Role of polymer–surfactant interactions in foams: Effects of pH and surfactant head group for cationic polyvinylamine and anionic surfactants

When Bulk Matters: Disentanglement of the Role of Polyelectrolyte/Surfactant Complexes at Surfaces and in the Bulk of Foam Films

Foam films display exciting systems as on one hand they dictate the performance of macroscopic foams and on the other hand they allow studies of surface forces. With regard to surface forces, we attempt to disentangle the effect of the foam film surfaces and the foam film bulk. For that, we study the influence of salt (LiBr) on foam films formed by mixtures of oppositely charged polyelectrolyte and surfactant: anionic monosulfonated polyphenylene sulfone (sPSO₂-220) and cationic tetradecyltrimethylammonium bromide (C₁₄TAB). Adding a small amount of salt (≤10^-3 M) decreases the foam film stability due to a weakened electrostatic net repulsion. In contrast, a large amount of salt (10^-2 M) unexpectedly increases the foam film stability. Disjoining pressure isotherms reveal that the increased stability is due to an additional steric stabilization, which is attributed to sPSO₂-220/C₁₄TAB complexes in the film bulk. These bulk complexes also contribute to the measured apparent surface potential between the two air/water interfaces. We find, for the first time, the formation of Newton black films for mixtures of anionic polyelectrolytes and cationic surfactants.

Polyelectrolyte/Surfactant Mixtures: A Pathway to Smart Foams

This review deals with liquid foams stabilized by polyelectrolyte/surfactant (PS) complexes in aqueous solution. It briefly reviews all the important aspects of foam physics at several scales, from interfaces to macroscopic foams, needed to understand the basics of these complex systems, focusing on those particular aspects of foams stabilized by PS mixtures. The final section includes a few examples of smart foams based on PS complexes that have been reported recently in the literature. These PS complexes open an opportunity to develop new intelligent dispersed materials with potential in many fields, such as oil industry, environmental remediation, and pharmaceutical industry, among others. However, there is much work to be done to understand the mechanism involved in the stabilization of foams with PS complexes. Understanding those underlying mechanisms is vital to successfully formulate smart systems. This review is written in the hope of stimulating further work in the physics of PS foams and, particularly, in the search for responsive foams based on polymer-surfactant mixtures.

Friction Dynamics of Foams under Nonlinear Motion

Foams are viscoelastic soft materials with complex mechanical properties. Here, we evaluated the friction dynamics of foams between acrylic plates using a sinusoidal motion friction evaluation system and we found some interesting characteristics under accelerated conditions. On a typical solid surface, a symmetrical friction profile, in which static and kinetic frictions are observed, is obtained under reciprocating nonlinear motion. Meanwhile, significant lubricant effects and velocity-dependent friction profiles without static friction were observed in foams. The friction force in foams increased in proportion to the power of velocity, with a power index of <1. These characteristic and dynamic phenomena in foams were observed in this study. They had been caused by the formation of a thick lubricant film and various dissipative modes including surfactant diffusion, viscous dissipation, and wall slip of bubbles. Moreover, the addition of a thickener increased the friction force and the delay time of friction response and improved the foam durability against normal force and shear. These findings are useful for understanding dynamic phenomena in soft materials.

Impact of polyelectrolyte-surfactant interactions on the rheology and wet lubrication performance of conditioning shampoo

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study is to understand the impact of the cationic polymer merquat on the rheological behavior of the mixed surfactant system of sodium lauryl ether sulfate (SLES) and cocamidopropyl betaine (CapB) as well as the impact of varying formulation conditions on the wet lubrication performance of the SLES-CapB-Merquat system.

METHODS

Rotation mechanical Rheometry was used to study the rheological response of the SLES-CapB-Merquat systems. Frequency sweeps were conducted to analyze the rheological properties of the system at low frequency ranges and bulk viscosity of the system was studied at high shear rates at varying salt and polymer concentrations. Wet combing tests and hair friction tests were run on the Dia-stron MTT175 flexible miniature tensile tester in order to evaluate the conditioning effects of the different formulations.

RESULTS

The SLES-CapB system on its own exhibits very little viscosity. The bulk rheology results show that the addition of Merquat enhances the viscosity and viscoelastic properties of the SLES-CapB-Merquat system indicating the presence of electrostatic interactions between the surfactant and polyelectrolyte. Addition of salt had a significant impact on the system's rheological response due to the charge screening effect of salt. Wet combing force data indicate that the charged polyelectrolyte binds to the hair substrate resulting in reduced combing force values after the product was applied. The addition of silicone oil to the formulation seemed to greatly enhance the conditioning effect of the formulation.

