Anammox bacteria exhibit capacity to withstand long-term starvation stress: A proteomic-based investigation of survival mechanisms

Chemomixoautotrophy and stress adaptation of anammox bacteria: A review

Anaerobic ammonium oxidizing (anammox) bacteria, which were first discovered nearly three decades ago, are crucial for treating ammonium-containing wastewater. Studies have reported on the biochemical nitrogen conversion process and the physiological, phylogenic, and ecological features of anammox bacteria. For a long time, anammox bacteria were assumed to have a lithoautotrophic lifestyle. However, recent studies have suggested the functional versatility of anammox bacteria. Genome-based analysis and experiments with enrichment cultures have demonstrated the association of the metabolic activities of anammox bacteria with different stress conditions, revealing the importance of utilizing specific organic substances, including organoautotrophy, for growth and adaptation to stress conditions. Our understanding regarding the utilization and metabolism of organic substances and their associations with anammox reactions in anammox bacteria is growing but still incomplete. In this review, we summarize the effect of the utilization of organic substances by anammox bacteria under environmental stress conditions, emphasizing their potential organoautotrophic activity and metabolic flexibility. Although most anammox bacteria may utilize specific organic substances, Ca. Brocadia exhibited the highest level of mixoautotrophic activity. The environmental factors that substantially affect the organoautotrophic activities of anammox bacteria were also examined. This review provides a new perspective on the organoautotrophic capacity of anammox bacteria.

Potential Role of the Anammoxosome in the Adaptation of Anammox Bacteria to Salinity Stress

The underlying adaptative mechanisms of anammox bacteria to salt stress are still unclear. The potential role of the anammoxosome in modulating material and energy metabolism in response to salinity stress was investigated in this study. The results showed that anammox bacteria increased membrane fluidity and decreased mechanical properties by shortening the ladderane fatty acid chain length of anammoxosome in response to salinity shock, which led to the breakdown of the proton motive force driving ATP synthesis and retarded energy metabolism activity. Afterward, the fatty acid chain length and membrane properties were recovered to enhance the energy metabolic activity. The relative transmission electron microscopy (TEM) area proportion of anammoxosome decreased from 55.9 to 38.9% under salinity stress. The 3D imaging of the anammox bacteria based on Synchrotron soft X-ray tomography showed that the reduction in the relative volume proportion of the anammoxosome and the concave surfaces was induced by salinity stress, which led to the lower energy expenditure of the material transportation and provided more binding sites for enzymes. Therefore, anammox bacteria can modulate nitrogen and energy metabolism by changing the membrane properties and morphology of the anammoxosome in response to salinity stress. This study broadens the response mechanism of anammox bacteria to salinity stress.

The survival strategy of direct interspecies electron transfer-capable coculture under electron donor-limited environments

Direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) has been considered as an effective mechanism for interspecies electron exchange in microbial syntrophy. Understanding DIET-capable syntrophic associations under energy-limited environments is important because these conditions more closely approximate those found in natural subsurface environments than in the batch cultures in the laboratory. This study, investigated the metabolic dynamics and electron transfer mechanisms in DIET-capable syntrophic coculture of Geobacter metallireducens and Geobacter sulfurreducens under electron donor-limited condition. The wild-coculture and the mutant-coculture with a citrate synthase-deficient G. sulfurreducens exhibited similar rates of syntrophic metabolism under ethanol-limited and ethanol-replete conditions. Transcriptomic analyses revealed that, in the mutant-coculture in which interspecies electron exchange was the sole electron source for G. sulfurreducens, the transcription of genes associated with uptake hydrogenase in G. sulfurreducens were significantly repressed and thus DIET tended to be the preferred mode of interspecies electron exchange under electron donor-limited condition. To overcome electron donor limitation, c-type cytochromes in the coculture actively moved from outer membrane to extracellular environment, potentially via increased secretion of outer-membrane vesicles. These results suggested a preferred electron transfer mechanism for DIET-capable syntrophic communities' survival in the electron donor-limited environments, providing valuable insights into the biogeochemical processes mediated by DIET in natural and engineered environments.

