Dissolved oxygen has no inhibition on methane oxidation coupled to selenate reduction in a membrane biofilm reactor

Changes in microbial communities during high-rate microbial selenate reduction in an up-flow anaerobic fluidized bed reactor

Biological fluidized bed reactor (FBR) is a promising treatment option for removing selenium oxyanions from wastewater by converting them into elemental selenium. The process can achieve high rates and be efficiently operated at low hydraulic retention times (HRT). However, the effects of HRT on the changes in microbial community in the FBR process have not been previously explored. In this study, dynamic changes of microbial communities both on biofilm carrier and in suspension of a selenate-reducing FBR were explored at various HRTs (0.3-120 h). Based on partial 16S rRNA gene sequencing of the microbial communities, alpha diversity of microbial communities in suspension rather than in the biofilm were impacted by low HRTs (0.3 h-3 h). Members from genera Geobacter, Geoalkalibacter, and Geovibrio were the main selenate-reducing bacteria on carrier throughout the FBR process. Genus Geobacter was dominant in FBR carrier at HRT of 24 h-120 h, whereas Geoalkalibacter and Geovibrio dominated at low HRT of 0.3 h-6 h. Suspended microbial communities detected in the FBR effluent were more sensitive to HRT changes than that in biofilm. "Shock loading" at HRT of 0.3 h had a great impact on microbial community compositions both in the biofilm and effluent. Reactor operation in batch mode and long HRT of 24 h helped recover the community from "shock loading" and improved selenite reduction and ethanol oxidation. Redundancy analysis revealed that HRT, influent pH and selenate loading were key operational parameters impacting both the FBR performance and the composition of microbial communities associated with both the FBR carrier and effluent. Overall, the microbial communities in FBR biofilm flexibly responded to the changes of HRT and showed resilience to the temporary shock loading, enabling efficient selenate removal.

Impact of Nitrate on the Removal of Pollutants from Water in Reducing Gas-Based Membrane Biofilm Reactors: A Review

The membrane biofilm reactor (MBfR) is a novel wastewater treatment technology, garnering attention due to its high gas utilization rate and effective pollutant removal capability. This paper outlines the working mechanism, advantages, and disadvantages of MBfR, and the denitrification pathways, assessing the efficacy of MBfR in removing oxidized pollutants (sulfate (SO4-), perchlorate (ClO4-)), heavy metal ions (chromates (Cr(VI)), selenates (Se(VI))), and organic pollutants (tetracycline (TC), p-chloronitrobenzene (p-CNB)), and delves into the role of related microorganisms. Specifically, through the addition of nitrates (NO3-), this paper analyzes its impact on the removal efficiency of other pollutants and explores the changes in microbial communities. The results of the study show that NO3- inhibits the removal of other pollutants (oxidizing pollutants, heavy metal ions and organic pollutants), etc., in the simultaneous removal of multiple pollutants by MBfR.

Deterministic effect of oxygen level variation on shaping antibiotic resistome

An increase in acquisition of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) by pathogens under antibiotic selective pressure poses public health threats. Sub-inhibitory antibiotics induce bacteria to generate reactive oxygen species (ROS) dependent on dissolved oxygen (DO) levels, while molecular connection between ROS-mediated ARG emergence through DNA damage and metabolic changes remains elusive. Thus, the study investigates antibiotic resistome dynamics, microbiome shift, and pathogen distribution in hyperoxic (5-7 mg L-1), normoxic (2-4 mg L-1), and hypoxic (0.5-1 mg L-1) conditions using lab-scale bioreactor. Composite inoculums in the reactor were designed to represent comprehensive microbial community and AR profile from selected activated sludge. RT-qPCR and metagenomic analysis showed an increase in ARG count (100.98 ppm) with enrichment of multidrug efflux pumps (acrAB, mexAB) in hyperoxic condition. Conversely, total ARGs decreased (0.11 ppm) under hypoxic condition marked by a major decline in int1 abundance. Prevalence of global priority pathogens increased in hyperoxic (22.5%), compared to hypoxic (0.9%) wherein major decrease were observed in Pseudomonas, Shigella, and Borrelia. The study observed an increase in superoxide dismutase (sodA, sodB), DNA repair genes (nfo, polA, recA, recB), and ROS (10.4 µmol L-1) in adapted biomass with spiked antibiotics. This suggests oxidative damage that facilitates stress-induced mutagenesis providing evidence for observed hyperoxic enrichment of ARGs. Moreover, predominance of catalase (katE, katG) likely limit oxidative damage that deplete ARG breeding in hypoxic condition. The study proposes a link between oxygen levels and AR development that offers insights into mitigation and intervention of AR by controlling oxygen-related stress and strategic selection of bacterial communities.

