A scoping review of methods used in musculoskeletal soft tissue and nerve shear wave elastography studies

Median Nerve Shear Wave Elastography Is Associated With the Neurophysiological Severity of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

OBJECTIVES

This study examines the associations between the median nerve (MN) shear wave elastography (SWE), the MN cross-sectional area (CSA), patient's symptoms, and the neurophysiological severity of carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). The most appropriate site to perform SWE was also tested.

METHODS

This prospective study comprised 86 wrists of 47 consecutive patients who volunteered for MN ultrasound after an electrodiagnostic study. The neurophysiological severity of CTS was assessed according to the results of a nerve conduction study (NCS). The MN CSA was measured at the carpal tunnel inlet (wCSA) and the forearm (fCSA). SWE was performed on the MN in a longitudinal orientation at the wrist crease (wSWE), at the forearm (fSWE), and within the carpal tunnel (tSWE).

RESULTS

The wCSA and wSWE correlated positively with the neurophysiological severity of CTS (r = .619, P < .001; r = .582, P < .001, respectively). The optimal cut-off values to discriminate the groups with normal NCS and with findings indicating CTS were 10.5 mm2 for the wCSA and 4.12 m/s for the wSWE. With these cut-off values, wCSA had a sensitivity of 80% and specificity of 87% and wSWE a sensitivity of 88% and specificity of 76%. Neither tSWE nor fSWE correlated with the neurophysiological severity of CTS or differed between NCS negative and positive groups (P = .429, P = .736, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Shear wave velocity in the MN at the carpal tunnel inlet increases in CTS and correlates to the neurophysiological CTS severity equivalently to CSA measured at the same site.

Effect of soft tissue tension around the knee joint on medio-lateral patellar position

Patellofemoral pain (PFP) is one of the most common sports injuries of the knee joint and has a high persistence and recurrence rate. Medio-lateral patellar position in the knee extension position during contraction is associated with PFP. However, soft tissue tension that most influences the medio-lateral patellar position in the knee extension position during contraction in vivo is unclear. We aimed to clarify the relationship between medio-lateral patellar position and soft tissue tension around the knee joint. Twelve patients with PFP and 20 healthy participants were included. Medio-lateral patellar position and tension of the rectus femoris, vastus lateralis (VL), vastus medialis, iliotibial band (ITB), lateral patellofemoral ligament, and medial patellofemoral ligament were measured during contraction and rest. The tensions of the VL and ITB during contraction and the medio-lateral patellar position at rest were significantly associated with medio-lateral patellar position during contraction (β = 0.449, 0.354, and 0.393, respectively). In addition, the tension of ITB was significantly associated with the medio-lateral patellar position at rest (β = 0.646). These relationships were not affected by the presence of PFP. These findings suggest that the patellar position during contraction became more lateral as the tension in the VL and ITB increased, regardless of the presence of PFP. These results may facilitate the prevention and treatment of PFP.

Upper extremity soft tissue stiffness measured with shear wave elastography: A between-day reliability study

Background

Imbalances in soft tissue stiffness (STS) of the pectoralis and common wrist extensors (CWEs) can adversely alter upper extremity function. Shear wave elastography (SWE) has the capacity to provide precise, repeatable, objective data on STS. The purpose of this study was to determine the between-day intrarater reliability for the pectoralis and CWE tendon stiffness as measured by SWE.

Methods

STS measured by the shear wave modulus (kilopascals (kPa)) was captured bilaterally on the pectoralis major, pectoralis minor, and CWE tendon using 2D SWE ultrasound imaging (GE Logiq S8, 9 L transducer) on two separate days. Within examiner intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC (3, 3)) with 95% confidence intervals, standard error of the measure, and minimal detectable changes were calculated.

Results

The investigators recruited 10 healthy participants (mean age = 23.50  ±  1.43). Between day intrarater reliability values were obtained for the dominant pectoralis major ICC  =  0.70 (-0.15, -0.93), nondominant pectoralis major ICC  =  0.63 (-0.30, -0.91), dominant pectoralis minor ICC  = 0 .72(-0.04, -0.93), nondominant pectoralis minor ICC  = 0.75(0.08, -0.94), dominant CWE tendon ICC  =  0.75(-0.08, -0.94), and nondominant CWE tendon ICC  =  0.75(-0.12, -0.94).

