Improvement of sewage sludge anaerobic digestion through synergistic effect combined trace elements enhancer with enzyme pretreatment and microbial community response

Ultrasonication as anaerobic digestion pretreatment to improve sewage sludge methane production: Performance and microbial characterization

A large amount of sludge is inevitably produced during sewage treatment. Ultrasonication (US) as anaerobic digestion (AD) pretreatment was implemented on different sludges and its effects on batch and semi-continuous AD performance were investigated. US was effective in sludge SCOD increase, size decrease, and CH4 production in the subsequent AD, and these effects were enhanced with an elevated specific energy input. As indicated by semi-continuous AD experiments, the mean daily CH4 production of US-pretreated A2O-, A2O-MBR-, and AO-AO-sludge were 176.9, 119.8, and 141.7 NmL/g-VSadded, which were 35.1%, 32.1% and 78.2% higher than methane production of their respective raw sludge. The US of A2O-sludge achieved preferable US effects and CH4 production due to its high organic content and weak sludge structure stability. In response to US-pretreated sludge, a more diverse microbial community was observed in AD. The US-AD system showed negative net energy; however, it exhibited other positive effects, e.g., lower required sludge retention time and less residual total solids for disposal. US is a feasible option prior to AD to improve anaerobic bioconversion and CH4 yield although further studies are necessary to advance it in practice.

Metataxonomic Studies to Evaluate the Beneficial Effect of Enzymatic Pretreatment on the Anaerobic Digestion of Waste Generated in Turkey Farming

Turkey litter waste is lignocellulosic and keratinous, requiring prior enzymatic treatment to facilitate fiber hydrolysis and utilization by microorganisms in anaerobic digestion (AD) process. The understanding of the performance of microorganisms in AD can be facilitated through molecular biology and bioinformatics tools. This study aimed to determine the taxonomic profile and functional prediction of microbial communities in the AD of turkey litter waste subjected to enzymatic pretreatment and correlate it with operational parameters. The tests involved the use of turkey litter (T) at 25 g L-1 of volatile solids, a granular inoculum (S) (10% m/v), and the addition of cellulase (C), and pectinase (P) enzymes at four concentrations. The use of enzymes increased methane production by 19% (turkey litter, inoculum, and cellulase-TSC4) and 15% (turkey litter, inoculum, and enzymatic pectinase-TSP4) compared to the control (turkey litter and inoculum-TS), being more effective in TSC4 (667.52 mLCH4), where there was consumption of acetic, butyric, and propionic acids. The pectinase assay (TSP4) showed a methane production of 648 mLCH4 and there was the accumulation of metabolites. Cellulolytic microorganisms Bacteroides, Ruminofilibacter, Lachnospiraceae, Ruminococcaceae, and Methanosaeta were favored in TSC4. In TSP4, the predominant genus was Macellibacteroides and Methanosarcina, and genes involved in methylotrophic methanogenesis were also found (mtaB, mtmB, and mtbB). Enzymes involved in hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis were identified in both assays (TSC4 and TSP4). Molecular tools helped to understand the metabolic routes involved in AD with enzymatic treatment, allowing the elaboration of strategies to improve the sustainable degradation of turkey litter waste.

Evaluation of initial pH and urea hydrogen peroxide (UHP) co-pretreatment on waste-activated sludge

Wastewater treatment and conversion into renewable energy sources have been of great interest in recent times due to growing environmental pollution concerns and need for sustainable energy sources. Sewage sludge treatment can convert sludge into renewable energy. In this study, the impact of initial pH and urea hydrogen peroxide (UHP) co-pretreatment on sludge hydrolysis and anaerobic digestion was investigated. The pH of sludge was initially adjusted to 7, 9, and 11 before the addition of 8 mmol/g VS UHP. Under 24 h pretreatment, alkaline medium and UHP effectively enhanced sludge solubilization and hydrolysis. The combination of chemical, sonication, and centrifugation improved the extraction of extracellular polymerase substances released in soluble state. Secondly, anaerobic digestion was performed for 11 days to determine the influence of a lower mesophilic temperature (20 °C) and retention time on the pretreated sludge. The highest NH4+-N concentration of 5.32 g/L was recorded in pH 7+UHP. The most significant total VFA concentration of 13.1 g COD/L was observed in pH 7+UHP on day 9. Acetic acid, isovaleric acid and propionic acid accounted for 80%-83% of the total VFA composition in all pretreated reactors. Lower mesophilic temperature efficiently optimized UHP and VFA production in the pretreated reactors. Microbial metabolism was stabilized under a longer retention time. Alkaline pH and longer retention time elevated NH4+-N and VFA concentration. The results showed that initial pH and UHP co-pretreatment of waste activated sludge offer an alternative pathway for enhancing sludge hydrolysis and VFA production applicable in sludge treatment.

