Experimental insights into anodic oxidation of hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (GenX) on boron-doped diamond anodes

Integrating kinetic modeling and experimental insights: PFAS electrochemical degradation in concentrated streams with a focus on organic and inorganic effects

This study investigated the impact of organic and inorganic constituents on electrochemical degradation of per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in a sulfate-based brine from regeneration of spent ion exchange (IX) resin. The system's performance was assessed in the presence of natural organic matter (NOM) and common inorganic constituents: chloride, nitrate, and bicarbonate. Results revealed distinct outcomes based on constituent type, concentration, and specific PFAS variant. NOM hindered PFAS decomposition, especially for more hydrophobic compounds. Chloride reduced degradation and defluorination efficiencies through competitive interactions with PFAS for the anode's active sites and scavenging effects on SO4•- and •OH. Nitrate and bicarbonate minimally impacted degradation but significantly reduced defluorination. Investigating the electrochemical process in real brine solutions showed higher efficiency and lower electrical energy consumption when methanol was distilled, as methanol scavenges reactive radicals and competes for active anode sites. A kinetic model was also developed to determine the direct electron transfer (DET) and mass transfer coefficients for the species present, considering both surface and bulk solution interactions. The model predicted mass transfer (mol m-2 s-1) and DET (m2 mol-1 s-1) coefficients of 6:2 FTCA, PFOA, GenX, and PFBA to be (5.0 ×10-10, 3.7 ×1011), (1.0 ×10-9, 8.0 ×108), (6.0 ×10-8, 7.5 ×108), and (6.2 ×10-8, 4.2 ×108), respectively.

Complete Aqueous Defluorination of GenX (Hexafluoropropylene Oxide Dimer Acid Anion) by Pulsed Electrolysis with Polarity Reversal

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are extremely stable chemicals that are essential for modern life and decarbonization technologies. Yet PFAS are persistent pollutants that are harmful to human health. Hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (GenX), a replacement for the PFAS chemical perfluorooctanoic acid, continues to pollute waterways. In this study, we report the complete defluorination of GenX through electrocatalysis in aqueous LiOH electrolytes, utilizing high surface area anodes consisting of pulsed laser in liquid synthesized [NiFe]-(OH)₂ nanocatalysts on hydrophilic carbon fiber paper. Additional experiments with industrial nickel-iron alloy demonstrated exceptional stability for >100 hours. Including a brief interval of reversed polarity in pulsed electrolysis and optimizing the pulse train sequence enabled the complete defluorination of GenX. Our facile approach employs only nonprecious materials, does not require bisulfate or other auxiliary chemical agents that are consumed, and thus provides a promising strategy for alleviating the environmental impact of PFAS pollutants.

Surface fluorination mediated electro-oxidative degradation of HFPO-DA on boron-doped diamond electrode

Heptafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (HFPO-DA), as an alternative to perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), has been shown to pose similar environmental and health risks as other perfluorinated compounds. The electrochemical-based advanced oxidation processes are promising techniques for the treatment of perfluorinated compounds, and the boron-doped diamond (BDD) anode could degrade HFPO-DA under mild conditions. However, the roles of radicals in the degradation and how to overcome the steric hindrance of the -CF3 branch on the carboxyl group were not yet clear. In this study, we investigated the degradation mechanism of HFPO-DA on the BDD anode. Instead of other non-active anodes (PbO2 and SnO2 electrodes), HFPO-DA can be degradable on the BDD electrode with a rate constant logarithmic correlation to the applied current density. The hydroxyl radical (•OH) was one of the key factors in the degradation of HFPO-DA, accounting for almost 89% of the significant effect, and the direct electron transfer was the rate-limiting step in the degradation reaction. Physicochemical characterization including field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM), X-ray photo-electron spectroscopy (XPS), water contact angle, and electrochemical property indicated that the BDD electrode was fluorinated after electrolysis, the electrode surface became more hydrophobic due to the bonding of -CxFy, leading to a decrease in the electrochemically active area. Moreover, degradation products (pentafluoropropionic acid, trifluoroacetic acid, and fluorine ion) were detected and the mass balance of carbon and fluorine was calculated during the degradation. Therefore, a degradation mechanism for HFPO-DA was proposed, which involved direct electron transfer, decarboxylation, radical reaction, decarboxylation, and decarboxylation. The de-CF3 step initiated the fluorination of the BDD electrode, which was initiated by the defluorination process. This study contributes to the understanding of the electro-oxidative degradation of perfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acids and provides guidance for the application of electrochemical advanced oxidation processes.