Discussion

Our data demonstrate acceptable reliability but future studies should include methods that control for variables known to effect STS.

Ultrasonic shear wave elastography predicts the quality of the residual tendon before the rotator cuff repair

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Effective evaluation of rotator cuff tear residual tendon quality is the key to surgical repair. However, until now, the evaluation of rotator cuff tissue by ultrasonic shear wave elasticity (SWE) has been controversial. This prospective study analyzed the association between preoperative SWE and arthroscopic residual tendon quality scores.

METHODS

The shear wave velocity (SWV) of the deltoid muscle, the supraspinatus tendon, and the supraspinatus muscle were measured in full-thickness rotator cuff tear patients. Tendon quality was scored according to tear size, tendon margin, tendon thickness, and footprint coverage during arthroscopy. The arthroscopic scores were used as the gold standard, and the SWV ratio of tendon and muscle (supraspinatus tendon/deltoid and supraspinatus muscle/deltoid) were calculated and correlated with the arthroscopic scores.

RESULT

Eighty-nine patients (129 shoulders) were enrolled, including 89 operation shoulders and 40 control shoulders. In the group of operation shoulders, both the SWV ratios of tendon (SWV-RT) and the SWV ratio of muscle (SWV-RM) were negatively correlated with arthroscopic scores (The correlation coefficient (R) ranged from -0.722 to -0.884 and -0.569 to -0.689). The SWV-RT and SWV-RM of the operation shoulders were significantly lower than that of the control shoulders (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

SWE could be used to predict the quality of the residual tendon before the rotator cuff repair. SWV of the supraspinatus tendon and muscle was a useful parameter to predict the quality of the residual tendon.

CRITICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT

Measuring the shear wave velocity of the supraspinatus tendon and muscle with SWE is useful for predicting the quality of the residual tendon which is one of the key factors for a successful rotator cuff repair.

KEY POINTS

• Evaluating the quality of the residual tendon is important before surgery. • Elasticity measurements were negatively correlated with the arthroscopic score. • SWE is useful for predicting the quality of the residual tendon.

In Vivo Effects of Joint Movement on Nerve Mechanical Properties Assessed with Shear-Wave Elastography: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Peripheral nerves are subjected to mechanical tension during limb movements and body postures. Nerve response to tensile stress can be assessed in vivo with shear-wave elastography (SWE). Greater tensile loads can lead to greater stiffness, which can be quantified using SWE. Therefore, this study aimed to conduct a systematic review and meta-analysis to perform an overview of the effect of joint movements on nerve mechanical properties in healthy nerves. The initial search (July 2023) yielded 501 records from six databases (PubMed, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, Cochrane, and Science Direct). A total of 16 studies were included and assessed with a modified version of the Downs and Black checklist. Our results suggest an overall tendency for stiffness increase according to a pattern of neural tensioning. The main findings from the meta-analysis showed a significant increase in nerve stiffness for the median nerve with wrist extension (SMD [95%CI]: 3.16 [1.20, 5.12]), the ulnar nerve with elbow flexion (SMD [95%CI]: 2.91 [1.88, 3.95]), the sciatic nerve with ankle dorsiflexion (SMD [95%CI]: 1.13 [0.79, 1.47]), and the tibial nerve with both hip flexion (SMD [95%CI]: 2.14 [1.76, 2.51]) and ankle dorsiflexion (SMD [95%CI]: 1.52 [1.02, 2.02]). The effect of joint movement on nerve stiffness also depends on the nerve segment, the amount of movement of the joint mobilized, and the position of other joints comprised in the entirety of the nerve length. However, due to the limited number of studies, many aspects of nerve behavior together with the effect of using different ultrasound equipment or transducers for nerve stiffness evaluation still need to be fully investigated.