Chameleon-like Anammox Bacteria for Surface Color Change after Suffering Starvation

Bacteria are often exposed to long-term starvation during transportation and storage, during which a series of enzymes and metabolic pathways are activated to ensure survival. However, why the surface color of the bacteria changes during starvation is still not well-known. In this study, we found black anammox consortia suffering from long-term starvation contained 0.86 mmol gVSS-1 cytochrome c, which had no significant discrepancy compared with the red anammox consortia (P > 0.05), indicating cytochrome c was not the key issue for chromaticity change. Conversely, we found that under starvation conditions cysteine degradation is an important metabolic pathway for the blackening of the anammox consortia for H2S production. In particular, anammox bacteria contain large amounts of iron-rich nanoparticles, cytochrome c, and other iron-sulfur clusters that are converted to produce free iron. H2S combines with free iron in bacteria to form Fe-S compounds, which eventually exist stably as FeS2, mainly in the extracellular space. Interestingly, FeS2 could be oxidized by air aeration, which makes the consortia turn red again. The unique self-protection mechanism makes the whole consortia appear black, avoiding inhibition by high concentrations of H2S and achieving Fe storage. This study expands the understanding of the metabolites of anammox bacteria as well as the bacterial survival mechanism during starvation.

Electron transfer mechanism of intracellular carbon-dependent DNRA inside anammox bacteria

Generally, anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) converts nitrite (NO2-) and ammonium (NH4+) to nitrogen gas (N2) but generates some nitrate (NO3-) (equivalent to 11% of inlet total nitrogen (TN)). Although it reported that anammox bacteria could degrade NO3- via dissimilatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) pathway using the intracellular carbon as the electron donor, it is still unclear the specific electron transfer mechanism in this intracellular carbon-dependent DNRA inside anammox bacteria, and whether the sole anammox bacteria could achieve higher TN removal efficiency more than the theoretical maximum of 89%. In this study, transcriptome analysis and metabolic inhibitor experiments demonstrated that NADH generated from the decomposition of the intracellular carbon (glycogen) supplied electrons for the NO3-conversion; the electrons were transferred from NADH to nitrate reductase (Nar) and nitrite reductase forming ammonium (NrfA) from ubiquinone (UQ) and complex III, respectively. Combining the intracellular carbon-dependent DNRA with normal anammox process, an average TN removal efficiency of 95% was achieved by the sole anammox bacteria in a sequencing batch reactor. Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) images and real-time fluorescence quantitative PCR (qPCR) results illustrated anammox bacteria could survive and proliferate in the SBR. Our work improved the understanding of the electron transfer mechanism inside anammox bacteria, and further exploit its potential in nitrogen pollutants removal.

Insights into the denitrifying phosphorus removal decay processes by profiling of the response mechanism of denitrifying phosphate-accumulating organisms to starvation stress

Starvation conditions were inevitably encountered by biological wastewater treatment systems. Four anaerobic starvation periods (5, 10, 16 and 20 days) were conducted to investigate the response mechanism of denitrifying phosphate-accumulating organisms (DPAOs) in order to dissect denitrifying phosphorus removal (DPR) decay processes. The denitrifying phosphorus removal performance suffered with the decay rate of 0.162 ± 0.022 d^-1 during 20-day starved duration. Metabolic activity decay was responsible 93.20 ± 0.11% for the damaged DPR performance, while biomass decay contributed to 6.79 ± 0.68%. The genus Dechloromonas affiliated to DPAOs exerted stronger survival adaptability to starvation with the abundance increasing from 1.98% to 3.15%, depended upon the endogenous consumption of intracellular polymers. In view of PHA-driven DPR mechanism of DPAOs, the metabolic activity was restricted by the depletion of available PHA. These results revealed the poorer stability but preponderant recovery of DPR system encountering with starvation.

