reactions of Ag[P(C₂F₅)₂F₂] with [FeCl(CO)₂Cp], [FeCl(CO)₂Cp*], and [PdCl₂(NCMe)₂]. Surprisingly, P(C₂F₅)₂F demonstrated fluorinating abilities toward [FeCl(CO)₂Cp], [FeCl(CO)₂Cp*], [AuCl(tht)], and [PdCl₂(NCMe)₂]. Apparently, fluorido transition metal complexes were generated in situ under the formation of P(C₂F₅)₂Cl. The fluorido iron and palladium complexes transfer their fluoride ions onto P(C₂F₅)₂F, yielding the respective phosphoranido complexes, featuring the P(C₂F₅)₂F₂ moiety.

Low‐Temperature Isolation of a Labile Silylated Hydrazinium‐yl Radical Cation, [(Me 3 Si) 2 N−N(H)SiMe 3 ] .+

The oxidation of silylated hydrazine, (Me₃Si)₂N−N(H)SiMe₃, with silver salts led to the formation of a highly labile hydrazinium‐yl radical cation, [(Me₃Si)₂N−N(H)SiMe₃]^.+, at very low temperatures (decomposition > −40 °C). EPR, NMR, DFT and Raman studies revealed the formation of a nitrogen‐centered radical cation along the N−N unit of the hydrazine. In the presence of the weakly coordinating anion [Al{OCH(CF₃)₂}₄]⁻, crystallization and structural characterization in the solid state were achieved. The hydrazinium‐yl radical cation has a significantly shortened N−N bond and a nearly planar N₂Si₃ framework, in contrast to the starting material. According to DFT calculations, the shortened N−N bond has a total bond order of 1.5 with a π‐bond order of 0.5. The π bond can be regarded as a three‐π‐electron, two‐center bond.

The Power of the Proton: From Superacidic Media to Superelectrophile Catalysis

Superacidic media became famous in connection with carbocations. Yet not all reactive intermediates can be generated, characterized, and eventually isolated from these Brønsted acid/Lewis acid cocktails. The counteranion, that is the conjugate base, in these systems is often too nucleophilic and/or engages in redox chemistry with the newly formed cation. The Brønsted acidity, especially superacidity, is in fact often not even crucial unless protonation of extremely weak bases needs to be achieved. Instead, it is the chemical robustness of the aforementioned counteranion that determines the success of the protolysis. The advent of molecular Brønsted superacids derived from weakly coordinating, redox-inactive counteranions that do withstand the enormous reactivity of superelectrophiles such as silicon cations completely changed the whole field. This Perspective summarizes general aspects of medium and molecular Brønsted acidity and shows how applications of molecular Brønsted superacids have advanced from stoichiometric reactions to catalytic processes involving protons and in situ generated superelectrophiles.

Silylated Sulfuric Acid: Preparation of a Tris(trimethylsilyl)oxosulfonium [(Me3 Si-O)3 SO]+ Salt

The chemistry of silylated sulfuric acid, O2 S(OSiMe3 )2 (T2 SO4 , T=Me3 Si; also known as bis(trimethylsilyl) sulfate), has been studied in detail with the aim of synthesizing the formal autosilylation products of silylated sulfuric acid, [T3 SO4 ]+ and [TSO4 ]- , in analogy to the known protonated species, [H3 SO4 ]+ and [HSO4 ]- . The synthesis of the [TSO4 ]- ion only succeeds when a base, such as OPMe3 that forms a weakly coordinating cation upon silylation, is reacted with T2 SO4 , resulting in the formation of [Me3 POT]+ [TSO4 ]- . [T3 SO4 ]+ salts could be isolated starting from T2 SO4 in the reaction with [T-H-T]+ [B(C6 F5 )4 ]- or T+ [CHB11 Br6 H5 ]- when a weakly coordinating anion is used as counterion. All silylated compounds could be crystallized and structurally characterized.