Mechanical properties change of immobilized skeletal muscle in short position measured by shear wave elastography and pure shearing test

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of immobilization on mechanical properties of skeletal muscle over the time. An in vivo rat model was used to investigate the shear modulus change of the flexor carpi ulnaris (FCU) in a short position. Measurements were performed by shear wave elastography (SWE) to compare contralateral and immobilized cases. The results showed a significant increase of 18.1% (p = 3.86. 10-7) in the shear modulus of immobilized skeletal muscle after two weeks (D14) when compared with the contralateral case. For the purposes of comparison, in vitro mechanical pure shearing tests were performed on samples collected from the skeletal muscles of the same rats. Although the difference between contralateral and immobilized cases was 17.6% (p = 0.32) at D14, the shear modulus difference was 35.7% (p = 0.0126 and p = 1.57.10-5 for immobilization and contralateral respectively) between in vivo and in vitro approaches. The mechanical properties changes were then correlated with the density of collagen from histological analysis, and it was shown that the contralateral collagen surface density was 25.4% higher than the immobilized density at D14 (p = 0.001). Thus, the results showed the feasibility of the comparison between the two approaches, which can surely be improved by optimizing the experimental protocols.

Chinese Ultrasound Doctors Association Guideline on Operational Standards for 2-D Shear Wave Elastography Examination of Musculoskeletal Tissues

The Ultrasound Physician Branch of the Chinese Medical Doctor Association sought to develop evidence-based recommendations on the operational standards for 2-D shear wave elastography examination of musculoskeletal tissues. A consensus panel of 22 Chinese musculoskeletal ultrasound experts reviewed current scientific evidence and proposed a set of 12 recommendations for 13 key issues, including instruments, operating methods, influencing factors and image interpretation. A final consensus was reached through discussion and voting. On the basis of research evidence and expert opinions, the strength of recommendation for each proposition was assessed using a visual analog scale, while further emphasizing the best available evidence during the question-and-answer session. These expert consensus guidelines encourage facilitation of the standardization of clinical practices for collecting and reporting shear wave elastography data.

Influence of the physical pressure of an ultrasound probe on shear-wave elastography measurements of the gastrocnemius muscle in a paediatric population: a non-interventional cohort study

Purpose

The aim of our study is to evaluate the impact of ultrasound probe mechanical pressure on the stiffness of the gastrocnemius muscle in a healthy paediatric population. As far as we know, there has been no previous qualitative in vivo study on the impact of probe pressure on muscle shear-wave elastography results with objective evaluation of compression in the paediatric population.

Material and methods

In this cohort study, a group of 22 children (mean age 8.99 years, SD 2.74, 11 males) underwent elastography of the gastrocnemius muscle of the dominant leg. A custom-made, 3-dimensional printed probe cover was used to measure the mechanical pressure of the probe on tissues.

Results

The obtained results were related to the age, sex, BMI, and calf circumference of the subjects. We observed a significant difference in the stiffness parameter at a pressure of 1 N, with a further increase if force was increased (p < 0.001). A significant, very weak positive correlation of age and stiffness was observed (p < 0.001, r2 = 0.022). There was no significant correlation of stiffness, BMI, and calf circumference.

Conclusions

The use of compression during muscle elastography in children causes a significant bias in results, regardless of age, sex, BMI, or calf size.

Shear-wave elastography for the evaluation of tendinopathies: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

To compare pathologic and healthy tendons using shear-wave elastography (SWE).

METHODS

A systematic review with meta-analysis was done searching Pubmed and EMBASE up to September 2022. Prospective, retrospective and cross-sectional studies that used SWE in the assessment of pathologic tendons versus control were included. Our primary outcome were SWE velocity (m/s) and stiffness (kPa). Methodological quality was assessed by the methodological index for non-randomized studies (MINORS). We used the mean difference (MD) with corresponding 95% confidence intervals (CIs) to quantify effects between groups. We performed sensitivity analysis in case of high heterogeneity, after excluding poor quality studies according to MINORS assessment. We used Grades of Recommendation, Assessment, Development and Evaluation to evaluate the certainty of evidence (CoE).