Recovery of anammox process performance after substrate inhibition: Reactor performance, sludge morphology, and microbial community

Most of the current studies have focused on the inhibition of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) by substrates, however, little attention has been paid to the recovery process of the reactor after inhibition. Therefore, we investigated the changes in reactor performance, granular sludge structure, and microbial community during the recovery phase after being inhibited by a high nitrogen load for 15 d. The nitrogen removal rate of the reactorwasrestored to pre-inhibition levels after 75 d of recovery, and the stoichiometric ratio converged to the theoretical value. The surface of the granular sludge developed into a broccoli-like structure, and the Ca and P contents of the granules increased from 6.88% and 4.39% to 24.42% and 13.88%, respectively. The abundance of the anammox bacterium Candidatus brocadia increased from 5.86% to 12.10%, and network analysis indicated that SMA102 and SBR1031 were positively correlated with the occurrence of Candidatus brocadia.

Long-term effect of perfluorooctanoic acid on the anammox system based on metagenomics: Performance, sludge characteristic and microbial community dynamic

The effects of PFOA on the nitrogen removal performance, microbial community and functional genes of anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) sludge in an anaerobic baffled reactor (ABR) were investigated. The removal efficiencies of ammonia nitrogen (NH₄⁺-N) and nitrite (NO₂^--N) decreased from 93.90 ± 3.64% and 98.6 ± 1.84% to 77.81 ± 6.86% and 77.96 ± 1.88% when PFOA increased from 5 mg/L to 50 mg/L, respectively. X-ray photoelectron spectra analysis of the anammox sludge showed the presence of both C-F and CaF₂ forms of F. Metagenomics analysis of the anammox sludge in the first compartment illustrated that the relative abundance of Ca.Brocadia and Ca.Kuenenia decreased from 22.21% and 5.61% to 2.11% and 2.84% at 50 mg/L PFOA compared with that without PFOA. In addition, the nitrogen metabolism pathway showed that adding 50 mg/L PFOA decreased the expression of HzsB, HzsC, and Hdh (anammox genes) by 0.096%, 0.05% and 0.062%, respectively.

Achieving rapid mainstream deammonification through inoculating long-term refrigerated sidestream sludge in plug-flow fixed-bed biofilm reactor

The start-up of a stable mainstream deammonification requires sufficient anaerobic ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AnAOB). This study used a plug-flow fixed-bed reactor (PFBR) to verify the feasibility of establishing the mainstream deammonification system by inoculating the sidestream sludge after long-term refrigeration. A rapid resuscitation of the mainstream deammonification system was accomplished by controlling the front-end aeration rate of the PFBR. Results showed that the system was rapidly resuscitated in 44 days eventually with the nitrogen removal rate and nitrogen removal efficiency of 0.1 kg N·(m³·d)^-1 and 79.1%, respectively. Also, the efficient performance was secured by the proportionate approaching equilibrium of AnAOB and ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) activity of 2.35 ± 0.40 and 2.60 ± 0.29 mg N·(g VSS·h)^-1, respectively. In addition, Pearson correlation analysis revealed that AnAOB abundance (detected Candidatus Kuenenia) negatively correlated with the AOB (mainly Nitrosomonas)/AnAOB abundance ratio, while correlated positively with the residual ammonium concentration of a region. Furthermore, long-term refrigeration probably reduced the cross-feed relationship between AnAOB and other symbiotic organisms (Armatimonadetes and Chloroflexi) to maintain the basic metabolism. Meanwhile, extracellular polymeric substances produced by other genera (order Xanthomonadales and Pseudomonadales) decreased the mass transfer, protecting AnAOB from unfavorable conditions, thereby facilitating high AnAOB abundance during refrigeration. Thus, this study provides a promising perspective towards the practical applications of mainstream process.

