Synthetically Accessible Non-Secosteroidal Hybrid Molecules Combining Vitamin D Receptor Agonism and Histone Deacetylase Inhibition

Design, synthesis and antiproliferative activity of raloxifene/histone deacetylase inhibitor hybrids in breast cancer

Antiestrogen/histone deacetylase inhibitor (HDACi) hybrids were designed by merging structures of raloxifene with suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid, incorporating the HDACi unit into the phenolic ring of the antiestrogen. These hybrids were synthesized with a range of HDACi chain lengths and assessed for bifunctionality. Four hybrids, 21 (YW471), 22 (YW490), 27(YW486), and 28 (YW487) showed good potency both as antiestrogens in a BRET assay and in a fluorometric HDACi assay. The antiproliferative activity of the hybrids was demonstrated in both ER+ MCF7 and ER- MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cell lines.

Bifunctionality and Antitumor Efficacy of ZG-126, a Vitamin D Receptor Agonist/Histone Deacetylase Inhibitor Hybrid Molecule

Analogues of hormonal vitamin D, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D (1,25D), signal through the nuclear vitamin D receptor (VDR). They have potential in combination therapies with other anticancer agents such as histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi's). Here, we characterize the ZG series of hybrid compounds that combine HDACi within the backbone of a VDR agonist. All display improved solubility, with ZG-126 being the most robustly bifunctional molecule in multiple cell lines. ZG-126 is well tolerated and strongly induces VDR target gene expression in vivo at therapeutic doses. Its antitumor efficacy is superior to 1,25D and the HDACi SAHA, separately or together, in mouse models of melanoma and triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC). Notably, ZG-126 treatment reduces metastases almost 4-fold in an aggressive TNBC model. ZG-126 also reduces total macrophage infiltration and the proportion of immunosuppressive M2-polarized macrophages in TNBC tumors by 2-fold. ZG-126 thus represents a bifunctional and efficacious anticancer agent with improved physicochemical properties.

The Centennial Collection of VDR Ligands: Metabolites, Analogs, Hybrids and Non-Secosteroidal Ligands

Since the discovery of vitamin D a century ago, a great number of metabolites, analogs, hybrids and nonsteroidal VDR ligands have been developed. An enormous effort has been made to synthesize compounds which present beneficial properties while attaining lower calcium serum levels than calcitriol. This structural review covers VDR ligands published to date.

Molecular mechanisms of bifunctional vitamin D receptor agonist-histone deacetylase inhibitor hybrid molecules in triple-negative breast cancer

The active form of vitamin D, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D (1,25D), and its analogues signal through the nuclear vitamin D receptor (VDR), a ligand-regulated transcription factor, and have been extensively investigated as anticancer agents. 1,25D and its analogs have potential in combination therapies because they exhibit synergistic activities with other anticancer agents such as histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi). We have developed a series of hybrid molecules that combine HDACi within the backbone of a VDR agonist and thus represent fully integrated bifunctional molecules. They exhibit anti-tumor efficacy in reducing tumor growth and metastases in an aggressive model of triple-negative breast cancer. However, their solubility is limited by their hydrophobic diarylpentane cores. Our goals here were two-fold: (1) to improve the solubility of hybrids by introducing nitrogen into diarylpentane cores, and (2) to investigate the molecular mechanisms underlying their anti-tumor efficacy by performing comparative gene expression profiling studies with 1,25D and the potent HDACi suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA). We found that substituting aryl with pyrydyl rings did not sacrifice bifunctionality and modestly improved solubility. Notably, one compound, AM-193, displayed enhanced potency as a VDR agonist and in cellular assays of cytotoxicity. RNAseq studies in triple negative breast cancer cells revealed that gene expression profiles of hybrids were very similar to that of 1,25D, as was that observed with 1,25D and SAHA combined. The effects of SAHA alone on gene expression were limited and distinct from those 1,25D or hybrids. The combined results suggest that efficacy of hybrids arises from targeting HDACs that do not have a direct role in gene regulation. Moreover, pathways analysis revealed that hybrids regulate numerous genes controlling immune cell infiltration into tumors and suppress the expression of several secreted molecules that promote breast cancer growth and metastasis.

Dual-function antiandrogen/HDACi hybrids based on enzalutamide and entinostat

The combination of androgen receptor antagonists with histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi) has been shown to be more effective than antiandrogens alone in halting growth of prostate cancer cell lines. Here we have designed, synthesized and assessed a series of antiandrogen/HDACi hybrids by combining structural features of enzalutamide with either SAHA or entinostat. The hybrids are demonstrated to maintain bifunctionality using a fluorometric HDAC assay and a bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) antiandrogen assay. Antiproliferative assays showed that hybrids bearing o-aminoanilide-based HDACi motifs outperformed hydroxamic acid based HDACi's. The hybrids demonstrated selectivity for epithelial cell lines vs. stromal cell lines, suggesting a potentially useful therapeutic window.