Methane Oxidation Coupled to Selenate Reduction in a Membrane Bioreactor under Oxygen-Limiting Conditions

Microbial methane oxidation coupled to a selenate reduction process has been proposed as a promising solution to treat contaminated water, yet the underlying microbial mechanisms are still unclear. In this study, a novel methane-based membrane bioreactor system integrating hollow fiber membranes for efficient gas delivery and ultrafiltration membranes for biomass retention was established to successfully enrich abundant suspended cultures able to perform methane-dependent selenate reduction under oxygen-limiting conditions. The microbial metabolic mechanisms were then systematically investigated through a combination of short-term batch tests, DNA-based stable isotope probing (SIP) microcosm incubation, and high-throughput sequencing analyses of 16S rRNA gene and functional genes (pmoA and narG). We confirmed that the methane-supported selenate reduction process was accomplished by a microbial consortia consisting of type-II aerobic methanotrophs and several heterotrophic selenate reducers. The mass balance and validation tests on possible intermediates suggested that methane was partially oxidized into acetate under oxygen-limiting conditions, which was consumed as a carbon source for selenate-reducing bacteria. High-throughput 16S rRNA gene sequencing, DNA-SIP incubation with 13CH4, and subsequent functional gene (pmoA and narG) sequencing results collectively proved that Methylocystis actively executed partial methane oxidation and Acidovorax and Denitratisoma were dominant selenate-reducing bacteria, thus forming a syntrophic partnership to drive selenate reduction. The findings not only advance our understanding of methane oxidation coupled to selenate reduction under oxygen-limiting conditions but also offer useful information on developing methane-based biotechnology for bioremediation of selenate-contaminated water.

Intracellular electron competition in response to the oxygen pressure of the aerobic denitrification process in an O2-based membrane biofilm reactor (MBfR) for nitrate removal

This study quantitatively investigated the effect of dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration on aerobic denitrification, and showed the mechanism of aerobic denitrification from the perspective of electron competition by cultivating Pseudomonas stutzeri T13, a typical aerobic denitrifier, in an oxygen-based membrane biofilm reactor (O₂-based MBfR). The experiments showed that when the O₂ pressure increased from 2 to 10 psig , the average effluent DO concentration during steady-state phases increased from 0.02 to 4.23 mg/L, and the corresponding mean NO₃^--N removal efficiency slightly decreased from 97.2 % to 90.9 %. Compared to the maximum theoretical flux of O₂ in various phases, the actual O₂ transfer flux increased from a limited status (2.07 e^- eq m^-2 d^-1 at 2 psig) to an excessive status (5.58 e^- eq m^-2 d^-1 at 10 psig). The increase of DO inhibited the electron availability for aerobic denitrification, which decreased from 23.97 % to 11.46 %, accompanying the increased electron availability for aerobic respiration from 15.87 % to 28.36 %. Unlike the napA and norB genes, the expression of the nirS and nosZ genes was significantly affected by DO, with the highest relative fold-changes of 6.5 and 6.13 at 4 psig O₂, respectively. The results contribute to clarifying the mechanism of aerobic denitrification from the quantitative perspective of electron distribution and the qualitative perspective of gene expression, which benefits the control and practical application of aerobic denitrification for wastewater treatment.

Coupled Aerobic Methane Oxidation and Arsenate Reduction Contributes to Soil-Arsenic Mobilization in Agricultural Fields

Microbial oxidation of organic compounds can promote arsenic release by reducing soil-associated arsenate to the more mobile form arsenite. While anaerobic oxidation of methane has been demonstrated to reduce arsenate, it remains elusive whether and to what extent aerobic methane oxidation (aeMO) can contribute to reductive arsenic mobilization. To fill this knowledge gap, we performed incubations of both microbial laboratory cultures and soil samples from arsenic-contaminated agricultural fields in China. Incubations with laboratory cultures showed that aeMO could couple to arsenate reduction, wherein the former bioprocess was carried out by aerobic methanotrophs and the latter by a non-methanotrophic bacterium belonging to a novel and uncultivated representative of Burkholderiaceae. Metagenomic analyses combined with metabolite measurements suggested that formate served as the interspecies electron carrier linking aeMO to arsenate reduction. Such coupled bioprocesses also take place in the real world, supported by a similar stoichiometry and gene activity in the incubations with natural paddy soils, and contribute up to 76.2% of soil-arsenic mobilization into pore waters in the top layer of the soils where oxygen was present. Overall, this study reveals a previously overlooked yet significant contribution of aeMO to reductive arsenic mobilization.

