Hirayama disease: Three cases

Cervical Spine Magnetic Resonance Imaging Findings in Hirayama Disease

Background Hirayama disease is an uncommon type of cervical cord myelopathy seen typically in young males due to trauma from flexion movements. This study aims to assess the clinical presentations and classify the extent of various cervical spine MRI findings for the local population. Methodology A retrospective study of 13 patients diagnosed with Hirayama disease on cervical MRI was performed from January 2017 to December 2022 at Dr. D. Y. Patil Medical College, Hospital and Research Center, Pune. Results Of the 13 patients, 12 (92%) were male, and one (8%) was female. Nine (69%) patients were in the 16-25-year age group, two (15%) were in the 26-35-year age group, and one (8%) each was in the 6-15-year and 66-75-year age groups. Upper limb weakness was the most common clinical symptom seen in 12 (92%) patients, followed by distal muscle atrophy in seven (54%) patients. Tremors in the hand were a rare symptom seen in two patients. Claw hand was an atypical symptom seen in one patient. On cervical MRI, all patients showed excessive forward shifting of the posterior dura on flexion, with resultant cord compression due to tightness of the dural sac. One (8%) patient had no signs of myelopathy, while 12 (92%) patients had developed chronic myelomalacia and showed abnormal cord hyperintensity and atrophy in the lower cervical cord. All 13 (100%) patients showed increased laminodural space on flexion; the mean thickness was 4.08 mm, with the minimum and maximum thickness being 2.4 mm and 6.7 mm, respectively. Classifying by length of the anterior bulging dura, one (8%) patient showed involvement of less than two vertebral body segments, eight (62%) patients showed involvement of two to four vertebral body segments, and four (30%) patients showed involvement of more than four vertebral body segments. Crescent-shaped post-contrast enhancement on flexion was seen in all eight (100%) patients who underwent a contrast study. Prominent epidural flow voids on flexion were seen in six (46%) patients. Conclusions Hirayama disease is an uncommon type of cervical myelopathy seen typically in juvenile males. The occult onset of distal upper limb weakness and atrophy during puberty, typical MRI features of lower cervical cord atrophy, and the presence of a crescent-shaped enhancing mass in the posterior epidural space are pathognomonic of the condition. A few atypical cases can also occur. Early diagnosis and treatment are crucial to avoiding serious dysfunction.

Hirayama disease: Nosological classification and neuroimaging clues for diagnosis

Hirayama disease (HD) is a rare, benign, and nonprogressive motor neuron disease (MND) affecting the upper limbs. It usually presents with weakness and amyotrophy in a single upper extremity with an insidious onset between adolescence and the third decade of life. Since its description in 1959, HD has been known under several names and eponyms in Europe and in Asian countries probably due to its heterogeneous clinical features. Thus, the unclear nosological classification makes challenging the differential diagnosis between HD and other neuromuscular conditions, such as MNDs. However, apart from the nosological difficulties and the lack of evidence‐based guideline for diagnosis, the neuroimaging is the mainstay for the diagnosis of HD. Indeed, the specific findings on cervical flexion MRI usually lead to a prompt diagnosis. Here, we reviewed the nosological classifications of HD and its neuroimaging features. Also, we report a case of a 18‐year‐old boy who presented to our Clinic complaining of muscle weakness of the left distal upper limb without other neurological signs. The cervical MRI, in the neutral position, revealed a high T2 signal intensity in the C5‐C7 cervical myelomeres as well as the loss of cervical lordosis, whereas, during neck flexion, it showed the anterior displacement of the posterior dura ad the post‐gadolinium T1‐weighted imaging enhancement of the posterior epidural plexus. These findings are typical for HD allowing the diagnosis as well as the differential diagnosis from other neuromuscular diseases.

Update on the Pathogenesis, Clinical Diagnosis, and Treatment of Hirayama Disease

Hirayama disease (HD) is characterized by the juvenile onset of unilateral or asymmetric weakness and amyotrophy of the hand and ulnar forearm and is most common in males in Asia. A perception of compliance with previous standards of diagnosis and treatment appears to be challenged, so the review is to update on HD. First, based on existing theory, the factors related to HD includes, (1) cervical cord compression during cervical flexion, (2) immunological factors, and (3) other musculoskeletal dynamic factors. Then, we review the clinical manifestations: typically, (1) distal weakness and wasting in one or both upper extremities, (2) insidious onset and initial progression for 3-5 years, (3) coarse tremors in the fingers, (4) cold paralysis, and (5) absence of objective sensory loss; and atypically, (1) positive pyramidal signs, (2) atrophy of the muscles of the proximal upper extremity, (3) long progression, and (4) sensory deficits. Next, updated manifestations of imaging are reviewed, (1) asymmetric spinal cord flattening, and localized lower cervical spinal cord atrophy, (2) loss of attachment between the posterior dural sac and the subjacent lamina, (3) forward displacement of the posterior wall of the cervical dural sac, (4) intramedullary high signal intensity in the anterior horn cells on T2-weighted imaging, and (5) straight alignment or kyphosis of cervical spine. Thus, the main manifestations of eletrophysiological examinations in HD include segmental neurogenic damages of anterior horn cells or anterior roots of the spinal nerve located in the lower cervical spinal cord, without disorder of the sensory nerves. In addition, definite HD needs three-dimensional diagnostic framework above, while probable HD needs to exclude other diseases via "clinical manifestations" and "electrophysiological examinations". Finally, the main purpose of treatment is to avoid neck flexion. Cervical collar is the first-line treatment for HD, while several surgical methods are available and have achieved satisfactory results. This review aimed to improve the awareness of HD in clinicians to enable early diagnosis and treatment, which will enable patients to achieve a better prognosis.