Paradigm shift of "classical" HDAC inhibitors to "hybrid" HDAC inhibitors in therapeutic interventions

'Epigenetic' regulation of genes via post-translational modulation of proteins is the current mainstay approach for the disease therapies, particularly explored in the Histone Deacetylase (HDAC) class of enzymes. Mainly sight saw in cancer chemotherapeutics, HDAC inhibitors have also found a promising role in other diseases (neurodegenerative disorders, cardiovascular diseases, and viral infections) and successfully entered in various combination therapies (pre-clinical/clinical stages). The prevalent flexibility in the structural design of HDAC inhibitors makes them easily tuneable to merge with other pharmacophore modules for generating multi-targeted single hybrids as a novel tactic to overcome drawbacks of polypharmacy. Herein, we reviewed the putative role of prevalent HDAC hybrids inhibitors in the current and prospective stage as a translational approach to overcome the limitations of the existing conventional drug candidates (parent molecule) when used either alone (drug resistance, solubility issues, adverse side effects, selectivity profile) or in combination (pharmacokinetic interactions, patient compliance) for treating various diseases.

Vitamin D and Its Synthetic Analogs

For many individuals, in particular during winter, supplementation with the secosteroid vitamin D₃ is essential for the prevention of bone disorders, muscle weakness, autoimmune diseases, and possibly also different types of cancer. Vitamin D₃ acts via its metabolite 1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D₃ [1,25(OH)₂D₃] as potent agonist of the transcription factor vitamin D receptor (VDR). Thus, vitamin D directly affects chromatin structure and gene regulation at thousands of genomic loci, i.e., the epigenome and transcriptome of its target tissues. Modifications of 1,25(OH)₂D₃ at its side-chain, A-ring, triene system, or C-ring, alone and in combination, as well as nonsteroidal mimics provided numerous potent VDR agonists and some antagonists. The nearly 150 crystal structures of VDR’s ligand-binding domain with various vitamin D compounds allow a detailed molecular understanding of their action. This review discusses the most important vitamin D analogs presented during the past 10 years and molecular insight derived from new structural information on the VDR protein.

Efficacy of hybrid vitamin D receptor agonist/histone deacetylase inhibitors in vitamin D-resistant triple-negative 4T1 breast cancer

Hormonal 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D (1,25D) and its analogues have shown efficacy in some preclinical models of cancer. However, many models are resistant to the antiproliferative effects of 1,25D or its analogues in vitro or in vivo, and such compounds have failed in the clinic as monotherapies because of tumor resistance. Given the observed synergism between 1,25D analogues and histone deacetylase inhibitors (HDACi) in 1,25D-resistant cells, we previously developed a series of hybrid secosteroidal and easily assembled non-secosteroidal analogues that combined agonism for the vitamin D receptor and HDACi in a single backbone. These compounds displayed enhanced efficacy against 1,25D-resistant malignant cells in vitro. Structure/function studies led to synthesis of several non-secosteroidal variants in which HDACi potency was optimized without substantially sacrificing VDR agonism. Here, we present the first studies of efficacy in vivo of two of these compounds, DK-366 and DK-406, in the aggressive mouse 4T1 model of triple-negative breast cancer, a form of the disease for which treatment options are limited. 4T1 cells are resistant in vitro to the cytostatic and cytotoxic effects of 1,25D and the potent HDACi SAHA individually up to concentrations of 1μM and 50μM, respectively, whereas combinations of the two are efficacious. In vitro, DK-366 or -406 induced dose-dependent arrest of cell proliferation and cytotoxicity at 10-20μM. In vivo, the maximum tolerated dose (MTD) of DK-366 and DK-406 were 2.5 and 5.0mg/kg, respectively. Although the compounds induced hypercalcemia at elevated doses, consistent with VDR agonism in vivo, they both reduced tumor burden at doses below their MTD's. Moreover, in a separate experiment, DK-406 at 5mg/kg reduced 4T1 lung metastases by at least 50%. Under the same conditions, 1,25D (0.25μg/kg) and SAHA (25mg/kg) combined had no effect on tumor burden or on lung metastases. These experiments show that hybrid compounds are bioavailable and efficacious against a particularly aggressive model of metastatic breast cancer, providing strong support for the therapeutic potential of the hybrid concept.

