Improvement effects of cytokinin on EDTA assisted phytoremediation and the associated environmental risks

Biodegradable chelating agents for enhancing phytoremediation: Mechanisms, market feasibility, and future studies

Heavy metals in soil significantly threaten human health, and their remediation is essential. Among the various techniques used, phytoremediation is one of the safest, most innovative, and effective. In recent years, the use of biodegradable chelators to assist plants in improving their remediation efficiency has gained popularity. These biodegradable chelators aid in the transformation of metal ions or metalloids, thereby facilitating their mobilization and uptake by plants. Developed countries are increasingly adopting biodegradable chelators for phytoremediation, with a growing emphasis on green manufacturing and technological innovation in the chelating agent market. Therefore, it is crucial to gain a comprehensive understanding of the mechanisms and market prospects of biodegradable chelators for phytoremediation. This review focuses on elucidating the uptake, translocation, and detoxification mechanisms of chelators in plants. In this study, we focused on the effects of biodegradable chelators on the growth and environmental development of plants treated with phytoremediation agents. Finally, the potential risks associated with biodegradable chelator-assisted phytoremediation are presented in terms of their availability and application prospects in the market. This study provides a valuable reference for future research in this field.

Cytokinin-mediated shoot proliferation and its correlation with phytoremediation effects in Cd-hyperaccumulator ecotype of Sedum alfredii

The phytohormones cytokinins (CKs) are known to regulate apical/auxiliary meristems, control shoot growth and are associated with nutrient uptake and high biomass production. In this study, different cytokinins were tested on Sedum alfredii (S.alfredii) for shoot proliferation and growth performance as well as their correlation with phytoextraction efficiency. Among the tested cytokinins, Zeatin (ZTN) treatments produced the highest number of shoots (5-6 per explant) with 5 and 10 μM ZTN concentrations which are shown as zeatin (ZTN) > kinetin (KTN) > benzylaminopurine (BA) > thidiazuron (TDZ). Maximum biomass production was produced on these media. The maximum biomass (0.14 g) was found in 10 μM ZTN concentration with a 1-fold difference (mean value: 0.02 g) from CK (0.12 g). However, the lowest biomass (0.11 g) was found with 4 μM TDZ, with a 1-fold difference (mean value: 0.02 g) from CK (0.13 g) which suppressed shoot growth. The leaf area and leaf chlorophyll index were significantly increased in all cytokinins except TDZ, and the relation was ZTN > KTN > BA>CK > TDZ. Cadmium accumulation was significantly higher in treatments containing cytokinins as compared to cytokinin-free media. Zeatin at 10 μM concentration was the most effective for high biomass production and correlated with higher cadmium uptake efficiency. The results suggest that cytokinins particularly ZTN, play a crucial role in enhancing both biomass production and cadmium, uptake efficiency in S. alfredii. Therefore, in large-scale phytoremediation initiatives conducted in field conditions, cytokinins can be utilized as growth regulators to enhance biomass production and cadmium extraction efficiency in S.alfredii.

Biodegradable chelant-metal complexes enhance cadmium phytoextraction efficiency of Solanum americanum

Toxic contaminants (metals and metal-containing compounds) are accumulating in the environment at an astonishing rate and jeopardize human health. Remarkable industrial revolution and the spectacular economic growth are the prime causes for the release of such toxic contaminants in the environment. Cadmium (Cd) is ranked the 7th most toxic compound by the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (USA), owing to its high carcinogenicity and non-biodegradability even at miniscule concentration. The present study assessed the efficiency of four biodegradable chelants [nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA), ethylenediamine disuccinate (EDDS), ethylene glycol tetraacetic acid (EGTA), and citric acid (CA)] and their dose (5 mM and 10 mM) in enhancing metal accumulation in Solanum americanum Mill. (grown under 24 mg Cd kg^-1 soil) through morpho-physiological and metal extraction parameters. Significant variations were observed for most of the studied parameters in response to chelants and their doses. However, ratio of root and shoot length, and plant height stress tolerance index differed non-significantly. The potential of chelants to enhance Cd removal efficiency was in the order - EGTA (7.44%) > EDDS (6.05%) > NTA (4.12%) > CA (2.75%). EGTA and EDDS exhibited dose-dependent behavior for Cd extraction with 10 mM dose being more efficient than 5 mM dose. Structural equation model (SEM) depicted strong positive interaction of metal extraction parameters with chelants (Z-value = 11.61, p = 0.001). This study provides insights into the importance of selecting appropriate dose of biodegradable chelants for Cd extraction, as high chelant concentration might also result in phytotoxicity. In the future, phytoextraction potential of these chelants needs to be examined through field studies under natural environmental conditions.