Rethinking alternatives to fluorinated pops in aqueous environment and corresponding destructive treatment strategies

Alternatives are being developed to replace fluorinated persistent organic pollutants (POPs) listed in the Stockholm Convention, bypass environmental regulations, and overcome environmental risks. However, the extensive usage of fluorinated POPs alternatives has revealed potential risks such as high exposure levels, long-range transport properties, and physiological toxicity. Therefore, it is imperative to rethink the alternatives and their treatment technologies. This review aims to consider the existing destructive technologies for completely eliminating fluorinated POPs alternatives from the earth based on the updated classification and risks overview. Herein, the types of common alternatives were renewed and categorized, and their risks to the environment and organisms were concluded. The efficiency, effectiveness, energy utilization, sustainability, and cost of various degradation technologies in the treatment of fluorinated POPs alternatives were reviewed and evaluated. Meanwhile, the reaction mechanisms of different fluorinated POPs alternatives are systematically generalized, and the correlation between the structure of alternatives and the degradation characteristics was discussed, providing mechanistic insights for their removal from the environment. Overall, the review supplies a theoretical foundation and reference for the control and treatment of fluorinated POPs alternatives pollution.

Single-crystal vs polycrystalline boron-doped diamond anodes: Comparing degradation efficiencies of carbamazepine in electrochemical water treatment

The ongoing challenge of water pollution by contaminants of emerging concern calls for more effective wastewater treatment to prevent harmful side effects to the environment and human health. To this end, this study explored for the first time the implementation of single-crystal boron-doped diamond (BDD) anodes in electrochemical wastewater treatment, which stand out from the conventional polycrystalline BDD morphologies widely reported in the literature. The single-crystal BDD presented a pure diamond (sp3) content, whereas the three other investigated polycrystalline BDD electrodes displayed various properties in terms of boron doping, sp3/sp2 content, microstructure, and roughness. The effects of other process conditions, such as applied current density and anolyte concentration, were simultaneously investigated using carbamazepine (CBZ) as a representative target pollutant. The Taguchi method was applied to elucidate the optimal operating conditions that maximised either (i) the CBZ degradation rate constant (enhanced through hydroxyl radicals (•OH)) or (ii) the proportion of sulfate radicals (SO4•-) with respect to •OH. The results showed that the single-crystal BDD significantly promoted •OH formation but also that the interactions between boron doping, current density and anolyte concentration determined the underlying degradation mechanisms. Therefore, this study demonstrated that characterising the BDD material and understanding its interactions with other process operating conditions prior to degradation experiments is a crucial step to attain the optimisation of any wastewater treatment application.

Novel Defluorination Pathways of Perfluoroether Compounds (GenX): α-Fe2O3 Nanoparticle Layer Retains Higher Concentrations of Effective Hydrated Electrons

The development of efficient defluorination technology is an important issue because the kind of emerging pollutant of hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (GenX) as an alternative to perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) has the higher environmental risks. In the UV/bisulfite system, we first developed a hydrophobic confined α-Fe2O3 nanoparticle layer rich in oxygen vacancies, which accelerated the enrichment of HSO3- and GenX on the surface and pores through electrostatic attraction and hydrophobic interaction, retaining more hydrated electrons (eaq-) and rapidly destroying GenX under UV excitation. Especially, under anaerobic and aerobic conditions, the degradation percentage of GenX obtain nearly 100%, defluorination of GenX to 88 and 57% respectively. It was amazed to find that the three parallel H/F exchange pathways triggered by the rapid reactions of eaq- and GenX, which were unique to anaerobic conditions, improved the efficiency of fluoride removal and weaken the interference of dissolved oxygen and H+. Therefore, this study provided an available material and mechanism for sustainable fluoride removal from wastewater in aerobic and anaerobic conditions.

Kinetics and proposed mechanisms of hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (GenX) degradation via vacuum-UV (VUV) photolysis and VUV/sulfite processes

We investigated the degradation of hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (GenX) in water via VUV photolysis and VUV/sulfite reactions under nitrogen-saturated conditions. Approximately 35% and 90% of GenX were degraded in 3 h in the VUV photolysis and VUV/sulfite reaction. While GenX removal rate was highest at pH 6 in VUV photolysis, it increased under alkaline pHs, especially at pH 10, in VUV/sulfite reaction. Radical scavenging experiments showed that, while both eaq- and •H contributed to VUV photolysis, eaq- played a significant role and •OH had a negative effect during VUV/sulfite reaction. Two transformation products (TPs) (TFA and PFPrA) were identified in VUV photolysis, whereas five TPs (TFA, PFPrA, TP182, TP348, and TP366) were identified in VUV/sulfite reaction by LCMS/MS and LCQTOF/MS. Defluorination of GenX was observed with the defluorination efficiency after 6 h reaching 17% and 67% in the VUV photolysis and VUV/sulfite reactions, respectively. Degradation mechanism for GenX based on the identified TPs and the theoretical calculation confirmed the susceptibility of GenX to nucleophilic attack. The initial reactions for GenX decomposition were C-C and C-O bond cleavage in both reactions, whereas sulfonation followed by decarboxylation was observed only in the VUV/sulfite reaction. ECOSAR ecotoxicity simulation showed that the toxicities of the TPs were not as harmful as those of GenX.