Enzyme enhanced lactic acid fermentation of swine manure and apple waste: Insights from organic matter transformation and functional bacteria

Anaerobic co-fermentation is a favorable way to convert agricultural waste, such as swine manure (SM) and apple waste (AW), into lactic acid (LA) through microbial action. However, the limited hydrolysis of organic matter remains a main challenge in the anaerobic co-fermentation process. Therefore, this work aims to deeply understand the impact of cellulase (C) and protease (P) ratios on LA production during the anaerobic co-fermentation of SM with AW. Results showed that the combined use of cellulase and protease significantly improved the hydrolysis during the enzymatic pretreatment, thus enhancing the LA production in anaerobic acidification. The highest LA reached 41.02 ± 2.09 g/L within 12 days at the ratio of C/P = 1:3, which was approximately 1.26-fold of that in the control. After a C/P = 1:3 pretreatment, a significant SCOD release of 45.34 ± 2.87 g/L was achieved, which was 1.13 times the amount in the control. Moreover, improved LA production was also attributed to the release of large amounts of soluble carbohydrates and proteins with enzymatic pretreated SM and AW. The bacterial community analysis revealed that the hydrolytic bacteria Romboutsia and Clostridium_sensu_stricto_1 were enriched after enzyme pretreatment, and Lactobacillus was the dominant bacteria for LA production. This study provides an eco-friendly technology to enhance hydrolysis by enzymatic pretreatment and improve LA production during anaerobic fermentation.

Pyrrhotite-dependent microbial reduction and magnetic separation for efficient vanadium detoxification and recovery in contaminated aquifer

Microbial reduction under anaerobic condition is a promising method for remediating vanadate [V(V)] contamination in aquifers, while V(V) may be re-generated with redox fluctuations. The inability to remove vanadium after remediation has become a key issue limiting bioremediation. In this study, we proposed the use of pyrrhotite, a natural mineral with magnetic properties, to immobilize V(V) to insoluble V(IV) under microbial action and remove vanadium from the aquifer using a magnetic field, which could avoid the problem of V(V) recontamination under redox fluctuating conditions. Up to 49.0 ± 4.7 % of vanadium could be removed from the aquifer by the applied magnetic field, and the vanadium in the aquifer after the reaction was mainly in the acid-extractable and reducible states. pH had a strong effect on the magnetic recovery of V(V), while the influence of initial V(V) concentration was weak. Microbial community structure analysis showed that Thiobacillus, Proteiniphilum, Fermentimonas, and Desulfurivibrio played key roles for V(V) reduction and pyrrhotite oxidation. Structural equation model indicated the positive correlation between these genera with the magnetic recovery of vanadium. Real time-qPCR confirmed the roles of functional genes of V(V) reduction (napA and nirK) and SO42- reduction (dsrA) in such biological processes. This study provides a novel route to sustainable V(V) remediation in aquifers, with synchronous recovery of vanadium resources without rebound.