A critical review on the phytoremediation of heavy metals from environment: Performance and challenges

Phytoremediation is an effective, green and economical technique. Different types of phytoremediation methods can be used for the reduction of heavy metal contaminations, such as phytoextraction, phytovolatilization, phytostabilization and phytofiltration. The biomass of plants and the bioavailability of heavy metals in soil are the key factors affecting the efficiency of phytoremediation. It's worth noting that the low remediation efficiency and the lack of effective disposal methods for contaminated biomass have limited its development and application. At present, biological, physical, chemical, agronomic and genetic approaches have been used to enhance phytoremediation. Disposal methods of contaminated biomass usually include pyrolysis, incineration, composting and compaction. They are effective, but are costly and have security problems. Improper disposal of contaminated biomass can lead to leaching of heavy metals. The leaching possibility of different forms of heavy metal in plants is different. Hence, it has great significance to explore the different forms of heavy metals in plants which can help to explore appropriate disposal methods. According to the challenges of phytoremediation, we put forward some views and recommendations for the sustainable and rapid development of phytoremediation technology.

Effect of using Celosia argentea grown from seeds treated with a magnetic field to conduct Cd phytoremediation in drought stress conditions

The mechanisms of the stimulatory effect of external magnetic fields on plant growth have been revealed; however, the role of magnetic fields in the efficiency of phytoremediation with Celosia argentea grown under drought stress which results in detrimental influences on food security has not been reported. Therefore, this study evaluated the physiological responses of C. argentea to the interactions between exposure to a magnetic field and drought stress. Compared with a control, a drought treatment negatively affected the dry weight, transpiration rate, and Cd extraction efficiency of the species and caused oxidative damage in plant cells, as manifested by the increase in malondialdehyde levels and antioxidant enzyme activities. The biomass production, pigment levels, Cd content, and phytoremediation efficiency of the plant were positively affected by all magnetic field treatments compared to the control. All magnetic treatments, except those at 30 mT, alleviated the detrimental effects induced by a 10-day irrigation regime by enhancing the dry weight, chlorophyll content, and activities of antioxidant enzymes in the leaves of the plant. In terms of the interaction between pre-sowing magnetic field seed treatment and drought stress, a 100 mT treatment increased most of the measured parameters, particularly under a 3-day irrigation regime; this corresponded to the optimal phytoremediation efficiency. The results suggest that magnetic field treatment is a novel, economical, and practicable strategy by which to increase the efficiency of phytoremediation using C. argentea under drought stress.

Application of sulphate and cytokinin in assisted arsenic phytoextraction by industrial Cannabis sativa L

Phytoextraction is currently investigated to effectively remediate soil contaminated by metals and provide highly competitive biomass for energy production. This research aimed to increase arsenic (As) removal from contaminated soil using industrial Cannabis sativa L., a suitable energy crop for biofuel production. Assisted phytoextraction experiments were conducted on a microcosm scale to explore the ability of two friendly treatments, sodium sulphate (SO₄) and exogenous cytokinin (CK), in increasing As phytoextraction efficiency. The results showed that the treatments significantly increased As phytoextraction. Cytokinin was the most effective agent for effectively increasing translocation and the amount of As in aerial parts of C. sativa. In fact, the concentration of As in the shoots of CK-treated plants increased by 172% and 44% compared to untreated and SO₄-treated plants, respectively. However, the increased As amount accumulated in C. sativa tissues due to the two treatments negatively affected plant growth. Arsenic toxicity caused a significant decrease in aerial C. sativa biomass treated with CK and SO₄ of about 32.7% and 29.8% compared to untreated plants, respectively. However, for our research purposes, biomass reduction has been counterbalanced by an increase in As phytoextraction, such as to consider C. sativa and CK an effective combination for the remediation of As-contaminated soils. Considering that C. sativa has the suitable characteristics to provide valuable resources for bioenergy production, our work can help improve the implementation of a sustainable management model for As contaminated areas, such as phytoremediation coupled with bioenergy generation.

Effects of plant growth regulator and chelating agent on the phytoextraction of heavy metals by Pfaffia glomerata and on the soil microbial community