CONCLUSION

The charge interactions between SLES, CapB and Merquat results in the formation of an integrated gel like network, thus building the viscosity of the system. Variation of parameters like polymer and salt concentration has the potential to modify the bulk rheological properties and consequently the wet lubrication properties of the system.

Different strategies of foam stabilization in the use of foam as a fracturing fluid

An attractive alternative to mitigate the adverse effects of conventional water-based fluids on the efficiency of hydraulic fracturing is to inject foam-based fracking fluids into reservoirs. The efficiency of foaming fluids in subsurface applications largely depends on the stability and transportation of foam bubbles in harsh environments with high temperature, pressure and salinity, all of which inevitably lead to poor foam properties and thus limit fracturing efficiency. The aim of this paper is to elaborate popular strategies of foam stabilization under reservoir conditions. Specifically, this review first discusses three major mechanisms governing foam decay and summarizes recent progress in research on these phenomena. Since surfactants, polymers, nanoparticles and their composites are popular options for foam stabilization, their stabilizing effects, especially the synergies in composites, are also reviewed. In addition to reporting experimental results, the paper also reports recent advances in interfacial properties via molecular dynamical simulation, which provide new insights into gas/liquid interfacial properties under the influence of surfactants at molecular scale. The results of both experiments and simulations indicate that foam additives play an essential role in foam stability and the synergic effects of surfactants and nanoparticles exhibit more favorable performance.

Microfluidics Mediated Production of Foams for Biomedical Applications

Within the last decade, there has been increasing interest in liquid and solid foams for several industrial uses. In the biomedical field, liquid foams can be used as delivery systems for dermatological treatments, for example, whereas solid foams are frequently used as scaffolds for tissue engineering and drug screening. Most of the foam functionalities are largely correlated to their mechanical properties and their structure, especially bubble/pore size, shape, and interconnectivity. However, the majority of conventional foaming fabrication techniques lack pore size control which can induce important inhomogeneities in the foams and subsequently decrease their performance. In this perspective, new advanced technologies have been introduced, such as microfluidics, which offers a highly controlled production, allowing for design customization of both liquid foams and solid foams obtained through liquid-templating. This short review explores both the fabrication and the characterization of foams, with a focus on solid polymer foams, and sheds the light on how microfluidics can overcome some existing limitations, playing a crucial role in their production for biomedical applications, especially as scaffolds in tissue engineering.

New structural approach to rationalize the foam film stability of oppositely charged polyelectrolyte/surfactant mixtures

The foam film stability of polyelectrolyte/surfactant mixtures is rationalized using structural data from neutron reflectometry for the first time.

Synergy, competition, and the "hanging" polymer layer: Interactions between a neutral amphiphilic 'tardigrade' comb co-polymer with an anionic surfactant at the air-water interface

Understanding the structure of polymer/surfactant mixtures at the air-water interface is of fundamental importance and also of relevance to a variety of practical applications. Here, the complexation between a neutral 'tardigrade' comb co-polymer (consisting of a hydrophilic polyethylene glycol backbone with hydrophobic polyvinyl acetate grafts, PEG-g-PVAc) with an anionic surfactant (sodium dodecyl sulfate, SDS) at the air-water interface has been studied. Contrast-matched neutron reflectivity (NR) complemented by surface tension measurements allowed elucidation of the interfacial composition and structure of these mixed systems, as well as providing physical insights into the polymer/surfactant interactions at the air-water interface. For both polymer concentrations studied, below and above its critical aggregation concentration, cac, (0.2 cac and 2 cac, corresponding to 0.0002 wt% or 0.013 mM and 0.002 wt% or 0.13 mM respectively), we observed a synergistic cooperative behaviour at low surfactant concentrations with a 1-2 nm mixed interfacial layer; a competitive adsorption behaviour at higher surfactant concentrations was observed where the polymer was depleted from the air-water interface, with an overall interfacial layer thickness ~1.6 nm independent of the polymer concentration. The weakly associated polymer layer "hanging" proximally to the interface, however, played a role in enhancing foam stability, thus was relevant to the detergency efficacy in such polymer/surfactant mixtures in industrial formulations.

