Electrostatic stabilization of foam films from β-lactoglobulin solutions

Exploring proteins at soft interfaces and in thin liquid films - From classical methods to advanced applications of reflectometry

The history of the topic of proteins at soft interfaces dates back to the 19th century, and until the present day, it has continuously attracted great scientific interest. A multitude of experimental methods and theoretical approaches have been developed to serve the research progress in this large domain of colloid and interface science, including the area of soft colloids such as foams and emulsions. From classical methods like surface tension adsorption isotherms, surface pressure-area measurements for spread layers, and surface rheology probing the dynamics of adsorption, nowadays, advanced surface-sensitive techniques based on spectroscopy, microscopy, and the reflection of light, X-rays and neutrons at liquid/fluid interfaces offers important complementary sources of information. Apart from the fundamental characteristics of protein adsorption layers, i.e., surface tension and surface excess, the nanoscale structure of such layers and the interfacial protein conformations and morphologies are of pivotal importance for extending the depth of understanding on the topic. In this review article, we provide an extensive overview of the application of three methods, namely, ellipsometry, X-ray reflectometry and neutron reflectometry, for adsorption and structural studies on proteins at water/air and water/oil interfaces. The main attention is placed on the development of experimental approaches and on a discussion of the relevant achievements in terms of notable experimental results. We have attempted to cover the whole history of protein studies with these techniques, and thus, we believe the review should serve as a valuable reference to fuel ideas for a wide spectrum of researchers in different scientific fields where proteins at soft interface may be of relevance.

Ultrathin Micellar Foam Films of Sodium Caseinate Protein Solutions

Sodium caseinates (NaCas), derived from milk proteins called caseins, are often added to food formulations as emulsifiers, foaming agents, and ingredients for producing dairy products. In this contribution, we contrast the drainage behavior of single foam films made with micellar NaCas solutions with well-established features of stratification observed for the micellar sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) foam films. In reflected light microscopy, the stratified SDS foam films display regions with distinct gray colors due to differences in interference intensity from coexisting thick-thin regions. Using IDIOM (interferometry digital imaging optical microscopy) protocols we pioneered for mapping nanotopography of foam films, we showed that drainage via stratification in SDS films proceeds by the expansion of flat domains that are thinner than surrounding by a concentration-dependent step-size, and nonflat features (nanoridges and mesas) form at the moving front. Furthermore, stratifying SDS foam films show stepwise thinning, such that the step-size and terminal film thickness decrease with concentration. Here we visualize the nanotopography in protein films with high spatiotemporal resolution using IDIOM protocols to address two long-standing questions. Do protein foam films formulated with NaCas undergo drainage via stratification? Are thickness transitions and variations in protein foam films determined by intermicellar interactions and supramolecular oscillatory disjoining pressure? In contrast with foam films containing micellar SDS, we find that micellar NaCas foam films display just one step, nonflat and noncircular domains that expand without forming nanoridges and a terminal thickness that increases with NaCas concentration. We infer that the differences in adsorbing and self-assembling unimers triumph over any similarities in the structure and interactions of their micelles.

Variations in foam collapse and thin film stability with constant interfacial and bulk properties

The stability of foams is commonly linked to the interfacial properties of the proteins and other surfactants used. This study aimed to use these relationships to explain differences in foam stability observed among similar beer samples from different breweries. The foam stability was different for each sample (Nibem foam stability ranged from 206 to 300 s), but ranking was similar for all three foaming methods used, thus independent of the method, gas, etc. Differences in foam stability were dominated by differences in coalescence, as illustrated by the correlation with the stability of single bubbles and thin liquid films. The differences in coalescence stability could not be explained by the measured interfacial properties (e.g. surface pressure, adsorption rate, dilatational modulus and surface shear viscosity), or the bulk properties (concentration, pH, ionic strength, viscosity), since they were similar for all samples. The drainage rates and disjoining pressure isotherms measured in thin liquid films were also similar for all samples, further limiting the options to explain the differences in foam stability using known arguments. The differences in coalescence stability of the thin films was shown to depend on the liquid in between the adsorbed layers of the thin film, using a modified capillary cell to exchange this liquid (to a buffer, or one of the other samples). This illustrates the need to review our current understanding and to develop new methods both for experimental study and theoretical description, to better understand foam stability in the future.