Evidence of the Lewis-Amphoteric Character of Tris(pentafluoroethyl)silanide, [Si(C2 F5 )3 ]. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 2021;60:12124-12131. [PMID: 33617080 PMCID: PMC8252080 DOI: 10.1002/anie.202016455]

According to a first view on the geometrical and electronic structure of the tris(pentafluoroethyl)silanide, this anion appears as a Lewis base. Quantum chemical calculations on perfluoroalkylated silanides show significantly lower HOMO and LUMO energy levels in comparison to their non-fluorinated counterparts, which implies reduced Lewis basicity and increased Lewis acidity of the [Si(C2 F5 )3 ]- ion. With these findings and a HOMO-LUMO gap of 4.80 eV similar to N-heterocyclic silylenes (NHSis), perfluoroalkyl silanides are predestined to exhibit Lewis-amphoteric character similar to silylenes. Deprotonation of Si(C2 F5 )3 H with sterically demanding phosphazene bases afforded thermally stable phosphazenium salts of the [Si(C2 F5 )3 ]- anion, which add to benzaldehyde, benzophenone, CS2 , and CO2 in various manners. This behavior also mirrors the reactivity of silylenes towards ketones as well as heterocumulenes and is rationalized by Lewis amphotericity being inherent in these silanides.

Synthesis, Characterization, and Density Functional Theory Studies of Three-Dimensional Inorganic Analogues of 9,10-Diboraanthracene-A New Class of Lewis Superacids

The three-dimensional inorganic analogues of 9,10-diboraanthracene, B₂X₂(C₂B₁₀H₁₀)₂ (X = Cl, 1; X = Br, 2), were attained by salt elimination of Li₂C₂B₁₀H₁₀ and trihaloboranes. The methyl- and phenyl-substituted compounds B₂Me₂(C₂B₁₀H₁₀)₂ (3) and B₂Ph₂(C₂B₁₀H₁₀)₂ (4) were obtained by treating 1 or 2 with the corresponding Grignard reagents. These compounds were fully characterized by NMR, cyclic voltammetry (CV), IR, and single-crystal X-ray diffraction analyses. Experimental (CV and Gutmann-Beckett method) and computational (fluoride ion affinity, hydride ion affinity and LUMO energy) results suggest that the order of Lewis acidity is 2 > 1 > 4 > 3 > SbF₅. Treatment of 1 or 2 with HSiEt₃ gave a rare neutral borane-silane adduct, (Et₃SiH)₂B₂H₂(C₂B₁₀H₁₀)₂ (5). The equilibrium of 5 in solution was thoroughly investigated by spectroscopy and quantum calculations.

Bicyclic and tricyclic phosphanes with p-block substituents

This review summarises the experimental and structural knowledge on polycyclic phosphanes, with a focus on bicyclic and tricyclic phosphanes, as they have not only been the most studied in the last 25 years, but also show the greatest diversity in terms of constitutional isomerism and structural motifs. Moreover, only polycyclic phosphanes that have p-block substituents at all free valences are discussed.

Silylium Ions: From Elusive Reactive Intermediates to Potent Catalysts

The history of silyl cations has all the makings of a drama but with a happy ending. Being considered reactive intermediates impossible to isolate in the condensed phase for decades, their actual characterization in solution and later in solid state did only fuel the discussion about their existence and initially created a lot of controversy. This perception has completely changed today, and silyl cations and their donor-stabilized congeners are now widely accepted compounds with promising use in synthetic chemistry. This review provides a comprehensive summary of the fundamental facts and principles of the chemistry of silyl cations, including reliable ways of their preparation as well as their physical and chemical properties. The striking features of silyl cations are their enormous electrophilicity and as such reactivity as super Lewis acids as well as fluorophilicity. Known applications rely on silyl cations as reactants, stoichiometric reagents, and promoters where the reaction success is based on their steady regeneration over the course of the reaction. Silyl cations can even be discrete catalysts, thereby opening the next chapter of their way into the toolbox of synthetic methodology.

Extending the chemistry of weakly basic ligands: solvates of Ag+ and Cu+ stabilized by [Al{OC(CF3)3}4]- anion as model examples in the screening of useful weakly interacting solvents

Weakly Coordinating Anions (WCAs) facilitate the formation of exotic "naked" cationic species. However, the feasibility of the respective synthesis approaches may be limited by the basicity of the solvent utilized, as the latter is one of the most important factors determining the solvation ability. In this work, we focus on a series of novel complexes of Ag(i) and Cu(i) with weakly basic ligands such as CH₂Cl₂, Cl₃CCN and SO₂ stabilized by perfluorinated alkoxyaluminate, Al[(OR^F)₄]^-, R^F = C(CF₃)₃. The discussion includes their synthesis protocols, crystal structures, vibrational spectra and thermal stability (TGA/DSC/EGA). We show that the Cu-SO₂ adducts present exceptional stability in relation to other metal-SO₂ complexes. To broaden the scope of weakly basic ligands which could prove helpful in the development of chemistry with WCAs, the screening of potential candidates based on DFT calculations is presented.