Epigenetic polypharmacology: from combination therapy to multitargeted drugs

The modern drug discovery process has largely focused its attention in the so-called magic bullets, single chemical entities that exhibit high selectivity and potency for a particular target. This approach was based on the assumption that the deregulation of a protein was causally linked to a disease state, and the pharmacological intervention through inhibition of the deregulated target was able to restore normal cell function. However, the use of cocktails or multicomponent drugs to address several targets simultaneously is also popular to treat multifactorial diseases such as cancer and neurological disorders. We review the state of the art with such combinations that have an epigenetic target as one of their mechanisms of action. Epigenetic drug discovery is a rapidly advancing field, and drugs targeting epigenetic enzymes are in the clinic for the treatment of hematological cancers. Approved and experimental epigenetic drugs are undergoing clinical trials in combination with other therapeutic agents via fused or linked pharmacophores in order to benefit from synergistic effects of polypharmacology. In addition, ligands are being discovered which, as single chemical entities, are able to modulate multiple epigenetic targets simultaneously (multitarget epigenetic drugs). These multiple ligands should in principle have a lower risk of drug-drug interactions and drug resistance compared to cocktails or multicomponent drugs. This new generation may rival the so-called magic bullets in the treatment of diseases that arise as a consequence of the deregulation of multiple signaling pathways provided the challenge of optimization of the activities shown by the pharmacophores with the different targets is addressed.

Multitarget Drugs: an Epigenetic Epiphany

Epigenetics refers to changes in a biological phenotype that are not due to an underlying change in genotype. In eukaryotes, epigenetics involves a set of chemical modifications of the DNA and the histone proteins in nucleosomes. These dynamic changes are carried out by enzymes and modulate protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions to determine whether specific genes are expressed or silenced. Both the epigenetic enzymes and recognition domains are currently important drug discovery targets, particularly for the treatment of cancer. This review summarizes the progress of epigenetic targets that have reached a clinical stage: DNA methyltransferases, histone deacetylases, lysine methyltransferases, lysine demethylases, and bromodomains; this is followed by a comprehensive survey of multitarget drugs that have included an epigenetic target as one of their mechanisms of action.

Structural Studies of Vitamin D Nuclear Receptor Ligand-Binding Properties

The vitamin D nuclear receptor (VDR) and its natural ligand, 1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 hormone (1,25(OH)2D3, or calcitriol), classically regulate mineral homeostasis and metabolism but also much broader range of biological functions, such as cell growth, differentiation, antiproliferation, apoptosis, adaptive/innate immune responses. Being widely expressed in various tissues, VDR represents an important therapeutic target in the treatment of diverse disorders. Since ligand binding is a key step in VDR-mediated signaling, numerous 1,25(OH)2D3 analogs have been synthesized in order to selectively modulate the receptor activity. Most of the synthetic analogs have been developed by modification of a parental compound and some of them mimic 1,25(OH)2D3 scaffold without being structurally related to it. The ability of ligands that have different size and conformation to bind to VDR and to demonstrate biological effects is intriguing, and therefore, ligand-binding properties of the receptor have been extensively investigated using a variety of biochemical, biophysical, and computational methods. In this chapter, we describe different aspects of the structure-function relationship of VDR in complex with natural and synthetic ligands coming from structural analysis. With the emphasis on the binding modes of the most promising compounds, such as secosteroidal agonists and 1,25(OH)2D3 mimics, we also highlight the action of VDR antagonists and the evidence for the existence of an alternative ligand-binding site within the receptor. Additionally, we describe the crystal structures of VDR mutants associated with hereditary vitamin D-resistant rickets that display impaired ligand-binding function.

Vitamin D in cancer chemoprevention

CONTEXT

There is increasing evidence that Vitamin D (Vit D) and its metabolites, besides their well-known calcium-related functions, may also exert antiproliferative, pro-differentiating, and immune modulatory effects on tumor cells in vitro and may also delay tumor growth in vivo.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this review is to provide fresh insight into the most recent advances on the role of Vit D and its analogues as chemopreventive drugs in cancer therapy.

METHODS

A systematic review of experimental and clinical studies on Vit D and cancer was undertaken by using the major electronic health database including ISI Web of Science, Medline, PubMed, Scopus and Google Scholar.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

Experimental and clinical observations suggest that Vit D and its analogues may be effective in preventing the malignant transformation and/or the progression of various types of human tumors including breast cancer, prostate cancer, colorectal cancer, and some hematological malignances. These findings suggest the possibility of the clinical use of these molecules as novel potential chemopreventive and anticancer agents.