Effects of treatment processes on AOC removal and changes of bacterial diversity in a water treatment plant

The effectiveness of different treatment processes on assimilable organic carbon (AOC) removal and bacterial diversity variations was evaluated in a water treatment plant. The van der Kooij technique was applied for AOC analysis and responses of bacterial communities were characterized by the metagenomics assay. Results show that the AOC concentrations were about 93, 148, 43, 51, 37, and 38 μg acetate-C/L in effluents of raw water basin, preozonation, rapid sand filtration (RSF), ozonation, biofiltration [biological activated carbon (BAC) filtration], and chlorination (clear water), respectively. Increased AOC concentrations were observed after preozonation, ozonation, and chlorination units due to the production of biodegradable organic matters after the oxidation processes. Results indicate that the oxidation processes were the main causes of AOC formation, which resulted in significant increases in AOC concentrations (18-59% increment). The AOC removal efficiencies were 47, 28, and 60% in the RSF, biofiltration, and the whole system, respectively. RSF and biofiltration were responsible for the AOC treatment and both processes played key roles in AOC removal. Thus, both RSF and biofiltration processes would contribute to AOC treatment after oxidation. Sediments from the raw water basin and filter samples from RSF and BAC units were collected and analyzed for bacterial communities. Results from scanning electron microscope analysis indicate that bacterial colonization was observed in filter materials. This indicates that the surfaces of the filter materials were beneficial to bacterial growth and AOC removal via the adsorption and biodegradation mechanisms. Next generation sequencing analyses demonstrate that water treatment processes resulted in the changes of bacterial diversity and community profiles in filters of RSF and BAC. According to the findings of bacterial composition and interactions, the dominant bacterial phyla were Proteobacteria (41% in RSF and 56% in BAC) followed by Planctomycetes and Acidobacteria in RSF and BAC systems, which might affect the AOC biodegradation efficiency. Results would be useful in developing AOC treatment and management processes in water treatment plants.

Cross-feeding interactions in short chain gaseous alkane-driven perchlorate and selenate reduction

Short chain gaseous alkanes (SCGAs) mainly consist of methane (CH₄), ethane (C₂H₆), propane (C₃H₈) and butane (C₄H₁₀). The first three SCGAs have been shown to remove perchlorate (ClO₄^-) and selenate (SeO₄^2-), yet it is unknown whether C₄H₁₀ is available to reduce these contaminants. This study demonstrated that C₄H₁₀ fed biofilms were capable of reducing ClO₄^- and SeO₄^2- to chloride (Cl^-) and elemental selenium (Se⁰), respectively, by employing two independent membrane biofilms reactors (MBfRs). Batch tests showed that C₄H₁₀ and oxygen fed biofilms had much higher ClO₄^- and SeO₄^2- reduction rates and enhanced expression levels of bmoX and pcrA than that without C₄H₁₀ or O₂. Polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) accumulated in the biofilms when C₄H₁₀ was supplied, and they decomposed for driving ClO₄^- and SeO₄^2- reduction when C₄H₁₀ was absent. Moreover, we revisited the literature and found that a cross-feeding pathway seems to be universal in microaerobic SCGA-driven perchlorate and selenate reduction processes. In the ClO₄^--reducing MBfRs, Mycobacterium primarily conducts C₂H₆ and C₃H₈ oxidation in synergy with Dechloromonas who performs perchlorate reduction, while both Mycobacterium and Rhodococcus carried out C₄H₁₀ oxidation with perchlorate-respiring Azospira as the partner. In the SeO₄^2--reducing MBfRs, Mycobacterium oxidized C₂H₆ solely or oxidized C₃H₈ jointly with Rhodococcus, while Burkholderiaceae likely acted as the selenate-reducing bacterium. When C₄H₁₀ was supplied as the electron donor, both Mycobacterium and Rhodococcus conducted C₄H₁₀ oxidation in synergy with unknow selenate-reducing bacterium. Collectively, we confirm that from CH₄ to C₄H₁₀, all SCGAs could be utilized as electron donors for bio-reduction process. These findings offer insights into SCGA-driven bio-reduction processes, and are helpful in establishing SCGA-based technologies for groundwater remediation.