Effect of molecular weight of polyvinylpyrrolidone on the skin irritation potential and properties of body wash cosmetics in the coacervate form

Body wash cosmetics are among the most common groups of cosmetics used by consumers. Faced with strong competition in the marketplace, cosmetic manufacturers search for innovative solutions both in terms of product composition and form. An example of an innovative technology which can be used in the production of body wash cosmetics is the process of coacervation which yields a concentrated body wash product. Another important aspect which needs to be considered in the formulation of body wash cosmetics is their safety of use. It is crucial to ensure that such cosmetic products do not induce skin irritations. At present, the most widespread method of reducing the skin irritation potential of cosmetic products is the use of surfactant mixtures. The study is an attempt to evaluate the effect of using polyvinylpyrrolidone in the formulations of model body wash cosmetics in the coacervate form on the skin irritation potential and basic quality determinants of body wash products. Polyvinylpyrrolidone was found to contribute to a significant reduction in the irritant effect, and the skin irritation potential decreased in proportion to increasing molecular mass of the polymer. The application of polyvinylpyrrolidone with the different molecular weight also has an impact on improving the foaming properties of model body wash cosmetics and the stability of foam they produce.

Surface properties and foamability of saponin and saponin-chitosan systems

In this work we investigate the surface properties and foamability of saponin and mixed saponin-chitosan solutions. These natural compounds are widely used in various cosmetic, pharmaceutical and food technologies because of their efficiency as bio-active components and their biodegradability. These compounds and their mixture were investigated versus the composition by surface tension and dilational rheology measurements and the respective foams analysed at the formation and during their entire time evolution. The results show that these systems present peculiarities relevant for their utilisation as foam stabilisers, such as strong amphiphilicity of saponin and high values of dilational viscoelasticity. The behaviour of foams has been interpreted on the basis of the adsorption properties at liquid-air interface and the interfacial rheology. Specifically, we found a remarkable effect of the chitosan on the long-time stability of foams. This has been explained considering the changes of the bulk properties induced by chitosan, which influence also the dynamics of the saponin adsorption. This work aims to contribute to the development of new formulations of biodegradable and biocompatible foams for industrial applications, where it is advantageous to reduce the use of synthetic surfactants in commercial products.

Achieving foaming control smartly: pre-solubilized flavor oil serves as an in situ homogeneous defoamer

In the wide application of aqueous foam, creating abundant foam and processing appropriate foaming control are both essential, depending upon the actual situation; the latter process is not only harder to achieve, but also more complicated to comprehensively understand on the molecular level. In this paper, a type of natural flavor oil, carvone, was solubilized in a micelle solution of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) to study the effect on the foaming properties. The foamability and foam stability of the swollen micelle solutions were experimentally characterized, and the molecular behavior of the surfactant and oil molecules before, during and after the foaming process were investigated. It was found that the solubilized carvone co-adsorbed with SDS at the gas/water interface and caused a prominent effect on the foam film stability in several approaches, thereby making the flavor oil a possible foam controller that would not inhibit foam formation, but could eliminate foam efficiently once foam was undesired. Interestingly, it was found that the release of flavor in the foaming process was promoted. Detailed discussion of the interfacial behavior of carvone and the effect on the foaming properties of surfactants in different stages of foam may provide a theoretical foundation for exploring green and smart approaches in achieving foaming control.

Structure of Polystyrenesulfonate/Surfactant Mixtures at Air-Water Interfaces and Their Role as Building Blocks for Macroscopic Foam

Air/water interfaces were modified by oppositely charged poly(sodium 4-styrenesulfonate) (NaPSS) and hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) polyelectrolyte/surfactant mixtures and were studied on a molecular level with vibrational sum-frequency generation (SFG), tensiometry, surface dilatational rheology and ellipsometry. In order to deduce structure property relations, our results on the interfacial molecular structure and lateral interactions of PSS-/CTA+ complexes were compared to the stability and structure of macroscopic foam as well as to bulk properties. For that, the CTAB concentration was fixed to 0.1 mM, while the NaPSS concentration was varied. At NaPSS monomer concentrations <0.1 mM, PSS-/CTA+ complexes start to replace free CTA+ surfactants at the interface and thus reduce the interfacial electric field in the process. This causes the O-H bands from interfacial H2O molecules in our SFG spectra to decrease substantially, which reach a local minimum in intensity close to equimolar concentrations. Once electrostatic repulsion is fully screened at the interface, hydrophobic PSS-/CTA+ complexes dominate and tend to aggregate at the interface and in the bulk solution. As a consequence, adsorbate layers with the highest film thickness, surface pressure, and dilatational elasticity are formed. These surface layers provide much higher stabilities and foamabilities of polyhedral macroscopic foams. Mixtures around this concentration show precipitation after a few days, while their surfaces to air are in a local equilibrium state. Concentrations >0.1 mM result in a significant decrease in surface pressure and a complete loss in foamability. However, SFG and surface dilatational rheology provide strong evidence for the existence of PSS-/CTA+ complexes at the interface. At polyelectrolyte concentrations >10 mM, air-water interfaces are dominated by an excess of free PSS- polyelectrolytes and small amounts of PSS-/CTA+ complexes which, however, provide higher foam stabilities compared to CTAB free foams. The foam structure undergoes a transition from wet to polyhedral foams during the collapse.