Structural considerations of vitamin D signaling

Crystal structures represent the static picture in the life of a molecule giving a sneak preview what it might be in reality. Hence, it is very hard to extrapolate from these photos toward dynamic processes such as transcriptional regulation. Mechanistically VDR may be considered as molecular machine able to perform ligand-, DNA- and protein recognition, and interaction in a multi-task manner. Taking this into account the functional net effect will be the combination of all these processes. The long awaited answer to explain the differences in physiological effects for various ligands was one of the biggest disappointment that crystal structures provided since no substantial distinction could be made for the conformation of the active VDR-ligand complexes. This may have come from the limitation on the complexity of the available ligand-VDR structures. The recent studies with full length VDR-RXRα showed somewhat more comprehensive perspective for the 3D organization and possible function of the VDR-RXRα-cofactor complex. In addition to in vitro approaches, also computational tools had been introduced with the aim to get understanding on the mechanic and dynamic properties of the VDR complexes with some success. Using these methods and based on measurable descriptors such as pocket size and positions of side chains it is possible to note subtle differences between the structures. The meaning of these differences has not been fully understood yet but the possibility of a “butterfly effect” may have more extreme consequences in terms of VDR signaling. In this review, the three functional aspects (ligand-, DNA- and protein recognition, and binding) will be discussed with respect to available data as well as possible implication and questions that may be important to address in the future.

Structure-activity relationship of nonsecosteroidal vitamin D receptor modulators

The vitamin D receptor (VDR), a receptor for the secosteroid 1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 [1,25(OH)2D3], is a promising drug target in the treatment of bone and mineral disorders, cancer, autoimmune disease, infection, and cardiovascular disease. Indeed, approximately 100 nonsecosteroidal VDR modulators (VDRMs) have been developed. Analysis of X-ray crystal structures reveals: (i) nonsecosteroidal VDRMs bind to VDR in a position similar to 1,25(OH)2D3; (ii) hydrogen bond interactions between ligands and VDR are the most important for VDR binding; (iii) hydrophobic interactions and CH-π interactions in aromatic ligands are also important for VDR binding; and (iv) exchange of C-O-C linkage to C-CH2-C linkage in VDRMs increases transactivation activity, probably as a result of an entropic effect of solvation/desolvation of molecules. Several VDRMs have better therapeutic efficacy when compared to 1,25(OH)2D3 in experimental models of cancer and osteoporosis with less induction of hypercalcemia, a major potential adverse effect in the clinical application of VDR ligands.

A chimeric SERM-histone deacetylase inhibitor approach to breast cancer therapy

Breast cancer remains a significant cause of death in women, and few therapeutic options exist for estrogen receptor negative (ER (-)) cancers. Epigenetic reactivation of target genes using histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitors has been proposed in ER (-) cancers to resensitize to therapy using selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs) that are effective in ER (+) cancer treatment. Based upon preliminary studies in ER (+) and ER (-) breast cancer cells treated with combinations of HDAC inhibitors and SERMs, hybrid drugs, termed SERMostats, were designed with computational guidance. Assay for inhibition of four type I HDAC isoforms and antagonism of estrogenic activity in two cell lines yielded a SERMostat with 1-3 μM potency across all targets. The superior hybrid caused significant cell death in ER (-) human breast cancer cells and elicited cell death at the same concentration as the parent SERM in combination treatment and at an earlier time point.

Docking ligands into flexible and solvated macromolecules. 6. Development and application to the docking of HDACs and other zinc metalloenzymes inhibitors

Metalloenzymes are ubiquitous proteins which feature one or more metal ions either directly involved in the enzymatic activity and/or structural properties (i.e., zinc fingers). Several members of this class take advantage of the Lewis acidic properties of zinc ions to carry out their various catalytic transformations including isomerization or amide cleavage. These enzymes have been validated as drug targets for a number of diseases including cancer; however, despite their pharmaceutical relevance and the availability of crystal structures, structure-based drug design methods have been poorly and indirectly parametrized for these classes of enzymes. More specifically, the metal coordination component and proton transfers of the process of drugs binding to metalloenzymes have been inadequately modeled by current docking programs, if at all. In addition, several known issues, such as coordination geometry, atomic charge variability, and a potential proton transfer from small molecules to a neighboring basic residue, have often been ignored. We report herein the development of specific functions and parameters to account for zinc-drug coordination focusing on the above-listed phenomena and their impact on docking to zinc metalloenzymes. These atom-type-dependent but atomic charge-independent functions implemented into Fitted 3.1 enable the simulation of drug binding to metalloenzymes, considering an acid-base reaction with a neighboring residue when necessary with good accuracy.