Cationic Niobium-Sandwich and Piano-Stool Complexes

The syntheses of the homoleptic bis(arene) niobium cations [Nb(arene)2 ]+ (arene = C6 H3 Me3 , C6 H5 Me) with 16 valence electrons and heteroleptic arene-carbonyl cations [(CO)Nb(arene)2 ]+ (arene = C6 H3 Me3 , C6 H5 Me) and [(arene)M(CO)4 ]+ (arene = C6 H3 Me3 , C6 H6 ) obeying 18 valence electrons are described. Stabilization of these complexes was achieved by using the weakly coordinating anions [Al(ORF )4 ]- or [F{Al(ORF )3 }2 ]- (RF = C(CF3 )3 ). The limits of two synthesis routes starting from neutral Nb(arene)2 (arene = C6 H3 Me3 , C6 H5 Me) or [NEt4 ][M(CO)6 ] (M = Nb, Ta) were investigated. All compounds were analyzed by single crystal X-ray determination, vibrational and NMR spectroscopy. DFT calculations were executed to support the experimental data.

Effects of structural variations on π-dimer formation: long-distance multicenter bonding of cation-radicals of tetrathiafulvalene analogues

The multicenter (pancake) bonding between cation-radicals of tetramethyltetraselenafulvalene, TMTSF⁺˙, tetramethyltetrathiafulvalene, TMTTF⁺˙, and bis(ethylenedithio)-tetrathiafulvalene, ET⁺,˙ was compared to that of tetrathiafulvalene, TTF⁺˙. To minimize counter-ion effects, the cation-radical salts with weakly coordinating anions (WCA), tetrakis(3,5-trifluoromethylphenyl)borate, dodecamethylcarborane and hexabromocarborane were prepared. Solid-state (X-ray and EPR) measurements revealed diamagnetic π-dimers in the TMTSF and ET salts and the separate monomers in the TTF salts with all WCAs, while TMTTF existed as a dimer in one and a monomer in two salts. The variable-temperature UV-Vis studies of these salts in solution showed that the thermodynamics of formation of the π-bonded dimers of TMTTF⁺˙ was close to that of TTF⁺˙, while TMTSF⁺˙ and ET⁺˙ showed a higher propensity for π-dimerization. These data indicated that the replacement of sulfur with heavier selenium or insertion of ethylenedithia-substituents into the TTF core increases the π-dimers' stability. Yet, computational analysis indicated that the weakly covalent component of π-bonding decreases in the order TTF > TMTTF > TMTSF > ET. The higher stability of the π-dimers of TMTSF⁺˙ and ET⁺˙ cation-radicals was related to a decrease of the electrostatic repulsion between cationic counter-parts and an increase of dispersion components in these associations.

Stack by Stack: From the Free Cyclopentadienylgermanium Cation Via Heterobimetallic Main-Group Sandwiches to Main-Group Sandwich Coordination Polymers

Heterobimetallic cationic sandwich complexes [M(μ-Cp)M'Cp]+ of group 13 (M=Ga, In) and group 14 (M'=Ge, Sn) elements have been prepared as [WCA]- salts (WCA=Al(ORF )4 ; ORF =OC(CF3 )3 ). Their molecular structures include free apical gallium or indium atoms. The sandwich complexes were formed in the reactions of [M(HMB)]+ [WCA]- (HMB=C6 Me6 ) with the free metallocenes [M'Cp2 ]. Their structures are related to known stannocene and stannocenium salts; the unprecedented germanium analogues, namely the free germanocenium cation [GeCp]+ and the corresponding triple-decker complex cation [CpGe(μ-Cp)GeCp]+ , are described herein. By variation of the reaction conditions, these sandwich complexes can be transformed into the group 13/14 mixed cationic coordination polymer [{In(HMB)(μ-SnCp2 )}n ][WCA]n . This polymeric chain motif was also successfully replicated by the synthesis of complexes [{Ga/In(HMB)(μ-FeCp2 )}n ][WCA]n containing FeCp2 as a bridging ligand.