Analysis of the Effect of Surgical Treatment for the Patients with Hirayama Disease from the Perspective of Cervical Spine Sagittal Alignment

OBJECTIVE

This study was carried out to analyze the surgical effect of cervical spine sagittal alignment for patients with Hirayama disease (HD).

METHODS

Forty-four subjects were retrospectively analyzed for the parameters of cervical spine sagittal alignment. The case group consisted of 23 patients with HD, whereas the control group consisted of 21 healthy adolescent subjects. Pre- and postoperative cervical spine sagittal parameters of the patients with HD were collected; the cervical sagittal parameters of the healthy adolescent subjects were also collected. Sagittal alignment parameters were compared between the patients with HD and the healthy adolescent subjects, and between the pre- and postoperative parameters for the patients with HD.

RESULTS

Forty-four subjects completed the follow-up, with the average follow-up period being 18.0 months. No significant differences were detected between the HD and control groups for clinical parameters (P > 0.05). The preoperative HD group had smaller values compared with the control group in the sagittal parameters of C2-7 cervical lordosis (CL) angle, T1 slope, thoracic inlet angle (TIA), and cervical tilt angle (P < 0.05). For the patients with HD, the preoperative values were smaller compared with the postoperative HD values for the parameters of C2-7 CL angle, T1 slope, and cervical tilt angle (P < 0.05). We found no significant differences between the postoperative patients with HD and the healthy subjects, including C2-7 CL angle, C2-7 sagittal vertical axis, T1 slope, TIA, neck tilt angle, cervical tilt angle, and cranial tilt angle (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with HD have sagittal imbalance of the cervical spine compared with age-matched healthy adolescent subjects, and surgical treatment could correct the sagittal imbalance.

A Confirmed Case in the United Kingdom of Hirayama Disease in a Young White Male Presenting with Hand Weakness

BACKGROUND

We present the first reported case of Hirayama disease in the United Kingdom. A literature review of Hirayama disease in the Western literature shows that this case is unique in being the first in the United Kingdom, constituting one of only a few cases in Europe with supporting magnetic resonance imaging and reported treatment outcome.

CASE DESCRIPTION

Our patient was a young Caucasian male who presented with progressive bilateral hand weakness, had confirmatory magnetic resonance imaging findings of Hirayama disease, and experienced improvement of symptoms with cervical collar immobilization.

CONCLUSIONS

This case lends further evidence to the flexion-induced myelopathy theory of Hirayama disease and supports the findings of other studies in which avoidance of neck flexion and cervical immobilization helped to attenuate disease progression in this patient group.

Hirayama's disease: an Italian single center experience and review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Hirayama's disease (HD), is a benign, self-limited, motor neuron disease, characterized by asymmetric weakness and atrophy of one or both distal upper extremities. In the present study we report the clinical, electrophysiological and MRI features of a group of Italian patients, with review of the literature. Moreover we propose an optimized MRI protocol for patients with suspected or diagnosed HD in order to make an early diagnosis and a standardized follow up.

METHODS

Eight patients with clinical suspicion of Hirayama disease underwent evaluation between January 2007 and November 2013. All patients underwent standard nerve conduction studies (NCS), electromyography (EMG) and motor/sensory evoked potentials (MEP/SEP). Cervical spine MRI studies were conducted with a 1.5 Tesla MRI scanner in neutral and flexion position, including sagittal T1-weighted sequences and sagittal and axial T2-weighted sequences. The following diagnostic features were evaluated: abnormal cervical curvature, localized cervical cord atrophy in the lower tract (C4-C7), presence of cord flattening (CF), intramedullary signal hyperintensity on T2 weighted sequences, anterior shifting of the posterior wall of the cervical dural sac (ASD) and presence of flow voids (EFV) in the posterior epidural space during flexion.

RESULTS

All patients complained of weakness in hand muscles as initial symptoms, associated with hand tremor in three of them and abnormal sweating of the hand palm in two of them. No sensory deficits and weakness at lower limbs were reported by any patients. Distal deep tendon reflexes at upper limbs were absent in all patients with the absence of the right tricipital reflex in one of them. Deep tendon reflexes at lower limbs were normal and no signs of pyramidal tract involvement were present. The clinical involvement at onset was unilateral in six patients (three left-sided and three right-sided) and bilateral asymmetric in two of them, with the right side more affected. With the progression of the disease all patients but one experienced weakness and wasting of hand muscles and forearm bilaterally, but still asymmetric. The duration of the progression phase of the disease ranged from eight months to three years. In all patients, NCS and EMG findings were consistent with a spinal metameric disorder involving the C7-T1 myotomes bilaterally; sensory conduction and electrophysiologic features at lower limbs were normal. MEP and SEP were normal and we did not observe the disappearance of the spinal potential during the neck flexion in any of the patients. MRI is the best diagnostic tool in the diagnosis of HD; it can confirm clinical diagnosis and exclude other conditions responsible for the neurological deficits leading to a correct patient management and therapy, limiting arm impairment. On MRI all patients had loss of the normal cervical lordosis (100%). Five patients had loss of attachment of posterior dural sac and anterior dural shift on flexion MRI with presence of flow voids from venous plexus congestion (62.5%); three patients had no anterior dislocation of the dural sac and no epidural vein congestion. Two patients showed localized cord atrophy, one at C5-C6 and the other at C6-C7 level (25%). Three patients had T2 intramedullary hyperintensities (37.5%) and cord flattening (CF) was present in 5 patients of 8 (62.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

HD is a rare entity and a self-limited condition, but it has to be early differentiated from other diseases that may determine myelopathy and amyotrophy to establish a correct therapy and limit arm impairment. MRI is very important to confirm the clinical suspect of HD and a standardized MRI protocol using axial and sagittal images in both neutral and flexing position is needed, in order to diagnose and follow up affected patients.