Strategies for improving detection of circulating tumor DNA using next generation sequencing

Dynamic characterization of circulating tumor DNA in HER2-altered advanced non-small cell lung cancer treated with pyrotinib and apatinib: Exploratory biomarker analysis from PATHER2 study

BACKGROUND

HER2 mutations are critical drivers of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), affecting 2 %-3 % of patients and often leads to poor prognosis and limited response to conventional therapies. This study investigates the genomic characteristics and prognostic relevance of dynamic circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) monitoring in advanced NSCLC patients with HER2 mutations treated with pyrotinib and apatinib.

METHODS

The PATHER2 study included 33 advanced NSCLC patients harboring HER2 mutations or amplification, who received combination therapy of pyrotinib and apatinib. Among them, 27 patients had baseline blood samples available for analysis. Baseline blood samples (n = 27), follow-up samples after one treatment cycle (n = 13), and samples upon disease progression (n = 18) were collected. ctDNA was extracted and sequenced using a 556-gene panel.

RESULTS

At baseline, HER2 mutations were detected in 21 of 27 patients through ctDNA, and 19 showed consistent results between tissue and blood sample testing. Patients with TP53 and DNMT3A alterations at baseline had significantly shorter progression-free survival (PFS). Dynamic ctDNA monitoring revealed that patients without detectable HER2 mutations after one treatment cycle had longer PFS and a trend toward longer overall survival (OS) compared to those with persistent HER2 mutations. The newly emerged mutations after resistance were infrequently found in HER2, instead primarily enriched in the chromatin remodeling pathway.

CONCLUSION

ctDNA holds significant value in guiding the treatment of patients with HER2 mutations. Baseline TP53 and DNMT3A alterations, along with persistent HER2 mutations after initial treatment, are associated with poorer prognosis. The primary mechanism of resistance to pyrotinib and apatinib in these patients may be attributed to chromatin remodeling rather than on-target alterations.

Circulating Tumor DNA (ctDNA) Dynamics Predict Early Response to Treatment in Metastasized Gastroesophageal Cancer (mGEC) After 2 Weeks of Systemic Treatment

mGEC is associated with poor overall survival (OS) of approximately 4-10 months. CtDNA is emerging as a promising prognostic biomarker with high potential for early relapse detection. However, until now, there was little knowledge on serial ctDNA detection and its impact on early treatment evaluation and prognosis in mGEC.

METHODS

ctDNA detection (ddPCR) was carried out serially in 37 matched tissue (NGS) patients with mGEC prior to systemic treatment initiation and every two weeks thereafter until restaging (n = 173 samples). The results have been correlated with response to treatment (restaging CT), overall survival (OS), and progression-free survival (PFS).

RESULTS

The pretherapeutic detection rate was 77.8%. Response to treatment assessment was correct in 54.2% (pretherapeutically pos./neg.) and 85.7% (dynamics at week 4). Moreover, a decline in ctDNA (MAF in %) below 57.1% of the pretherapeutic value after 2 weeks of systemic treatment was accompanied by a sensitivity of 57.1% and a specificity of 90% (AUC = 0.73) for correct restaging assessment (response evaluation by CT after 3 months) evaluating 76.5% of patients correctly after only 2 weeks. In contrast to mere pretherapeutic ctDNA positivity (p = 0.445), a decline in ctDNA dynamics to under 57.1% of its initial value was significantly associated with OS (4.1 (95% Cl 2.1-6.1) vs. 13.6 (95% CI 10.4-16.6) months, p < 0.001) and PFS (3.2 (1.9-4.5) vs. 9.5 (95% CI 5.5-13.5) months, p = 0.001) after two weeks of treatment. Additionally, the change in detectability from positive pretherapeutic levels to negative during treatment was associated with similar survival as for patients who were always regarded as ctDNA-negative (9.5 (95%Cl 0.4-18.5) vs. 9.6 (95%Cl 1.3-17.9)). The absence of becoming undetectable was associated with worse survival (4.7 months).

CONCLUSIONS

ctDNA is a promising additional biomarker allowing for early evaluation of response to treatment and saving unevaluated treatment time for patients with mGEC, and could allow for an early change in treatment with anticipated prognostic benefit in the future.

Liquid biopsy: Comprehensive overview of circulating tumor DNA (Review)

Traditional tumor diagnosis methods rely on tissue biopsy, which can be invasive and unsuitable for long-term monitoring of tumor dynamics. The advent of liquid biopsy has notably improved the overall management of patients with cancer. Liquid biopsy techniques primarily involve detection of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). The present review focuses on ctDNA because of its significance in tumor diagnosis, monitoring and treatment. The use of ctDNA-based liquid biopsy offers several advantages, including non-invasive or minimally invasive collection methods, the ability to conduct repeated assessment and comprehensive insights into tumor biology. It serves crucial roles in disease management by facilitating screening of high-risk patients, dynamically monitoring therapeutic responses and diagnosis. Furthermore, ctDNA can be used to demonstrate pseudo-progression, monitor postoperative tumor status and guide adaptive treatment plans. The present study provides a comprehensive review of ctDNA, exploring its origins, metabolism, detection methods, clinical role and the current challenges associated with its application.

