Sulfonated methyl esters, linear alkylbenzene sulfonates and their mixed solutions: Micellization and effect of Ca2+ ions

The Physicochemical and Functional Properties of Biosurfactants: A Review

Surfactants, also known as surface-active agents, have emerged as an important class of compounds with a wide range of applications. However, the use of chemical-derived surfactants must be restricted due to their potential adverse impact on the ecosystem and the health of human and other living organisms. In the past few years, there has been a growing inclination towards natural-derived alternatives, particularly microbial surfactants, as substitutes for synthetic or chemical-based counterparts. Microbial biosurfactants are abundantly found in bacterial species, predominantly Bacillus spp. and Pseudomonas spp. The chemical structures of biosurfactants involve the complexation of lipids with carbohydrates (glycolipoproteins and glycolipids), peptides (lipopeptides), and phosphates (phospholipids). Lipopeptides, in particular, have been the subject of extensive research due to their versatile properties, including emulsifying, antimicrobial, anticancer, and anti-inflammatory properties. This review provides an update on research progress in the classification of surfactants. Furthermore, it explores various bacterial biosurfactants and their functionalities, along with their advantages over synthetic surfactants. Finally, the potential applications of these biosurfactants in many industries and insights into future research directions are discussed.

Enhanced solubility of methyl ester sulfonates below their Krafft points in mixed micellar solutions

HYPOTHESIS

Methyl ester sulfonates (MES) show limited water solubility at lower temperatures (Krafft point). One way to increase their solubility below their Krafft points is to incorporate them in anionic surfactant micelles. The electrostatic interactions between the ionic surfactant molecules and charged micelles play an important role for the degree of MES solubility.

EXPERIMENTS

The solubility and electrolytic conductivity for binary and ternary surfactant mixtures of MES with anionic sodium alpha olefin sulfonate (AOS) and sodium lauryl ether sulfate with two ethylene oxide groups (SLES-2EO) at 5 °C during long-term storage were measured. Phase diagrams were established; a general phase separation theoretical model for their explanation was developed and checked experimentally.

FINDINGS

The binary and ternary phase diagrams for studied surfactant mixtures include phase domains: mixed micelles; micelles + crystallites; crystallites, and molecular solution. The proposed general phase separation model for ionic surfactant mixtures is convenient for construction of such complex phase diagrams and provides information on the concentrations of all components of the complex solution and on the micellar electrostatic potential. The obtained maximal MES mole fraction of transparent micellar solutions could be of interest to increase the range of applicability of MES-surfactants.

Solubility of ionic surfactants below their Krafft point in mixed micellar solutions: Phase diagrams for methyl ester sulfonates and nonionic cosurfactants

HYPOTHESIS

Many ionic surfactants with wide applications in personal-care and house-hold detergency show limited water solubility at lower temperatures (Krafft point). This drawback can be overcome by using mixed solutions, where the ionic surfactant is incorporated in mixed micelles with another surfactant, which is soluble at lower temperatures.

EXPERIMENTS

The solubility and electrolytic conductivity for a binary surfactant mixture of anionic methyl ester sulfonates (MES) with nonionic alkyl polyglucoside and alkyl polyoxyethylene ether at 5 °C during long-term storage were measured. Phase diagrams were established; a general theoretical model for their explanation was developed and checked experimentally.

FINDINGS

The binary and ternary phase diagrams for studied surfactant mixtures include phase domains: mixed micelles; micelles + crystallites; crystallites, and molecular solution. The proposed general methodology, which utilizes the equations of molecular thermodynamics at minimum number of experimental measurements, is convenient for construction of such phase diagrams. The results could increase the range of applicability of MES-surfactants with relatively high Krafft temperature, but with various useful properties such as excellent biodegradability and skin compatibility; stability in hard water; good wetting and cleaning performance.

Revealing the Origin of the Specificity of Calcium and Sodium Cations Binding to Adsorption Monolayers of Two Anionic Surfactants