Building blocks for the chemistry of perfluorinated alkoxyaluminates [Al{OC(CF3)3}4]-: simplified preparation and characterization of Li+-Cs+, Ag+, NH4+, N2H5+ and N2H7+ salts

Advanced weakly coordinating anions (WCAs) significantly facilitate synthesis of various exotic chemical compounds and novel, potentially useful materials. One of such anions - [Al{OC(CF₃)₃}₄]^-, denoted [Al(OR^F)₄]^-, appears particularly convenient, as it can be easily prepared from the commercially available alanates and HOC(CF₃)₃. Here we present a thorough characterization of a series of solvent-free M[Al(OR^F)₄] salts, M = Li-Cs, Ag, NH₄, N₂H₅ and N₂H₇, and related compounds of monovalent cations, which are crucial starting materials for further work with these species. Notably, the corresponding synthetic protocols are updated by an improved method for fast, facile and easily scalable synthesis of Li[Al(OR^F)₄], which remains the most useful primary source of the anion. The physico-chemical properties of these salts including crystal structures, thermal stability by TG/DSC, vibrational spectra as well as solubility are discussed in a systematic fashion.

Soft interactions with hard Lewis acids: generation of mono- and dicationic alkaline-earth metal arene-complexes by direct oxidation

The synthesis of the first unsupported dicationic arene complexes of calcium and strontium [(η⁶-HMB)AE(oDFB)₄]²⁺ is reported (HMB = hexamethylbenzene; AE = alkaline earth metal; oDFB = ortho-difluorobenzene). They were prepared by direct oxidation of the elemental metals employing the ligand-forming radical cation salt [HMB][WCA] as an oxidant (WCA = [Al(OR^F)₄] or [μF-{Al(OR^F)₃}₂]; R^F = C(CF₃)₃). In addition, monocationic η⁶-HMB complexes of calcium, strontium and barium supported by coordination of the monodentate anion [F-Al(OR^F)₃]^- are reported. In all examples, almost undistorted η⁶-HMB coordination is observed with rather short M-arene_centroid distances approaching those observed with the isoelectronic but negatively charged pentamethylcyclopentadienyl ligand. The structure and bonding, thermodynamic stability and Lewis acidity (fluoride/hydride ion affinities, FIA/HIA) of the generated complexes were assessed by DFT methods. It followed that the gaseous dications [(η⁶-HMB)AE(oDFB)₄]²⁺ are extremely hard Lewis acids that retain FIAs close to superacidity in solution.

Bimolecular vinylation of arenes by vinyl cations

Styrene derivatives can be easily synthesized from vinyl triflates and arenes under mild reaction conditions, using [Li][Al(OC(CF₃)₃)₄] as a catalyst and LiHMDS as a base.

Hydrated Metal Ion Salts of the Weakly Coordinating Fluoroanions PF6-, TiF62-, B12F122-, Ga(C2F5)4-, B(3,5-C6H3(CF3)2)4-, and Al(OC(CF3)3)4-. In Search of the Weakest HOH···F Hydrogen Bonds

FTIR spectra of microcrystalline samples of 11 metal ion salt hydrates of a variety of weakly coordinating fluoroanions are reported. The compounds studied were Li(H₂O)₄(Al(OC(CF₃)₃)₄), Li(H₂O)(B(3,5-C₆H₃(CF₃)₂)₄), Li(H₂O)_n(Ga(C₂F₅)₄), Li(H₂O)(PF₆), Li₂(H₂O)₂(TiF₆), Li₂(H₂O)₄(B₁₂F₁₂), Na(H₂O)(PF₆), Na₂(H₂O)₂(B₁₂F₁₂), K₂(H₂O)₂(B₁₂F₁₂), Rb₂(H₂O)₂(B₁₂F₁₂), Cs₂(H₂O)(B₁₂F₁₂), and their partially or completely deuterated isotopologs and isotopomers. The O-D···F hydrogen bonds in Li(HOD)(H₂O)₃(Al(OC(CF₃)₃)₄) (ν(OD) = 2706 cm^-1), Li(HOD)(B(3,5-C₆H₃(CF₃)₂)₄) (ν(OD) = 2705 cm^-1), and Li(HOD)(H₂O)_n(Ga(C₂F₅)₄) (ν(OD) = 2697 cm^-1) rival HOD absorbed in polyvinylidene difluoride (ν(OD) = 2696 cm^-1) and HOD···FCH₃ in a frozen Ar matrix (ν(OD) = 2685 cm^-1) for the weakest hydrogen bonds between a water molecule and an F atom in any compound. As weak as they are, minor differences in O-H···F hydrogen bonds in the same fluoroanion salt can be distinguished spectroscopically. Uncoupled HOD molecules in asymmetric F···HOD···F' hydrogen bonding environments in Rb⁺, Cs⁺, Mg²⁺, and Co²⁺ hydrates of B₁₂F₁₂^2- gave rise to two observable ν(OD) bands even though the two R(O···F) distances differ by only 0.010(4) Å (Mg²⁺), 0.033(2) Å (Co²⁺), 0.074(4) Å (Rb⁺), and 0.106(6) Å (Cs⁺). A plot of ν(OD) for hydrates with a single uncoupled HOD molecule per metal ion (e.g., Li(HOD)(H₂O)₃(Al(OC(CF₃)₃)₄)) vs R(O···F) distance from single-crystal X-ray or neutron diffraction structures was prepared. The ν(OD) values range from 2305 to 2706 cm^-1 and the R(O···F) distances range from 2.58 to 3.17 Å. The plot consists of 53 {ν(OD), R(O···F)} data points, 23 of which are new and have ν(OD) > 2600 cm^-1, in contrast to a 1994 ν(OD) vs R(O···F) plot with 28 data points, none of which had ν(OD) > 2600 cm^-1. There is a clear and significant difference between the new ν(OD) vs R(O···F) plot and a literature ν(OD) vs R(O···O) plot for hydrates containing O-D···O hydrogen bonds. For a given ν(OD) stretching frequency, the exponential regression curves show that R(O···F) is typically 0.1-0.2 Å shorter than R(O···O), in harmony with the lower basicity and smaller size of F atoms vs O atoms.