RESULTS

Overall, 16 studies with 676 pathologic tendons (188 Achilles, 142 patellar, 96 supraspinatus, 250 mixed) and 723 control tendons (484 healthy; 239 contralateral tendon) were included. Five studies (31.3%) were judged as poor methodological quality. Shear-wave velocity and stiffness meta-analyses showed high heterogeneity. According to a sensitivity analysis, pathologic tendons had a lower shear wave velocity (MD of - 1.69 m/s; 95% CI 1.85; - 1.52; n = 274; I2 50%) compared to healthy tendons with very low CoE. Sensitivity analysis on stiffness still showed high heterogeneity.

CONCLUSION

Pathological tendons may have reduced SWE velocity compared to controls, but the evidence is very uncertain. Future robust high-quality longitudinal studies and clear technical indications on the use of this tool are needed.

PROTOCOL

PROSPERO identifier: CRD42023405410 CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT: SWE is a relatively recent modality that may increase sensitivity and diagnostic accuracy of conventional ultrasound imaging promoting early detection of tendinopathy. Non-negligible heterogeneity has been observed in included studies, so our findings may encourage the conduct of future high-quality longitudinal studies which can provide clear technical indications on the use of this promising tool in tendon imaging.

Emerging Role of Quantitative Ultrasound-Based Imaging Techniques for Characterizing Rotator Cuff Tears: A Scoping Review

Rotator cuff myosteatosis following cuff tears is very common and one of the most important prognostic factors in clinical management. Quantitative ultrasound-based imaging techniques (QUBIT) are frequently used along with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to evaluate rotator cuff fatty degeneration. However, the examination of rotator cuff tissue integrity by QUBIT is lacking a standardized imaging protocol and procedural methodologies. In this scoping review, we synthesized the current state of QUBIT against the reference imaging modalities in patients with rotator cuff tears. The literature search was extracted from 963 studies, with 22 studies included in the final review in accordance with the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses extensions for scoping reviews. The selected studies included human participants and focused on measuring at least one prognostic or diagnostic factor using ultrasonography-based imaging with reference to MRI. The findings suggest both conventional B-mode ultrasound and shear wave elastography imaging were comparable to MRI-based imaging techniques for the evaluation of fatty infiltration and rotator cuff tear characterization. This review establishes guidelines for reporting shoulder-specific QUBIT aimed at developing a standardized imaging protocol. The objective was to enhance the diagnostic and prognostic capabilities of QUBIT in the clinical setting.

Elastography in the assessment of the Achilles tendon: a systematic review of measurement properties

BACKGROUND

Managing and rehabilitating Achilles tendinopathy can be difficult, and the results are often unsatisfactory. Currently, clinicians use ultrasonography to diagnose the condition and predict symptom development. However, relying on subjective qualitative findings using ultrasound images alone, which are heavily influenced by the operator, may make it difficult to identify changes within the tendon. New technologies, such as elastography, offer opportunities to quantitatively investigate the mechanical and material properties of the tendon. This review aims to evaluate and synthesise the current literature on the measurement properties of elastography, which can be used to assess tendon pathologies.

METHODS

A systematic review was conducted according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. CINAHL, PubMed, Cochrane, Scopus, MEDLINE Complete, and Academic Search Ultimate were searched. Studies assessing the measurement properties concerning reliability, measurement error, validity, and responsiveness of the instruments identified in healthy and patients with Achilles tendinopathy were included. Two independent reviewers assessed the methodological quality using the Consensus-based Standards for the Selection of Health Measurement Instruments methodology.

RESULTS

Out of the 1644 articles identified, 21 were included for the qualitative analysis investigating four different modalities of elastography: axial strain elastography, shear wave elastography, continuous shear wave elastography, and 3D elastography. Axial strain elastography obtained a moderate level of evidence for both validity and reliability. Although shear wave velocity was graded as moderate to high for validity, reliability obtained a very low to moderate grading. Continuous shear wave elastography was graded as having a low level of evidence for reliability and very low for validity. Insufficient data is available to grade three-dimensional shear wave elastography. Evidence on measurement error was indeterminate so evidence could not be graded.

CONCLUSIONS

A limited number of studies explored quantitative elastography on Achilles tendinopathy as most evidence was conducted on a healthy population. Based on the identified evidence on the measurement properties of elastography, none of the different types showed superiority for its use in clinical practice. Further high-quality studies with longitudinal design are needed to investigate responsiveness.