The studied anionic surfactants linear alkyl benzene sulfonate (LAS) and sodium lauryl ether sulfate (SLES) are widely used key ingredients in many home and personal care products. These two surfactants are known to react very differently with multivalent counterions, including Ca²⁺. This is explained by a stronger interaction of the calcium cation with the LAS molecules, compared to SLES. The molecular origin of this difference in the interactions remains unclear. In the current study, we conduct classical atomistic molecular dynamics simulations to compare the ion interactions with the adsorption layers of these two surfactants, formed at the vacuum-water interface. Trajectories of 150 ns are generated to characterize the adsorption layer structure and the binding of Na⁺ and Ca²⁺ ions. We found that both surfactants behave similarly in the presence of Na⁺ ions. However, when Ca²⁺ is added, Na⁺ ions are completely displaced from the surface with adsorbed LAS molecules, while this displacement occurs only partially for SLES. The simulations show that the preference of Ca²⁺ to the LAS molecules is due to a strong specific attraction with the sulfonate head-group, besides the electrostatic one. This specific attraction involves significant reduction of the hydration shells of the interacting calcium cation and sulfonate group, which couple directly and form surface clusters of LAS molecules, coordinated around the adsorbed Ca²⁺ ions. In contrast, SLES molecules do not exhibit such specific interaction because the hydration shell around the sulfate anion is more stable, due to the extra oxygen atom in the sulfate group, thus precluding substantial dehydration and direct coupling with any of the cations studied.

Properties of Binary Mixture of Cetyl Diphenyl Ether Disulfonate and Linear Alkylbenzene Sulfonate

The surface properties of the binary mixture of cetyl diphenyl ether disulfonate (C16-MADS) and linear alkylbenzene sulfonate (LAS) have been investigated by salinity and hardness tolerance, equilibrium surface tension, wettability, foam and emulsification measurements. The results show that with increasing mass ratio of LAS in the C16-MADS/LAS mixed system, the ability to reduce the surface tension of the solution is improved. The wetting performance is also improved. The critical micelle concentration (CMC) values are increased first, then decreased, and are higher than the ideal CMC values, which indicates that there is an antagonistic effect that is not conducive to the formation of mixed micelles between C16-MADS and LAS. In addition, the C16-MADS/LAS system improves the hard water resistance of LAS and reduces the foam properties of LAS.

Rheology of mixed solutions of sulfonated methyl esters and betaine in relation to the growth of giant micelles and shampoo applications

This is a review article on the rheological properties of mixed solutions of sulfonated methyl esters (SME) and cocamidopropyl betaine (CAPB), which are related to the synergistic growth of giant micelles. Effects of additives, such as fatty alcohols, cocamide monoethanolamine (CMEA) and salt, which are expected to boost the growth of wormlike micelles, are studied. We report and systematize the most significant observed effects with an emphasis on the interpretation at molecular level and understanding the rheological behavior of these systems. The experiments show that the mixing of SME and CAPB produces a significant rise of viscosity, which is greater than in the mixed solutions of sodium dodecyl sulfate and CAPB. The addition of fatty alcohols, CMEA and cationic polymer, leads to broadening of the synergistic peak in viscosity without any pronounced effect on its height. The addition of NaCl leads to a typical salt curve with high maximum, but in the presence of dodecanol this maximum is much lower. At lower salt concentrations, the fatty alcohol acts as a thickener, whereas at higher salt concentrations - as a thinning agent. Depending on the shape of the frequency dependences of the measured storage and loss moduli, G' and G", the investigated micellar solutions behave as systems of standard or nonstandard rheological behavior. The systems with standard behavior obey the Maxwell viscoelastic model (at least) up to the crossover point (G' = G") and can be analyzed in terms of the Cates reptation-reaction model. The systems with nonstandard rheological behavior obey the Maxwell model only in a restricted domain below the crossover frequency; they can be analyzed in the framework of an augmented version of the Maxwell model. The methodology for data analysis and interpretation could be applied to any other viscoelastic micellar system.

Micellar Effects on the Hydrolysis Reaction of an Anionic Surfactant in Aqueous Solution

The hydrolysis mechanisms of 2-sulfoalkanoic acid methyl ester salts (methyl ester sulfonate, MES) were studied. Under acidic, neutral, and alkaline conditions, the hydrolysis rates of MES were strongly affected by the state of aggregation and the hydrolysis rate changed at the critical micelle concentration (CMC). Under acidic conditions, the hydrolysis rates of MES were enhanced by micellar formation and correlated quantitatively with the amount of protons bound on the micellar surfaces being measured by the electric conductivity along with fluorescence and hydrogen-ion electrode measurements. MES having longer acyl chain lengths showed higher hydrolysis rates above the CMC because of the many bound protons and the higher degree of counterion binding to the micelle, β. The rates were affected by the type of counterion and followed the order of sodium > potassium > calcium salts of MES. In alkaline conditions, the rates of MES hydrolysis were suppressed to lower values by micelle formation and MES with longer acyl chain lengths showed lower rates above the CMC. Additionally, the hydrolysis rates of MES under neutral conditions were suppressed to a very low value by micelle formation. These mechanisms of inhibitory effect of hydrolysis by the aggregation should be dominated by the electrical repulsive interactions between hydroxyl anions and anionic micellar surfaces, as well as by interference with the penetration of the hydroxyl anion to the ester group in the micelles for alkaline hydrolysis and by interference from water molecules for neutral hydrolysis.