Pfaffia glomerata is a candidate for the remediation of heavy metal-contaminated soil, but phytoremediation efficiency requires enhancement. In this study, we evaluated how application of DA-6, EDTA, or CA affected the growth and heavy metal accumulation of P. glomerata and soil microorganisms. We found that P. glomerata removed more Cd and Zn than Pb or Cu from contaminated soil. When compared to the control, application of DA-6, CA, or CA + DA-6 increased plant biomass and increased stem Cd concentration by 1.28-, 1.20-, and 1.31-fold respectively; increased leaf Cd concentration by 1.25-, 1.28-, and 1.20-fold, respectively; and increased the total quantity of Cd extracted by 1.37-, 1.37-, and 1.38-fold, respectively. When compared to the control, application EDTA or EDTA + DA-6 significantly increased the soil available metal and Na concentrations, which harmed plant growth. Application of EDTA or EDTA + DA-6 also significantly decreased the Cd concentration in roots and stems. 16S rRNA high-throughput sequencing analysis revealed that application of EDTA or CA alone to soil significantly reduced the richness and diversity of soil bacteria, while foliar spraying of DA-6 combined with EDTA or CA slightly alleviated this reduction. EDTA or CA addition significantly changed the proportion of Actinobacteria and Proteobacteria. In addition, EDTA or CA addition caused changes in soil properties (e.g. heavy metal availability, K concentration, Na concentration, soil pH, soil CEC, and soil DOC concentration) that were associated with changes in the bacterial community. EDTA addition mainly affected the soil bacterial community by changing soil DOC concentration, the soil available Pb and Na concentration, and CA addition mainly affected the soil bacterial community by changing the soil available Ca concentration.

Aqueous extracts from the selected hyperaccumulators used as soil additives significantly improve accumulation capacity of Solanum nigrum L. for Cd and Pb

The effects of soil treatment with aqueous extracts from three hyperaccumulators on Cd and Pb accumulation by Solanum nigrum L. were determined. The stem (S-RG) and leaf extracts (L-RG) of Rorippaglobosa (Turcz.) Thell., and stem extract (S-BP) of Bidens pilosa L. significantly enhanced Cd and Pb total accumulation capacity of S. nigrum compared to control (by 44 %, 47 %, and 29 % for Cd and by 28 %, 28 % and 21 % for Pb, respectively), while EDTA caused its 9 % and 15 % decrease due to the plant biomass reduction (by 33 %). The leaching experiments reflected affinity of additives to metal mobilization in soils. The concentrations of total organic acid in S-RG, L-RG and S-BP were the highest among studied extracts, which besides the beneficial effect on the soil environment (microbe number and enzyme activities), may be partial reasons of strong promotion of S. nigrum accumulation capacity for Cd and Pb. It was shown that hyperaccumulation properties of a plant are not a prerequisite of enhancing effect of the plant-based soil additive on the metal accumulation capacity of the target living hyperaccumultor. The plant-based chelators were found to be promising candidates for EDTA and other chemicals replacement in promoting efficient and environmentally safe phytoremediation.

Chelator complexes enhanced Amaranthus hypochondriacus L. phytoremediation efficiency in Cd-contaminated soils

The use of degradable chelating agent to enhance phytoextraction is a promising and low-cost method for remediation of heavy metals-polluted soil. However, very limited information is available regarding the effect of chelating agent combinations on plant growth and its capacity to extract metals. In this study, a pot experiment was conducted to evaluate the applicability of [N, N]-bis glutamic acid (GLDA), nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA), [S, S]- ethylenediamine disuccinic acid (EDDS), and citric acid (CA) alone and in combination to enhance the phytoextraction efficiency of amaranth (Amaranthus hypochondriacus L.) in two Cd-contaminated agricultural soils (S₁ soil 2.12 mg/kg and S₂ soil 2.89 mg/kg; the environmental standard value of Cd in agricultural soils in China is lower than 0.8 mg/kg). The results showed that, except for EDDS, other treatments had no obvious effect on plant biomass, and even promoted biomass increase to reach 1.06 (S1), 2.07 (S2) g/pot. The increase in total Cd extraction amount by 5 mM of single chelators GLDA and NTA reached 3.87 and 2.81 (S1), and 3.28 and 2.50 (S2) times that of the control group, respectively. For complexed chelating agents, G-N (GLDA + NTA) combinations (GLDA = 3 mM, NTA = 2 mM) extracted the highest amount of Cd compared with other treatments, reaching 0.36 and 0.52 mg/pot (4.50 and 3.71 times that of the control group), respectively. The order of extraction amount was G-N > GLDA > NTA > G-E (GLDA + EDDS) > G-C (GLDA + CA) > CA (5 mM total Cd concentration). Moreover, soil enzyme activity of G-N treatment increased significantly compared to that of the control group, indicating the great application potential of a composite chelating agent relative to a single chelating agent. Therefore, degradable chelators, especially the G-N combination, can effectively increase the available Cd content and greatly enhance the ability of plants to absorb and transport Cd in soils.