Thermodynamics, interfacial pressure isotherms and dilational rheology of mixed protein-surfactant adsorption layers

Proteins and their mixtures with surfactants are widely used in many applications. The knowledge of their solution bulk behavior and its impact on the properties of interfacial layers made great progress in the recent years. Different mechanisms apply to the formation process of protein/surfactant complexes for ionic and non-ionic surfactants, which are governed mainly by electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions. The surface activity of these complexes is often remarkably different from that of the individual protein and has to be considered in respective theoretical models. At very low protein concentration, small amounts of added surfactants can change the surface activity of proteins remarkably, even though no strongly interfacial active complexes are observed. Also small added amounts of non-ionic surfactants change the surface activity of proteins in the range of small bulk concentrations or surface coverages. The modeling of the equilibrium adsorption behavior of proteins and their mixtures with surfactants has reached a rather high level. These models are suitable also to describe the high frequency limits of the dilational viscoelasticity of the interfacial layers. Depending on the nature of the protein/surfactant interactions and the changes in the interfacial layer composition rather complex dilational viscoelasticities can be observed and described by the available models. The differences in the interfacial behavior, often observed in literature for studies using different experimental methods, are at least partially explained by a depletion of proteins, surfactants and their complexes in the range of low concentrations. A correction of these depletion effects typically provides good agreement between the data obtained with different methods, such as drop and bubble profile tensiometry.

Surface adsorption of sulfonated poly(phenylene sulfone)/C14TAB mixtures and its correlation with foam film stability

Polyelectrolyte/surfactant mixtures of rigid monosulfonated poly(phenylene sulfone) (sPSO₂-220) and tetradecyl trimethylammonium bromide (C₁₄TAB) were investigated by surface tension, surface elasticity and foam film stability measurements.

Current applications of foams formed from mixed surfactant-polymer solutions

Foams cannot be generated without the use of special foaming agents, as pure liquids do not foam. The most common foaming agents are surfactants, however often for foam stability one active agent is not enough, it is necessary to add other component to increase foam lifetime. Foams on everyday use are mostly made from mixture of different components. Properly chosen combinations of two active ingredients lead to a faster foam formation and increased foam stability. During the last decade polymers (mainly polyelectrolytes and proteins) have become frequently used additives to foaming solutions. Mixtures of surfactants and polymers often demonstrate different foaming properties in comparison to surfactant only or polymer only solutions. The nature of surfactant-polymer interactions is complicated and prediction of resulting foaming properties of such formulations is not straightforward. Properties and foaming of surfactant-polymer mixtures are discussed as well as current applications of foams and foaming agents as foams are widely used in cosmetics, pharmaceutics, medicine and the food industry.

Role of macromolecules in the safety of use of body wash cosmetics

One of the most challenging problems related to the use of surfactants in body wash cosmetics is their potential to cause skin irritations. Surfactants can bind with proteins, remove lipids from the epidermal surface, contribute to the disorganization of liquid crystal structures in the intercellular lipids, and interact with living skin cells. These processes can lead to skin irritations and allergic reactions, and impair the epidermal barrier function. The present study is an attempt to assess the effect of polymers and hydrolysed proteins present in the formulations of model body wash cosmetics on product properties. Special attention was given to the safety of use of this product type. The study examined three macromolecules: polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), hydrolysed wheat protein (HWP) and polyvinylpyrrolidone/hydrolysed wheat protein crosspolymer (PVP/HWP). The addition of the substances under study was found to improve the foaming properties of body wash cosmetics, increase their stability during storage, and contribute significantly to an improvement in the safety of product use by reducing the irritant potential. The strongest ability to reduce the skin irritation potential was determined for the formula enriched with the PVP/HWP crosspolymer.