Poly (vinyl alcohol)-alginate as potential matrix for various applications: A focused review

Advances in polymers have made significant contribution in diverse application oriented fields. Multidisciplinary applicability of polymers generates a range of strategies, which is pertinent in a wide range of fields. Blends of natural and synthetic polymers have spawned a different class of materials with synergistic effects. Specifically, poly (vinyl alcohol) (PVA) and alginate (AG) blends (PVAG) have demonstrated some promising results in almost every segment, ranging from biomedical to industrial sector. Combination of PVAG with other materials, immobilization with specific moieties and physical and chemical crosslinking could result in amendments in the structure and properties of the PVAG matrices. Here, we provide an overview of the recent developments in designing PVAG based matrix and complexes with their structural and functional properties. The article also provides a comprehensive outline on the applicability of PVAG matrix in wastewater treatment, biomedical, photocatalysis, food packaging, and fuel cells and sheds light on the challenges that need to be addressed. Finally, the review elaborates the future prospective of PVAG matrices in other unexplored fields like aircraft industry, nuclear science and space exploration.

Storage without nitrite or nitrate enables the long-term preservation of full-scale partial nitritation/anammox sludge

Bioaugmentation with summer harvested sludge during winter could compensate for bacterial activity loss but requires that sludge activity can be restored after storage. This study assesses the effect of temperature and redox adjustment during the storage over 180 days of partial nitritation/anammox (PN/A) granular resp. floccular sludge from potato processing resp. sludge reject water treatment. Anoxic storage conditions (in the presence of nitrite or nitrate and the absence of oxygen) resulted in a loss of 80-100% of the anammox bacteria (AnAOB) activity capacity at 20 °C and 4 °C, while anaerobic conditions (without oxygen, nitrite, and nitrate) lost only 45-63%. Storage at 20 °C was more cost-effective compared to 4 °C, and this was confirmed in the sludge reactivation experiment (20 °C). Furthermore, AnAOB activity correlated negatively with the electrical conductivity level (R² > 0.85, p < 0.05), so strong salinity increases should be avoided. No significant differences were found in the activity capacity of aerobic ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AerAOB) under different storage conditions (p > 0.1). The relative abundance of dominant AnAOB (Candidatus Brocadia) and AerAOB genera (Nitrosomonas) remained constant in both sludges. In conclusion, preserving PN/A biomass without cooling and nitrite or nitrate addition proved to be a cost-effective strategy.

Maintenance power requirements of anammox bacteria "Candidatus Brocadia sinica" and "Candidatus Scalindua sp."

Little is known about the cell physiology of anammox bacteria growing at extremely low growth rates. Here, "Candidatus Brocadia sinica" and "Candidatus Scalindua sp." were grown in continuous anaerobic membrane bioreactors (MBRs) with complete biomass retention to determine maintenance energy (i.e., power) requirements at near-zero growth rates. After prolonged retentostat cultivations, the specific growth rates (μ) of "Ca. B. sinica" and "Ca. Scalindua sp." decreased to 0.000023 h^-1 (doubling time of 1255 days) and 0.000157 h^-1 (184 days), respectively. Under these near-zero growth conditions, substrate was continuously utilized to meet maintenance energy demands (m_e) of 6.7 ± 0.7 and 4.3 ± 0.7 kJ mole of biomass-C^-1 h^-1 for "Ca. B. sinica" and "Ca. Scalindua sp.", which accorded with the theoretically predicted values of all anaerobic microorganisms (9.7 and 4.4 kJ mole of biomass-C^-1 h^-1at 37 °C and 28 °C, respectively). These m_e values correspond to 13.4 × 10^-15 and 8.6 × 10^-15 watts cell^-1 for "Ca. B. sinica" and "Ca. Scalindua sp.", which were five orders of magnitude higher than the basal power limit for natural settings (1.9 × 10^-19 watts cells^-1). Furthermore, the minimum substrate concentrations required for growth (S_min) were calculated to be 3.69 ± 0.21 and 0.09 ± 0.05 μM NO₂^- for "Ca. B. sinica" and "Ca. Scalindua sp.", respectively. These results match the evidence that "Ca. Scalindua sp." with lower maintenance power requirement and S_min are better adapted to energy-limited natural environments than "Ca. B. sinica", suggesting the importance of these parameters on ecological niche differentiation in natural environments.