Roles of Oxygen in Methane-dependent Selenate Reduction in a Membrane Biofilm Reactor: Stimulation or Suppression

Although methane (CH₄) has been proven to be able to serve as an electron donor for bio-reducing various oxidized contaminants (e.g., selenate (SeO₄^2-)), little is known regarding the roles of oxygen in methane-based reduction processes. Here, a methane-based membrane biofilm reactor (MBfR) was established for evaluating the effects of oxygen supply rates on selenate reduction performance and microbial communities. The oxygen supply rate played a dual role (stimulatory or suppressive effect) in selenate reduction rates, depending on the presence or absence of dissolved oxygen (DO). Specifically, selenate reduction rate was substantially enhanced when an appropriate oxygen rate (e.g., 12 to 184 mg/L^.d in this study) was supplied but with negligible DO. The highest selenate reduction rate (up to 34 mg-Se/L^.d) was obtained under an oxygen supply rate of 184 mg/L^.d. In contrast, excessive oxygen supply rate (626 mg/L^.d) would significantly suppress selenate reduction rate under DO level of 3 mg/L. Accordingly, though the high oxygen supply rate (626 mg/L^.d) would promote the expression of pmoA (5.9 × 10⁹ copies g^-1), the expression level of narG (a recognized gene to mediate selenate reduction) would be significantly downregulated (6.1 × 10⁹ copies g^-1), thus suppressing selenate reduction. In contrast, the expression of narG gene significantly increased to 2.8 × 10¹⁰ copies g^-1, and the expression of pmoA gene could still maintain at 1.1 × 10⁹ copies g^-1 under an oxygen supply rate of 184 mg/L^.d. High-throughput sequencing targeting 16S rRNA gene, pmoA, and narG collectively suggested Methylocystis acts as the major aerobic methanotroph, in synergy with Arthrobacter and Variovorax which likely jointly reduce selenate to selenite (SeO₃^2-), and further to elemental selenium (Se⁰). Methylocystis was predominant in the biofilm regardless of variations of oxygen supply rates, while Arthrobacter and Variovorax were sensitive to oxygen fluctuation. These findings provide insights into the effects of oxygen on methane-dependent selenate reduction and suggest that it is feasible to achieve a higher selenate removal by regulating oxygen supply rates.

Heavy metal reduction coupled to methane oxidation：Mechanisms, recent advances and future perspectives

Methane emission has contributed greatly to the global warming and climate change, and the pollution of heavy metals is an important concern due to their toxicity and environmental persistence. Recently, multiple heavy metals have been demonstrated to be electron acceptors for methane oxidation, which offers a potential for simultaneous methane emission mitigation and heavy metal detoxification. This review provides a comprehensive discussion of heavy metals reduction coupled to methane oxidation, and identifies knowledge gaps and opportunities for future research. The functional microorganisms and possible mechanisms are detailed in groups under aerobic, hypoxic and anaerobic conditions. The potential application and major environmental significances for global methane mitigation, the elements cycle and heavy metals detoxification are also discussed. The future research opportunities are also discussed to provide insights for further research and efficient practical application.

Development of simultaneous nitrification-denitrification and anammox and in-situ analysis of microbial structure in a novel plug-flow membrane-aerated sludge blanket

This study proposed a novel one-stage plug-flow microaerobic sludge blanket (PMSB) with membrane aerated for treating low carbon to nitrogen (C/N) ratio municipal sewage. The performance of simultaneous nitrification, denitrification, and anammox in the reactor was investigated. The results illustrated that the removal efficiencies of ammonium and total nitrogen (TN) were 93.2% and 87.1% with a C/N ratio of 4. High throughput sequencing revealed that aerobic bacteria, anaerobic bacteria and facultative anaerobe could co-exist at the same time in the sludge blanket. Meanwhile, a notable correlation between the oxygen concentration and the distance of the membrane module was analyzed. It was shown that the microbial community of functional bacteria developed in different aeration sites due to the oxygen concentration gradient. Microbial community structure was analyzed depending on the sludge stratification in the sludge blanket.