Photooxidative Generation of Dodecaborate-Based Weakly Coordinating Anions

Redox-active proanions of the type B₁₂(OCH₂Ar)₁₂ [Ar = C₆F₅ (1), 4-CF₃C₆H₄ (2), 3,5-(CF₃)₂C₆H₃ (3)] are introduced in the context of an experimental and computational study of the visible-light-initiated polymerization of a family of styrenes. Neutral, air-stable proanions 1-3 were found to initiate styrene polymerization through single-electron oxidation under blue-light irradiation, resulting in polymers with number-average molecular weights (M_n) ranging from ∼6 to 100 kDa. Shorter polymer products were observed in the majority of experiments, except in the case of monomers containing 4-X (X = F, Cl, Br) substituents on the styrene monomer when polymerized in the presence of 1 in CH₂Cl₂. Only under these specific conditions are longer polymers (>100 kDa) observed, strongly supporting the formulation that reaction conditions significantly modulate the degree of ion pairing between the dodecaborate anion and cationic chain end. This also suggests that 1-3 behave as weakly coordinating anions (WCA) upon one-electron reduction because no incorporation of the cluster-based photoinitiators is observed in the polymeric products analyzed. Overall, this work is a conceptual realization of a single reagent that can serve as a strong photooxidant, subsequently forming a WCA.

Electrostatic polarization of nonpolar substrates: a study of interactions between simple cations and Mo-bound N2

Although a great deal of catalytic studies have focused on covalent interactions between substrates and catalyst centers, recognition of the importance of noncovalent and ionic interactions is driving new approaches to catalyst design. Electrostatic interactions with simple cations (those with little covalency, such as alkali metals) play crucial roles in many catalytic processes, but these effects are challenging to study due to their complicated solvation and speciation behaviour. These effects are particularly difficult to study during cation-mediated reactions with weakly-polar or non-polar substrates. Dinitrogen is one of the most nonpolar substrates known to be affected by electrostatic interactions in both heterogeneous and homogeneous reactions but understanding the significance of these effects requires further exploration. To examine these effects systematically, a new multidentate ligand framework bearing pendent crown ethers has been developed and incorporated into a series of Mo(0)-based dinitrogen complexes. Prepared via both reduction and ligand substitution routes, the strength and impact of cation-N₂ interactions have been studied experimentally (IR spectroscopy) and computationally. Although the smallest cation (Li⁺) has the largest impact on the ground-state heterobimetallic activation of N₂, solvation interactions are highly competitive and result in low Li⁺-(N₂)Mo binding affinities. Thus, although smaller cations can have the largest electronic impact on substrates, these interactions are also the least persistent.