Interfacial properties of milk proteins: A review

The interfacial properties of dairy proteins are of great interest to the food industry. Food manufacturing involves various environmental conditions and multiple processes that significantly alter the structure and colloidal stability of food materials. The effects of concentration, pH, heat treatment, addition of salts etc., have considerable influence on the surface activity of proteins and the mechanical properties of the interfacial protein films. Studies to date have established some understanding of the links between environmental and processing related parameters and their impacts on interfacial behavior. Improvement in knowledge may allow better design of interfacial protein structures for different food applications. This review examines the effects of environmental and processing conditions on the interfacial properties of dairy proteins with emphasis on interfacial tension dynamics, dilatational and surface shear rheological properties. The most commonly used surface analytical techniques along with relevant methods are also addressed.

Adsorption dynamics of thermoresponsive microgels with incorporated short oligo(ethylene glycol) chains at the oil-water interface

Herein, we report a systematic study of the adsorption behaviour of short oligo(ethylene glycol) (OEG) chains incorporated into poly(N-isopropylaccrylamide) (PNIPAM) microgels at the dodecane-water interface as a function of the microgel concentration at two different temperatures: 298 and 313 K. The dynamic interfacial tension of the interface for the adsorption of these functional microgels is measured by means of a pendent drop method. We find that similar to pure PNIPAM microgels, the functionalized microgels initially get transported from the bulk to the interface, where they undergo the deformability dependent spreading process, and thus leading to a reduction of interfacial tension. However, the OEG chains significantly influence the dynamic processes of the microgels at the interface, enabling precise control over the interfacial activity. A tuneability of adsorption behaviour that is interpreted in terms of the diversity of structural and morphological features of the microgels, can be achieved by changing the temperature and/or the OEG chain length of the comonomer. While the temperature induced phase transition generally slows down the adsorption kinetics of the microgels, increasing the temperature from 298 to 313 K allows faster reduction of interfacial tension for the adsorption of the microgels with long OEG chains among the studied comonomers, making them a unique interfacially active functional material. Overall, incorporation of OEG chains allows tailoring the interfacial activity of microgels, thereby paving the way for the use of these microgels to act as effective Pickering emulsion stabilizers in a range of applications.

β-Lactoglobulin Adsorption Layers at the Water/Air Surface: 5. Adsorption Isotherm and Equation of State Revisited, Impact of pH

The theoretical description of the adsorption of proteins at liquid/fluid interfaces suffers from the inapplicability of classical formalisms, which soundly calls for the development of more complicated adsorption models. A Frumkin-type thermodynamic 2-d solution model that accounts for nonidealities of interface enthalpy and entropy was proposed about two decades ago and has been continuously developed in the course of comparisons with experimental data. In a previous paper we investigated the adsorption of the globular protein β-lactoglobulin at the water/air interface and used such a model to analyze the experimental isotherms of the surface pressure, Π(c), and the frequency-, f-, dependent surface dilational viscoelasticity modulus, E(c)f, in a wide range of protein concentrations, c, and at pH 7. However, the best fit between theory and experiment proposed in that paper appeared incompatible with new data on the surface excess, Γ, obtained from direct measurements with neutron reflectometry. Therefore, in this work, the same model is simultaneously applied to a larger set of experimental dependences, e.g., Π(c), Γ(c), E(Π)f, etc., with E-values measured strictly in the linear viscoelasticity regime. Despite this ambitious complication, a best global fit was elaborated using a single set of parameter values, which well describes all experimental dependencies, thus corroborating the validity of the chosen thermodynamic model. Furthermore, we applied the model in the same manner to experimental results obtained at pH 3 and pH 5 in order to explain the well-pronounced effect of pH on the interfacial behavior of β-lactoglobulin. The results revealed that the propensity of β-lactoglobulin globules to unfold upon adsorption and stretch at the interface decreases in the order pH 3 > pH 7 > pH 5, i.e., with decreasing protein net charge. Finally, we discuss advantages and limitations in the current state of the model.

