Contact angle dynamics on pseudo-brushes: Effects of polymer chain length and wetting liquid

Pinning Forces on the Omniphobic Dry, Liquid-Infused, and Liquid-Attached Surfaces

Omniphobic coatings effectively repelling water, oils, and other liquids are of great interest and have a broad number of applications including self-cleaning, anti-icing surfaces, biofouling protection, selective filtration, etc. To create such coatings, one should minimize the pinning force that resists droplet motion and causes contact angle hysteresis. The minimization of the free surface energy by means of the chemical modification of the solid surface is not enough to obtain a nonsticky slippery omniphobic surface. One should minimize the contact between the solid and the droplet. Besides coating the surface with flat polymer films, among the major approaches to create omniphobic coatings, one can reveal "lotus effect" textured coatings, slippery liquid-infused porous surfaces (SLIPS), and slippery omniphobic covalently attached liquid (SOCAL) coatings. It is possible to turn one surface type into other by texturizing, impregnating with liquids, or grafting flexible liquid-like polymer chains. There are a number of models describing the pinning force on surfaces, but the transitions between states with different wetting regimes remain poorly understood. At the same time, such studies can significantly broaden existing ideas about the physics of wetting, help to design coatings, and also contribute to the development of generalized models of the pinning force. Here we review the existing pinning force (contact angle hysteresis) models on various omniphobic substrates. Also, we discuss the current studies of the pinning force in the transitions between different wetting regimes.

Liquid-Like Surfaces with Enhanced De-Wettability and Durability: From Structural Designs to Potential Applications

Liquid-like surfaces (LLSs) with dynamic repellency toward various pollutants (e.g., bacteria, oil, and ice), have shown enormous potential in the fields of biology, environment, and energy. However, most of the reported LLSs cannot meet the demands for practical applications, particularly in terms of de-wettability and durability. To solve these problems, considerable progress has been made in enhancing the de-wettability and durability of LLSs in complex environments. Therefore, this review mainly focuses on the recent progress in LLSs, encompassing designed structures and repellent capabilities, as well as their diverse applications, offering greater insights for the targeted design of desired LLSs. First, a detailed overview of the development of LLSs from the perspective of their molecular structural evolution is provided. Then highlight recent approaches for enhancing the dynamic de-wettability and durability of LLSs by optimizing their structural designs, including linear, looped, crosslinked, and hybrid structures. Later, the diverse applications and unique advantages of recently developed LLSs, including repellency (e.g., liquid anti-adhesion/transportation/condensation, anti-icing/scaling/waxing, and biofouling repellency) are summarized. Finally, Perspectives on potential innovative advancements and the promotion of technology selection to advance this exciting field are offered.

Wetting on silicone surfaces

Silicone is frequently used as a model system to investigate and tune wetting on soft materials. Silicone is biocompatible and shows excellent thermal, chemical, and UV stability. Moreover, the mechanical properties of the surface can be easily varied by several orders of magnitude in a controlled manner. Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) is a popular choice for coating applications such as lubrication, self-cleaning, and drag reduction, facilitated by low surface energy. Aiming to understand the underlying interactions and forces, motivated numerous and detailed investigations of the static and dynamic wetting behavior of drops on PDMS-based surfaces. Here, we recognize the three most prevalent PDMS surface variants, namely liquid-infused (SLIPS/LIS), elastomeric, and liquid-like (SOCAL) surfaces. To understand, optimize, and tune the wetting properties of these PDMS surfaces, we review and compare their similarities and differences by discussing (i) the chemical and molecular structure, and (ii) the static and dynamic wetting behavior. We also provide (iii) an overview of methods and techniques to characterize PDMS-based surfaces and their wetting behavior. The static and dynamic wetting ridge is given particular attention, as it dominates energy dissipation, adhesion, and friction of sliding drops and influences the durability of the surfaces. We also discuss special features such as cloaking and wetting-induced phase separation. Key challenges and opportunities of these three surface variants are outlined.

Thickness of Nanoscale Poly(Dimethylsiloxane) Layers Determines the Motion of Sliding Water Drops

Layers of nanometer thick polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) are applied as hydrophobic coatings because of their environmentally friendly and chemically inert properties. In applications such as heat exchangers or fog harvesting, low water drop friction on surfaces is required. While the onset of motion (static friction) has been studied, the knowledge of dynamic friction needs to be improved. To minimize drop friction, it is essential to understand which processes lead to energy dissipation and cause dynamic friction? Here, the dynamic friction of drops on PDMS brushes of different thicknesses is measured, covering the whole available velocity regime. The brush thickness L turns out to be a predictor for drop friction. 4-5 nm thick PDMS brush shows the lowest dynamic friction. A certain minimal thickness is necessary to form homogeneous surfaces and reduce the attractive van der Waals interaction between water and the substrate. The increase in dynamic friction above L = 5 nm is also attributed to the increasing viscoelastic dissipation of the capillary ridge formed at the contact line. The height of the ridge is related to the brush thickness. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and atomic force measurements support this interpretation. Sum-frequency generation further indicates a maximum order at the PDMS-water interface at intermediate thickness.