How does the Environment Influence a Given Cation? A Systematic Investigation of [Co(CO)5 ]+ in Gas Phase, Solution, and Solid State

IR spectroscopic studies of the gaseous metal carbonyl cations [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ ⋅mCO (m=1-4) indicated that the weakly bound CO molecules in a second coordination sphere perturb the structure of [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ causing the CO stretching frequencies ν(CO) to become noticeably redshifted. In this work, we aimed to establish the relationship between such gas phase IR spectra and those recorded in condensed phases, either as a solid salt or as a solution in the weakly basic solvent o-difluorobenzene. For this purpose, a series of [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ [WCA]^- salts (WCA=weakly coordinating anion), with the counterions varying between more coordinating (WCA=F-Al(OR^F )₃ , (R^F O)₃ Al-F-Al(F)(OR^F )₂ ; R^F =C(CF₃ )₃ ) and almost non-coordinating (WCA=Al(OR^F )₄ , F{Al(OR^F )₃ }₂ ), were synthesized and characterized by vibrational spectroscopy as well as X-ray structure analysis. The experimental spectra differ considerably from that of the undisturbed gaseous [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ ion, as the structural deformation of [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ requires very little energy. Together with previously reported data, the perturbed condensed phase [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ ions were analyzed and compared with the gaseous [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ ⋅mCO ions. DFT calculations were performed on simply adapted [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ structures to allow the assignment of all the ν(CO) modes and a qualitative interpretation of structural deformations by external influences as a function of the environment (ligands, solvation, crystal packing). The analysis showed that especially the degenerate E' mode ν_e and the averaged asymmetric equatorial CO stretch ν ‾ _e , which originates from a split of the E' mode, are a function of the interaction with the environment. Whereas for the more coordinating counterions ν ‾ _e values of 2112-2120 cm^-1 were obtained, for the less coordinating counterions ν ‾ _e values of up to 2133 cm^-1 were found, which is very close to that of gaseous [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ ⋅4CO, with a ν ‾ _e value of 2135 cm^-1 . This indicates the possibility of approximating the gas phase conditions in the condensed phases with the [Co(CO)₅ ]⁺ ion probably being the prototypical probe molecule for investigating the strengths of interactions in different environments.

Cationic Complexes of Boron and Aluminum: An Early 21st Century Viewpoint

Boron and aluminum are lighter Group 13 elements, found in daily life commodities, and considered environmentally benign. Nevertheless, they markedly differ in their elemental properties (e.g., metal character, atomic radius). The use of Lewis acidic complexes of boron and aluminum for methods of bond activation and catalysis (e.g., hydrogenation of unsaturated substrates, polymerization of olefins and epoxides) is quickly expanding. The introduction of cationic charge may boost the metalloid-centered Lewis acidity and allow for its fine-tuning particularly with regard to preference for "hard" or "soft" Lewis bases (i.e., substrates). Especially the isolation of low-coordinate cations (number of ligand atoms smaller than four) demands elaborate techniques of thermodynamic and kinetic stabilization (i.e., electronic saturation and steric shielding) by a ligand system. Furthermore, the properties of the solvent and the counteranion must be considered with care. Here, selected examples of boron and aluminum cations are described.

Al(OCArF3)3 - a thermally stable Lewis superacid

The adduct free Lewis superacid Al(OCArF3)3 was obtained by the reaction of ArF3COH with AlEt3 and fully characterized (ArF = C6F5). It comprises a high thermal stability up to 180 °C and a distinct reactivity towards Lewis bases, as exemplified by the isolation of the neutral adducts Al(OCArF3)·D (D = MeCN, THF, Et2O, pyridine, OPEt3), the fluoride complexes [Q][FAl(OCArF)3] (Q+ = Cs+, Ag+, Tl+, [S(NMe2)3]+, [Ph3C]+, Li+, [NBu4]+, [FeCp2]+) and the chloride complex [Ph3C][ClAl(OCArF)3].