Compound mutation by ultraviolet and diethyl sulfate of protease producing thermophilic bacteria to hydrolyze excess sludge

Excess sludge (ES), a resource-rich organic waste, can be solubilized by thermophilic enzymes to extract proteins for sludge reduction and resources recovery. To solve the problems of low hydrolysis effect of ES and low enzyme producing ability of wild thermophilic bacteria, ultraviolet and diethyl sulfate (UV-DES) were adopted to mutate thermophilic bacteria in this study. Mutation sites were detected and annotated by whole genome sequencing analysis. The results showed that UV-DES mutagenesis could effectively improve enzyme-producing capacity of thermophilic bacteria and promote the hydrolysis of ES. The protease activity of the mutant strain KT16 was 46.7 % higher than that of the original strain DC8. The protein extraction rate with enzyme produced by KT16 reached 83.3 %. The total content of proteins recycled through KT16 enzyme solution was 3539.6 mg·L-1, 18.4 % higher than that of DC8. This work provided a theoretical idea and technical guidance for the protein recovery from ES.

Enzyme-enhanced acidogenic fermentation of waste activated sludge: Insights from sludge structure, interfaces, and functional microflora

Anaerobic fermentation is widely installed to recovery valuable resources and energy as CH4 from waste activated sludge (WAS), and its implementation in developing countries is largely restricted by the slow hydrolysis, poor efficiency, and complicate inert components therein. In this study, enzyme-enhanced fermentation was conducted to improve sludge solubilization from 283 to 7728 mg COD/L and to enhance volatile fatty acids (VFAs) yield by 58.6 % as compared to the conventional fermentation. The rapid release of organic carbon species, especially for tryptophan- and tyrosine-like compounds, to outer layer of extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) occurred to reduce the structural complexity and improve the sludge biodegradability towards VFAs production. Besides, upon enzymatic pretreatment the simultaneous exposure of hydrophilic and hydrophobic groups on sludge surfaces increased the interfacial hydrophilicity. By quantitative analysis via interfacial thermodynamics and XDLVO theory, it was confirmed that the stronger hydrophilic repulsion and energy barriers in particle interface enhanced interfacial mass transfer and reactions involved in acidogenic fermentation. Meanwhile, these effects stimulate the fermentation functional microflora and predominant microorganism, and the enrichment of the hydrolytic and acid-producing bacteria in metaphase and the proliferation of acetogenic bacteria, e.g., Rubrivivax (+9.4 %), in anaphase also benefits VFAs formation. This study is practically valuable to recovery valuable VFAs as carbon sources and platform chemicals from WAS and agriculture wastes.

Effect of alkali pretreatment time on kitchen waste anaerobic digestion performance enhanced by alkali pretreatment combined with bentonite: performance enhancement, microbial community structure, and functional gene analysis

Kitchen waste was mainly composed of carbohydrates, lipids, and proteins. Anaerobic digestion (AD) of kitchen waste usually occurred acidification and further deteriorated. In our previous study, alkali pretreatment combined with bentonite (AP/Be) treatment was proved to enhance high solid AD of kitchen waste. However, effects of AP time on AP/Be were not yet studied. This study investigated the effects of AP time on AP/Be treatment on enhancing high solid AD. The results showed that compared with the control group, the cumulative methane production rate could be increased by 3.30 times (149.7 mL CH4/g VS) and the volatile solids (VS) reduction rate increased by 63.36%. Microbial community analysis showed that the relative abundance of Methanosarcina and Methanosaeta were increased from 6.49 and 7.83% to 47.14 and 16.39% respectively. Predictive functional analysis showed that AP/Be treatment increased the abundance of energy production and conversion, coenzyme transport, and metabolism. This study revealed the potential mechanism of AP/Be enhanced kitchen waste AD performance and AP/Be was a potential strategy to strengthen AD.

Effects of ozone on activated sludge: performance of anaerobic digestion and structure of the microbial community

The treatment and disposal of activated sludge are currently challenging tasks in the world. As a common biological engineering technology, biological fermentation exists with disadvantages such as low efficiency and complex process. Ozone pretreatments are commonly applied to improve this problem due to their high efficiency and low cost. In this study, the significant function of ozone in anaerobic fermentation gas production was verified with excess sludge. Compared with other untreated sludge, ozone pretreatment can effectively degrade activated sludge. After ozone treatment and mixing with primary sludge, the methane production of excess sludge increased by 49.30 and 50.78%, and the methanogenic activity increased by 69.99 and 73.83%, respectively. The results indicated that the mixing of primary sludge with excess sludge possessed synergistic effects, which contributed to the anaerobic fermentation of excess sludge. The results of microbial community structure exhibited that methanogenic processes mainly involve hydrogenogens, acidogens and methanogens. The relative abundance of both bacteria and microorganisms changed significantly in the early stage of hydraulic retention time, which coincided exactly with the gas production stage. This study provided a feasible pretreatment strategy to improve sludge biodegradability and revealed the role of microorganisms during anaerobic digestion.