Drops on Polymer Brushes: Advances in Thin-Film Modeling of Adaptive Substrates

We briefly review recent advances in the hydrodynamic modeling of the dynamics of droplets on adaptive substrates, in particular, solids that are covered by polymer brushes. Thereby, the focus is on long-wave and full-curvature variants of mesoscopic hydrodynamic models in gradient dynamics form. After introducing the approach for films/drops of nonvolatile simple liquids on a rigid smooth solid substrate, it is first expanded to an arbitrary number of coupled degrees of freedom before considering the specific case of drops of volatile liquids on brush-covered solids. After presenting the model, its usage is illustrated by briefly considering the natural and forced spreading of drops of nonvolatile liquids on a horizontal brush-covered substrate, stick-slip motion of advancing contact lines as well as drops sliding down a brush-covered incline. Finally, volatile liquids are also considered.

Nanostructure Explains the Behavior of Slippery Covalently Attached Liquid Surfaces

Slippery covalently-attached liquid surfaces (SCALS) with low contact angle hysteresis (CAH, <5°) and nanoscale thickness display impressive anti-adhesive properties, similar to lubricant-infused surfaces. Their efficacy is generally attributed to the liquid-like mobility of the constituent tethered chains. However, the precise physico-chemical properties that facilitate this mobility are unknown, hindering rational design. This work quantifies the chain length, grafting density, and microviscosity of a range of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) SCALS, elucidating the nanostructure responsible for their properties. Three prominent methods are used to produce SCALS, with characterization carried out via single-molecule force measurements, neutron reflectometry, and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. CO2 snow-jet cleaning was also shown to reduce the CAH of SCALS via a modification of their grafting density. SCALS behavior can be predicted by reduced grafting density, Σ, with the lowest water CAH achieved at Σ≈2. This study provides the first direct examination of SCALS grafting density, chain length, and microviscosity and supports the hypothesis that SCALS properties stem from a balance of layer uniformity and mobility.

Method to Measure Surface Tension of Microdroplets Using Standard AFM Cantilever Tips

Surface tension is a physical property that is central to our understanding of wetting phenomena. One could easily measure liquid surface tension using commercially available tensiometers (e.g., Wilhelmy plate method) or by optical imaging (e.g., pendant drop method). However, such instruments are designed for bulk liquid volumes on the order of milliliters. In order to perform similar measurements on extremely small sample volumes in the range of femtoliters, atomic force microscope (AFM) is considered as a promising tool. It was previously reported that by fabricating a special "nanoneedle"-shaped cantilever probe, a Wilhelmy-like experiment can be performed with AFM. By measuring the capillary force between such special probes and a liquid surface, surface tension could be calculated. Here, we carried out measurements on microscopic droplets with AFM, but instead, using standard pyramidal cantilever tips. The cantilevers were coated with a hydrophilic polyethylene glycol-based polymer brush in a simple one-step process, which reduced its contact angle hysteresis for most liquids. Numerical simulations of a liquid drop interacting with a pyramidal or conical geometry were used to calculate surface tension from the experimentally measured force. The results on micrometer-sized drops agree well with bulk tensiometer measurement of three test liquids (mineral oil, ionic liquid, and glycerol), within a maximum error of 10%. Our method eliminates the need for specially fabricated "nanoneedle" tips, thus reducing the complexity and cost of measurement.

Dynamic wetting properties of PDMS pseudo-brushes: Four-phase contact point dynamics case

We investigate the wetting properties of PDMS (Polydimethylsiloxane) pseudo-brush anchored on glass substrates. These PDMS pseudo-brushes exhibit a significantly lower contact angle hysteresis compared to hydrophobic silanized substrates. The effect of different molar masses of the used PDMS on the wetting properties seems negligible. The surface roughness and thickness of the PDMS pseudo-brush are measured by atomic force microscopy and x-ray reflectivity. The outcome shows that these surfaces are extremely smooth (topologically and chemically), which explains the reduction in contact angle hysteresis. These special features make this kind of surfaces very useful for wetting experiments. Here, the dynamics of the four-phase contact point are studied on these surfaces. The four-phase contact point dynamics on PDMS pseudo-brushes deviate substantially from its dynamics on other substrates. These changes depend only a little on the molar mass of the used PDMS. In general, PDMS pseudo-brushes increase the traveling speed of four-phase contact point on the surface and change the associated power law of position vs time.