Diagnostic use of circulating cells and sub-cellular bio-particles

In the bloodstream or other physiological fluids, "circulating cells and sub-cellular bio-particles" include many microscopic biological elements such as circulating tumor cells (CTCs), cell-free DNA (cfDNA), exosomes, microRNAs, platelets, immune cells, and proteins are the most well-known and investigated. These structures are crucial biomarkers in healthcare and medical research for the early detection of cancer and other disorders, enabling treatment to commence before the onset of clinical symptoms and enhancing the efficacy of treatments. As the size of these biomarkers to be detected decreases and their numbers in body fluids diminishes, the detection materials, ranging from visual inspection to advanced microscopy techniques, begin to become smaller, more sensitive, faster, and more effective, thanks to developing nanotechnology. This review first defines the circulating cells and subcellular bio-particles with their biological, physical, and mechanical properties and second focuses on their diagnostic importance, including their most recent applications as biomarkers, the biosensors that are utilized to detect them, the present obstacles that must be surmounted, and prospective developments in the domain. As technology advances and biomolecular pathways are deepens, diagnostic tests will become more sensitive, specific, and thorough. Finally, integrating recent advances in the diagnostic use of circulating cells and bioparticles into clinical practice is promising for precision medicine and patient outcomes.

Circulating tumor DNA to guide diagnosis and treatment of localized and locally advanced non-small cell lung cancer

Liquid biopsy is a minimally invasive method for biomarkers detection in body fluids, particularly in blood, which offers an elevated and growing number of clinical applications in oncology. As a result of the improvement in the techniques for DNA analysis, above all next-generation sequencing (NGS) assays, circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) has become the most informing tumor-derived material for most types of cancer, including non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Although ctDNA concentration is higher in patients with advanced tumors, it can be detected even in patients with early-stage disease. Therefore, numerous clinical applications of ctDNA in the management of early-stage lung cancer are emerging, such as lung cancer screening, the identification of minimal residual disease (MRD), and the prediction of relapse before radiologic progression. Moreover, a high number of clinical trials are ongoing to better define the impact of ctDNA evaluation in this setting. Aim of this review is to offer a comprehensive overview of the most relevant implementations in using ctDNA for the management of early-stage lung cancer, addressing available data, technical aspects, limitations, and future perspectives.

Cell-free and extracellular vesicle microRNAs with clinical utility for solid tumors

As cutting-edge technologies applied for the study of body fluid molecular biomarkers are continuously evolving, clinical applications of these biomarkers improve. Diverse forms of circulating molecular biomarkers have been described, including cell-free DNA (cfDNA), circulating tumor cells (CTCs), and cell-free microRNAs (cfmiRs), although unresolved issues remain in their applicability, specificity, sensitivity, and reproducibility. Translational studies demonstrating the clinical utility and importance of cfmiRs in multiple cancers have significantly increased. This review aims to summarize the last 5 years of translational cancer research in the field of cfmiRs and their potential clinical applications to diagnosis, prognosis, and monitoring disease recurrence or treatment responses with a focus on solid tumors. PubMed was utilized for the literature search, following rigorous exclusion criteria for studies based on tumor types, patient sample size, and clinical applications. A total of 136 studies on cfmiRs in different solid tumors were identified and divided based on tumor types, organ sites, number of cfmiRs found, methodology, and types of biofluids analyzed. This comprehensive review emphasizes clinical applications of cfmiRs and summarizes underserved areas where more research and validations are needed.

Self-signal electrochemical identification of circulating tumor DNA employing poly-xanthurenic acid assembled on black phosphorus nanosheets

A self-signal electrochemical identification interface was prepared for the determination of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) in peripheral blood based on poly-xanthurenic acid (PXTA) assembled on black phosphorus nanosheets (BPNSs) acquired through simple ultrasonication method. The BPNSs with large surface area could be integrated with the xanthurenic acid (XTA) monomers by right of physisorption, and hence improved the electropolymerization efficiency and was beneficial to the enlargement of the signal response of PXTA. The assembled PXTA/BPNSs composite with attractive electrochemical activity was adopted as a platform for the recognition of DNA immobilization and hybridization. The probe ssDNA was covalently fixed onto the PXTA/BPNSs composite with plentiful carboxyl groups through the terminate free amines of DNA probes by use of the 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl) carbodiimide and N-hydrosulfosuccinimide cross-linking reaction, accompanied with the decline of the self-signal response. When the hybridization between the probe ssDNA and the target DNA was accomplished, the self-signal response of the composite interface reproduced by virtue of the shaping of helix construction. The determination limit of the assembled DNA identification interface was 2.1 × 10-19 mol/L, and the complementary target DNA concentrations varied from 1.0 × 10-18 mol/L to 1.0 × 10-12 mol/L. The DNA identification platform displayed magnificent sensitivity, specificity and stability, and was efficaciously implemented to the mensuration of ctDNA derived from colorectal cancer.