Microbial biogeography of pit mud from an artificial brewing ecosystem on a large time scale: all roads lead to Rome

IMPORTANCE

Baijiu is a typical example of how humans employ microorganisms to convert grains into new flavors. Mud cellars are used as the fermentation vessel for strong-flavor Baijiu (SFB) to complete the decomposition process of grains. The typical flavor of SFB is mainly attributed to the metabolites of the pit mud microbiome. China has a large number of SFB-producing regions. Previous research revealed the temporal profiles of the pit mud microbiome in different geographical regions. However, each single independent study rarely yields a thorough understanding of the pit mud ecosystem. Will the pit mud microbial communities in different production regions exhibit similar succession patterns and structures under the impact of the brewing environment? Hence, we conducted research in pit mud microbial biogeography to uncover the impact of specific environment on the microbial community over a long time scale.

Metabolic responses and microbial community changes to long chain fatty acids: Ammonia synergetic co-inhibition effect during biomethanation

Anaerobic co-digestion is an established strategy for increasing methane production of substrates. However, substrates rich in proteins and lipids could cause a long chain fatty acids (LCFA)-ammonia synergetic co-inhibition effect. The microbial mechanisms of this co-inhibition are still unclear. The current study explored the effect of the synergetic co-inhibition on microbial community changes and prediction of metabolic enzymes to reveal the microbial mechanisms of the co-inhibition effect. The results indicated that during the synergetic co-inhibition, methanogens were mainly affected by ammonia. Decreased relative abundances of Petrimonas (82%) and Paraclostridium (67%) showed that ammonia inhibition contributed to the suppression of LCFA β-oxidation under the synergetic co-inhibition conditions. The accumulation of more LCFA could further suppress microorganisms' activities involved in several steps of anaerobic digestion. Finally, decrease of critical enzymes' abundances confirmed the synergetic co-inhibition effect. Overall, the current study provides novel insights for the alleviation of synergetic co-inhibition during anaerobic digestion.

Energy-saving pretreatments affect pelagic Sargassum composition and DNA metabarcoding reveals the microbial community involved in methane yield

Sargassum spp. flood the Caribbean coastline, causing damage to the local economy and environment. Anaerobic digestion (AD) has been proposed as an attractive option for turning macroalgae into valuable resources. Sargassum spp. has a complex composition that affects the microbial composition involved in AD which generates a low methane yield. This study aimed to improve the methane yield of pelagic Sargassum, using different energy-saving pretreatments and identifying the microbial community associated with methane production. We applied different energy-saving pretreatments to algal biomass and assessed the methane yield using a biomethane potential (BMP) test. The microbial communities involved in the AD of the best- and worst-performing methanogenic systems were analyzed by high-throughput sequencing. The results showed that pretreatment modified the content of inorganic compounds, fibers, and the C:N ratio, which had a strong positive correlation with BMP. The water washing pretreatment resulted in the best methane yield, with an increase of 38%. DNA metabarcoding analysis revealed that the bacterial genera Marinilabiliaceae_uncultured, DMER64, Treponema, and Hydrogenispora, as well as the archaea genera Methanosarcina, RumEn_M2, Bathyarchaeia, and Methanomassiliicocus, dominated the microbial community with a high methane yield. This study is the first to demonstrate the microbial community structure involved in the AD of Sargassum spp. The pretreatments presented in this study can help overcome the limitations associated with methane yield.