Advances and challenges in slippery covalently-attached liquid surfaces

Over the past decade, a new class of slippery, anti-adhesive surfaces known as slippery covalently-attached liquid surfaces (SCALS) has emerged, characterized by low values of contact angle hysteresis (CAH, less than 5°) with water and most solvents. Despite their nanoscale thickness (1 to 5 nm), SCALS exhibit behavior similar to lubricant-infused surfaces, including high droplet mobility and the ability to prevent icing, scaling, and fouling. To date, SCALS have primarily been obtained using grafted polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS), though there are also examples of polyethylene oxide (PEO), perfluorinated polyether (PFPE), and short-chain alkane SCALS. Importantly, the precise physico-chemical characteristics that enable ultra-low CAH are unknown, making rational design of these systems impossible. In this review, we conduct a quantitative and comparative analysis of reported values of CAH, molecular weight, grafting density, and layer thickness for a range of SCALS. We find that CAH does not scale monotonically with any reported parameter; instead, the CAH minimum is found at intermediate values. For PDMS, optimal behavior is observed at advancing contact angle of 106°, molecular weight between 2 and 10 kg mol^-1, and grafting density of around 0.5 nm^-2. CAH on SCALS is lowest for layers created from end-grafted chains and increases with the number of binding sites, and can generally be improved by increasing the chemical homogeneity of the surface through the capping of residual silanols. We review the existing literature on SCALS, including both synthetic and functional aspects of current preparative methods. The properties of reported SCALS are quantitatively analyzed, revealing trends in the existing data and highlighting areas for future experimental study.

Omniphobic liquid-like surfaces

Liquid-repellent surfaces, especially smooth solid surfaces with covalently grafted flexible polymer brushes or alkyl monolayers, are the focus of an expanding research area. Surface-tethered flexible species are highly mobile at room temperature, giving solid surfaces a unique liquid-like quality and unprecedented dynamical repellency towards various liquids regardless of their surface tension. Omniphobic liquid-like surfaces (LLSs) are a promising alternative to air-mediated superhydrophobic or superoleophobic surfaces and lubricant-mediated slippery surfaces, avoiding fabrication complexity and air/lubricant loss issues. More importantly, the liquid-like molecular layer controls many important interface properties, such as slip, friction and adhesion, which may enable novel functions and applications that are inaccessible with conventional solid coatings. In this Review, we introduce LLSs and their inherent dynamic omniphobic mechanisms. Particular emphasis is given to the fundamental principles of surface design and the consequences of the liquid-like nature for task-specific applications. We also provide an overview of the key challenges and opportunities for omniphobic LLSs.

Slip transition in dynamic wetting for a generalized Navier boundary condition

HYPOTHESIS

Computer fluid dynamics simulations of dynamic wetting are often performed using a slip model on the substrate. In previous studies, the generalized Navier boundary condition (GNBC) has shown promising results and could help clear the gap between molecular and continuum scales, but lacks quantitative comparisons to experiments. We seek to investigate the dependence between the contact-line velocity and the slip length in a GNBC, by confronting numerical simulations to experimental data.

EXPERIMENTS

The physical properties of a molten polymer (polyethylene glycol) were assessed thoroughly. Its dynamic contact angle on a cellulosic substrate was measured carefully using the Wilhelmy method. The experiment was reproduced in a finite elements model using a GNBC. It was repeated for capillary numbers between 10^-6 and 10^-1, and slip lengths ranging from 1 μm to 1 mm.

FINDINGS

A realistic value of the slip length was selected by matching the dynamic contact angles issued from numerical simulations and their experimental counterparts. The slip length behavior as a function of contact line velocity displayed a clear transition. The model also reproduced a dynamic wetting transition between frictional and viscous dissipations, which seems to be linked to an increasing difference between microscopic and macroscopic contact angles.

Probing the concept of line tension down to the nanoscale

A novel mechanical approach is developed to explore by means of atom-scale simulation the concept of line tension at a solid-liquid-vapor contact line as well as its dependence on temperature, confinement, and solid/fluid interactions. More precisely, by estimating the stresses exerted along and normal to a straight contact line formed within a partially wet pore, the line tension can be estimated while avoiding the pitfalls inherent to the geometrical scaling methodology based on hemispherical drops. The line tension for Lennard-Jones fluids is found to follow a generic behavior with temperature and chemical potential effects that are all included in a simple contact angle parameterization. Former discrepancies between theoretical modeling and molecular simulation are resolved, and the line tension concept is shown to be robust down to molecular confinements. The same qualitative behavior is observed for water, but the line tension at the wetting transition diverges or converges toward a finite value depending on the range of solid/fluid interactions at play.

Life and death of liquid-infused surfaces: a review on the choice, analysis and fate of the infused liquid layer

We review the rational choice, the analysis, the depletion and the properties imparted by the liquid layer in liquid-infused surfaces – a new class of low-adhesion surface.