Effect of Surfactant-Bile Interactions on the Solubility of Hydrophobic Drugs in Biorelevant Dissolution Media

Biorelevant dissolution media (BDM) methods are commonly employed to investigate the oral absorption of poorly water-soluble drugs. Despite the significant progress in this area, the effect of commonly employed pharmaceutical excipients, such as surfactants, on the solubility of drugs in BDM has not been characterized in detail. The aim of this study is to clarify the impact of surfactant-bile interactions on drug solubility by using a set of 12 surfactants, 3 model hydrophobic drugs (fenofibrate, danazol, and progesterone) and two types of BDM (porcine bile extract and sodium taurodeoxycholate). Drug precipitation and sharp nonlinear decrease in the solubility of all studied drugs is observed when drug-loaded ionic surfactant micelles are introduced in solutions of both BDM, whereas the drugs remain solubilized in the mixtures of nonionic polysorbate surfactants + BDM. One-dimensional and diffusion-ordered ¹H NMR spectroscopy show that mixed bile salt + surfactant micelles with low drug solubilization capacity are formed for the ionic surfactants. On the other hand, separate surfactant-rich and bile salt-rich micelles coexist in the nonionic polysorbate surfactant + bile salt mixtures, explaining the better drug solubility in these systems. The nonionic alcohol ethoxylate surfactants show intermediate behavior. The large dependence of the drug solubility on surfactant-bile interactions (in which the drug molecules do not play a major role per se) highlights how the complex interplay between excipients and bile salts can significantly change one of the key parameters which governs the oral absorption of poorly water-soluble drugs, viz. the drug solubility in the intestinal fluids.

Enzyme-Compatible Dynamic Nanoreactors from Electrostatically Bridged Like-Charged Surfactants and Polyelectrolytes

Reported is an unanticipated mechanism of attractive electrostatic interactions of fully neutralized polyacrylic acid (PAA) with like-charged surfactants. Amphiphilic polymer-surfactant complexes with high interfacial activity and a solubilization capacity exceeding that of conventional micelles are formed by bridging with Ca²⁺ ions. Incorporation of a protease into such dynamic nanoreactors results in a synergistically enhanced cleaning performance because of the improved solubilization of poorly water-soluble immobilized proteins. Competitive interfacial and intermolecular interactions on different time- and length-scales have been resolved using colorimetric analysis, dynamic tensiometry, light scattering, and molecular dynamic simulations. The discovered bridging association mechanism suggests reengineering of surfactant/polymer/enzyme formulations of modern detergents and opens new opportunities in advancing labile delivery systems.

Growth of wormlike micelles in nonionic surfactant solutions: Quantitative theory vs. experiment

Despite the considerable advances of molecular-thermodynamic theory of micelle growth, agreement between theory and experiment has been achieved only in isolated cases. A general theory that can provide self-consistent quantitative description of the growth of wormlike micelles in mixed surfactant solutions, including the experimentally observed high peaks in viscosity and aggregation number, is still missing. As a step toward the creation of such theory, here we consider the simplest system - nonionic wormlike surfactant micelles from polyoxyethylene alkyl ethers, C_iE_j. Our goal is to construct a molecular-thermodynamic model that is in agreement with the available experimental data. For this goal, we systematized data for the micelle mean mass aggregation number, from which the micelle growth parameter was determined at various temperatures. None of the available models can give a quantitative description of these data. We constructed a new model, which is based on theoretical expressions for the interfacial-tension, headgroup-steric and chain-conformation components of micelle free energy, along with appropriate expressions for the parameters of the model, including their temperature and curvature dependencies. Special attention was paid to the surfactant chain-conformation free energy, for which a new more general formula was derived. As a result, relatively simple theoretical expressions are obtained. All parameters that enter these expressions are known, which facilitates the theoretical modeling of micelle growth for various nonionic surfactants in excellent agreement with the experiment. The constructed model can serve as a basis that can be further upgraded to obtain quantitative description of micelle growth in more complicated systems, including binary and ternary mixtures of nonionic, ionic and zwitterionic surfactants, which determines the viscosity and stability of various formulations in personal-care and house-hold detergency.