Sewage sludge pretreatment: current status and future prospects

Sewage sludge is regarded by wastewater treatment plants as problematic, from a financial and managerial point of view. Thus, a variety of disposal routes are used, but the most popular is methane fermentation. The proportion of macromolecular compounds in sewage sludges varies, and substrates treated in methane fermentation provide different amounts of biogas with various quality and quantity. Depending on the equipment and financial capabilities for methane fermentation, different methods of sewage sludge pretreatment are available. This review presents the challenges associated with the recalcitrant structure of sewage sludge and the presence of process inhibitors. We also examined the diverse methods of sewage sludge pretreatment that increase methane yield. Moreover, in the field of biological sewage sludge treatment, three future study propositions are proposed: improved pretreatment of sewage sludge using biological methods, assess the changes in microbial consortia caused with pretreatment methods, and verification of microbial impact on biomass degradation.

Metataxonomic characterization of the microbial community involved in the production of biogas with microcrystalline cellulose in pilot and laboratory scale

Biogas, produced in anaerobic digestion, is a sustainable alternative for generating energy from agro-industrial and municipal waste. Information from the microbiota active in the process expands the possibilities for technological innovation. In this study, taxonomic annotations, and functional prediction of the microbial community of the inoculum of two processes were carried out: an industrial unit (pilot-scale urban solid waste plant-IU) and a laboratory-scale reactor fed with swine and cattle waste (LS). The biochemical potential of biogas was obtained using tested inoculum with microcrystalline cellulose, obtaining 682 LN/kgVS (LSC-laboratory scale inoculum and microcrystalline cellulose), and 583 LN/kgVS (IUC-industrial unit inoculum and microcrystalline cellulose), which is equivalent to a recovery of 91.5% of total biogas to LSC. The phyla Synergistota and Firmicutes were more abundant in LS/LSC. In the IU/IUC (treatment of restaurant waste and customs seizures), there was a greater microbiological variety and a predominance of the Bacteroidota, Cloacimonadota, Firmicutes and Caldatribacteriota. The genus Methanosaeta predominated in the process, and it was possible to infer the genes (K01895, K00193 and K00625) related to acetoclastic pathway, as well as endoglucanases that are involved in the metabolism of cellulose (LSC). Terpenoids, polyketides, cofactors, and vitamin metabolism were higher in reactors that received different substrates (IU; IUC). The taxonomic and functional differences revealed the importance of determining the microbiota in the analysis of the potential of an inoculum, combined with the use of microcrystalline cellulose, which can provide optimization information in the production of clean energy.

Long-term rumen microorganism fermentation of corn stover in vitro for volatile fatty acid production

Rumen microorganisms have the ability to efficiently hydrolyze and acidify lignocellulosic biomass. The effectiveness of long-term rumen microorganism fermentation of lignocellulose in vitro for producing volatile fatty acids (VFAs) is unclear. The feasibility of long-term rumen microorganism fermentation of lignocelluose was evaluated in this study, and a stable VFA production was successfully realized for 120 d. Results showed that VFA concentration reached to 5.32-8.48 g/L during long-term fermentation. Hydrolysis efficiency of hemicellulose and cellulose reached 36.5%-52.2% and 29.4%-38.4%, respectively. A stable bacterial community was mainly composed of Prevotella, Rikenellaceae_RC9_gut_group, Ruminococcus, and Succiniclasticum. VFA accumulation led to a pH decrease, which caused the change of bacterial community structure. Functional prediction showed that the functional genes related to hydrolysis and acidogenesis of corn stover were highly expressed during long-term fermentation. The successful long-term rumen fermentation to produce VFAs is of great significance for the practical application of rumen microorganisms.

Enzymatic integrated in-situ advanced anaerobic digestion of sewage sludge for the removal of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes

Antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in sewage sludge can cause high ecotoxicological risks in the environment and public health concerns. The aims of this study were to establish enzymatic integrated in-situ advanced anaerobic digestion (AAD) by adding cellulase and papain as well as the two enzymes combined with zero valent iron (ZVI) directly into the anaerobic digesters to explore the removal of antibiotics and ARGs under the mesophilic condition (35 °C). The methane production potential during in-situ AAD was effectively improved. Papain and cellulase at 30 mg/gTSS were most effective in improving antibiotic removal. The removal of sulfamerazine (SMZ) and sulfadiazine (SMR) could reach 89.10 % and 71.75 %. Combined enzymes with ZVI also enhanced the removal of all target antibiotics, especially roxithromycin (ROX), SMZ and SMR most significantly. Except for sul1, tetA and tetB, the removal of ARGs by papain reached 6.33 %-82.15 %. The addition of cellulase effectively improved tetA removal. The combination of biological enzymes further enhanced the removal of qnrS and ermX. The tetG, tetB, sul3, ermX, ermT, qnrS, and aac(6')-IB-CR by combined enzymes with ZVI could even not be detected after digestion. Addition of papain, cellulase, and ZVI caused variations in the dominant bacteria. All target antibiotics presented significant positive correlations with the genera norank_f__Bacteroidetes_vadinHA17, norank_f__norank_o__SJA-15, norank_f__norank_o__Aminicenantales. Redundancy analysis showed archaea Methanosaeta and Candidatus_ Methanoacidiosum genera greatly contributed to antibiotics removal with the combination of enzymes and ZVI. Co-occurrence network analysis indicated the removal of ARGs was mainly based on the changes of existence of host bacteria.

Effects of mineral additives on antibiotic resistance genes and related mechanisms during chicken manure composting

In this study, two typical minerals (diatomite and bentonite) were applied during composting, and their influences on antibiotics, antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), intI1 and the bacterial communities were investigated. The relative abundance of total ARGs decreased by 53.72% and 59.54% in diatomite and bentonite addition compared with control on day 42. The minerals addition also reduced the relative abundance of intI1, as much as 41.41% and 59.81% in diatomite and bentonite treatments. Proteobacteria and Firmicutes were the dominant candidate hosts of the major ARGs. There was a significant correlation between total ARGs and intI1 during the composting. Structural equation models further demonstrated that intI1 and antibiotics were the predominant direct factors responsible for ARG variations, and composting properties and bacterial community composition also shifted the variation of ARG profiles by influencing intI1. Overall, these findings suggest that diatomite and bentonite could decrease the potential proliferation of ARGs in chicken manure.

Digested Sludge Quality in Mesophilic, Thermophilic and Temperature-Phased Anaerobic Digestion Systems

Anaerobic digestion (AD) technology is commonly used to treat sewage sludge from activated sludge systems, meanwhile alleviating the energy demand (and costs) for wastewater treatment. Most often, anaerobic digestion is run in single-stage systems under mesophilic conditions, as this temperature regime is considered to be more stable than the thermophilic one. However, it is known that thermophilic conditions are advantageous over mesophilic ones in terms of methane production and digestate hygienisation, while it is unclear which one is better concerning the digestate dewaterability. Temperature-phased anaerobic digestion (TPAD) is a double-stage AD process that combines the above-mentioned temperature regimes, by operating a thermophilic digester followed by a mesophilic one. The aim of this study is to compare the digestate quality of single-stage mesophilic and thermophilic AD and TPAD systems, in terms of the dewaterability, pathogenic safety and lower calorific value (LCV) and, based on the comparison, consider digested sludge final disposal alternatives. The research is conducted in lab-scale reactors treating waste-activated sludge. The dewaterability is tested by two methods, namely, centrifugation and mechanical pressing. The experimental results show that the TPAD system is the most beneficial in terms of organic matter degradation efficiency (32.4% against 27.2 for TAD and 26.0 for MAD), producing a digestate with a high dewaterability (8.1–9.8% worse than for TAD and 6.2–12.0% better than for MAD) and pathogenic safety (coliforms and Escherichia coli were not detected, and Clostridium perfringens were counted up to 4.8–4.9 × 103, when for TAD it was only 1.4–2.5 × 103, and for MAD it was 1.3–1.8 × 104), with the lowest LCV (19.2% against 15.4% and 15.8% under thermophilic and mesophilic conditions, respectively). Regarding the final disposal, the digested sludge after TAD can be applied directly in agriculture; after TPAD, it can be used as a fertilizer only in the case where the fermenter HRT assures the pathogenic safety. The MAD digestate is the best for being used as a fuel preserving a higher portion of organic matter, not transforming into biogas during AD.