The Early Stages of Mimetite Dissolution in EDTA Studied with Atomic Force Microscopy and Scanning Electron Microscopy

A mineral, mimetite Pb5(AsO4)3Cl, is one of the most insoluble minerals and continues to be considered a viable remedial strategy for immobilization of Pb and As from contaminated soils. It has been recognized that many well-known, naturally-occurring, and synthetic chelators strongly influence dissolution processes in near-surface geological environments. In this study, crystals of mimetite were observed in scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) before and after dissolution in EDTA (ethylene diamine tetra-acetic acid) solution. Direct in situ observations at room temperature made in an AFM fluid cell revealed that the grain surface roughness has increased due to development of etch pits. Both hexagonal and prismatic walls developed dissolution features between 0.6 and 1.2 µm, respectively, during duration of the experiment. AFM observations suggest surface-controlled dissolution dominated step retrieval on both prismatic and hexagonal surfaces. SEM observations showed the development of rounded edges on hexagonal walls and elongated, oval etch pits on the prismatic wall. These results, representing early dissolution patterns on mimetite surfaces, might suggest that low pH conditions in soils containing organic acids similar to EDTA might contribute to remobilization of Pb and As from mimetite when applied to stabilization of these toxic metals in contaminated soils.

Differentiation between physical and chemical effects of oil presence in freshly spiked soil during rhizoremediation trial

Petroleum contamination and its remediation via plant-based solutions have got increasing attention by environmental scientists and engineers. In the current study, the physiological and growth responses of two diesel-tolerant plant species (tolerance limit: 1500-2000 mg/kg), Italian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum) and Birdsfoot trefoil (Lotus corniculatus), have been investigated in vegetable oil- and diesel oil-amended soils. A long-term (147-day) greenhouse pot experiment was conducted to differentiate the main focus of the study: physical and chemical effects of oil (vegetable and diesel) in freshly spiked soils via evaluating the plant performance and hydrocarbon degradation. Moreover, plant performance was evaluated in terms of seed germination, plant shoot biomass, physiological parameters, and root biomass. Addition of both diesel oil and vegetable oil in freshly spiked soils showed deleterious effects on seedling emergence, root/shoot biomass, and chlorophyll content of grass and legume plants. Italian ryegrass showed more sensitivity in terms of germination rate to both vegetable and diesel oil as compared to non-contaminated soils while Birdsfoot trefoil reduced the germination rate only in diesel oil-impacted soils. The results of the current study suggest that both physical and chemical effects of oil pose negative effects of plant growth and root development. This observation may explain the phenomenon of reduced plant growth in aged/weathered contaminated soils during rhizoremediation experiments.

Past and emerging topics related to electronic waste management: top countries, trends, and perspectives

A bibliometric analysis was performed to assess historical and recent research trends regarding e-waste studies from 1998 to 2018. Documents related to e-waste were identified from the Clarivate Analytics Web of Science© (WoS) database, and a total of 3311 academic articles was retrieved. The analysis was performed from four main aspects: (1) publication activity by year, by WoS category, and by geographic distribution; (2) journals; (3) most-cited papers; and (4) top 10 countries and author keyword analysis. The number of publications concerning e-waste issues has increased substantially over the last 20 years, especially in the environmental science category, and more than a third of the publications were produced in China (1181 records). Waste Management and Environmental Science & Technology were the most sought-after journals for disseminating the results. Studies related to "e-waste flow analysis," "recycling," "recovery of precious metals," and "risk assessment of recycling areas" have been the most common for several years. The analysis of keywords suggested that there are many topics on electronic waste and that each country has presented a different focus of research. Overall, the bibliometric analysis proved to be an efficient tool with which to monitor historical and current research trends and to evaluate the sheer volume of currently existing scientific literature on e-waste topics.

The effects of EDTA on plant growth and manganese (Mn) accumulation in Polygonum pubescens Blume cultured in unexplored soil, mining soil and tailing soil from the Pingle Mn mine, China

The effects of water-extractable Mn concentration, bioaccumulation factor (BAF), translocation factor (TF), and Mn uptake by Polygonum pubescens Blume cultured in the unexplored soil, mining soil and tailing soil from the Pingle Mn mine in China were quantified in a pot experiment to determine the effects of EDTA exposure on the success of phytoremediation. The results showed that EDTA significantly (P < 0.05) increased the water-extractable Mn concentration, and soils with different amounts of artificial disturbances had different responses to EDTA exposure. Low and medium EDTA concentrations might have positive effect on plant growth of P. pubescens cultured in the unexplored soil, as indicated by comparable increases in biomass, plant height and photosynthetic pigment content, but opposite results were found with high EDTA concentrations exposure. EDTA exposure had a negative effect on the growth of P. pubescens cultured in the mining soil and tailing soil. In general, the concentration of Mn in different tissues significantly (P < 0.05) increased as the EDTA concentration increased in each soil. The efficacy of Mn remediation by P. pubescens was enhanced in all three soils, with all EDTA treatments.