Facile and systematic access to the least-coordinating WCA [(RFO)3Al-F-Al(ORF)3]- and its more Lewis-basic brother [F-Al(ORF)3]- (RF = C(CF3)3)

By reaction of the Lewis acid Me3Si-F-Al(ORF)3 with a series of [PF6]- salts, gaseous PF5 and Me3Si-F are liberated and salts of the anion [F-Al(ORF)3]- ([f-al]-; RF = C(CF3)3) can be obtained. By addition of another equivalent of Me3Si-F-Al(ORF)3 to [f-al]-, gaseous Me3Si-F is released and salts of the least coordinating anion [(RFO)3Al-F-Al(ORF)3]- ([al-f-al]-) are formed. Both procedures work for a series of synthetically useful cations including Ag+, [NO]+, [Ph3C]+ and in very clean reactions with 5 g batch sizes giving excellent yields typically exceeding 90%. In addition, the synthesis of Me3Si-F-Al(ORF)3 has been optimized and scaled up to 85 g batches in an one-pot procedure. These anions could previously only be obtained by difficult to control decomposition reactions of [Al(ORF)4]- or by halide abstraction reactions with Me3Si-F-Al(ORF)3, generating relatively large countercations that are unsuited for further use as universal starting materials. Especially [al-f-al]- is of interest for the stabilization of reactive cations, since it is even weaker coordinating than [Al(ORF)4]- and more stable against strong electrophiles. This bridged anion can be seen as an adduct of [f-al]- and Al(ORF)3. Thus, it is similarly Lewis acidic as BF3 and eventually reacts with nucleophiles (Nu) from the reaction environment to yield Nu-Al(ORF)3 and [f-al]-. This prevents working with [al-f-al]- salts in ethereal or other donor solvents. By contrast, the [f-al]- anion is no longer Lewis acidic and may therefore be used for reactions involving stronger nucleophiles than the [al-f-al]- anion can withstand. Subsequently it may be transformed into the [al-f-al]- salt by simple addition of one equivalent of Me3Si-F-Al(ORF)3.

Taming the Cationic Beast: Novel Developments in the Synthesis and Application of Weakly Coordinating Anions

This Review gives a comprehensive overview of the most topical weakly coordinating anions (WCAs) and contains information on WCA design, stability, and applications. As an update to the 2004 review, developments in common classes of WCA are included. Methods for the incorporation of WCAs into a given system are discussed and advice given on how to best choose a method for the introduction of a particular WCA. A series of starting materials for a large number of WCA precursors and references are tabulated as a useful resource when looking for procedures to prepare WCAs. Furthermore, a collection of scales that allow the performance of a WCA, or its underlying Lewis acid, to be judged is collated with some advice on how to use them. The examples chosen to illustrate WCA developments are taken from a broad selection of topics where WCAs play a role. In addition a section focusing on transition metal and catalysis applications as well as supporting electrolytes is also included.

A twist on Hellwinkel’s salt, [P(2,2′-biphenyl)2]+[P(2,2′-biphenyl)3]–

Treating PCl5 with C12H8Li2, generated from either C12H10, C12H8Br2, or C12H8I2, affords three products in different ratios depending on the source of the lithiated biphenyl. Hellwinkel’s salt [P(C12H8)2][P(C12H8)3] ([1][2]) and another product [P(C12H8)(C24H16)][P(C12H8)3] ([1′][2]) were obtained by reacting PCl5 with 2,2′-dilithiobiphenyl [Route A: 2.5 equiv.; obtained from biphenyl, n-BuLi, and TMEDA; Route B: 3.0 equiv.; obtained from 2,2′-diiodobiphenyl and n-BuLi; Route C: 4.0 equiv.; obtained from 2,2′-dibromobiphenyl and n-BuLi]. The synthesis, isolation, and characterization of the chiral spiro-compound [1′][2] and the characterization of the pentavalent phosphorane [P(C12H8)2(C12H9)] (3) are reported. The complex [1′][2] was characterized by 31P{1H} NMR spectroscopy, X-ray crystallography, and mass spectrometry. The pentavalent compound (3) was characterized by 31P{1H} NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography.

Further Development of Weakly Coordinating Cations: Fluorinated Bis(triarylphosphoranylidene)iminium Salts

So far unknown bis(triarylphosphoranylidene)iminium cations [PPN]⁺ with one fluorine atom in para ([PPN-1^F ]⁺ ), two in meta ([PPN-2^F ]⁺ ), or three in para and meta positions of the phenyl rings ([PPN-3^F ]⁺ ) were obtained by a newly developed one-pot reaction. These halogenated [PPN]⁺ cations were characterized by IR and Raman spectroscopy in comparison with quantum-chemical calculations, ESI⁺ mass spectrometry, NMR spectroscopy, and single-crystal X-ray diffraction. To assess their quality as weakly coordinating cations and the associated ability to stabilize labile anions, the electrostatic potential and fluoride-ion affinity were calculated and compared with those of the unsubstituted and so far unknown perfluorinated [PPN-5^F ]⁺ cations.