Combination of 15N Tracer and Microbial Analyses Discloses N2O Sink Potential of the Anammox Community

Although nitrogen removal by partial nitritation and anammox is more cost-effective than conventional nitrification and denitrification, one downside is the production and accumulation of nitrous oxide (N₂O). The potential exploitation of N₂O-reducing bacteria, which are resident members of anammox microbial communities, for N₂O mitigation would require more knowledge of their ecophysiology. This study investigated the phylogeny of resident N₂O-reducing bacteria in an anammox microbial community and quantified individually the processes of N₂O production and N₂O consumption. An up-flow column-bed anammox reactor, fed with NH₄⁺ and NO₂^- and devoid of oxygen, emitted N₂O at an average conversion ratio (produced N₂O: influent nitrogen) of 0.284%. Transcriptionally active and highly abundant nosZ genes in the reactor biomass belonged to the Burkholderiaceae (clade I type) and Chloroflexus genera (clade II type). Meanwhile, less abundant but actively transcribing nosZ strains were detected in the genera Rhodoferax, Azospirillum, Lautropia, and Bdellovibrio and likely act as an N₂O sink. A novel ¹⁵N tracer method was adapted to individually quantify N₂O production and N₂O consumption rates. The estimated true N₂O production rate and true N₂O consumption rate were 3.98 ± 0.15 and 3.03 ± 0.18 mg_N·g_VSS^-1·day^-1, respectively. The N₂O consumption rate could be increased by 51% (4.57 ± 0.51 mg_N·g_VSS^-1·day^-1) with elevated N₂O concentrations but kept comparable irrespective of the presence or absence of NO₂^-. Collectively, the approach allowed the quantification of N₂O-reducing activity and the identification of transcriptionally active N₂O reducers that may constitute as an N₂O sink in anammox-based processes.

Glycogen metabolism of the anammox bacterium "Candidatus Brocadia sinica"

Presence of glycogen granules in anaerobic ammonium-oxidizing (anammox) bacteria has been reported so far. However, very little is known about their glycogen metabolism and the exact roles. Here, we studied the glycogen metabolism in "Ca. Brocadia sinica" growing in continuous retentostat cultures with bicarbonate as a carbon source. The effect of the culture growth phase was investigated. During the growing phase, intracellular glycogen content increased up to 32.6 mg-glucose (g-biomass dry wt)-1 while the specific growth rate and ATP/ADP ratio decreased. The accumulated glycogen begun to decrease at the onset of entering the near-zero growth phase and was consumed rapidly when substrates were depleted. This clearly indicates that glycogen was synthesized and utilized as an energy storage. The proteomic analysis revealed that "Ca. B. sinica" synthesized glycogen via three known glycogen biosynthesis pathways and simultaneously degraded during the progress of active anammox, implying that glycogen is being continuously recycled. When cells were starved, a part of stored glycogen was converted to trehalose, a potential stress protectant. This suggests that glycogen serves at least as a primary carbon source of trehalose synthesis for survival. This study provides the first physiological evidence of glycogen metabolism in anammox bacteria and its significance in survival under natural substrate-limited habitat.