Improvement of stability of polidocanol foam for nonsurgical permanent contraception

BACKGROUND

Polidocanol foam (PF), used clinically as a venous sclerosant, has recently been studied as a safe and inexpensive means for permanent contraception. Delivering the sclerosant to the fallopian tubes as a foam rather than a liquid increases the surface areas and thus enhances the desired epithelial disrupting activity of the agent. However, the foam is inherently unstable and degrades with time. Therefore, increasing foam stability and thus duration of the agent exposure time could increase epithelial effect while allowing reduction in agent concentration and potential toxicity.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We studied methods to improve foam properties that might improve safety and efficacy of PF for intrauterine application. Several types of microporous filters adapted to a syringe-based foaming device were used to study the effect of pore structures on the formation of PF. The foam drainage time and bubble size were characterized. The addition of benzalkonium chloride (BZK) to polidocanol was also investigated for its effects on foam characteristics.

RESULTS

A syringe-based foaming device adapted with an inline filter produced smaller bubble PF with a longer foam drainage time. PF generated with a circular pore filter lasts longer than with a noncircular pore filter. The addition of 0.01% of BZK also improved the stability of PF.

CONCLUSION

The stability of PF is affected by the pore characteristics of the filter used for foam generation and enhanced by the presence of a small amount of BZK. The improved foam, if shown to be efficacious in animal models of contraception, could lead to a safe, simple and inexpensive method alternative to surgical contraception.

Enhancement of foamability and foam stability induced by interactions between a hyperbranched exopolysaccharide and a zwitterionic surfactant dodecyl sulfobetaine

Weak hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions between a zwitterionic surfactant dodecyl sulfobetaine (DSB) and a hyperbranched exopolysaccharide (EPS) enhanced considerably the stability and foamability of EPS/DSB foam.

The interfacial structure of polymeric surfactant stabilised air-in-water foams

Small-angle neutron scattering was used to probe the interfacial structure of nitrogen-in-water foams created using a series of tri-block polymeric surfactants of the poly(ethylene oxide)-poly(propylene oxide)-poly(ethylene oxide) (EOx-POy-EOx) range, from which the nature of the polymeric interface could be characterised. The data follow a pronounced Q(-4) decay, along with a number of inflexions and weak but well-defined peaks. These characteristics were well-described by a model embodying paracrystalline stacks of adsorbed polymer layers, whose formation is induced by the presence of the air-water interface, adsorbed at the flat air-water (film lamellae) interface. A minimum of approximately five paracrystalline polymer layers of thickness of the order of 85-160 Å, interspersed with somewhat thicker (400 Å) films of continuous aqueous phase were found to best fit the data. The thickness of the layer (L) was shown to follow a relationship predicted by anchor block dominated polymer adsorption theories from non-selective solvents, L ∼ EO(1)PO(1/3). The insight gained from these studies should permit a more rational design of polymeric stabilisers for hydrophilic polyurethane foams.

Effects of ionic strength on the surface tension and nonequilibrium interfacial characteristics of poly(sodium styrenesulfonate)/dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide mixtures

We rationalize the surface tension behavior and nonequilibrium interfacial characteristics of high molecular weight poly(sodium styrenesulfonate)/dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide (NaPSS/DTAB) mixtures with respect to the ionic strength. Excellent agreement is achieved between experimental data and our recent empirical model [Langmuir 2013, 29, 11554], which is based on the lack of colloidal stability of bulk aggregates in the phase separation region and has no free fitting parameters. We show that the size of a surface tension peak positioned at the edge of the phase separation region can be suppressed by the addition of inert electrolyte, which lowers the critical micelle concentration in relation to the phase separation region. Such manipulation of the peak is possible for the 100 ppm NaPSS/DTAB system because there is a high free surfactant concentration in the phase separation region. The close agreement of our model with the experimental data of samples in the phase separation region with respect to the ionic strength indicates that the surface tension behavior can be rationalized in terms of comprehensive precipitation regardless of whether there is a peak or not. The time scale of precipitation for the investigated system is on the order of one month, which emphasizes the need to understand the dynamic changes in the state of bulk aggregation in order to rationalize the surface properties of strongly interacting mixtures; steady state surface properties measured in the interim period will represent samples far from equilibrium. We show also that the surface properties of samples of low ionic strength outside the equilibrium phase separation region can be extreme opposites depending on the sample history, which is attributed to the generation of trapped nonequilibrium states. This work highlights the need to validate the underlying nature of oppositely charged polyelectrolyte/surfactant systems prior to the interpretation of experimental data within an equilibrium framework.