β-Lactoglobulin Adsorption Layers at the Water/Air Surface: 4. Impact on the Stability of Foam Films and Foams

The complexity and high sensitivity of proteins to environmental factors give rise to a multitude of variables, which affect the stabilization mechanisms in protein foams. Interfacial and foaming properties of proteins have been widely studied, but the reported unique effect of pH, which can be of great interest to applications, has been investigated to a lesser extent. In this paper, we focus on the impact of pH on the stability of black foam films and corresponding foams obtained from solutions of a model globular protein—the whey β-lactoglobulin (BLG). Foam stability was analyzed utilizing three characteristic parameters (deviation time, transition time and half-lifetime) for monitoring the foam decay, while foam film stability was measured in terms of the critical disjoining pressure of film rupture. We attempt to explain correlations between the macroscopic properties of a foam system and those of its major building blocks (foam films and interfaces), and thus, to identify structure-property relationships in foam. Good correlations were found between the stabilities of black foam films and foams, while relations to the properties of adsorption layers appeared to be intricate. That is because pH-dependent interfacial properties of proteins usually exhibit an extremum around the isoelectric point (pI), but the stability of BLG foam films increases with increasing pH (3–7), which is well reflected in the foam stability. We discuss the possible reasons behind these intriguingly different behaviors on the basis of pH-induced changes in the molecular properties of BLG, which seem to be determining the mechanism of film rupture at the critical disjoining pressure.

β-Lactoglobulin Adsorption Layers at the Water/Air Surface: 3. Neutron Reflectometry Study on the Effect of pH

Several characteristics of β-lactoglobulin (BLG) layers adsorbed at the air/water interface exhibit a strong pH dependence, but our knowledge on the underlying structure-property relations is still fragmental. Here, we therefore extend our recent studies by neutron reflectometry (NR) and provide a comprehensive overview through direct measurements of the surface excess Γ and the layers' molecular structure. This enables comparison with available literature data to draw general conclusions. The NR experiments were performed at various pH values and within a wide range of protein concentrations, C_BLG. Adsorption kinetics measurements in air-contrast-matched-water and over a narrow Q_z range enabled direct quantification of the dynamic surface excess Γ(t) and are found to be consistent with ellipsometry data. Near the isoelectric point, pI, the rates of adsorption and Γ are maximal but only at sufficiently high C_BLG. NR data collected over a wider Q_z range and in two aqueous isotopic contrasts revealed the structure of adsorbed BLG layers at a steady state close to equilibrium. Independent of the pH, BLG was found to form dense monolayers with average thicknesses of 1.1 nm, suggesting flattening of the BLG globules upon adsorption as compared with their bulk dimensions (≈3.5 nm). Near pI and at sufficiently high C_BLG, a thick (≈5.5 nm) but looser secondary sublayer is additionally formed adjacent to the dense primary monolayer. The thickness of this sublayer can be interpreted in terms of disordered BLG dimers. The results obtained and notably the specific interfacial structuring of BLG near pI complement previous observations relating the impact of solution pH and C_BLG on other interfacial characteristics such as surface pressure and surface dilational viscoelasticity modulus.

Charge-Controlled Surface Properties of Native and Fluorophore-Labeled Bovine Serum Albumin at the Air-Water Interface

Proteins at interfaces are important for protein formulations and in soft materials such as foam. Here, interfacial stability and physicochemical properties are key elements, which drive macroscopic foam properties through structure–property relations. Native and fluorescein isothiocyanate-labeled bovine serum albumin (BSA) were used to modify air–water interfaces as a function of pH. Characterizations were performed with tensiometry and sum-frequency generation (SFG). SFG spectra of O–H stretching vibrations reveal a phase reversal and a pronounced minimum in O–H intensity at pH values of 5.3 and 4.7 for native and labeled BSA, respectively. This minimum is attributed to the interfacial isoelectric point (IEP) and is accompanied by a minimum in surface tension and negligible ζ-potentials in the bulk. Interfacial proteins at pH values close to the IEP can promote macroscopic foam stability and are predominately located in the lamellae between individual gas bubbles as evidenced by confocal fluorescence microscopy. Different from the classical stabilization mechanisms, for example, via the electrostatic disjoining pressure, we propose that the presence of more close-packed BSA, because of negligible net charges, inside the foam lamellae is more effective in reducing foam drainage as compared to a situation with strong repulsive electrostatic interactions.

Role of Proteins on Formation, Drainage, and Stability of Liquid Food Foams

Foam is a high-volume fraction dispersion of gas into a liquid or a solid. It is important to understand the effect of formulation on shelf life and texture of food foams. The objective of this review is to elucidate mechanisms of formation and stability of foams and relate them to the formulations. Emulsifiers are important in foam formation, whereas proteins are generally preferred to provide long-term stability. Syneresis in foams is a precursor to their collapse in many instances. Intermolecular forces, conformation, and flexibility of proteins play an important role in foam stabilization. An adsorbed protein layer at air/water interfaces imparts interfacial rheology that is necessary to improve the shelf life of foam products. Wettability and spreading of food particles at the interface can stabilize or destabilize foams, depending on their properties. More studies are needed to fully understand the complex interplay of various mechanisms of destabilization in a real-food formulation.