Study on the importance of the reductive degradation of GenX in its overall electrochemical degradation process on different cathode materials

Per- and polyfluoro alkylated substances (PFAS) are well known for their recalcitrant nature caused by the abundance of CF bonds. It has been proven that electrochemical degradation is a potentially suitable technique for treating PFAS; however, most studies solely focus on electrochemical oxidation, with limited attention given to electrochemical reduction, and the relative contribution of the two towards the total PFAS degradation has not yet been elucidated. This manuscript reports an investigation on the contribution of electroreduction to the overall electrodegradation of a target PFAS, HFPO-DA (i.e. GenX), using a boron doped diamond (BDD) anode and different cathode materials (Cu, Ti, Au). The oxidation and reduction reactions were successfully decoupled from each other and studied simultaneously using an electrochemical H-cell with an agar membrane. It was determined that reduction plays a significant role in the overall degradation of GenX for each of the cathodes studied, with its contribution ranging from 52 % for the Ti cathode, to 66 % for Cu, and to 92 % for Au.

Sustainable application of electrocatalytic and photo-electrocatalytic oxidation systems for water and wastewater treatment: a review

Wastewater treatment and reuse have risen as a solution to the water crisis plaguing the world. Global warming-induced climate change, population explosion and fast depletion of groundwater resources are going to exacerbate the present global water problems for the forthcoming future. In this scenario, advanced electrochemical oxidation process (EAOP) utilising electrocatalytic (EC) and photoelectrocatalytic (PEC) technologies have caught hold of the interest of the scientific community. The interest stems from the global water management plans to scale down centralised water and wastewater treatment systems to decentralised and semicentralised treatment systems for better usage efficiency and less resource wastage. In an age of rising water pollution caused by contaminants of emerging concern (CECs), EC and PEC systems were found to be capable of optimal mineralisation of these pollutants rendering them environmentally benign. The present review treads into the conventional electrochemical treatment systems to identify their drawbacks and analyses the scope of the EC and PEC to mitigate them. Probable electrode materials, potential catalysts and optimal operational conditions for such applications were also examined. The review also discusses the possible retrospective application of EC and PEC as point-of-use and point-of-entry treatment systems during the transition from conventional centralised systems to decentralised and semi-centralised water and wastewater treatment systems.

New insights into the degradation mechanism and risk assessment of HFPO-DA by advanced oxidation processes based on activated persulfate in aqueous solutions

Hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (HFPO-DA) is widely used as a substitute for perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). HFPO-DA exhibits high water solubility and low adsorption potential, conferring significant fluidity in aquatic environments. Given that the toxicity of HFPO-DA is similar to PFOA, it is necessary to control its content in aquatic environments. Electrochemical and thermally-activated persulfates have been successfully used to degrade HFPO-DA, but UV-activated persulfates cannot degrade the compound. Given that research on degradation mechanisms is still incomplete and lacks kinetic research, the mechanism and kinetic calculations of oxidative degradation were studied in detail using DFT calculations. And the toxicity of HFPO-DA degradation intermediates and products was evaluated to reveal the feasibility of using advanced oxidation process (AOP) technology based on persulfate to degrade HFPO-DA in wastewater. The results showed that the committed step of HFPO-DA degradation was initiated by the electron transfer reaction of SO4•- radicals. This reaction is not spontaneous at room temperature and requires sufficient electrical or thermal energy to be absorbed from the external environment. The perfluoroalcohol produced during this reaction can subsequently undergo four possible reactions: H atom abstraction from alcohol groups by an OH radical; H atom abstraction by SO4•-; direct HF removal; and HF removal with water as the catalyst. The final degradation products of HFPO-DA mainly include CO2, CF3CF2COOH, CF3COOH, FCOOH and HF, which has been identified through previous experimental analysis. Ecotoxicity assessment indicates that degradation does not produce highly toxic intermediates, and that the final products are non-toxic, supporting the feasibility of persulfate-based AOP technologies.