Detection of Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms of Circulating Tumor DNA by Strand Displacement Amplification Coupled with Liquid Chromatography

The detection of multiple single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) is still a great challenge. In this study, we designed enzyme-assisted nucleic acid strand displacement amplification combined with high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) for the simultaneous detection of three ctDNA SNPs. First, the trace ctDNA could be hybridized to the specially designed template strand, which initiated the strand displacement nucleic acid amplification process under the synergistic action of DNA polymerase and restriction endonuclease. Then, the targets would be replaced with G-quadruplex fluorescent probes with different tail lengths. Finally, the HPLC-fluorescence assay enabled the separation and quantification of multiple signals. Notably, this method can simultaneously detect both the wild type (WT) and mutant type (MT) of multiple ctDNA SNPs. Within a linear range of 0.1 fM-0.1 nM, the detection limits of BRAF V600E-WT, EGFR T790M-WT, and KRAS 134A-WT and BRAF V600E-MT, EGFR T790M-MT, and KRAS 134A-MT were 29, 31, and 11 aM and 22, 29, and 33 aM, respectively. By using this method, the mutation rates of multiple ctDNA SNPs in blood samples from patients with lung or breast cancer can be obtained in a simple way, providing a convenient and highly sensitive analytical assay for the early screening and monitoring of lung cancer.

A perspective: the integration of ctDNA into Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumours 1.1 for phase II immunotherapy clinical trials

A consensus guideline, iRECIST, was developed by the Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumours (RECIST) working group for the use of the modified RECIST version 1.1 in cancer immunotherapy trials. iRECIST was designed to separate pseudoprogression from real progression. However, this is not the only ambiguous situation. In clinical immunotherapy trials, stable disease may reflect three tumor responses, including real stable disease, progressive disease and responsive disease. The prediction of a "true complete/partial response" is also important. Much data has accumulated showing that ctDNA can guide decisions at this point; thus, integrating ctDNA into the RECIST 1.1 criteria may help to distinguish a true tumor response type earlier in patients treated with immunotherapy; however, prospectively designed validation studies are needed.

Sequencing paired tumor DNA and white blood cells improves circulating tumor DNA tracking and detects pathogenic germline variants in localized colon cancer

BACKGROUND

In the setting of localized colon cancer (CC), circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) monitoring in plasma has shown potential for detecting minimal residual disease (MRD) and predicting a higher risk of recurrence. With the tumor-only sequencing approach, however, germline variants may be misidentified as somatic variations, precluding the possibility of tracking in up to 11% of patients due to a lack of known somatic mutations. In this study, we assess the potential value of adding white blood cells (WBCs) to tumor tissue sequencing to enhance the accuracy of sequencing results.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 148 patients diagnosed with localized CC were prospectively recruited at the Hospital Clínico Universitario in Valencia (Spain). Employing a custom 29-gene panel, sequencing was conducted on tumor tissue, plasma and corresponding WBCs. Droplet digital PCR and amplicon-based NGS were performed on plasma samples post-surgery to track MRD. Oncogenic somatic variants were identified by annotating with COSMIC, OncoKB and an internal repository of pathogenic mutations database. A variant prioritization analysis, mainly characterized by the match of oncogenic mutations with the evidence levels defined in OncoKB, was carried out to select specific targeted therapies.

RESULTS

Utilizing paired tumor and WBCs sequencing, we identified somatic mutations in all patients (100%) within our cohort, compared to 89% using only tumor tissue. Consequently, the top 10 most frequently mutated genes for plasma monitoring were altered. The sequencing of WBCs identified 9% of patients with pathogenic mutations in the germline, with APC and TP53 being the most frequently mutated genes. Additionally, mutations in genes related to clonal hematopoiesis of indeterminate potential were detected in 27% of the cohort, with TP53, KRAS, and KMT2C being the most frequently altered genes. There were no observed differences in the sensitivity of monitoring MRD using ddPCR or amplicon-based NGS (p = 1). Ultimately, 41% of the patients harbored potentially targetable alterations at diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

The germline testing method not only enhanced sequencing results and raised the proportion of patients eligible for plasma monitoring, but also uncovered the existence of pathogenic germline variations, thereby aiding in the identification of patients at a higher risk of hereditary cancer syndromes.