Aqueous clay suspensions stabilized by alginate fluid gels for coal spontaneous combustion prevention and control

We have developed aqueous clay suspensions stabilized by alginate fluid gels (AFG) for coal spontaneous combustion prevention and control. Specially, this study aimed to characterize the effect of AFG on the microstructure, static and dynamic stability, and coal fire inhibition performances of the prepared AFG-stabilized clay suspensions. Compared with aqueous clay suspensions, the AFG-stabilized clay suspensions manifest high static and dynamic stability, which can be ascribed to the formation of a robust three-dimensional gel network by AFG. The coal acceleration oxidation experimental results show that the prepared AFG-stabilized clay suspensions can improve the coal thermal stability and effectively inhibit the coal spontaneous oxidation process by increasing crossing point temperature (CPT) and reducing CO emission. The prepared low-cost and nontoxic AFG-stabilized clay suspensions, exhibiting excellent coal fire extinguishing performances, indicate great application potentials in coal spontaneous combustion prevention and control.

Interfacial properties, thin film stability and foam stability of casein micelle dispersions

Foam stability of casein micelle dispersions (CMDs) strongly depends on aggregate size. To elucidate the underlying mechanism, the role of interfacial and thin film properties was investigated. CMDs were prepared at 4°C and 20°C, designated as CMD_4°C and CMD_20°C. At equal protein concentrations, foam stability of CMD_4°C (with casein micelle aggregates) was markedly higher than CMD_20°C (without aggregates). Although the elastic modulus of CMD_4°C was twice as that of CMD_20°C at 0.005Hz, the protein adsorbed amount was slightly higher for CMD_20°C than for CMD_4°C, which indicated a slight difference in interfacial composition of the air/water interface. Non-linear surface dilatational rheology showed minor differences between mechanical properties of air/water interfaces stabilized by two CMDs. These differences in interfacial properties could not explain the large difference in foam stability between two CMDs. Thin film analysis showed that films made with CMD_20°C drained to a more homogeneous film compared to films stabilized by CMD_4°C. Large casein micelle aggregates trapped in the thin film of CMD_4°C made the film more heterogeneous. The rupture time of thin films was significantly longer for CMD_4°C (>1h) than for CMD_20°C (<600s) at equal protein concentration. After homogenization, which broke down the aggregates, the thin films of CMD_4°C became much more homogeneous, and both the rupture time of thin films and foam stability decreased significantly. In conclusion, the increased stability of foam prepared with CMD_4°C appears to be the result of entrapment of casein micelle aggregates in the liquid films of the foam.

Specific effects of Ca(2+) ions and molecular structure of β-lactoglobulin interfacial layers that drive macroscopic foam stability

β-Lactoglobulin (BLG) adsorption layers at air-water interfaces were studied in situ with vibrational sum-frequency generation (SFG), tensiometry, surface dilatational rheology and ellipsometry as a function of bulk Ca(2+) concentration. The relation between the interfacial molecular structure of adsorbed BLG and the interactions with the supporting electrolyte is additionally addressed on higher length scales along the foam hierarchy - from the ubiquitous air-water interface through thin foam films to macroscopic foam. For concentrations <1 mM, a strong decrease in SFG intensity from O-H stretching bands and a slight increase in layer thickness and surface pressure are observed. A further increase in Ca(2+) concentrations above 1 mM causes an apparent change in the polarity of aromatic C-H stretching vibrations from interfacial BLG which we associate to a charge reversal at the interface. Foam film measurements show formation of common black films at Ca(2+) concentrations above 1 mM due to considerable decrease of the stabilizing electrostatic disjoining pressure. These observations also correlate with a minimum in macroscopic foam stability. For concentrations >30 mM Ca(2+), micrographs of foam films show clear signatures of aggregates which tend to increase the stability of foam films. Here, the interfacial layers have a higher surface dilatational elasticity. In fact, macroscopic foams formed from BLG dilutions with high Ca(2+) concentrations where aggregates and interfacial layers with higher elasticity are found, showed the highest stability with much smaller bubble sizes.