Fabrication and characterizations of Zn-doped SnO2-Ti4O7 anode for electrochemical degradation of hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid and its homologues

Hexafluoropropylene oxide dimer acid (HFPO-DA) and its homologues, as perfluorinated ether alkyl substances with strong antioxidant properties, have rarely been reported by electrooxidation processes to achieve good results. Herein, we report the use of an oxygen defect stacking strategy to construct Zn-doped SnO₂-Ti₄O₇ for the first time and enhance the electrochemical activity of Ti₄O₇. Compared with the original Ti₄O₇, the Zn-doped SnO₂-Ti₄O₇ showed a 64.4% reduction in interfacial charge transfer resistance, a 17.5% increase in the cumulative rate of •OH generation, and an enhanced oxygen vacancy concentration. The Zn-doped SnO₂-Ti₄O₇ anode exhibited high catalytic efficiency of 96.4% for HFPO-DA within 3.5 h at 40 mA/cm². Hexafluoropropylene oxide trimer and tetramer acid exhibit more difficult degradation due to the protective effect of the -CF₃ branched chain and the addition of the ether oxygen atom leading to a significant increase in the C-F bond dissociation energy. The degradation rates of 10 cyclic degradation experiments and the leaching concentrations of Zn and Sn after 22 electrolysis experiments demonstrated the good stability of the electrodes. In addition, the aqueous toxicity of HFPO-DA and its degradation products was evaluated. This study analyzed the electrooxidation process of HFPO-DA and its homologues for the first time, and provided some new insights.

Insight into the binding model of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances to proteins and membranes

Legacy per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) have elicited much concern because of their ubiquitous distribution in the environment and the potential hazards they pose to wildlife and human health. Although an increasing number of effective PFAS alternatives are available in the market, these alternatives bring new challenges. This paper comprehensively reviews how PFASs bind to transport proteins (e.g., serum albumin, liver fatty acid transport proteins and organic acid transporters), nuclear receptors (e.g., peroxisome proliferator activated receptors, thyroid hormone receptors and reproductive hormone receptors) and membranes (e.g., cell membrane and mitochondrial membrane). Briefly, the hydrophobic fluorinated carbon chains of PFASs occupy the binding cavities of the target proteins, and the acid groups of PFASs form hydrogen bonds with amino acid residues. Various structural features of PFAS alternatives such as chlorine atom substitution, oxygen atom insertion and a branched structure, introduce variations in their chain length and hydrophobicity, which potentially change the affinity of PFAS alternatives for endogenous proteins. The toxic effects and mechanisms of action of legacy PFASs can be demonstrated and compared with their alternatives using binding models. In future studies, in vitro experiments and in silico quantitative structure-activity relationship modeling should be better integrated to allow more reliable toxicity predictions for both legacy and alternative PFASs.

Removal and destruction of perfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acids (PFECAs) in an anion exchange resin and electrochemical oxidation treatment train

Perfluoroalkyl ether carboxylic acids (PFECAs) are a group of emerging recalcitrant contaminants that are being developed to replace legacy per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in industrial applications and that are generated as by-products in fluoropolymer manufacturing. Here, we report on the removal and destruction of four structurally different PFECAs using an integrated anion exchange resin (AER) and electrochemical oxidation (ECO) treatment train. Results from this work illustrated that (1) flow-through columns packed with PFAS-selective AERs are highly effective for the removal of PFECAs and (2) PFECA affinity is strongly correlated with their hydrophobic features. Regeneration of the spent resin columns revealed that high percentage (e.g., 80%) of organic cosolvent is necessary for achieving 60-100% PFECA release, and regeneration efficiency was higher for a macroporous resin than a gel-type resin. Treatment of spent regenerants showed (1) >99.99% methanol removal was achieved by distillation, (2) >99.999% conversion of the four studied PFECAs was achieved during the ECO treatment of the still bottoms after 24 hours with an energy per order of magnitude of PFECA removal (EE/O) <1.03 kWh/m³ of total groundwater treated, and (3) >85% of the organic fluorine was recovered as inorganic fluoride. Trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), perfluoropropionic acid (PFPrA), and perfluoro-2-methoxyacetic acid (PFMOAA) were confirmed via high-resolution mass spectrometry as transformation products (TPs) in the treated still bottoms, and two distinctive degradation schemes and four reaction pathways are proposed for the four PFECAs. Lastly, dissolved organic matter (DOM) inhibited uptake, regeneration, and oxidation of PFECAs throughout the treatment train, suggesting pretreatment steps targeting DOM removal can enhance the system's treatment efficiency. Results from this work provide guidelines for developing effective separation-concentration-destruction treatment trains and meaningful insights for achieving PFECA destruction in impacted aquatic systems.

Recent trends in degradation strategies of PFOA/PFOS substitutes

The global elimination and restriction of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctane sulfonic acid (PFOS), respectively, have urged manufacturers to shift production to their substitutes which still pose threat to the environment with their bioaccumulation, toxicity and migration issues. In this context, efficient technologies and systematic mechanistic studies on the degradation of PFOA/PFOS substitutes are highly desirable. In this review, we summarize the progress in degrading PFOA/PFOS substitutes, including four kinds of mainstream methods. The pros and cons of the present technologies are analyzed, which renders the discussion of future prospects on rational optimizations. Additional discussion is made on the differences in the degradation of various kinds of substitutes, which is compared to the PFOA/PFOS and derives designing principles for more degradable F-containing compounds.