NC10 bacteria promoted methane oxidation coupled to chlorate reduction

The strictly anaerobic serum bottles were applied to investigate methane oxidation coupled to chlorate (ClO₃^-) reduction (MO-CR) without exogenous oxygen. 0.35 mM ClO₃^- was consumed within 20 days at the reduction rate of 17.50 μM/d, over three times than that of ClO₄^-. Chlorite (ClO₂^-) was not detected throughout the experiment and the mass recovery of Cl^- was over 89%. Isotope tracing results showed most of ¹³CH₄ was oxided to CO₂, and the electrons recovery reached to 77.6%. Small amounts of ¹³CH₄ was consumed for DOC production probably through aerobic methane oxidation process, with oxygen generated from disproportionation reaction. In pMMO (key enzyme in aerobic oxidation of methane) inhibition tests, ClO₃^- reduction rate was slowed to 7. 0 μmol/d by 2 mM C₂H₂, real-time quantitative PCR also showed the transcript abundance of pMMO and Cld were significantly dropped at the later period of experiment, indicating that the O₂ disproportionated from ClO₂^- was utilized to active CH₄. NC10 bacteria Candidatus Methylomirabilis, related closely to oxygenic denitrifiers M. oxyfera, was detected in the system, and got enriched along with chlorate reduction. Several pieces of evidence supported that NC10 bacteria promoted CH₄ oxidation coupled to ClO₃^- reduction, these oxygenic denitrifiers may perform ClO₂^- disproportionation to produce O₂, and then oxidized methane intracellularly.

A mixed consortium of methanotrophic archaea and bacteria boosts methane-dependent selenate reduction

Though methane-based selenate reduction has been reported, neither the selenate load nor the removal rate could satisfy practical applications, thus limiting this technique to bio-remediate selenate pollution. In the present study, using a membrane biofilm batch reactor (MBBR), we successfully enriched a consortium performing methane-dependent selenate reduction, with enhanced reduction rates from 16.1 to 28.9 μM-day^-1 under a comparable Se concentration to industrial wastewaters (i.e., ~500 μM). During active reduction, 16S rRNA gene copies of Archaea and Bacteria were both increased more than one order of magnitude. Clone library construction and high-throughput sequencing indicated that Methanosarcina and Methylocystis were the only methane-oxidizing microorganisms. The presence of 20 mM bromoethanesulphonate or 0.15 mM acetylene both significantly, but not completely, inhibited methane-dependent selenate reduction, indicating the concurrent contributions of methanotrophic archaea and bacteria. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) revealed that archaea directly adhered to the surface of the membrane while bacteria were in the outer layer, together forming the mature biofilm. This study highlights the crucial role of both methanotrophic archaea and bacteria in methane-dependent selenate reduction, and lays foundations in applying methane to bio-remediate practical selenate pollution.

Why does sulfate inhibit selenate reduction: Molybdenum deprivation from Mo-dependent selenate reductase

Selenium pollution has become an increasingly serious global concern. Methane-fed selenate reduction has proven to be of great interest for the bioremediation of selenate-contaminated waters even with the coexistence of nitrate and dissolved oxygen. However, it is unclear if the common concurrent sulfate anion affects selenate removal. To address this question, we first introduced selenate (SeO₄^2-) as the sole influent electron acceptor in a CH₄-fed membrane biofilm reactor (CH₄-MBfR); then we added different concentrations of sulfate (SO₄^2-). The initial selenate removal efficiency (∼90%) was decreased by 50% in the presence of 15.6 μM of sulfate and completely inhibited after loading with 171.9 μM of sulfate. 16S rRNA gene sequencing showed that the selenate-reducing bacteria decreased after the addition of sulfate. Metagenomic sequencing showed that the abundance of genes encoding molybdenum (Mo)-dependent selenate reductase reduced by >50% when exposed to high concentrations of sulfate. Furthermore, the decrease in the total genes encoding all Mo-oxidoreductases was much greater than that of the genes encoding molybdate transporters, suggesting that the inhibition of selenate reduction by sulfate was most likely via the direct competition with molybdate for the transport system, leading to a lack of available Mo for Mo-dependent selenate reductases and thus reducing their activities. This result was confirmed by a batch test wherein the supplementation of molybdate mitigated the sulfate effect. Overall, this study shed light on the underlying mechanism of sulfate inhibition on selenate reduction and laid the foundation for applying the technology to practical wastewaters.