Exogenous extracellular polymeric substances as protective agents for the preservation of anammox granules

The preservation of anammox granules is of great significance for the rapid start-up of the anammox process and improvement of performance stability. Therefore, it is necessary to explore an economical and stable preservation strategy. Exogenous extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) were used as protective agents for the preservation of anammox granules in this study. In brief, EPS from anammox sludge (A-EPS) and denitrifying sludge (D-EPS) were added to preserve anammox sludge at 4 °C and room temperature (15-20 °C). The results showed that A-EPS addition at 4 °C was the optimal condition for the preservation of anammox granules. After 90 days of preservation, the specific anammox activity (SAA) of the anammox granules remained at 92.7 ± 2.2 mg N g^-1 VSS day^-1 (remaining ratio of 33.4%), while that of the sludge with D-EPS addition at the same temperature was only 77.1 ± 3.2 mg N g^-1 VSS day^-1 (remaining ratio of 27.8%). The nitrogen removal efficiency of the experimental group with D-EPS at room temperature was 85.9%, and that of the A-EPS group reached 90.6% under the same temperature conditions. The abundance of the functional genes hzsA, hdh and nirS of the sludge (4 °C; A-EPS addition) after recovery were 138.5%, 317.1%, and 375.9%, respectively, of those of sludge from the D-EPS-added group at the same temperature. RDA revealed the contribution of proteins to the preservation process. Overall, this study provides an economical and robust strategy for the preservation of anammox granules.

Nutrient Limitation Causes Differential Expression of Transport- and Metabolism Genes in the Compartmentalized Anammox Bacterium Kuenenia stuttgartiensis

Anaerobic ammonium-oxidizing (anammox) bacteria, members of the "Candidatus Brocadiaceae" family, play an important role in the nitrogen cycle and are estimated to be responsible for about half of the oceanic nitrogen loss to the atmosphere. Anammox bacteria combine ammonium with nitrite and produce dinitrogen gas via the intermediates nitric oxide and hydrazine (anammox reaction) while nitrate is formed as a by-product. These reactions take place in a specialized, membrane-enclosed compartment called the anammoxosome. Therefore, the substrates ammonium, nitrite and product nitrate have to cross the outer-, cytoplasmic-, and anammoxosome membranes to enter or exit the anammoxosome. The genomes of all anammox species harbor multiple copies of ammonium-, nitrite-, and nitrate transporter genes. Here we investigated how the distinct genes for ammonium-, nitrite-, and nitrate- transport were expressed during substrate limitation in membrane bioreactors. Transcriptome analysis of Kuenenia stuttgartiensis planktonic cells showed that four of the seven ammonium transporter homologs and two of the nine nitrite transporter homologs were significantly upregulated during ammonium-limited growth, while another ammonium transporter- and four nitrite transporter homologs were upregulated in nitrite limited growth conditions. The two nitrate transporters were expressed to similar levels in both conditions. In addition, genes encoding enzymes involved in the anammox reaction were differentially expressed, with those using nitrite as a substrate being upregulated under nitrite limited growth and those using ammonium as a substrate being upregulated during ammonium limitation. Taken together, these results give a first insight in the potential role of the multiple nutrient transporters in regulating transport of substrates and products in and out of the compartmentalized anammox cell.

Inhibition of nitrite oxidizing bacterial activity based on low nitrite concentration exposure in an auto-recycling PN-Anammox process under mainstream conditions

For municipal wastewater with low temperature and ammonium, conventional oxygen-limited have difficulty achieving long-term stable inhibition of nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB) and stable nitritation. So a partial nitrification-anaerobic ammonium oxidation integrated reactor with independent partitions was used to investigate the feasibility of adding an auto-recycling system to promote low exposure of nitrite in the aerobic zone and to inhibit the NOB activity. The results showed that nitrite produced in the aerobic zone could be timely transported to the anaerobic zone for Anammox utilization, and the nitrite nitrogen concentration was diluted to keep within 1 mg/L in the aerobic zone by the effluent recycling. NOB growth was inhibited by nitrite deficiency. The maximum nitrogen removal rate of the reactor was 0.29 kg/(m³·d), and the nitrate nitrogen production rate of NOB was controlled within 0.04 kg/(m³·d). Nitrosomonas and Candidatus Kuenenia were found as functional species of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and Anammox bacteria, respectively.